Labour’s plan to stifle criticism breach the Bill of Rights

Labour plans to dramatically curtail the ability of both the Opposition and third parties to criticise the Government – not just for the 90 days before an election, but for all of election year.

One will need a free speech permit in election year, by registering with the Electoral Commission if you plan to spend money to advocate against the Government. And you can spend only $60,000 over up to eleven months.

So it is no surprise that the NZ Herald learns that Crown Law has advised the proposals breach freedom of expression protections in the Bill of Rights. I’d say they do not so much breach them as destroy them.

The concept of a limit for third parties is not without merit. But the notion that such limit applies for an entire year rather than just the immediate pre-election period is repulsive. And the limit is far too low at $60,000. The important thing is to require far better disclosure so people know who is behind a campaign (which is what the Brethren did wrong) – but again this must be for the immediate pre-election period, not all communications in election year.

Quote of the Week

Mr English described the Exclusive Brethren this week as “people whose stupidity is beyond estimation”.

– Source: NZ Herald

I’ve been waiting for someone to say it. Well done Bill.

I look forward to the conspiracy theorists alleging that Bill is actually secretly in bed with the Exclusive Brethren, and that this is all staged.

Bazley Investigated

The NZ Herald has a nice scoop about how someone hired private investigators to dig up dirt on Dame Margaret Bazley.

Ha – they wasted their money. Dame Margaret has had a reputation for being straighter than straight. The worse they could find was a not particularly desirable ex-husband – but they divorced in 1978!

Dancing With The Stars Review

Cactus Kate has written what is the best review around of Dancing With the Stars.

Kate already has a fortnightly column with the Dominion Post, but really she should be appearing more often. The Herald should enter into a bidding war with Fairfax for exclusive rights for a daily column.

Also read her post about how lawyers need to be harder. Superb.

Heidi Wishart being stalked

Trotter admits taxpayer funding of parties needed so Labour can (ironically) pay back the taxpayer

Lucyna has done us a big favour (please forgive her Fairfax) by retyping in the Chris Trotter column from today’s Dom Post. Go read it.

State funding has become a matter of necessity for the Labour Party because of the unprecedented and massive political fines levied on it by the auditor-general in 2006.

Trotter admits Labour need state funding because of the Auditor-General requiring them to repay the $800,000 of taxpayer funds illegally funded by the Parliamentary Labour Party (taxpayer). Talk about robbing Paul to pay Peter. And remember they haven’t yet paid it back.

They will also note the arbitrary character of the decision to restrict his investigation to printed material distributed in the final three months of the 2005 election campaign (thus excluding National’s billboards)

Trotter again attacks the Auditor-General, comparing him to Sir John Kerr. But Chris misses a big point above. National’s red and blue billboards were 100% funded by the National Party, not the taxpayer. The AG could have gone further back then three months and it would not have affected the billboards because they were not taxpayer funded.

Go read the whole column. It is almost as good as the one in which Trotter said Labour were justified in breaking the law, so long as it stopped National winning the election.

NBR dignoses compulsive comment disorder

An article in today’s NBR talks about blogs. Some of the amusing quotes are below, and the full article over the break for those interested (hoping NBR won’t object to the publicity)

Stumbling across David Farrar’s blog on Monday, Scribbler was stunned by the amount of writing he had done and the range of subjects he had covered over the weekend.

I type fast and think faster 🙂

Reading it, though, was rather like watching television news in the company of someone suffering from compulsive comment disorder.

Ha. Try going to a movie with me.

Nothing crosses Farrar’s borders without getting a thorough going over. Foolish attempts to smuggle politically correct or even vaguely leftish opinions are exposed under his relentless scrutiny and paraded for all to see.

I think that is the nicest thing said about me yet in NBR!

While you and I were out and about enjoying the sunniest Easter weekend in living memory, they [me and Russell] stayed inside huddled over their keyboards, blogging flat out to keep their output of commentary, opinion and insight up to the speed of incoming commentary, opinion and insight on their screens.

Actually if they had read my blog closer they would have discovered I spent Good Friday up north with friends, having an outdoor lunch and wine. I spent Easter Saturday in Featherston playing with siege engines, Saturday evening out partying until 2 am, and Easter Day, went driving with new found friends around Wellington scenic spots, and then dinner with them.

