Chief Judge on Court Evidence
The Chief High Court Judge, Hon Justice Tony Randerson, has written a column in the NZ Herald on the issues around evidence in trials, specifically admissibility of previous crimes etc.
An alarming story in the Dom Post on the resignation from clinical roles of three top anaesthetics at Wellington Hospital, and how the hospital is in danger of losing its training accreditation. This would affect the entire hospital system as they currently train a quarter of all anaesthetics in the country.
The Chief High Court Judge, Hon Justice Tony Randerson, has written a column in the NZ Herald on the issues around evidence in trials, specifically admissibility of previous crimes etc.
More and more schools are opting out of NCEA and offering Cambridge exams also.
In an attempt to win the spin award off Helen and Sue, Steve Maharey has claimed:
Education Minister Steve Maharey said last night to move towards adopting the Cambridge exams did not indicate a lack of confidence in NCEA.
It seems parents are pressuring schools to offer alternatives to NCEA or they will go elsewhere. No doubt the Government in time will respond to this by either banning non NCEA assessment, or banning people from moving schools.
I’ve been in a strategic planning session most of the day so only now got time to blog the pre-election quote that Whale Oil and other blogs have highlighted from Helen:
RT HON. HELEN CLARK (PRIME MINISTER): A lot of people aren’t comfortable with beating but they don’t want to see, you know, a stressed and harassed parent, you know, called in by the police because they smacked a child so…
BOB MCCOSKRIE: So you don’t want to see…
CLARK: … I think there’s a debate to go on.
MCCOSKRIE: Right, so you don’t want to see smacking banned?
CLARK: Absolutely not. Well, I think you’re trying to defy human nature.
Now after the election not only is Helen voting for such a ban, she has enforced a whip on Labour MPs to vote for it, ensuring it will pass even though the majority of MPs in Parliament do not support it.
Helen has of course tried to argue that it will not ban smacking. Of course it will, unless they vote for the Borrows amendment. And if you don’t beleive me here’s Sue Bradford quoted by Newstalk ZB:
Sue Bradford has confirmed parents will not be able to smack their children after her bill is passed.
When questioned again today about the effect it would have on parents, she was asked whether it would be possible to smack children after her bill becomes law – and she said no.
Now Bradford is trying to dig Helen out a hole later on by claiming the bill does not ban smacking, it just doesn’t permit it, and that smacking is not listed as an offence. Jesus Christ give that MP a spin award. This is like arguing that the Crimes Act does not ban shoplifting, it only bans theft.
It is simple. Helen Clark said before the election that she absolutely does not want to see smacking banned. She is forcing through Parliament a law which will have exactly that effect.
Transtasman may not be a well known publication to those outside the “beltway”. It is a weekly newsletter on politics, economics, legislation and trade. A 50 year veteran of the press gallery, Ian Templeton is Senior Editor, and the publisher and editor-in-chief is Max Bowden. It is widely anticipated and read around Parliament and other subscribers. I receive a complimentary copy for which I am most grateful.
Their take on the smacking bill is dead on, so I hope they do not mind me sharing it with a wider audience:
It should not, one would have thought, have been beyond the ability of our Parliamentarians to come up with a law which says a slap on the hand or bum with the open hand is OK, and anything else is not. But it looks like they can’t manage that.
Hear hear.
Much of the debate on the Bill has been marked by its irrelevance. Bradford herself kicked this off when she introduced the Bill by arguing it is a blow against colonialism. Corporal punishment, she said, was imported with the missionaries and their bibles. What this does tell you, apart from its dubious history, is this is very much an ideological battle which has little to do with protecting children. The other irrelevancy, of course, is this is something to do with child abuse.
Indeed.
On the other side, though, the debate has been championed by some of the more zealous Christian groups. There is not a press gallery journalist who has not been bombarded with messages about how the Bill is a Satanist-lesbian-communist plot. The lip-smacking glee with which some of these types talk about whacking their kids is rather disturbing, and doesn’t exactly help the cause of moderation.
I can’t disagree with that either. People have been too extreme on both sides.
