Turning in his grave?

Guess who said all the following:

17 Sep 1998 – “however one of the worst of old traditions still hanging on is abuse of urgency procedure.”

21 Dec 2001 – “Urgency should only be used for matters which are genuinely urgent, The only exception is that from time to time we have considered – and will continue to consider – approaches for extra sitting hours, and then only for one stage of a bill at a time.”

12 Jun 2002 – “We all know that urgency leads to bad legislation. It often leads to amendment bills to fix up mistakes that have happened because the original bill has been rushed through. We also know that Standing Orders exist for a reason–that is, to ensure considered passage of the law.”

20 July 2005 – “”The Greens have long stated that urgency should only be used where legislation is truly urgent.”

All that principle being washed away by the shabby little deal between Labour and Greens to try and ram the anti smacking bill through both remaining stages under urgency.

Five good and five bad for the Government

Jordan Carter has done a really good post describing five good and five bad things the Government has done. Of course I don’t agree with him on the substance, but it’s a useful balanced post.

I figured the least I could do is to do the same, and like Jordan, challenge people in comments to do otherwise.

I am going to focus on policies and management rather than behaviour and ethics (which frankly are appalling), and suggest others do the same.

I’m going to list five portfolios, and focus on good and bad in each:

Fiscal Policy

Good – running a surplus for the last seven years (the size of it is a different issue)
Bad – running the second largest surpluses in the world and refusing reductions in tax rates

Defence

Good – extra funding for the Army
Bad – reneging on the F16 purchase

Employment/Welfare

Good – historically low unemployment levels
Bad – blow out in sickness and invalids numbers

Telecommunications

Good – Operational Separation of Telecom
Bad – Not doing LLU in 2003

Health

Good – overdue pay rise for hospital nurses
Bad – ideological hostility to using private sector when it has spare capacity

I have not listed education as I am unsure if I can point to a single positive. It’s a fiasco ranging from the 20 hours policy in tatters for pre-school, the NCEA mess to all the tertiary funding scams. I don’t actually know how Maharey could make it worse if he tried. Maybe the apprenticeships one can give a positive mark to.

Anyway that is my five.

The 40 below party

David Farrar’s killers arrested

96 days to go ….

Labour have only 96 days to pay back their $800,000 of illegal (until validated) taxpayer expenditure. When will it be paid? And remember we want to see the receipt.

But more to the point when will NZ First make a decision? This is not a complex issue. They have just three options:

(1) pay it back
(2) refuse to pay it back
(3) take court action over the Auditor-General’s report

NZ First had their long awaited legal advice on 20 February, five weeks ago. A slightly retarded used car salesman could even manage to make a decision in that timeframe.

The Auditor-General released his final report on Wednesday 11 October 2006. 166 days has passed since then. Or 3,984 hours. Or 239,040 minutes. However one counts it, that has been bucketloads of time.

If I was a newspaper journalist I would be running a story every Tuesday about NZ First’s refusal to say what they will do, and their silly delaying tactics. The media need to make the cost of not saying so high that they finally do commit to paying it back or alternatively confirming they won’t pay it back (which will mean they are wiped out at the next election).

Party databases

The Privacy Commissioner has confirmed, which is little surprise, that voters can ask for a copy of any info held on them by political party databases.

The Privacy Commissioner has expressed a caution that with electronic media, New Zealanders’ personal details could be pooled and could potentially be accessed with ease by any party employee or member of Parliament.

This is true in theory but a well designed database would only share certain non sensitive info, and keeps other info restricted to the office or user who created it.

Parental support for NCEA falls

The NZ Herald reports that parental support for NCEA has fallen to a low of 37%. I suspect this will continue to decline unless the Government makes some changes.

The same survey found 90% of school principals back NCEA though. I suspect however that the larger schools are less supportive, so if you weight by student numbers it would be less.

The NZ Herald editorial calls for fast action on NCEA flaws.

Blog Bits

Nigel at Kiwi Pundit has a very useful post on the laws and rules around evidence in trials.

PC links to a You Tube video showing a swedish brat in a supermarket. A clear case of someone needing Section 59. But a hilarious ending.

Tim Blair links to an ebay auction where someone threatens to kill a tree and release carbon into the environment unless people bid for the tree to save it. Quick someone organise a Telethon!

Scott Adams blogs about the Wisconsin man who has been charged with having sex with a dead deer he found in a ditch. Scott wonders whether he took the deer home or did it in the ditch. He concludes that anyone so horny to fornicate with a dead deer will be too horny to wait until he gets home.

Taser use

No Right Turn has blogged how the Police tasered a youth who did nothing more than try to intervene in a fight.

At first my reaction was also that it seemed an improper use. But one should not rush to judgement from limited media and third party reports.

Whale Oil points outthe next day the youth involved has been charged with numerous weapons and assault charges after allegedly attacking a man with a metal bar and lashing out at police.

To quote from the Herald article:

“When the policeman got there he began lashing out, punching and kicking the officer and being an absolute menace,” said Melissa Church, who was in her car when the fight broke out in front of her.

