Contradictory stories in NZ Herald

Today John Roughan writes about how he, like many people, knew about the Mt Maunganui rape convictions.

But Roughan asserts:

And you can guarantee the jury did not know. If the defendants’ lawyers had got the slightest suspicion that any word of their clients’ convictions had reached a juror they would have had the trial aborted.

Yet the NZ Herald reported yesterday that

Brad Shipton’s brother-in-law Chris Foot told Newstalk ZB: “Jury members approached our family last night, yesterday evening, and actually said that they did know.

And Peter Winter, past president of the Criminal Bar Association, said:

“No one in their right mind could believe that the jury didn’t know about Shipton and Schollum’s previous conviction,”

So does John Roughan not read the stories in his own newspaper, or does he just not believe them? šŸ™‚

I personally am with Peter Winter and would be amazed if at least some of the jurors did not know.

Group Sex Frequency

The NZ Herald has taken the “throwaway” remark from Clint Rickards’ lawyer that half of NZers have engaged in group sex as an excuse to write a story about how frequent it is.

They dig up a Durex survey which found 26% of NZers have admitted to group sex. Well that is 26% of NZers who fill in durex surveys, so I would assume it is probably less than 20% overall.

What they don’t distinguish between is MFM group sex and FMF group sex. I suspect the former is far more frequent than the latter. I know quite a few people who have had a FMF threesome, but only one person who has had a MFM.

Fran O’Sullivan on police misconduct

Will time-outs be illegal?

The latest turn in the smacking debate is an opinion by a QC that even placing your child into time-out cold be illegal under Bradford’s bill.

I really can’t work out why they don’t support the Borrows amendment. It will achieve pretty much everything Bradford has claimed she wants to achieve, without all the legal uncertainty.

Ex Cops face further allegations

Lots more dirt coming out of the woodworks.

The NZ Herald has a story on the prosecution of John Dewar for attempting to obstruct or defeat the course of justice. This has been suppressed. Ironically I accidentally broke some suppression details on the case by blogging something about Dewar off memory, totally unaware that the suppression order covered those details. There’s an interesting issue here about how do you not break suppression orders you do not know the details of.

There is a new allegation against Rickards – that he had sex in 1983 with a woman on the bonnet of a police car. From what I can see there is no suggestion the sex was non consensual, but it may be used to stop him being reinstated on behaviour grounds.

Also a very lengthy profile of mainly Shipton, and various people he has slept with.

And finally a further allegation against Shipton of forced oral sex, that the Police did not investigate at the time.

Kiwiblog Stats Feb 2007

Visits up 10.6% on January
Average duration – 406 seconds

Domains of Visitors

New Zealand nz 334090
Network net 99436
Unknown ip 98126
Commercial com 90,415
Australia au 18,569
Thailand th 3,909
United Kingdom uk 3,785
Czech Republic cz 3,492
Saudi Arabia sa 3,348
USA Educational edu 2583
Info domains info 2423
Canada ca 2282

Hosts

pspc18-241.parliament.govt.nz 2428
node5.moh.govt.nz 1978
vuwunicoproxy03.vuw.ac.nz 1845
tur-cache2.massey.ac.nz 1749
inetgate.msd.govt.nz 1553
mswfb1.parliament.govt.nz 1121
watson.comcom.govt.nz 1051
gate1.ird.govt.nz 1025
apngw6.apn.co.nz 959
staff-4.networking.otago.ac.nz 902

Top Pages

/2007/01/the_cyfswatch_blog.html 2475
/2007/02/the_unforgiveable_sin.html 2356
/2007/02/field_to_be_expelled_from_labo.html 1731
/2007/02/teaching_conspiracies.html 1692
/2005/05/miss_universe.html 1655
/2007/02/islam_says_bdsm_is_okay.html 1608