As for whether it will pass, well that depends on Labour. Reports are emerging that if there was a true conscience vote on the bill, the Borrows amendment would pass, and/or the bill would fail. The six to eight Labour MPs who are being whipped to vote for it (and breaking the whip in Labour is an offence which can lead to expulsion) against their wishes are going to be under huge pressure. Some of them suspect they could lose their seat on it. If the bill passes, it will be due to Helen Clark not Sue Bradford.
The Press has an article on the Police Watch Blog someone has set up. It seems to be the work of one person with a very specific complaint.
I’m quoted in the article saying much the same as I did with CYFS Watch. I did make the point that I did not think Google had grounds to remove the blog as defamation alone is not something they will usually act on. I did say, as reported, that it would be far more useful if these sort of scrutiny blogs (which are good in concept) actually backed up allegations with some evidence. For instance a police watch blog linking to news stories of cops censored by the PCA or charged with offences would be quite a different thing.
I should be on National Radio today at around 4.20 pm discussing the issue also.
Phil Rennie from The Centre for Independent Studies has today published a paper called “New Zealand’s Spending Binge“.
It’s a relatively short paper at 16 pages, so I encourage people to read the whole thing. Some key points are:
* Core government spending has increased by $20 billion since 2000, or 32% in real (inflation adjusted) terms
* If one had not increased spending by this amount, one could have almost abolished income tax and funded the 2000 level expenditure from GST and a low corporate tax rate
* The government has little information on how effective this extra spending has been and the available social indicators we have show negligible improvements since 2000 in life expectancy, infant mortality, hospital outputs, literacy, violent crime, suicide and poverty.
* Much of the spending is middle class welfare churned back to those who pay it. Therefore much public spending today is not ‘new’ spending; it is displacing spending that would have happened anyway, by individuals themselves. It follows that more public spending will not necessarily increase public welfare, and may even reduce it.
* Many people could afford to purchase their own social services if taxes were lower. This would allow for more competition, innovation and personal responsibility, and would reduce unnecessary bureaucracy.
* Australia provides an interesting comparison to New Zealand, because they have a smaller government with more reliance upon private health, education and superannuation. They also outperform New Zealand on most social indicators.
Looking just at health spending up 49% in real term, we have since 2000:
* a slow down in the rate of life expectancy increase
* a slow down in the rate of infant mortality decrease
* a reduction in elective surgery operations from 107,366 in 2000 to 105,437 in 2006
* no change in hospital readmission rates (a key indicator of quality of care)
* no change in hospital mortality rates
* a decline in patient satisfaction with DHB services
A comparison is made with Australia.
Australia has a smaller government than New Zealand; their government spends 34% of GDP compared to New Zealand’s 40%.54 It is also a much richer country with better social outcomes.
Incomes are a third higher across the Tasman, and the Australians also outperform us on a range of social indicators, including life expectancy, infant mortality, income inequality and suicide rates.
Australia doesn’t necessarily have less social spending; the difference is that private provision is more prevalent, and actively encouraged by the Federal Government. In health for example, 33% of Australian spending comes from the private sector compared to 23% in New Zealand. In education, the corresponding figures are 26% for Australia and 17% for New Zealand.
Rennie concludes by saying:
Too often politicians take the view that all government spending is inherently ‘good’. There is not enough scrutiny of public spending, of its benefits and of the alternatives available to policymakers. Too often this reflects an ideological commitment to the role of the state, rather than a dispassionate look at what the state can realistically achieve.
There needs to be a wider debate on what the proper role of government is and what services should be realistically provided by people themselves. We need to consider what governments can do as well as what they should do.
Hear hear,
As a former parliamentary staffer one thing I follow closely are what ones call house tactics to delay a bill. Now before everyone yells at me that they hate delaying tactics, let me explain that there is a place for them as long as you don’t do it too often. If the Opposition do not have the numbers to defeat a bill, then the only way they can show how strongly they oppose a bad law is by fighting it tooth and nail and delaying it.
The first second and third reading debates are all set by standing orders as two hours each. So it is the committee of the house stage which considers it clause by clause which allows delaying tactics.
Now it is rare for a bill to actually be considered clause by clause. Normally there are too many clauses so the Government will move that it be taken part by part. The Chairman has discretion as to how long to allow for each clause or part but the rule of thumb is an hour each.