So my 30 posts over Easter did not deprive me of enjoying the sun. I had a great time. I just blogged when most people are sleeping!
Continue reading »

Weird

A Syrian sports team has pulled out of a international tennis tournament in Christchurch due to concerns about their security.

It reminds me of that old joke about what is happening when the best rapper in the world is white, and the best golfer is black.

Now we have middle eastern teams worried about the danger of coming to NZ!

NZ Herald supports abolition of sedition law

The NZ Herald has backed calls to abolish the sedition law. Good. Extracts:

Sedition is not at all common and is largely irrelevant to people’s daily lives. Yet it is a charge which is misused on occasion and represents an overly broad, worrying threat to one of our most basic rights, the freedom of expression.

The Law Commission’s final report … saying the provisions are overly broad. “They infringe on the principle of freedom of expression and have the potential for abuse, a potential that has been realised in some periods of our history, when these offences have been used to stifle or punish political speech.” It goes on to observe that in a democracy it is hard to see how or why speech uttered against the government should be a crime. And it says that other parts of the Crimes Act deal adequately with inciting violence, rioting and willing insurrection.

We have a largely open society, but it is one in which threats to freedom of expression and the freedom of the press regularly arise. The Law Commission’s clear and forceful report is a welcome support for free speech. It usefully quotes English writer and thinker John Milton from a speech in 1644: “Give me the liberty to know, to utter and to argue freely according to conscience above all liberties … Let [truth] and falsehood grapple; whoever knew truth put to the worse in a free and open encounter.”

Bainimarama sacks Great Council of Chiefs

This is interesting. The Dictator has sacked the entire Great Council of Chiefs and has cut off its funding. That is because they wouldn’t be poodles and appoint his nominee as Vice-President.

Now I’m no great fan of the GCC being a undemocratic itself, but hey so was the House of Lords and they often did some useful stuff.

I can’t see anyway Bainimarama will ever hand over power, as he is dismantling the institutions of state – the Parliament, the independent judiciary and now the GCC.

Isn’t the charter working well?

TVNZ have an impossible task – to be both a commercial broadcaster and a public service broadcaster. The TVNZ Charter has confused the company. And this is not just my opinion but also what former CEO Ian Fraser who was a charter supporter.

So the massive slashing of news and current affairs jobs at TVNZ, is not so much the fault of the company, but the Govt.

The charter is a disaster. 99% of NZers couldn’t tell you what programmes are or are not charter programmes to save their life.

Sell off TV2 and make TV One a public service broadcaster. Or sell them both off. But the status quo is not working.

Soaked

Wellington’s long summer may be over – is now pouring down. Sadly for me it wasn’t raining when I walked to the gym this morning at 8 am. But when I left at 9 am it was bucketing down and even in the short distance home, I got soaked to the bone – not a spot of dry cloth left on me.

Days like today, a spa bath would be nice!

Spending and Votes

In its jihad against voluntary private funding of political parties (so it can then claim the taxpayer has to be forced to fund parties instead), Labour and others would have you believe that how much money a party spends correlates to how many votes they get. Indeed someone on my blog has proclaimed the US elections are always won by the candidate who raised the most money.

Bryce Edwards correctly blogs that money is no guarantee of political success. Of course it helps to varying degrees but it is far from decisive. Edwards quotes from an Economist article about US elections:

Money is not a guarantee of success nor is lack of it a guarantee of failure. Phil Gramm and Steve Forbes have both proved that truckloads of money do not necessarily translate into political momentum. And Bill Clinton proved that you can win the presidency without being the big money candidate. Howard Dean has gone one better and proved both that you can succeed without money and fail with it. He came from nowhere to dominate the money primary in 2004. But his $40m treasure chest did not prevent him from imploding during the Iowa primaries

Now I thought it would be interesting to look at what linkages there are between campaign spending and votes in NZ, for the four MMP elections we have had.

1996.JPG

The expenditure comes from the Electoral Commission and includes both the broadcasting allocation and the direct party expenditure. So what do we see:

NZ First and Labour spent almost the same amount, yet Labour got twice the votes. ACT almost spent the same as National, yet got one sixth the number of votes. The Alliance spent half of what ACT did and got almost twice the votes.

Labour in 1996 had the best return in terms of votes for dollars.

1999.JPG

National spent over 50% more than Labour in 1999, yet lost the election by around 10%. Labour got a vote for every $2.05 and National every $4.36.

