The sacking of Paul Buchanan

I was pretty shocked to hear that Auckland University had sacked Paul Buchanan just because of a harsh e-mail he had written to a student rejecting an extension. It seemed like a massive over reaction where an appropriate sanction would be counselling or a formal warning.

But as I read in the Herald that he referred to the excuse as “culturally driven and preying on some sort of Western liberal guilt”. With one in eight FTE students coming from overseas and being full fee paying, the university bureaucrats would have been having nightmares of millions of dollars being lost if they appeared to be weak.
Buchanan’s full e-mail is here. It is obviously inappropriate. You never call someone a liar without proof (an investigative journalist however might like to find out if her father is dead or not!) and the dig at his colleague Steve Hoadley is inappropriate to make to a student (even though there may be a real story there about quality of standards being lowered for full fee paying students to the detriment of others).

But nevertheless an outright dismissal seems over the top. Buchanan is contrite and has apologised I am sure. It would be a shame to lose him as he is generally regarded as a popular and competent lecturer, and also wider public commentator. He’s even popped up here on occasion to add some expert analysis to threads on the Middle East.

Hopefully the University can find a way to resolve the issue short of dismissal. It doesn’t even sound like the student e-mailed wanted him dismissed.

UPDATE: Scoop has a long list of comments made, almost all supportive, of Buchanan by his former students. And the Herald has 23 pages of comments. The university is facing a tidal wave of criticism.

A Chinese wall – yeah right

Helen Clark is trying to insist that comments by herself and th Trade Minister on Auckland Airport will have no impact on what is meant to be the impartial decision making by Mallard and Parker on the application.  She explains:

Mr Mallard and Mr Parker are the relevant ministers – they are not subject to cabinet responsibility or collective responsibility on this, they make those decisions in their own right.”

She also said that any views which other ministers might wish to express about a particular proposal had to be done out of earshot of Mr Mallard and Mr Parker, in case their decision became subject to legal challenge.

Well unless Trevor and David have been a hermatically sealed room with no access to newspapers on TV, then I suggest the so called Chinese Wall has been breached,

What this means is that if the bid is turned down, Dubai will have a reasonable chance of success in getting the decision overturned by the courts because Goff could not keep his mouth shut.

Ian Templeton

When Ian Templeton first started reporting in the press gallery:

  • Holyoake was yet to become Prime Minister
  • Decimal currency was a decade away
  • Muldoon was yet to even become an MP
  • Winston Churchill has only recently retired as UK PM
  • Singapore was not yet independent
  • Scott Adams was born that year

So congratulations to Ian on his 50th anniversary in the gallery.  A record that will probably never be beaten. Ian still has a weekly interview wih both the Prime Minister and Opposition Leader and writes for Trans-Tasman.

Oh wonderful description

Colin James writes on how John Key could have used opportunities to be more prime ministerial in waiting.  But I especially had to highlight this section:

Clark’s breathtaking rhetoric last October and in February about leading the world and being carbon-neutral has turned out near-indistinguishable from the gases she abhors.

Heh. And then:

… this will consist of some firm principles, some preferred options and some unranked options – all to go out for “consultation”. If the Government sticks to its usual form of consultation, the result would be about as productive as poking a beehive: a lot of noise and little honey.

Greens on National on RMA

Russel Norman has blogged his analysis of National’s RMA policy.  No surprise that he doesn’t agree with parts of it, but he has usefully detailed which parts he does and does not agree with.

This is one of the beauties of the blogging environment.   A one page media release, of which only a couple of paragraphs will get quoted in the media, will be little more than a superficial slogan or two.  But actual point by point analysis is so much better.

The Hollow Woman

Forgot to cover a column last week by Fran O’Sullivan.  The first half is covering the Key Therapeutics Medicines issues (which I have previously blogged on).  The second part I am highlighting:

Clark’s game is more immediate. While Key has been on the road the Prime Minister has cooked National’s election goose with a legislative gerrymander in a dirty deal cooked up between Labour and the minor parties.

Clark had sworn to put an end to the anonymous trust funds and donors who funnelled cash to National at the last election (and Labour).

The “Hollow Woman” has now decided its all right – long after Brash’s ousting – for political parties to be funded by secret donations from wealthy donors. Particularly hers.

But Clark’s also ensured that the upcoming election fight will be on her territory.

The Electoral Finance Bill caps third-party expenditure at $60,000, attacks freedom of expression, and, makes it illegal for publishers to print advertisements campaigning against policies the Government backs without making onerous checks to ensure clients are within the law. It’s an extraordinarily draconian attack on New Zealanders’ democratic rights.