So Bradford’s bill having six clauses, might take six hours. A large bill with several hundred clauses in ten parts could take ten hours.
Now one trick the Government can do to reduce debating time is to have less parts and use sub-parts. It’s sort of cheating on the spirit but means instead of say 12 one hour debates, you only have four because you have Parts 1A, 1B, 1C, 1D, 2A, 2B etc instead of Parts 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 … 12.
A very smart Opposition can try and do the opposite and add a new Part to a bill. But that is very difficult because to be accepted by the Chairman it has to cover issues that are not within the scope of any other Part of the Bill, yet is within the objects of the Bill.
Next you can move individual amendments. Now these do not actually increase the time for debate. They just get considered along with the Bill. But each has to be voted on and voting takes around a minute. So you see Taito Philllip Field tabling 50 amendments to the Bradford Bill would delay it by around 50 minutes.
If you start voting in Maori, which requires translation, that means each vote takes two minutes instead of one. This happens rarely.
One can also keep a debate going just by having lots of MPs jumping up to take the call. The one hour per clause/part is a very rough guideline. If the Chairman sees lots of MPs still wanting to debate, especially ones who have not yet spoken, he or she is more likely to keep debate going. So sometimes one may even get two hours per part. Normally the Whips work out in advance a speaking order. But when people are trying to keep the debate going you actually see MPs genuinely competing for the call, and the Speaker choosing between them.
Another tactic is points of order. Experienced MPs can raise valid points or order which can take a couple of score of minutes to deal with. Sometimes up to two hours with the Speaker recalled if a critical issue.
Now the Government has ways to speed things up also. Any amendment which involves incurring expenditure can be vetoed by the Minister of Finance without vote or debate. And it cn be hard to word amendments with no fiscal consequences.
And with the Bradford Bill debate the Government did something quite cunning. Rather than vote against all 50 of Field’s amendments changing the implementation date by 1 to 50 months, they voted for the first one. This then meant that the other amendments could not be put as they were contrary to an amendment already accepted. I am impressed they thought of that tactic.
Despite this the Bill did not get to a final vote in committee stage, so expect that to happen in two weeks time, and then the third reading three weeks after that,
And again before people say how much they hate silly delaying tactics and the like, they do have a valid place to show opposition, and they are done fairly rarely – most of the time debate moves along swiftly.
Do people remember Winston donating $500,000 of our money to Hamas the Palestian Authority?
And how he resented being criticised for doing so.?
Well maybe he should read this story in the Daily Telegraph:
A former World Bank official who is about to become the Palestinian finance minister has warned foreign donors that he has no idea where much of their money has been spent.
Now, Palestinian Authority spending is out of control, salaries are being paid to workers who never turn up, and nobody can track where the money is going, according to Mr Fayyad.
Don’t Helen and Winston talk about linking aid to good governance? Talk about money down the drain, or even worse to terrorists,
I’ve been unable to comment on blogger sites for the last few days. The reason is that where it is meant to display a graphic showing me a code to prove I am human, it instead just comes up with the alt words “visual verification”. Which means I can not get past the spam test.
Has anyone else had this problem? And how do you fix it?
Fishslice is an interesting blog. The author claims he is being victimised and tortured by a number of NZers, including:
* Peter Jackson
* Mike (sic) Havoc
* Claire Chitham
* Oliver Driver
* David Herkt,
Now I wouldn’t put some mental torture past my friend Mr Herkt 🙂 but I am sure that nice Claire Chitham would not be involved with:
I have been kidnapped and have biotech device embedded in my body these devices operate digitally and are used to torture me. I suffer great and sustained continuous pain. I have people talking into a cell phone secreted in my body and have many of my bodily functions controlled by computer and hideous individuals.
Canterbury Law Professor Duncan Webb has an interesting column in The Press on the Section 59 debate. Professor Webb, incidentally is also Labour’s Christchurch Central Electorate Chair.
Webb basically says that both the Bradford bill as amended, and the Borrows amendment will be vague bad law. He argues that outright repeal is the preferred way to go saying the bill “has been turned into a largely incomprehensible equivocation”. Taking some of his comments in turn:
The amended Bradford Bill states four situations where one can use (undefined) reasonable force:
* To prevent harm to the child or another.
