Botched Sterilisations

This must be a new level of medical incompetence. Six out of 32 patients sterilised by a Whangarei gynaecologist have fallen pregnant.

If a couple have taken the decision to sterilise as they want no more children, it can be devastating to still get pregnant. A friend of mine got pregnant even after her husband had a vasectomy and it was all very difficult as when people heard she was pregnant they’re all gushing about how wonderful it is she is having another child, and in reality it’s a disaster as she had just got back into her career.

RIP Frank Haden

Are the Chinese on the right track?

China argues, despite building on average a coal-fired power plant every week that greenhouse gas emissions level of any given country is a multiplication of its per capita emission and its population, and that it contributes to the world environment by having population controls.

They have somewhat of a point. Even if one can stabilise emissions per capita, if the world population grows by 20%, then emissions grow by 20%.

In fact I seriously doubt one can lower emissions per capita by enough, to compensate for population growth.

And if you ask me what is easier? Convince every person in the world to cut their living standards and emit 20% less carbon or to have 20% less people born, I suspect the latter is far easier. Hell this si already the case in most European countries.

So maybe the best thing we can do to help global warming is not to focus on emissions per capita, but to campaign for birth control.

Frog on Aid and Climate Change

A curious post on Frog Blog. They claim that rich countries will have to boost the US$100billion a year we give to the developing world by up to 100% in order to get a deal on climate change.

The rationale is “countries such as Bangladesh, or regions such as the Sahel and the Caribbean, contributed little to global emissions – so would not be significant players in a carbon market – but were expected to suffer disproportionately from climate change; and their support would be needed for a global deal”.

Now let us think about this. These countries will be some of the hardest hit by climate change, and won’t be negatively impacted by a carbon market as they contribute little, yet despite this they will blackmail the rest of the rest of the world into not agreeing to a global deal, unless they get more money.

I have a simple response to that: No.

The fact their countries will be hit hardest by climate change should be reason enough to agree to a deal. They’ll be spiting themselves if they block a deal. Plus if they are such small carbon emitters anyway, then do a deal without them. You really only need the major emitters.

Wikipedia doesn’t seem to have a list of overall carbon emissions, but for CO2 only emissions. The top 20 countries (if you count EU as one country) contribute 89.7% of emissions. Those 20 need to agree, the other 100+ should not be allowed to block a deal.

Incidentally I actually favour increasing overseas aid, where it can be tied to good governance etc. But I reject being blackmailed to increase overseas aid as the price for a deal on climate change.

Russel Norman on the rape trials

A good blog post by Green co-leader Russel Norman on the rape trials. He deals with two issues:

1) Should the jury have been told of the previous rape conviction for Schollum and Shipton?

He thinks there was enough similarity that they should have been told, but it was the Court of Appeal who decided otherwise.

I note that at least some of the jurors have admitted they did know of the previous convictions. And they were also aware of the Nicholas case and the similarity between the cases. I am unsure a law change would have changed the verdicts.

2) Should Rickards be allowed back?

Norman says that Rickards involvement in consenting group sex not a reason to stop him, neither is using sex aids, nor is cheating on his partner, and even sex on the bonnet of a police car 20 years ago shouldn’t stop him either.

But Rickards comments in defence of Schollum and Shipton are cited by Norman as good reason for him to no longer be in a senior position in the police, as these men are convicted rapists.

I think that is a pretty fair view of things. One thing I will comment on is the whole issue of whether the sex with Louise Nicholas was consensual, as people seem to be debating two different standards.

There is no question that the sex was found legally to be consensual, with the not guilty verdict. But the issue is not one of strict legality, but of behaviour as a police officer. Sex with an 18 year old is not illegal. But if (for example) you are her teacher, it is unethical.

Three police officers in their 20s and 30s having group sex with an 18 year old girl is unethical and abusive, even if consensual. As I said back when the Nicholas verdict came out:

I don’t tend to judge anyone’s consensual sexual behaviour, but three police officers all having casual and group sex with a teenager is not a relationship of equals. Don’t get me wrong I am not saying one can not have a strong loving relationship with someone significantly younger than yourself. Of course you can (as many people, including me, have). Neither am I saying casual or group sex by itself is exploitative. What I am saying is that in this case it was exploitative with the combination of factors involved.