2002.JPG

In 2002 Labour spent more than National by around 25% yet got around twice as many votes. ACT spent more money than National, yet got one third the number of votes.

The Greens got the same votes as ACT for under half the spent. NZ First got 50% more votes than both Greens and ACT despite spending 60% and 25% respectively of what they did.

2005.JPG

Finally we have 2005. Note Labour for two elections in a row have had a higher total spend than National. This time they spent around 30% or $950,000 more than National yet got only 2% more. ACT spent twice as much as NZ First for one quarter the votes. The Greens spent more than NZ First yet got less votes.Of the parties that made Parliament the spend per vote ranged from $3.40 to $34.00.

So while there is a case for overall spending limits, any nonsense about buying elections is just that – nonsense. The last four elections stand testament to this. The impact of money on elections is relatively insignificant compared to policies, party reputation, leadership and media treatment.

So why do parties spent money? Well obviously it has some impact. But more importantly it is the *only* way parties can communicate directly to the public on the issues they choose in the manner they decide. The more you restrict the ability of parties to do this, the more power you give to the media, and especially the press gallery, to control what the public hear.

The proposal by Labour to restrict what both political parties, and third parties, can say not just immediately prior to an election, but for up to an entire 11 months prior is a blight on free speech and is more about silencing criticism than any notion of fairness, or stopping elections being decided by money. The public have shown for all four MMP elections that they do not largely decide their votes based on campaign advertising – such advertising is merely one aspect of a campaign.

More Section 59 debate

Tony Milne has done a constructive response to my latest post (which was deliberately non inflammatory) on the Section 59 debate.

I’ll deal with a couple of Tony’s points and then go back to what I think is the crux of the debate:

The Bradford Bill does make it clear that in the course of everyday parenting smacking is permitted. And if that wording isn’t quite adequate, why don’t they improve it, rather than vote it down?

The Borrows amendment is exactly that – an improvement to the Bradford bill. If it got adopted, I suspect the bill would pass with over 110 votes in favour. The problem with the bill as currently worded is it permits smacking for some situations, but not for others. It allows you to smack to stop a child being publicly disruptive, but not to smack for coerrective reasons if they are privately disruptive at home. We’ll come back to this point.

PS: David, you have called me a ‘ranter’ for saying those opposed to repeal of section 59 are ‘pro violence’. I’ll happily retract, if you apologise for the weeks of calling me and others “anti-smackers”. I’m not sure why you think it is fair to spend weeks branding people who disagree with you things they don’t believe while taking offense (indeed labelling as ranting) at me calling the pro-smacking camp pro-violence.

I think most people would say it is more offensive to be labelled pro-violence than it is to be labelled as anti-smacking. And the problem is many of the opponents of the Borrows amendment are anti smacking. Not all, but many are. I’m happy to accept Tony’s assurance that he doesn’t think smacking should be banned for correctional purposes.

For all of those in the comments sections suggestion I shouldn’t have a view on this debate because I don’t have children – I assume you are going to immediately go to David Farrar’s site and disagree with his view and tell him it isn’t valid for the same reason.

I absolutely agree that trying to deny someone a voice because they do not have children themselves is silly. Having said that, I do think actual parental experience can be a valid issue in some situations. As sympathetic as I am towards couples who have kids, I don’t know first hand just how stressful it is to constantly be looking after a child, minimising harm, helping educate them etc. Being an uncle isn’t the same. I often stand in awe of the sacrifices parents make for their children. That’s one reason I don’t think we should second guess how they raise their kids, unless they are clearly failing in protecting and educating them.

But anyway back to the crux of the issue with regards to the Borrows amendment, and why Clark and Bradford and co reject it. They claim they only want to target the most serious abuse cases which are getting off in the courts (which average one very two years incidentally) and that parents who lightly smack their children for correctional purposes won’t have to worry about prosecution because Police will use common sense.

But, and this is the big but, why then did they feel the need to insert legislative defences for the use of force, or smacking, when it is being done to prevent harm or prevent disruption? I mean by the same logic, the Police would use common sense and not prosecute?

Parents feel this bill is MPs telling them how to raise their children. And they are in fact right. Because Bradford and Clark have a bill which says we approve of you smacking your children for the purposes of preventing harm or preventing disruption (and will give specific legislative protection to you) but we do not approve of you smacking your children for correctional purposes, so we will not give you any protection for that.

