Fijian elections within two years

Some good news from Brussels regarding Fiji. The EU has managed to get ((along with Pacific states) an agreement with Fiji to hold elections within two years, in exchange for continuing to buy their sugar. This means elections some 12 to 18 months earlier than would otherwise have been the case.

Whether the Commodore will keep his word is another matter, but let us hope so. And let us hope he starts to think about whether he wants to be a politician or a solider – for he should not be allowed to continue to be both. Also one will need to make sure the Fijian media are allowed to report fairly on any election, but if they do try to censor them, well the blogs are always there!

The key points to which Fiji has agreed are:

* fair and free parliamentary elections within 24 months of 1 March 2007
* elections to be audited by the Pacific Islands Forum Secretariat
* a schedule for the election to be published by 30 June 2007
* that changes to boundaries and electoral reform should be done in accordance with the Constitution (we need such an agreement for NZ!!)
* That the appointment of the Vice-President shall be done in accordance with the Constitution
* respect institutions like Great Council of Chiefs and an independent judiciary
* pledges about freedom of media

As I said, let’s hope Fiji and the Commodore stick to their word.

UPDATE: I have not linked to an online source for this as I got my info via e-mail from one of the diplomats involved. The agreement may not have yet been signed off by the Commodore but was agreed to by the Fijian Minister of Foreign Affairs, the Minister of Finance and the Attorney General.

Gay neighbours

A survey has found 22% of NZers would not like homosexuals as neighbours. I’m not sure whether I should be pleased the figure is so low at 22%, or sad that there are still one in five people who worry about what their neighbours next door do at night time.

I wonder sometimes how much of an issue homosexuality is to people, is related to whether they know or have many dealings with gay people. I know from my own experience I was terribly homophobic at school, and there were no openly out kids. I did not know any (out) gay students. When I got to uni, it was impossible not to know gay people if you were involved in student politics, and over around 18 months my attitudes changed 180 degrees.

And since then I can’t think of a workplace I have been at where there hasn’t been gay staff, and in politics there seems to be a disproportionately high number of gay staffers and activists (not just in Labour, in National also) so over the last 20 years I would have worked with oh at least 50 or 60 gays and lesbians. And I just can’t imagine how I ever once held the views I did when I was back at school. I’m at the stage where learning someone is gay is about as significant to me as learning they have blue eyes. It’s just a feature of who they are. So I do struggle to understand how 1 in 5 people would have a problem with gay neighbours.

Anyway turning back to the survey, I’ve located the original with the raw data. It asks not just about having a homosexual neighbour, but also of a different race, a Muslim, a Jew, and a Immigrant or foreign worker.

NZers were not asked about Muslims and Jews (a pity, would be interesting) but only 3% objected to a different race, 5.4% to immigrants, and 22.3% to homosexual neigbours.

We are second lowest (out of 23 countries) for bigotry on race. Only Sweden is lower at 2.6%.Average was 8.5%

On immigrants/foreigners we are 7th lowest with 5.4% compared to average of 10.1%. And on homosexual neighbours we are in the bottom half (just) at 13th. The average is 19.6% and we were 22.3%.

The average for Muslims was 14.5% and for Jews 9.5%. The most anti-Muslim country was Greece at 20.9% and least was Canada at 6.5%. For Jews worst was Spain at 21.7% and best was Netherlands at 1.7%.

So we are only one third as bigoted (the author’s term) on different races compared to most countries, one half as bigoted against immigrants and foreigners but slightly more bigoted against homosexuals than the average.

The term bigoted is somewhat harsh, but at the end of the day judging a neighbour off their “group affiliation” rather than as an individual, is the thin wedge end of bigotry.

EU to outlaw Holocaust denial

The EU plans to make denying the Holocaust a criminal offence throughout Europe.

While well-intentioned, this proposal is regrettable. The way to deal with holocaust deniers is to laugh, mock, expose, and ridicule them. But banning them will just add to their paranoid theories.

