John Key, Drummer

Maharey vs Plunket

Russell B pointed out that I had ignored the issue which got Maharey so angry at Radio NZ. That is true – I focused on his idiocy in threatening to go to the RNZ Board instead of the BSA.

In terms of the substance of the issue, I can’t see any rational defence for Sean Plunket in asking whether the comparison to Botswana suggested racism. I’d be very annoyed if I was Maharey and would want an apology also. However I wouldn’t threaten to illegally involve the Board and I wouldn’t lose my rag in Parliament over the issue of the Minster threatening illegally to go to the Board.

Whoops

Ban sedition

The Law Commission has formally asked Parliament to repeal the sedition laws.

This is more than timely. Not only was Tim Selwyn charged with it, but get this the Police tried to charge a Dunedin bar owner with sedition over his offer of a petrol soaked couch to students. It seems the Police are now using sedition regularly.

There are many other crimes which cover actually incitement to violence etc. We do not need a general speech crime law.

The Government should act on the Law Commission’s recommendation. If they do not, it would be great to have an Opposition MP do a private members bill.

Iran to release UK sailors and marines

New Zealand Crime and Safety Survey 2006

Jordan quotes from the latest crime and safety survey by the Ministry of Justice.

People should indeed read the report. I found this data interesting:

The incidence rate per 100 households has increased from 2000 to 2005 as follows:

* Burglary from 7% to 9%
* Vehicle theft from 2% to 3%
* Thefts from Vehicles from 10% to 13%
* All household offences from 34% to 44%

And the rate per 100 adults from 2000 to 2005:

* Assaults from 12% to 17%
* Threats from 12% to 18%
* Robbery constant at 1%
* All personal offences from 30% to 42%

Now the authors say survey changes may make comparisons difficult but they did conclude that for household offences at least, the increase was statistically significant.

Another version of Steve “fuck you” Maharey

The Whale Oil version was unobtainable for a bit as someone it seems complained. It is back up now. But in case it doesn’t survive here is another version. I prefer the Whale Oil one as he has made the “fuck you” into a background track 🙂

State Funding of Political Parties

I welcomed earlier this week the formation of the COG which has put proposals together for changes to the Electoral Act. It is vital that changes are not introduced for partisan gain.

Reflecting more on the proposals, I do wonder if COG has overlooked a very basic and core principle – one I would certainly advocate. And that is that NZers should be encouraged to donate to, to join and to participate in political parties. Democracy is stronger when you have parties with active involvement from the public. Private funding of parties is not a bad thing, but in fact highly desirable. You want parties to value members and supporters. You want parties to hurt, if their members leave them.

Now this is not to say there should be no limits on levels of donations and disclosure at appropriate levels. But any restrictions should come in only when a clear case can be made that the “good” of encouraging donations is being trumped by the “bad” of disproportionate influence.

Now this leads into the story in the Dom Post today that Labour is trying to secretly get the numbers to support direct state funding of political parties (which is different to the broadcasting allocations). Now there is a debate you can have on the pros and cons of that, but there is a more fundamental issue at play.

No move to direct state funding of political parties should happen without the consent of the public. It would be outrageous and wrong to ram through a law change in advance of the next election. Having illegally had $800,000 of taxpayer funding, Labour wants to legalise such funding for future elections – before it has even paid the money back!

There are only two ways state funding of political parties should be brought in. The first is for political parties to go into the 2008 campaign with explicit policy that if elected they will vote for state funding of political parties. Then if those parties form a majority they have a mandate to do so for post 2008.

The other is a referendum.

A move to direct state funding will change the nature of our democracy and political parties for ever. There are arguments for and against. But it must not be done without a mandate.

Dom Post on Education

The Dom Post has a supportive editorial on John Key’s speech on education. Extracts:

Education is, as National Party leader John Key observes, a one-shot game for most, and it is vital to get it right, writes The Dominion Post. If children fail to learn to read adequately at primary school, they spend the rest of their lives playing a game of catch-up with the odds stacked against them. That is why his education policy release this week is welcome, both for its intent and for its moderation in pursuing that intent.

