Wind Power

I am a huge fan of wind power. I wouldn’t at all mind a view with wind turbines in the landscape. I’m still disappointed that the plan to have wind turbines at the entrance to Wellington Harbour failed to proceed due to objections from residents on *the other side* of the harbour. It would have been magnificent to have people sailing and flying into Windy Wellington to see rows and rows of wind turbines.

Anyway the Dom Post has an editorial on how the biggest obstacle to wind power, is – yes the Government. The RMA delays have threatened the viability of the Makara project, and the proposed deforestation tax is threatening a planned wind farm northeast of Pauatahanui.

71 days to go

On Day 71 of the countdown, Labour have claimed they have raised enough money for paying back the $826,000 and will set a repayment date this week. Remember every week they delay that is $1,271 the taxpayer is out of pocket due to foregone interest.

Still to pay are United Future with $72,000 and of course NZ First with $158,000. NZ First have not 100% conclusively agreed to pay it back.

I’ll believe them all when I see the receipts!

Tax Breaks for Kiwi Saver

Winston Peters may have let slip that the budget looks likely to include targeted tax breaks – but only if you put money into Kiwi Saver.

This isn’t as desirable as universal tax cuts, but isn’t necessarily a bad thing. Will be interesting to see details if true.

If one is self employed, but pay yourself a salary of $100,000 a year through your company, then Kiwi Saver may be very beneficial. The 4% the employer puts in and the 8% you put in could all be tax deductible. So that’s a tax reduction of $4,680 a year or $90 a week for those on $100,000. Plus you get $6,000 lump sum ($1,000 now and $5,000 in five years). Almost $5,000 a year less tax in return for investing $12,000 into Kiwi Saver – a great rate of return.

Not so good for the person on $30,000. Their tax cut will be $480 (based on 20% average tax rate on 4% of $30,000).

So could be quite amusing if Dr Cullen is going to give someone on $100,000 ten times the tax cut of someone on $30,000. Of course this is speculation, but we will see.

Ask Rod

Cameron’s Credit Cards

Most people might be slightly embarrassed at having their credit cards stolen, and used to purchase $3,000 worth of clothes followed by some quality time in a pub and then brothel.

But not Newmarket Business Association general manager Cameron Brewer. It’s just another opportunity for a news story 🙂

I am somewhat amazed that they could use his credit card anywhere in Auckland and not be recognised as not being Cameron, who is upset if he isn’t in the media every second day. We’ll forgive the brothel for not recognising it wasn’t him though 🙂

Cameron has a point re pin numbers. I always use pin on credit cards when it is an option. But many overseas visitors do not have PINs.

Joint Currency

I’m fairly ambivalent on the idea of joint currency with Australia, but UMR has found support for it up from 29% in 2000 to 49% today.

Dr Cullen, and some others, are adamant that the only way Australia would agree to currency union is for NZ to adopt the Australian dollar.

I think he forgets politics is about deals. In the right circumstances I believe one could get Australia to agree to a new currency with a joint Reserve Bank. It might be after we have won at the WTO over apple access (not saying we would necessarily want to make that trade), or when there is something else to negotiate, with.

French Exit Polls

Exit Polls can be wrong, as we saw in the US in 2004, but they are very much in line with pre-election polling.

Three exit polls have been published, and averaging them out (they are all close to each other) gives:

Sarkozy 29.7%
Royal 25.5%
Bayrou 18.6%
Le Pen 11.3%

So Sarkozy vs Royal in two weeks.

The pitch invasion law

Hamilton bikini streaker Lisa Lewis is set to campaign against the Government’s proposed pitch invasion law.

Lewis does actually make a good point:

“It’s sobering to note that Sitiveni Sivivatu got off lighter in beating his wife than I did for entertaining thousands in my sporty Rip Curl bikini,” she said in her submission.

When Ms Lewis does present her submission to the select committee, I am sure the cameras will be there!

Garry Sheeran in the SST also complains about the proposed law, labelling it as too precious a reaction.

