More irony

Sheer hypocrisy

I said on Tuesday that the failure of the Government clamp down on anonymous and trust donations must be due to one of two possible reasons – either that they were short of money themselves and dropped it voluntarily, or that they couldn’t get the numbers for it.

I commented at the time that I thought it was the latter option and gave Labour the benefit of the doubt that it was not the former, as that would be sheer hypocrisy.

But Helen has confirmed it is the former.  NZPA reports:

But Miss Clark today said banning anonymous donations in their current form without providing additional state funding would have led to parties “across the spectrum” struggling for funding.

Every member of the Labour Party should hang their head in shame.  For over a year Labour have spent almost every day whining about these secret donations.  It has been the centrepiece of their entire electoral reform campaign.  National had agreed they should end. But Helen Clark and Labour decided unilaterally to leave it out because Labour would have struggled for funding without such money.

Can one get any more hypocritical?

Labour have about as much moral right to draw up election financing laws as Paris Hilton has to promote abstinence.
Let us look at previous quotes from Helen Clark:

“I think the public wants to know who is funding political parties. They want to know who is pulling strings, if they are pulling strings through funding.” – 6 Dec 2006

 “I look forward to the National Party’s support for clamping down on anonymous donations. I understand that in Australia everything over $250 has to be declared. That sounds like a good idea to me.” – 6 Sep 2006

 Week in, wek out, Labour MPs have bleated about these donations.  They have vowed to get rid of them.  They have held them up as the epitome of all that is wrong with the political system.  They have all but called them corrupt.

And now we have a price for Labour’s principles.  They unilaterally move to remove any clamp down on anonymous donations, because gee whiz we get quite a few of them ourselves, and we’ll be too stretched if we ban them.

 Come on, this goes even beyond hypocrisy. How can anyone take anything Labour says or does on electoral finance seriously.

Their Electoral Financing Bill is an abortion.  The penalties are still a joke.  The restrictions on election year speech are beyond draconian, and they left out the most important part of the whole bill – because Labour needed the secret donations too much.

Chauvel for Wellington Central

Labour List MP Charles Chauvel has confirmed he wishes to stand for Wellington Central, not Ohariu-Belmont, next election and has written to local Labour Party members asking them for their support.

It will be interesting to see if Grant Robertson contests the nomination.

Also of interest is that Northland based List MP Shane Jones has said he is interesting is seeking the Rimutaka nomination.  So the so called rejuvenation may just turn out to be electorate MPs replaced by list MPs!

What should Dr Bollard do tomorrow?

Fran O’Sullivan has an open letter to Dr Bollard on why he should not put the cash rate up tomorrow. She tells him to ignore those who say he has no alternative (which may be aimed at people like me – Fran gave me a reasonable decent bollocking over my attacking Matt McCarten on this).

She also notes that John Key has called for them not to go up, and if one assumes Cullen doesn’t want them up, he has bipartisan cover.

The Dominion Post editorial also calls for Dr Bollard not to put the rate up, citing declining house sales.

I suspect the traders have already assumed the cash rate will go up, and that is one of the reasons for the dollar’s continual climb. However it has dropped around 50 points today which is a lot, so maybe it has peaked?

My personal view is unchanged. It doesn’t matter that Michael Cullen and John Key both want you not to. If as Governor Dr Bollard believes that without an increase, inflation would breach 3%, then he is obliged to put the cash rate up. Inflation is never the answer!

Phil Goff once quoted me

I did a vanity Google on my name in Hansard last night. I know Clark once referred to me (but not by name) in 2004 in relation to an issue around parliamentary staff so didn’t expect any hits. But there were two – the traditional thanks from Mark Blumsky in his maiden speech but also a couple of years ago by Phil Goff in defence of the Government’s bill dealing with issues around the age of consent. No-one mentioned this at the time so I was genuinely surprised. Goff said:

Mr Ryall raised the question of a particular change that will be made. Under the previous law, if a person was 1 day over the age of 21, there was no defence at all, even if one could demonstrate that one had reasonably and genuinely believed that a person was not under age—say, one had asked for her driver’s licence, had checked it, and it had stated that that was so. Unfortunately, there is the situation—and I think Mr Mark agrees with me on this—where some young women, some girls out there, can look a lot older than 16 and do use false identification. If a person acts in good faith, but is conned by an under-age person, why should there be no defence to protect that person? Of course there should be a defence, and it should not be arbitrarily restricted to those who are under the age of 21.

