RIP Fraser Folster

Like many in Wellington, and no doubt further afield, I am mourning the death of Fraser Folster who passed away on Friday.

Fraser was a journalist and then press secretary.  He worked for many Ministers of all hues and stripes.  He must have been one of the nicest people you can ever hope to meet.

Fraser was aged only 54, and over the last two weeks many of those who know him have been in shock when told of his limited prognosis.

Words can’t do justice to what a thoroughly decent and nice guy Fraser was.  I recall him cheerily coming in at 5 am to help do a media summary for a 6.30 am  meeting, and he was always smiling.

Fraser is somewhat infamous for missing the story of the year in 1989 when he was in hospital and David Lange came to visit him.  Lange, as he left and no doubt with a huge mischievous  smile, casually mentioned he was resigning tomorrow.  Fraser thought Lange was pulling his leg and did not follow it up, and as it happens Lange did resign the next day.

I’m not sure when the funeral service is, but will blog details when I have them.  It will be a very sad occasion.

A Who’s Who of the Madeleine Setchell story

Good Guys

The PSA

Bad Guys

Steve Hurring
Hugh Logan
David Benson-Pope
Mark Prebble

Innocent Bystanders

Madeleine Setchell
Kevin Taylor

Now let’s take each player one by one

The PSA

The PSA win the good guy award. As a trade union they are generally very cozy with a Labour Government, but by speaking out (no doubt due to many concerned members contacting them) they remind people of the salient point. To quote them:

“The commissioner says it would be wrong to conclude anyone with political family connections is unwelcome in the public service. But I’m afraid I’m not reassured because of the way this case was handled,” says Brenda Pilott, National Secretary of the PSA, which has 55,000 members working in the state sector.

If the Government gets away with moving someone out of a public service job, just because of their family, then the bar has been moved – and not in a minor way.

Steve Hurring

We’ll take the bad guys in chronological order. Steve Hurring is a Senior Advisor to David Benson-Pope. He is also a [former] Vice-President of the NZ Labour Party. In a Minister’s office you have a mixture of political appointees and apolitical – he is clearly political. He is a former EPMU union official.

Hurring made the call to the Secretary for the Environment about Setchell. He should have made no such call. The whitewash excuse that he did not know if she was Taylor’s partner and was just checking if it was true is crap. You would not call the CEO to find that out. You would call her direct report. You call the CEO to complain.

But at the end of the day Hurring is only a minor villain. Because there can be no doubt that he would not have made that call without his Minister’s permission or more likely at his request.

Hugh Logan

Logan has acted disgracefully as CEO of the Environment Ministry. His only response to the Minister’s Office should have been “We trust this person’s professionalism. We have of course made very clear to her the absolute need for discretion and confidentiality. If she ever gives us cause for concern then we will take action, but as her employer she has my confidence to behave impartially”.

Logan is a bad employer and has seriously dented confidence in an apolitical public service. He has failed his staff and frankly I think his position is untenable. How could any future Government have confidence in him?

David Benson-Pope

David Benson-Pope has a habit of being, shall we say, evasive with the truth. After denying he knew any details about the case, the SSC report reveals he had a direct briefing on the case by Hugh Logan. The SSC report did not interview Benson-Pope or Hurring so we do not know how often they discussed it between themselves.

Of course the Minister should not have authorised Hurring to complain to Logan. By dong so he politicised the public service. The SSC report states that Logan not Benson-Pope made the decision to move Setchell from her job. This is an irrelevant truism. Of course Logan made the decision – it is impossible for anyone else to have done so. That is not the issue. The issue is what views did Hurring and Benson-Pope express to him, and how much he was influenced by them. Keeping the Minister happy sits very high on CEO’s priorities.

Mark Prebble

This is the person who has most disappointed me. I expect Benson-Pope to behave like he did, but it is incredibly regrettable that the head of the public service has become complicit in defending what happened, rather than protecting the public service’s neutrality. Prebble went into print last week claiming that what happened did not mean people with family in politics could not work in the public service. But as the PSA pointed out, one can no longer reach that conclusion.

Prebble as head of the public service should have been telling his Environment CEO not to damage the neutrality of the public service, that managing the conflict has almost never meant removing them from their job, and that the CEO’s response to the Minister should have been to assert independence over staff decisions and reassure the Minister of faith on his staff’s professionalism and integrity.