All in the past

Rebutting Anderton

People will remember that ridiculous assertion last week by Jim Anderton that research had shown people you are more likely to abuse animals if you were disciplined as a child?

I’ve been forwarded an e-mail from Dr Robert Larzelere, who will be in NZ next weekend. He has been researching child correction for over 30 years and has over 70 publications in the area. His response:

I have the Flynn (1999b) study that this report cites. College students who said their father spanked them WHEN THEY WERE TEENAGERS were 2.4 times more likely to have been cruel to animals in some way AT ANY TIME DURING THEIR CHILDHOOD. (over 1/3 of boys had been cruel to an animal at least once, 9% of girls). This is an example of the faulty logic that prevails. We train college students that “correlation does not equal causation” in their first two college courses in psychology. This is not only a correlation, the time sequence is mostly in the opposite direction of the implied causal relationship. The first limitation of the study listed by the author (Flynn) was that the study “is correlational in nature, making it difficult to discern causality, as well as the direction of the relationship between violence toward children and animal abuse. . . . Further, these findings may reflect the fact that males are more likely to engage in deviant behavior, including violence toward animals, and thus are more apt to be physically punished.”

It would be like finding out that those who had radiation treatment during the last 7 years are 2.4 times more likely to report having had cancer in the last 15 years. And then concluding that we therefore need to ban radiation treatment.

So Jim Anderton’s proof is based on research showing that getting smacked several years after you mistreated an animal, means that the smack is why you mistreated the animal five years earlier!! So sad and desperate.

Some bloggage

Bryce Edwards continues his excellent series of posts on party funding. In his 14th post he argues:

State funding actually weakens political parties and encourages them to be ideologically bland. This very long, but crucial blog post argues that such funding plays a dramatic role in divorcing parties from civil society, leading to much reduced civic participation in politics.

I don’t agree with everything Bryce has said in his series, but it is one of the most well supported and researched pieces around.

In an unusual occurence, No Right Turn attacks the Greens for “pulling numbers out of their arse” by advocating an annual $1.6 billion spend on righting climate change. He concludes his post saying:

The Greens need to go away and do some rough costings of what they want to fund. Otherwise, it just looks like they’re pulling numbers out of their arse purely for rhetorical effect – which doesn’t do a thing to convince people that you have serious, sensible, well-thought-out policy.

And this is from one of the leading supporters of doing more to mitigate climate change.

The (NSW) Daily Telegraph has some famous Australian political sledges:

Keating was the master:
* “I am not like the Leader of the Opposition. I did not slither out of the Cabinet room like a mangy maggot …”
* “He is the greatest job and investment destroyer since the bubonic plague.”
* calling Andrew Peacock a “painted, perfumed gigolo”.

Also worth reading Nick Cohen from the Observer about the damage done by eco-zealots.

Hooton on Electoral Act

In the SST today, Matthew Hooton sums up far better than I could, why it is so important that Labour’s attempts to secretly negotiate changes to the Electoral Act to favour themselves, does not proceed:

If Chris Trotter and Helen Clark don’t like the government being called corrupt, they should discourage ministers from behaving in ways which give rise to the accusation.

The integrity of our electoral law is ultimately the sole legal protection we as New Zealanders have against tyranny. We do not have a written constitution that defines and limits our government’s powers. Our Supreme Court has not yet assumed the authority to strike down legislation, even if it overrides our most fundamental rights. Most probably, our governor-general would never refuse the Royal Assent. We don’t even have an Upper House that could prevent or delay outrageous legislation.

In fact, perhaps uniquely in the developed world, our House of Representatives claims for itself total supremacy. Attorney-General Michael Cullen has argued it can do literally anything it likes. Unlike Americans, Australians, Canadians, and even the British with their House of Lords, the sole check on our House of Representatives is our decision every three years on which mob will control it.

Matthew nails it 100% here. The Electoral Act is our sole safeguard. Changes to it should be made in a public and open fashion, not a result of dirty backdoor deals.