I have no better authority on that than David Farrar, who is the co-chairman of the liberal group within the National Party—with Katherine Rich, I think—a former staffer of Don Brash, a long-time member and supporter of National, and a worker in the office of Leader of the Opposition, who made the point that I have just made. It is nonsense to say that a person who is 21 years and 1 day old has no defence at all, if the young woman concerned looked like she was 18 and presented the person concerned with a driver’s licence that stated that. That is why the old law did not make sense—not just the fact that the arbitrary threshold was contrary to our New Zealand Bill of Rights Act.

If I recall correctly the law change didn’t go through.

Facebook is evil

Facebook is evil.  There are no other words for it.  It is far too addictive.  Any moment now I await the Greens wanting to ban it for being unhealthy.

I’ve only been on for a week and every day I spend more time on it.  Someone tell me this will wear off after a while.

For those interested, my Facebook page is here.   The third party applications are what seems to make this more of a killer site than the others.

I’ve also got a less frequently used Bebo page and an almost never used My Space page.

An example of the proposed Act

Many NZers hate battery hen farming. There is I am sure a group out there that campaigns on that.

Now the Greens have identified themselves as wanting battery hen farming to be outlawed.

This means in election year it will be illegal for any organisation to spend money promoting or advertising that battery hen farming should be illegal, unless they do the following:

(a) File a statutory declaration every time they do anything costing money, that the cost over the year will be under $5,000.

or

(b) File an application to the Government to be registered as a “third party” and then appoint a financial agent and an auditor and then have the agent place the ad for you.

Seriously. That will be the law. That will be the only way one can spend money to say battery hen farming is wrong and should be stopped.

This will be a nightmare for newspapers. If someone wants to advertise a protest march in election year, the newspaper will need to check if the march is about a policy which is associated with a political party, and then get a statutory declaration from you or seek proof you are registered and that this person is your financial agent.

And imagine the nightmare for the Chief Electoral Officer, the Electoral Commission, the Police and Judges. They are all going to have to decide what is or is not a “position on a proposition with which one or more parties is associated”.

I hope Dr Catt and Mr Peden are putting in budget bids for lots more staff. Maybe to provide certainty (and laws are meant to provide certainty) the Electoral Commission in election year could say daily update a list of policies or propositions we are not allowed to spend money on, without registering. Just as Sulla provided helpful lists in 81 BC.

By the way it applies to all parties, not just those in Parliament. If the nutters in AMBLA set up a pedophile rights party, then one could not advertise against pedophilia being legalised in an election year, without following the procedure above. Because that would be unfair to the pedophile rights party. Never mind they are only 0.001% in the polls.

I’m sorry, I have to say this. I am trying to be restrained. But what retard dreamed up this bill. I mean seriously, having to register with the Government to advertise your opinion on a policy or proposition associated with a political party. Did no one at all in Cabinet read the bill?

Period of “regulated speech”

Under the Electoral Financing Bill we will have free speech for two years and one month of every three year electoral cycle and “regulated speech” for eleven months when it will be illegal to take a position on a policy proposition associated with a political party unless you are registered and/or don’t spend more than a couple of ads.

So for 30% of our lives, we will live under a regulated speech regime. But will it stop at 30%?

You see the traditional 90 day period which restricts political expenditure has a sensible basis to it.  A lot of research shows many people decide during that period.  The active intense campaign occurs during that period, and it is also a short enough period of time that one can halt Government and Parliamentary advertising.

But what is the logic for 1 January in election year – 11 months before most elections?  Do people suddenly wake up with a New Year Eve’s hangover and start thinking about how to vote?  So what is to stop a future Government deciding 11 months of regulated speech is not enough?  They may say people start to focus on an election at the halfway point of an electoral term, so  let’s ban any advertising over minimal limits for 18 months before an election.  I mean it makes as much sense as 11 months.

Then once we get to 50% of our time being regulated speech instead of free speech, a Government can make a case that a new Government is vulnerable to attack while it is getting its feet.  If a Government gets off to a bad start, then it may never recover from it (as did Nat/NZF in 1997).  So hey we need to protect Government while they are in start up mode.   So let’s also regulate criticism of them which involves advertising for their first year in office.

And no doubt at some stage the remaining six months of free speech will be deleted as an anomaly!

Okay I am being dramatic, but there is a very important principle at play here.  Any restrictions on freedom of speech should be as minimal as possible, and apply for as short a period as possible, and need the highest standards of proof of necessity.

