Mayor becomes CEO

Goodness – this is unusual. The Mayor of Hamilton has become the CEO.

Nothing wrong with this per se, so long as he recused himself from any involvement in the appointment process.

We had a similiar situation at InternetNZ a few years ago when the incumbent President sucessfully applied for the senior staff position. We were extremely careful that they were quarantined from all involvement in the process, even excluding input into the job description. In one sense it is a huge hassle when it happens because it adds a degree of complexity and sensitivity to the employment process, but on the other hand, excluding such as application may mean you don’t get the bets person for the job.

What is important is you don’t do it the way it was done at Maori TV a few years ago when the Chair of the Selection Panel declined all the applicants, and then was appointed himself.

Air NZ is another example of someone going from governance to management, as Ralph Norris did.

Greens threaten Government

The Greens have said that if the Government does not provide more money in next year’s budget for their initiatives, they will consider voting against the Budget and the Government.

It is noticeable that despite the PM’s pledge of a vision of carbon neutrality, the budget was almost silent on the issue, confirming what many suspected – the Government’s commitment to the issue doesn’t go much beyond slogans.

NZ Herald on BDM Bill

The NZ Herald has an excellent editorial on the latest attack on our freedoms – the Births Death and Marriages Bill, which seeks to remove public access to the record of such events.

The motivation may be sincere, which is to make identity fraud more difficult. But it is a massive over-reaction. In fact I would go the other way and the BDM Register and the Citizenship Register available online for everyone to access. That way if someone is using an identity, then it is easier to check if it is genuine etc.

Again credit goes to the minor parties, who have teamed up with National (which oppossed the bill at first reading) to demand changes.

Hooton on Culen

Matthew Hooton calls Michael Cullen “paternalistic” in his SST column, and that is by far the nicest words he has about Dr Cullen in the column. Other words are losers, economic madness, clever little man, contempt, thick and lazy, superior, minions, patronising, supercilious and despise.

NZ’s Tax Monster

Last week was so busy, I didn’t have time to blog about the latest CIS analysis on how to tame NZ’s tax monster.

Some key points:

* The tax take has increased $20 billion since 2000, a 37% increase in real terms
* Tax revenue for 2007 is $7 billion higher than projected just five years ago
* A person on the average wage is paying $2,400 more (up 34%) in income tax than in 2000 as the tax thresholds have not been indexed to inflation (unlike benefits)
* Our total tax burden is 36.5% of GDP compared to 31% in Australia (also the weighted OECD average)
* MMP encourages bidding wars between parties

They propose some remedies:

* There should be more focus on the outcomes of government spending, not the inputs or outputs
* The annual $2 billion (cumulative) slush fund for unallocated spending should be scrapped with extra spending each year having to be justified on merit
* Require $1.20 of benefits for every $1 in spending to recognise the cost of raising the money
* Have funding for projects self destruct after three years unless project goals have been met
* Have the budget process not only review the 5% of new spending proposals but the 95% of existing spending which is often not systematically reviewed at all
* Emulate the UK and Australia’s work in measuring the actual results of government spending
* End bracket creep for tax, with annual adjustments

The CIS also looks at the ACT/BRT proposal to constitutionally entrench a maximum level of taxation (adjusted only for inflation and population growth) but rejects it as an infringement on parliamentary sovereignty and an issue which should be decided by voters every three years not by legislation.

These suggestions by CIS should be looked at seriously by politicians from all sides of the political spectrum. Improving the outcomes from government spending and eliminating wasteful low quality expenditure, benefits everyone.

Sarkozy’s Cabinet

When Sarkozy won the French Presidential election I recall Radio New Zealand declaring that French voters had turned down the chance to have their first woman President, and with a tone of disbelief announced they had opted for the divisive and dangerous Sarkozy.

He seems to be off to a pretty good start though. First he chopped the Ministry in half to just 15 Ministers. And half the Cabinet are women. As Foreign Minister he has appointed the very popular and respected Bernard Kouchner who founded Medecins Sans Frontieres. The Socialist Party has expelled Kouchner for accepting the role.

Also appointed is the first ethnic minority figure in a senior cabinet post, with Rachida Dati named as justice minister. Also the former Chief of Staff to centrist Francois Bayrou was made Education Minister. The Defence Minister also comes from Bayrou’s team making 20% of the Cabinet being from other parties. Not quite the divisive figure his foes tried to make him seem.