This is extremely judgemental. This is effectively a ban on smacking for correctional purposes. Because otherwise why do they just rely on the common sense of the Police for all cases of smacking?

Personally I trust the vast majority of parents to judge the context correctly of whether they think smacking is appropriate. I don’t think parents need MPs to tell them we approve of you smacking your child for this purpose, but we do not approve for this other purpose.

The original unamended Bradford bill was defensible. It had the advantage of being able to send a very clear message that the law does not allow any force against children. It would have left all complaints of force to the discretion of the Police and maybe the courts (and CYFS). I can understand that rationale, even if not overly convinced by it.

But the bill as amended is actually less defensible. If the MPs supporting it really believed that one can trust the Police to use discretion sensibly, then they would not need the four exemptions they have placed in. They should argue that the Police would never charge you for smacking your child to stop him running onto the street in front of a car. But by putting these defences in for minimising harm, preventing a criminal offence, preventing offensive/disruptive behaviour and “good care and parenting” yet explicitly rejecting it for “the purpose of correction”, they are being totally inconsistent.

So it is hard not to conclude that the intent is to ban smacking for correctional purposes, if one votes against the Borrows amendment. Because if you really believed in leaving it to the discretion of the police, you would not have the other four defences. You would just remove Section 59 entirely.

Young Labour Elections

Young Labour hold their AGM this weekend, and specifically elections for their senior roles. Princes Street Labour has put up candidates for three of the four positions, which it seems has upset other branches at this Auckland takeover. So while details are sketchy, there could be a number of hotly contested positions.

The ‘anointed’ candidates are:

President: Meg Bates (Auckland)
Vice-President: Sonny Thomas
Secretary: David Do (Auckland)
Treasurer: Glen Riddell (Auckland)
NZ Council Rep: Unknown

I’m a huge advocate of young people getting involved in politics, regardless of party, so congratulations to everyone who is willing to stand.

In regards to the presidency, I do wonder at the conflict of interest caused by having a youth section president who is employed directly by the Prime Minister. I’m not picking on Ms Bates who I have never met. In fact if she has managed to get employed by the PM in her electorate, she is probably highly intelligent, politically astute and very well organised – all good qualities for a youth leader in politics.

But if Young Labour wants to take a different view on an issue to the Government, it will be pretty hard to do so, when your President works for the PM. That’s potentially a huge loss of independence. And youth sections should have some independence.

Now I’m not just saying that because this is Young Labour, and I want them to attack the Government. My comments equally apply to Young Nationals. In fact over the years I have berated various YN Chairs that they are too compliant to the senior party and the caucus. Yes, even when I worked in the PM’s Office, I still encouraged the Young Nats to take an independent policy line. When Don Brash ordered the YNs take the Darth Vader joke of Helen off their website, I told the YN Chair they should have refused (in fact I suggested they put up a second cartoon of Don as Han Solo kissing Princess Leia) as the party leader is not an officer of the young nationals.

When I talk about youth sections being independent, I don’t mean that they should attack their own party, MPs or Govt (if in power) in inflammatory terms. That is just stupid and a cheap easy headline. I mean they should push policies their party has not yet signed up to. They should campaign for things they believe in, even if not the same as the rest of the party.

I recall two such instances from when I was YN National Secretary. The YN Exec, led by Shane Frith, signed off on a policy paper called six steps to freedom. it advocated 1) VSM, 2) Repeal Shop Trading Hours, 3) Voluntary Euthanasia, 4) Legalise Prostitution, 5) Decriminalise Cannabis, 6) Lower Drinking Age to 18. Now Mr Bolger was the PM, and as a good Catholic was not exactly rushing to implement our agenda. In fact his office banned us from having it included in the conference pack for national conference. So what did we do? We just went in before breakfast and stuck a copy on all 800 chairs! Caused a great stink.

Now if one of us was working for the PM, I doubt we could have done that act of defiance.

Another instance was when the YN Conference voted to sell off all public hospitals (the rationale being that the state would still fund public health services, but who owns the hospitals didn’t matter). Now this pissed off the entire health sector. We got condemned by the Opposition (who accused us of being a front for the Government’s secret plans to do this), by the doctors, the nurses, the unions, the assn of public hospitals and even the assn of private hospitals (they didn’t want the competition) and of course the Minister (Shipley) and the Under-Secretary (English) – both whom ironically I went on to work for. It’s fair to say the MPs were not that happy with us, but we have a genuine belief this would be a good policy, so we advocated it.