I don’t know Prebble particularly well. He worked in DPMC when I was in the PMs Office but I was about as junior as you can get on the totem pole, and he was at the very top. But I have always regarded him as one of the most intelligent and competent public servants NZ has. We’re certainly way better off for his contributions over many year.

But if I had one major criticism, it would his tendency to put his loyalty to the Government of the Day ahead of his loyalty to the institution of Government. We saw it over Corngate and we see it again today. And it is a worrying tendency for someone who is now head of the public service.

Madeleine Setchell
I have never met Madeleine Setchell. But some Google research shows that she has worked in the public service for many years, in roles very similiar to the one she took up at the Environment Ministry. It is unthinkable that the Ministry CEO would have asked her to leave her job had he not had a call from the Minister’s Office. She has previously been a Senior Comms Advisor for MAF and a spokeswoman for OSH in the DOL. Presumably she left a current job to take up the Environment job, and is now out of work.

As everyone has stressed she has behaved entirely properly in disclosing her relationship, and there has been no reason at all to suggest she has not and would not act in a professional manner. It is ironic that Steve Hurring [was] is the union vice-president of Labour, as his actions (on behalf of DBP) led to a worker losing her job for no good reason – something unions are meant to be against.

Kevin Taylor

Kevin worked for the NZ Herald for many years, and was a professional journalist. A couple of years ago he took up a role as a senior press secretary to the Leader of the Opposition and late last year was promoted to chief press secretary.

Staff in the leader’s office broadly are of two types. Those with a party background, and those without. People like myself in National, or Tony Timms (or Steve Hurring) in Labour are what jokingly get called the true believers.

The other staff, while certainly comfortable with what a party stand for, are not party members or activists. Examples are Mike Munro in Labour, Rob Eaddy in United Future and Kevin Taylor.

So Kevin isn’t a party hack. He comes from a journalist background, and like his partner, has moved into communications. I haven’t chatted to him about this, but can only just imagine how mortified he is having his relationship such a matter of public debate. He’s also a victim in this.

So of al the four bad guys, who is most to blame? I am tempted to say Hugh Logan who as CEO undoubtedly made totally the wrong call in asking Setchell to leave her job.

But at the end of the day I ask one question. If Steve Hurring had not made that phone call on behalf of his Minister, is there any real possibility Logan would have removed her from her job? No there is none. So Benson-Pope has to take responsibility. He had direct conversations with the CEO on this and Hurring works at his direction.

At the end of the day this is not an issue just about one civil servant who lost her job. It is about whether one has a neutral public service or a partisan public service. I am not in favour of an American style public service, and it is a shame to see the head of the civil service trying to pretend that what happened was acceptable.

UPDATE: Hurring is no longer a Labour Party Vice-President.  The Labour website was two years out of date!

Fiji vs Bloggers

Murray has a transcript of a chiling interview with Fijian military re Fijian bloggers:

 HILL: And, is there any truth to the reports that the army is preparing to round up another 20 people on suspicion of being bloggers?

LEWENI: There are investigations ongoing, but I couldn’t confirm to you the number of people.

HILL: What’s so wrong about it? They’re just engaging in some free speech, which is protected by the Fiji Constitution?

LEWENI: What paid to go around and saying bad things about people and speculating? To you that’s right? If that’s right, then I don’t think we should continue this conversation, bye.

So in Fiji it is now illegal to speculate and say bad things about people.

OECD Report on Telecommunications

I’m late blogging this but want to highlight how we compare to other OECD countries in regards to telecommunications.

First of all as TUANZ notes, we spend much more in NZ on telecommunications than any other country. A total of 5.4% of GDP compared to an OECD average of 3.0%. We are placed 1st of 30 for total spend.

So you would think with such a high level of telco revenue, we would be near the top for capital investment. But alas we spend barely half the OECD average as a % of revenue on capital investment. Just 8.7% of telco revenue went into capital investment, while the OECD average is 15.3%. So we are 3rd lowest of 30 for capital expenditure.

