Truth in Statistics

As I have said many times, the stats on benefit numbers are easily manipulated by having people hived off into pointless training schemes, on other benefits etc etc. This is why the HLFS is the official record of unemployment levels.

We see this by Rick Barker’s claim that no-one in Flaxmere is on the unemployment benefit. Now it defies belief that no one in Flaxmere is unemployed – it just means they are not recorded as receiving the dole..

As the Dom Post points out, there are 20 people just appearing in Court who are from Flaxmere and unemployed. A local resident jokes half the neighbourhood is unemployed, including three members of her family.

Roughan on Key

John Roughan writes about John Key, and how people should be paying more attention to the message he is sending out on changing the economy.

As National’s finance spokesman at the last election it was evident in Key’s speeches that he wants to make quite a distinct change of economic speed. He is fond of saying that if New Zealand was a stock he would buy it, but he would change its gearing.

He thinks the country is past the stage when it needs to continue with cautious, thrifty, balanced budgets and that it is time to invest in greater expansion. Besides returning revenue to the private sector in tax cuts and targeting welfare better, as indicated this week on family tax credits, he would, I think, borrow happily.

Borrowing to fund an operating deficit is basically always a bad thing. Borrowing to fund infrastructure and capital investment can be good or bad – it depends on the quality of the investment.

Hinchcliff challenges Hubbard

Dick Hubbard was the de facto candidate of the left last local body elections. But his performance has been so abysmal, that people have realisedthat almost anyone who challenged Hubbard would beat him, and if there is no leftwing candidate, the city would have a centre-right Mayor again.

So it is no surprise that Labour Councillor John Hinchcliff has announced he is standing for Mayor.

What will be interesting is who else stands. Hinchcliff would probably beat Hubbard one on one but he is tainted by being on the Council which has angered so many Aucklanders with massive rate rises, backing the unwanted stadium, not sorting our Transport, and the billboard ban. Plus as Hubbard points out, Hinchcliff is the Chair of the dysfunctional Selwyn College which will be used against him.

Steve Crow is standing also, which will make it an even more interesting campaign than normal.

15 years of Shortland Street

So Shortland Street is 15 years old. For anyone born after 1980, they probably can’t remember a time when there was no Shortland Street.

It seems almost every NZ actor has been on the show at some stage. So to celebrate 15 years vote below in the comments for your hottest male and hottest female cast member. You can vote for anyone, but my suggested shortlists for both are:

Men

Hone Ropata (Temuera Morrison)
Chris Warner (Michael Galvin)
Dominic Thompson (Shane Cortese)
Victor Kahu (Calvin Tuteao)
Stuart Neilson (Martin Henderson)
Mark Weston (Tim Foley)
TK Samuels (Benjamin Mitchell)
Rangi Heiramaia (Blair Strang)

Women

Alison Raynor (Danielle Cormack)
Angela Dotchin (Kirsty Knight)
Waverly Wilson (Claire Chitham)
Tiffany Pratt (Alison James)
Rachel McKenna (Angela Bloomfield)
Toni Warner (Laura Hill)
Alice Piper (Toni Potter)
Caroline Buxton (Tandi Wright)
Rebecca Frost (Luisa Burgess)
Anne Greenlaw (Emmeline Hawthorne)
Jo Jordan (Greer Robson)

My personal picks. Well hell of a hard call but the long standing crush on Rachel McKenna/Angela Bloomfield has her win for me. Amongst the men I think the original Dr Ropata would take honours!

The Press on Winners

I’m not the only one saying both Clark and Key come out of this winners. The Press Editorial concludes:

Reaching consensus on the bill is a political achievement for leaders on both sides. The pragmatism and flexibility of the Prime Minister, Helen Clark, are well known and this is a striking example of her leadership qualities. The deal with National shields her party from public fury about the bill but also takes most of the heat out of the issue. For the leader of the National Party, John Key, it is an even more impressive accomplishment. He has not only distanced his party from an out-of-touch religious faction, but he has shown himself willing to negotiate and make sensible compromises in order to bring about a result. He has also shown immense skill in bringing a reluctant caucus with him. His performance has, more than anything hitherto in his career, demonstrated his leadership qualities.