I can understand with sympathy why Austria and Germany especially felt the needs for such laws after WWII. But today such laws are unnecessary, and most of all the special circumstances of Germany and Austria do not apply to all of Europe.

We see what a precedent this can create, with the Poles wanting denial of Stalinist crimes to also be an offence.

We’re all animal abusers!

Oh this is hilarious. How desperate can you get. Jim Anderton claims that people spanked as a child are much more likely to turn into animal torturers.

His basis for such a claim is a solitary study of 90 male students! And it wasn’t based on 90 convicted animal abusers, but on self reports. So basically what they did is ask 90 students how many of you have ever abused an animal, and that of those students who self reported they are animal abusers, 2.4 times as many claimed they were physically disciplined as a child.

Now let us assume that of these 90 male students, only around 20% were animal abusers, your actual sample is something like 17 students. You see if 17 was the sample it works out precisely that 5 said they were not discipled and 12 say they were.

So Anderton’s assertion is probably based on 17 male undergraduate students in the US. And that is before one even gets into was it a random sample, can you trust self reporting, and is a correlation a causative effect.

Anderton would get an E- from any university for his claim.

The union money go round

CYFS has been a department under siege with critical report after critical report into it. So what are they spending their money on? A $650 bonus to PSA union members. Yes only to PSA members. They were not obligated to give it, they just decided to make it a birthday present to celebrate their partnership anniversary!

And this was all kept secret,and only came to light through a leaked memo. And unions complain about transparency of electoral donations. Let’s look at the union financing scheme.

1) Labour elected to Government

2) Labour funnels state funds to unions through employment education funds

3) Labour funnels state funds to union members by approving special bonuses just to union members

4) Unions gain more members and more funds

5) Unions campaign for Labour

6) Labour elected to Government

No wonder the CTU wants to ban private donations to political parties!

Norton 360

Peter Griffin has a very positive review of the new Symantec product, Norton 360.

One feature which really appeals is this one:

An excellent feature is the ability to upload important files to the internet for safe-keeping on Symantec’s servers. You get 2GB (gigabytes) of storage with your subscription and Norton 360 will regularly prompt you to back up a set of files or folders you’ve indicated are very important.

That would be very cool. I backup to a external hard drive but I am still vulnerable to a fire as I am not disciplined enough to take backups to a bank vault etc. The idea of online backup is a good one. I already sort of use Gmail for that, but something which will just do it automatically for all files in folders marked important is a great utility.

Also the online chat to a support tech is something I like. I much prefer that to filling in forms, or phoning people.

The price at $129 annually is a bit on the high side though.

Bosses Pay

A NZ Herald article on Tubepack, and how the high exchange rate is threatening the viability of the business. They note the business owners have stopped paying themselves wages to try and keep the company afloat.

This is not unusual in small and medium sized businesses. I know of one business which went through tough times and the highly experienced and skilled owners were paid less than the receptionist.

Some people just focus on the rewards some business owners get from their business, and want to punish tax them for it. But risk is the slip side of reward, and it is not insignificant.

Inflation

The inflation stats out yesterday were not flash, and mortgage rates look set to rise again. The Reserve Bank has been, in my opinion, rather lacking in its responses to date.

The cumulative inflation rate over the last three years has been 8.9%. Since 1999 it has been 20.7%. In my opinion it should be averaging no more than 1% a year.

Interesting to look at the items that have increased the most over the last 12 months. They are:

Fruit and vegetables 17%
Property Rates 8%
Household Energy 7%
Hospital Services 6%
Passenger transport services 8%
Primary and secondary education 7%

So nothing important then. Just healthy food, compulsory rates, energy, hospitals, school and transport!

A Labour MP on why unions wil be exempt!

This is stunning. Listen to Labour MP Shane Jones on Newstalk ZB this morning.

The host was interviewing Katherine Rich and Shane Jones on the proposed electoral law changes and restrictions on third parties. He then asked Shane Jones

“Why would you exempt Unions?”

