Ontario to vote on adopting MMP

Ontario, Canada’s largest province, is going to have a referendum on whether to move from FPP to MMP for their provincial elections.

Their version of MMP will have a 3% threshold, a Parliament of 119 with 70 electorates and 29 list seats.

The decision to have a referendum wasn’t made in secret by the Government but by a an independent assembly of 102 citizens who were chosen randomly to study the electoral system.

As a constitutional amendment, it will need more than a bare majority to pass. Overall it needs at least a 60% vote in favour, plus it needs at leats 64 of the 103 ridings to vote in favour (by a basic majority).

COG on enforcing the Rules

The Coalition for Open Government has two very good posts on the need to enforce the electoral rules. They point out there are currently four bodies involved in electoral issues:

* The Electoral Commission (registers parties, allocates broadcasting funds, receives donation and expenditure returns)

* The Chief Electoral Office (conducts elections a division of the Ministry of Justice)

* The Electoral Enrolment Office (enrols voters, and is a division of New Zealand Post)

* The Police (responsible for investigating and prosecuting breaches of electoral law).

The COG say the system is almost designed so there is no one body responsible, and call for one integrated electoral agency. I strongly support that. The Electoral Commission should be given total responsibility for elections (as they have an independent board) and also the power to prosecute directly. The Police have shown what I can only call incompetence in electoral matters.

The COG states:

The evidence was clear – it doesn’t add anything now to speculate whom – but someone in the Labour Party (perhaps more than one) should have been convicted of a corrupt practice and probably have been sent to prison for their overspending, and someone in the National Party should have faced that $100,000 fine for their broadcasting cap breach.

Labour’s breach of the spending cap was not accidental (an illegal act) but deliberate (a corrupt act). It is not hyperbole to say a prison term was warranted for those responsible. they ignored the law, and lied to the Chief Electoral Office with impunity. The non prosecution of National was almost as baffling. National actually effectively pleaded guilty. They admitted what had happened, and accepted responsibility for it. A prosecution would have been a slam dunk.

In their second post, the COG turn to penalties. Here I am very much in agreement also:

The current penalties are laughable; the Government’s proposed increases aren’t much better – what use is a new $40,000 fine for party secretaries (up from $20,000) when it’s introduced in the same law that gives some parties $3m+ each electoral cycle?

COG proposes that parties as well as individuals should be liable for prosecution. This is essential so it avoids the situation where no prosecution occurs because the law breach can’t be traced to a particular individual.

The penalties need to go up a lot – not maximum fines of $40,000 like the Government has proposed, but for corrupt practices, fines for political parties and corporations of $1,000,000. And for individuals of up to 7 years’ imprisonment and/or fines of $100,000.

You can get 7 years’ prison for stealing a car (or indeed anything over $1000) and stealing an election is at least as serious. 7 years is also the penalty for corruption as an MP, fraud/deception, and perjury – offences analogous to many of the crimes the Electoral Act deems “corrupt practices”.

One can argue about the exact amounts, but to my mind COG is clearly in the right ballpark of being high enough to be a disincentive, while the Government’s proposed levels are far too low. One has to ask the Government why they will not bring in harsh penalties for electoral law breaches – is it so they can break the law again if they get desperate again?

Ding dong the fix is dead

Dr Cullen has confirmed today that their proposed taxpayer funding of political parties is dead (not buried though) as it does not have the numbers. Good. The amount of money they were trying to legislate to themselves was obscene.

The way the Government has handled this whole issue has been so bad, you really have to wonder if they are really really stupid or just really really suffering from third term arrogance. I don’t think they are stupid. The mistakes they made:

* Trying to jack up the numbers in private, rather than have a public debate
* Trying to legislate for state funding, while they are still yet to pay back the $800,000 they woe the taxpayer
* Proposing that all activity in election year by opposition and third parties be capped raising huge freedom of speech issues
* Allowing the proposals to leak out day by day in the media, rather than release a discussion paper
* Having changes which so blatantly favour Labour at the expense of National, they look like they are trying to rig the game
* Barely increasing the penalties for over-spending

I am not the only one critical. Read this post (and comments) from No Right Turn:

Theodore Roosevelt once referred to the US Presidency as a bully pulpit – by which he meant a superb platform from which to advocate for an agenda. Within New Zealand, holding the government benches is the best bully pulpit you can get. When a Minister says something, the media listen. The requirement for balance means they will seek out alternative views, but the government’s position will be reported, allowing the public to assess it on its own merits. Labour is systematically wasting this opportunity – and in doing so pissing away one of their biggest advantages. I don’t know whether it is stupidity, or the hubris of seven and a half years in office in an MMP environment which has led them to draw the conclusion that everything can be dealt with by negotiating with other parties, and that the wider public don’t matter – but either way if they don’t start actually talking to us and trying to persuade us of their programme (to the extent that they actually have one), they will receive – and deserve – a good kicking at the next election.