Who is this?

Different sorts of winners

The favourite game at the moment is trying to pick who are the winners and the losers from the smacking compromise. And later in this post I’ll play that game, by saying both Key and Clark are winners, but in very different ways.

But first it is important to note that what matters to the 10% or so of the population who study politics furiously, is not the same as the other 90% for whom the rather cynical “perception not reality counts” is somewhat true. People like me can say it’s still a pretty damn stupid bill, but to most of the public they will just be very pleased that Helen and John put aside politics to do a compromise which makes it sound less likely parents will be prosecuted for light smacking. And the fact the Police have welcomed the amendment lends to that perception. Again I can point to the concern I have about how CYFS will use this law, but it is not a concern of your average parent.

293603.jpg

Now one should also give kudos to both Clark and Key for their trust in each other. As the Dom Post says, Clark risked a fair bit in making the approach to Key. He could have rushed out a PR accusing the Govt of panicking and coming up with a half hearted meaningless compromise. Likewise Key risked the backlash to any deal. It’s not a bad thing the PM and the Opposition Leader could trust each other to work in good faith. And I suspect neither will suffer electorally for it.

But back to winners and losers. People need to remember the difference between a tactical victory and a strategic victory.

If I have to pick a tactical winner, I would say Helen Clark. She was facing somewhat of a nightmare. Low opinion polls, some very unhappy MPs on this issue (see Mitchell on how unhappy Duynhoven was), and the very real fear that next week’s budget would only remain in the headlines until the next smacking debate day in the House.

The Government has not been driving the political agenda for the last year, and if their budget had sunk, they might have gone into election year very weak. This move gives them an opportunity to use the budget to regain political initiative. And Clark managed to find an amendment which she can claim isn’t inconsistent with what she wanted.

But as a strategic winner, I point to John Key, and so do most of the columns I have seen, Transtasman, and the TV reports. Why? Because Labour’s 2008 election strategy just took a beating. When you are going for your fourth term, it is hard to win it on new policy ideas (as Jordan has blogged about). You win it by scaring the crap out of the public about the Opposition. And you won’t be able to demonise John Key now as cancerous and divisive and corrosive.

Add to that John Key gets credit for calling for the compromise in the first place, he got to look absolutely Prime Ministerial, and a growing list of achievements one has managed despite not even being in Government (in case no one has noticed the minor parties with a supportive National have started to influence the legislative agenda significantly). There is no better place to be in election year wanting to be PM, than already looking the part.

Clark needed the tactical win badly and she got it. But Key’s strategic win will I suspect be of more lasting value.

Surpluses

Dr Cullen is already admitting that once again there will be another huge surplus. This is not a surprise. I have been blogging for some years that Treasury systemically underestimates the surplus by several billion. Yet these projections are held up as a reason not to have tax cuts.

Now people will say ha we have an inflation problem, and tax cuts can contribute to inflation, so we should not have tax cuts.

Not at all. The inflation issue means one should spread any tax cuts over time, rather than do them all in one year while inflation pressures are high.

The tragedy is that Cullen could have delivered gradual tax cuts over the last four or five years – say a cumulative billion a year, and this would have minimised any overheating the economy. But by refusing any and all tax relief to date, he has built up huge surpluses.

And while not minimising the importance of low inflation, tax cuts are forever, while a spike in interest rates may only last a year or two. So it is not a choice of one or the other. It is a matter of timing and quantum.

It is also worth remembering that tax cuts are less inflationary than extra government spending, as a proportion of tax cuts will be saved.

So is it likely National can propose a huge tax cut in one year? No. But can National commit to a series of moderate reductions in the tax burden, over time? Yes. Can National commit to an overarching principle of “If we take in more money then we need, we’ll give it back to taxpayers”? Yes.

Facing Off

I’m on Face Off on Newstalk ZB (Wellington) from 11 am to midday today. The other panelists are Lindsay Mitchell and Ken Laban (Lower Hutt Mayoral Candidate).

We’ll probably be discussing smacking, dogs and waste.

Once again the Government is not talking to itself

The Government really seems to be unable to present a coherent message. Just last week we sar Trevor Mallard seek multiparty talks on monetary policy and then Helen Clark contradicting that.