* To prevent the commission of a crime by the child.
* To prevent offensive or disruptive behaviour by the child.
* And performing the normal daily tasks that are incidental to good care and parenting.
Webb says:
National MP Nicky Wagner suggests that the current proposals are “a nonsense, a long string of words that says everything and nothing” (Feb 23). In this she is right.
The select committee, with the help of the Law Commission, have looked for a middle ground that does not exist.
In multiplying the situations in which force can be used against a child, they have multiplied the possibility of confusion and avoidance.
However he is equally unimpressed with the Borrows amendment. He states:
Unfortunately, the National response is simply to replace one set of nonsense with another by proposing to replace the existing law with a version which permits the use of force where its effects are “transitory and trifling”. It would also prohibit the use of implements and the use of force in a cruel, degrading or terrifying manner.
The truly frightening aspect of National’s proposals is that they have glibly permitted the use of force causing harm that is not “transitory or trifling”.
Wagner claims that this is “a common-law phrase which is limited to reddening of the skin, but does not allow any bruising or worse injury”. That is a dangerous distortion.
Harm which is not “transitory or trifling” is used to define injury in the criminal law. So where someone is charged with, for example, injuring with intent, it must be shown that the harm is not “transitory or trifling”. It must be lasting.
On the basis of the common-law authorities, the effect of the proposed amendment would be to allow parents to hit their children as long as they stopped short of injuring them. This is a retrograde step from the current justification of the use of force only “by way of correction” which is “reasonable in the circumstances”.
There are significant problems with National’s proposed amendments. For example, they would pose problems for the prosecution of a parent who violently slapped a child on the face, as the harm would be transitory. It would also be difficult to prosecute an outright punch to the body which caused no bruising – and therefore a lawyer could argue that the harm was transitory and trifling because no injury resulted.
Now I am not going to argue legal definitions with a law professor. Personally I thought the use of trifling and transitory was setting that bar about as low as one can go. Professor Webb thinks it doesn’t and cites some common law grounds for doing so. What I would welcome would be a legal expert who could come up with a wording which would not cover stuff like smacking, but would cover hitting, a face slap etc. The problem is I suspect it is a bit like trying to define spam. We all know it when we see it, but damn hard to do a definition for it which covers all situations.
One aspect which is wrong is where he says:
These failings have been exacerbated in this case by the decision of National to vote on this conscience issue along party lines, and the inevitable response of Labour to do the same. This is an issue which is ill-suited to party politics.
This is not at all the case. At the second reading Labour party voted in favour while National allowed a conscience vote and six MPs voted for, and 42 against. To blame National for Labour making it a party vote is quite misleading.
While I disagree with aspects of the column, it’s a pretty fair take on the issue, and he is certainly right that what gets passed is not going to be clear law.
NRT has the news that the excellent Fijian blog Ms Vakaivosavosa has closed down due to fear of arrest (or worse) by the military government. They are actively seeking he authors of the blog Intelligentsiya.
I think Fiji is a great example of how blogs can be a beacon of free speech. The dictator and his thugs can suppress other criticism and censor newspapers, and arrest journalists. But blogs can and do allow the truth to come out.
Talking of Fiji there has been a minor schism (very minor – one person) in the Libertarianz over the Fijian situation.
One member, Tim Wikiriwhi, has left as he supports Bainimarama on the grounds the Commodore claims he will get rid of racist seats. Now I think race based seats are a bad idea also. But a libertarian of all people should know one can’t justify noble ends with means which involve coups, killing people, censoring the media, and appointing yourself boss. Every tyrant in history has claimed noble ends or intentions.
The Centre for Independent Studies has a public lecture on “Reinventing the welfare state” on Wednesday 28 March at Turnbull House, from 6 pm to 7.15 pm.
CIS Social Research Director Peter Saunders will be giving the lecture, and Sir Roger Douglas also making some comments.
Peter will be looking at how government spending has increased by $20 billion since 2000, with most of this going “on a welfare state that has become increasingly bloated, expensive and ineffective”.