The reply from Mr Jones:

“They’re valuable and long term supporters of ours etc”

If you do not believe me click on the link above and go to 1:40 minutes through. I mean one has to commend Mr Jones for his honest answer, but doesn’t this prove what the motivation behind these changes are – to benefit their supporters and hurt their opponents?

Conversation with a journalist

Hack: Here’s another entry for your stupid file

DPF: Oh great I love them

Hack: Guess who the Government got to front up today on the smacking issue?

DPF: Helen’s overseas, so was it Steve “Fuck You” Maharey?

Hack: No it was Benson-Pope

DPF: Oh my God, you are joking

Hack: No. It’s just hysterical that the Government can’t see the irony.

DPF: Clark will be pissed off. She’s been keeping him hidden away. I mean how stupid can they get?

Hack: They used to be so much smarter than this. Their first two terms it was an almost flawless performance but it is now like lemmings. I mean Benson-Pope had the Police find a prima facae case regarding allegations he assaulted kids he taught, and they think he should front for the Government on this issue?

DPF: Plus as a teacher he used to administer corporal punishment

Hack: Yes, and of course the Investigate stuff.

DPF: Oh yes the unprintable. Even without that he is a very bad choice of someone to front up. With it, well it’s almost funny.

Hack: Maybe one could do an advertising campaign – “Don’t smack your kids unless they enjoy it”

DPF: Ha ha ha oh that is priceless. I so have to blog this conversation.

Hack: Don’t name me.

DPF: Never. It’s only MFAT who reveals what happens at secret meetings!

Hack: Yes, smacked by lunchtime!

Human Rights Film Festival

The Human Rights Film Festival occurs in May. Venues are:

2 – 9 May, Academy Theatre, Auckland
9 – 16 May, Paramount Theatre, Wellington
2 – 19 May, Regent on Worchester, Christchurch

Some of these movies are NZ productions. There are a mixture of full and short feature films.

I will try and see Carla’s List, about UN prosecutor, Carla Del Ponte, as she pursues war criminals from the former Yugoslavia in an attempt to bring them to justice.

Well done John Key

John Key correctly said yesterday, in a speech:

What is quite clear, however, is that almost all members of Parliament say they want the same outcomes.

• To prevent violence against children being protected by the defence of reasonable force.

• Not to criminalise good parents who occasionally give their children a light smack.

• To lower the threshold for acceptable physical discipline.

Key makes the point that the current bill does criminalise smacking for correction:

Say, for example, you see your young son slowly pushing his sister’s Barbie doll into the fire. Under Sue Bradford’s bill, you would be able to use force to pull your son away from the fire, because his actions constitute offensive or disruptive behaviour, as well as being potentially dangerous.

But if you then gave him a smack and told him not to do it again, this would be against the law.

Key asked to meet with Sue Bradford and Helen Clark to see if they could find a compromise which will achieve all three objectives. Sue Bradford, to her credit, is keen to talk and will address National’s caucus. The Government had David Benson-Pope come out and sneer, and accused John Key of being soft on child abuse.

The bill as it stands is horribly unpopular with the public. National could just let a flawed bill pass into law and reap the electoral benefits of most MPs oppossing it. It is to Key’s credit that he would rather stop a bad law being passed, by proposing direct talks on a compromise.

Having said that, I am unsure a compromise can be found. Because the Greens insist their party “was not willing to lower the threshold for acceptable physical violence towards children”. With such an absolutionist position, it is hard to see compromise.

You see despite denials from some, I blogged last Thursday that the bill as worded does ban smacking for correctional purposes:

They claim they only want to target the most serious abuse cases which are getting off in the courts (which average one very two years incidentally) and that parents who lightly smack their children for correctional purposes won’t have to worry about prosecution because Police will use common sense.

But, and this is the big but, why then did they feel the need to insert legislative defences for the use of force, or smacking, when it is being done to prevent harm or prevent disruption? I mean by the same logic, the Police would use common sense and not prosecute?