Rickards has said he is ashamed of cheating on his partner back then. It would be nice to also hear him say that in hindsight he regards it as highly inappropriate for him and his colleagues to have group sex with an 18 year old, even if they thought she was consenting.

The anti-anti-smacking campaign

It is interesting to consider the actions of Larry Baldock in circulating petitions against the anti-smacking bill on Air NZ flights.

First obviously Air NZ staff shouldn’t have allowed him to do this. We don’t want this to be a precedent for lobbying on board flights.

But what is fascinating to me, is that on three out of four flights the pilots did give permission for the petitions to be circulated, despite undoubtedly knowing they shouldn’t. And in one case they handed over the PA system to him.

Why?

The obvious answer is because they think the proposed law is so ridiculously stupid. And that they figured almost everyone on board would agree. And this happened on three separate flights.

This is one of those issues which transcends party affiliations. I’ve heard so many negative comments on this law from people whose politics I know are not my own.

I haven’t seen recent polling on this issue, and the wording of any poll questions would be crucial, but off memory older polls have shown 80% opposition.

The issue before Parliament now isn’t whether to vote for Bradford’s bill or not. It is whether to accept Borrows amendment. This will allow smacking for disciplinary purposes so long as any harm is “trifling and transitory”.

Every MP who votes against the Borrows amendment is voting to criminalise parental discipline which is merely “trifling and transitory”. This is a million miles away from the cases the Bradford bill is meant to be about – kids beaten black and blue.

Purely from a political sense, I should be delighted that Labour MPs are lining up like lemmings to vote against the amendment. It will haunt them politically at the election.

But I’d rather have a sensible compromise law, than scoring political points.

DPF’s Parole Changes

There is a debate about whether one should have parole at all, but for now while we have parole, I want to propose a number of steps which would improve the decision making of the Parole Board.

The first is to change the over-riding requirement on the Parole Board so it is “To keep prisoners in custody, unless the Parole Board is convinced they are unlikely to reoffend“.

At present the default is to let them out early unless they are convinced they are an undue risk to the community. This has the test the wrong way out. The default must be to keep them in. And the test should be propensity to reoffend, not the higher standard of danger to the community.

And noting around 75%+ of those release on parole reoffend, this suggest parole should only be granted to a small minority of prisoners.

The second is to set up an “Office of Public Safety” whose job is to advocate before the Parole Board for prisoners not to be given parole.

The original trails have a prosecution and a defence, with a Judge and/or Jury weighing up the evidence and making a decision. The Parole Board has no equivalent of a prosecutor. Sure sometimes a victim may appear, but often they only hear from counsel for the prisoner, plus the bureaucrats. No wonder the Board so often gets it wrong.

I want an Office of Public Safety who will argue against releasing violent prisoners early, who will point out the potential risks to the community, who will suggest the prisoner is faking their remorse if they think they are.

Without this, the Parole Board hears only a rose tinted view of the world and the prisoner.

The third change is for full prison records to be made available

Every single prison guard and prisoner knew Burton was a psychopathic violent thug. Yet this information was kept from or ruled out by the Parole Board because allegations were not proven.

Parole is a privilege not a right. I want the Parole Board to hear about every fight the prisoner got involved in, every threat he has made to guards. I want prison guards to be able to testify as to the prisoner’s general behaviour and co-operation.

I had more information on Burton from commenters on my blog (info which in every case proved to be correct) that the Parole Board officially considered.

Karl Kuchenbecker is dead because the Parole Board was more concerned about being fair to Burton and not taking into account unproven allegations, than it was about making sure violent psychopaths are not given parole.

At your original trial is when you get innocent until proven guilty beyond reasonable doubt. And that is as it should be. But once you are a prisoner you do not have that luxury. You are guilty and have been sentenced to a jail term, which you should serve in full unless you are an exemplary prisoner who is deemed most unlikely to reoffend.

What other changes should be made? Or are you happy with the status quo and we have to accept the deaths of Karl Kuchenbecker as just bad luck?