This is why the changes made last year were so necessary. NBR referred to the crushing weight on our economy and at 5.4% of GDP that is indeed a huge weight. And to have so little of it go back into capital investment indicates a market failure.

The Herald also has some good extracts, comparing investment levels in various countries.

Update on Labour “retirements”

Family First want boycott of Hell’s Pizza

Family First are urging people to boycott Hell’s Pizza over their Hell-O magazine.

They have a long list of features that have upset them, including:

Picture of President Bush
“Hell Condoms, for those who don’t know when to pull out”

which personally I think is bloody good.

 

In terms of whether or not the boycott will be effective, well I doubt those with religious sensitivities tended to be frequenting “Hell” Pizza anyway!

Peters vs Shirley

The beloved Foreign Minister took time out from his travels to urge the Researched Medicines Industry Association to rescind the appointment of Ken Shirley as their new CEO.

A very petty thing to do.  Winston claims it is because Shirley is not a supporter of the health system.

It couldn’t at all be related to the fact that Peters is trying to sue Shirley.

Connell to NZ First?

Economic illiteracy

Matt McCarten admits himself that he is not into economics, saying “Economists are a secular priesthood, where they speak their own gibberish, and we hope they know what they’re talking about.”

But even with this disclaimer, he should know better than to write:

But when I read this week that Warren Buffet – one of the richest men in the world – made more than NZ$150 million just by speculating on our dollar from 2003 to 2006, I know something very, very bad is going on with our economy. This year alone, our exchange rate has soared to 27 per cent. The mind boggles how much extra money he and other foreign speculators have been skimming off us in the past six months.

The notion that gains made by currency traders is somehow at the expense of taxpayers is just simply economically illiterate.

The mid-winter funk

Fran O’Sullivan labels Labour as having a mid-winter funk.  All their 1 July policy achievements have been over shadowed with other news:

  •  parliamentary defeat over plans for a trans-Tasman therapeutics regulatory agency
  • severe criticism of suggestions by Finance Minister Michael Cullen he could suspend monetary policy
  • inquiry into HB District Health Board
  • the action of David Benson-Pope and his office which reuslted in a civil servant losing her job

Later in the article Richard Prebble is quoted as saying “The Greens must know they have a better chance of making a National Cabinet than Labour” while Barry Gustafson says “It’s by no means certain that the Greens would go with National.”

I can’t even see a National/Green coalition.   If Labour is in a position to form a Government, the Greens I am sure will choose them 99 times out of 100.

However it is not impossible that National could negotiate an agreement for the Greens to abstain on supply and confidence, if a Labour led Government is not viable.

Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows

Okay this thread is for people to discuss the book, either as you read it, or once you have finished.  Obviously this will involve huge spoilers for those who have not read the book so read comments at your own danger.

Pity Dr Bollard

One can only feel sympathy for the awful position the Reserve Bank Governor has been placed in. Part of the solution to getting inflation down (domestic inflation is at over 4%) is to reduce expectations of future inflation. It isn’t just about house prices and the level of government spending. If people expect 5% inflation then they ask for 5% pay rises and then employers put prices up by 5% etc etc. Some people say the RB Governor’s most powerful weapon is his megaphone.

The problem is the Government is undermining this. When the Foreign Minister says he wants to change the law away from targeting low inflation, then expectations are affected – especially when the Government says they won’t vote against it at first reading. Even worse, when the Finance Minister publicly muses about using the emergency powers to suspend the agreed inflation target range, that is a massive signal regarding inflation expectations.

I am surprised that Dr Cullen is blundering so badly, as generally he has been a fairly solid performer. But it reminds me of something I blogged six weeks or so ago. This Government has never faced a really tough economic issue. They have never had to confront a $5 billion deficit or an Asian Crisis. They have never had to deal with doing something very unpopular but economically necessary.

You see the current level of the dollar is not a crisis. Yes there are sectors which will be really hurting. But the country is not about to go into recession. Home owners are not going to be defaulting by the thousands. There is no emergency which comes closes to justifying the Finance Minister musing abous suspending monetary policy. All we have is a Government which can’t handle the pressure and is undermining the Reserve Bank in its task to keep inflation low.

The Herald reports that most economists are saying the Reserve Bank must now raise interest rates next week, or be seen not to be independent.

