Labour and the Brethren

On Monday I got to inspect a couple of extraordinary documents. They were minutes of meetings between Labour Cabinet Ministers David Benson-Pope and Pete Hodgson, and Exclusive Brethren members.

The Brethren were so proud of these meetings that typed up notes of them. And I mean typed up. I presume they are banned from using computers so the minutes looked like they had been lovingly prepared on a manual typewriter – complete with uneven lettering, smudges and all.

Now it transpires that not only did the Brethren meet the PM twice (she claims they were not planned meetings, but the Brethren say there were) but they also met no less than five of her Ministers. And there is no doubt from those minutes these were planned, prepared meetings.

Now Clark would have you believe these scary Brethren were so bad she needed extra Police security to protect her from them. I’m surprised she hasn’t ordered the Police to taser any Brethren member on sight the way she goes on about them. The minutes tell quite another story with the meetings with her Ministers. The Ministers went out of their way to be receptive to the Brethren’s messages, agreeing with them on many issues such as Defence (pointing out the money they have spent on the Army) while disagreeing with them on others like civil unions and nuclear ships. No improper behaviour, it was a typical try and convince a group of NZers that they should support you. And the Brethren went out of their way to thank Ministers for previous policy concessions such as their exemption under the ERA.

Now it is interesting to contrast the helpful friendly Hodgson and Benson-Pope when they were trying to win Brethren support with what they now say (Hat Tip: Clint Heine):

Pete Hodgson (20 June 2006) “… a very strange group of white men who don’t even vote, who put a million dollars on the table to help the National Party…that is a very strange group of people”

DBP (22 Nov 2005) ” …they (National) tried to buy the election with its tax cuts and its underhand campaigns, financed by strange sects and shady deals with industry in return for favours that the voters were never supposed to know about”

So what do we take from all this? Well it destroys the myth that the Exclusive Brethren were somehow controlled by National and operating as a secret front for them. They were doing what groups interested in politics do – meet with MPs to advocate for policies they wanted.

Upon getting the go ahead from on high to start taking an interest in politics, they undertook a series of meetings to learn about the parties and politics. They met not just with MPs and political parties, but also with other people (Owen McShane has commented here on how they approached him) as part of their shall we say steep learning curve. Their wish list of desired policies is almost laughably naive. Former Brash Chief of Staff Richard Long has written about how appalled National was that the Brethren were trying to campaign on the nuclear ships issue, when that was the last thing National wanted in the public arena. All very clear that any influence National had was minor.

The Brethren did two major things wrong, IMO.

1) They should have called a press conference before the pamphlets went out explaining who they were, and what they were doing. If they had done that, the pamphlets would have been a big yawn.

2) Their hiring a private detective to spy on the PM was an appalling lack of judgement, which has rightly led to widespread condemnation.

But those two mistakes don’t change the underlying reality that there was no grand conspiracy. They advocated for a set of policies they believed in, met with MPs from almost all parties, and then advocated against the parties whose policies they most oppossed.

And it is a good sign of the tolerance of NZers that most NZers (see CB poll) are rejecting Clark’s attempts to muzzle the Brethren, even though very few would personally approve of what they advocate. It’s called freedom of speech, not just speech we agree with.

The Best Times Of Our Lives

Bail on Parole

The story of Hiro Joe shows all that is wrong with our justice system.

In 2002 he reaped a 15 year old girl. He got a miserly six year term (less than one third the maximum). Thanks to Labour’s new parole laws, he got parole after one third of the sentence – after a couple of years.

Late last year he then kidnapped someone and was arrested. Now despite still being on parole, he got bail which allowed him to flee.

If someone is out on parole, and they are charged with a serious crime, then they should not be eligible for bail and/or have their parole cancelled. But instead we have the farce where Mr Joe is on both parole and bail at the same time. No wonder he fled – couldn’t believe his luck.

Parole is a privilege, not a right. But again a prisoner is freed despite a “high risk of violent offending and a medium-high risk of sexual offending” assessment.

The accuracy of carbon predictions

Just three years ago, the International Energy Agency said that China would overtake the US as the biggest carbon emitter, sometime after 2025.

It has now been revealed that in fact they will overtake the US this year.

The flawed Kyoto Protocol has effectively zero obligations on China, which will be the biggest emitter. Kyoto is as much about punish the west as it is climate change.

Also makes you wonder about some of the numbers underlying policy decisions, when they can get it so wrong for just one country.