Burton Parole Review

Well Corrections and the Parole Board have both reviewed their actions with regards to allowing Graeme Burton out early on parole, and both have cleared themselves. What a surprise.

Stephen Franks is scathing of the reports, labelling them a cover-up. Go read his blog for a great analysis of the report. Stephen summarises the thinking of the Parole Board as this:

In other words, having discarded all the inconvenient evidence that Burton is dangerous, including the psychologists’ judgments that he remained a high risk, and the Board’s unavoidable knowledge that their conditions are pie in the sky, and the action of of prison officers in fear of Burton, then it is reasonable to decide that there is not enough evidence that he might be a danger.

The Sensible Sentencing Trust has also called the reports a whitewash. And one of Burton’s victims after he was released notes:

The board ignored information that Burton was facing allegations of serious assault in jail, Mr Rae said. And, even with the allegations aside, a psychologist had warned the board Burton was at medium to high risk of violent reoffending.

Yet the Government is claiming it was the right decision on the facts known???

Party Party Party

The organisers of National’s “40 Below” Party have asked me to do a quick promo.

This is on Friday 23 March at the Rendezvous Hotel Ballroom, (formerly the Carlton Hotel Ballroom),on the corner of Vincent Street and Mayoral Drive,

They have an excellent mix of politics, music and vodka!

The festivities start at 6.30 p.m. and you’ll hear from Geoff Ross, Founder and Chief Vodka Bloke of 42 Below, plus National Leader John Key.

sarahbrown.jpg

Kiwi Musician Sarah Brown provides the vocals. A N Herald review of her is here.

Looks to be a great fun night. The $40 ticket covers finger food and beverages until 8 pm, and that party keeps going on a cash bar until late.

You can order tickets from [email protected] or phone Kate on 09 522 0940

Why student associations should be voluntary

If one ever needed a reason for why student associations should be voluntary, look at this report on the VUWSA Exec:

These people run an organisation with a couple of million dollars budget, which is forcibly funded by every student.

We have:

* The Welfare VP jumping onto a stage where someone had just flashed their breasts, to make sure she was “okay”
* Then she attacks the President for not defending her from the crowd who made fun of her
* The Education VP is attacked by the President for being too hungover to do his duties

And this is the first week of the year. Muppets indeed.

Talking of Salient, I did like this tag for the new MyVictoria portal. They tagged it “Like MySpace, but with fewer paedophiles”

McCarten on Auckland

Matt McCarten is worried that the combination of overseas trips and and attempts to ban billboards may seal the fate of the centre-left Auckland City Council in October.

It would be a pity if that is why the Council is thrown out, because there are so many better reasons.

The main would have to be the explosion in rates. Backing the Mallard stadium proposal is another. Giving money to quacks who claim to speak to the dead is also on my list. Oh and cutting down the trees.

Coddington on MPs making a difference

Deborah Coddington shines a welcome light on the often unseen side of being an MP – helping constituents. She uses Sandra Goudie as an example of someone who isn’t a robust performer in the House yet has taken a marginal seat and turned it into 10,500+ majority because she is so highly regarded as a local MP for her work on their behalf.

I hate draws

God I hate draws. And to have two in a week means that I scored a miserable 16 points only.

However most people did as badly. so I have ironically gone up the ratings. My global rating is up 11,888 to 28,747. And am 17th= out of of 85 in the bloggers challenge (Name: NZ Bloggers, Password: dpf).

The top three on the challenge are Peter McCaffrey on 142 points, Andrew Thompson on 140 and Michael Harbrow on 137. I have 121.

The top score for the week for 26 points within the challenge. That is out of a possible 72 points.

Globally the top scorer is on 185 points, and the top score for the week was 58 points.

Rates Increases

The Dominion Post sums up local body rates well:

Any business that continuously raised prices by three times the rate of inflation with no discernible improvement in the quality of the services it offered would soon find itself bereft of customers and courting bankruptcy.

Amnesty International

I used to be a very proud member of Amnesty International some years ago. Like Red Cross, whom I used to work for, I saw it as a devoted humanitarian organisation which helped those detained and tortured around the world without regard for the politics of the government involved.