Operating Systems

Windows 87%
Windows XP 74%
Windows Vista 1%
Linux 1.8%
Mac 4.8%

Browsers

MSIE 60.7%
MSIE 7 20.7%
Firefox 25%
Firefox 2+ 16%
Opera 3.4%
Safari 3.0%

Incoming Referrals

http://briefingroom.typepad.com 837
http://www.scoop.co.nz 660
http://norightturn.blogspot.com 364
http://blog.greens.org.nz 265
http://www.sirhumphreys.com 224
http://andrewfalloon.blogspot.com 186
http://newzeal.blogspot.com 139

Top Search Phrases

cyfswatch 1370
david farrar 1231
kiwiblog 1158
cyfs watch 459
aja rock 449
farrar 245
kiwi blog 190
sevens photos 149
virtual super 14 145
cyfs 139
sue bradford 135
cactus kate 130

Hubbard Mathemathics

Rich at ObservationNZ has applied some maths to the Hubbard claims, and it isn’t pretty. Mayor Hubbard claimed, on the basis of his vibes, that a sister city arrangement with Hamburg would be worth $500 million of trade.

Now Rich has found that our total exports to Germany are only $894 million and Hamburg being 3.6% of the economy, would probably account for only $32 million of that.

Now further to that Auckland is, I think, just under one third of the NZ economy. So Auckland-Hamburg trade is probably around $10 million a year.

Mayor Hubbard’s vibe is that this will increase 50 fold to $500 million. All due to his visit. I think not. Let’s be generous and assume a 5% increase in exports to Hamburg from Auckland. That’s $500,000 not $500 million.

Why they were found not guilty

Peter Metcalf has done a post explaining why he thinks the three ex-cops were found not guilty in both of the last two trials. He doesn’t express an opinion as to whether or not they did it, but says neither should have been prosecuted as they were unwinnable.

He says both complainants lacked credibility (that doesn’t mean they were not telling the truth) with Nicholas having lied about a previous rape allegation, and the latest complainant having killed her own case when she said “I know poor Louise Nicholas lost her case and I am trying damn hard to make sure these guys are done”.

He is also very critical of the prosecution’s desperate attempt to discredit Rickards as a “practised liar” as he had been an undercover cop. That prosecutor will never be able to prosecute a case involving undercover cops again, or his own words will be used against him.

I just think it is a pity complaints were not made at the time, when there would have been a better chance of convictions if the rapes did occur. Having said that though, I can understand the reluctance to go to the Police, when you are complaining about three officers,

Out of laws, out of ideas

I think there is no better example of how this third term Government has no vision, no leadership and is really just drifting than the current legislative agenda.

At the conclusion of Parliament on Thursday, there are only 13 government bills left on the order paper. And of those 13, only five are actual bills the Government is ready to advance with. The others are stalled waiting for some inquiry or review. So the only five bills left for Parliament are:

Fisheries Act 1996 Amendment Bill
Disabled Persons Employment Promotion (Repeal and Related Matters) Bill
Immigration Advisers Licensing Bill
Student Loan Scheme Amendment Bill (No 2)
Appropriation (2005/06 Financial Review) Bill

Two of the bills are 2.5 years old, two are standard adjustment bills. In fact only one bill at all is what you would call fresh.

No Right Turn has also noted this lack of legislative agenda. Unlike NRT, I don’t think you can blame it on Labour being a minority government reliant on NZ First and United Future.

Labour, as a party of the left, sees spending as the solution to almost everything. They are genuinely surprised when after spending an extra $20 billion, the world is not perfect. Their instinctive response to any problem is to throw money at it. So they don’t tend to have many ideas apart from opposing the right, and spending money.

Parties of the right have a healthy scepticism over the ability of the state to do everything. While they will increase funding, they are more likely to also look at can we reform the system to make it better. Can we get better outcomes by doing it differently?

Labour really does have no agenda. Every years it invents a new buzz word or phrase. We started with Top half of OECD and they dropped that. We then had closing the gaps, and they dropped that. The current spin driven phrase is sustainability, despite seven years of no policy. It’s not an agenda, it’s a brand.