Brian Fallow reviews what is causing the inflation and why the Governor must increase the cash rate. He quotes Westpac chief economist Brendan O’Donovan as sayign he expects a hike not just next week but also in September. If this is the case, I wonder if Dr Bollard would be better to do a 0.5% hike next week instead of the minimum 0.25%. This would be a very clear signal that the RB remains dedicated to pushing inflation down and would help reduce expectations of higher inflation. That way it might then be his last rise.

John Armstrong reviews Dr Cullen’s actions:

If he does not suspend the Reserve Bank’s primary focus on controlling inflation, he will be accused of making empty threats and his credibility will take another knock among those suffering from the high dollar and interest rates. And more so should the bank’s governor, Alan Bollard, again hike the official cash rate next week.

Alternatively, if Cullen does follow through, he risks his credibility being completely ravaged if it creates more problems than it solves – as many economists fear would happen.

In threatening to override the bank’s priority of price stability and require it to avoid damaging the exchange rate, Cullen has shaken monetary policy to the core.

Suspending the priority on tackling inflation for 12 months may be fine in a recession. In an overheating economy, it is a recipe for disaster.

Uncertainty about the direction of economic policy might see lenders add a premium to interest rates, while the tight labour market would likely provoke a wage-price spiral upwards. Labour’s record as a credible economic manager would correspondingly spiral downwards.

Don Brash was on Agenda this morning.  He agreed with Fallow that Cullen’s intervention means that Bollard almost has no alternative to increase rates. Brash also made the point that so many have missed – the real solution is to make changes which will increase productivity which will allow the level of non inflationary growth to increase.

Brash also made the point that high inflation does not help exporters in the long run.  He reminds us  that once the NZ$ was $1.12 vs the US yet today exporters struggle at $0.80.  The reason is because over time our inflation has been higher than our trading partners. The Zespri CEO agreed 100% that relaxing the inflation limit would not help exporters.  He said the dollar goes up and down but once inflation goes up it never goes down (in terms of the price level).

Fallow on Agenda stressed the point I made above, that Cullen’s statements may lead to an increase in pricing expectations and undermine Bollard’s job to reduce them.

While most of the focus has been on Cullen for his foolish talk of suspending monetary policy, I should also say that I think John Key should resist the temptation to say whether or not he thinks Dr Bollard should or should not increase the cash rate.  If he gets into a habit of saying what he thinks the RB Governor should do as Opposition Leader, then he may find it hard to not comment if he is Prime Minister.  This is not to say he shouldn’t comment generally on monetary policy, where he thinks the dollar is heading etc.  He has considerable expertise in these.  But politicians are best not to specifically state what they think the Governor should do with the cash rate.

The Teacher’s Council

There is a perception that the teaching profession is not as vigilant about protecting children as it could be, with a number of dubious decisions from the Teacher’s Council which even the Minister resiles from.

The Herald this morning reports a truly awful outcome.  A teacher, Derek James McCarthy, was found with child porn on a school computer in 1999.  The then Teachers Registration Board decided not to strike him off the roll of registered teachers.

This week he was convicted of molesting a nine year old boy in 2005.

I would have though possessing child porn would be a no brainer for striking someone off as a teacher.

The fact that the teacher went on to employ such methods such as “touch the boy’s penis if he did not answer multiplication questions (such as 6 x 12) correctly” is a tragedy for the boy involved.  The parents will rightfully be very angry at the system which allowed this teacher to carry on.

Incidentally at school I was very good at my times table and could do up to 25 x 25.  If I had a teacher such as  Derek McCarthy I suspect I would have been spending five hours a night on homework until I could could do every combination up to 100 x 100!!!

Maori Party upset at Labour official’s statement

NZPA are running the following story:

The Maori Party says it is horrified by a Labour Party official’s reported remark that “Pakeha prefer to vote for white people with names they can pronounce”.

A Radio New Zealand report by its Pacific issues correspondent attributed the remark to Labour’s women’s vice president Kate Sutton.

It also reported her as saying Labour took that preference into account when it selected candidates for local body elections.

Maori Party MP Te Ururoa Flavell said it was “outright racism” to select candidates on that basis.

“If that was the case, I probably wouldn’t have made the grade,” he said.