Indeed it is.  A regime which will require statutory declarations from almost any person in NZ who want to publish criticism of the Government.

And the scope of the proposed law is so wide that organisations who would never have thought of themselves as “lobby groups” will get caught up.  As an example most banks have regular publications from their economists to clients.  Now if those publications take a position on any issue associated with the Labour Government, then they count as electoral advertising and are restricted to $60,000 a year.

If Labour announced it was going to quadruple the price of sitting a driver’s licence  in 2008, then the Automobile Association, despite having over one million members, would be unable to spend more than $60,000 protesting against this decision.

The biggest voluntary group in NZ with one million members will have the same limit as  a lobby group with 15 members.

Hustle for autism night

Despite having lots of work on, a 6.15 am flight, and no bags packed, I still made the Hustle for autism last night, and pleased I did so.

I finally got to meet Che Tibby who I once referred to (through ignorance) in the feminine. As he is around twice as tall as me, I won’t make that mistake again 🙂

Had a good conversation with Catalyst’s Don Christie re open source software and Government. Lots of work to be done there.

The highlight of the evening was the speeches. God they were moving. But I’ll come to them last.

The auctions went well and I suspect the total got close to or over five figures. The morning tea with John Key went for $1,500 and I got outbid for the dinner with Marian Hobbs which went for $1,600. The Helen Clark signed wine (many jokes about authenticity of the signature) went for $300.

During the evening chatted to an acquaintance who has autistic children. He left me with no uncertainty about the inadequacy of the support for these kids. The parents who are relatively well off can cope with great dedication, but for others it is beyond tough.  The SST reports how the Cohens spent $120,000 over three years on therapy and that a US study estimates the lifetime societal cost to be NZ$4 million or so.

Both Russell Brown and David Cohen gave great speeches, and Nicola Legat referred to how this issue had brought detente to the former Brown-Cohen cold war 🙂

For me the speech that touched me the most was that from Bill English. Bill wasn’t there as a politician (even though he did introduce himself as the Deputy Leader of the Labour Party which got some good laughs) but as an old schoolfriend of David Cohen’s.

Bill had obviously read the book “A perfect world” by Cohen in great detail and talked about the passages that most moved him.  He said that after reading the book he probably agrees that hope, even more than love, is the most important emotion.   The speech was quite simply stunning in its empathy and message.

Bill also spoke about the meeting David C when he was 13 and how the irrepressible Cohen left a lasting impact with his defiance towards authority.  This was shown by David going through eight schools in the next two years.  He hasn’t lost that wonderful anti-establishment streak

Russell’s new autism website called humans.org.nz is now up and running and will I am sure be a great resource to those many many families out there with autistic children.

I went along mainly because I knew Russell amd David and wanted to support them both, and also for an enjoyable social function.  I left though with a new understanding about the incredible challenges families with autistic children have, and how we need to do more as a society to help.

The optimistic Mr Key

Rob Hosking had an article in last week’s NBR about how Opposition Leaders are normally not as positive as John Key is.

And he doesn’t mean positive and cheery in terms of personal demeanour (even though Key certainly is that).  He means positive about NZ’s future.

Normally the Opposition Leader portrays NZ on the edge of Armageddon, and only by them becoming Prime Minister will the country be saved.  Bolger did this in 1990, Clark in 1999.

But in almost every speech Key gives, he starts off saying how he thinks NZ has a great future ahead, and the next 30 years could be wonderful with demand climbing for our dairy and other agricultural products.

He then of courses shares his concerns.  The brain drain, the school dropout rate etc.  But he makes clear that he is not saying NZ is stuffed if they don’t change.  He’s saying that NZ will miss out on opportunities, will fail to achieve its potential and the gap will just get bigger between us and Western Europe, with Eastern Europe becoming our new benchmates,

Also lacking from most of his speeches is the harsh criticism of the incumbents.  Other MPs do that, and Key certainly will throw some barbs, but usually with humour rather than outrage.

It’s a novel strategy for an Opposition Leader.  Not totally new.  In 1935 the then Opposition Leader did much the same.  Now I’m not saying there are any similarities, just that 1935 was remarkable for how Savage conducted his campaign.

It will be interesting to see whether the tone changes, as the election comes closer.  For now, it certainly seems to be a winning strategy.

Power Cuts at Wellington Airport

Grrrr.  Between 4 am and 5 am Wellington Airport was without power, or at least in the check in section.  Around a dozen times the lights came on briefly to fail again.  More critically the computers were all down so the queues just got bigger.