I attended a couple of meetings of the parliamentary section when I worked there, and it was good to see MPs there from ACT to the Greens.

But in more recent times it seems Amnesty has departed from being politically neutral and as Michael Ellis blogs it has become a socialist organisation that now has a view on income equality and distribution etc.

This is a real pity because it means that they send a message out to people like me that they don’t want our support or membership, even though I admire the work they do opposing tyrants and torture.

They risk becoming a society for the left only, and in doing so lose their strongest virtue of impartiality.

More bad news for Al Gore

Last week Al Gore was in the news for the fact that his house consumes more power in a month than the average house in a year. This week it has been discovered that the company he buys carbon offset credits from is part owned and chaired by himself.

So in other words he buys his carbon offsets from himself.

This doesn’t mean that Gore is wrong about global warming, but it does mean that like so many he prefers to talk the talk than walk the walk.

Disturbing Headline

A quality broadban plan

The new Telco Act requires Telecom to offer a wholesale broadband product capable of supporting “real time” applications. In response they are developing a new product which will have performance guarantees and a higher guaranteed sustained information rate (SIR) of between 60 and 100 kilobits per second (standard now is 24).

This looks to be a good step forward giving ultimately the consumers the choice between packages with and without minimum performance levels. The price of course will be a key issue.

Oh stop grandstanding

Politicians Hubbard and Clark should butt out of the Clint Rickards issue.

Hubbard, by coming out declaring he doesn’t want Rickards as Auckland Police Commander has probably just forced the Police to write a blank cheque to Rickards. Any possibility they had of formal disciplinary procedures has been made much more difficult by Hubbard’s outburst. Any semi-decent lawyer will be able to point to what he Mayor said and cite it as an improper influence on police decision making when Rickards is not re-appointed.

So if Rickards walks away with a million dollars, blame politicians who can not keep their mouth shut.

Meanwhile the PM is talking about a need to change the rules of evidence. Umm sorry Helen, but guess who was Prime Minister when the Evidence Act 2006 was passed??? I’ll give you a hint. It’s someone very very close to you.

So despite being Prime Minister of the Government that just last year passed a new evidence act, you didn’t then try to amend the law to allow defendant’s histories to be made known to juries? Why not? And what are you now proposing that your Government couldn’t have done last year?

UN Funding

Iain Dale has been to the Conservative Political Action Conference in the US, and has a mixed review.

What I found interesting was John Bolton pointing out that to win a vote at the UN you need 97 votes, and the bottom 97 members contribute only 0.3% of the UN budget. So those who fund 0.3% of the UN can decide where 100% of the budget is spent.

And talking of politics, somehow announcing your candidacy for the most powerful position on the planet is best done on a late night comedy chat show, so above see John McCain announce on the Dave Letterman show he is running for President.

More views on ex-Police

It’s still the topic of the day.

Kerre Woodham thinks most people had heard of the previous conviction, and doesn’t think Rickards can return to his old job.

Michael Laws labels it an unwinnable case, and attacks the current Police culture as being too influenced by the “sisterhood”.

The SST has a lengthy interview with Clint Rickards. Obviously he has a partisan view of what happened, but I find the allegation that Lousie Nicholas made 17 different statements to the Police, with them being varied to paper over inconsistencies, disturbing if true.

Sue Bradford Interview

Teacher-Student Afffair on Bebo

I find it interesting how people often don’t see an Internet discussion as “public”. The Wairarapa teacher and student who ran off together have been refusing public comment, yet as reported in the HoS, her Bebo page has been full of recriminations between her, her ex-bf and her sister etc.

TVNZ On Demand

Throng has a preview and review of the new TV On Demand site. Check it out as it has screen shots and lots of details.

The currency for the site will be playpoints. You start with 10 free ones and then they cost 50c each. A 30 minute show (23 mins without ads) is 4 points or $2 and a 60 minute show (44 mins) is 8 points or $4. The licence lasts for seven days only!

The site uses RSS (yay) and shows to go on there include Shortland Street, Eating Media Lunch, Rude Awakenings, One News, Breakfast, Karaoke High, and NZ Idol, Also some classics shows such as Radio With Pictures.

More Hubbard Fun