Hell has now frozen over …

NIMeetingPOOL_468x297.jpg

A photo and agreement one would have sworn would never happen. Ian Paisley and Gerry Adams agreeing to form a joint Government. Paisley will become First Minister of Northern Ireland and former IRA Chief of Staff Martin McGuinness will be his Deputy First Minister. Incredible. McGuiness has probably ordered Paisley assassinated at some stage in the past. They have both come a long way.

This is a very good day for the Irish. A lot of hard work ahead, but this is truly historic.

DPF at Parliament

Jordan Carter and myself are appearing before the Commerce Select Committee (in Bowen House) at 11 am on Thursday to speak to InternetNZ’s submission on the Digital Copyright Bill.

The Copyright (New Technologies and Performers’ Rights) Amendment Bill sounds a very boring piece of law, but in fact its deals with issues that affect almost every NZer. And also very much the running of the Internet and how ISPs deal with copyright issues.

The bill is well intentioned but quite seriously flawed in its current state. Obviously we are hoping the select committee will make changes to preserve the good parts, and improve the not so good parts.

The Section 59 march

I’d estimate around 500 people marching against the Bradford/Clark bill and around 30 counter protesters. Recognised a few from Young Labour in the counter march.

Lindsay Perigo was the main speaker and MC and he was in fine form against nanny state. Around six speakers in total. more than a few people winced though when Christine Rankin mentioned the PM’s lack of children. One just knows that will be the segment on the news. It was unnecessary and counter productive.

a1.JPG

The marchers starting to arrive in Parliament.

a2.JPG

All the media there loved the “Legalise Smack” sign.

a3.JPG

Young Labour changing Family First’s name to Family Fist.

a4.JPG

This sign cracked me up. One can escape hell if you hit your kids. I never realised it was so easy. I thought you had to go to church and all that, but it seems all you need to do is a bit of whacking!

a5.JPG

Two of the younger protesters.

a6.JPG

The old sickle and hammer.

a7.JPG

An MP leaves Helen in no doubt as to his views, with this sign in his office window.

a8.JPG

Even Che is against the bill!

a9.JPG

A pretty funny counter protest sign.

a10.JPG

A cute police officer. I’ll leave it to readers to work out which one I mean 🙂

Is this a grope?

0%2C%2C2007140484%2C00.jpg

The Sun has a story, plus the photo above, of Prince William posing for a photo with two girls who asked for the photo.

They are of course saying he groped her. But did he? You often when posing for photos have your hand on their side. Now HRH is shall we say well advanced, but not necessarily past the ribs so to speak.

So would you consider that a grope? Putting aside that half the population would like Prince William to do so!

Lies, damn lies and more lies

At coffee on Monday a companion observed that I appeared to be pretty heated up on the Section 59 issue. I said that yes I was, but not on the primary issue of Section 59 but because of the absolute lies being told by the Bradford bill backers.

I actually recognise that a reasonable case can be made for outright repeal of Section 59, on the grounds that a small minority of parents can not cope with subtleties such as the concept of reasonable force. If they (Clark/Bradford) were honest that this bill would now ban smacking, but that they are asking parents to accept this restriction in order to help with that small number of problem families, then you might even have got a majority of parents onside and selflessly willing to make that sacrifice for the greater good. In fact almost every person I have spoken to has said that they could be persuaded if it was framed like that.

But the proponents of this bill have lied and twisted and spun. They are the reason 85% of NZers are now against this bill. It has been a catalog of political incompetence. Yes the bill will probably get passed into law, but the political ill will they have generated may haunt them for some time.

So what are these lies? Let us take them in turn:

NZPA quotes Steve Maharey using the standard Labour line of:

“It simply removes the defence of a person who is facing prosecution in court for using excessive force to discipline their children,”

The Labour spin is that smacking is already illegal, and that a defence in the Crimes Act is just something you can use in court. This is with all respect absolute bullshit and we know this with common sense.

Another Crimes Act defence is the right to self-defence. Now does Labour claim that it is illegal to use force to defend yourself in self-defence? Of course not. Take an example. Let us say you are in town and someone pulls a knife out on you and your girlfriend. He goes to stab you. You whack him in arm and he drops the knife. You have just saved your life, and maybe your girlfriend’s.