Also last week Helen Clark was talking up export tax credits, and this week Michael Cullen says they have been dropped from the budget.

I keen waiting for the Government to regain its former competence. I keep saying they are only having a bad spell, as all parties do. But as simple mistakes continue such as Ministers not pushing the same message, I wonder if they are going to recover.

Blogging Economists

The NZ Herald has an article on blogging economists.

I subscribe to a number of blogs of economists and love the debates there.

Firstly there is the popular and wonderful Freakonomics.

The Economist Magazine actually has a blog itself.

Milton Friedman’s son, David Friedman has a blog.

And best of all there is Marginal Revolution by Tyler Cowan and Alex Tabarrok.

Fibre for Auckland

Auckland City Council is planning a 100 km fibre loop, plus a wireless network in the CBD.

Wellington businesses are fortunate that WCC did similar around a decade ago, resulting in the now privately owned Citylink with their fibre and Cafenet products.

The Auckland plan seems a good step forward, based on the details reported. I think the Council does have a legitimate role in providing key infrastructure such as roads and fibre. Now that is not to say it shouldn’t eventually be user pays, but to a degree one has to build the infrastructure before companies can start offering services over it. And it is best that the fibre owner is not a service provider so one doesn’t get the problems we have had with the copper local loop.

Proposed 2008 Boundaries

The proposed 2008 boundaries (12 MB file) are out, and as I predicted there are some major changes with few electorates left untouched – only eight out of 69.

Terralink have done a cool map of NZ where you can see current and proposed boundaries, and zoom in and out.

Let’s have a look at the changes, starting at the bottom of the South Island. My commentary of whether it is good or bad for a party and MP is based on general memory of areas. At this stage I have not looked at actual polling booth results.

Invercargill – moves east and west into rural areas, good for National and Eric Roy

Clutha-Southland – now takes in Queenstown, Arrowtown and Roxburgh. Bill will be very happy!

Dunedin North – picks up Palmerston from Otago. Useful but not about to become a blue seat.

Otago – loses Queenstown etc and picks up Waimate, Fairlie and all area up to Timaru. Good for Dean. Is renamed Waitaki.

Aoraki – loses southern areas to Waitaki and now takes in huge amount of Rakaia – right up to the Rakaia river. Most population will be in Timaru and Ashburton so might not be so good for National as loses some rural areas. Goodhew has solid majority though. Renamed Rangitata.

Rakaia – this seat loses Ashburton and south of Rakaia and picks up some area from Wigram [actually not Wigram, there was a typo in the official report], and is renamed Selwyn. Still a nice blue seat.

Christchurch – some fairly minor changes to most seats to reflect Wigram losing territory to Rakaia and Waimakariri needing to lose territory into Christchurch. Waimakariri improves slightly for National.

Kaikoura does not change at all, but Nelson loses quite a bit of land to Tasman West-Coast. Makes TWC better for National and Nelson worse. National would struggle in Nelson if the local Nick Smith didn’t have such wide cross-party support locally.

Now in the North Island we start in Wellington.

Rongotai picks up area around Wellington Hospital up to the Basin which is Labour voting. WC loses that and loses Crofton Downs to OB. National will be pleased they did not lose Wadestow but it remains a red seat.

Ohariu-Belmont – loses Belmont to Rimutaka and renamed Ohariu. Dunne won’t mind.

Rimutaka – gains Belmont and loses Naenae to Hutt South. Makes Rimutaka better for National but not a blue seat by any stretch.

Mana – picks up some of Paraparaumu which is normally blue, but the actual area transferred is red.

Otaki – Darren Hughes majority of 200 or so shrinks slightly.

Palmerston North – loses Linton and all rural area to become urban electorate only. Good for Maharey but he did not need it.

Rangitikei – grabs Mt Ruapehu, Taumauranui, Ohakune off Taupo. Simon Power gets the skifields. The extra area in the north is probably Labour friendly but he has a large majority.

Whanganui – this used to stop at just past Hawera but now goes all the way around Egmont/Taranaki and includes Opunake. This will help Chester Borrows and National considerably. Probably now a safe seat.

New Plymouth – gains a but of rural area.

