Second Preferences

A recent poll in the UK asked people who their second choice would be. It’s one of those silly hypothethical questions, because there are always mainstream parties on the right and left to choose from. Some Tories were understandably upset to see that 12% of their voters said the BNP would be their second choice.

If I had to rank the parties in the NZ Parliament in terms of personal preference, the ranking would be:

1 National
2 ACT
3 United Future
4 NZ First (without Winston)
5 Labour
6 Maori
7 Greens
8 NZ First (with Winston
9 Progressive

David Russell retires

Waa waa waa waa waa

The Bazley Report

The Bazley Report is out, and can be viewed here.

The early focus will be on the numbers – 313 complaints of sexual assault against 222 police officers from 1979 to 2005. Of those 313, 141 were thought to have enough evidence to lead to charges or internal discipline.

While in no way mitigating that there has been some disgraceful behaviour, it is only fair to look at the fact that over that 27 year period there were probably 20,000 police officers or so.

Bazley finds no organised coverup, but many officers condoning or turning a blind eye to sexual activity of an inappropriate nature, protection of those officers complained about; negative, stereotyped view of complainants, and a culture of scepticism in dealing with complaints of sexual assault.

Also there were no polices or procedures to deal with such complaints against colleagues, and no guidelines on appropriate sexual behaviour – especially in terms of using their position to secure sexual favours.

There are 60 recommendations in all.

John Key has pointed out that sadly the Police may not be getting it. To quote him:

The police response to the comprehensive Commission of Inquiry into Police Conduct is of deep concern, says National Party Leader John Key.

“Police Minister Annette King should be as concerned as I am at Police Commissioner Howard Broad’s written response which states: ‘the report does not point to systemic failings with police policy, procedures, standards, training or behaviour’.

“That flies in the face of the Dame Margaret’s press release which states that ‘the good work done by many investigating officers, particularly in the past 15 years, has been placed in jeopardy by systemic flaws that need attention…’

“Just as worrying is Dame Margaret’s comments that she is concerned the police impetus for change may not be sustained once the Commission has reported.

Burton given 26 year non parole period

Graeme Burton has been given periodic detention, with a minimum 26 year non parole period. This means he will be 62 years old when next eligible for release and that in theory he should only be released if he clearly do danger to the community.

His sentence is the second longest non-parole period, behind RSA triple murderer William Bell (33 years). Double murderer Bruce Howse did originally get 28 years but it was reduced to 25 on appeal.

No apologies needed

NZPA has a story on the wires, headlined:

NO APOLOGIES NEEDED, INCIDENT DEAD AND BURIED SAYS DEPUTY PM

Now anyone just looking at the headline would think that some awful slight was done to the Deputy PM, and he was being magnanimous in forgiving the incident and saying it is in the past.

But no. Unbelievably this is Michael Cullen declaring there is no need for him to apologise to journalist Nick Wang, and declaring on behalf of Mr Wang that the incident was “dead and buried”. Or as the PM would instruct – time to move on.

My God – how arrogant. Cullen publicly blamed Wang for being evicted illegally, and said he had been creating a disturbance. If it was not for the video tape, that stigma would have remained with Wang, whose only crime it seems was not to allow the Chinese Government to censor him.

It doesn’t matter that Cullen was given bad info from the Police. He could have asked questions of other journalists, he could have asked if there was pertinent information. But he chose to attack Mr Wang, and he owes him an apology, rather than declaring the issue is “dead and buried”.

Why is sorry such a foreign word?

Twins

288152.jpg

Cactus Kate blogs that she thinks the sister of Miss Universe NZ (the brunette) is hotter than Miss Universe NZ.

Now both sisters clearly fall into the “would not kick her out of bed for farting” category, but Kate may be right in that Sharaine is hotter than her sister Laural. And I say this as someone who normally prefers blondes.

So let’s have your votes – Is Sharaine (blonde) or Laural (brunette) hotter? And no jokes about wanting to try them both out to decide!

Marginalising those who disagree

Bomber at Tumeke gives us an excellent example of the tendency by some to not address arguments you disagree with, but try to paint your opponents as having impure motives, or being brought off.