“I was absolutely disgusted to hear he was being made out to be an innocent who was trying to help.”

Another witness, Rebecca Ellis, said she would give a statement to police today and agreed the Tasered man was “nowhere near innocent”.

“It took four police to restrain him and the officers got a bum rap. It was a very violent situation and they did a fantastic job.”

Virtual Super 14 Week Eight

It really would be nice if teams had consistent form. Another frustrating week.

Only 21/42 points to total 191 in total. This is a drop of 7,445 to 47,818.

I got 3/6 games right, and two of them by the correct margin. The inability of the Hurricanes, Highlanders and Sharks to win did not help.

Of the 89 in the NZ Bloggers challenge, I am in 34= place along with Martin, Amanda, Andrew, Morgan and Grant. Jeremy G is No 2 and Matt is No 1 with 228 points.

A good Wellington weekend

Summer arrived in Wellington around three months late, but it looks to be staying late also. Today was another nice Wellington day. Decided to ditch the car and walked from my parent’s place in Roseneath back to Thorndon, around the waterfront. Ran into a few people I know (as you do in Wellington) and nicely wasted much of the afternoon.

Last night met up initially with the infamous Alex Foulkes of Princes Street Labour, through a mutual friend. Alex is on the “hard left” of Labour so we didn’t agree on much except republicanism, but was a fun conversation. During the evening also ran into Russell Brown (and friends) who was on his way to a bash. Reminded me again how you always run into people here.

Had a quick dinner at the Oaks Noodle House. For $8 you get a remarkably large bowl of soup. A good place for a quick and cheap fill up.

Oh had a look over a the Southern bypass which opened today. Seemed fairly congested. Will have to see if it improves over time.

In defence of NZ First MPs

This may surprise some, but I am appalled to see the NZ First Party President threatening to demote on the party list, MPs Brian Donnelly and Doug Woolerton because they are voting in favour of Sue Bradford’s bill.

The bill is a conscience issue. Just because Helen had trampled on this convention is no reason for other parties to do so. I don’t know Doug Woolerton but do know Brian Donnelly reasonably well and have even chatted to him on the Section 59 issue at an airport lounge. Brian is a very decent sincere person who holds genuine views on the bill. He should be allowed to vote on it without threats from his party president.

As someone who wants Labour MPs to have a conscience vote on the issue, that goes for NZ First MPs also, even if that is in the other direction.

What angers me isn’t the bill itself, or the MPs who support it. It’s the dishonesty of those MPs who claim it does not ban smacking, when it clearly does. And the actions of Clark in forcing Labour MPs to vote for it, when some of them do not wish to. Oh yes and in trying to ram it through under urgency. But I can respect a genuine difference of opinion on the bill and its amendments.

Sleazy Shipton

Sunday News has stories on Brad Shipton, including a group-sex session on video made in 2001, involving three former officers.

A more detailed story has an interview with the girl involved, who says it was consensual but exploitative. The part where they joke about sending a copy to Sharon Shipton might have Mrs Shipton reconsider her long standing support of her husband.

More NCEA nonsense

A fascinating HoS story on all the ways NZQA uses to push up NCEA pass rates.

Karamu High School had a policy of only allowing students to take a test twice. They were told to stop this by NZQA as contrary to national practice to allow students to take the tests as often as necessary until they pass. Hey if it is multi-choice it can’t take too many goes.

Now remember they do not record failure. So the NCEA record will not show any difference between someone who passed the test on their first go, and someone who passed it on the eighth go.

Another school was told that even if a student failed two tests, one can take the good stuff from one test and add it to the good stuff from another test to declare they have passed.

And they wonder why employers (and parents and students) have so little faith in the system.

Kerre Woodham on Smacking Ban Law

Some common sense from Kerre today:

… the frustration is that most of us know, too, that this flabby and ultimately unworkable bill will not make a blind bit of difference in changing the attitude of those people who beat their babies until their kids are dead.

I can’t for the life of me understand why the Government is now trying to get the thing through Parliament under urgency. Bad enough that the Labour MPs have been whipped into line, and what is a conscience vote for other parties is a party vote for Labour.

And this same sort of overweaning arrogance may well see Labour paying at the ballot box. The Government might well believe that it has a higher authority in introducing this legislation, but to do so without engaging in consultation and education is just buying a fight. You cannot solve the problem of child abuse with one wave of a legislative fairy wand. And you’re not going to stop parents smacking in moments of parental panic or frustration.

Births, Death, Marriages and Relationships Amendment Bill

I hadn’t followed this bill much, but in today’s HoS a group of historians make a convincing case against it.

Basically the bill will ban access to birth and other records of individuals born within the last 100 years. The purpose is to stop people (cough cough Tim Selwyn) from easy identity fraud, but it will stop historians from from being able to do research from these records.

It also may cover up lies from public figures. A politician could claim they were born in poverty in say the East Coast, and no-one will be able to find out that in fact they were born in a private hospital in Epsom for example.

I suspect it will also make genealogy a lot harder for those putting family trees together.