Taranaki – King Country – loses some nice rural areas down south, so takes in Raglan and some area south of Hamilton. Still a nice blue seat.

Over east, Wairarapa moves north to include Waippukurau up to Waipawa. Should be good for John Hayes.

Tukituki – Craig Foss loses some nice area down south but picks up some area from the north. Overall effect is slightly negative.

Napier – takes in a lot more rural area which will help Tremain, but Wairoa may cancel some of that out.

East Coast – moves past Whakatane right up to edge of Te Puke. Will help Anne Tolley and make it hard for Labour to win back.

Bay of Plenty – big movements losing area to Rotorua and East Cost, but enveloping Tauranga by taking in some land from Coromandel. Ryall remains safe.

Coromandel picks up some rural area from Piako in exchange.

Hamilton East and West both lose rural areas. Helps Labour a bit in both seats.

Taupo having lost Ruapehu has to move north and takes in Cambridge. That is probably enough for Mark Burton to lose it next election.

Rotorua also picks up some rural areas, and as a highly marginal seat for Labour may also fall to National now (these are proposed not final boundaries though).

Piako changes dramatically, enveloping Hamilton and taking territory from Port Waikato over to the west coast and up to the Bombay Hills. Becomes safer for Tisch I would say.

Port Waikato loses that territory and the rest goes into Clevedon now called Hunua. Hunua loses Clevedon and surrounding territory to the north. Will still be a blue seat.

Papakura is formed out of Manurewa and Clevedon. Could be a winnable seat for either party.

Howick comes from Pakuranga, Manukau East and Clevedon. This is the new seat and should be very safe for National.

Pakuranga – majority for WIlliamson is slashed but he has a large one to start with.

Other changes in Auckland are unlikely to change any seat from Labour to National or vice versa. Will detail later.

Up north, Northland picks up Wellsford from Rodney and Whangarei is unchanged. Not significant.

East Coast Bays loses Bayview and Witherford Heights to Helensville, which may dent the majority a bit for McCully, but not much.

Helensville having picked up this area has to lose Massey which makes it an even more blue seat for John Key.

Of course the Commission doesn’t look at the political effects of their boundary change proposals – they look at criteria such as local authority boundaries, communities of interest etc. But politically it looks quite favourable for National (unlike the last few which have favoured Labour) as they will win the new seat of Howick, and on paper maybe pick up Rotorua and Taupo.

Again the boundaries are not final and there are submissions and objections to submissions to go through.

The compromise

59(4) To avoid doubt, it is affirmed that the Police have the discretion not to prosecute complaints against a parent of a child or person in the place of a parent of a child in relation to an offence involving the use of force against a child, where the offence is considered to be so inconsequential that there is no public interest in proceeding with a prosecution.

This compromise will help make a bad bill better. It will not totally leave it to Police discretion and will provide some comfort to parents they will not be charged for light smacking.

National could not stop the bill. It could however improve it, and has done that. Given a choice between opposition which would have failed and a compromise which improves things, they have gone for the latter.

The bill, as amended, will still be problematic. It does still ban *all* force for correctional purposes, it just says don’t charge them if trivial. The way CYFS may use the bill remains a major concern. If National had the numbers I am sure they would prefer a Borrows amendment, but that wasn’t achievable thanks to Labour and the Greens.

One should certainly vote for the amendment as an improvement. Reasonable people can disagree on whether the bill as a whole is still am improvement over the status quo. As I have said many times the original Bradford Bill was more commendable than the Select Committee version. Personally I would vote for the amendment and not for the bill, even with the amendment, because it is still badly drafted law which I suspect a future Parliament will end up revisiting regardless.

John Key started the process of finding a compromise, and has sacrificed the potential massive political gain from being able to thrash the Govt over this issue at the next election, in exchange for giving parents more certainty under the law. I think that is what people call putting New Zealand first.

