17 days to go

17 days to go and The Parliamentary Service has confirmed neither United Future nor NZ First has paid back the amounts identified by the Auditor-General as illegal.

United Future have agreed to do so, and I am sure will.

NZ First is still being opaque and talking about an announcement in the near future but no clear commitment to pay it back before the end of the financial year.

Helengrad extends to Australia

A kind reader has sent me this newspaper clipping from Page 46 of the Australian Financial Review:

Hacks displeased with Clark’s Victorian ways

New Zealand Prime Minster Helen Clark looked right at home during a Melbourne business lunch yesterday to spruik trade connections. There were plenty of pictures of her country looking fabulous in videos featuring frolicking dolphins and snow-capped mountains. On hand, too, was plenty of good wine that took the tastebuds straight to the South Island.

The assembled crowed also got a sampling of her renowned tight grip on the script. Questions were invited from the floor but not in the customary, and unpredictable, way so beloved by Australian scribes. No, inquiries were to be written on a form along with the option of providing your name, submitted for approval and then presented to Clark.

Perhaps she was concerned that invited guest Toll boss Paul Little might ask a pesky question about their marriage over the railways or that Telstra chairman Donald McGauchie could query the state of the communications market.

A raised eyebrow about the state management brought a resigned response from a Kiwi hack: “It’s not called Helengrad for nothing.”

Lengthy John Key interview

Get Frank has done a lengthy three part interview with John Key, over Skype. You can read Part One, Part Two and Part Three.

The most amusing part to me was:

Q: It’s been argued that Murray McCulley was essentially New Zealand’s version of Dick Cheney for Don Brash in terms of being a significant ‘steerer’ of policy and strategy; what have you been doing to change that, because the party does seem in quite a different direction now to what it was, and you’re obviously reaping the benefits of that in terms of being preferred Prime Minister and Helen Clark being deposed for the first time in 8 years.

A: Firstly Murray McCully hasn’t shot his hunting partner, so I guess he’s got some differences to Dick Cheney

Also some thoughts on broadband:

Q: Can you tell us about your thoughts on broadband in New Zealand? Are you familiar with how the Japanese and Korean governments have used a mixture of incentives to encourage private companies to service small remote areas where the government matches private contributions. They now have speeds of up to 100Mb per second.

A: Well I think the first thing is, I think broadband is critical and the internet is critical to New Zealand’s economic success, so you can see that for the first time in New Zealand’s history, the tyranny of distance is not going to be an issue. Not withstanding that we’re not getting this to work currently at the moment. This is kind of the future I think of where we go in terms of business and politics and communication in general, and this is impossible unless you have broadband. I think secondly you’re absolutely right, I don’t know what the numbers of households are that are not economic to roll out broadband to currently, but my guess is it’s probably not a long way from half the current applications.

Q: And your policy in regards to the local loop unbundling and separation of Telecom.

A: We support local unbundling and the separation of Telecom. My view is that I’m not as negative as they are on operational separation and they’re really arguing that structural separation is the only thing that will work. They know the numbers better than I do, and my view’s been for a long period of time that they were pretty happy with the system that we’ve actually proposed, which is a tripartite model: a wholesale company, a retail company and a network company. But what ever, we will need to look at it. If structural separation is the right answer with a net-code type model then yeah; look maybe that’s the way forward. But whatever we do know is that, I think unless we can get competition into that market then a big monopolistic incumbent ultimately slows competition and we don’t like that.

English on tax cuts

No Right Turn is upset that Bill English has said he would like to see large numbers paying a top tax rate of no more than 20%. I’m delighted. It should be noted this is an aspiration, not a detailed policy, but good to see the heart is in the right place.

Of course the left are already claiming such a policy could costs $3 billion a year and that this would mean massive just massive spending cuts. Well sure if you ignore the huge surpluses we have running at twice that level. Also if you ignore the $26 billion of contignency spending over the next four years.