Any government of integrity needed to act after the law had so obviously failed to be obeyed or enforced, but the government had a duty to proceed with full transparency, the greatest care and with the utmost good faith. Labour has failed these tests.

Instead of appointing an independent commission with impeccable reputations, Justice Minister Mark Burton has acted unilaterally and secretly, under the “guidance” of none other than Labour’s own party strategist, Health Minister Pete Hodgson.

Burton tells us there is nothing in his proposals – which are still secret – to stop abuses like the pledge card rort. We do know state-funding of political parties has been dropped. Sorting out the various enforcement agencies will be left until 2009, the justice minister tells us with a straight face. There is nothing, as far as we know, to amend parliament’s standing orders to prevent a future government retrospectively legalising its own breaches of electoral law.

Again Matthew nails it. Nothing in these proposals will stop the pledge card rort happening again. There is a desperate need to have dramatically stronger penalties for serious breaches of the election law.

Plunket, Greenpeace, churches, Federated Farmers and so forth will be restricted to spending $60,000 in election year on public policy campaigns, but unions will be able to spend as much as they like lecturing their members on how to vote. Labour’s rising star, Shane Jones, admitted on radio this week that the union exemption is because “they’re valuable and long-term supporters of ours”.

Indeed. And the unions already are developing plans to spend lots of cash to exploit their exemption.

This is not the way to reform our electoral law and associated enforcement procedures, but our justice minister is almost certainly not corrupt. He only looks it, because he is politically incompetent, unsuited to high office and lacks proper guidance on how an honourable government would go about reforming this special part of our law.

Incompetent but not corrupt. Matthew is in a generous mood 🙂

Matt McCarten seems to agree with the incompetent tag, finishing his column with:

Now Labour gets the worst of both worlds. They won’t get State funding through and they get bad press for appearing self-serving.

How dumb is that?

McCarten also makes an interesting observation regarding the last election:

Labour owes a whopping $824,000. Getting the grassroots party members to raise this on top of campaign funds is very difficult. In my view the party should have made Cabinet Ministers chip in $30,000 each to pay the bill. After all, the decision to raid the parliamentary piggy bank wasn’t a decision of the party organisation. MPs will be well aware that if this money hadn’t been spent it is quite likely the Nats would be sitting in the Beehive. Given that the difference in salary between an opposition MP and a Minister is over $300,000 over a parliamentary term, it’s not a big hit given the returns.

McCarten has just admitted that the $800,000 overspend by Labour was “quite likely” to have been what won the election for them. I have always taken the line one can’t no either way what impact it had,, but the fact McCarten thinks it “quite likely” is a revelation.

Voluntary Law Society Membership

It is good to see that membership of the Law Society is set to become voluntary.

One of the arguments supporters of compulsory membership of student associations have made, is that if the law society is compulsory, why can’t they be.

One answer has been that the law society does professional regulation, which student associations do not do. But law societies do more than that, and do advocate politically on issues. Hence I have been a long time supporter of having law the same as medicine.

In medicine everyone has to pay a compulsory levy (to the Medicial Council) for registration and the costs of a disciplinary process. And if they wish to they can also join the NZ Medical Association which advocates on issues.

In law, the NZ Law Society will be the regulator, and lawyers can choose whether to join theri voluntary district law societies (which may merge into a national one).

This is what should happen on campuses. Student association membership should be voluntary. Any essential student services (and few of these are provided by SAs) should be funded by the tertiary institute.

The dog attack

If only there was a simple solution to dog attacks. Certainly micro-chipping is not it.

Hopefully the owners will face a considerable penalty for the death they are indirectly responsible for. They did not keep their dogs secure, and they chose to have a dog known for its vicious attacks.

A breed ban can be hard to enforce and can over-reach by affecting “good” dog owners. Mind you I really struggle as to why anyone has a pitbull except to intimidate.

If I lived next door to dogs such as pitbulls, I’d want to be able to legally carry some sort of weapon for defence – pepper spray or a taser or even a pistol. For sure as hell I know who is going to lose in a wrestling match between me and two pitbulls.