Mr Key is right not to accept the status quo. His proposal to set clear national standards in reading, writing and maths using existing tests, to give parents the right to see all assessment information and to have regular reports on their children’s progress toward meeting national standards is what should be happening in all schools anyway. There is little point in parents being told their child is a joy to teach but not that he or she is struggling with reading or mathematics.

That is what is happening too often ….

Wisely, that is not what Mr Key proposes. Instead, he is asking all schools to do what the best of them already do – test pupils using existing assessment programmes, and then use information from those tests to see how those pupils measure up against their peers nationally, and share that information with parents. That is both reasonable and sensible.

Working for Families

Phil O’Reilly of Business NZ has an excellent column on Working for Families, reminding us that the welfare payments result in high effective marginal tax rates. The effect of this is that a family with three kids on $35,000 a year has a 5% pay increase, they only end up with a 1.8% increase in the hand. In some cases with accommodation supplements the effective marginal tax rate is 90% so one could get a $10,000 pay increase and only keep $1,000 of it.

The net effect of this is a reduced incentive for productivity gains. And without productivity gains, we will continue to fall behind Australia.

Show some spine!

The Chinese Government continues to interfere in New Zealand affairs, this time by pressuring Mayors not to attend the Divine Performing Arts show, because shock horror some of the performers belong to Falun Gong.

And sure enough at least one Mayor, George Wood, has buckled and now decided not to go.

This sort of craven behaviour only encourages the Chinese Government. What they do in China is up to them, but I object to their suppression tactics being applied in NZ. What should happen when they pressure people to boycott a show, is for every Mayor to go out of their way to attend, and to make sure the press highlight the show also.

For the Chinese Government is not stupid. They have adapted to the times in certain areas. If their suppression tactics continue to backfire, they will drop or modify them. But for that to happen we need some spine.

The Baubles of Office

VUW Press launched last night their traditional post-election review book. I have all the previous ones so was delighted to be invited along. One of the chapters written by Rob Salmond and Peter Fitzjohn, was on the Battle of the Blog and I was one of those interviewed for it. The interview ironically took place in Canada. Rob was US based and I was in Canada so he crossed the border.

The book was launched by Winston Peters. I understand he accepted the invite to launch the book before they told him the title – The Baubles of Office. Winston was not overly amused and spent most of his speech attacking the cover title and the media. He did praise Jane Clifton though who wrote in the book that it was a noble sacrifice to change their position when the stability of the Government needed it. And it did give him the opportunity to repeat the maxim – never judge a book by its cover!

Lots of political types there, and quite a few POLS students. All very up on the latest US primary election positionings. Had a great chat to NZ First MP Brian Donnelly, who had a huge laugh when someone came up and asked me, but not him, to autograph their book.

I’ve read two chapters of the book already. Should keep me amused over Easter, finishing it. NZ Herald has a story on the launch here.

The Goulter Report

Former Auckland Airport CEO John Goulter has just had tabled in the House his review of how Parliament operates. This is done every three years. He proposes some radical changes.

The report is 121 pages and online here.

I have been a long-term proponent of either merging some of the parliamentary agencies together, or at least having common support areas such as in IT, HR, Security, Buildings etc. The Goukter Report makes some excellent recommendations in this area.

It was interesting to learn that there are 152 OOP offices – 104 for 69 electorate MPs, 45 for 52 List MPs and three which are shared. The report focuses a lot of improving their quality and resources, and tieing them into the main campus more.

The review also finds huge staff turnover in the parliamentary party offices (where I used to work). It was 55% on 03/04, 33% in 04/05 and 63% in 05/06.

Recommendations include:

* That security responsibility for Parliament be outsourced from The Parliamentary Service to the New Zealand Aviation Security Service. I just hope that doesn’t mean plastic knives at Bellamys!

