Ruapehu Lahar
A long awaited lahar has finally emerged from Mt Ruapehu today. Sounds like it was a moderate one. Morphyoss has been following the action.
Heather Roy usefully points out that the monopoly ACC is spending $5.1 million just to make people feel good about having ACC. That’s a disgraceful waste of money. Advertising promoting safety or accident reduction is valid and laudable, but this self promotion is an insult to those who have to pay the levies to fund it.
A long awaited lahar has finally emerged from Mt Ruapehu today. Sounds like it was a moderate one. Morphyoss has been following the action.
National’s Blue Libs now have a refreshed website, including a welcome video from co-chair MP Chris Finlayson.
Talking of Chris, Russell Brown recommended, and I concur, people watch the video from TVNZ of Chris being interviewed about the Arts on Frontseat. It’s the video called Arts Votes.
Just looking through the transcripts from Agenda, and can’t believe this line from Bradford:
SUE To accept Chester Burrows amendment would be the worst possible thing we could do for the kids of this country
I’m sorry but someone find the planet she is on and give it a name. I mean there is hyperbole, but to label an amendment which will lower the degree of force the current laws allow, as “the worse possible thing we could do for the kids of this country” is just hysterical bullshit.
Slightly better this week with 28 points taking me to 170, which sees a slight recovery of 4,005 places to 40,373.
I got five out of six games picked with the right winning team (only one not picked was the Stormers winning), however only got the margin right once. I should have picked more 13+ margins.
Of the 88 taking part in the Bloggers challenge, I am 31st=. Jeremy Greenbrook-Held will be very happy to be back in 1st place on 201 with a huge 42/48 points this round.
Globally the top score is 236,
Whale Oil has nicely put together various audio and video from Helen Clark on the smacking debate. Click above to view.
Andrew Falloon has discovered that even communist China has lower corporate tax rates than NZ – just 25%.
Legal Beagle Junior has a cunning theory that everyone who donates to Labour’s Big Whip Round may be breaching the Electoral Act, because they are providing money which is to repay money used to exceed the Electoral Act caps.
And Quatsch is excited by the discovery that human ass fat can drive sustainability. Yes.
The SST reports on the poll last week showing 80% of NZers oppose a capital gains tax on property, however this reduces to 41% if the first home is exempted.
In theory capital gains taxes generally can have a role to play in an economy. It is important to note however that many capital gains are already taxed – including property.
And expert John Shewan notes a gains tax on property “becomes easy to avoid, expensive to administer, easily exploitable, and still favours some taxpayers over others”
Something which would make me more favourable towards such a tax, would be a guarantee that any government introducing it would cut other taxes so that total taxation doesn’t just keep going upwards.
We see this also with Nandor’s proposed waste tax. I’d be more prepared to back a waste tax, if in exchange for it other taxes were lowered. But left wing Governments just come up with more and more taxes it seems.
Hat Tip: Tony Milne
Matthew Hooton highlights the upcoming Clark/Bush meeting as a time for the PM to shine, in a column that praises Clark often. Extracts are:
Helen Clark has the potential to pull off something spectacular when she meets counterpart George Bush this week. We should expect nothing less.
Despite one or two notorious gaffes, Clark is the most skilled diplomat ever to be prime minister. Reports last year about her potential to be UN secretary-general were true, and she would have done the job better than any of the alternatives, including Ban Ki-moon. Our Foreign Ministry has nothing but praise for her knowledge, skill and hard work.
Clark’s diplomatic skills have been honed through a lifetime of interest in foreign affairs. Her involvement in politics was not sparked by housing, health or education, but by Vietnam, apartheid and Mururoa. Her first important job was chairing the foreign affairs select committee, and she has travelled an enormous distance from when she worried the CIA was bugging her as she shepherded the anti-nuclear legislation through the committee in the 1980s.
The very fact she has secured a full two hours with President Bush is testament to her abilities. Along with Australia’s John Howard, Clark and Bush are the old hands in the Asia Pacific region. Clark has put aside any personal concerns about Bush’s policies to forge a warm friendship with her American colleague.