Now NRT points out 70% of people already pay less than 20%, as 70% earn less than $40,000. This is correct but somewhat misleading as the data includes everyone over 15 years old. So it includes those at school or uni, those on benefits and those retired.

If you look at families, and how many families have someone eanring over $38,000 – I would say it is well over half. So raising the threshold for the 33c rate from $38,000 would benefit a lot of families. The average income for a full-time earner is $46,002.

Remember in Australia, Peter Costello has lowered the tax on someone earning $50,000 by 32%.

Whoops

A female friend sends me photos of her recent travels. The first one is of her with a hottie, so I immediately fire back “Who’s the hottie?”

The reply comes back that I have already met Nicole, her sister. Ouch. Bad memory.

NZ Herald criticises the Reserve Bank

The NZ Herald editorial is critical of the Reserve Bak’s currency intervention and quotes the RB’s own research back at it:

Most fundamentally, Dr Bollard has erred by sending out a conflicting message. Just last Thursday, while lifting the official cash rate to 8 per cent, he implied a steelier approach to tackling inflation, notably by taking the wind out of the housing market. Further tightening would, it seemed, follow. Monday’s intervention conveyed a totally different impression. Selling the kiwi to lower the exchange rate is an easing move. As such, it is at odds with the thrust of overall monetary policy, and should not have been contemplated at this time.

The contradiction was expressed succinctly in a paper by bank staffers Kelly Eckhold and and Chris Hunt in 2004. “Intervention should be timed to roughly coincide with the broad thrust of interest rate settings,” they wrote. “It makes little sense to intervene to try to push the exchange rate lower when the bank believes that higher interest rates may be required in the near future to control inflation pressures. In this situation, a successful intervention would inappropriately loosen monetary conditions.”

I commented at the time, that the messages were somewhat contradictory.

Parliamentary Code of Conduct stillborn

The proposed parliamentary code of conduct appears to be dead already.

I tend to agree with Cullen and Brownlee, that changing standing orders is the only effective way to regulate conduct. A code which states:

We will show respect for other Members. We will behave in a manner that enhances the dignity and decorum of the House. We will debate the issues raised and refrain from personal attacks.

was going too far. I’m not defending personal attacks, but what one personal calls a personal attack, another may call accountability. Were the questions about the conduct of Taito Phillip Field a personal attack?

Where is the accountability?

John Armstrong calls it time up for Corrections:

Can it get any worse for Corrections? The punch-drunk department stumbles from one embarrassment to the next, this time being flayed alive by the Chief Ombudsman to such a degree he was worried his report would be construed as criticism for criticism’s sake.

The word “unsatisfactory” peppers just about every page of his report on Corrections treatment of prisoners when transporting them from jail to court or from jail to jail. And when things are not unsatisfactory, they tend to be “highly unsatisfactory”, “undesirable” or “unacceptable”.

If it was not obvious already, John Belgrave’s 116-page report confirms the department is – to use National’s one-word description – dysfunctional.

It simply has not been performing to the standards expected of a government department. Not that you would know, judging from the silence of the State Services Commission, the supposed state sector watchdog.

The full report from the Ombudsmen is here.

Claire Trevett highlights that the Corrections Department were found to have misled the Ombudsmen, yet amazingly no-one has lost their job.

The Minister, Damien O’Connor, has said “it had previously been difficult to isolate who was accountable on the issue.”

Indeed. I have a fairly good idea of who should be accountable, as I suspect do most people.

Equality of Opportunity vs Equality of Outcome

Last week Jordan Carter blogged on what it means to be left wing and quotes from some overseas socialist parties. What I found most fascinating was his statement:

Our ideology at heart says that because people are morally equal, and because the distribution of talents and capacities is largely a matter of luck (and therefore morally arbitrary), the community as a whole has a responsibility to embrace a political and economic system that reflects this.