Cats

Am over at my brother’s baby sitting my niece. Have been trying to work on laptop and blog now she has gone to bed, but the two Tonkinese kittens make it difficult.

I am on the couch and they are both on my lap, so I have the laptop next to me on the couch and am having to type one handed. Very slow.

They’ve both just been desexed, and have those plastic cones around their heads to stop them licking and biting the stiches. This makes it even more funny than normal when they try to fight each other as they both just keep bouncing off each other’s cone.

I thought I would be smart by hanging their favourite toy off the curtain rail so they could jump up at it but never reach it. However one of them did a very impressive eight foot climb up the curtains to get it. I am not sure I am meant to be teaching them curtain climbing.

Some interesting blogs

Red Rasputin has a competition on what my middle name should be. The winner gets a copy of the 2002 National Party Manifesto signed by myself and Bill English. There are also bonus points if you can correctly say who would win in a fight between a robot, and a bear holding a shark!

James Sleep has set up a Sleep-ON-Politics blog in which I feature often. It seems I am involved in the “Molestering Church”, am dangerous and unfair. Oh yes according to James I am also one of those people John Key doesn’t like as I am so right wing.

I “Love the Melestering Brethren” my polling company is “right wing and corrupt” and Kiwiblog is “an extremely right winged, Descriminitive Pack of Brash Whores who love violence and hate unions”.

James finishes saying “Up yours!!! You Hollow Deceptive, Brash Arse kisser, oh not to mention Melestering Brethren member and capitalist.”

Oh gosh I better give us this blogging lark. I can handle being called a “Melestering Brethren member” but to also call me a capitalist is just too much. I surrender!

There’s already some lively comments on James’ site concentrating mainly on his age. I suggest people don’t use his age against him, but welcome that someone at 15 is so passionate about his politics. I am sure given time, he will realise his approach is umm less than highly effective.

James has an ally on his site in Clare Swinney. Clare was the first person on the planet to work out and speculate that the Virginia shooting was also a US Govt Black-Op. My goodness is there nothing that brilliant US Govt black ops department can’t do?

My blogging on Princes Street Labour led to an article in the Scotsman, as one of the protagonists is the son of a well known Scottish politician – Lord George Foulkes.

Whale Oil has a huge collection of political number plates based on reader feedback. There are 97 of them now.

The culprit for interest rate rises

Fran O’Sullivan fingers government spending as the real culprit behind the Reserve Bank having to increase interest rates.

The focus merely on the housing sector, is risky. Higher interest rates do not just affect house purchases but business development.

The record high exchange rate is going to bite exporters very soon. I am not sure people realise how much of a difference there is between 74c (high), 55c and 40c (low). One might think only a small difference but because the calculation is an inverse it is much more.

For example let’s say you have a market price for your exports of US$100/unit. At 40c you get NZ$250, at 55c you get NZ$182 and at 74c you get NZ$135. So your revenue at 74 c is 26% lower than at 55c and 46% lower than at 40c. Now if your margin is only 30%, bang you are unprofitable.

Peters for Tamaki?

An interesting suggestion in the NZ Herald, that Winston Peters may seek to win Tamaki, rather than just rely on NZ First making 5%.

If he managed to portray himself as the heir to Sir Robert, he might do better than expected. On the other hand it has been 15 years since Muldoon died and a lot of people will have moved in and out of the electorate since then.

The Bolger Years

The NZ Herald has a rare interview with Jim Bolger, in the lead up to The Bolger Years conference next weekend.

The conference costs $150, but the line up of speakers is superb – most of the former Cabinet, several journalists, some former staff, Sir Tipene O’Regan, former heads of Treasury and MFAT, Ken Douglas etc.

Sadly I have a board meeting for most of Friday, but will still try and attend what I can.

Blogs on Section 59

Some excellent well researched blog posts on the Section 59 debate.