Election Campaign Funding Poll

One News had a Colmar Brunton poll on three issues around campaign funding. I’m pleased to say it puts me in the majority on all three issues.

By almost a 3:1 ratio NZers are against state funding of party’s election campaigns – 70% against and 26% in favour. Labour’s proposal in fact went beyond that and was for actual funding of the party not just their campaign.

Now what I found fascinating was that Labour Party voters were more opposed to state funding than the average NZer. So Labour was out of step with even its own supporters in its greed.

On the issue of declaring all sources of campaign funding, 81% are in favour, and only 16% against. Banning anonymous donations and trust donations over a threshold has the support of both National and Labour, so should happen.

The final issue is that of third party advertising. Now Labour will be appalled that despite a year of vilification of the Brethren, only 39% support tighter controls on such third party advertising. 61% (a 3:2 ratio) say there should be no controls beyond the current law. And this comes despite an explicit reference to the Brethren in the question.

I am basically with the public on this one. I support greater transparency requirements for third party groups, and can live with a limit similar to political parties – $1 million for the last 90 days, but the proposed limits of $60,000 over eleven months are an appalling attack on free speech.

So pretty grim for Labour. The public only support them on the issue which already has bipartisan support, and are not with them on the others.

Secret deals?

The Manawatu Standard has an editorial, which compares the treatment of unions to the Brethren:

Much of Labour’s non-taxpayer funding comes from unions. One of this Government’s first acts of office was to skew the employer-employee, union-individual employment contract balance back in favour of unions.

How is that any less dodgy than the Exclusive Brethren distributing a few pamphlets saying National would do a better job of running the country than Labour? What is wrong with a group of people – any or every group of people – having the right to say what they think about our politicians?

Union leader Andrew Little, who is currently attempting to disrupt the New Zealand Herald’s business in Auckland by taking legal action against APN News and Media, is tipped to be a Labour MP after the next election, with an offer of a safe spot on the party’s list. He would join, or replace, Rick Barker, another former union activist list MP pulling in a six-figure salary courtesy of the taxpayer. Mr Barker was rejected by his electorate, but was returned to Parliament by the Labour Party anyway.

Is the safe union seat intended as a reward for Mr Little’s disruption of a major Auckland business that doesn’t always back Labour? Or because his union has helped bankroll the Labour Party over recent years?

Wouldn’t democracy be better served if such secret deals were exposed to public scrutiny in the same way Ms Clark is applying the heat to the Exclusive Brethren?

Now first let me say I don’t actually agree with the Manawatu Standard. I don’t think there is a secret deal where the EPMU disrupts the NZ Herald because it isn’t sycophantic enough to the Government and that the Rimutaka seat is the pay off. In fact I have said I think Andrew Little will be a fine MP.

But what the editorial exposes is the hypocrisy and double standards of the Government. The paper allege a conspiracy between EPMU and the Government just as the Government has ridiculously beat up conspiracy allegations between National and the Exclusive Brethren – that there was some sort of secret master deal.

Having allied interests is not the same as conspiracy deals. And if Labour is going to throw mud around like that, then it can’t complain if a newspaper does the same back.

Hat Tip: Craig Foss

More on ANZAC Day

There’s been some interesting perspectives on ANZAC Day from some of the left blogs, and also comments here on the protesters who thought it a good idea to burn the flag and blow horns during the dawn service.

The comment by Anon comparing protesting at ANZAC Day to protesting at funerals made me realise who the nutters remind me of?

They’re the extreme left counterpart to Rev Fred Phelps and godhatesfags.com! Phelps and his inbred family travel around military funerals protesting against gays in the military. They lack the insight to realise that when people are mourning dead colleagues, it is not the time to make a political protest.

So Valerie Morse is our extreme left equivalent of Fred Phelps. Sounds about right. Someone should lock them in a room together.

Maia asks the question about why do we honour soliders who die, but not others who die such as mothers in child birth, or workers in accidents?

To me that is easy. Of course many people die in accidents, but being slain in combat is no accident. People have volunteered or been conscripted into a job where other people are going to try and kill you. This is not some accidental side-effect. It is literally the ultimate sacrifice. It doesn’t matter whether 80 years later we think the cause is as noble as defeating Hitler was. The soldiers don’t get to make that call.

And back in WWI or WWII it was not like modern warfare where maybe you have 2% casualty rates. Some of their rates were well over 50%. I know how incredibly sad it is to lose even a single close friend. I can’t imagine the mental anguish it must have caused veterans to see somewhere between half and all of their colleagues slaughtered.