The bill has gone to select committee and submissions are open to 4 May 2007. This is a bill worth opposing, or more constructively putting up amendments so the work of historians and genealogists are not frustrated by an over-reaction to the problem of identity fraud.

Looking at the Hansard debate on the bill (only National and Field voted against the first reading) I did have to chuckle at Chris Finlayson’s contribution:

Some have, indeed, suggested that Labour is tightening up the procedures so those people can hide their own past because they have ancestors who were pickpockets and vagabonds. Well, that cannot apply to Annette King, who is related to Chester Borrows and me, and we come from good stock. If they have ancestors who were pickpockets—and I do not really care whether they do—then that, of course, is minor compared with the Labour MPs of today, who stole $800,000 of public funds that Labour has not paid back.

Heh.

Labor re-elected in NSW

As expected, Labor were re-elected in NSW.

NSW has 93 seats in the lower house. Before the election it was Labor 53, L-NP 30, Independents 10. At this stage it looks like Labor have lost only three seats despite their share of the primary vote being only 38%. Greens are at 9% but no seats.

The failure of NZ climate change policy

No Right Turn has a post quoting from a Listener article on how NZ came to miss our Kyoto target so badly. One factor was:

the government programmes supposed to reduce total emissions by 10% turned out on closer examination to be worth 0%… the inconvenient truth was that all the announced steps the Environment Ministry had for the past three years sworn were going to make a meaningful difference to New Zealand’s emissions were assessed to have no measurable effect.

Okay so all the money spent on the government programmes had zero effect. Did not help at all. They were meant to save 21 meagtonnes and it seems saved zero.

Now NRT blames this on underfunding by the Government. He claims the EECA only got half of what it said it needed. Now I think it was more than half, but even putting that aside, let’s concede it was half.

If you double zero, it is still zero!!! The Vote in this area has had $115 million spent on it from 2002/03 to 2006/07 and their net impact was zero. So what blind faith No Right Turn has in the bureaucracy that if it had been more than that, it would magically have worked.

Now if for spending half the money the bureaucrats said you have to, one had got even 25% of the results, then maybe you have a case. But when the impact has been zero, you have to wonder if it would simply be throwing good money after bad?

I’m prepared to spend money on climate change measures, but to me they need to meet two criteria:

1) That they will work
2) That the benefits from the measures will be greater than the cost of the measures

It seems we can’t even manage (1)

Scare Mongering Climate Change Website

The Press reports on a website purporting to show NZers how their homes will be affected by rising sea levels.

It is a bunch of crap of course, because the official UN IPCC projections are for a 59 cm rise by 2100. So if you live to be 120, and your house is within a metre of the sea, you might possibly be affected.

But what does this alarmist website do? It shows you a default seal level change of seven metres, and allows you to go up to 14 metres. This will be very interesting if you plan to live to be 6,000 or so.

There is an issue with climate change, but hysterical scenarios at odds with the consensus science just discredit the proponents.

Incidentally I’ve just checked out my street and we are okay even at a 14 metre increase, so what’s the problem. Plus I’m on the 5th floor so reckon I only need worry at 25 metres or so. And the good news is by then I’ll be able to paddle to the stadium.

Cullen: You can’t eat your house

Herald praises PM

The NZ Herald editorial is headlined “Top marks for PM at Oval Office”.

They conclude:

She is one of the veterans of international leadership now and probably respected for her command of issues and judgment. Her reception in Washington, and the realism she has engendered on the nuclear stalemate, is a credit to her.

While I think it is fair for the PM to get credit for her role in improving relations, I think it overlooks the fact that many have been working on this, including the US Embassy in Wellington whose initial overture a few years ago on the 4th of July was rebuffed by Clark at the time.

Australian broadband major election issue

Another story on Australian broadband, and how it is going to be a major election issue in Australia.

What I found interesting was the comments of the very powerful Murdoch and Packer who have called the status quo a disgrace and are calling for an investment of $12b or so.

Lame Duck Government

John Armstrong writes that the signs are increasing of Labour drifting closer to a lame duck Government.

Labour is distracted, however. The political year is barely two months old.

Yet, the Government is becoming increasingly besieged across major policy fronts, notably law and order, education and health with the turmoil in the Corrections Department, renewed criticism of the NCEA and now the debacle over the contract for laboratory testing in Auckland.

With Corrections going off the boil, if only temporarily, the damning High Court ruling invalidating the $560 million laboratory testing contract could not have been timed better for National to sustain its strategy of painting Labour as a Government where accountability is absent, standards are lax and mismanagement is endemic.

The Ribena Girls

American Idol

I only watch American Idol for the judging, not the singing. The banter between the judges is the best part, and especially Simon Cowell. Last night we had this exchange between Simon and host Ryan. Very puerile but was very funny looking at the shocked expressions on the othe rjudges wondering how far they would goad each other:

A contestant was complaining that the hardest part of the show was wearing the high heels, and this followed:

Ryan: Simon, any advice on the high heels

Simon: You should know, Ryan

Ryan: Stay out of my closet

Simon: come out

Ryan: This is about the top twelve, not your wishes