A plague on both their houses destroys the myth that smacking is already illegal, and hence this bill will not ban smacking. He makes the point that there are three possible responses to whether this bill will ban smacking:

* the brave response (yes it does and so it should)
* the under enforcement response (yes it does but no-one will be charged)
* the no new criminality response (smacking already is a crime)

He labels the brave response as legitimate, the under-enforcement response as evasive and unconvincing, but the no new criminality response as “outright deceitful”.

This is why John Key will probably not be able to find a compromise. Clark and Bradford’s public statements on their bill are basically deceitful.

Plague also does a first class job in showing how much of the research cited by anti-smacking groups is flawed.

Also Richard at Philosphically, et cetera makes a useful observation on the Section 59 debate:

Frankly, I’m amazed there’s any controversy here at all. Given that no-one really wants to prosecute all parents for smacking, outlawing it just seems like an obviously bad idea, for two reasons.

(1) It’s patently unjust to remove a legitimate defence merely because the occasional “false positive” lets guilty people go free. Surely, if a defendent’s use of force really is reasonable, then it’s not abuse or assault. Justice demands that our legal system recognize this.

(2) As a general principle, it’s always a bad idea to have unenforced (or inconsistently enforced) laws. (It’s asking for trouble to grant such discretionary powers to the police. Much better to leave them with jurors.)

In terms of those false positives, they’re looking damn low. It’s been one every two years on average. Family First point out that just in the last fortnight there have been three successful prosecutions of parents for assault, despite Section 59. So the false positive rate could be under 1%.

Richard also makes a useful observation when he says:

Given the social controversy over what constitutes good parenting, it seems entirely inappropriate for the state to be mandating any particular answer. Of course there are limits, as all reasonable people agree: we shouldn’t tolerate serious abuse, or other gross harms. But smacking is plainly not in the same league. It’s a trivial harm, if it’s any harm at all. Bradford’s proposal is like passing a law mandating what parents must tell their kids about Santa Claus (“Santa is a lie, and lying is wrong, end of story”, blah). It’s totally inappropriate, even if they happen to be right about what “the perfect parent” would do. It just isn’t their place to say.

And this is indeed correct. Clark and Bradford are using their positions as legislators to mandate a particular view on how children should be raised. If they did not want to do so, then they would vote for either the Borrows amendment, or a similar one which would prevent smacking being criminalised.

Richard concludes:

In a liberal democracy, the government shouldn’t try to micromanage people’s lives. It certainly has no business foreclosing public debate over such a contentious cultural issue, mandating one particular parenting style over another. For issues where reasonable people may disagree, the appropriate response for a liberal state is to uphold autonomy and pluralism. Let parents decide for themselves how best to raise their own children. I expect they’ll do a better job than the government would.

Hear hear.

Round One on Sunday

The first round of the French presidential election is on Sunday.

In this final week, there have been 11 polls so far. Averaging them out gives us:

Sarkozy 28.3%
Royal 24.0%
Bayrou 18.6%
Le Pen 13.8%
Others 15.3%

The good news is that Le Pen looks like he will not make the second round, unless the polls are totally stuffed. Also it looks very much like Sarkozy will make the second round. None of the polls have shown a shift on the left to strategically vote for Bayrou over Royal, as he has the better chance of beating Sarkozy. So it should be an old fashioned right vs left Sarkozy vs Royal in two weeks.

The cloest Bayrou has been to Royal this week has been 2% in one poll. The average gap is 5.4% and one poll had a 10% gap.

In terms of the second round, one poll has had a 50/50 split. None have had Royal in front and two have had Sarkozy 7% ahead. The average has been Sarkozy 52.3% and Royal 47.7%

Young Labour Executive

Young Labour have put out a release on their AGM and Executive elections. They had a creditable 70 attendees, as being their largest turn out. It would have been even larger if they hadn’t evicted one young activist just because he was wearing a Ronald Reagan t-shirt!

They have also planted some trees to offset their carbon usage of 3.3 tonnes. That’s 0.000000014% of the problem solved.