Humanitarian interventions

Dr Mirko Bagaric in the Herald advocates that humanitarian intervention should be mandatory in cases of large-scale government-sanctioned killings and that the UN Security Council should be given the authority and responsibility to muster Coalitions of the Willing, perhaps selected by ballot, to supply the necessary resources.

He points out that

The number of people killed in internal conflict and through wanton acts of dictatorial violence since World War II (170 million) exceeds the total number of people killed during both major wars.

As international law stands, the main obstacle to getting rid of tyrants who kill thousands of their own citizens is state sovereignty. However, this concept is overrated. Invisible lines on the earth’s surface have no moral standing and can’t trump moral standards which are of universal application.

Successful interventions include Vietnam’s invasion of Cambodia in 1979; Tanzania’s intervention to remove Idi Amin from Uganda in the same year and Nato’s invasion of Yugoslavia in 1999. The success of these interventions and the absence of criticism of such action demonstrate that state sovereignty is no barrier to humanitarian interventions. In fact it shows respect for state sovereignty is an excuse, rather than a reason for the inaction of the world.

Bagaric advocates the Security Council start with Zimbabwe and they should authorise an international force to remove Mugabe.

Exclusive Brethren suggested Kiwi Saver!

Heh this is funny. From an NZPA story today:

And in the latest twist to the Kiwisaver story today, the seven members of the Exclusive Brethren who ran a campaign against National’s opponents in 2005 issued a statement, saying they welcomed the Kiwisaver scheme.

The men took credit for the changes announced in Thursday’s budget saying they had suggested them to Dr Cullen.

“This policy development has taken a while. However, Dr Cullen appears to be implementing our suggestions forwarded to him and other members of parliament as early as 2004 to combine tax cuts and employer contributions.”

The group said it was “ironic” that the Government which had been so critical of it had adopted their ideas.

Dr Cullen’s spokesman said the claim was “laughable”.

Perhaps it was decided upon during one of the half dozen or so meetings held between Labour and the Exclusive Brethren! 🙂

Key’s Budget Response

Paying back taxpayers money with more taxpayers money

NZPA reports on how 15 former WINZ staff who stole from WINZ are now on benefits and repaying the money from their benefits.

So the taxpayer:

* paid them a salary while employed by WINZ
* had them steal an additional $1 million from us from being paid by us
* had us no doubt fund their legal aid
* are now giving them a benefit
* and we are getting repaid out of the very benefit we are giving them

Wow we lose out big don’t we.

Heh nice line

Shane Wenzel

Shane Wenzel appears to like threatening and intimidating people. According to this HoS story, he has:

* tried to take a camera from a Herald on Sunday photographer
* physically shoved a reporter
* tried to strip a mobile telephone from the hands of a reporter as he tried to call police
* verbally threatened National Party MPs Katherine Rich and Judith Collins
* demanded that Bob Clarkson’s office supply personal information about complaining students and when refused said he would ruin Mr Clarkson

Seems like such a nice man.

McCarten gets it

Matt McCarten gets it. He realises the extent of what Michael Cullen has done with Kiwi Saver. Dr Cullen has introduced a de facto compulsory private savings scheme (Sir Roger would be proud of him) and shattered the 14 year consensus on public superannuation. Oh no MP today will say it is shattered, but as Kiwi Saver grows in size, the pressure to have it replace public superannuation as the main source of retirement income will grow. Anyway to quote McCarten:

This budget exonerates Winston Peters.

Michael Cullen …has introduced what is, in effect, a compulsory individualised savings scheme for workers.

The KiwiSaver idea is sold on the basis of securing pensions for retired workers. But what it really signals is that the welfare state, as we know it, is finished. The principle of superannuation and other societal benefits is now being replaced by individual, user-pay schemes run by private investment corporations.

The Government and its allied parties have privatised superannuation and given its control to large, off-shore financial institutions.

The expected 4 per cent contribution from workers is effectively a tax increase for something they have previously received as a right.

An employer paying their employee, say, $25,000 a year (and most do) and contributing 4 per cent to their KiwiSaver gets a tax-break for all that contribution, effectively paying nothing. They also get a 10 per cent cut in their company tax. Business owners should make Cullen head of the Business Roundtable.

The breathtaking paradox is that under a workers’ government, corporates get tax cuts, while workers effectively receive a tax increase.