Parents feel this bill is MPs telling them how to raise their children. And they are in fact right. Because Bradford and Clark have a bill which says we approve of you smacking your children for the purposes of preventing harm or preventing disruption (and will give specific legislative protection to you) but we do not approve of you smacking your children for correctional purposes, so we will not give you any protection for that.

And over the weekend I pointed out, that in regard to the infamous Timaru riding crop case, the Borrows amendment would 100% rule out a defence for that, while the current Bradford/Clark bill would not necessarily be effective in preventing a defence in court.

Former Labor Press Secretary made TVNZ Head of News

Telecom and structural separation

Fran O’Sullivan is supportive of Telecom’s proposal to actually structurally separate the network division, rather than just operationally separate it.

I blogged on my enthusiasm for structural separation back on 18 March. So I am naturally pleased to see Telecom’s proposal.

However from my reading of the proposal, Telecom are not proposing that the assets which would have gone into an operationally separated network division, would be the same assets in a structurally separated network company. And that division of assets is essential, as if you do not have the monopoly bottleneck assets in the network division or company, then you will not get the competition you need.

But I may be misreading the proposal, and it is light on details. In my InternetNZ role I’m meeting with three Telecom officials tomorrow, where they’ll be explaining to us their proposal in more detail. I’m definitely looking forward to that, and may be able to blog in some more detail once I understand it better.

I would love for there to be a separate network company, so Telecom can get on with its business with less regulation. Whether this proposal will adequately achieve that I don’t yet know. But it is great that Telecom have taken the initiative in proposing it.

CTU calls for all political donations to be disclosed

In a fit of hypocrisy the CTU has called for every single donation to a political party to be disclosed. This would mean that every single member of a political party (even those who give $5) would be a matter of public record.

Considering how much effort we put in to having a secret ballot, the thought of outing tens of thousands of people’s party membership and voting preference is a huge privacy breach.

But here’s the hypocrisy. Many unions are formally affiliated to Labour, and donate to Labour. I’ll take the CTU suggestion seriously if they include a requirement for any union affiliated to a political party to also disclose its full membership list and every single source of income for that union.

We see some idea of Wilson’s true agenda when he promotes the idea of banning private donations all together, and to have public funding as the only source for parties. This would allow political parties to ditch all those troublesome members who demand votes on things, and just be captured by, oh goodness, the unions for parties on the left.

How independent are the Group of Seven?

An official spokesperson for the Exclusive Brethren has said that the Group of Seven are acting independently of the church, and are acting in their role as concerned businessmen.

I basically reject that premise for two reasons, but there is a factor I will come back to which may make it literally true.

First of all, involvement by the Brethren in election campaigns has occurred in half a dozen countries in very recent times. This strongly implies that the senior leadership of the church has been encouraging, if not mandating, this activity. I do not believe in coincidences.

Secondly the involvement in NZ was not just the pamphlets put out by the Group of Seven, but also many hundreds or thousands of volunteers who helped with pamphlet deliveries etc. Again this very strongly suggests that the senior leadership of the church encouraged or mandated such activity.

But there is one factor at play, which may make any third party restrictions meaningless. I suspect the pamphlets were in fact not funded by the Exclusive Brethren church, but by the individuals named on them. Many of their members are successful and prosperous business owners and their individual resources are in this case probably significantly more than any collective funds with the church. So when they say the pamphlet was published by say P Lim rather than the EB, they may technically be right because P Lim could well have paid for it personally.

Now even if the proposed limit of $60,000 remains in force, so long as the seven are paying individually they can still legally do $420,000 of advertising (and many would say they should be allowed to anyway so long as they have full disclosure). If seven other EB members join in then they can do $840,000. The law may have no effect on the very people Labour claims it is targeted at.

Uni/Police response panned re shooting

It seems that many of the deaths at Virginia Tech were preventable. The killer shot two people initially at 7.15 am and then the 30 others at 9.50 am.

