Pushing the Boundaries

All political parties have a habit of appointing friendly people to various Ambassadorships and boards.

But as the Dominion Post editorial says, Labour is pushing the boundaries beyond what is acceptable. They cite two examples.

The first is the appointment of Ross Wilson as ACC Chair.  Now one could possibly justify the appointment if at the time of the vacancy he was available and best qualified.  But they have kept the job open for eleven months, leaving ACC without stable leadership, just so he can take over the day he ends up at the CTU.  Could you imagine anyone other person in NZ having a board chair role kept open 11 months for them? Of course not.

It is also incredibly insulting to the other board members and the Acting Chair to say we have so little faith in you that we will keep you without a permament Chair for 11 months, rather than appoint one of them as Chair.

The Dom Post also touches on the incredibly vindictive action towards Madeleine Setchell who lost her job in the Environment Ministry simply because her partner worked for National not Labour.  Mark Prebble should be defending the neutrality of the public service, not help Minister’s offices get rid of public servants bcause the Minister does not like their boyfriend.

As the Dominion Post says, there have been numerous examples of partners of Labour Party people holding roles in the public service – both under National and Labour. In fact Alison Timms was appointed acting head of the fire service in 1999 while her husband, Tony, was a very senior adviser to Helen Clark.  And that is how it should be – you trust people’s professionalism.

As the Dominion Post concludes:

The problem for Ms Setchell was not that her partner worked for a politician; it is that he worked for a politician from the wrong political party.

Harry Potter Book Seven on the Internet

Peter McC blogs on how someone has photographed the seventh Harry Potter book – Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, and placed them on the Internet. Peter deleted the file after the first chapter.

I’m not going to link to where one can get a copy. J K Rowling deserves to have people buy the book, not take it for free. Not that I think many people really want to read a 700 page book as a series of jpegs!

But I am going to give away below a major spoiler.  A really really big spoiler.  So if you don’t like spoilers don’t read the rest of the post.  However the spoiler does not give away the ending – in fact it will probably make you more likely to want to buy the book.

Continue reading »

Tertiary Prostitution Courses

NZPA reports how officials from the Tertiary Education Commission said funding for prostitution training courses could be considered under new criteria.

I think the sums up well what Katherine Rich labelled as the “agnostic” attitude that TEC seems to have had towards course content.   I don’t think the Government should be selective about what courses are offered by tertiary providers, but they sure as hell should be selective about what they fund.  It should be more than justcorrectly ticking the right boxes on a criteria form.

Under the TEC reign (and to be fair it has been better lately) we have seen hundreds of millions of dollars go on low quality courses which are almost scams.  Certain tertiary providers have shown huge innovation at how they rort the system.

Whale Oil enjoys himself in proposing specific courses such as “Advanced Book-keeping for whores” 🙂

Electoral Law proposed changes due soon

Newsroom reports that Labour will introduce changes to the Electoral Act next week. It is appalling that they continue to negotiate in secret changes to one of our most important constitutional acts.

I suspect that their changes will be primarily designed to silence critics of the Government in election year. It may be the most draconian attack on free speech we have seen. Otherwise why else would they have not consulted all parties on the changes, or released a policy paper before introducing law changes.

Also this bill was due in the House months ago. Because they have kept delaying it until they have the numbers stitched up in secret, its timing is now going to be an issue. Normally a bill has six months with a select committee to allow for full submissions and consideration. So a bill introduced in July might have first reading in August, report back in February, and get passed into law in March or April.

But this will break the convention of no changes to the Electoral Act in election years. So Labour will have to either break the convention or ram the changes through Parliament under a shortened timeframe. Both are highly undesirable.

Insolent Prick blogs on why the Government is so keen to silence its critics in election year.  It’s all about  stopping forest owners from complaining about the  nationalisation of their carbon credits.

SIS vs Gangs

I’m surprised there hasn’t been more coverage of the suggestion by the SIS Director that the mandate of the SIS be expanded to include fighting organised crime such as gangs.

I can’t see that one can seriously entertain such a proposal.  It would blur the roles of the Police and intelligence agencies too much.