The Climate Science Coalition took issue with NIWA blaming the Northland floods on global warming (an unprovable assertion).

Now Bomber in a wonderful conspiracy theory discovers that two of the twenty or so members of the CSC have both written the odd article for Tech Central Science Foundation (which has over 100 writers), and that four years ago Exxon-Mobil gave US$151,430 to TCS.

Now he demands the NZ Herald publishes this damning revelation. The very clear implication is that the CSC is in the payroll of Exxon-Mobil and you can’t trust anything they say because they are being paid to say whatever their corporate masters demand they say.

So because 10% of the members of the CSC, may have written articles which they may or not have been paid for by TCS, and because TCS has had a donation by Exxon-Mobil that may be less than 1% of their budget over the last four years, this means the CSC is in the pay of Exxon-Mobil.

Or one could just conclude that people with honestly held views sceptical of the AGM theories, write for organisations that share those views.

This is not to say the the CSC is right or wrong with the scepticism. But trying to close down debate by alleging that scepticism is due to funding from big oil, is not the way to go.

By that rationale we should not listen to a single word Labour says on employment law, because they are part funded by the Unions.

A letter to the editor

Dear Mr Farrar,

I noted today that you stated on one of your blogs, which from a cursory glance can be best described as propaganda for the New World Order, that I claimed the twin towers were brought down by “Dubbya’s brother” as you put it. No I did not, as I’m sure you knew. Rather, I wrote the well known fact that Marvin P.Bush, the president’s younger brother, was a principal in a company called Securacom that provided security for the World Trade Center and I speculated that this would have enabled demolition charges to have been laid without incident.

Clare Swinney

Hey I never knew I worked the New World Order. They must be the ones responsible for the large donations into my bank account.

As it happens Clare has the wrong person. It was a commenter called Dave who made the comment in this thread.

According to Not PC, Clare thinks:

It’s common knowledge that Al Qaeda is the product of elements of the US Admin, bent on a one world government – or as Bush Senior termed, the New World Order…

Hey so I am linked to Al Qaeda. I want a website to prove it- say dpf.aq

More damage from the Police sex scandals

Apart from all the other damage done by the Police behaviour in the1980s, it almost led to the movie “Big Boob Lesbian Cops II” being banned. The SPCS tried to get it banned on the grounds it advocates behaviour such as that complained about.

The Chief Censor rejected this though, noting that apart from anything else, there were no men in the film!! He also notes that while yes they are dressed in police uniforms, these are “quickly disgregarded”

I wonder if the SPCS watched the entire movie before complaining about it? Do they watch all the movies they complain about? If so, they must get to watch lots and lots of porn!

National’s testing policy

John Key announced yesterday that National would bring in three things for primary and intermediate schools:

1) Clear National Standards
2) Effective Assessment
3) Upfront Reporting

There is no bigger tragedy if a kid can not read, write and count, and you only discover this at secondary school – it is far too late by then.

We don’t actually even know how many kids leave primary school without being able to read, write or do maths. Yes, there is no national standard and reporting to measure against.

There is a handy Q&A on the policy. It stresses this is not national testing against one test. Schools will be able to choose which assessment method is best for their school, but they will be benchmarked against a national standard.

John Armstrong comments that for John Key to succeed with support for this policy, he needs to make the case that that “testing of primary school children is not only in parents’ interests, it is also in the national interest”.

The Principals’ Federation has attacked the plan, because it worries it would pit school against school. Oh yes we can’t let parents know how well a school is doing can we. The ERO has found that 49 per cent of schools did not use the results of assessment to raise performance or inform parents.

The NZ Herald editorial quite strongly supports the plan, and usefully reminds us that Labour a decade ago proposed similar testing, but dropped it in the face of union opposition.

Colin James on the carbon plan

Colin James has (as expected) a thoughtful piece on the Government’s carbon plans.

First he notes that poorer families benefit most from having cheap (but fuel-inefficent) cars. Will Labour price such cars beyond the reach of low income families? Will carbon neutrality be worth it?

Secondly one needs to do more than plant trees. Will Labour amend the RMA to fast track renewable electricity generation?