So my genuine advice to Young Labour, regardless of who is elected, is not to be poodles. Again I don’t mean attack the Government. I mean advocate things they may not want to do. If you think benefit rates should be lifted, then say so. If you think NZ should be non-aligned, then say so. If you think there should be no business tax cuts, then say so.

At the end of the day, if a youth section doesn’t have different views on issues to the main party, then they lose much of the rationale for being a separate section.

Hilarious

From the NZ Herald:

“Mr Burton said he wanted to reassure …. that we would never put forward proposal giving preferential treatment to any particular group.”

Tell me when to stop laughing. This is the same Government that made it illegal to enter into a collective employment contract unless you joined a union.

As Russel Norman says, it would have been better if it [Labour] had established a commission last year. The way Labour are going about these law changes reeks of utu and partisan gain.

All Labour should be doing at this stage is seeking an assurance that a majority in Parliament would send the electoral act amendment bill to select committee, so that it can be considered on its merits.

But Labour are trying to stitch up a deal in private, so that regardless of what the public say, there is a majority in Parliament to not just refer the bill to select committee, but pass it into law afterwards.

The proposed law changes are looking even more draconian and partisan, the more detail that comes out. They propose to extend the period covered by spending restrictions from 90 days to eleven months. That is a attack on freedom of speech like we have never seen. It will deny the Opposition the chance to campaign effectively against bills in Parliament. It will see the $60,000 limit on third parties apply for not just the 90 days before the election, but for all of election year.

And is the Government planning to halt the tens of millions of taxpayer dollars they spend on “government information” campaigns for all of election year? You bet they are not.

And it is an effective unprecedented lowering of the amount candidates can spent, which is already an incredibly low $20,000 or 50c/voter. At present in tightly contested seats, one starts spending soon after a candidate is selected to try and increase name awareness. Over the year one might spent $50,000 of which $20,000 is within the last 90 days. They are now making this $20,000 over eleven months. This would make it almost impossible for new candidates to challenge sitting MPs.

These proposed law changes are downright dangerous. Restrictions on freedom of speech should be minimal, but here Labour wants to shut up its critics for the entire fucking election year. Yes one year out of every three, you will be prevented from spending too much money attacking Government actions.

NZ Herald Editorial on Climate Change

The NZ Herald has harsh words on the Government’s actions on climate change:

The Government’s response to climate change is not just feeble, it is in disarray.

Public opinion appears to have settled on an acceptance that global warming is as serious as the IPCC keeps saying and that something must be done before it gets much worse.

Yet all we have received from the Government is a Minister for Climate Change, and all we hear from the minister, David Parker, are timeless assurances that polices are being developed and announcements can be expected, perhaps by the end of the year.

If the Government finds global warming too hard to handle, it should have the honesty to say so and end the uncertainty facing investment in carbon-emitting activities and alternatives.

10 days to go

Only ten days to go until the first round of the French Presidential Election. No matter who wins, it will be a significant break from the past where Mitterrand and Chirac have been involved in politics since the 5th Republic was founded, The new President will be a new man (or woman).

I blogged on the polls last week, and noted Sarkozy had led in the last 45 polls. A correspondent made the very good point to me that Le Pen should not be written off as historically people don’t admit to pollsters they will vote for him,but do. So some of those Sarkozy voters may vote Le Pen. I doubt Sarkozy is as vulnerable to this as Chirac was though.

So to recap there are four main candidates:

Nicolas Sarkozy, Union for a Popular Movement (right)
Ségolène Royal, Socialist Party (left)
François Bayrou, Union for French Democracy (centre)
Jean-Marie Le Pen, National Front, (far right)

This gives six possible combinations for the run-off. As I make no claim to be an expert on French politics, I’ll risk predictions and probability for each scenario .:

Sarkozy/Royal – 65%
Sarkozy/Bayrou – 24%
Sarkozy/Le Pen – 3%
Royal/Bayrou – 5%
Royal/Le Pen – 2%
Bayrou/Le Pen – 1%

And for each scenario, what is the likely outcome in the run-off:

Sarkozy/Royal – Sarkozy wins by 2% to 6%
Sarkozy/Bayrou – Bayrou wins by 4% to 8%
Sarkozy/Le Pen – 3% – Sarkozy wins by more than 55%
Royal/Bayrou – 5% – Bayrou wins by over 10%
Royal/Le Pen – 2% – Royal wins by more than 40%
Bayrou/Le Pen – 1% – Bayrou wins by more than 50%

It will be interesting to see if the polls change in the next week, and more so if they prove more accurate than in 2002.