Cut Red Tape

Preferring blondes

Hayley Holt

(Photo of Hayley Holt)

A former Canterbury psychology professor has written a book which explains why men are attracted to busty blondes.

This needs a book and a psychology professor to explain it???

Of course it is all a vicious stereotype. Men would never base attraction on hair colour or breast size. We are far more civilised than that. There’s nothing wrong with redheads. No nothing at all. And women never judge on arbitrary criteria such as height. No never happens.

NZ Herald on Complementary Medicines

The NZ Herald had a good editorial on what was wrong with the proposed trans-tasman agency on complementary medicines.

After five years of fitful debate the Government has given up its attempt to control a wide range of health products – everything from surgical equipment to sunscreens and vitamin pills – through a joint licensing agency with Australia.

The complaint from many suppliers of herbal remedies and dietary supplements in this country was that the mooted transtasman regulatory regime would needlessly import Australian restrictions, adding to their costs and rendering it uneconomic for non-Australian manufactures to supply New Zealand’s small market.

Many natural concoctions available in this country cannot be sold in Australia, where even dietary supplements are regulated as medicines. Here they are approved under the Food Act 1981 and subject to regulations issued in 1985 that set permissible dosages and labelling requirements. Some make dubious claims on accompanying pamphlets that are outside those controls. But the proposed joint arrangement looked more like the Australian regime to industry insiders of both countries.

The Australian economy is more regulated than ours in many sectors these days. Much of it seems petty and needlessly restrictive to New Zealand visitors and traders. We do not need to buy into it. Closer economic relations can surely survive separate regulatory regimes whenever we beg to differ.

Silly Labour behaviour re Maori Party

The Maori Party obviously still has Labour worried. Some of Labour’s more excitable Maori MPs were demanding the Maori Party MPs resign because the Maori Party did not have the numbers to pass the first reading of their Foreshore & Seabed Bill.

This is about as sensible as demanding the Green Party resign because greenhouse gas levels are still rising,or that NZ First resign because we still allow immigrants in.

The Maori Party has four MPs, not 61 MPs.  Does Labour really think Maori voters are so stupid that they expected the Maori Party could unilaterally repeal the law?  Of course not.  They expect them to keep the issue alive and make their best effort to repeal it.

The logical response for Maori voters to to increase the number of Maori Party MPs to increase their leverage. Of course that would probably result in more overhang MPs which undermines the proportionality of MMP.

350 political geeks

So 350 tuned into Parliament yesterday. Hands up you sad political geeks 🙂

The Herald also reports on the heroic deeds of the TV networks who seem to regard themselves as modern day Nelson Mandelas – risking prison to show the truth – TV3 had a nose picking MP, TV One four snoozing MPs and Prime an evicted MP.

The only thing worse than the self righteousness of the TV networks is Michael Cullen trying to defend the satire ban by invoking the Queen’s treatment by the BBC.

But that was not satire.  That was a disgusting and possibly malicious case of misrepresentation. And the BBC has been pilloried for it and those involved may lose their jobs.

Presley vs Dick

Annette Presley is suing former husband Malcolm Dick over his setting up of a new company which has all the directors and shareholders of Callplus – except Ms Presley.

If it proceeds to court, it will be an interesting test of the fiduciary duty obligation on directors. Having Directors set up a new business which excludes a current shareholder could indeed pose problems.

Go Boris Go!

Making it up

More made up claims regarding the 20 “free” hours policy.

Steve Maharey was asked how much the average weekly saving would be for parents with children at kindy, and he said about $60.

However the Kindergarten Association said initial figures showed 76 per cent of kindy parents would save $20 or less.

How could this be?

A spokeswoman for Mr Maharey said his estimate was not based on “official” figures but anecdotal information from kindergartens, parents and officials.

Oh that explains it. He made it up.

Almost there

Jordan on National frontbench

In a post where Jordan explains it is a choice between “high handed dishonest Nats” and “the Labour government they have today” (got to love the epitaphs) Jordan says:

But if you look at the core of the National Front Bench (English, Ryall, Brownlee, Collins, Williamson, Lockwood Smith) you are looking at the past. Those are the people who implemented the policies people threw out in 1999, after trying to throw them out in 1996 as well.