Now I am now against there being a restricted period.  I’ve seen nothing at all to justify extending it from 90 days.  The fact National had some billboards is a pathetic excuse. In previous elections I can recall many a Labour advertisement attacking the Government outside the 90 day period.

But the limits proposed are appallingly low.  $60,000 over 11 months is miniscule.  We have 2.5 million voters.  That allows a spend, over 11 months of 2.4c per voter.  Per month it is a mere 0.22 of one cent.

That’s not buying elections.  Hell that doesn’t even buy a grain of rice.

The answer is not fiddling though with what the limit should be.  $100,000 is no more satisfactory than $60,000.

The answer is to have a much shorter period.  There is no sound public policy reason to regulate speech for an entire year, during which time the Government is announcing policy and initiatives non stop.

The period should be short enough so that Government spending can also halt during that period.

It is unthinkable that the Government can release a budget with multiple initiatives and any organisation that wants to say bad things about it [clause 5(1)(a)(iii)] on their website [paragraph (g) of the definition of a publication] will need to file a statutory declaration [Clause 53(3)] with their website hosting company that they will not be spending more than $5K [Clause 53(3)(b)] over the year on commenting on Government policies.  And if you do want to spend more than $5K in election year on promoting your view on policies, then you need to register to do so.

Help us pick a name

In the United States they have this quaint habit of calling their bills any name they like such as the Patriot Act or the Can Spam Act. This is part of the wider political battle over labelling (Estate Tax called a Death Tax). In NZ we saw the Section 59 bill almost universally called the anti-smacking bill (including by Sue Bradford by press release when she launched it).

Well a group of us think the benignly named Electoral Financing Bill needs a name that better describes it. But we can’t decide amongst ourselves, so I want your help in suggesting names, and/or indicating which names you most like. I might then even run a poll of say five finalists to pick the preferred name.

Suggested names to date are:

  • The Gag My Critics Bill
  • The Block the Knockers Bill
  • The Muzzle My Enemies Bill
  • The Freedom From Expression Bill
  • The Criticism Prevention Bill
  • The Alternative Opinion Prevention Bill
  • The Election Theft No.2 Bill
  • The Helengrad Gag
  • Helen’s Gag
  • Helen’s Muzzle
  • The Red Muzzle
  • The Red Gag
  • The Shut Down Dissent Bill
  • The Shut Down Democracy Bill
  • The Labour Party Corruption Validation Bill
  • The Labour Party Preservation Bill
  • The Freedom from Criticism Bill
  • The Helen Clark Preservation Bill
  • The Helen Clark PM for Life Bill
  • The Democratic Rights Amendment Bill
  • The Anti-Democracy Bill
  • The Democracy Amendment Bill
  • The Stamp Out Democracy Bill
  • The Death of Democracy Bill
  • The Frankly Fijian Bill
  • Entrench the Goverment Bill
  • No Power to the People Bill
  • Bill of Rights Amendment Bill

None of these names are endorsed at this stage. As I said let’s try and get views on the best, and then have a poll to select the best name. Something not too extreme, but that gets the point across.

To save time, nothing which mentions Mugabe or has any German connotations.  Yes the Bill is a massive attack on free speech, but no it isn’t the end of civilisation as we know it!

Govt will not approve Auckland Airport sale

I rarely make predictions, but I am going to predict that the Government will not approve the sale of Auckland Airport to a Dubai company.

The xenophobia over foreign ownership to “Arabs” is as repugnant here as it was in the US when port management was blocked on much the same grounds. People talk about foreign control of an asset as if we might wake up one day and find the airport has suddenly been moved overseas.

And as for profits going overseas, well to be consistent you should then support overseas countries banning New Zealanders and NZ companies owning any overseas assets. Plus people forget that if the airport is sold for $2.6 billion, then that $2.6 billion is available for investment in other companies (which may make even bigger profits), or in the case of Councils in local infrastructure.

So why do I predict the sale will be turned down, even though it shouldn’t be? One word. Winston.

He collapsed the coalition in 1998 over the sale of Wellington Airport. It wasn’t actually about the airport at all (that issue got resolved) but was about NZ First trying to recover in the polls.

And we have the same situation in 2007 – NZ First supporting an unpopular third term Government, below 5% in the polls, and without even an electorate seat as a safety net. And remember since re-elected in 1984 Winston Peters has never once gone into an election supporting the Government of the day. So this issue is a perfect excuse for him to walk out over. He has vowed to “vowed to battle right through to the final decision”.