VUWSA Rep Groups

In the latest VUWSA President’s column, I had to chuckle at the list of rep, groups and how each is compulsory – you are represented by then, if you like it or not:

• The Victoria University Post-Graduate Students’ Association (PGSA), representing all post-graduate students;
• The Victoria University of Wellington Law Students’ Society Incorporated (LSS), representing all law students;
• STUDIO, representing all students in the faculty of Architecture and Design;
• Mature Students Network (MSN), representing all mature students;
• UniQ, representing gay, lesbian, bisexual, transsexual, transgender, and intersex students;
• International Students Council (ISC), representing all international students;
• VicComm, representing all commerce and administration students;
• Pasifika Council, representing all Pacific Island students;
• Can-Do, representing all students with disabilities;
• Crèche Parents Committee, representing all student users of the university crèche.

The good news is that if you are a mature post-graduate law and commerce student who is gay, has a disability, are from the Pacific, and you have a kid at the creche, then you have a total of nine different groups who all represent you. What do you do if they disagree with each other?

Of course instead of claiming those groups represent *all* students in their areas, one could just say they represent all students who actually join them.

Obama – all style?

My preferred Democratic nominee for President remains Hillary Clinton at this stage. Obama’s rhetoric and potential is impressive but I have consistently said that two years as a Junior Senator is not enough experience for the most powerful role in the world.

This report from his first real debate suggests this is the case. He did a less than stellar performance.

Obama appeals for his potential, but you need more than just talking about hope. My hope is that he will develop further and be a more credible candidate for 2012 or 2016. But he may still beat Clinton for the 2008 nomination -time will tell.

April 2007 Kiwiblog Stats

General Stats

Unique Visitors: 146,237 (up 32% on March)
Unique Visits: 302,570 (up 27%)
Page Views: 969,232 (up 20%)
Bandwidth: 122 GB (up 27%)
Highest Unique Visits/Day: 14,283
Average Visit Length: 6 minutes 25 seconds

Visitor Countries/Domains

New Zealand nz 389832
Australia au 30714
Japan jp 10429
Czech Republic cz 9235
United Kingdom uk 8383
Canada ca 7990
Russian Federation ru 5726
Germany de 3285
Poland pl 3109
Italy it 2920
Brazil br 2891
Netherlands nl 2437
United States us 2271
France fr 2190
Argentina ar 1792
India in 1742
Israel il 1554
Switzerland ch 1369
Mexico mx 1292
Belgium be 1237
Singapore sg 1099
USA Military mil 1068
Malaysia my 1006
Turkey tr 1005
Sweden se 1000

Visitor Hosts

vuwunicoproxy03.vuw.ac.nz 2414
pspc18-241.parliament.govt.nz 2390
gate1.ird.govt.nz 1635
smtp.training.co.nz 1549
node5.moh.govt.nz 1274
smtp.waitakere.govt.nz 1135

Top Pages Visited

/2007/04/nicole_begg.html 8758
/2007/04/no_smacking_compromise.html 2682
/fun_things/ 2568
/2007/04/10_days_to_go.html 2532
/2007/04/the_union_money_go_round.html 2367
/2006/04/lego_pc.html 2053
/2007/04/a_labour_mp_on_why_unions_wil.html 1919
/2007/04/conversation_with_a_journalist.html 1806
/2007/04/hilarious.html 1762
/politics_nz_general/ 1694
/2007/04/the_bazley_report.html 1601
/2006/12/where_the_bloody_hell_is_she.html 1591
/2007/04/waa_waa_waa_waa_waa.html 1540

Visitor Operating Systems

Windows 86.3 %
Windows XP 75.2 %
Windows NT 0.3 %
Windows Me 0.4 %
Windows Vista (Longhorn) 2 %
Windows 98 1.5 %
Windows 2003 1.8 %
Windows 2000 4.6 %
Linux 1.3 %
Macintosh 5.3 %

Visitor Browsers

MSIE 60.6 %
Msie 7.0 22.8 %
Msie 6.0 36.9 %
FIREFOX 26.2 %
Firefox 2.0.0.3 16.4 %
Firefox 2.0 1.3 %
Firefox 1.5.0.11 4.9 %
NETSCAPE 0.4 %
Safari 3.2 %
Mozilla 2.5 %
Opera 1.8 %