Overall James say that the key question is whether Clark will risk the unpopularity of increased costs and regulations, for the ability to say they are on track for carbon neutrality.

NZ Herald on South Park

Govt fails to make anti smacking bill a Govt bill

The PM has announced that the anti smacking bill will not become a Govt Bill. She claims that NZ First were happy for this to happen, but I doubt this because the official explanation given doesn’t add up.

Clark claims it was unlikely to be able to be passed into law before Easter, even as a Government bill. But this is not the case. The Government has almost no bills on the order paper and could make this the first priority. On Tuesday they could 5.5 hours of debate and on Wednesday 4.5 hours. That is 9 hours to finish committee stage which is more than enough. You could then do third reading on Thursday which is a two hour debate and there are three hours available.

They’re tried to ram it through under urgency and failed. They’ve tried to make it a Government bill and failed. This is not a good look.

And talking of the bill, people should read this Manawatu Standard article where Police confirm that every complaint of smacking will not only be investigated by Police, but names will be passed onto CYFS. Big Brother will be watching!

Also Peter McC blogs how in the UK teachers are actually being given the power to use reasonable force to restrain unruly pupils and break up fights etc.

Crime Stats

The crime stats for 2006 are out and as usual, the news is not great. The total amount of crime has increased but that is not a useful figure anyway because it treats an under age drinking or cannabis offence as the same as a murder or rape. No one would claim that a country with 10% more rapes and 5% less under age drinking offences is getting better.

So I always look at the two most important categories – violence and sexual offences, and two or three of the more serious offences. Note population growth last year was only 1% and has been only 8% since 1999.

Violent Offences are up 5% in 2006, and have increased by 28% since 1999.

Sexual Offences are up 8% in 2006, and have increased by 17% since 1999.

Grievous Assaults are up 7% in 2006, and have increased by 65% since 1999.

Kidnappings and Abductions are up 30% in 2006, and have increased by 70% since 1999.

Sexual Attacks are up 14% in 2006, and have increased by 25% since 1999.

The Police say a new computer system has lead to some of the increase, but the trend since 1999 has been consistent – increases in the most serious categories.

Coalition for Open Government

A group of interested individuals (including former Electoral Commission CEO Paul Harris) has reformed the Coalition for Open Government, to campaign for strong new election finance laws.

I welcome such an initiative as I believe it is vital that the rewrite of our Electoral Act is not done purely by Labour and friends, to benefit them.

They are calling for five things at this point:

1. Ban anonymous donations greater than $20 and disclose any donors greater than $200 a year, stop donations via trusts or other people.

The limits are far too low but requiring an identity for donations over $100, and disclosure over $1,000 would be more reasonable. People should be able to make say a $250 donation, and not have their boss know about it. This is a real issue for civil servants.

2. Limit the size of donations to $5,000 a year, and no more than $1,000 per candidate.

Labour may not be too happy with having their $500,000 overseas donor cut off! I am not sure whether one can justify such a limit though, if anonymous donations are banned. If the identity of large donors are known, then that acts as the best safeguard against any possibility of favours for donations.

Such a limit would seriously impact parties ability to communicate with the public, and that is a vital part of informed elections. I think it is potentially undemocratic – certainly at that level.

Also one has to look at the consequences of such a low limit. The US has an even lower limit at $2,000 but they have the worst system in the world for buying influence. What happens though is the major donations go to third party groups and lobbyists which have less accountability than political parties. It’s well intentioned but the effect will be to make our system more like the US, not less.

3. Control third-party election campaigning with disclosure and spending caps

I’m in favour of this in principle (if one caps political parties, one should cap third parties) but it may be near impossible to define without infringing free speech. You would have to have the spending cap apply only to paid advertising, and not to media releases, Internet campaigns, marches.

Also it can be trivially easy to get around the spending cap by just setting up multiple groups. Here’s one example – say you have a $100,000 spending cap. Instead of having the CTU spend $250,000, you may have five unions spend $50,000 each. And there are ways to have this happen without it being collusion.

I very much support enhanced disclosure of identity though.