So if I was Helen Clark, and Helen is a student of history, I would be telling the two Ministers who officially decide, that they can go and commission all the reports they want, and get all the advice they want, but unless they want to be having an early election, they should turn down the proposal.

I mean if Winston was ready to use the excuse of Wellington Airport being sold to a NZ private company as a reason to collapse one Government, how can he not do the same to stop a bigger airport sale to not just a foreign company, but shock horror, “Arabs” with “security concerns”. Of course in this case the Govt is not the seller or owner – it is just the permission given, but Winston doesn’t tend to deal with unhelpful facts and subtle distinctions.

Chavez set to rule for life

Chavez looks set to rule for life, instituting term limits for every elected role in Venezuela, except his own, and now kicking out people who criticise him.

Whenever anyone claims they are shifting “control of the country’s destiny to the grassroots citizenry and the poor” it means they are about to start a reign of oppression!

I prefer a country with a free press, freedom to criticise, and have in fact supported term limits (for all MPs) since the early 1990s when I proposed them at a National Party conference and the NZ Herald unhelpfully highlighted the only two MPs who would have been affected by my proposal were those obscure backbenchers Sir William Birch and the Rt Hon James Bolger. 🙂

Why further increases in the dollar have less impact

Somewhat ironically, one of the features of having the NZ dollar at such a high level, is that further increases have less of an impact.

Let’s say you sell widgets for US$100 each.  Having the NZ$ go from US$0.50 to US$0.60 reduces your income by $33.33.

But having the NZ$ go from US$0.70 to US$0.80 only reduces your income by $17.86.

Now of course in absolute terms you are always worse off (if an exporter) the higher the dollar is, but the relative change is far worse going from 0.50 to 0.60 than 0.70 to 0.80.

Random Encounter II

Had a lunch meeting on Monday with some folks giving a cool preview of a new website which will launch next month.  I go upstairs at Boudeaux Bakery to meet the three of them, and when introduced to the third person, F, we both instantly recognise each other, but for the life of us can’t work out when or how.  Just that we seem very familiar.  We try for a minute or two to place each other, but no luck.

Around quarter of an hour later, when she mentions her area of speciality, it suddenly clicks.  We hadn’t met each other years ago, but had been in a meeting together the previous Wednesday!  And not a large or quick meeting, but a meeting of just seven people which lasted two hours.

We both find it hilarious that we failed to place each other just five days later.  For me, this was even more unusual, as F is strikingly attractive, and not someone one would normally forget.

We sort of rationalised that the inability to place each other was because of the change in environment.  The week before we met in Auckland and I was there wearing my InternetNZ hat and she was there in association with ICT-NZ.  This week it was in Wellington on a totally different issue, with me in my role as a blogger and a market researcher and F in her commercial role.

Have others had similar, when you fail to place someone you just met a couple of days ago because it was in a different setting?  Or maybe I just have early senility!

Random Encounter I

Having coffee at Astoria on Saturday with Bishop Junior and suddenly hugged from behind by G, who I have not seen for a couple of years as she only moved to Wellington two weeks ago.  She mentions she is off overseas the next day, so we agree to meet up when she is back.

G calls me in somewhat of a panic on Sunday afternoon.  She had encountered a minor problem at the airport – her passport had expired.  And yes she is blonde.  I am the only person in Wellington who has known her for more than a year and can verify her photos for her urgent passport application.  In between cracking up with laughter, I of course agree to meet her asap.  DIA, impressively, are able to get her a new passport within 12 hours.

Also in a fit or irony, she was telling me a story about someone that she herself didn’t know, but related to a role he has.  Around ten seconds after she finishes telling me the story, we bump into him and I have great pleasure in introducing him to her.

Wellington is a small place.

Who is Rodney taking out for dinner?

Cactus Kate profiles her list of people Rodney Hide could date, now he is trim and single.  It’s a great post so go check it out.   Her contenders are:

  1. Aja Rock
  2. Julie Christie
  3.  Annette Presley
  4. Cactus Kate
  5. Casey Green
  6. Theresa Gattung
  7. Pippa Wetzell

I wonder if he is allowed combinations? 🙂

A freudian slip indeed

The official story is that David Benson-Pope knew nothing at all about his staff’s phone call to his Ministry CEO about Madeleine Setchell.

Yet in an interview this morning on Radio NZ (audio file go to 2:45), he said:

It turned out that the rumour we’d heard …

The interviewer seized on this, and DBP claimed he meant we in referring to the whole office, but excluding him!

He then said in response to questions later from journalists “his use of the word “we” had been a Freudian slip” (quote from NZPA).