Delamere not guilty

Tuariki John Delamere has been found not guilty on all 14 immigration fraud charges. Delamere is a former NZ First and Mauri Pacific Cabinet Minister.

The schemes sounded pretty dodgy to me, from what the media reported. But the jury which heard all the evidence obviously concluded it was not illegal, beyond reasonable doubt anyway.

Women in Parliament

The IPU has just released the latest statistics on what proportion of legislators are women, in each country.

The “top” country is surprisingly Rwanda with 39/80 MPs being women, or 49%

NZ is in 14th= place (out of 189 countries) at 32%.

Australia is 33rd with 25%.

Nine countries have no women as legislators. The bottom ranked European country is Ukraine at 9%, then Russia 10%, Romania 11%, and France 12%.

It’s good to see NZ doing so well, and there is no doubt MMP has helped with this.

The stats per region are also interesting:

World 17%
Pacific (excluding Australia and New Zealand) 3%
Arab States 9%
Pacific (including Australia and New Zealand) 15%
Asia 16%
Sub-Saharan Africa 17%
Europe (excluding Nordic countries) 17%
Europe (including Nordic countries) 19%
Americas 20%
Nordic countries 41%

So the worse areas are the Pacific Islands, followed by Arab states, and then Asia and Africa.

Herald: Key establishing a reputation as someone who gets things done

A pretty positive editorial from the NZ Herald on John Key. They are right that it is very hard to actually achieve things in Opposition, yet Key is doing this. Some extracts:

National’s new leader, John Key, is fast establishing a reputation as someone who gets things done, which is never easy in Opposition. In his first major speech he challenged businesses to help provide food and sports equipment to schoolchildren in deprived neighbourhoods. While the Prime Minister and others were chipping at his incursion on Labour’s territory, Mr Key was busy with firms responding to his call. Tasti Foods donated 100,000 snack bars to the KidsCan organisation. James Crisp Ltd donated 100,000 boxes of raisins.

Mr Key is promoting the idea that we should not look to the Government for everything in social welfare, that the Government is not necessarily the best judge of what is needed and that charity is a good thing. If that last suggestion sounds obvious, it is a matter of contention by the traditional Left. Charity, they believe, is random, unreliable, demeaning for the recipient and prone to value judgments about who is deserving.

Selective tax incentives for any purpose have been out of favour for 20 years because they invite companies to gear their activities for tax advantages rather than market returns. But philanthropy is an activity outside market options. It is an investment in the social environment of business, rather like a tax payment. There seems a certain logic, therefore, in reducing a donating company’s taxation by a proportion of the amount it has voluntarily given to the community.

The difficulty is in defining a charity for tax purposes. All sorts of recreational and co-operative enterprises are likely to register as charities if it gives their benefactors a tax break. But then the virtue of independent charity is that many more people than a Cabinet contains can pick a deserving cause.

Herald slays Council

The NZ Herald seems sick of being bullshitted to by the Auckland City Council. It seems the costs of the sister city programme have been downplayed, so at the end of their article, they ran the following:

SISTER CITIES
How much do they cost to run?

* Wednesday: $120,000 a year.

* Yesterday: $270,000 a year.

Source: Auckland City Council (both days)

And in response to Dick Hubbard claiming Hamburg sister city agreement as “one of the significant successes of my mayoralty”, they point out in just two years rates have increased by 25% under his mayoralty.

Jurors knew of previous convictions

The Herald reports that some jurors have told a a relative of Brad Shipton that they did know of teh Mt Maunganui convictions.

I am not surprised. At the time of the trial, it was obvious that Shipton and Schollum were two of the accused. And those who didn’t work it out at the time would probably have heard about it after the Louise Nicholas verdict.

The article has people debating the pros and cons of allowing previous convictions to be known to the jury, and there are arguments either way.

However I am surprised that no-one mentioned the major reason that suppressing previous convictions should be stopped – it does not work. In the Internet age especially, suppression orders are like trying to stop a dam leak with a finger.