In doing so, she has taken a political risk. Not all her supporters will be pleased to see her hobnobbing with the president, but Clark is more sophisticated than the average Labour hack. She knows it can only be in New Zealand’s interests to have the closest possible friendship with the world’s strongest military and economic power.
On Afghanistan, Clark’s commitment to standing beside Bush was such that she put her own government at risk when the left faction of the Alliance, led by Laila Harre, split with Jim Anderton over his support for the war.
In the context of this wider friendship, the dispute over our nuclear policy has become silly, especially now it enjoys unambiguous bipartisan support.
The dispute was never really about the substance, because US allies Japan and Denmark had similar policies. The real trouble was that the Lange government went back on a private understanding about how the policy would be implemented.
But the US is the elder sibling. It’s the one who should be big enough to forgive the pip-squeak down the hall for telling a fib, especially when it was more than 20 years ago, and when our soldiers’ lives continue to be put at risk in pursuit of common values.
The time has surely come for the US to drop us from its list of “very, very, very good friends” and recognise that it has few more loyal allies in the world than Clark’s New Zealand. The prime minister has the diplomatic skills to make these points more delicately than a newspaper columnist. A lifetime of training has prepared her to exceed everyone’s expectations this week.
Citigroup have said the Telecom board should actively consider a structural split of the company. I agree this has the potential to increase value for Telecom.
Telecom is required by legislation to do a three way operational split into network, wholesale and retail. The idea is that all parties can access the network in an equivalent way, and also that wholesale customers are also treated equally.
Now if Telecom wished to, it could actually split into two companies. One would be the network access company, and the other would be the wholesale and retail services company. Now why would it split? Well because having lost the ability to make use of vertical integration to create monopoly profits at all levels, the different divisions require different strategies, different management and I suggest different investors.
The network access company, if it was split from the rest of Telecom, could have a huge future. It would be well placed to be the future fibre network for most of New Zealand. It would have dozens of companies wanting to use their network, and willing to pay for it. As an infrastructure company they would be more likely to attract specialist infrastructure investors and their investment profile is likely to be lower profits yet lower risk as it has guaranteed income. If the network access company remains a division of Telecom, people will be wary about them having too large a share of the fibre network in NZ. If they are truly independent and their only focus is on providing access to all comers, then they would be far better placed to grow.
The wholesale/retail remainder of Telecom, freed from ownership of the monopoly network, would be free to compete far more aggressively than it is able to at the moment. It could even rebrand to improve its tarnished image. It’s board would require far more of a marketing outlook and it would attract investors looking for potentially higher returns, but with increased risk.
The Board could do this by splitting into the two companies and giving existing shareholders equal shares in both. Over time, as people sell one sort of share but not the other, they would end up with quite diverse shareholdings.
Now the Telecom Board shouldn’t structurally separate on a theory. But they have a fiduciary duty to shareholders to increase value. Hence one of their first instructions to the new CEO should be to fully investigate whether a structural split would increase shareholder value over the medium to long term.
Kerre Woodham writes of a childhood incident, and how if it had happened today she could “probably blame my heavy drinking and my fascination for the pockets of men’s trousers on my early childhood experience”.
Kerre does the self-deprecating line very well.
Incidentally, like her father, I would have wanted to “kill the bastard” also. She doesn’t reveal whether or not the Dads caught him, and what happened if they did.
The HoS has an article on NCEA which upon close reading makes me realise the variability in standards is far far worse than previously discovered.
People may recall that in 2005 a small proportion of papers, 3.2%, were checked and a massive 29% were marked incorrectly. Now we firstly discover a further 10% were invalid as the tasks set by schools were inappropriate so we’re up to 40% have a result they should not have.
But it seems that schools know which schools and even which subjects will be checked six months before the checking. So this 40% inaccuracy rate is arguably as good as it gets, as teachers know this are is being checked, In other areas it could be much much worse. How can any parent, employer or student have faith in such results?