* Enhanced support for the Information Systems and Technology Group to allow them to take on a leadership role for the campus (they are very under resourced)

* That a market review of the services and products as supplied by the caterers to Parliament be undertaken. (Bellamys is canned in the review for its quality, range service and pricing – first time visitors are always disappointed by how mundane it is)

* That MPs funding be increased with Leaders funding going from $50K + $57,176/non exec MP to $100K + $64,320 per MP, whips/research from $20K to $22K per MP, Elect MP support from $59,500 to $64,260 and List MP support from $37,900 to $40,932.

* This would see each party’s total funding change as follows:
– National up 11.0% from $6.24m to $6.93m
– Labour (incl Field) up 10.6% from $5.04m to $5.58m
– Maori Party up 17.7% from $0.60m to $0.70m
– ACT up 25.2% from $0.30m to $0.38m
– NZ First up 16.0% from $0.80m to $0.93m
– United Future up 22.6% from $0.36m to $0.44m
– Greens up 16.6% from $0.74m to $0.86m
– Progressive up 43.8% from $0.13m to $0.19m

* To improve the quality of the OOP offices, and also not to call them OOP offices anymore!

* Providing IT support to OOP offices (they are left to their own devices currently)

* To provide a third OOP staff member to Electorate MPs with an electorate larger than 20,000 sq kms.

* Trial 0800 free calling to OOP offices which cross toll areas

* To have the Parliamentary Service reformed to have a customer focus and and a Chief Executive with an advisory board for governance.

I hope Parliament looks seriously at implementing the recommendations. There is considerable room for improvement. Having said that there are some world class services provided by the Parliamentary Library, the Clerk’s office is often the model of professionalism and the security staff are great.

Parliament Register of Interests

The Clerk of the House has published the latest Register of Pecuniary Interests of Members of Parliament.

It’s 64 pages so here are some of the more interesting entries:

Jim Anderton, who set up Kiwibank in protest against foreign owned banks, is a share holder in the Commonwealth Bank of Australia. So he invests our money in Kiwibank and his own in the foreign one.

Gerry Brownlee was hosted by the International Division of the Chinese Communist Party.

Helen Clark has a townhouse in Wellington. Why? It is not listed as an investment property like her one in Rodney.

Taito Phillip Field has eight properties, and eleven sections.

Nathan Guy has a beneficial interest in seven trusts, six of them named Guy!

John Key owns a gold mine (okay, well part of one)

Winston attended the World Cup soccer final.

Eric Roy was gifted a Coopworth Ram – number 5069

Heather Roy donated her army salary to the RSA

Feeling the pressure

Labour are showing signs of feeling the pressure as they cope with scandal after scandal and a backlash against the smacking ban bill. Watch this video (thanks to Whale Oil) from Parliament today as Steve Maharey says “fuck you” to National MP Jonathan Coleman. TV isn’t allowed to play the unedited footage on air as it would breach broadcasting standards – and this is the Broadcasting Minister. Maharey claims it was a “slip of the tongue”. Yeah Right.

And last week Trevor Mallard was dispatched to the press gallery to complain to them that the gallery are not sycophantic enough biased against the Government. This did not go down well with some journalists especially as Trevor’s diplomacy saw him ending up in a heated argument (could be clearly heard in other offices) with TVNZ Political Editor Guyon Espiner. TVNZ’ was castigated for not having given the PM’s Washington trip enough positive coverage.

The PM got incredibly positive coverage of her trip. I even said on Good Morning TV that it had been very successful. God knows how positive it would need to be, to meet the Government’s requirements. They must be looking at the Chinese model of reporting with favour.

No wonder Jordan continues to make posts wailing and wailing. Can I please urge anyone out there who is a swinging voter, who is not a party loyalist, to go read the first post especially, but also the second. And also all the comments if you have time.

Fergie’s lesbian romps

Equal Opportunity Blogging

Seeing from time to time I have blogged about the odd Miss NZ or Miss Universe contestant, it is only fair I link to Cactus Kate who has blogged photos of a dozen finalists for Mr World.