Finally they got it all working, but then we had the most scary sight of all.  You know the monitors above the counters?  Well imagine seeing 20 of them all booting up together and then all displaying the Windows 95 logo!

Reserve Bank interventions

Kiwi Trader blogs that the Reserve Bank has revealed it sold $702 million of NZ$ in June.

The dollar is now at a lower level than when they intervened so on paper they are up, but I doubt they have replenished all their reserves yet.

I never thought the RBNZ would lose money on the interventions. My concern is that the interventions wouldn’t work, and there is little evidence that they did. The first one had a very temporary effect but the dollar still rose 5c about that level before other forces brought it back down.

Roaming Data Charges

Within NZ my Vodafone data card is invaluable.  Around $40 a month for 1 GB of data, it saves me a lot of money as without I’d be paying $35 a night to the hotel for Internet access.

But overseas it is a very different case.  Suddenly your cost per MB goes from 4c to $30.  Yes $30.  There is a story in Computerworld about Whale Oil being hit with a $7,000+ plus bill for roaming in Australia.  I’m quoted also.

Vodafone say that can put in a warning system as they only get informed of the overseas charges at the end of each billing month.  I don’t accept that.  Firstly they could set up a system where they do exchange data more often.  Secondly they could modify the software on their mobile connect package so the package itself alerts you.

Yes people should look up and be aware of the fine print about the cost when overseas.  But you know if whenever the mobile connect package connected to an overseas network, it flashed an alert box warning your data rate is now $30 a MB (or $10 if still Vodafone) then people wouldn’t be caught unawares.

In Australia

Losers

Adolf at No Ministers blogs about Downer on the radio this morning:

Alexander Downer was asked this morning by Sean Plunket what he thought about the handful of protesters outside the Gnat’s conference.

“Well they are from the Socialist Alliance. These people are losers, you know. They lost the Soviet Union and they lost the Cold war. Yes I thought about them. It was raining and I thought the harder it rains the wetter they’ll get.”

Priceless

Australian politicians are so much more in your face. A NZ MP would talk about how they respect their right to protest yet disagree with them.

In Wellington tonight

David Cohen at Public Address (a sentence many would have thought would never be primted) gives some reasons why people in Wellington should go to the San Francisco Bathhouse tonight.

  1. Autism is everywhere
  2. The Autism Intervention Trust is a great cause
  3. Long speeches have been banned
  4. The Bonnie Scarlets are not a maypole dancing ensemble
  5. The auction items look amazing

Hustle For Autism:

Monday, 6 August at SFBH (San Francisco Bathhouse),

171 Cuba Street, Wellington, from 6.30pm

Get your tickets from:

Working Style Wellington, 8 Woodward Street, 04 472 2194

Millwood Gallery, 291b Tinakori Road, Thorndon, Wellington 04 473 5178

Or email [email protected] to reserve tickets at the door.

Won’t refer to Key by name

I hadn’t picked up on this but it seems in a recent NZ Herald interview with Helen Clark she never once referred to John Key by name:

So does a recent Herald interview with Clark, in which she referred to Key many times without once using his name.

He was dismissed, variously, as “that guy”, “this guy” and even “it”, as in, “It is a foreign exchange dealer”.

Key finds this hilarious, and replies with “Well, ‘it’ wasn’t offended.”

Possibly not surprisig as she often refers to herself in the third person also.

John and Bill

Catching up on stories, the joint interview with John Key and Bill English is a good read.

Some extracts:

John, if you won an outright majority at the next election, would you still enter into co-operation deals with other parties?

JK: We’d have to look at that. My inclination would be to do so. We’re trying to build a government. Our focus is on earning the right to be the next government, but in the end any government needs a period of time to roll out a programme. And I think for long term stability we could afford to be generous.

Would a National first-term Cabinet look much like the shadow Cabinet does now, in terms of who holds which portfolio?

JK: In terms of the top level personalities, the first dozen or so, I think you’ve got to say yes. They are strong individuals who have good capability. Whether they’re in their exact portfolios is something we would decide further down the track. I think there is a lot of competition. But some stuff is rock solid – Bill’s going to be Minister of Finance.

Bill, is the public expectation around future personal tax cuts too high as a result of what was offered in 2005?

BE: The public would expect a National government to make a significant difference to the tax regime. Probably the expectation of a single big hit would be too high. We’ve talked for some time now about a credible programme of tax cuts rather than a big hit.

More mobile phones than people

Peter Griffin blogs the Telecom profit announcement.