The HoS has an in depth article on Rotorua Police in the 1980s, talking to former police, various onlookers, and sadly another person who claims they were raped (she now lives in the US and only heard about the cases last week).
While the SST looks into who was who in the chain of command in Rotorua in the 1980s.
The Herald on Sunday has an article on the recent conflict at the Princes Street branch of Labour. We await Wednesday’s AGM with interest.
Another great episode. Butters parents think Butters is “bi-curious” (because of Cartman) and send him off to “straight camp” where they teach gay kids not to be gay.
I need not say more need not say more than that.
I agree with the NZ Herald editorial on Paul Holmes that it is quite incredible that for over a decade Holmes did the country’s leading early morning radio and evening television programmes on the same day, every day.
I also agree that his radio legacy is his better one. I think Holmes is a natural on his radio show, and the ratings have reflected that. His TV show annoyed me somewhat. It was very good at light news and entertainment but wasn’t a hard news show, yet got portrayed as one.
Of late Holmes has also been doing newspaper features, specifically interviews with high profile NZers. He seems to have quite an ability to get subjects to open up, and I’m enjoying the series, I almost find them a must read.
The Dominion Post has got excited that shock horror National MPs use databases. They report on payments to an Australian company for use and support of the Feedback Database.
I know more than a wee bit about this as long ago I was part of the team that customised Feedback for NZ use, and installed it in MPs offices around the country, training staff up on it.
It has a full suite of tools for MPs allowing them to track all correspondence on behalf of constituents, all phone and e-mail inquiries, all submissions to govt departments on behalf of those needing assistance. This is exactly what you want MPs to be doing. It is an outstanding constituent assistance tool.
It also allows things such as recording of views on issues and policies, which has both parliamentary and political uses. One can use it to alert constituents to bills on issues they have an interest in for example which is an appropriate parliamentary activity. Obviously at election time that info may also be useful in a political sense. They key is how it is used, when it is used and by whom.
Now the Dominion Post reports that the National Leaders Office has paid $90,000 over the last few years towards Feedback, and the National Party itself $366,000. On these numbers the party itself has funded 80% of the database and the MPs budgets 20%. I would suggest that not only is that entirely appropriate, but I would be surprised if other parties have anywhere near 80% funded by the party not the MPs budgets. In fact on those numbers I would say the party is subsidising the MPs budgets but National is traditionally quite conservative about the parliamentary funding rules, so this is no surprise.
John Armstrong writes on how Labour has alienated the one sector which is most crucial to its stated aim of carbon neutrality – forestry.
Their refusal to use any carrot has angered the sector, and then to threaten them with deforestation taxes has led to massive slumps in new plantings and a surge of deforestation. Incompetence doesn’t even come close to covering it. Even the Greens are saying the Government should hand over a portion of carbon credits to to the forestry sector to get seedlings planted.
And even more schools are reported to be planning to offer NCEA alternatives. What is interesting with these schools is they includes ones who have been huge supporters of NCEA but they complain that the Government hasn’t listened to their concerns and, for example, still do not record when a student has a ‘not achieved’. Yes the Government thinks it can abolish failure by refusing to record it.
The Business Roundtable has just highlighted that today’s labour productivity statistics are the lowest on record.
This should be of great concern to everyone. High levels of labour productivity growth are the key to lifting our national income compared to Australia and the OECD. It can’t happen just by increasing wages without productivity.
The annual increase is a mere 0.4%, compared to the average of 2.5% over the last 18 years.
Now look at it over periods of Government. Labour from April 00 to March 06 is an average of a miserable 1.2%.
From April 91 to March 00 the average was 2.9% – two and a half times as great.
Sue Bradford and Helen Clark may be surprised to learn they have an ally in Cactus Kate. She is supporting them in their law change to ban smacking.
They may not be flattered by Kate’s rationale though:
For the record though I am with the filthy Commo’s on this. I support Sue Bradford’s Bill.