Now a Freudian slip is where you say something you didn’t mean to, because of your subconscious mind. The example given is when you call your wife by your mistress’ name.

So Benson-Pope is right that it was a Freudian slip – one which revealed the truth as Freudian slips often do.

Anonymous and trust donations remain legal

At first I thought the Greens were over dramatising when they claimed that the Electoral Financing Bill left anoymous donations and donations through trusts legal.

I thought they must be mistaken.  I mean this was at the centre of what Labour complained about.  This was the one area where even National said they agree that the use of anonymous and trust donations should be reduced.  It was the one thing everyone expected to be in the bill.

But the Greens were not wrong.  The Coalition for Open Government says the same thing, and having reread the bill, I concur with them.  This is just quite frankly bizarre. No Right Turn labels the bill disappointing and a betrayal.

So why did the Government not include in the bill, what everyone was expecting – a clamp down on anonymous and trust donations?  I can only think of two reasons.

  1. They realised the impact it would have on Labour’s own fundraising, and being short of money anyway dropped it.
  2. They couldn’t get agreement for it from other parties.

If (1) is the answer that is the height of hypocrisy.

If (2) is the answer then there is some seriously incompetent political management of this bill.

As Mark Burton is the Minister in charge I will opt for (2).

The irony is that considering National publicly said they would support a clampdown on trust and anonymous donations,  and National asked to be consulted – then Labour could have approached them for support.  If National refused to, then the heat could have gone on them.

This is like the complementary medicines bill.  Labour had a hissy fit at National for never supporting the Peters compromise, but they never even gave National a copy of it nor asked them to negotiate on the basis of it.  They just announced it all through the media.

DBP should go squad

Idiot/Savant at No Right Turn concludes Beoson-Pope should go for three reasons:

  1. He has misled the public
  2. He claims that he would have made the call himself, and “reserves the right” to express such concerns in future.
  3. Benson-Pope is responsible for the conduct of the staff in their own office

Span also says Benson-Pope should go, mainly because he has become a distraction and liability.

I’m trying to think of something else that Idiot/Savant, Span and I would all agree on.  Maybe Harry Potter 🙂

Good quote

It’s ironic that Parliament will be voting to legalise advocacy of the violent overthrow of the government while at the same time they are criminalising non-violent advocacy of the democratic overthrow of the government.

– Nigel Kearney

Nigel is right – it is ironic. And sad.

Shutting down dissent

The Government has released its Electoral Finance Bill. It’s 73 pages long and has too much detail to be dealt with in one post, so I’ll do a series of posts, each dealing with one aspect. There are some good things in there like the Canadian idea of financial agents. Penalties for breaches have been increased (which is good) but are still too low by at least a magnitude and maximum penalties should be ten times those in the Bill. Also disappointingly there is no provision for parties as well as individuals to be held liable.

But the parts I want to focus on today, is three changes. The combination of the three changes represent the biggest threat to free speech and the ability to effectively criticise the Government in recent times.

The Government is changing three things:

  1. It is changing the period of time during which spending is regulated from 90 days before the election to 1 January of election year, which will usually be 11 months.
  2. It is restricting the amount third parties can spent on “election advertising” to $60,000.
  3. It is introducing a new definition of “election advertising” which includes “taking a position on a proposition with which 1 or more parties or 1 or more candidates is associated”

The combination of these three things will shut down any significant criticism of the Government in election year, except by the media. Whether you are on the left or right you should be appalled at this, and preparing to do battle. Remember one day there will be a National Government, and I think people should be able to run ads against what National does when in office. This bill will stop you.

The regulated period

Clause 4 defines the regulated period as “the period that commences on 1 January of that year and ends with the close of polling day” if it is a year in which Parliament is due to expire.

This totally advantages the incumbent Government. It closes down advertising by Opposition parties and third parties for all of election year, but leaves them more able to undertake advertising.

The traditional 90 day period was all about a level playing field, not just on party advertising but also parliamentary and government advertising. The traditional consensus was that parliamentary and government advertising reduce to the bare minimum during the last 90 days, and the parties be restricted to a couple of million each.

Now let us look at what Labour’s changes do to each of the three sorts of advertising:

  • Government advertising is totally unrestricted and can occur throughout all of election year. The Government can spend millions promoting its election year budget, all legally.
  • Parliamentary advertising has been significantly liberalised due to the law over-ruling the Auditor-General. Labour can now fund their pledge card from the taxpayer legally, and distribute it a month before the election
  • Spending by registered parties is greatly reduced. Not only are the limits not even adjusted for inflation, they now apply over an 11 month period instead of a three month period.
  • Spending by third parties is now restricted for all of election year

So what Labour is doing is making it easier for it to spend taxpayer money without challenge in election year, and making it much harder for anyone to criticise what they are doing by doing their own advertising.