Now according to the Labour lies, you have just committed a crime, and that your right of self defence is something you will have to use in court. This is obviously not the case, Crown Law will not prosecute you, the Police will not charge you – because you have not broken the law. A defence under the Crimes Act means your actions are not illegal. So for Labour to claim smacking is already illegal, means you accept that defending yourself from a knife wielding maniac is also illegal. They can not have it both ways.

The second lie is that this is all about bating and thrashing, to quote Helen Clark in the Herald:

Helen Clark yesterday said some bill opponents were “demanding the right to be able to thrash and beat children”

This ignores that almost all opponents will be satisfied if the Borrows amendment is passed. And it is hysterical nonsense to claim that such an amendment allows any thrashing or beating. It sets the bar very low as only trifling or transitory. The more they try to demonise those who disagree with them as being “child beaters”, the more you piss off 85% of NZers.

Even if one does not like the exact wording of the Borrows amendment, the Government ignores the question of why it simply doesn’t pass a law saying you can not beat or thrash children, but a light smack is okay for correctional purposes. One can only conclude because they do in fact want to ban smacking, but don’t want to admit it.

Then we have the lies and spin over whether the Bradford bill repeals Section 59. It does not (her original bill did). The bill amends Section 59 to remove one defence and insert around four new ones.

Amazingly Tony Milne is arguing that this is a repeal. This I am afraid is a clear example of Labour tactics of arguing semantics over substance.

Let’s take Tony’s argument seriously for a second, that replacing one set of words with another is a repeal rather than an amendment. Let’s say a future Government removes the current definition of murder, and replaces it with a new definition which allows for three degrees of murder (like in the US). Well by Tony’s logic such a Government has repealed murder as a crime!!!

This is where all the Government arguments fall short. They argue legal semantics instead of common sense. They argue it does not ban smacking when it does. They then argue smacking has been illegal for 100 years when it clearly has not. They argue an amendment is a repeal. It’s just an insult to people’s intelligence, and is why 85% of NZers are now against the bill.

The Government is in fact having a false debate. They are arguing the merits of a total repeal of Section 59 vs the status quo. What is on the table is whether or not to vote for the Borrows amendment which will in fact drastically lower the level of force deemed reasonable and allow smacking for correctional purposes, on top of the four other grounds now listed in the Bradford bill.

The Government still appears desperate to get this through Parliament as quickly as possible. Having failed to ram it through under urgency, the signs now are they may make it an official Government bill (which at least would be more honest) so it can progress more speedily. It will be interesting to see if they finish committee stage today.

Shipton sex video to be banned?

In a somewhat weird move, the SPCS has asked the Chief Censor to classify, and preferably ban as objectionable, the Brad Shipton sex tapes.

As presumably only “Mary” has a copy, it seems a waste of time trying to have a private video classified. I mean imagine if everyone started sending in their private sex tapes to the poor Censor’s office asking for a classification?

In fact as SPCS doesn’t have a copy of the Shipton tape, they can’t get it classified I would have thought.

House affordability

Ouch. The latest figures show that if on the average income, 75% of your take home pay would need to go on mortgage repayments. The recommended level is 40%.

I purchased in 2001, luckily before some of the big increases. To pay it off early I’ve been contributing well over half my take home pay. I am looking forward to an increase in my standard of living when it is all finished!

In Auckland it is even worse. There on average you need to out 93% of your after tax income into the mortgage. And in Queenstown it is 105%.

The report calls for a big increase in the housing supply as the only way to fix the problem.

Well done Madam Speaker

While the Government has been defending the eviction of a press gallery journalist from covering Chinese officials, the Speaker has stepped in and is usefully cutting through the spin.

Dr Cullen claimed that the journalist was at fault and was removed because he caused a disturbance. But footage shows he was evicted on instructions from a Chinese official.

The Speaker has said the incident disturbs her, and she will write to the Chinese Government to make it clear they can not be selective with media in attendance, and she will also meet the Police Commissioner to make sure they follow her instructions on press gallery accreditation and attendance, not a foreign Government’s.

This is good, and this should be the last time such an incident occurs.

DPF now weekly on TV also

On top of my weekly slot with Larry Williams on Newstalk ZB every Tuesday (6.30 pm), I was thrilled to accept today an invitation to join Barry Soper and Jane Clifton every Monday on TV One at 11.30 am (part of the Good Morning show) to discuss politics.

The only downside is having makeup applied every week!