4. Enforce the laws effectively by having parties liable for electoral law breaches, increased penalties and wider definition of election expenses

I have advocated for over a year that parties, not just individuals, must be made liable for breaches of electoral laws and increasing the maximum penalty to $1 million for a corrupt practice or seven years jail is around what I have advocated. Labour would never have lied to and ignored the Chief Electoral Officer if the penalties were more significant for doing so.

But the Coalition loses it with their suggestion that internal expenses such as staff, research and polling be included as part of a party’s spending limit. Of course I may be seen as conflicted, but you are setting up an unworkable law where you need to decide if certain staff are strategists or not. This will lead to creative accounting 101. God I can think of 30 ways such a system would be unworkable. Do you include MPs salaries as part of campaign expenses. What if research is part policy and part political. Do you divide it per question. It would be a nightmare with no consistency and no way to fairly measure.

The Coalition ignores the public policy rationale for a spending limit. It is to stop one party dominating the communicaton channels by buying ten times as much press, direct mail, as other parties.

They also ignore that our election spending caps are ridicolously low. They come to barely $1 per voter. That is enough for two personally targeted direct mail letters at most. In fact I would argue the current spending limits are so low they prevent effective communications from the party. $20,000 to reach 40,000 voters is insanely low. What it does is mean that almost all info voters receive is based on the press gallery and media reporting of issues, rather than parties directly communicating with voters.

I would suggest a spending limit of $5 million nationally and $50,000 per electorate. There is no way that amount of money “buys” campaigns – we have seen that with results for previous elections having little resemblance to amounts spent.

I do agree with the Coalition over merging the three electoral agencies into one. I don’t know why Labour keeps refusing to do this.

5. Make all public funding of elections fairer and more transparent – linking it to a party’s popular support, and abolish the broadcasting rules.

I am in favour of parties being able to buy broadcast time on top of their allocation. I do not accept that the current Parliament has any mandate to bring in enhanced party funding for this election. The public have shown their displeasure at the improper use of taxpayer funds last election, and the public must be given a chance to approve any significant increase in taxpayer funding. This means either a referendum or a number of parties go into the election campaign promising to introduce full taxpayer funding, and if elected on the basis of an explicit polict, then they have a mandate to do so.

But what should not be tolerated is Labour and some allies, starved of funds by being unpopular, legislating to fund themselves form the taxpayer for 2008, without a voter mandate.

Anyway a long post. Well done to the Coalition for starting the debate. It is too important to leave it to the Government alone to decide.

Digital Copyright

Russell Brown has a superb blog post on the digital copyright bill before Parliament and especially the submission from the Recording Industry Association of New Zealand. Too long to try and summarise but worth the effort to read.

I appeared last week as part of the InternetNZ team, and were on just after the RIANZ. It didn’t go as well as previous submissions, and I am very worried about what the final shape of the bill will look like. I got so angry listening to the mischaracterisations of the RIANZ I threw away my prepared notes for our submission, and instead spent most of the time rebutting theirs. In hindsight that was a mistake as it allowed them to set the agenda. It was hard to get across at times that this bill is not just about the music industry, but has provisions that have alarming free speech ramifications. Also we failed to make clear that asking for ISPs not to be judge and jury on what is or is not a copyright infringement, is not the same thing as saying ISPs have no role at all to play.

I’m very sympathetic to the artists like Bic Runga who have had CD sales decline to a third, but this has happened under the current US laws anyway, so importing their laws here won’t change anything.

Breast Feeding

Ana at Spare Room blogs on this mother who doesn’t quite subscribe to the old maxim that you should only breast feed until they are old enough to talk (approximately). Veronica Robinson is still breast feeding her eight year old daughter, and breast fed the other one until she was five. She says it is their decision when to stop. The older daughter says breast milk is even better than mango, and they have different nicknames for both of her breasts.

As weird as that is, NZ has an even worse case. David Bain’s mother breast fed her kids until they were 13!!! No wonder they were so mucked up.

Beer

Another warming hypocrite

John Travolta joins Al Gore as one of a growing league of global warming hypocrites. They advocate everyone else should cut their carbon emissions, except them.