The limits for third parties

Now I am not against there being some limits on third parties, seeing there are limits on registered parties, for the last 90 days. Parties can spend $2 million or so, so a limit of say $1 million on a third party could be justified. Remember the problem with the Exclusive Brethren wasn’t that they spent money, but that they were secretive about who was behind it. The new disclosure laws cover that.

A limit of $60,000 spread over 11 months can only be seen as wanting to silence critics. That is around $5,000 a month only. A full page advert in just one newspaper – the NZ Herald – can cost $36,000. So Labour is saying a third party group can not do more than two full pages ads over a year criticising the Government, and only in one city. $60,000 will only get a couple of spots on TV for just one evening. And this is over an 11 month period. It is draconian.

Definition of election advertising

Clause 5(1) defines an election advertisement. Paragraph (a)(i) basically says it includes encouraging people to vote for or not to vote for one or more parties. So that now includes phrases such as “vote out the Government”.

Paragraph (a)(ii) says it also includes encouraging votes for or against a type of party or type of candidate that is described by reference to views, positions or policies of parties or candidates. That means if you are NORML and want to campaign against MPs who do not support cannabis decriminalisation, just saying “Do not vote for MPs who do not support cannabis decriminalisation” is restricted to $60,000 over an entire year.

Paragraph (a)(iii) is the one which made me drop the Bill in disbelief and start phoning people though. This one is the clincher. It says an election advertisements includes

“taking a position on a proposition with which 1 or more parties or 1 or more candidates is associated”

Now just think about this. Anything Labour announces in its election year budget. If you spend any money advocating against it, then bang the limit sets in. You don’t even have to say “Do not vote Labour because their student loans policy is bad”. Just running an ad saying “Free interest on student loans is a bad idea because …” is illegal unless you are a registered third party and you keep spending to under $60,000 in election year.

Also be aware this definition applies to registered parties also. So if National spends money campaigning against a particular policy in February, then it has to spend less money in the actual campaign. Yet Labour has unlimited money from the taxpayer to promote Government policies.

These changes must be stopped in their current form. It is as simple as that. They are unacceptable.

One redeeming aspect is paragraph (2)(g) of Clause 5(2) which exempts blogs from the law. And yes the bill even refers to blogs by name. It says: in reference to things which are not election advertisements

“the publication by an individual, on a non-commercial basis, on the Internet of his or her personal political views (being the kind of publication commonly known as a blog).

Firstly thanks to whoever did put that clause in. But it does show how wide reaching the new definitions are, that they have had to put in a blog exemption. If you are an organisation and run a website, and take a position on a policy associated with a political party, then your website costs may have to be declared as part of your limit.

Also the blog exemption may need some tidying up. Does me receiving some minor income from Google ads make me commercial? At what level could it be seen to do so?

There are now two big issues before New Zealand. One is public service neutrality and the other is freedom of speech. And the two may well be linked. Read what Dominion Post political editor Tracy Watkins says on the Satchell sacking:

The reason Ms Setchell’s job was deemed so sensitive was that Prime Minister Helen Clark had placed carbon neutrality at the forefront of Labour’s political agenda. Ministry staff have been told to rack their brains for bold plans which are likely to form the centrepiece of Labour’s election campaign.

Hitherto the ministry has been an innocuous arm of the civil service. Now the Government’s future may rest partly on the ministry’s ability to help formulate election- winning policies to woo the increasingly critical green vote.

The decision to try to shift Ms Setchell out of a job which would give her access to the Government’s strategy in this highly sensitive area can point to only one thing – that the Government sees the ministry not just as the department that will implement government policy, but as its de facto political and strategic arm.

That sets the controversial and costly Working for Families ad campaign by government departments (roughly $18 million, down from $24 million after the auditor- general intervened) in a whole new light.

So the Government prepares to politicise the civil service further by having them run huge ad campaigns in election year to “inform” people of Government policies. And at the same time they reduce the ability of either the Opposition or third parties to criticise them, except my media release.

Any price for a fourth term.

And we hit 80c

One starts to see why John Key was so good in his former job. When over a month ago he predicted the NZ$ which was hitting 75c would go and hit 80c, it was I thought a gutsy call.