That is, public policy uses a range of tools – sometimes markets, sometimes community provision, sometimes state provision – to ensure that each person has a roughly comparable standard of living, quite independent of their luck in drive, intelligence, physical aptitude etc.

This shows the difference between right and left. On the right we think it is nonsense to have a society where everyone has the same standard of living. Certain countries have tried paying brain surgeons the same as street cleaners. The results are well known. yet despite this, it remains a goal of the left – to drag everyone down to the same standard of living. To penalise those who have ambition, intelligence and drive etc. After all they’re just lucky to have inherited them in their worldview.

This notion of society compensating for those who are not as “gifted” as others is classic statist thinking. Where should it end? Should ugly guys have the state provide paid prostitutes so they get as much sex as the “studs”. Should those with arsehole personalities be given more money to compensate for the fact they don’t get promoted as much as helpful people?

This post explains much about the thinking of the left. There is never ever a time where there is too much state involvement. Because until the laziest, thickest, most arseholed member of society has a comparable standard of living to the most hard working and intelligent, then there is always more state intervention to be done.

It is unfair that some people are lucky enough to be hard working and ambitious, and the role of the state is not to encourage them, but to drag everyone down to the same level.

Letterman on Paris

Oh Dave Letterman is having great fun with Paris Hilton being in jail. By chance he had Nicole Richie on the show two nights ago, and as he asked her about Paris being in jail, he just couldn’t help himself and starts giggling and smiling. And then when he asks her whether she might join Paris in jail, and she says yes (she has drug charges to fight) he starts almost cracking up again, and Richie actually goes “I don’t know why me and Paris being in jail is so amusing” which fo course made it worse.

Last night a comedian joked that Paris isn’t eating in jail because she is “very picky about what she puts in her mouth”, which was a cheap but hilarious shot.

She has also made the Top Ten lists three times this week with Top Ten Ways Paris Hilton Is Preparing For Jail, Top Ten Things Paris Hilton Heard Today In Prison, and Top Ten Signs Paris Hilton Isn’t Doing Well In Prison.

My favourites from the three lists, in order are:

2 Telling herself, “Heck, 45 days? That’s not even a month”

3 “I’m in here for illegally downloading video of you off the Internet”

10 Suffering from insomnia because she’s not used to sleeping in the same bed every night

I wonder which New Zealander, if they were so dumb they end up imprisoned for not reading their own court orders, would make for the best comedy?

Mitt Romney blog

The best blog (in my view) of the US Presidential is the Five Brothers blog run by Mitt Romney’s five sons.

Generally blogs of prominent candidates are not great, as they go in one of two directions:

1) They’re run by low level campaign staffers, and you get little connection with the actual candidate

2) The posts are done by the candidate, but they are so sanitised for fear of saying something off message, that they make press release reading sound fun.

The Romneys have managed to avoid this. Yes Mitt Romney himself doesn’t post much, but his five sons are posting every day with photos and news of the campaign, and amusing inside antecdotes. They respond to comments and even ask for feedback such as how the five of them can appear less “square”. Suggestions included you tubing their brotherly farting contest!

The blog comes across as very real and genuine. Because they are the sons, not the candidate, they can get away with saying stuff a candidate couldn’t, but give an insight into their family and father. Dad and Mom make occassional guess posts.

My preferences are Rudy and then McCain, but Romney also makes a very favourable impression. To be a Republican Governor of arguably the US’s most liberal state is not something which happens by chance. However most polls show that he would lose the overall election of he did win the primary. And again polls show voters are far less likely to vote for a Mormon than they are a Catholic, a woman, an African-American or a Hispanic.

Anyway for those who like to follow the US politics, I recommend the Five Brothers blog.

Deja Vu

The Reserve Bank is intervening in the currency market.

The Government is telling schools what sort of food is allowed in tuck shops.

The taxpayer has just purchased a highly competitive company in a highly competitive industry

This is like the scene in Dallas where we wake up in the shower and discover we’re still in the 1970s!