Anarchafairy, like the prostesters (or he may have been one) calls for NZ forces to pull out of not just Afghanistan, but also East Timor and the Solomons.

Now I can understand how some on the left can have an issue with Afghanistan. I do not fo course, but I can at least understand their reasoning. But to call for NZ to pull out of East Timor and the Solomons? I mean our involvement comes as close to pure altruism as you can get. Neither are strategically important countries or valuable trading partners. Our involvement there is basically pure humanitarism to help stop locals getting slaughtered by militias, and allow democracy a chance. We gain no money or value or anything apart from not having too many basketcase countries in the Pacific. I mean my God our soliders are risking their lives to try and improve some pretty shitty lives for those who live in Timor and the Solomons, and somehow this is NZ being a bad guy? I wonder what it feels like to hate your own country so much?

What did cheer me up though was how Anarchafairy proposed a campaign against the military, and Maia tells him off for using a militaristic word such as campaign. No wonder the revolution hasn’t yet happened! 🙂

Span has an excellent post on how ANZAC Day is not glorifying war, but remembering the the grim reality of it. Span also has a round-up of ANZAC Day posts.

Jordan also posts on how ANZAC Day is about peace, not celebrating war. He says most wars are bad, but not all.

Dawn Service

Like the PM, I didn’t make dawn service today, but at least I planned to attend. But my good intentions of waking up before 5 am didn’t eventuate after I ended up chatting to someone well past midnight. A pity, especially as Hayley Westenra was singing.

I can’t even begin to imagine how offensive it must have been for those veterans of WWII and more recent conflicts to see some morons burning the NZ Flag during the dawn service. Even if ANZAC Day is not your thing, that is incredibly rude. It’s legal to be an offensive boor, and I have no problems with a silent protest, but to actually disrupt the service by burning the flag – well it goes beyond tacky.

The Herald has a nice roundup of pictures and events.

10c petrol levy in Auckland

The Government is set to whack Aucklanders with a extra 10c petrol levy with one third going for rail electrification, and the rest on some roading projects.

I’m not actually against the petrol tax increase, but it needs to be done in a transparent way. At the moment it is onaque with some petrol tax going to roads, some to public transport and some to the cpnsolidated fund. And then on top of that the consolidated fund is paying for some ad hoc roading projects and some public transport projects.

Here’s what I would do:

1) Have any public transport projects funded from the consolidated account, just like other “public goods”. They should be scrutinised against clear criteria such as number of passengers helped, carbon reduced, no of cars off road etc. Some rail proposals will cost $3 million or so for every car they get off the road. Insane – you could just buy everyone a helicopter instead.

2) Have the Government set a benefit:cost ratio for road construction and repairs, over which funding will automatically be approved. Now you could argue anything above 1:1 but as the benefits tend to be indirect and the costs direct, I think 2:1 would be safer. Even this would see far far more road constuction than currently is the case.

3) The petrol tax should go solely towards roading projects, and automatically increase or decrease each year to meet the amortised costs of the roads that year so that every road proposal with benefits at least twice of the estimated cost is able to proceed. In the initial years there may be some timing issues.

This is not pro-roads or anti-roads. This is saying roads should be user pays and petrol tax (for now) is the best way to fund roads, and the tax should automatically adjust to fund necessary new roads to reduce crashes or congestion.

And public transport proposals, as a “public good” should come from taxation and be considered on their merits, and not be competing in a limited pool against roads. They are not competitors but complementary.

Any person who tells you that we can survive by having no new roads, and just investing in public transport is crazy, or lying, or ideologically blinkered (hates cars). You need better public transport and you need better roads.

Celebrities helping the environment

I love Sheryl Crow’s music. She’s great. But just because someone can sing well, or act well, doesn’t mean they have a view more valid that your local taxi driver on political issues. They just have fame.

We see this on Sheryl’s blog where she comes up with a new way to save the planet:

I have spent the better part of this tour trying to come up with easy ways for us all to become a part of the solution to global warming. Although my ideas are in the earliest stages of development, they are, in my mind, worth investigating. One of my favorites is in the area of conserving trees which we heavily rely on for oxygen. I propose a limitation be put on how many sqares of toilet paper can be used in any one sitting.

Oh yes a toilet paper law. And yes she is serious. Now how will this work? Will there be special bog police who check how many squares you are using while having a crap?