Oh and even worse luck, the trees won’t help much in the long term, as Wikipedia says: “Significant concern arises from the fact that carbon sequestered in the newly planted trees will be again released as CO2 when the tree dies and decays, thus merely postponing the negative impact of the man-made increase in CO2”

So Young Labour are permanently responsible for their 0.000000014% of global carbon emissions. Future generations of Young Labourites will have to keep replanting the trees when they die.

Listed below are those who got elected onto the Young Labour Executive. One can only call it inclusive with 23 people on it – that makes it even larger than Cabinet! But it is genuinely great to see so many people wanting to be involved.

Many years ago we would have Young Labour vs Young Nats debates on campuses. They were great fun.

Anyway names and some links below. Hopefully Trevor Loudon has already started profiles on some of them. 🙂

President Meg Bates
Vice President Sonny Thomas

Maori Vice President Kapu Waretini
Secretary David Do
International Secretary Eric Goddard
Treasurer Glenn Riddell
New Zealand Council Tony Milne
Policy Council Rep James Kennelly
Communications Peter Wilson
Rangatahi Recruitment Kieran Brown
Maori Liaison Amelia Dalley
Pacific Island Rep Leah Rees
Women’s Rep Sophia Blair
Rainbow Rep Jordan King
Affiliates Rep Jeremy Greenbrook-Held
Auckland/Northland Rep Rochelle Rees
Auckland/Northland Rep Stephen Cooper
Waikato Georgia Farrell-Summers
Central North Island Julia Haydon Carr
Wellington Rep Rita Lowe
Northern South Island Holly Griffin
Southern South Island Ashley Murchison
Immediate Past President James Coyle

Green Party Electoral Policy

The Green Party have published a policy on electoral finance reform. I’ll summarise and critique it:

Introduction – shamefully they don’t even mention Labour’s pre election behaviour where they ignored warnings from the Chief Electoral Officer and lied to him. They also took about over-spending as if $8,000 is the same as $800,000. It’s the sort of hypocriticial approach I’d expect from Labour, but not from teh Greens. Remember how once they claimed to be principled on these things.

Even more shamefully they have not written a word on increasing penalties for election law breaches. This is arguably the most important thing to happen – doesn’t matter what laws you have if they are not enforced and they do not have significant penalties for non compliance.

* Establish an independent commission of inquiry into campaign finance rules

Good. Agreed it should not just be the MPs who do it. But it can’t just be Labour and Greens who appoint the Commission.

* Ban anonymous donations over $1,000

I think there is univerdal support for full transparency of significant donations. The issue is at what level is a donation significant. I think the current level of $10,000 is about right. Labour’s proposal of $5,000 is okay. $1,000 is too low. No-one buys any influence or policy for $1,000.

* Ban overseas donations

Their only exception is for NZers living overseas and eligible to vote. That is fairer than what Labour proposes which is to allow their sugar daddy who has not lived here since 1966 to keep donating.

* Rolling disclosure in the election lead up

No real problem with this. Weekly is proposed. Could argue for fortnightly. In my experience once the campaign starts all the activity is on spending money not raising it.

* Limits on total donations

So long as there is full transparency, I am unconvinced one needs a limit. The public are sensible people and can judge for themselves if they see anything wrong with such donations. Also the Greens proposal will lead to a US style campaign finance system (US has $2,000 limits) where most money goes to lobby groups, who have less rigorous disclosure requirements and less public accountability.

The Green rationale for wanting to encourage parties to reach out to more people for funding is unconvincing, considering they are strong supporters of compulsory taxpayer funding, which would act as far less of an incentive for mass membership and support.

Also Kiwi Pundit makes a point I had been planning to make – why regulate the amount of money one can donate but not the amount of time? If you believe it is unfair someone can donate more money than someone poorer than them, then is it not equally unfair that someone who is unemployed can donate more time than someone who has a job?

* extend the campaign spending cap period back to 1 January

This is preposterous and to be blunt an outrageous suppression of the right of opposition parties to campaign against the Government while the Government is still spending state money on advertising, passing budgets, passing laws. A fixed date for the campaign period is desirable but anything before 1 September is too far out.