I don’t go as far as McCarten in making Cullen head of the Business Roundtable, but he is right that Cullen has just announced one of the biggest privatisations in our history. And I applaud this.

Sex Survey

The HoS comments on a survey by the Family Planning Association (and Durex) showing young women are now having more sexual partners than young men.

It is unclear whether this was a random scientific poll or a survey where the sample is self selecting.

The survey says 13% of women aged 16 to 25 have had ten or more sexual partners, compared to 7% of men in the same age range. Now at first this seems counter intuitive as men generally (certainly not in all cases) have higher sex drives (curse that testosterone) than women and given half a chance will go for anything with a heartbeat (yes I am exaggerating – calm down).

However the survey results might possibly be right if you consider that a “promiscuous” (and yes I hate that word also) young woman is far more likely to go be able to secure ten or more partners than a male who may have the desire but not the success.

In my experience generally unmarried singles of both genders are having much more casual sex. In fact I would say I know more people who have a FWB/FB arrangement than those who do not. It is decidedly common, but of course when people then fall for their FWB/FB, complications arise.

Enhanced WiFi

Peter Griffin talks about 802.11n which is coming out next month and has five times the data rate of WiFi.

What I found most interesting is the company which has a product to allow almost any user to also become a WiFi access seller. This could eventually lead to mass nets of WiFi in urban areas.

The employee super-class

Michael Cullen’s changes to Kiwi Saver may turn out to be one of the bigger transfers of wealth from poor New Zealanders to well off New Zealanders we have seen. If National had done what he did, I am sure Dr Cullen would have condemned them.

Fran O’Sullivan covers this well in her column. Well paid employees who have money to spare will do really well. Their 4% Kiwisaver contribution will be matched by Government and employers at a ratio between 1:1 and 2:1 – both massively generous.

But poor (Labour voting) workers who can not afford to have a 4%+ reduction in take home pay, will get nothing at all. And in Australia they have had their tax drop by over 50%.

Also those poor workers who can not afford to save, will potentially also be hit by higher interest rates. You see I am not convinced Kiwi Saver will not have some initial inflationary impact. As employers get whacked with compulsory contributions, many will seek to recover these costs by putting prices up. I don’t think interest rates will be dropping at the next review.

We should also look at how much Dr Cullen will personally get from Kiwi Saver. I mean Labour always claim National cuts tax just so they personally benefit. Well how well do Labour MPs do from Kiwi Saver.

Helen Clark benefits by $15,480 an annum once fully implemented
Michael Cullen benefits by around $11,500
Cabinet Ministers benefit by $10,020
Backbench MPs by $5,940

Their retirements are just looking better and better.

Social Networking via phone

Reuters has a story on how GPS phones will create new social networks:

Finding friends and meeting new ones could become even more important uses for global positioning chips than getting from A to B as the technology spreads to cellphones in coming years. Combined with mobile internet access, GPS (global positioning system) is seen in the industry as adding a new dimension to social networking that could also have implications for the media business.

“One of the more compelling things that we might use every day is the integration of that information into knowing where my friends are,”

Nokia predicts that 25 per cent of phones in 2010 will have GPS and an Amsterdam company, is currently building a social networking application for GPS-enabled phones.

The service, branded GyPSii, will allow users to upload pictures, videos and sound clips recorded with their phones that are automatically encoded with the location where the picture was taken or the recording was made.

Users can see where their friends are and see and search each other’s saved places.

I have been predicting this for a year or so. It will be huge as it gets fully developed.

Billboards saved

On National Radio today

Another blow to sensible shop trading laws

The day before the budget, the House rejected on a 57-64 vote the second reading of the Shop Trading Hours Act Repeal (Easter Trading) Amendment Bill by Rotorua MP Steve Chadwick.

This legislation would have allowed territorial authorities to decide — after consulting their communities — whether shops in their area could open on Easter Sunday. It was a very modest bill but would at least have removed the anomalies in the current law where Taupo can open but Rotorua can not etc.

The Table Office of the Office of the Clerk has kindly sent me through the voting list, which is included after the break.

The voting breakdown by party was:

National 33-15
Labour 13-36
Maori 0-4
ACT 2-0
NZ First 7-0
United 1-1
Green 0-6
Progressive 1-0
Independents 0-2

I’m disappointed to see 15 National MPs vote against this modest step towards more sensible law. It was great to see all of NZ First in support and 13 Labour MPs. If four more MPs had voted for it, it would have survived.