The Role of Government

A post by Lindsay Mitchell led me to this survey by Massey University of 2,250 people on what they think the role of Government should be.

Key results are:

* Provide health care for the sick 98%
* Provide decent standard of living for the old 96%
* Protect the Environment with laws 92%
* Provide industry with help it needs to grow 87%
* Give financial support to low income university students 79%
* Keep prices under control 78%
* Provide housing for those who need it 72%
* Reduce income inequality 50%
* Provide decent standard of living for the unemployed 49%
* Provide a job for everyone who needs one 38%

The top three are the only ones which had over 50% say the Government should definitely fo this. The next one down, relating to industry support has only 28% say definitely and 59% say probably.

And in terms of how successful the Government has been on key issues:

* Protect Environment 50%
* Fight Unemployment 50%
* Deal with security threats 50%
* Provide decent standard of living for elderly 40%
* Provide health care for the sick 37%
* Controlling crime 26%

The low scores on the last two should be of concern. On crime 42% say they have been unsucessful.

In terms of spending on areas, we have

* Health 84% want more vs 1% less
* Education 70% vs 1%
* Police 64% vs 2%
* Superannuation 51% vs 2%
* Environment 39% vs 10%
* Defence 24% vs 22%
* Arts 11% vs 41%
* Dole 6% vs 59%

Overall though they found “In general, most New Zealanders (60%) are in favour of cuts in government spending, but in specific areas there are marked differences in support for more
or less government spending.”

On tax they found that tax rates for different levels of income are:

Low income earners – 65% too high v 35% about right
Middle income earners – 70% too high, 30% about right
High income earners – 50% too high, 35% about right, 15% too low

Some nice food for thought.

The great scam

It is looking hopeful that Labour’s plan for taxpayer funding of political parties is dead for now, but as sure as the sun rises in the East, they will try again.

Now they tried to do a nice little snow job this time. They tried to tie in the unpopular policy of taxpayer funding with the popular clampdown on anonymous and trust donations. They claimed that the reduction in funding from such a clampdown would make taxpayer funding essential.

Sadly so many people took this assertion as fact. But it is a myth. In the tables below, I examine how much funding the various parties would have gained since MMP came in, under Labour’s proposed taxpayer funding formula.

Then I look at how many anonymous and trust donations there have been since 1996, and hence calculate the potential net loss or gain for each party.

statefund.JPG

This is how much each party would have received since the 1996 election, based on Labour’s proposal of an annual $2 a vote up to 20% of the vote and $1 per vote from 20% to 30%.

Note that nice Graham Capill and his party would have received over $1 million by now. Brian Tamaki would have $85,000 for new bishop’s robes, the Legalise Cannabis Party $450,000 for a series of bloody good parties and oh yes Labour would have raked in $12.5 million.

But how much money would each party have lost from tightened rules on anonymous and trust donations?

1gain.JPG

Now this is a conservative analysis in that it assumes every single dollar of anonymous and trust donations would disappear. In reality many would probably still occur, and just be disclosed. To counter that we do not yet know donation levels for post 2005.

So what does this tell us? That if we apply this proposed taxpayer funding policy retrospectively, then taxpayers would have been forced to contribute $40.5 million to political parties, just to make up for $6.0 million of foregone private donations.

This was an attempted great swindle. Labour would have gained (over four elections) $12.5 million to replace $1.8 million of lost donations. Think of all the pledge cards they could fund with that!

People may want to reflect on the selfishness of National and NZ First (and ACT and maybe United Future) in rejecting taxpayer funding even though they would have benefited massively also.

The losers would be the rank and file party members who would no longer be needed by a political party to remain viable. Plus the taxpayer who would have forked out $40.5 million against their will.

Personalised Plates

Fran and Audrey on Electoral Law Changes

Audrey Young and Fran O’Sullivan on Saturday did a nice tag team effort on the Government over their proposed electoral law rorts reforms.

Audrey writes

The one thing that can be said of Labour’s handling of the sensitive issues of election spending and election funding is that it has been consistent – consistently poor.