This is because welfare has changed from a safety net to middle class welfare which provides cash and services for the great mass of the population, rich and poor alike, and of course in many cases the same people who get the benefits also pay for them through their taxes.
Peter will be proposing a system where people can opt out of the welfare state, in exchange for lower tax payments. This won’t reduce money for welfare to those who need it, but stop the churning of money from taxpayer to the state back to the same taxpayer as a welfare recepient. The only people who win with this churning are the extra staff IRD has to employ!
Sounds a great concept to me, and I’ll definitely be there. People can register here or just call 04 499 5861.
Michael Cullen has a superb wit in the House (except when he loses his rag), and even his targets appreciate it. Case in point from Rodney’s blog:
Rodney Hide: Has the Minister seen any reports of a political party that has always advocated extensive tax cuts, whatever the macroeconomic conditions, its own electoral fortunes, and the fads and fashions of politics–and, indeed, irrespective of floods and volcanoes?
Hon Dr MICHAEL CULLEN: Yes, I have. I have noted that both the size of the caucus and the size of its leader are shrinking at approximately the same rate.
Classic.
Damian Christie at Public Address gives an excellent critique of the Bradford Bill. Some extracts:
But I don’t accept Bradford saying that we should pass a law making something –even light smacking– illegal and rely on police and the judiciary to act reasonably in applying it. This is the same judiciary, is it not, who have failed to act responsibly in applying the “reasonable force” test that currently stands, failing to convict parents guilty of what any “reasonable” person would surely call child abuse?
I find it even less palatable to leave such discretion to the police.
Bradford’s Bill has been further watered down –or at least further confused– in the select committee process. The original idea of removing “reasonable force” as a defence has gone, and the Bill instead now allows reasonable force in a number of situations. Most vague is where such force is for the purpose of “performing the normal daily tasks that are incidental to good care and parenting,” as long as it is not “for the purpose of correction”. Good, that’s so much clearer.
“Reasonable force” remains undefined, which, need I remind you, was the whole problem the Bill was meant to address in the first place.
… Bradford’s “I’m not trying to make a criminal out of ordinary parents” line doesn’t wash. She is; the Bill does, the only question is whether the police choose to prosecute. It’s the same as marijuana smoking – the police might confiscate your joint and tell you to piss off, but you’ve still committed a criminal act.
What Parliament shouldn’t do is pass a law that criminalises many thousands of parents every day, and just kinda sorta assume that it’ll all work itself out somehow. Cos it won’t.
I think Damian hits on the key issues very nicely, being:
1) This will criminalise thousands of loving caring parents
2) Relying on the Police not to enforce a law is daft
3) The amended bill doesn’t even remove or define reasonable force as a defence, just changes when it can be used
Hmmn I think Martha at Wanda Harland is trying to knock me off my throne as the blogosphere media whore.
She’s in Hutt News and appeared at Webstock.
I think the airline practice of overbooking flights is deplorable, and hope one day someone sues over it. If there are 300 seats on a flight then they should sell 300 tickets for it. You can have a standby list on top of that, but selling 320 tickets for a 300 seat flight should not be allowed.
Yes some passengers do not turn up for flights. But the airline has already been paid for those tickets. They are not left out of pocket. And even if some passengers transfer flights at the last minute, they either have to pay huge penalties for doing so, or have paid up to three times the normal price for a flexi ticket.
I’ve never personally been affected by an over-sold flight (I guess air points status is used to decide who to not let on) but I would kick up almighty hell if I was.
If Air NZ does continue with such a policy, they should be giving a lot more than a $6 cafe voucher as compensation. I would expect to get the cost of the ticket reduced by at least 50%, a complimentary Koru Club pass for while you wait, and if you have to wait overnight, free accommodation.
I just noticed that one of the NZ Herald reporters is called Martha McKenzie-Minifie. It’s not often you get an three part alliteration just from someone’s name.
Can anyone name any other names which are at least three part alliterations?
The Government has introduced legislation to allow both foreign and domestic armed air marshalls or AIr NZ flights.
I guess it was pretty inevitable, but I do wonder at the empirical evidence that air marshals prevent terrorism. Has there been a single case of air marshals preventing a terrorist attack? In the Robert Reid shoe bomber case it was passengers and crew who took action I think.