In terms of party leaders it was supported by six of them. Clark, Key, Peters, Dunne, Hide and Anderton all voted in favour. Well done.

Also well done to the Labour MPs who voted for it – Benson-Pope, Burton, Chadwick, Chauvel, Choudhary, Clark, Cullen, Dalziel, Goff, Hawkins, Hodgson, Parker, and Wilson.
Continue reading »

Budget Snippets

Randominanity has a giggle (and a photo) that Dr Cullen’s office was serving up Wishart Estate wine last night.

And Scoop has photos from the lockup, including one of me asking Dr Cullen a question. Not sure why I was looking so dour. Probably nervousness as one doesn’t want to ask a stupid question in front of 200 business analaysts, Treasury staff and media!

Also Scoop has their summary here with more photos.

Qantas Media Awards

Yay. I’ve always wondered what the Qantas Media Awards are like and I’m now going to get to go. NBR have a spare ticket and very kindly have donated it to me. That’s the sort of Tory charity I approve of 🙂

So they are on tonight. Looking forward to a long and fun night.

The case against Bain

In an earlier thread on David Bain, a commenter called Dave made a superb comment on why he thought Bain was guilty. It is worth of a wider audience and the relevant parts are repeated here.

The evidence of David Bain’s guilt is so compelling the case is open and shut. There is no room for doubt. The Privy Council decision does not question this, it simply says a jury should also have had before it all the various red herrings Karam has thrown in over the years.

In no particular order:

– Stephen put up a strong fight with his killer, who shot him through the hand and tried to throttle him before inflicting the fatal shot. Many fibres from David’s jersey were under Stephen’s fingernails. David had unexplainable bruises and scratches consistent with being in a fight. Robin did not and no fibres from Robin’s clothes were under Stephen’s fingernails.

– It is inconceivable that Robin could have killed his wife and three of his children, getting into a prolonged fight with Stephen in the process, without emptying a full overnight bladder first (or in the fight). Also Robin was a frail, sick elderly man unlikely to be able to overcome the strapping Stephen in a fierce fight. Also, Margaret, Arawa, Laniet and Stephen died a couple of hours before Robin, yet Karam expects us to believe he did not go to the toilet between killing them around 5am and himself around 7pm.

– David’s bloody fingerprints were on light switches and walls, and his bloody handprint was on the side of the washing machine where his bloody clothes were washed, as well as on the detergent packet. Robin’s bloody prints were nowhere.

– David’s gloves were used by the killer, presumably to mask the killer’s prints. Soaked in blood, the gloves were found in the debris
of the fight in Stephen’s room. Why would Robin use David’s gloves when he had his own and why would he use gloves anyway if he intended to kill himself?

– Bloody footprints made by a sock found in the washing machine were found throughout the house. While these could have been made by either Robin or David, if either were the killer, Robin had no blood anywhere on him (other than his fatal head wound) or his clothes or socks, nor was the room-to-room pattern of the prints consistent with how Robin would have entered the house from the caravan he slept in outside, but it was consistent with the killer having come from inside the house.

– While Robin had no blood on him (other than the fatal headwound) or his clothes, David’s clothes were soaked in blood consistent with the blood that would have gushed from the victims when being shot at close range. He also had their blood on his skin under his clothes, and on his under-wear, which had soaked through the outer clothes before he took them off to wash and which he did not notice.

– Robin was shot in the top of the head as he kneeled, consistent with him having just come into the house from the caravan to pray as he normally did at 7am. While it is theoretically possible to have held the rifle up at an awkward angle to commit suicide by shooting it into the top of one’s head with the trigger finger hand far outstretched, there are much easier and more definite ways to do it, eg put the barrel into one’s mouth aimed at the roof of the mouth. Robin’s fatal wound is consistent with being shot by David standing over him and not with suicide.

– Robin’s prints were not on the gun at all, meaning he could not have used it to kill himself.

– David’s prints were on the gun in a position consistent with where he would have held it while the killer wiped it clean of prints in the blood splattered all over it by the killings (fine wiped fresh blood was all over the gun). Karam claims David’s prints on the gun came from a hunting expedition. Even if that were so, Robin could not have wiped the gun clean after the killings because he was dead. I think this is the most compelling evidence of all.