Over the following weeks the gutsy call became a consensus and today a reality.

Today’s NZ Dollar

This graph stolen from the National Bank. It’s been pretty volatile today with a 50 point range and it broke 80c a bit before 6 pm.

NZ Dollar post float

This graph of the dollar since the float is pretty alarming. In just one year we’re gone up 20c which is huge.  The rate of growth is steeper than any other time since 1989.  And look at the very final part on the far right- that’s almost a bloody vertical line.

It’s a problem but it isn’t a case for panic.  I do wish NZ importers such as bookshops were reflecting the dollar in their prices.  If a book costs them US$10 then the cost to them has dropped this year from $16.70 to $12.50.  I’d like some of that back thank you very much.

The question is now at what level will it stabilise?  I haven’t seen anyone picking over 85c.

Case studies in political conflicts of interest

The Prime Minister has blundered badly by stating that she basically believes Madeleine Setchell should never have been appointed to her job in the first place (she agreed that it was a mistake that her application was progressed at all).

This makes it a story now not just about DPB but about Helen Clark and fundamental issues around the neutrality of the public service.

No Right Turn labels the PM’s statement as “The end of public service neutrality” and he is right – it is that big. The PSA is also concerned and has called on the SSC to clarify the position.

So the Labour has instituted a new rule that you can not hold any sort of senior job in the public service if you have a family member associated with the National Party. This is in complete contrast to how National has treated such issues. I’m going to go through four case studies to show how far Labour has plummeted.

Case Study 1 – Alison Timms

Alison Timms is now a professional director but was a civil servant for many years. Her husband is Tony Timms. Tony Timms is about as 100% Labour as you can get – a former General Secretary (CEO) of the Party itself and then an advisor to Helen Clark – one of her closest advisors.

Alison’s relationship with Tony Timms did not affect her undertaking very senior roles within the Department of Social Welfare from 1994 to 1999.

Even more telling is that under a National Government, Alison was appointed (Acting) Chief Executive of the NZ Fire Service in 1999. Now this was at a time when the Fire Service was hugely controversial, there had been a CIR on it etc. It was a powder keg and potentially a major election issue.

But Alison Timms was appointed, despite her marriage to Tony Timms, because she was trusted to act in a professional manner and not misuse confidential information she had. Because her Minister did not interfere.
Case Study 2 – Alec McLean

Alec McLean is a respected civil servant (and former Olympic rower!) who is currently Helen Clark’s Senior Private Secretary. He is one of the few (very valuable) professional SPSs who work for the Ministerial Services section of DIA. He is married to (or the partner of) Dinah Okeby who has worked for Labour Party MPs since 1984 and was/is Helen Clark’s private secretary.

Now within a Minister’s private office (very different to their Department) the Minister does have basically absolute veto on who works for them, or not. One can absolutely decide not to employ someone because their partner works for an opposing MP. But Alec was employed in the 1990s as a Senior Private Secretary (the most senior role in a Minister’s office) by both Deputy PM Don McKinnon and Tony Ryall, despite his wife working for Helen Clark. That is because they trusted his professionalism and that he and his wife could separate out their professional and persona lives.

So we have two clear examples of potential conflicts of interest which was massively more substantial than a 3rd or 4th level manager in the Environment Ministry having a press secretary as a partner. In neither case were they denied a job or moved out of one, because of the potential conflict.
Now for the next two case studies, let us look at a situation where the grounds for moving someone out of a job are far greater- when it is the actual civil servant who has the political connection, not their partner.

Case Study 3 – Verna Smith

Verna Smith stood for Labour in 1996. You can not get more a political conflict of interest than that. She was No 25 on their list, missing out by just four places.

Both prior to and after the 1996 election Verna was a senior manager with the Department of Social Welfare. I don’t have all her roles but she has been policy and strategy manager for CFA, General Manager of CYF Contracting, and CYF General Manager of Social Work etc.

All senior roles, and ones which the then Minister recalls often involved attending meetings and briefings in the Minister’s office. So even the fact she was a Labour Party candidate did not result her being moved to a different job. Again she was trusted not to misuse information she learnt at work.

Case Study 4 – Parekura Horomia

Parekura Horomia in the 1990s was a civil servant and a highly ranked Regional Manager for Te Puni Kokiri. Prior to that he was general manager of the Community Employment Group.