The process smacked of self-interest at the outset, and the result has lived up to its promise: a series of proposals affecting disclosure of donations and restrictions on spending, which in relative terms advantages Labour over National.

And Fran:

Voters beware! Helen Clark’s Labour, the party that filched $800,000 of taxpayers’ money to pay for its 2005 election campaign, is trying to orchestrate a state-funded bailout using your money.

That’s the only possible conclusion a right-thinking person could draw from the contemptible abuse of process the ruling party is demonstrating with its behind-the-scenes machinations to get state funding for political parties in place for next year’s election.

You would think Labour would have learned some lessons from its public drubbing last year. It was ultimately forced to back down and pay back the $800,000. The grubby deal it is trying to negotiate with two minor parties has outraged the public.

But if New Zealand is to examine making a substantial shift to state funding to provide a bedrock for political parties, then it should be addressed by an authority that is independent of politics. Certainly not by a partisan Justice Minister. And not through grubby inter-party negotiations that do not include the ruling party’s opponents.

Undoubtedly there are complexities. National – and Labour – have received anonymous donations. National Party president Judy Kirk concedes her party is prepared for more open donor disclosure and will also need to dismantle the trust structures which are subject to abuse.

But Labour was itself propelled into power in 1999 on the back of some $824,000 of anonymous donations. Labour argues that dismantling anonymous donations will ensure that National can’t make any cash-for-policy deals. But that simply begs the question whether Labour gave its anonymous donors anything in return for their support.

The foreign-donor clampdown preserves Labour’s practice of hitting up businessmen like Owen Glenn, an expat who has not lived here for decades, for $500,000 donations. But it outlaws part-time residents, such as US businessman Julian Robertson, from contributing to National.

The third-party spending clampdown is aimed at the Exclusive Brethren. But it tramples our rights to free speech.

Labour wants the election campaign period backdated because National got its witty billboards up well before the last election. Such a clampdown will, however, give Labour an extraordinary opportunity to boost its policy profile by ramping up Government advertising while critics suffer in silence.

Free speech – but only for some

No Right Turn is normally a great champion of free speech. But I was somewhat alarmed to read his attack on the NZ Herald because its editorial lambasted the Government for slowness on climate change policy, while it also ran a column by Garth George which was highly sceptical that climate change was man made.

This is in fact exactly how a newspaper should work. The editorial line of the newspaper should not be used to filter out opinions the editor does not agree with. Garth George is a weekly regular columnist who writes on any topic he wishes. The notion that the Editor should ban his columns whenever they are on a topic the Editor disagrees with, is not what I call free speech.

It is also alarming that No Right Turn compares climate change scepticism to holocaust denial. The latter is a historical fact. The former is a scientific theory. Now I personally accept the consensus opinion that greenhouse gases are playing a major role in global warming, but the day we do not allow scientists to dissent from their peers, is a sad one for free speech and for science.

Incidentally, accepting the consensus position on the occurrence of climate change, does not mean accepting every daft proposal people come up with to deal with it, such as the Kyoto Protocol which could cost hundreds of billions of dollars and only reduce average global temperatures by 0.07 of a degree by 2050. I don’t dispute the science – I dispute the economics.

Benefit Numbers

The number of people on working-age benefits are down significantly since 1999, and it is churlish to not give the Govt credit for its role in having had the economic growth which has led to the fall in the number of unemployed. Unemployment has in fact been reducing since 1991, apart from during the Asian Crisis in 1997/98.

Against the fall in unemployment, has been a 46% increase in sickness beneficiaries since 1999 and a 47% increase in invalids beneficiaries.

Also remember when the PM promised a crackdown on “clusters” of beneficiary households such as the Kahuis? It turns out no work has been done at all in this area.

Also Lindsay Mitchell points out some (not all) of the decrease in benefit numbers has come about through “Where a beneficiary has moved from, for example, the DPB onto an In Work payment, with no change in working hours, they cease being a beneficiary”

Jordan Carter has a useful thread seeking ideas on how to stop the increase in sickness and invalids benefit.

But one thing I have to query is the assumption put forward by both Jordan and the Government that “an ageing population generates more sick and invalid people”. I dispute that is the reason. We are aging because people are living longer. Certainly in one’s final years you will have more sick and invalid people, but these benefits only apply up until 65, when super kicks in. One could argue a population living longer means there will be less people sick and invalid between the ages of 15 and 64.

Virtual Super 14 Week 11

An okay week. I got five out of six games called for the right team, but only three margins were correct. A total 34/48 points. I think almost everyone was surprised by the Sharks beating the Blues. Maybe they shouldn’t rest so many players!