* Third party campaigns over $1,000 to register with Electoral Commission

Agreed

* $50,000 cap from 1 January on third party expenditure

This is a magnitude too low. Reputable groups like Federated Farmers will be prevented from campaigning against say the Fart Tax. The cap should be similar to what political parties themselves can spend – $1 million.

The Greens should trust the intelligence of voters to judge the source of any campaign material, and give it an appropriate weighting in their minds.

* Clarify parliamentary rules on expenditure

It’s easy. During the election period, the parliamentary parties should not pay for any advertising at all, except the most basic stuff such as electorate office hours.

* Maintain status quo on broadcast funding and allocation

Actually I would abolish the funding, and remove the restrictions on parties buying their own air time. It’s inconsistent to say a party can not buy a 30 second radio ad on Radio Live, but they can buy a full page ad in the NZ Herald.

* Remove major party reps from Representation Commission and Electoral Commission when doing broadcasting

The status quo is not very satisfactory, but I am not sure total removal of reps is the right answer. The political reps can often bring useful knowledge and perspective to the roles. There may be some compromise such as non voting members.

Culture & Identity Stats

Another bunch of stats out today from the census. Ones I found interesting:

* Since 2001, Maori population up 30%, Pacific up 59%, Asian 255%, and total population up 19%.
* Also since 2001 those identifying as English has dropped 17%, but British is up 63%, Tongans 117%, Fijians 93%, Chinese 216%, Indian 226%, Korean 3,211%, Afghani 2,069%,
* 73.5% of residents were born in NZ, 1.6% Australia, 3.4% in the Pacific, 6.2% in UK/Ireland, 0.7% North America, 6.2% Asia,
* 6,034 NZers were born in Iraq, 2,793 in Iran and 2,145 in Afghanistan
* Of the 879,543 NZers born overseas 6.7% have been here less than year, 24.2% 1 – 4 years, 16.2% 5 – 9 years, 17.05 10 – 10 years and 31.5% over 20 years
* In terms of language 95.9% speak a Germanic language, 2.1% a romantic language, 0.5% a Balto-Slavic language, 2.8% a Sino-Tibeto-Burman language, and 7.5% a Central-Eastern Malayo-Polynesian language
* 213 NZers born in Asia speak Maori, 459 NZers born in Australia speak Samoan
* 6,531 NZers can speak five or more languages, including two kids aged under five!
* Since 1996, Anglicans are down 12.1%, Catholics up 7.4%, Mormons up 5.7%, Brethren down 10%, Evangelicals up 773%, Sallies down 21.4%,
* In other religions, Muslims up 166%, Jews up 43%, Ratana up 39%, And Satanists up 28% (to 1,167). We also have 357 Scientologists

Setting election rules

Transparency International makes the case in the NZ Herald for election rules to be decided on by some sort of independent panel, rather than the MPs who are directly affected by it.

In the past rule changes have tended to have wide bi-partisan support, so there was less need for an independent panel, but Labour’s attempts to screw over their opponents by jacking up partisan favourable law changes shows the danger in leaving it to MPs.

An independent panel has considerable merit. However it is not a guarantee of good outcomes. Who gets to appoint the independent panel and set the terms of reference would be a key issue.

It actually angers me what Labour is doing with these changes to the Electoral Act. They are treating the Electoral Act as some partisan policy issue where you negotiate a majority in secret before you even reveal the details to the public. This is not common practice for most laws, and especially electoral law.

What they should have done is a process such as the Government has used on say the spam act and the copyright acts. First you publish a discussion document highlighting the issues, and asking for public feedback on the issues. Then you publish a further document which sets out some proposals, and get feedback on those proposals. And then after that feedback, you might then introduce a bill into Parliament.

The Government spent three to five years getting feedback and developing its policy on the Copyright Act. Yet on the far far more important Electoral Act it has developed policy in total secrecy, and hasn’t had a single public consultation to guide its decision making. Why? Because the Electoral Act changes are about utu or revenge. It is a nasty undemocratic attempt to fuck over its opponents and critics.