He stood for Labour in the 1999 election. He was a confirmed Labour Party candidate for the best part of a year. His job was in an area which undoubtedly he would be involved with as an MP.  But despite this he was not shifted sideways.  He did not lose his job until the mandatory stand down for the election campaign.

So all four case studies show that there have been far far greater political conflicts of interests that that of  Madeleine Setchell, and they have never had their careers suffer for it.  Yet, despite this history, Helen Clark believes Madeleine Setchell should never have been appointed to her role.  Helen Clark’s view of a neutral public service is very different to National’s.  This is of course why Wellington was named Helengrad by some civil servants.

If a future National Government was to adopt Helen Clark’s views as the standard for ineligibility to hold senior or sensitive roles in the public service, then dozens and dozens of civil servants would be out of their jobs.  Fortunately National has confirmed they will not behave like Labour has.

I shudder to think what life will be like in the public service if Labour get back for a fourth term.  Helen Clark’s view that having a family member associated with National is reason enough not to be employed, will reign.

PM says Benson-Pope didn’t know

The PM has said that David Benson-Pope did not even know Steve Hurring was calling the Minister’s chief executive.

So in Helen’s world DBP has done nothing wrong at all, and as for Hurring – in the ultimate wet bus ticket slap, he is “an extremely hard working and conscientious employee” who might need to “reflect on whether the call was wise” and will get get “at least a little counselling”.

Also Helen actually thinks Setchell should never have been employed at all – something I’ll deal with in a later post.

Audrey Young of the Herald blogs:

I don’t know which is worse, Helen Clark’s double standards or the State Services Commission’s toadyism in the Madeleine Setchell employment affair.

Deputy State Services Commissioner Iain Rennie rather sweetly relies on the view that Benson Pope’s henchman, Steve Hurring, simply sought information from Logan about Setchell’s private links.

The unspoken question would have more force: Do you realise that your new comms manager will be working closely on some of the campaigns on sustainability and carbon-neutrality we feel certain that the ministry will be planning before the election next year?

If Labour had nothing to hide, it would have nothing to worry about. But the line between legitimate public information and political advertising has become increasingly blurred. That is why Auditor General Kevin Brady instigated a cautioning report before about it the 2005 election.

We always knew the politicians had blurred the line to get money for nothing: the real worry with this case is that it appears the state sector bosses are willing to go along with it.

Colin Espiner has a Tui moment in relation to the PM’s claim there was no political interference.

There’s a certain advertisement for a brand of beer that springs to mind upon hearing that David Benson-Pope was nowhere near the phone call from his office to the chief executive of the Ministry of the Environment.

Yeah, right. Senior political advisers in front-bench ministers’ offices routinely make sensitive telephone calls on employment matters to the heads of their minister’s department without checking with their boss first.

But there was no political interference. Oh, no. It was a simple, innocent phone call to enquire about Setchell’s wellbeing and how she was settling into her new job. Benson-Pope, known as something of a control freak who keeps his staff on a tight leash, had no knowledge of the call and hadn’t heard the rumours swirling around the Beehive that Setchell was the partner of Taylor.

I think I just saw a big pig fly past my Beehive annex window.

Colin also goes on to note that there is a pattern of behaviour here with this Minister:

So the staff member gets the blame. There’s a certain sense of deja vu in all of this. Benson-Pope, who has gone through more press secretaries than he’s had hot Bellamy’s dinners, burned off one of his previous secretaries after he was hung out to dry for leaking a police report clearing Benson-Pope of wrongdoing over allegations he mistreated pupils in his care while a teacher at Bayfield High School.

Pete Coleman got the blame, although it later transpired that Benson-Pope had known of the leak and had authorised it.

Also worth a look at is video shot today of Duncan Garner interviewing Benson-Pope. It is seven minutes long but worth viewing.

Also Colin James has some useful thoughts on the issue, noting:

A person in a minister’s office speaks for the minister. The minister is responsible for what that person says or does as a member of the minister’s office whether or not it is as at the minister’s specific bidding or with the minister’s knowledge.

So, in effect, David Benson-Pope queried the employment of Madeleine Setchell, partner of Kevin Taylor, chief press secretary of Opposition leader John Key.

Final week for half price gym memberships

A reminder that FitnessNZ’s offer of half price gym memberships finishes at the end of this week.

You can go to their website and just click the region you live in. It will then show you a list of participating gyms for that area. You click on the gym you are interested in, and it shows you a range of prices for three, six and twelve months, along with the normal and discounted price. Some big savings there. For Bodyworks where I go that’s a $650 saving on a 12 month membership.

Happy Birthday Russell