Now, I don’t want to rob any law-abiding American of his or her God-given rights, but I think we are an industrious enough people that we can make it work with only one square per restroom visit, except, of course, on those pesky occasions where 2 to 3 could be required.

Now Sheryl has not specified if our allotted one square is single or double ply. Quick reconvene Congress. But why stop at one square – why not just provide high powered hoses with every toilet and supply no toilet paper – people just have to blast the crap away.

When presenting this idea to my younger brother, who’s judgement I trust implicitly, he proposed taking it one step further. I believe his quote was, “how bout just washing the one square out.”

I suspect the brother is kidding. Ms Crow however is not.

Hat Tip: The Briefing Room

Tony Milne standing for Council

Tony Milne is standing for the Christchurch City Council.

I do find it amusing that Tony says that “people of this city are unhappy with the direction the current Council is taking Christchurch” and that “People are hungry for new direction and fresh leadership”.

Remind me someone of what party and ticket the current Mayor of Christchurch is from?

It would be nice to hope that the Christchurch Council elects a 100% sensible centre-right Council, but this this is too much too hope for. I’d say Tony has a better chance of being elected to Council than Megan Woods has in becoming Mayor, and frankly if you have to have some lefties on Council, then Tony would be preferable to anyone married to Jim Anderton 🙂

So good luck Tony – always good to see people willing to stand for what they believe in.

Tony Blair’s legacy

Red Rasputin has a post on what will be the good and bad of Tony Blair’s ten years in office. His list is:

Positive
# Northern Ireland
# Climate Change
# Third World Debt
# House of Lords
# Low Unemployment
# The Minimum wage
# Gift Aid for charities

Negative
# Iraq
# Crime
# The Regiments
# Cash for Peerages
# The Labour Party
# The Royal Family

It’s a reasonable list. What strikes me though is how modest it is for ten years of power. Whether or not you agreed with her, Thatcher in ten years implemented a massive agenda which changed the country. Blair will IMO be most remembered for winning elections, rather than what he did after winning.

A big boost to repealing the sedition law

A big thumbs up to the four minor parties today who combined forces to advocate for the repeal of NZ’s sedition laws. This is a superb example of how minor parties can make a difference on issues which the big parties may not see as crucial, but are important none the less.

Peter Dunne put together what some may call an unlikely coalition of United Future, Greens, Maori Party and ACT. They held a press conference at 2.30 pm to announce their support and to challenge one or both of the major parties to also support repeal. Their 15 votes are enough to pass it with either Labour or National.

Peter spoke about how the provisions conflict with our regard for free speech and that there are other laws to deal with actual criminal incitement. Keith Locke was excellent in outlining all the historical cases of sedition and how regrettable it is Labour have yet to agree to repeal it, considering three Labour Party leaders from the past have been charged with sedition themselves (Holland, Fraser and Nash).

Then Heather Roy spoke about the three modern cases in the last couple of years and how after 50 years of disuse, the Police have suddenly discovered it is a great catch-all charge which they are using instead of more appropriate other charges. The case of the Dunedin bar owner who was charged with sedition for having a beer for petrol soaked couch competition was a great example of how the law is currently being used.

The minor parties hope the Government will agree to repeal as a Government bill (and Burton has said they will decide by October), but if not they may keep submitting it as a private member’s bill.

I met Idiot/Savant from No Right Turn at the conference, and he deserves much of the credit for publicising and researching the issue. It’s a good example of how a blogger can make a difference.

NZPA cover the press conference here.

I happened to run into Steven Price on Molesworth Street just minutes after finishing talking about him over coffee with Idiot/Savant. In between debating electoral law, Steven made the point on the sedition repeal, that if both ACT and Greens are agreed on something, that’s usually a good sign it should be done!

So kudos again to Peter Dunne for organising the coalition, and to the other parties for working together on this. It does show the value the smaller parties can bring to Parliament.

Sunday Visits

How strange. On the 22nd the blog hit a new high for daily unique visits – 14,283. But that was on a Sunday which is normally well below weekday levels. Had 85,000 visits over the week which is also a high.

Heh, have worked out part of the reason for the spike. Google searches for Nicole Begg make up 10% of my search traffic 🙂

Why is he not in jail?

I’m all for rehabilitation but there comes a time where one has to put the safety of the community ahead of the 0.0001% chance someone may now stop offending.

The Press reports on Andre Charles Port who has been given merely a supervision sentence for assault despite being assessed as having a high risk of further offending.