First of all Jordan is straight out wrong.  Judith Collins only became an MP in 2002 and Gerry Brownlee did not have an Executive role between 1996 and 1999.  And Lockwood is not even on the front bench.  There are more errors than non errors in his assertion.

Also note that Jordan to try and make a point has randomly selected some front benchers.  He skips over three others who all came into Parliament in 1999 or 2002.

Not that I think there is anything wrong with those who were in Government in the 1990s.  For all Jordan goes on about how their policies were rejected, Labour have changed relatively few of them, and I doubt the average NZer is as obsessed with the 90s as Labour activists are.

The irony in all this is if you take the top eight in each party, well the ones most associated with the past are Labour. All but two of them entered Parliament in or before 1984 and their average age is just over 58.  Contrast with National whose average year of entry to Parliament is 1996 and  average age is just under 44.

Swain confirms his retirement

Paul Swain has confirmed that he will retire at the 2008 election after 18 years in Parliament.

While never a high flyer, Swain was a pretty competent Minister.  And I always appreciated the fact he did recommend local loop unbundling in 2003, but Theresa went over his head and struck a deal with Helen.  Would have been nice to have LLU happen three years earlier.

His seat is reasonably safe, so will be interesting to see who stands for it, now that Andrew Little has said he won’t.

Foreshore & Seabed bill to fail

National actually announced months ago it would not be supporting the Maori Party bill to repeal the Foreshore & Seabed Act so it isn’t really big news that they have confirmed they will vote against at first reading.

Personally it’s a pity a compromise couldn’t be found with the Maori Party so it could at least make Select Committee, but it takes two to compromise.

Congestion Charging

The Business Roundtable in their latest newsletter brought to my attention an excellent article by Andrew Leigh which appeared last month in the Australian Financial Review on congestion charging.

I am a fan of congestion charging.  It is the market at work, where in times of increased demand, you pay more.  In some areas in the US the congestion charge actually changes by the minute depending on how congested a road is.  This allows you to choose between a free road with no guaranteed time to reach your destination and a road where they can guarantee the time, but the price is variable.

In nineteenth century Britain, the law required all steam cars to be preceded by an attendant carrying a red flag. In cities, cars were not permitted to drive faster than 6 km/h. In twenty-first century Australia, convention requires that every peak hour driver in Australia must have steam coming out their ears, and be preceded by an equally red-faced driver. In cities like Sydney, this ensures that peak hour speeds average 12 km/h.

Congestion costs are a classic example of what economists call a ‘negative externality’ (or what your grandmother might have called ‘just plain selfishness’). In deciding whether to drive or take the train, I consider only on my own costs: fares, fuel, tyres and time. But I ignore the impact that my decision to drive has on you and everyone else on the roads.

A natural solution is to force drivers to ‘internalise’ the negative externality, by raising the price of driving into busy areas. Just as ’sin taxes’ on alcohol, tobacco and gambling recognise the potential harm that can be done to the rest of us, so a congestion fee is society’s way of making drivers take account of other road users.

Recognising the potential of congestion fees, London and Singapore now charge drivers a fee to enter the city during peak times. In April, New York has announced a plan to charge drivers US$8 to enter the southern half of Manhattan. Following successful trials last year, Stockholm will implement a congestion charge in July.

What is notable about these examples is that they come from across the political spectrum. In London, the chief proponent for the congestion fee was mayor Ken Livingstone (known as “Red Ken”). In New York, Republican mayor Michael Bloomberg is backing the charge. Congestion fees are a commonsense reform, not an ideological one.

In Australia, the use of public-private partnerships to build new motorways has led to a proliferation of toll-roads. Yet for the most part, those fees are not designed to reduce congestion. Busy old streets in the CBD are free. Quiet new toll-roads in the outer suburbs are pay-per-use. While a congestion fee should be higher in peak hour, Melbourne’s City Link and the Sydney Cross City Tunnel cost exactly the same whether you’re using them at 5pm or midnight.