The uni relied on e-mail (!!!) to tell people not to come onto campus after teh first shooting, and started to phone people. Good God the Police SWAT team should have been there within minutes with loudhailers evacuating the campus until they caught the killer.

It sounds like a love affair gone sour. Very tragic. Also sounds like the killer had only been in the US a few months and was from China – there could be some complications arising from that.

It would be nice if the bodies were at least cold before the NZ Herald uses the tragedy to editorialise against the US’s gun laws. Yes there is a legitimate debate about those laws. But a knee jerk reaction before it is known how the students got the guns is just that – knee jerk.

1,000 extra …

33 dead in Virginia

Cartoon says it all

290599.jpg

This great cartoon from Stuff. The stuff ups in the last year have been numerous:

* Taxpayer Funding of Parties
* Pledge Card/Auditor-General
* Taito Phillip Field
* Corrections
* Auckland DHBs
* The Mallard Stadium
* NCEA
* 2006 Budget
* Smacking Ban

Any I’ve missed?

Myths of NZ Party Finance

Smacking Bill petition half way there

The petition calling for a CIR on the proposed changes to Section 59 already has 150,000 signatures after six weeks. I will be very surprised if they do not make the 310,000 needed seeing they have a year to do so.

So will Parliament pass the law in advance of the referendum?

Will the referendum be held in conjunction with the general election (which would save money) or will they waste money having it separately so voters don’t have the explicit reminder of the issue on election day?

Multiple bites of the cheery

I am not a major art buyer, but on principle I’m far from enthused about the Government’s proposal that you never own an artwork you pay for outright, and that if you resell it you have to pay 5% every time to the artist who sold it in the first place.

Sure it means a new artist may sell something for $1,000 when they start off, which later becomes more valuable and worth say $50,000. But if their reputation has grown so much, then the artist will be able to produce more artworks at current prices.

And as the article points out, a 5% resale clause can be inserted into existing contracts for those artists and buyers who agree to them.

Fighting the billboard ban

Great to see so many Aucklanders fighting the proposed draconian billboard ban in Auckland. One Cr, Graeme Mulholland, has resigned in protest off the hearing panel because the Chair, Glenda Fryer, refuses to recuse herself.

I had to laugh upon reading that the only submitters in favour of the ban on day one were two community boards – both controlled by City Vision.

Also one has to appreciate the research done by Mark Venter who finds that the Auckland City Council itself has more advertising space on Queen Street than commercial billboards.

Mad Green candidate in Canada

The Canadian Greens have finally dumped, after days of defending him, Kevin Potvin. Potvin’s comments on 911 and 7/7 illustrate well the sheer ugliness of the extreme left.

Potvin describes his reaction to seeing over 2,000 innocent civilians die in the World Trade Centre attacks (at the time the toll was thought to be over 10,000)

“When I saw the first tower cascade down into that enormous plume of dust and paper, there was a little voice inside me that said, ‘Yeah!’ When the second tower came down the same way, that little voice said, ‘Beautiful!’ When the visage of the Pentagon appeared on the TV with a gaping and smoking hole in its side, that little voice had nearly taken me over, and I felt an urge to pump my fist in the air,” wrote Potvin.

And then he defends the terrorists in the uK:

“The London subway bombings were not cowardly, despicable and unspeakable acts; they were acts of war, and civilians for a century have been regarded as legitimate targets in war, even if our own warriors won’t admit it….Terrorists…are defending themselves from cultural genocide. We would do no less, and in fact, we do no less.”

Potvin incidentally now thinks 911 wasn’t done by the terrorists, but by the US Government. Quack. Quack.

Oh yes Potvin also finds more in common with the terrorists:

“When we fight to remove Coke machines from our elementary schools, to filter pornographic web sites from our public library computers, to restrict admittance to excessively violent films in our theatres, and to ban cigarette and alcohol advertising from cultural and public events, we are totally of like mind and purpose with the core of Islamist terrorist cells.”

Hmmn which party in NZ wants to remove coke machines and ban cigarette and alcohol advertising?