Referrers

http://www.scoop.co.nz 588
http://norightturn.blogspot.com 378
http://publicaddress.net/default,4076.sm 342
http://briefingroom.typepad.com 321
http://blog.greens.org.nz 239
http://www.publicaddress.net/default,4076.sm 230
http://newzeal.blogspot.com 191
http://www.sirhumphreys.com 186
http://www.investigatemagazine.com 129
http://www.publicaddress.net/hardnews 119
http://www.publicaddress.net/default,hardnews.sm 109
http://andrewfalloon.blogspot.com 105
http://www.big-news.blogspot.com 105
http://asianinvasion2006.blogspot.com 105
http://www.publicaddress.net/default,4082.sm 104
http://pc.blogspot.com 100

Search Terms used to find Kiwiblog

nicole begg 4147 6.7 %
kiwiblog 1585 2.5 %
david farrar 1001 1.6 %
nicole begg nude 702 1.1 %
group sex 330 0.5 %
debbie gerbich 329 0.5 %
kiwi blog 319 0.5 %
cyfswatch 295 0.4 %
sex video 238 0.3 %
nicole begg naked 216 0.3 %
hayley holt 205 0.3 %
reasons to stay in iraq 199 0.3 %
election slogans 150 0.2 %
nicole begg photos 147 0.2 %
nicky watson 146 0.2 %
incest 135 0.2 %
nude swimming 120 0.1 %
farrar 105 0.1 %

Well looking at the top reasons, you’re a perverted bunch!

Some other interesting ones:

site www.kiwiblog.co.nz danyl.mclauchlan 92 0.1 %
estonian women 91 0.1 %
cactus kate 90 0.1 %
anti smacking bill 83 0.1 %
male whores 66 0.1 %
mfm sex 45 0 %
coke zero vs diet coke 45 0 %
alex foulkes 39 0 %
adult sheep finder 39 0 %
valerie morse 30 0 %
chicks with guns 25 0 %
dihydrate monoxide 20 0 %
dinner tax analogy 18 0 %
deborah hill cone 15 0 %
steven price 14 0 %
tze ming mok 13 0 %
kerre woodham 13 0 %
how to use neighbours wireless internet 11 0 %
girls snogging each other 10 0 %
french presidential election poll 9 0 %
difference between newcastle and sweden 8 0 %

Is it an anti-smacking bill?

Many on the left are wailing that it is all the media’s fault the public don’t like the anti-smacking bill, because they report it as an anti smacking bill, and they claim it is an anti child abuse bill.

Well a helpful reader has pointed out that Sue Bradford’s own press release in October 2003 labelled it an anti-smacking bill.

And yet on 15 March 2007 Bradford says “I have never called it an anti-smacking bill – my opponents did, and the media adopted the phrase”

God the proponents of this bill are so dishonest, it is unbelievable. I hope the media, who Bradford has attacked as being to blame, highlight her hypocrisy and outright lie.

UPDATE: A compromise has been reached. Details in another post.

Honesty over Smacking

Yesterday’s Dominion Post Editorial calls for some honesty over the anti-smacking bill [(c) Sue Bradford]. Some extracts:

Ms Bradford continues to be disingenuous over her legislation.

She denies her legislation is an anti-smacking bill [see other post for how she has been caught out lying on this – dpf] , but says she is opposed to any definition of an acceptable level of force, or anything which legitimises any use of force.

However, opponents of her legislation are entitled to take at face value the provision that states nothing in the exemptions of the legislation “justifies the use of force for the purpose of correction”. That, however, much she may deny it, is a ban on what most people would regard as smacking.

If Parliament wants to vote to ban all smacking – and there are many who would see that as a laudable position – that is what it should do, but Ms Bradford and her supporters should have the courage of their convictions, and not pretend that her law says otherwise. If it is her intention that parents who give their children the odd light smack should not be considered criminals, then that is what the law should say.

The other key thing to remember is this is not just about whether the Police will prosecute for smacking. It is about how CYFS will use this law against families. Whale Oil tells a story of how CYFS, even before the law is changed, is already threatening parents who smack their children. Go read the full story and consider what the outcome might be once the law changes.

Less than half of NCEA cheats punished

Amazing. Less than half of those caught cheating in NCEA actually get punished for it.

Now I am not in the category of botting someone out of school or cancelling their entire year’s results if they cheat. But at a minimum they surely should not gain credits in the subject they cheated in, shouldn’t they?