I am now on 298 points and moved up 3,118 places to 27,299 out of 155,497, so in the top 20%. The top players globally are on 365.

In the NZ Bloggers challenge I am 23rd out of 90. Mark Montgomerie leads on 337 and Brian Burgess 2nd on 332. Span is top female on 305 in 16th place.

Oh and talking of sport, a nice win this morning to the Black Caps.

Borders Wellington

I am enjoying having Borders in Wellington. The book collection is nowhere near as large as Auckland, but it is significantly more than Dymocks and Whitcoulls.

In my first foray I picked up four books. One book was on Hitler, and is the translation of secret briefings to Stalin from two of Hitler’s close military aides, whom were captured at the end of the war. It provides one of the most detailed accounts of Hitler we have.

Also picked up a nice biography of Cicero. Cicero was pretty much the only man to lead the Roman Republic who wasn’t from a noble family or was a great general. He got there on the strength of his political, legal and oratory skills alone. Oh plus no-one was too keen on his opponents in the year he stood.

Also got the Constant Princess, a fictional account of Katherine of Aragorn – the first wife of Henry VIII, and previously wife of his older brother.

And another fictional book called Empire of Dragons – about some Romans who end up in the Chinese Empire around 300 AD.

I can see my monthly book spend only going up thanks to Borders. Oh yes plus of course I have pre-ordered my copy of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows.

Alleged rape victim charged with making a false complaint

Oh dear. Have just heard that the women who claims someone pretending to be a police officer raped her, has been charged with making a false complaint, and has been referred to mental health professionals.

She has needlessly terrified a lot of women in and around Papakura. And sadly she adds to the climate of doubt around genuine rape complaints.

I hope she gets the help she needs. But I also hope she does get sanctioned by the court. At least her false complaint was a general one, which isn’t as bad as a false complaint of rape against an actual individual (which can destroy their life).

The riding crop case

One of the cases which has sparked calls for changes to Section 59 was the Timaru mother who was acquitted of assaulting her son with a riding crop, after a jury trial. She has put out a You Tube video defending her actions, despite appearing in court a second time for a new charge of alleged assault.

Now some people think those of us who advocate for the Borrows amendment would find the above troubling to our cause. Not at all. The Borrows amendment would categorically have stopped there being an acquittal in the first case. To quote from it:

59(2) The use of force for a purpose specified in any of paragraphs (a) to (e) of subsection (1) is unreasonable if-
(b) it causes or contributes materially to harm that is more than transitory and trifling; or
(c) any weapon, tool, or other implement is used; or
(d) it is inflicted by any means that is cruel, degrading or terrifying

Now this mother asserts her right to use a riding crop and a cane to discipline her son. Regardless of whether or not you agree with her, it is crystal clear that under the Borrows amendment such behaviour would be illegal. There would be no possible defence in court.

Now here is the irony. Under the current Bradford/Clark bill, the mother might still get found not guilty. Because the current bill does not define reasonable force or rule out specifics such as using a weapon, tool or implement. It does ban the use of force for the purpose of correction, but the force used against her son was after he allegedly assaulted or threatened her husband.

Now if we go to the Bradford/Clark bill, they allow defences of:

59(1) Every parent of a child and every person in the place of a parent of the child is justified in using force if the force used is reasonable in the circumstances and is for the purpose of—
‘‘(a) preventing or minimising harm to the child or another person; or
‘‘(b) preventing the child from engaging or continuing to engage in conduct that amounts to a criminal offence; or
‘‘(c) preventing the child from engaging or continuing to engage in offensive or disruptive behaviour; or
‘‘(d) performing the normal daily tasks that are incidental to good care and parenting.

Now the mother would have a arguable defence under paragraphs (a), (b) and (c). She can argue her action was necessary to prevent harm to another person, to stop the son from engaging in criminal assault and to prevent the son from being offensive and disruptive.

Now who knows how a jury would rule, but the case is certainly arguable.

So let us be clear about this. Under the Borrows amendment, the actions in the Timaru case would absolutely be forbidden. Without the Borrows amendment, they might still be found to be legal under the Bradford/Clark bill.