While I don’t think the Bill will solve all the problems of family violence, it sends a very clear message to stupid people (ie. the leftist electorate) that hitting your kids is not acceptable.
Remember most laws are an attempt to protect the stupid from themselves and unfortunately New Zealand’s worst child abusers are the poor and stupid. This is a law aimed at the lowest forms of life in New Zealand that can’t be trusted at all not to beat the be jesus out of their kids as they are not sophisticated enough to tell the difference between a gentle smacking and a Jake The Muss beating. It can turn the middle and upper class gentle smackings into a criminal offence, yes, but you are just going to have to live with the changes for the sake of the offspring of the poor and stupid.
At an ACT, Libertarianz or National Party policy meeting this is NOT a law we would ever dream of promoting when we look at the sophistication and responsibility of our own membership, however Labour, Maori & Green Party and Alliance voters are simply too dumb and irresponsible to be left to discipline their kids in a physical manner. Their Parties know that and so are doing the responsible thing by passing legislation banning smacking.
The Anti-smacking Bill is an admission that their own voters are too stupid to apply a basic parenting skill correctly.
Lets give them credit for realising this.
I disagree on this rare occassion with Kate. Look at this case here where a Timaru mother dropped her 18-month daughter to the footpath 10 or 11 times and then threw her headfirst to the ground,
Will this law change stop that woman? Not in a million years.
A march is being organised for Wednesday 28 March for those wanting to protest the Bradford/Clark bill to ban smacking.
It will start at the Civic Square at 12 pm. There may be an Auckland march also.
Bradford and Clark are still insisting that their law does not ban smacking because it does not create a new offence of smacking, it just removes an existing defence.
Now this is a ludicrous assertion which fails the common sense test. They are arguing form over substance. But in case anyone is stupid enough to actually give it credence, let look at applying their logic further.
Section 59 is just one of many defences under the Crimes Act. Another is Section 48:
Self-defence and defence of another
Every one is justified in using, in the defence of himself or another, such force as, in the circumstances as he believes them to be, it is reasonable to use.
Now think if Helen and Sue came along and got rid of Section 48. You and I would say they have banned using force in self-defence. They would argue no they have not – that they have merely removed it as a defence!!
Or think if Section 56 went:
Defence of land or building
Every one in peaceable possession of any land or building, and every one lawfully assisting him or acting by his authority, is justified in using reasonable force to prevent any person from trespassing on the land or building or to remove him there from, if he does not strike or do bodily harm to that person.
Now you and I would say they have banned people from forcibly evicting trespassers. But Sue and Helen would claim no they have just removed it as a defence.
Pathetic isn’t it? I mean how stupid do they take us to be, and how much contempt do they have to try such puerile attempts to deceive? Why can’t they just tell the truth and say “Yes the bill will ban smacking”.
You know what I want, what I really really want ….
But will there be a second movie?
Oh this is delightful. Because we the plebs do not understand how a law which will make it illegal to smack your children for corrective purposes is not actually a smacking ban, Sue Bradford has suggested a public education campaign to educate us.
Now I actually think this is a wonderful idea. I suggest all the MPs who vote against the Borrows amendment should front up to public meetings up and down the country to explain the law. It will be priceless:
Pleb: So am I allowed to smack my four old child if they misbehave and refuse to go into time out?
MP: No that will be illegal
Pleb: So you’re banned smacking
MP: No no no we haven’t
Pleb: But you just told me it would be illegal
MP: Yes that’s right
Pleb: Well then you’ve banned it.
MP: No we haven’t. You probably won’t be prosecuted
Pleb: But that’s different to whether or not I will be breaking the law.
MP: Yes
Pleb: I’m confused
MP: Yes. My pleasure.
I think the Government should also spend millions of dollars on a TV campaign like they did for Working with Families. They should remind every parent of this law, and attempt to educate them on it. Even better why don’t they set up education classes and make them compulsory!
On the topic of the smacking ban, yesterday’s Herald has a good article on the debate in Parliament on Wednesday.