“Nor would my friend Tariana Turia, or even perhaps Hone Harawira.”

Mr Flavell suggested the Labour Party should explain why its candidate selection process seemingly prioritised white people with names that could be easily pronounced.

This may explain why the NZ Labour Party has no Welsh MPs – they couldn’t pronounce their names!

$20,000 for 7 cm

The Resistance!

Gossipmonger mother sues rival gossipmonger

Poor little foot soldiers

You can only feel sorry for the poor little Labour MPs last night.  ACT proposed an amendment to the Sentencing and Parole Act restoring the automatic right of the victims of crime to attend parole hearings.

Labour MPs were in full flight opposing the amendment and saying why it was bad law.  And then Mark Burton got up and announced Labour would be voting for it.

I suspect he had some angry backbenchers to placate, for not working it out earlier to save them looking stupid.

It could almost become a famous John Kerry type quote – “I spoke against it before I voted for it” 🙂

Virtual NPC

Okay the time to play Virtual NPC is upon us.  I’ve set up again a NZ Bloggers challenge.  To take part, do the following.

Go to Virtual NPC and register as a user.  If you have participated in previous seasons it can transfer your details over.

Then go to the challenges page and click on join a challenge.

Type “NZ Bloggers” into the top search box. Then join it with the password “bloggers”.

Also my profile is “dpfdpf” for those who want to do direct comparisons.  I made the top 10% or so last time so I’m aiming for top 5% this time.

Transtasman on Parliamentary Satire

I’ve previously blogged that while I think the rules banning satrical use of footage from Parliament are silly, I don’t think having the press gallery pretend they are Nelson Mandelas fighting for freedom does much either. Transtasman sums it up well:

There are few spectacles as ridiculous as elected representatives trying to stop people laughing at them. The spectacle of journalists behaving like cheeky sixth formers, and pretending they are very brave in doing so, comes pretty damn close.

Indeed.

Tintin is racist!

Well according to Borders anyway.

I suspect few things written in 1931 are quite as enlightened as we are today, but hell hiding them from the kids when they are a kids book is daft.  Good to see Whitcoulls not playing along.

Next they’ll ban Shakespeare’s work because some people think it is anti-semitic.

Cullen playing with fire

Dr Cullen is playing with fire by even hinting that he may suspend monetary policy, and direct the Reserve Bank to stop targeting inflation.

This would be the end of 20 years of bipartisan consensus on monetary policy.  It would be a return to the failed policies of the 1970s.

Apart from his overtaxing of NZers, Michael Cullen’s record has been one of a reasonably successful and orthodox Finance Minister. Job growth has been strong, and economic growth has been reasonable (yet below what we need).  But if he starts dicking around with monetary policy in some sort of panic over the dollar, he will be returning to Muldoonism.

It would also be seen as a vote of no confidence in the Reserve Bank.

I suspect he is trying to pressure the Governor to not increase interest rates at the next review.  According to the law and the agreed policy targets agreement, most market experts are saying Bollard should raise interest rates again – because the latest inflation data was stronger than expected.  Cullen is really telling Bollard to ignore the PTA and the law and not to put interest rates up again, with the implied threat of suspending monetary policy if he does.

It will be fascinating to see what Dr Bollard does?  If he does not raise interest rates he will be seen to be caving in to Cullen, and if inflation again breaches the acceptable limit, his reputation as Governor will be damaged.  But if he ignores Cullen and does increase interest rates, the Government may then intervene which could create a crisis of confidence.

On TV today

Filling in for Wille Jackson (who is away) on the Good Morning political panel today at 11.10 am.  By coincidence I am up in Auckland and staying at Sky City when TVNZ asked if I could fill in.  Sky City is literally next door to TVNZ in Auckland so couldn’t be more convenient.

Cactus Kate on Gareth Morgan on Kiwisaver

Money is the one subject in which Cactus Kate is even more of an expert than she is on sex and relationships. I suspect she would even rank their importance in that order!

So when she blogs about Gareth Morgan is “dead on the money” about Kiwisaver fees, one should listen.  The Government subsidies will over time make KiwiSaver a de facto compulsory scheme.  The Government should ensure that all fees and charges are as transparent as possible.

Heh duped indeed