So if jurors are going to learn about the previous convictions anyway, why not have them told officially, but also told not to place reliance on it. Trying to suppress information just doesn’t work anymore.

Application of smacking law

The Herald reports that there has been debate in Parliament over how Police will act, under Bradford’s anti-smacking law. Every single complaint will have to be fully investigated under current guidelines (unlike assault complaints against motorists!) and the policy is “the majority of offenders in family violence cases will appear before the court”.

As I have mentioned previously I think the real issue will be CYFS and its interpretation of the law. The Police can only put you before a court. CYFS will be able to take your family away from you just because you lightly smacked a child for misbehaviour.

Hawkins won’t go

George Hawkins has obviously read in the Dom Post that Helen wants him gone, because he has just put out a press release saying he is definitely restanding in 2008.

They could try to deselect him, but Hawkins is pretty popular with his locals, and it would not be easy.

Hawkins is probably (in my opinion) the most incompetent Minister of recent times (and there is a fair amount of competition for that title) and he has no chance of ever making the Executive again. So I am surprised he is so determined to stay on, but if he enjoys being a backbench MP it will be hard to stop him.

Comments held for moderation

Have discovered another quirk in the system. Since being in Bali, whenever I post a comment, I get a message it is being held for moderation. I presume the IP adress range I am on over here is in a blacklist somewhere.

However I have discovered that the comments are not held in the moderation queue but just go into the junk comments queue which is very large and fast moving. Within an hour they are normally off the 1st page of the queue and I never go in there as 99.9% of the time they are junk spam comments.

This helps explain why some other people say their comments have not appeared. I think it happens only rarely, but until there is a permanent fix my advice would be that if you ever get a message saying your comment is held for moderation, then e-mail me asap with the time you made the posting and what thread it was in. That way I can recover it from the junk comment queue.

Top Ten Male Whores

A Wikipedia article on Charlie Sheen (or Carlos Irwin EstƩvez) mentioned he is thought to have slept with 5,000 women and that led me to this news article which listed the top ten male whores.

10. Bill Wyman (Rolling Stones bassist) – 1,000
9. Earvin (Magic) Johnson (basketball star) – 1,000
8. Lemmy Kilmister (Motorhead frontman) – 1,200
7. Jack Nicholson (actor) – 2,000
6. Ilie Nastase (tennis star) – 2,500
5. Engelbert Humperdinck (singer) – 3,000
4. Julio Iglesias (singer) – 3,000
3. Gene Simmons (Kiss frontman) – 4,600
2. Charlie Sheen (actor) – 5,000
1. Umberto Billo (Venetian hotel porter) – 8,000

Now Sheen is 41. Let’s assume he started at age 16 having lots of women (in reality it was probably later) so he has slept with 5,000 women over 25 years. That is 200 women a year or a different woman every second day. Of course that excludes sessions with multiple women together, or sleeping with one woman in the morning and another in the evening, but on average every two days. Now you wonder if he has 100% sucess rate at bedding the first girl he hits on, or does he have to ask three or four until he gets a yes.

Also how about all the days he is home with his wife and family. That might be half of the time, so in reality to make 5,000 he would have had to sleep with a different women everytime he was allowed out of the house. No wonder Madam Fleiss did so well out of him.

I did enjoy the humour the Denise Richards left Sheen after he said she was among the hottest 1,000 women he had bedded šŸ™‚

Kerry Tankard

Mike Heine writes about the actions of a Kerry Tankard on Vic Clubs Day. Student Choice had a stand up, and were collecting signatures in favour of voluntary membership of student associations.

A woman, Kerry Tankard, allegedly “ran up, ripped the signed petitions off our table, screwed them up and ran away laughing”. When later asked to give them back, she refused.

Tankard, who alleges she is a pacifist, sees nothing wrong with using force to deny people their democratic rights to have their views counted.

According to this account, Tankard is no better than a thug. There can be no other word for someone who behaves in such a way. She has no interest in protecting anyone’s rights, only in forcing her viewpoint on everyone else by suppressing dissent.