Port went to the Kingslea youth detention centre at the age of 10 and had spent most of his adult life in jail for a series of violent or sexual attacks. By 1996 $250,000 had been spent on rehabilitation for him. He has made a series of attacks on mainly women.

To be fair to the Judge, the Crown actually suggested a supervision sentence. God knows why – he sounds like a case for preventative detention. I suppose once he has actually killed someone then it may happen.

Dr Rhys Cullen

People may remember Dr Rhys Cullen as the author of a book saying “Maori have every right to enjoy smoking, gambling and eating fatty foods if they want to” and “Maori health workers who say otherwise are just brainwashed ‘house niggers'”

Dr Cullen said there is no reason why young Maori should not smoke. They advised Maori to lie about their smoking habits to avoid being hassled by “health Nazis”.

Dr Cullen even said “the health system is racist and opposes activities like smoking and eating fatty foods simply because Maori enjoy them”

Maybe few are surprised that Dr Cullen is accused before the Health Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal of prescribing massive amounts of the decongestant Sudomyl, which can be used to make P.

Extremists tend to be involved in extreme and illegal activities.

Telecom’s Bogoievski on Separation

Telecom’s Marko Bogoievski is in the Dom Post talking up structural separation. He usefully confirms that the proposed network company would not just have the copper wires in it, but the kerbside cabinets, the fibre back to the exchanges, the regional exchanges and regional backhaul back to the larger exchanges. Or as Telecom explained in a meeting on Thursday, much the same asset split as proposed by the Government for operational separation.

That makes the structural separation proposal (subject to seeing actual details which are key) potentially very attractive. Telecom will have a detailed proposal done by the end of the week, so I’ll probably comment more when that is out.

It’s an incredibly exciting time for the industry, and I want to see NZ do what Netherlands are doing and have fibre to the home. A separate network company, not owned by Telecom, could be a very key player in making that happen, subject of course to the investment returns being there.

Yeltsin is dead

The first independent President of Russia, Boris Yeltsin, has died aged 76. His shining moment was standing up to the Soviet Generals who attempted a coup. The breakup of the USSR may have been very bloody otherwise.

He also became the first Russian leader to surrender power peacefully.

On the negative side he was often an alcoholic buffoon. Stuff has some of his more amusing misdeeds. Mind you I’m not sure ordering your guards to throw your press secretary in the river counts as a misdeed 🙂

The creeping face of Socialism

Almost every week the Government pushes new measures that interfere with voluntary transactions, and build up an all powerful state.

The latest is the socialist proposal that housing developers be forced to build a proportion of cheap houses in large new Auckland estates. What nonsense. The state should not be forcing private property developers to build a certain type of house. They have Housing NZ to do that if they think there is a need.

Why not go all the way and have the state fix the price for every house built? Worked so well in the USSR didn’t it?

Sadly the Government looks set to ignore the more useful proposals such as financially punishing councils for resource consent delays and abolishing the artificial city limit boundary for Auckland. Land supply is a big issue.

The 5% art sale royalty

I have to say the more I think about the 5% royalty on sale proposal for artworks, the more I don’t like it.

At the end of the day it is the state interfering in voluntary transactions. No artist has to sell for a price below what they want, and no buyer has to pay more than what they want. Now if an artist wants to include a sales clause which says if you resell, give me 5% then good on them. And if the buyers are okay with that, all the better.

But to have the state legislate to force such a clause on every single sale, is unjustified.

The NZ Herald editorial actually supports the proposal. They say:

The most cogent objection is that such a right is an unwarranted interference with common law property contracts. These assume ownership and attendant rights transfer in full upon the sale of, say, a house. But this must be balanced against the moral and economic right for artists to be guaranteed a fair return for their work. Copyright rules protect authors from exploitation, as do intellectual property rules in other areas, yet no similar dilution of the law of property applies to New Zealand visual artists.

I wonder if the NZ Herald could define for us what is a fair return, and at what level should this be? Why 5%? Why not 50%? I mean if one is going to have the state decide everything, instead of leaving it to buyers and sellers.

The Dominion Post argues against the proposal:

It recognises that life should be devoid of risks and that those who invest in art should not profit unduly from it. It is socialism en salon. If it were a painting it would be titled: Beehive Landscape – Impressing the Artists (hot-air-brushed oil on public canvas).

It is the compulsion to pay that differentiates the Government move. It is one that radical political landscape creator Sir Robert Muldoon would have been proud of. And there is every reason why it should apply to other sectors of the economy. Once again New Zealand could lead the world in social experimentation. A stud ram, for instance, could attract a royalty when sold, every deposit a winner. So, too, race horses. Every win a double.