Many other pieces of evidence also point to David being the killer but the above, all put before the jury, are incontrovertible. One also has to ask why, if Robin left a computer message saying David was the only one who deserved to live, that he went out of his way to frame David for the murders.

The Privy Council says that the Court of Appeal was wrong to decide that the subsequent “evidence” put forward by Karam about Robin’s mental state, his alleged incest with Laniet, etc, etc, would not have altered the jury’s verdict. The Privy Council says it should be for juries to decide all the evidence, not judges on appeal. The law lords
expressely made no findings of guilt or innocence when ordering a retrial, saying that was for a jury.

I’ve also always wondered why Robin Bain would do a suicide note on a computer! This was the early 1990s and Robin Bain was over 60 years old. Did he even use the computer himself normally? As Dave said if Robin thought David Bain was the only one who deserved to live, why did he so go out of his way to frame him?

Oh and Juha has further proof on his blog!

More on Kiwisaver

I’ve worked out that $26,000 is the salary level at which the tax credit for Kiwi Saver (it is really a subsidy not a tax credit) gets exhausted. So if a staffer earns $26,000 or less they do not cost their employer if they are in Kiwi Saver. But once they earn over $26,000 the employer ends up paying more and more of their superannuation.

The maximum benefit for employees, in percentage terms, is at under $26,000. For every $1 you put in, the Government puts in $2. But in absolute terms the rich do better. Someone on $26,000 gets $2,080 a year from the Government into their Kiwi Saver. Someone on $100,000 gets $2,968 from the Government and $2,072 from the employer for a net gain of $5,040.

With Kiwi Saver I think the Government has done the same thing as it did with the Section 59 compromise. It has gone for the tactical victory, and overlooked the strategic implications.

I think Kiwi Saver will be quite popular. I also think uptake into it will be much higher than 50%. You have to be very very poor or very very stupid to turn down an up to 2:1 subsidy. And if people go into Kiwi Saver in their 20s, it will deliver to them in their retirement just as much money as government superannuation will. This is one reason I quite like it. The unilateral imposition of compulsory employer contributions without warning or consulation is the part which I don’t like.

But by making it so large, by making it as valuable as NZ superannuation, Dr Cullen has opened the doors to turn superannuation into a compulsory private savings scheme as Winston Peters and Roger Douglas have long advocated. Dr Cullen has set up the biggest privatisation in history.

It won’t happen under Cullen. It might not even happen in the next decade. But once you have almost all NZers in a Kiwi Saver fund, then it will be hugely popular to take the multi billion dollar Cullen Fund and hand it all out to NZers into their Kiwi Saver accounts. In 2021 the fund will be around $80 billion. Now whack $20,000 into the Kiwi Saver account of every NZer and it will not be unpopular.

Now will that mean one totally closes off public superannuation? Nope. The Cullen Fund was only going to fund 14% or so of it anyway. What one would do is just change it from being indexed to the average wage, to being inflation adjusted like other benefits. That will keep the level of superannuation the same in real terms but most people will receive much more from their Kiwi Saver account anyway, so the government super will just be an extra bonus or a top up.

So I think Dr Cullen will have a place in history. As the man who set up the privatisation of NZ Superannuation and the Cullen Fund!

NZ Herald Budget Reaction

The Herald’s headline is “Cullen reneges on ‘chewing gum’ cuts”. It is worth recalling this was a budget promise made in election year, and regardless of the fact it was not popular (as it did not go far enough) its cancellation is a clear broken promise.

Audrey Young describes the budget as a sweet and sour menu for bosses.

John Armstrong says Kiwi Saver is the next best thing to compulsory superannuation. I agree it is de facto compulsory.

Brian Fallow says the ordinary taxpayer is losing patience.

Laila Harre says the budget should have done more to help the poor. I presume she means benefit increases. Here I am with Labour – I’d rather give more to people in work.

Richard Prebble looks at the SOEs and how they are being outperformed by the private sector, such as TV3 beating TVNZ. He also points out that last year civil service pay increased around 40 per cent faster than inflation and 30 per cent faster than the private sector.

Fran O’Sullivan says Cullen has his spot in NZ history, calling it a first step towards the implementation of a compulsory superannuation scheme. She says Cullen will still go down in history as the Finance Minister who had the guts to tackle savings – however imperfectly – when so many political predecessors wimped out.

And the NZ Herald itself says KiwiSaver is bold and tempting.