Kordia buys Orcon

New Zealand now has its first state owned ISP with Kordia (formerly BCL the transmission arm of TVNZ) buying Orcon.

Firstly congratulations to Seeby Woodhouse and Mark Mackay for the sale. Great to see their investments over the years pay off.

Also congratulations to new CEO Scott Bartlett. I’ve had the pleasure of working with Scott on some telco issues through his involvement as a Director of ISPANZ – the ISP Assn of NZ.

However (and this is very much a personal view) I am not convinced the public good is served by have the taxpayer become the owner of an ISP in what is a very competitive industry. Not that Kordia is to blame – Trevor Mallard has told SOEs to go out and pursue business opportunities, even if it crowds out the private sector.

Kordia claim Orcon will be run independently, but it does appear that they have the risk of becoming a vertically integrated player like Telecom running both an access division and a wholesale/retail division. And that is the problem so many have been trying to solve.

I thought Kordia was possibly uniquely placed to become a major provide of fibre access around NZ. That is an area where the market is not competitive, and never fully will be, and in my opinion a much more useful area for a state owned company to be investing in. But with Kordia entering the services market as well as the access market, it is less clear.

Rod Drury has similar concerns to me, by chance. He says:

I would have thought Kordia would be the natural manager of state managed infrastructure, so this move would disappoint me. Regardless, becoming a vertically integrated ISP and competing against private industry doesn’t seem quite right.

On the positive side, it may mean Orcon has deeper pockets when it comes to investing in DSlams under local loop unbundling. But it it really wants to expand big time, then it will be Cabinet having to decide whether to inject more capital into Kordia (as Cabinet decided for NZ Post and Kiwibank) and you know the Government as the regulator and as a market player is generally not a good thing.

Cullen does a Lucy

You all know the famous Lucy scenes from Charlie Brown? You know where she holds a football out for him to kick, and promises *this time* she won’t jerk it away at the last moment, despite having done so scores of previous times. Almost painful to watch as gullible Charlie Brown falls for it every time.

Anyway Dr Cullen thinks New Zealanders are as gullible as Charlie Brown, with his football type talk of future tax cuts. He insists there will be tax cuts when “fiscal and economic pressures ease”. This from the man who broke his 2005 promise on the chewing gum tax cuts. This from the Minister who has had the second highest level of fiscal surplus in the world, yet no tax cuts, just an increased tax take.

Somehow magically in election year, Dr Cullen will once again promise tax cuts. And just like Lucy, after the election, he will once again cancel them.

Principals attack food police

Some prinicipals are not happy that nanny state is turning them into the food police:

Dale Burden, headmaster of Mt Albert Grammar in Auckland, said his school’s canteen largely complied with the new requirements.

But when asked if pies would be removed from the menu, he retorted: “We might just wait for the food police to come and tell us off. It’s a nonsense – selling pies once a term. Why … this level of interference in schools when there are so many more important things to worry about?”

“It’s more bureaucracy, more telling schools what to do. I don’t like it at all. We’re in the business of educating kids to make decisions. The Government shouldn’t be legislating away decision-making from people.”

At Ponsonby Intermediate, pies and sausage rolls were removed from the menu several years ago, but principal Wim Boxen objected to schools’ having to take even greater responsibility for children’s eating habits.

“What are they doing, for example, for educating parents. We have got the kids for a small part of the time.”

Indeed parental responsibility seems to be an unknown concept to some.

The Sopranos

So the series is over. Another great series (like West Wing) comes to an end.

How did people like the ending? Ambiguous, to say the least, but I liked it!

A total of 92 deaths over the six seasons, or maybe a bit more than 92?

IPv4 Address Exhaustion Projections

As the more technically minded readers will know, there is a finite number of IPv4 addresses available to be allocated – specifically 2^32 or 4,294,967,296. The replacement IPv6 is not yet widely used (I do not think a single organisation in NZ is on IPv6) as transition costs are not insignificant. IPv6 will never run out I would say as it is 2^128 or 340,282,366,920,938,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000.