Of the 336 cases of cheating last year, only 135 had their marks affected and the other 201 cases just had a reprimand! No wonder the incidence of cheating increased 60% last year.

Tax Cuts vs Working for Families

Labour has turned families with household incomes of $120,000 into beneficiaries with Working for Families. I am delighted that National is keeping its options open on whether to keep the latter portion of WFF, and have actual tax cuts instead of welfare.

Dr Cullen and the PM are delighted, because they think they can smear National as taking money from the poor to give to the rich. And there is some political risk that they may gain some traction, as it can be complex to explain the actual position and rebut a soundbite.

The reality is much of WFF involves taking tax money off low and middle income taxpayers and giving it to wealthy families with children. If you are single and earning $40,000, you are helping subsidise the family on $120,000 with four kids.

The mad thing is that the family on $120,000 is also subsidising themselves. They are paying extra tax, just to have some of it come back to them. This is what is called tax churning. It is highly wasteful and inefficient.

I support a welfare state. I am very happy to pay tax to help the low income family on say $35,000 with one or two kids. I am not happy to pay tax so a couple with kids who earns more than me gets a welfare payment.

The good thing is that polls have shown most non low income families would prefer to simply pay less tax, than receive WFF welfare payments or tax credits (which they have to apply for). They instinctively know that state welfare is best targeted to those who need it. What they want from the Govt is an economy with low inflation, low unemployment and low interest rates.

French Presidential Election Second Round

The second and final round of the French Presidential Election is this Sunday.

The opinion polls were almost spot on for the first round (which was rare for French politics) so what do they say for the second round?

There have been 17 polls since the first round. The remarkable thing is how consistent they have been. Every one has Sarkozy leading Royal. One by 2% (51% to 49%), two by 4%, three by 5%, five by 6%, two by 7%, and four by 8% (54% to 46%).

The mean, median and mode is all 53% to 47%. And that is what most polls were also saying prior to the first round.

Sarkozy has been having the rougher time in the media, but fundamentally the polls do not seem to have changed much at all over the last few months, so unless there is a major problem in the next five days, expect to see him the Eighth President of the Fifth Republic of France.

Rail Travel

A couple of dozen friends and I were looking at going up to Auckland in September, and thought it could be fun, and economical, to book a train carriage as one of the group heard Tranzscenic offered good group discounts. Now, the Transcenic website says this:

Group Benefits:
Amazing travel deals when you book your group of 20 or more with an Account Manager.

So said friend phones the contact person listed on the site. The Account Manager cheerfully announced that the price for 20 people would be $79 each. Friend didn’t think it was so amazing, so checked on their website.

The website quoted the rail fare from Auckland to Wellington at $85.

That’s right, according to Tranzscenic a 6% discount is an “amazing travel deal.”

With deals like these, it’s no wonder rail travel is dying.

Proposed Boundaries out Thursday

The Representation Commission will release its proposed boundaries on Thursday. I have previously been quite involved with some of the analysis around potential changes, so am looking forward to seeing what is proposed on Thursday.

The previous Commission tried to change boundaries as little as possible by using the 5% tolerance to the maximum. What this means is that changes this time will be quite significant in some areas. If a seat was say 4.5% over quota in 2001, then if it has kept growing it might now be 12% over quota, so will need to lose somewhere between 7% and 17% of its population.

So where will there be changes? 33 of the 69 electorates are more than 5% from the quota (or average). But more than that will change as as those seats gain or lose areas it affects their neighbours. Of the seats which *have* to change two are Maori seats, nine are South Island and 22 are in the North Island. The seats which must change, in order, are:

Clevedon 19.1%
Manukau East 19.0%
Auckland Central 15.3%
Hamilton East 15.2%
Manurewa 13.6%
East Coast Bays 13.1%
Waimakariri 12.8%
Mangere 12.3%
Clutha-Southland -11.7%
Port Waikato 11.6%
Invercargill -10.4%
Taupo -10.2%
Wairarapa -9.6%
Helensville 9.0%
Rakaia 8.5%
Rodney 8.4%
Aoraki -8.1%
Rangitikei -8.0%
East Coast -7.9%
West Coast-Tasman -7.5%
Wellington Central 7.2%
Banks Peninsula 6.9%
Hutt South -6.9%
Rotorua -6.7%
Ikaroa-Rawhiti -6.5%
New Plymouth -6.5%
Dunedin North -6.3%
Whanganui -5.8%
Palmerston North -5.8%
Dunedin South -5.8%
Bay of Plenty 5.7%
Te Tai Hauauru -5.5%
Te Tai Tonga 5.1%

The number is how much over or under they are from the average (quota). The law allows a maximum 5%.