With many cars now equipped with e-tags, Australia has the technology to get congestion charges right. An ideal system would charge commuters a fee to enter the city centre on weekdays. But simple changes could help immediately. For example, why not replace the $3 Sydney Harbour Bridge toll with a charge of $5 during weekdays, and $2 on nights and weekends?

Despite an outcry at the time it was implemented, British policymakers now generally recognise that the London congestion fee has been a success. Traffic volumes are down. Public transport usage is up. And average road speeds, which had fallen to jogging pace, are now increasing again.

As the Soviet Union eventually realised, queues help no-one. Time spent waiting in a traffic jam is neither devoted to productive activities, nor enjoyed with family and friends. With the typical worker spending the equivalent of seven days a year sitting in their car, coming up with clever ways to beat gridlock should be a high priority. A modest congestion fee might just be the solution that our lungs – and kids – have been looking for.

New pills

NZ Herald on Auckland Super City

The Herald editorial supports a more unified local government structure for Auckland.

Almost nothing of a civic nature happens unless it is done by one of the big four cities alone or an agency of the Government such as Transit NZ. The stalemate over the single city proposal is becoming a convincing argument for it.

A worthwhile solution to the city’s discord is unlikely to come from the bodies that are part of the problem. Once again, Auckland has to look to the Government to make something happen.

The leaders of both main political parties are Auckland residents and agree on the need for change. Little more has been heard on the subject from the Prime Minister but the National Party leader offered the project tentative support yesterday. John Key said a government led by him would reform Auckland’s set-up, though “now is not the time to make any decisions”.

He saw “a danger of rushing in and designing all sorts of new structures at the expense of actually thinking about what outcomes we are after”.

National politicians, even Auckland ones, are reluctant to risk offending the local loyalties of so many voters. But surely the Auckland MPs know that the real identity of their fellow citizens is not North Shore or Manukau or the other suburban units. When asked where they come from, citizens of all of those places are likely to reply, “Auckland”.

There is broad support for a more unified urban government, as long as the local element is not lost. A powerful single city council answerable to communities with their own representatives could fulfil that prescription. It is a plan members of the public should take upon themselves to consider. If they wait for their disparate councils to decide on it, they will wait forever.

Parliament Live

From today you can watch Parliament live over the Internet.  Sitting hours are:

Tuesday 2 pm – 6 pm, 7.30 pm – 10 pm
Wednesday 2 pm – 6 pm, 7.30 pm – 10 pm
Thursday 2 pm – 6 pm

Will be an interesting House session.  Sources tell me the Government is in a pretty foul mood with conceding defeat on the complementary medicines bill and the polls not shifting much – so it could be a fairly feisty question time.

Therapeutics Products and Medicine Bill dead

The Therapeutics Products and Medicine Bill is dead, or on hold which is the official euphemism for it.

I am surprised the Government did not concede earlier.  Even its own MPs have never been that keen on it.  I recall an earlier inquiry by the Health Select Committee which was unanimously against proceeding.

Sedition Submission

I’ve just done my submission on the Crimes (Repeal of Seditious Offences) Amendment Bill which I’ve included below. Submission close at the end of Tuesday. I’d encourage others to submit – my two pager took half an hour only and one can file them electronically.