She appears to be a member of or activists with the Greens also. Maybe someone there who knows her can encourage her to hand the petitions back, if she hasn’t destroyed them.

I also hope that either VUWSA or VUW itself will consider disciplinary consequences.

The good thing is that behaviour such as that alleged to be Tankard’s is very rare. Most clubs days the various political party reps get on pretty well together and have a good time.

And finally if the facts as described by Mike are correct, Kerry Tankard might want to reflect that within a few days anyone searching for her on Google will find a record of what she has done, and that even in 10 or 20 years that will still be there.

The great purge continues

Vernon Small writes in the Dom Post on Labour’s plans to purge the dead wood and bring in some new talent.

I think it is commendable that Labour is confronting the uselessness of some of its MPs, and that Helen wants at least five to eight new candidates in winnable list positions. Whether the replacements will be any better is another issue.

Vernon profiles Rimutaka where it seems Paul Swain will retire but only if his replacement is not a trendy lefty. If he does convince Andrew Little to be his replacement, then that will be a very good win for Labour. Little is a very smart operator and I would not be at all surprised if he became Labour Leader one day.

Wellington Central is seen as a race between two gay candidates – Grant Robertson and Charles Chauvel. It seems business lobbyist Phil Lewin is not favoured and being pushed towards Ohariu-Belmont (which is unwinnable).

Both seats will be interesting to watch.

Two jobs for $1 million

Hubbard predictions based on vibes

Just when you think they couldn’t make bigger asses of themselves, they manage to do so.

On Tuesday Auckland Mayor Dick Hubbard said that trade links with Hamburg could be worth up to $500 million. This was in the course of defending a $30,000 sister city trip to Hamburg.

When asked yesterday on what he was basing the $500 million figure, he replied that it was guesswork based on “picking up the vibes”.

These vibes must have a lot to answer for. Perhaps they are what told him to destroy the trees on Queen Street or to ban billboards.

He really should use a more scientific method of decision making. Perhaps astrology!

Bloggage February 2007

Span has up the “Bloggage February 2007” for NZ blogs. Thanks Span.

I like the way she has divided them up with boxing categories. They are:

Fly (1 post)
Bantam (under 10 posts)
Feather (10 – 19 posts)
Light (20 – 29 posts)
Welter (30 – 49 posts)
Middle (50 – 74 posts)
Cruiser (75 – 99 posts)
Heavy (100+ posts)
Super Heavy (200+)

No prizes for guessing Kiwiblog’s placement.

Charles wants McDonalds banned

Liberty Scott reports on how Prince Charles is encouraging the United Arab Emirates to ban McDonalds.

I’m not sure about you, but frankly I don’t want a King of New Zealand who thinks it is his job to try and get food outlets he doesn’t approve of banned.

Of course I don’t want anyone to be King of New Zealand, but I especially don’t want Charles.

Snoop Sticks

200702262348.jpg

Big Brother really is watching. This is a snoopstick.

It’s a $60 USB flash drive type device that allows you to monitor what your kids, employees, or anyone using a computer is doing while on the Internet.

You simply plug the SnoopStick into the computer you want to monitor and run the setup program which takes less than 60 seconds.

The SnoopStick monitoring components are completely hidden, and there are no telltale signs that the computer is being monitored.

You can then unplug the SnoopStick and take it with you anywhere you go. Any time you want to see what web sites are being visited on the other computer, or who they are chatting with, and what they are chatting about, simply plug in your SnoopStick to any Windows based computer with an Internet connection and a USB port. SnoopStick will automatically connect to the target computer.

It can monitor both sides of IM conversations in real time or tell SnoopStick to display recent activity. Also can check the sender and recipient of every email sent or received. You can even log the user off, disable internet access, set time restrictions or even turn the computer off. All using your SnoopStick from any computer.

I’m partly appalled, and partly want one šŸ™‚

Hat Tip: Boing Boing