Sideswipe carries the item on Travolta urging his fans to “do their bit” while he continues to fly 30,000 miles a year in his **five** jets, emitting 100 times the carbon of an average person.

Borrows on Section 59

A good interview in the NZ Herald with Chester Borrows on the smacking debate. He makes the point he is not pro-smacking, he is just against a flawed bill. Some quotes:

“I have prosecuted people for beating their kids, I have considered section 59 and how that would apply to situations,” Mr Borrows said.

“I have probably done more to protect children in this sort of area than anyone else who is in the Parliament, and I don’t want to see it trivialised.”

Mr Borrows served as a police officer in Auckland, Wellington and Nelson, before becoming a sole charge officer in the South Taranaki town of Patea.

A crucial point in his journey to Parliament was becoming a detective and investigating a series of child abuse cases.

“That experience has been life-changing, and made me want to make things better for victims of crime.”

It has also made more hurtful the comments from some supporters of Ms Bradford’s bill that by opposing it, Mr Borrows supports the hitting and abusing of children. “I think I’ve got quite a strong understanding of the nature of abuse, how it works within the heads of victims and how it works in the heads of offenders. I don’t like that label, I don’t think that’s fair.”

Mr Borrows, a 48-year-old father of three, also resents any assumption that he supports smacking.

“I have never advocated smacking. I don’t want to be labelled the pro-smacker. What I am is the defender of parents and children. This whole debate is about whether or not parents who smack their kid should be liable for prosecution.

“It’s not about whether smacking works, and it’s not about whether good parents smack and bad parents don’t. It’s solely about whether parents who do smack their kid should be liable for prosecution.”

And that is the crux of the debate. The Borrows amendment would outlaw all those cases cited by supporters of the Bill as having escaped successful prosecution, yet provide certainty that a light smack for the purposes of correction would not leave parents at the whim of Police or CYFS.

Go Buzzy Go

Lincoln Tan on Press Freedom

Lincoln Tan writes in the NZ Herald on how proud he has been in the past of NZ’s high ranking for press freedom, but the Beehive incident involving Nick Wang blots that record:

The case could have just been between an overzealous Chinese civil servant and an inexperienced diplomatic protection squad officer had it not been for Cullen jumping to the defence of the police action and of his Chinese counterpart.

Cullen said Wang was removed because he was creating a disturbance, but video showed that nothing of that sort happened.

New Zealand’s reputation for upholding democracy and freedom of speech was also dealt a blow with Cullen’s defence of the police actions and unjustified claims that Wang had caused a disturbance.

A true friend would help steer China towards doing this, rather than do a Cullen and defend efforts to push its head further into the sand.

Green scare-mongering

Green co-leader Russel Norman breathlessly blogs that the Amundsen Sea Embayment in Antarctica is melting quicker than previously realised and “If it goes, that’s six metres of sea level rise apparently”

This is blatant scare-mongering against the accepted scientific consensus. The Greens are not the party of science, but of fear if they promote crap like this. You note there is no indication as to whether this mythical six metres of sea level rise would happen next year, or over 1,000 years.

The UN IPCC latest report paints six scenarios for sea level rise by 2099. The range for the most optimistic scenario is 18 to 38 cm. The range for the most pessimistic is 26 to 59 cm.

This is the accepted scientific consensus – a worst case scenario of 59 cm over 100 years. Not hysterical stuff about six metre rises.

Scott Watson

I’ve always thought Scott Watson was guilty of the Smart/Hope murders. I followed the trials quite closely at the time and my former boss wrote a book on the case. His view, and mine, was that Watson did it but that the Police were lucky to get a conviction.

Rodney has been reading a more recent book which asserts it was not Watson, and doesn’t think “for a second” that Watson is guilty. I found the DNA evidence along with the fact Watson scrubbed his yacht so thoroughly it was cleaner than a hospital ward the main indicators of guilt.

I also recall a documentary after the trial when someone testified that Watson once caught a dolphin or shark and cut it up and dragged it behind his boat, and when asked why he said it was to see how long it would take for sharks to completely devour a body. Not rpoof of anything and was not evidence at the trial. But fairly chilling.

So what do people think?