Incidentially the number of stars in the universe is estimated at 5×10^22, so that is around 123 trillion IPv6 addresses for every solar system. So unless the aliens get greedy, we’re fine.

Anyway a fairly important question people ask is when will IPv4 addresses run out. An expert in this field is Geoff Huston. He knows more about this, than 99.99% of people. Huston has a script which analyses current allocations and predicts three dates.

The first is the date IANA will run out of IPv4 blocks to allocate. And that is quite soon – 16 February 2010. That’s when the global unallocated stock will run out.

The second is the date the Regional Internet Registries will run out of their local stocks, seeing they can get no more than IANA, and that is only a few months later on 21 September 2010.

Now it’s not quite the end of the IPv4 world at that stage, because there are allocated blocks which could be freed up. For example Ford Motor Company (and Haliburton!) have a Class A or /8 block of 16,777,216 addresses, and they certainly don’t use them all. The estimate is these could keep IPv4 allocations going until March 2017.

But as the IANA looks to run out in early 2010, I expect to see this being the catalyst for large scale transitions to IPv6.

Reserve Bank intervenes in NZ dollar

The Reserve Bank has started selling NZ currency in a bad to drive the price down – a strategy which has initially worked with a 1c fall.

The Reserve Ban needs to be careful. If you’re hiking up interest rates on the one hand, then naturally more people will want to buy NZ dollars which will push the NZ dollar up. So to then start selling also can be a bit of a King Canute.

If they are doing it just to smooth out the exceptional spike over the weekend, probably will get away with it. If they remain in the market until the level is at where they think it should be, then the dangers are significant.

Tear down this wall

Tuesday is the 20th anniversary of Ronald Reagan giving his now famous Tear down this wall speech in Berlin.

General Secretary Gorbachev, if you seek peace, if you seek prosperity for the Soviet Union and Eastern Europe, if you seek liberalization, come here to this gate. Mr. Gorbachev, open this gate. Mr. Gorbachev, tear down this wall!

The irony is that this part of the speech was vigorously opposed by both the State Department and the National Security Council. Most of the media reports at the time were very negative on it also. Peter Robinson, the person who wrote the speech for Reagan, details here the numerous attempts people made all the way up to the Chief of Staff and Secretary of State to get the words changed.

I met Peter Robinson in Santa Barbara last year and got to hear from him first hand the story of the speech. Inspiring indeed. Especially to all those in Eastern Europe who heard it.

Sheehan attacks Police again

Muliaga “family spokesman” Brenden Sheehan has once again attacked the Police.

He previously called them racist for interviewing the children in English not Samoan. It transpires that the two children interviewed in English had chosen to converse in that language, and both have educated to seventh-form level and one was in his second year of tertiary education. Where a family member was not confident in English, such as the father, he was interviewed in Samoan.

Dollar hits 76c

More banning

The Government is announcing today that they will be banning certain foods they have deemed unhealthy for New Zealanders. At thus stage the ban only applies to schools.

This ban works on the assumptions that kids do not know how to find a dairy.

Katherine Rich asks if the next step will be lunch-box police?

RIP Augie Auer

Tze Ming Mok on Coddington

Not surprisingly Tze Ming Mok doesn’t see the Press Council decision as vindication for Deborah Coddington’s use of statistics.

Mok’s blog post has links to the full press council ruling, and all the behind the scenes correspondence, so those interested should go there.

The winner of the Orwell award has to go to Deborah for her claim a “gathering crime tide” doesn’t mean she suggested crime is increasing as “a tide goes in and out”. Sure.

Online Insurance Comparisons

This is quite nifty. A new website, Maestro, allows you to compare insurance quotes online.

You enter in what sort of insurance you want, and to what level, and it gives you quotes from different providers such as Tower, Fidelity and Asteron. You can then use their site apply for the insurance,

God knows what we did before we had the Internet!