The Maori seats don’t need to change much. Te Tai Tonga loses a bit of territory north of Wellington and Te Tai Hauauru gain a bit of territory.

The South Island will change a lot. Apart from the nine seats over the 5% tolerance, other seats like Otago and Nelson will be affected by the flow on effects. The only seats which do not have to change are Kaikoura, Ilam, Chch Central and Chch East, but even they may do so.

A big example of the flow on effect we get from the bottom of the SI. Invercargill is under by 10% needs to gain between 3,000 and 9,000 to be within the 5%. Let’s say they go for the centre – 6,000. This means they take 6,000 off Clutha-Southland which itself is 12% under. So CS takes say 12,500 off Otago. The Dunedin seats also take 5,000 off Otago which means Otago has no choice but to take 17,000 or so of Aoraki. Aoraki was already 8% under or 4,500 short so has no choice but to take over 20,000 or over 40% of Rakaia off Rakaia. Rakaia in turn will take territory off Banks Peninsula, Waimakariri and maybe parts of Chch. I doubt the new Rakaia will be much like the existing one. Ashburton may in fact be cut in half with some in Aoraki and some in Rakaia, possibly both renamed.

Wellington doesn’t change too much. Rongotai is on quota, WC 7% over quota so will lose maybe a bit of Newtown to Rongotai but also some territory to Ohariu-Belmont. Maybe Wadestown? Hutt South is 7% under quota so may grab some land off OB, or even Rimutaka but not a lot.Mana and Otaki are within 5% so may not change, but Mana might grab some southern territory off Otaki.

Wairarapa is 10% under and can only grab land off Tukituki. Tukituki may then need to grab a bit off Napier or Rangitikei. Not major movements I expect.

Rangitikei and Whanganui are both under quota so unless they grab in Mt Ruapehu, will see Whanganui move north past Hawera close to New Plymouth. New Plymouth will also grab some land off TKC which I think has to move north close to Hamilton.

In the middle of the NI Taupo and Rotorua are both under quota so the logical expansions are to the north, some nice rural areas.

Over in the BoP East Coast is under quota so will move north closer to Te Puke. BoP is over quota so may not move much, same with Tauranga. All depends on their neighbours.

For now I will leave off Auckland, going down to Port Waikato, as the location of the new seat will be the major factor. For an idea of where it might be well the two biggest seats over quota are Clevedon and Manukau East at 19% each. But it could also be South Auckland more with Manurewa at 14% over and Mangere at 12%,

Finally up North, Northland need not change, and same for Whangarei. Rodney is 8% over though, as is East Coast Bays at 13% and Helensville at 9%. So I suspect all those seats may move North a bit.

But boundaries are notoriously hard to pick. It all depends on how much use the Commission makes of the 5% tolerances. Do they use them to the max like the last Commission or do they try and get as many seats as possible close to dead on the quota. Also many seats have four or five neighbouring seats and how those ones are done can affects dozens of others.

Finally the boundaries are only proposed. Once public they call for submissions and then objections to the submissions, before making final decisions. And the submission definitely do change things, or have in the past.

Telstra-Clear against Telecom’s structural separation proposal

The Herald reports that Telstra-Clear is against Telecom’s proposed structural separation, preferring the operational separation process already underway.

Putting aside for now the merits of structural vs operational separation, it is no surprise that Telstra-Clear is not endorsing structural separation. Their parent Telstra in Australia would not be at all happy with one of their companies saying yes let’s chop the big monopoly incumbent up into two.

Telstra-Clear is right that there are risks of delays with the structural separation, but to my mind the potential benefits from such a split, are worth the risk. But those benefits will need to be negotiated and agreed upon without undue delay.