I’m straight, but if I wasn’t I would agree with Kate that Mr Australia looks tops!

Analysis of Bazley Report Complaints

Peter Metcalf has done an analysis of then ten cases highlighted in the Bazley report, assessing each on a scale of 1 to 5 on:

* Likelihood of original offending
* Impact of alleged offending
* Original police handling
* Followup police handling

I haven’t read the cases myself, so can’t agree or disagree with Peter. I just thought it was an interesting analysis.

Defamation on the Web?

Wellington Urban Legends

The Wellingtonista has a list of their favourite Wellington urban legends, and the truth behind them. Never knew Wellington was big enough to have our own set. They are:

1. Liv Tyler was turned away from Motel.

2. The town belt between Oriental Parade and Palliser Rd is full of marijuana plantations.

3. Kenny could easily have got his amp back, but made more money as a “silent busker” than by actually playing.

4. Elijah Wood peed in the bucket fountain

5. Te Rauparaha used to be a regular at the Thistle Inn.

6. People honk in the Hataitai tunnel to ward off evil spirits

7. There is a tree in the Botanical Gardens where someone hung himself, and the branch has formed a noose shape.

8. A Japanese submarine entered Wellington harbour during WW2

Overseas Aid

The OECD stats on overseas aid are out, and they show NZ near the bottom. However first a couple of things to remember.

1) They only measure government aid, not total aid which is more important in my opinion.

2) They measure it as a % of GDP, rather than as a % of government spending which again IMO is more appropriate.

I would focus on two measures – govt aid as a % of govt spending and total aid as a % of GDP – that is comparing apples with apples. Also important to note that 2005 saw unusually high levels of aid due to debt writeoffs, so comparisons over time are more useful.

Total official aid in 2006 was US$116 billion which isn’t chicken feed. That’s the entire NZ economy for a year.

Having said that, I’m not against increasing our aid levels from 0.27%, so long as they are tied to good governance and democracy.

Broadcasting Minister threatens Plunket with Board complaint

Interesting story found by the NZ Herald about Broadcasting Minister Steve Maharey.

It seems Minister Maharey was upset by Sean Plunket, and when RNZ refused to give him an apology he threatened to take his complaint direct to the RNZ Board.

Now this is a no no in two ways.

The first is that complaints about Radio NZ get escalated to the BSA, not the Board, and one expects the Minister of all people to know this.

The second is the Minister is specifically forbidden by law to meddle in operational issues, so his threat to go to the board on what is an operational issue, would breach the Broadcasting Act.

Presumably one of his staff pointed this out to him, before he did follow through on his threat.

Technology Curriculum

For some time I’ve been hearing rumblings about the Government’s technology curriculum, and people have sent me extracts etc. I’ve not yet blogged on it.

But today’s announcement that the Education Forum and the PPTA (plus three other sector groups) have combined forces to call for a rethink of the proposed draft technology curriculum being developed by the Government, should highlight how bad things are for this most unlikely alliance to be happening.

They are writing to Parliament’s Education and Science Committee, asking them to investigate and review the technology curriculum.

The irony!

A 74 Indonesian man is reported to have been jailed for beating one of his 107 wives.

But here’s the irony – he beat her because he thought she was unfaithful!!

I wonder how much money you would get in NZ if you had 107 dependent wives?

Rich getting richer?

The NZ Herald has the headline that the rich are getting richer. In one sense this is true. The top 10% of NZers represent 52% of NZ’s personal wealth, up from 48% in 2001.

However this does not mean the same 10% are wealthier. It measures the top 10%, no matter who they are. And there is significant movement of people over time in terms of wealth. In fact age is a huge factor, as the median net worth of those aged 15 – 24 is $2,400 and those aged 55 to 64 is $170,000.

And I would say, that is not a bad thing. Of course those near retirement should be more wealthy than those just entering the workforce.