I found it interesting that NZ now has more mobile phones than people.  This it seems is because of people like me who have a work and a private phone – one with Telecom and one with Vodafone.

It would be interesting to see any stats, if they exist, on mobile penetration by age range.  Most kids seem to get a phone once they are ten or so now.  I’ve also noticed more and more retired people  taking up a phone.

Kerr on Regulatory Responsibility Bill

Roger Kerr writes in the NZ Herald on how Rodney Hide’s Regulatory Responsibility Bill is “a golden opportunity to improve the effectiveness and efficiency of government”.

Before any new law or regulation is passed, the following questions will need to be answered publicly:

  • What is the rule for?
  • Will it work?
  • Is there a cost, and if so, are the benefits greater?
  • Does it involve taking someone’s private property?
  • If so, will they be compensated?

I would hope few are against an explicit statement of why the law is needed, what the benefits and costs are and what the impact on private property rights are.

Herald on Groser

The NZ Herald has a story on the allegations by Tim Groser’s ex wife.

I joked to someone yesterday that as the allegations relate to his time as a civil servant, one should ask the States Services Commission to do an inquiry – that way it will automatically clear everyone involved.  Even better one could follow the latest example and have the SSC appoint Tim Groser as head of the inquiry into Tim Groser.  I mean this is what is happening with the Setchell inquiry.

The whole notion of heading up an inquiry into yourself may become a popular form of inquiry under this Government.

Airport deal almost dead

New Zealanders

The number of people who wrote in their ethnicity as “New Zealand” in the 2006 census was 429,429 – three times as many as expected and five times as many as in 2001.

Now I wasn’t one of those, but I am fascinated by the demography of those stating that as their ethnicity.  So I read through the 33 page report from Stats NZ.

No Right Turn doesn’t seem to have got past the summary page by concluding “they’re overwhelmingly dead white males”.  He really should have gone through the full report.

In terms of gender, yes there are more males than females but it is only 51.9% Male which is a light year away from overwhelmingly males.

Then in terms of age, their median age was 40.2 compared to 35.9 for the total population but part of this is a skew by number of kids in each group.  Stats concluded that people aged 35 – 53 were most likely to say their ethnicity was New Zealander.  Hardly dead.

11% of those who wrote in their ethnicity as “New Zealander” are of Maori descent.

Not surprisingly 93% of this group were born in NZ compared to 77% for the total population.

Also people are less religious in this group – only 58% have a religion comp to 63% overall.

They are also more educated with only 19% having no qualifications compared to 25% of all NZers.  They are also more likely to have a Bachelors degree.  This also mean they are way more likely to be earning over $40,000 a year and are also more likely to be in employment.

It will be interesting to observe how things change in the 2011 census.

The 1 Auckland campaign slogan

A wag suggested to me at the weekend that Steve Crow had convinced the 1 Auckland team to have the campaign slogan “Tick my box” 🙂

Okay it’s funnier after a few wines.  But really the combination of porn kings and genteel church going Remuera matrons is too funny to pass over.

Herald blog on Conference

Audrey Young blogged some of the highlights from the conference speeches.   She also covers the blooper over the party name in today’s speech.

The Herald has the full speech transcript online. There was quite a bit of grunty stuff in the section on home ownership including allowing Housing NZ tenants to purchase the house they live in.

Michael Laws

Southern Man blogs in the Herald:

The sudden announcement by Michael Laws, Mayor of Wanganui and radio host, that he will be running again was certainly a surprise after three years of emphatic denial that he would run for a second term.

Is this correct?  While Laws did say a while back he is reconsidering his decision not to restand, I haven’t seen any announcement that he will restand.  A quick Google doesn’t find any such announcement.  Is the Herald correct or not?

National Party Conference Dinner Photos

conf3.JPG

Mark and Nikki discussing which of my embarrassing moments was worse.

conf4.JPG

Some of the friendly HQ staff.

conf5.JPG

Yum. Now that is what I call dessert.

conf6.JPG

Nick A with his harem, only one of which he is due to marry!

conf7.JPG

Power Couple No 1

conf12.JPG

Power Couple No 2

conf8.JPG

The Otago “girls”

conf9.JPG

Lydia B and yours truly, posing for a photo purely because her mother said she reads my blog every day (waves to Karen). Mum should also ask Lydia about her Viaduct nightclubbing antics!

conf10.JPG

Power Couple No 3

conf11.JPG

Some of the Young Nats at the traditional post dinner party back in the room.

A very very fun night. We just won’t mention the antique bowl which ended up in 50 pieces. Luckily one of the hotel managers was with us at the party so can help us cover it up 🙂