  1. I write in support of the Crimes (Repeal of Seditious Offences) Amendment Bill.
  1. Generally speaking people should only go to jail for what they do, not for what they say. Of course this is not an absolute as you want to be able to restrict direct threats to individuals for example, but the current law is cast too wide.
  1. The existing Section 81(1) defines seditious intention as the intention:
    1. To bring into hatred or contempt, or to excite disaffection, against Her Majesty, or the Government of New Zealand or the administration of justice.
  1. This section especially is very wide ranging. I excite disaffection against both Her Majesty (as a National Councilor of the Republican Movement) and the Government on a regular basis. I could be judged to excite disaffection against the administration of justice – as arguably could be the National Justice Spokesperson also. There are defences in Section 81(2) but these are not absolute.
  1. One can argue that the Police would use discretion and only prosecute case where someone is clearly trying to (for example) illegally overthrow the Government. Alas, the history of prosecutions has shown that this is not the case. Most recently it was used in relation to a Dunedin bar owner having a competition for a petrol soaked couch. This clearly shows the Police will use such laws, even for trivial or dare I say trifling matters.
  1. In 2006 Tim Selwyn was convicted of sedition. His actions in smashing the window of the Prime Minister’s electorate office were deplorable and his actions in encouraging others to do the same were wrong. However these are a long way from needing a sedition law. His prosecution on other offences showed that the sedition charge was unnecessary as he was also convicted on the crime of conspiracy to commit criminal damage
  1. The blogger Idiot/Savant from No Right Turn has documented the historical uses of the sedition laws, and how these have been used and abused over our history. His archive is at http://norightturn.blogspot.com/2005/08/sedition-by-example-index.html and I recommend it as an excellent resource. Former PM Walter Nash is amongst those who have been found guilty of seditious offences.
  1. There are many other sections of the Crimes Act which can handle actions which are injurious to the public good, without the need of the sedition sections. They are:
    1. Treason s73
    2. Attempted Treason s74
    3. Inciting Mutiny s77
    4. Sabotage s79
    5. Unlawful Assembly s86
    6. Riot s87
    7. Criminal Nuisance s145
    8. Threatening to destroy property s307
    9. Threats of harm to people or property s307a
    10. Threatening act s308
    11. Conspiring to prevent collection of rates or taxes s309
  1. The existing criminal code has numerous, more appropriate, alternatives to the sedition laws.
  1. Also sections of other Acts also cover certain undesirable behaviors such as
    1. s131 of the Human Rights Act 1993
    2. s5 of the Terrorism Suppression Act 2002
    3. s3-s8 of the Summary Offences Act 1981
  1. In summary I agree with both the Law Commission’s report and the Bill before the Committee that the sedition laws should be repealed as:
    1. The meaning of sedition has changed over time and the definition in the Act is very broad and uncertain
    2. It is an infringement on free speech
    3. The current law could be used to restrict speech critical of the Government
    4. Other laws more are better suited to cover undesirable behaviour of a criminal nature
  1. I urge the Justice and Electoral Committee to support the Crimes (Repeal of Seditious Offences) Amendment Bill, and to recommend its passage to the House.

David Farrar
16 July 2007

Peak Oil

Roger Nome vented on another thread about peak oil.  Specifically he said:

What am I doing this Sunday morning? oh I don’t know, freaking out about the fact that we are on the cusp of global recession yet no one in New Zealand’s blogsphere seems to have a clue about it.

David, I see that you’re still yet to make one single post on the most important and urgent economic issue that this country, and indeed the world, currently faces. That is peak oil.

Now “Roger” has set up his own blog where people can read all about peak oil theory. And Insolent Prick has responded to Roger on his blog.

There is a lengthy debate on IPs’ blog between the two.  Worth reading.

Personally I don’t think decisions need to be made on the basis of guessing whose  prediction is right. If oil starts to become scarce, the price of oil and hence petrol will increase and the more it increase the more other sources of fuel will become economic.  To a limited degree we are already seeing this.

White Flight

The Aranui High School principal claims white flight is why his school has 500 students fewer than its capacity.

I’d be very interested to know if anyone has demographic breakdowns for the various Christchurch schools, so one can judge how greatly they differ by school.  Anyone can make an assertion.

It may also of course just be the case that parents do not think Aranui High School is as well run as other schools, hence why they go elsewhere.  Or they may prefer a single sex school. Or the other schools may have better academic standards.

If I ran a school which students actively avoid and is only 59% full, then I would spend a hell of a lot of time and energy working out why this is the case, and coming up with strategies to mitigate it.  Now maybe “white flight” is part of the problem, but where is the evidence for this, and are there are other issues around the school which can be changed?

At the end of the day, regardless of the reason, I support parents having a choice.  The Principals’ Association wants to ban out-of-zone enrolments. That suggest to me a focus on principals (as one would expect) not students.