Incidentally, this week I did finally strike an issue on which I resisted the invitation to comment (never happened before I think!). NZPA asked me if I wanted to comment (in my InternetNZ role) on the DIA profile of the typical child pornography trader being an Auckland Pakeha, aged in his early 30s, who is a student or working in the IT industry.

There are some issues you really don’t want to be quoted as an industry expert on!

March Day

Caption Contest

“child beaters”

If one refers to those against the Clark/Bradford smacking ban as “child-beaters”, does that mean you believe 85% of New Zealanders are child beaters?

Also do people not realise that Sue Bradford’s bill no longer repeals Section 59? It in fact retains it, enlarges the number of grounds on which you can use reasonable force, yet removes it for correctional purposes only.

So the entire website linked to is ir-relevant and fraudulent. It is asking people to support a bill which will not do what they claim – it will not repeal section 59.

Green policy on carbon credits and debits

The Greens have released a policy on carbon, and my first reaction was that it didn’t seem too unreasonable.

Don’t get me wrong. It is still lacking even a basic cost benefit analysis. It targets reducing emissions without looking at other approaches. And it wants to use the money from carbon taxes to give back to low income families so they are not affected by fuel price increases (which partly defeats the point of any price increase which is to reduce demand). It is far from ideal. It puts the emphasis on Kyoto, which is in fact close to being an official failure.

But the target of a global integrated carbon trading system is good, They also recognise that forest owners should receive some benefits from the carbon they store. And their approach with agriculture seems moderate.

The Dom Post reports both Labour and National say there is some common ground with what the Greens propose. A multi-partisan approach is desirable.

No Right Turn has doubts over the policy though – especially the lack of a full international carbon market.

I would be interested to see some modelling of the policy – specifically what reduction in carbon emissions are expected under this policy, and what impact that will have on the average global temperature.

Former crown prosecutor on Section 59

Michele WIlkinson-Smith writes on Section 59 in the NZ Herald. She is a lawyer who has prosecuted and defended child abuse cases. She knows what she is talking about. Some extracts:

I say the repeal of section 59 is unnecessary because in my experience it is just that – unnecessary. I never lost a case which I prosecuted on the basis of section 59.

I drafted an indictment against a man who was convicted of smacking his 4-year-old son about five times on the backside with an open hand, leaving marks.

I think the jury convicted because the man smacked his boy too hard and because the boy was smacked not for a deliberate misdemeanour but because he soiled himself.

I prosecuted a man, a loving father, for using a belt on his mildly intellectually handicapped and very challenging teenage daughter after she damaged her bedroom.The jury were hugely sympathetic to the father but when I asked them in closing if they would not have intervened to stop the man had they been in the room at the time I knew they would find him guilty.

Of course there will be the occasional case where section 59 has excused parents who overstepped the mark, but these are not cases where a child has been thrashed or beaten or injured. I challenge anyone to find a case where section 59 has excused a real bashing that left a child injured.

Sue Bradford doesn’t trust the New Zealand public so I find it amazing that she has so much faith in both the police and the justice system.

She is proposing to give a huge amount of discretion to individual police officers.

She expects them to wisely ignore the letter of the law. They won’t. I know this and so does National MP Chester Borrows, with whom I worked and who was a superb, wise and compassionate detective sergeant.

The police may not, and I’m sure will not, prosecute every case of smacking, but they will be obliged to at least investigate – and therein is the harm. Picture this: a child at the centre of a custody battle comes back from an access visit. Mum questions the child: Did Daddy smack you? Has Daddy ever smacked you? The child says yes.

Mum takes the child to the police station. She is vocal and upset. “Investigate” sounds benign. It is not.

That child will be put through the evidential interview process. It’s not a process you want your child involved in. Dad will be asked to go to the police station to make a statement.

All this will probably be good for lawyers. Probably no charges will be laid, but the child and the family will have been through a traumatic and damaging experience.

The Government should forget party politics on this one. We are lucky to have an experienced former police officer, who also has a law degree, sitting in the House. He is saying, for many different reasons, don’t give the police this much discretion. He’s right, and we should listen to him.

Electoral Act fiddling

Bryce Edwards blogs on how Labour is doing secret deals over changes to the Electoral Act.

The Electoral Act is part of our constitution. It sets out the basic rules parties and candidates must operate under. Any attempt to ream through partisan change secretly agreed to by a few select parties should be met with massive resistance.