Out of the Red

Interested Aucklanders may want to take note.

The launch of the audio book of Richard Prebble’s “Out of The Red”.is on Sunday.

It’s at 2.30pm, Sunday 15 April at Mecca Cafe, corner Nuffield St and Remuera Rd, Newmarket. It costs $16.00 which includes non alcoholic beverage, light sandwiches and cake.

You must RSVP today. A cash bar available.

More details with Gooner.

Wellingtonista Bowling League

The Wellingtonista have arranged a bowling league at The Lanes. Once a month on Tuesday. Teams of four.

My love of ten pin bowling is only matched by my lack of ability at it, so I’m not quite so masochistic enough to sign up for monthly humiliation, but if there;s any people out there who know how to avoid the gutters, go organise a team. Doesn’t have to be bloggers and blog readers. Can make it a work team, a group of friends etc.

Register your team here in the comments at the Wellingtonista, or email the.wellingonista @ gmail.com before next Wednesday 18.

The Chaser Strikes Again

I give Kiwis a bad name!

Claire Swinney thinks I give Kiwis a bad name because I am part of the conspiracy covering up how the Sep 11 attacks were actually staged by the US Government.

Please do go and read what she says. No charge for the enjoyment.

Here’s some of my favourite quotes:

In a shameless and crude attempt to shield the public from the facts surrounding government-sponsored terror, DPF, as he refers to himself, dishes out lies, like a trainee chef at a provincial polytechnic.

Oh, not just any polytechnic, but a provincial polytechnic. Just so long as it isn’t Wanganui!

This puerile content is essentially comprised of techniques one would expect to find in a beginners’ guide to disinformation from a CIA handbook for the paid-off media.

Actually my CIA disinformation handbook is getting out of date. Could Claire send me the latest copy. Oh and General Hayden, you’re getting tardy with the payments. And remember to make them in Euros so it doesn’t look suspicious.

There are so many whistleblowers and so much hard scientific evidence that’s freely available to demonstrate that 9/11 was the work of criminal elements in the US government, that Farrar is as conspicuous as a streaker at a rugby game as a propagandist –nothing more, nothing less

I am sure I speak for everyone when I say the words “Farrar” and “streaker” should not be used in the same sentence.

NZ Herald Editorial on Taxpayer Funding of Parties

Before I move onto the editorial, I want to make the point that people should regard with disquiet that the Govt is leaking over multiple days aspects of the Electoral Act changes. I am no political virgin – leaking govt policies and proposals is commonplace and fine. But the Electoral Act is a constitutional foundation of New Zealand. The entire way Labour is going about their proposed changes reeks of grubby political gain at the expense of New Zealanders having a fully informed debate on the rules that politicians and parties have to obey. It’s fine for most areas of Government, but not for the Electoral Act.

Now extracts from the Editorial:

The Labour Party has not learned very much from its public lashing last year over election spending. It seems still to regard its misuse of public finance as a disagreement over rules, which it hopes now to resolve once and for all with legislation permitting more state funding of political parties. Its plans, disclosed by the Herald this week, are those of a governing party looking to secure its future while it has the chance.

Indeed.

State funding can have an effect as unhealthy as secret slush funds and more far-reaching. State funding tends to entrench existing parties. Under Labour’s proposed formula, it and National would split the lion’s share of campaign finance and smaller parties would be awarded scraps. That would be so even if a major party’s support was to collapse between elections as Labour’s did in 1987-90 and National’s in 1999-2002.

This is a point Hooton made on radio. Take Labour from 1987 to 1990. They collapsed under a morass of infighting and what was seen as betrayal of their core principles. New Labour was the benficiary. But with state funding as pproposed by Labour, they would have received just as much money in 1990 as in 1987, and New Labour would have got nothing.

Likewise National lost a lot of support in 1991 and NZ First benefited in 1993. State funding would have seen National rewarded in 1993 despite it loss of support and NZ First get nothing.

State funding protects political parties from their own unpopularity.