The glaring minus of the proposal is that it does not allow for losses. What if an artwork falls in value? The artist can always go on the dole but what of the unfortunate buyer? If we are to socialise gains, why not losses too? An Arts Equalisation Authority could be established, its board a handy repository for the paint by numbers List members whose pigments have long faded.

I like the Dom Post leader writer when he or she gets sarcastic.

Harry Potter V Trailer

Batman and Robin

291278.jpg

Had a fun night at the Backbencher on Thursday evening, with the official excuse being the launch of the John Key puppet. Every National leader since Muldoon is there, plus every Labour leader since Lange, plus others such as Roger, Ruth, Koro, Prebs etc.

The theming was John as Batman and Bill as Robin. The unfortunate placement of Bill’s hand provided much mirth and we debated who should tell Bill than Robin is the camp one 🙂

John gave a very short but well received speech where he mused about getting his wife to dress up in lycra as Catwoman, and pledged to not drive the Batmobile at 160 km/hr. Witty, without being nasty.

It’s been a great tradition having the puppets there. The only leader in recent times to decline their own launch was Helen with her latest puppet (she had done earlier ones) as it showed her married to Winston. Don’s last puppet was the mad surgeon, which has now been transformed into an excellent likeness of The Joker! The BB was planning to put all the National Leaders together with Muldoon as the Penguin (that would have been great) but the costs are hideously expensive and redoing five of them too costly.

My own wee wall of misdeeds is still up in the BB also, having survived there 12 years.

Welly Girl was also there and blogged it also.

Why HLFS are the official figures

Numbers on benefits have decreased overall in the last seven years, and that is good. But one has to be very careful about comparisons between years as policy changes, new benefits, make work schemes etc can hide the true level of unemployment etc.

This is why the Household Labour Force Survey is the official measure of unemployment, and is comparable both internationally but also to previous years more easily.

Lindsay Mitchell points out that while the number of 15- 19 year olds on the dole has decreased since 1999 from 15,855 to 1,566, the HLFS records the number of unemployed (out of work, seeking work and available for work) 15 – 19 year olds as having increased from 23,900 in 1999 to 26,100 at the end of 2006.

This is still a minor reduction in percentage terms, but shows that the apparent massive decrease has not happened, just that they are recorded elsewhere in the system.

How’s this for child abuse

We all know Alec Baldwin, self appointed spokesperson for peace etc etc. Well many will have heard or read by now his phone message to his *11* year old daughter:

“I’m tired of playing this game with you. I’m leaving this message with you to tell you you have insulted me for the last time. You have insulted me. You don’t have the brains or the decency as a human being. I don’t give a damn that you’re 12 years old, or 11 years old, or that you’re a child, or that your mother is a thoughtless pain in the ass who doesn’t care about what you do as far as I’m concerned. You have humiliated me for the last time with this phone …

Do you understand me? I’m going to really make sure you get it. Then I’m going to get on a plane and I’m going to turn around and come home. So you’d better be ready Friday the 20th to meet with me. So I’m going to let you know just how I feel about what a rude little pig you really are. You are a rude, thoughtless little pig, OK?”

At least he never spanked her!!

Pies

Had an amusing day. The session on Good Morning TV with Barry Soper and Jane Clifton was lots of fun as it was about MPs getting into trouble in the House. So we covered the recent FU incident to John Carter’s cunning stunt mis-speak, some of Cullen’s wit, Muldoon’s drinking etc.

I checked before hand if I could tell the cunning stunt story, so long as I didn’t actually use the actual words that Carter said (he accidentally accused Labour of trying to get away with a stunning c**t). They said that was fine but as I was telling the story I could tell everyone was nervously waiting to see if I make the same mistake as the original person, and mis-speak. Would not go down well on morning TV, Luckily I avoided tongue twisting. I still remember the House when Carter made the mistake – the Speaker was convulsing with laughter, as was every MP. Took at least two minutes for it to resume.

Then headed up to Vic where I was one of four judges for a blind pie tasting competition. Salient got a rep each from National, Labour, Greens and ACT to sample five different mince pies from the various shops around campus, and rate them out of ten. We were also literally blindfolded for the tasting so they have some god awful photos of us, which I am told will be on their cover next week, as revenge for my blogging the Editor at a party.

I’m not allowed to reveal which outlets were best before publication but will say there was a lot of variety with my scores ranging from 2/10 to 8/10.