Easter Photos

A few photos from Easter weekend, just to prove I wasn’t inside blogging the whole time.

easter1.JPG

How did the Salient Editor get into that shot? And who is the mystery woman who admitted to a bunch of Labour activists she likes John Key?

easter3.JPG

Really no caption is necessary. And that is her being subdued!

easter5.JPG

Pazmiewazmie and me. I’m the one on the left 🙂

easter6.JPG

No we didn’t get so drunk that there was a snap wedding. These people were doing their wedding photos up at the Massey Memorial

easter7.JPG

The view from Massey Memorial. Not bad for halfway through Autumn.

easter8.JPG

The backseat of my car!

easter9.JPG

If you look closely you can see the “SLUTI” stamp from the bar the night before.

easter10.JPG

The view from the Brooklyn wind turbine.

easter11.JPG

Back at the girls’ flat. I love the makeshift table.

easter12.JPG

Our vegetarian feast, all prepared by Alex.

Thanks to G-Girl for the photos.

Exchange Rate

usrate.JPG

The graph above shows the monthly average exchange rate, according to Reserve Bank data. We are at a post-float all-time high.

Great for those travelling overseas and for the price of imported goods. Not so good for the export sector.

SST on taxpayer funding of parties

To no one’s surprise the SST editorial endorses, well absolutely everything the Govt is proposing. It doesn’t even criticise the process, which even the Greens have condemned.

However the SST should stick to areas they know something about – like how the SIS bugged the Maori Party. Oh wait, perhaps not that. Let’s take a few of their points:

The limit of $5000 on anonymous donations would staunch the flow of politically laundered cash. In fact, the cap should be lower to stop wealthy donors splitting their investment into small packages to flout the law.

The SST obviously has not read the law which makes it clear it is the total amount donated over a calendar year. So it is not possible to get around the cap by splitting the donation up.

And the spending limit of $60,000 by third parties is entirely reasonable, and probably too high

The SST thinks a $60,000 cap over up to eleven months is probably too high!!!!

It is worth remembering that the less money political parties and third parties are allowed to spend, the more powerful the role of the media are in deciding elections.

The result of these and other changes would be to drastically reduce the amount of money available to political parties

I will have a blog post on this point tomorrow morning. I bet you the SST haven’t actually checked out the facts behind this assertion.

The fact that a few thousand dollars of state funding might go to fringe and fanatical parties should bother no one. The Libertarianz will never get anywhere, even if the state throws them a small bone.

Again the SST has not done their research when they claim fringe parties will only get a small bone. I’ll reveal tomorrow just what impacts there will be under Labour’s proposal. I predict people will be surprised.

Field’s new party

The SST reports that Taito Phillip Field is set to launch a new party within a month – a family values party.

I can think of other possibilities for him:
* The property owners party
* The no minimum wage party
* The immigration assistance party
* The Thai tilers party

A headline which needs a comma

Which version do you believe?

David Newell claims the following:

* making a quick trip to his local Pt Chevalier shops to buy nappies for his three-year-old daughter
* stopped by one officer and the civilian observer in a marked patrol car on Great North Rd – one male and a female, later joined by two more officers – also male and female
* claims he had had half a glass of beer at lunch but nothing that evening
* claimed that the male officer asked him where he was from, to which he replied north London in the UK. The officer, who had an English accent, told him: “we used to deal with you people all the time,” a reference, Newell said, to the colour of his skin.
* claims the police officer with the English accent “whipped down” his pyjama pants, exposing his private parts to the other officers.
* claims the officers were all giggling and making jokes related to black men and the size of his penis, according to his affidavit. He said he was also called a “black ****”.
* claims he was asked to undergo a breath screening test and despite two attempts he claimed police were unable to obtain a reading.
* claims, he was hit in the face by the officer with the English accent and called “a monkey”. That officer, he said, refused to accept his word he did not have a criminal record, saying “all you people (black people) have convictions”.
* claims he had been happy to undergo a blood test but had wanted to go home after the ordeal

The Police version, backed by three officers and a civilian observer, is very different:

* claims Newell allegedly clocked at 107km/h in a 50km/h zone
* claims Newell said his mother-in-law was a High Court judge and he was a Kenyan diplomat
* claims Newell pulled down his pyjama pants in front of the three officers and civilian observer
* claims Newell, was then told to pull his pants up before being handcuffed and put into the back of the police car.
* claims Newell had been taken to Balmoral Police Station and had chosen not to engage the services of the duty solicitor, preferring instead to call his partner
* Newell was then charged with refusing to supply a blood sample

William and Kate split

Well the bookies will be pleased and not paying out on any of the bets as to when Prince William and Kate Miiddleton will be married, as they have split up.

On the plus side millions of girls can dream again of their chance to snare William.

The Sun (of course) has fuller details.