One ironic side effect of Sep 11 is that conventional terrorism on flights no longer works. Before Sep 11 passengers would allow hijackers to take a plane over and negotiate terms. Now the assumption is that the terrorists will crash the plane into some target and as you will all die under that scenario, then might as well rush the terrorists as only some of you may die that way, and you’ll save lives on the ground.
Finally I recall a friend’s suggestion as to how to stop terrorism and hijacking on flights. Instead of banning guns, he proposed you actually issue them. Every person as they board gets a loaded gun. However each gun has only one bullet. Hence any attempt at take over means you’ll only get one shot off, and probably end up shot 30 to 40 times 🙂
Of course all those gun shots on board may not be healthy for the plane, which might explain why the idea has not been implemented!
John Armstrong reports on how Corrections Minister Damien O’Connor said in Parliament yesterday that he felt like “almost apologising” to the family of Karl Kuchenbecker, the Wainuiomata father-of-two killed by parolee Graeme Burton.
How many people need to die for an “almost apology” to become an apology?
Cactus Kate has done a lengthy blog post on the versatile Deborah Hill-Cone. I won’t be doing it justice by extracting just a few quotes, so make sure you read the whole thing.
But some extracts worth highlighting:
This was the first offering of Hill Cone’s I had been able to read for quite some time. It disturbed me. It was quite clearly the most obvious attempt at flirting with not women but the opposite sex in the recent history of New Zealand girlie columnists. It was cheap and nasty and absolute and total girlie crap. She mentioned several times that the girl crush was NOT a lesbian thing aimed at men. Which of course only makes them think it is. It crossed a line I will never travel in my columns. I will never play the “is she possibly bisexual in my dreams” card. It’s too mean.
Of course I immediately deeply admired its brilliance.
Forget girl crushes it seems every man I know has had or does have a crush on Deborah Hill Cone.
As I have explained to many who question Hill Cone’s transformation from technical media pin-up girl to trash media whore, it’s actually rather hard to write and act like a girlie girl. In order to stoop to depths required to write a girlie girl piece you must remove from your head pretty much everything you have been taught about being taken seriously. It’s the closest that writers get to be actors. We get to play the stupid girl for a change.
There is a collective name for those of us categorised as such and we are called the “thinking man’s pussy”. I did not invent this, I have had it explained to me by men who find it a deeply attractive quality. In order to be TMP you must be able to on demand destroy those who are so stupid that they actually think you are stupid. You must also be able to switch back and forward between girlie column airhead and shit kicking political or economic analyst with valued and clearly expressed opinions.
I shall have to arrange for Ms Cactus and Ms Hill-Cone to meet up at some stage I think!

Hat Tip: Clint
I suspect many people have heard about Sheriff Joe Arpaio, known as America’s Toughest Sheriff for his initiatives such as chain labour.
Now I always just assumed Sheriff Joe was a small town Sheriff with a small population to look after. But upon looking up Maricopa County, Arizona I’ve discovered that the county population is a whopping 3.6 million – around the same as NZ. So Sheriff Joe runs a penal system which is probably larger than all of NZ. This means one can’t dismiss his methods quite so quickly.
The Sheriff Joe entry in WIkipedia lists all his programmes and the criticisms. They include laudable stuff such as only approved high school program in any American jail, anti-drug programmes, and English classes for non English speaking inmates.
The most well known and controversial are the chain gangs, including the first all woman chain gang. What I was unaware of is that the prisoners volunteer to go them, they are not conscripted. They can regain privileges lost through bad behaviour on them, and it seems many volunteer for them just so they get to be outside the prison.
There are some allegations of prisoner mistreatments which appear substantiated, and they can only be condemned.
But overall it’s an interesting mixture. What is most frustrating for me though is I can’t find any info on whether his “tough” measures work or not. Do they have a lower reoffending rate? Is prisoner violence less? Is the general crime rate in the community less?
The Maori Party have confirmed that they will not back the Borrows amendment, so the amendment will fail by around 59 to 62 tomorrow , and the bill itself should pass comfortably in a fortnight by at least 66 to 55.