The suspicion is that having been caught illegally spending taxpayer money last election, they will seek to legalise it for this election by bringing in direct party funding, despite having no public mandate for it.

There are a lot of necessary changes to the Electoral Act. The fact only individuals not parties can be prosecuted needs to be remedied. The maximum fine has to increase from $4,000 to probably $1 million or so. These are issues hopefully all parties can agree on.

But we should be very very wary of these secret negotiations whose prime motivation is to change the electoral laws to benefit themselves. Any major partisan change should be an election commitment, so a mandate is gained for it.

Inappropriate

I was very vocal with my disapproval when the CYFS Watch blog published posts describing how someone wanted Sue Bradford assaulted.

By the same measure Jeremy Greenbrook-Held does himself a disservice when referring to NZ First Party President Dail Jones, he says “in fact, I can understand where Ambrose Tindall was coming from when he stabbed Jones with a screwdriver in 1980”.

Tindall, who was obsessed about a $15 traffic ticket, stabbed the then MP Jones in the chest, puncturing one of his lungs. It could easily have been fatal.

Jeremy’s empathising with the man who stabbed Jones is inappropriate to put it mildly. Especially considering the senior post he is about to step into.

George W Bush is a smart man

No that’s not (necessarily) my opinion, but the opinion of Helen Clark, nicely recorded for posterity’s sake by Whale Oil.

So no more portraying him as a dumb Texan people – Helen has spoken – he is both a smart man and a clever man.

To be fair, she may have been comparing him to her Caucus 🙂

Chinese Government tries to censor local press again

One has little choice but to engage constructively with the Chinese Government. Apart from their size and power, they are a step above the former USSR in that their ambitions don’t stretch to a global empire etc.

But the incident yesterday in Wellington is a timely reminder that they are fundamentally an intolerant Government. They refused to take part in an official signing ceremony because they objected to a local Chinese journalist – an accredited member of the press gallery. Bad enough they suppress the media in their own country, but I really resent it when they try to do it here also.

The other thing i resent is their near total disregard for the truth, claiming the signing was delayed because the talks had gone on for longer than expected, when it was in fact their attempt to suppress the media. They have a culture where they are used to being able to lie, and not be held accountable for it.

So while I favour engagement and trade, we should never forget the nature of the beast we deal with.

Telecom Yellow Pages sale

Telecom looks to have got a reasonable price for its yellow pages sale – $2.24 billion.It will be interesting to see how much of that goes into capital investment – and will it be here or in Australia.

I do find it ironic that the new owner of our yellow pages business isn’t another telco or a known directory operator but instead the Ontario Teachers’ Pension Plan. Yep a group of Canadian teachers now effectively own it 🙂

Laws on Labtests debacle

Michael Laws actually makes some very valid points with regards to the Labtests debacle. To quote him in the SST:

… which was the most remarkable feature of Justice Asher’s High Court judgement last week. His clear and concise ruling condemned the three combined health boards that got it so wrong, but also, by implication, the Ministry of Health, the Crown Company Monitoring Advisory Unit and other central government monitoring agencies that let them do so.

In fact, the Nats have yet to make the proper political connections. It was the Labour government who appointed the chairpersons of all these boards. It was the Labour government who put their own flunkies on – in addition to those elected – to make sure that these kind of stuff-ups didn’t happen. And it was central government bureaucrats who were supposed to ensure nothing bad occurred on the health minister’s watch.

Third, there are too many hospitals and health boards. This is Hodgson’s greatest failure. He is intent upon preserving the status quo for political, but not health, reasons. He is wrong. There should be a maximum of eight health boards and an aggregation of public hospitals.

Finally, there are complete dunderheads running our hospitals and health boards. In part, that is because there are too many health boards. Currently we have under-qualified chief executives and senior managers who do not possess the intellectual, commercial or political acumen to make good decisions.

The elected membership of health boards is not much better. Add the government-appointed board members – with the prerequisite PC nod to women and minorities – and the wonder is that there are not more Auckland Labtests disasters. Not less.

To be fair, central government knows this. They trust district health boards like the ICC trusts Pakistani cricket. So they have appointed a galaxy of public health bureaucrats to scrutinise and second-guess every DHB initiative. The scrutiny is suffocating.

Which is why the Labtests result is so embarrassing for this Labour government. They had their pilots on the bridge. They had their appointees in the key health board positions. They approved the awarding of the contract.