Some political arrangements are too elemental to be decided by political parties. State funding of elections, disclosure of private contributions and restrictions on who may advertise in election campaigns are among them. Political parties are prone to believing their organisational interest is identical to the public interest. It is not. The public interest lies in ensuring elections can be contested as openly, intensely and freely as possible by people with their feet on the ground. It does no harm that they have to pass their hat around.

There is an irony that because Labour broke the electoral law last election with their $800,000 overspending, they are arguably now in a position to change the law to reward them for doing so.

Domainz

Computerworld has an article on Domainz, and how it is promoting its expanded services. They mention that Domainz turns 10 this month.

I take a degree of personal pride in seeing Domainz celebrate its 10th birthday, as I was very involved with its sale.

Domainz was set up by my predecessors at InternetNZ to take over running the .nz registrer from Waikato University. Cutting a long story short, it was then decided in 2000 that the functions of Domainz should be split into two parts – one company running the .nz register as a shared registration system, and another to be a Registrar which would be opened to competition.

NZRS was set up to become the new registry, and it has operated the register since October 2002. I’m one of five Directors of NZRS.

ISPs and others were allowed to bulk transfer their customers away from Domainz over the next year, to reduce Domainz’s market share from 100% to a competitive level. Once the market was deemed competitive, InternetNZ wanted to sell Domainz as it would be a conflict of interest to be the market regulator, own the registry and also own one of the competitive registrars. If only the Govt would adopt the same principles!

Now selling a commercial companny isn’t something InternetNZ, or myself, had a lot of experience with. We were fortunate we managed to hire a first class expert in this area, and we eventually asked for bids from interested parties to buy Domainz.

Now we had seen some scenarios that said Domainz couldn’t possibly survive as a stand alone Registrar and would not attract any significant bids for it. So we had a background of a very uncertain future for Domainz, as it was unknown how many customers would leave it.

There were around 13 bids which was superb. Now those without a commercial background may think this is all simple. You just go for the highest bid. If only. You see each bid was for different things. One or two wanted to buy the company whole. Another wanted just the assets. Some wanted the residual cash, some did not. One just wanted the names in the database. Some wanted to merge with their business. Others wanted to keep it separate as a going concern. Some wanted the tax imputation credits preserved, others didn’t value these.

I couldn’t make a decision based on the 13 bids, as they were so different. So I spent many hours with spreadsheets trying to analyse each bid in terms of total gain to InternetNZ. It turned out that the expert liked my analysis so much, that it became the official basis for comparison and decision making. I was pretty thrilled with that, as this was a new area for me.

We decided on a preferred bidder. Now again as a novice you may think that’s the end of the process. You just accept their bid. The hard work was still to come. As due diligence continued the negotiations over the actual sale deed were ferocious and complex. Australian companies especially are quite ruthless in their approach, and while we ended up all on good terms, there were some very tense moments incuding negotiations at 4 am in the morning with myself and two others in the Domainz CEO’s office reviewing the latest accounts and final valuations. The approval meetings were scheduled for 10 am and we only decided at 5 am that we would recommend we proceed.

Even after the sale was formally agreed to, there was ongoing negotiations over certain values and valuations. I became one of around six people in NZ I suggest who is now an expert on how you value prepayments for domain names. The entire sale process ended up taking up around two years, as one can file against the funds held in trust for 18 months after sale.

So having been so involved in the decision to split from the registry, and so involved in its sale, I retain a certain pride that the company is still doing well today, especially as at one stage many thought it would not survive.

It also gave me some very valuable commercial experience. It’s not often you get involved with a company sale, unless you are a lawyer or accountant. It remains one of the most intellectually challenging things I have been involved with.

2007 Netguide Awards

wa07_votenow.jpg

I’m repeating a post from a month ago, as the Netguide Awards close on the 15th.

I want people to vote for Kiwiblog so I can have a reason to go up to Auckland for the Netguide Awards and drinks lots of champagne. Oh also because I’ve made around 2,500 posts in the last year to keep you all amused or enraged or both.

So here are the very simple voting instructions:

1) Register with Netguide here (takes ten seconds)

2) Login to Netguide here

3) Go to the awards page here

4) The very top category is Best Blog. Type or copy in “https://www.kiwiblog.co.nz”

5) Click Submit Vote, immediately below the comments box for that category

6) Vote in any other category you so wish

This takes you around 60 seconds all up. Simple.