Now that is utu

I blogged a few weeks back about how the incredibly petty behaviour of the Florida State University Professors in refusing a honorary degree to former Governor Jeb Bush was so bad, the Student Senate voted unanimously to honour him for his contributions to the university.

I remind people that Jeb Bush, unlike his brother, retired with huge approval ratings for his two terms as Florida Governor. Anyway back to the story …

A committee of the Florida Parliament has amended an education bill to rename the University of Florida’s education school as the “Jeb Bush College of Education.

That is effing hilarious. I can just see some of the Professors near suicidal with grief. The resolution even requires them to erect “suitable markers” noting the college’s new name and include the revised name in all university documents.

In theory I don’t approve of legislators doing stunts like this, but in this particular case it is so delicious that I love it.

Various

Morph alerts us to the varisty.co.nz feature on the best student pranks of all time.

They remind me of our plan in 1989 in Dunedin to win the capping stunt competition by kidnapping PM David Lange who was down there for a public lecture. Lange’s office were keen on the idea, as was Lange we were told, but then they had scheduling problems which meant there would be no time for the stunt. We were going to burst in with water pistols at the end of the lecture and kidnap him, but alas it never happened.

Bonnie and Clyde has a disturbing series of photos, called the Cult of Farrar.

Michael Earley blogs about a woman who offered to sleep with anyone who would donate her 5,000 World of Warcraft gold. I don’t do WoW so not sure how much time it would take to get that much gold, but I suspect there were quite a few contenders. The young lady boasts she is a level 70 night elf druid and perfers someone with a costume.

Martha is proudly showing off her undies in the Dominion Post.

Russel Norman blogs that no one should own a car worth $109,000 and they should buy a cheaper car and donate the money saved to Oxfam. Very amusing, as I can think of one Green MP who has a very expensive BMW.

Zen Tiger does a wonderful translation of Chris Trotter’s column. Very good work. He also reminds us of Trotter’s column in favour of corruption:

“Social peace for a paltry half-million dollars? Strikes me as the most courageous and forgivable kind of corruption.”

Courageous corruption indeed.

Eye to Eye on Corrections

Despite the Government refusing to participate (which speaks volumes in itself), there was a great discussion on Eye to Eye re Corrections. Ron Mark, Hone Harewira, Matt Robson and teh Head of the Corrections Union.

Hone made a great point about how there was a capable Maori manager of Auckland Remand Prison, and how “Robson’s mob” booted him out by cancelling the private management contract, and “everything has gone straight back down the toilet again”.

Ron Mark weighed in how the ACRP, when privately run, had brilliant results, and we have lost great prison managers to Australia.

There is so much corruption in the public prison service, yet they shut down the non corrupt privately managed prison by passing a special law to stop the contract being renewed.

DPF on TV

Been interviewed today for two different stories.

TV One Business is doing a story on how people are turning to the Internet rather than travel agents to do their travel, and I provided comments on the benefits of doing it over the Internet. This will play some stage during the week.

TV Three are doing a story on the riding crop woman who put her story onto Youtube, and about to do an interview with them for tonight’s news. We’ll be talking about the pros and cons of using You Tube to get your message across.

Also after the Easter break, back on TV One on Monday for the politics panel on Good Morning. Will be a bit earlier this week – around 11.10 am.

And as always on with Larry Williams on NewstalkZB at 6.30 pm on Tuesdays.

Agenda 14 April

A discussion on electoral funding with Labour, Greens, ACT and United Future.

Greens want a cap on donations but Govt not proposing this (due to their $500,000 foreign donor).

It seems (sadly) that the Police will remain the prosecuting authority.

Rodney Hide did a great attack on the secret nature of the process to date – labelled it a jackup of the rules to favour Labour. NZ should be debating the trade-offs like freedom of speech, he said.

Burton seemed to back away from state funding, saying it is less important than having a fair and transparent system. Burton also denies any connection to the pledge card issue (someone tell Chris Trotter that).

Hide was in excellent form on how Labour is trying to build a 61 vote coalition in private, so it can pass the law regardless of what the public says. Also made the point how state funding will entrench existing parties.

Gordon Copeland proposed that only natural persons be allowed to donate to a party – unions and companies would be banned from doing so. If that happened they would donate to lobby groups instead I am sure.

David Beatson attacked the process, as being framed by the Government, not some public body. Russel Norman agreed with him.

I’d call Rodney the best performer. Russel Norman was very strong also. And Mark Burton – well, what can one say.

Agenda TV will have a transcript later today.