Their late attempt to cast Dr Bierre as the villain of the piece won’t wash. He did what every other DHB health professional does. He protected his back. He then protected his front as well.

All while his bureaucratic monitors slept on the job. And while Auckland’s health board officials slumbered with them. Unless Pete Hodgson demands their collective heads, then the only true casualty will be the minister’s reputation as a political fixer. Because the portfolio has just fixed him.

Two polls and a back-down

First the back-down. The Government and the Greens have dropped their plans to ram the smacking ban bill through Parliament under urgency. I still expect it is likely the committee stage will be completed on Wednesday, but the third reading would not be until Wednesday 2 May.

The key though is the committee stage. Getting the Borrows, or similiar amendment passed will insert some rationality into the bill. In fact if the Borrows amendment was passed, I suspect there would be over 100 votes for the bill.

Now the two polls – both random scientific ones. The One News/Colmar Brunton poll found 83% support smacking and only 15% disagree. A Research NZ poll found 73% disagree with the bill and 72% thought it was unenforceable. The One News poll also found 78% did not think the bill would help abused children.

So this bill is massively opposed by New Zealanders, and in fact is opposed by a majority of MPs. The Borrows amendment will be defeated purely because Helen Clark will not allow Labour MPs a conscience vote on it.

For MPs like Darren Hughes and Steve Chadwick who have marginal seats, this bill may well see them lose their seats. And all because their leader won’t let them support a common sense amendment to make it clear a light smack won’t be a criminal offence.

Bill Day

Just noticed that the Dom Post last week had a cool profile of Bill Day.

Bill is one of NZ’s leading entrepreneurs and the force behind Seaworks. Also one of the nicest people you can hope to meet.

Bill’s also Vice-Chair (the other one!) of the NZ Business Roundtable. That of course makes him an evil villain to some. Bill comments:

Convinced that it is promoting the best interests of New Zealand, he says the Roundtable cops a lot of flak, but mainly because it is right. “It is easier to demonise them than argue with them. Having a reasoned debate with them is bloody hard, because their research is so good.”

We’ve just seen this of course last week with the CIS study of the extra $20 billion spending. Lots of demonising the author and publisher and next to zero actual debating the facts.

Turning in his grave?

Guess who said all the following:

17 Sep 1998 – “however one of the worst of old traditions still hanging on is abuse of urgency procedure.”

21 Dec 2001 – “Urgency should only be used for matters which are genuinely urgent, The only exception is that from time to time we have considered – and will continue to consider – approaches for extra sitting hours, and then only for one stage of a bill at a time.”

12 Jun 2002 – “We all know that urgency leads to bad legislation. It often leads to amendment bills to fix up mistakes that have happened because the original bill has been rushed through. We also know that Standing Orders exist for a reason–that is, to ensure considered passage of the law.”

20 July 2005 – “”The Greens have long stated that urgency should only be used where legislation is truly urgent.”

All that principle being washed away by the shabby little deal between Labour and Greens to try and ram the anti smacking bill through both remaining stages under urgency.

Five good and five bad for the Government

Jordan Carter has done a really good post describing five good and five bad things the Government has done. Of course I don’t agree with him on the substance, but it’s a useful balanced post.

I figured the least I could do is to do the same, and like Jordan, challenge people in comments to do otherwise.

I am going to focus on policies and management rather than behaviour and ethics (which frankly are appalling), and suggest others do the same.

I’m going to list five portfolios, and focus on good and bad in each:

Fiscal Policy

Good – running a surplus for the last seven years (the size of it is a different issue)
Bad – running the second largest surpluses in the world and refusing reductions in tax rates

Defence

Good – extra funding for the Army
Bad – reneging on the F16 purchase

Employment/Welfare

Good – historically low unemployment levels
Bad – blow out in sickness and invalids numbers

Telecommunications

Good – Operational Separation of Telecom
Bad – Not doing LLU in 2003

Health

Good – overdue pay rise for hospital nurses
Bad – ideological hostility to using private sector when it has spare capacity

I have not listed education as I am unsure if I can point to a single positive. It’s a fiasco ranging from the 20 hours policy in tatters for pre-school, the NCEA mess to all the tertiary funding scams. I don’t actually know how Maharey could make it worse if he tried. Maybe the apprenticeships one can give a positive mark to.

Anyway that is my five.

The 40 below party