School Black Markets

The Government gets an agreement to remove sugary soft drinks from schools, and even this isn’t enough for the totalitarian Greens who want all soft drinks banned, even calorie free ones.

This isn’t about obesity. It’s about antipathy to large multinational companies.

How long until the Greens wants parents prosecuted for buying the wrong food at supermarkets for their kids?

Anyway the news isn’t all bad. I predict a thriving black market in soft drinks at schools from enterprising young NZers.

Australian Citizenship Tests

Australia is introducing citizenship tests for new immigrants focusing on core Australian values. This is similar to what Tony Blair has talked about and is already happening in countries like The Netherlands.

People are so wrong to classify these as illiberal. They are in fact necessary to protect liberal values such as tolerance, equal rights etc. As an example The Netherlands has had equal rights and tolerance for gay couples for some decades. So what they do is show intending immigrants and citizens a video which includes same sex couples kissing, and make the point that if this upsets you, maybe the Netherlands is not a good country to move to.

This is all part of the debate about balancing multiculturalism with integration. Both extremes are wrong. Just as a monocultural country is not one I find attractive, a country which is not integrated is even more unappealing. Now the integration may take a generation, and that is fine. But if there is no integration at all, then you have problems.

Minor Miracle

Gender Change

A NZPA story on telco views on banning cellphone in cars says:

Vodafone New Zealand corporate responsibility manager Raphael Hilbron said the company would not fight a ban on hand-held phones for drivers.

“While mobiles in vehicles have considerable benefits, including the ability to call emergency services, using a mobile while driving distracts drivers and increases the risk of accidents,” she said.

She said staff were not allowed to use hand-held phones but could use hands-free when it was safe to and this was also Telecom policy.

Now I might be wrong, but I’ve had pretty reliable reports in the past that Raph is male, not female!

Draft Energy Strategy

The Government has announced its draft energy strategy.

A lot of it is just reviews and discussions. Some specifics are:

* Increase competition in the electricity market by reducing restrictions on generation and retailing by lines companies
* A proposed requirement for major electricity generators to prepare triple bottom line reporting, including greenhouse gas emission inventories
* Establishing a contestable fund to support the early deployment of marine-based electricity generation such as wave or tidal, worth $8 million over four years
* Assessment of two price-based measures (emissions trading and greenhouse gas charges)

A long way removed from the rhetoric about the mythical carbon neutrality she aspires to.

Dom Post on John Key

John Key gets a pretty good tick from today’s Dominion Post Editorial. Some extracts:

National’s new leader, has not put a foot wrong since supplanting Don Brash two weeks ago, The Dominion Post writes in an editorial.

The reaction from the commentariat, which has long been singing Mr Key’s praises, has been equally positive. It will, however, take more than a couple of weeks of good press to make Prime Minister Helen Clark shake in her boots. In her 25 years in Parliament she has seen it all. Politics is not a race for sprinters, it is a contest for stayers and Mr Key has still to demonstrate he can perform when the going gets rough.

Nevertheless, he has put his stamp on the party and he has shown he knows where he wants to go and how he wants to get there. Those are qualities National desperately needs.

National’s willingness to be part of the solution rather than just a critic in the wilderness is a welcome breath of fresh air. So has been Mr Key’s leadership so far.

Whatever readers’ political inclinations, all should welcome the fact that the Government has been put on its mettle.

Banning

Not PC has an excellent definition of a ban:

BAN, v., Often seen as action (e.g., Government acts to ban X), but in reality a government action taken to prohibit private action. Often punishes all for stupidity of one. Assumes that policians acting hastily in response to headlines have better judgement about individuals’ action than do individuals themselves; and completely removes any possibility of judgement or of responsibility for actions. Assumes too that policing 0f ban doesn’t cause country’s laws to fall further into disrespect, and that ban is capable of being policed. Often taken in reponse to headline-grabbing tragedy

Bans should be the last, not the first resort, of a Government.

Slaughter the Cows

A new UN report has found that cows are a bigger threat to the environment than cars, as they produce more greenhouse gases than cars, planes and all other forms of transport put together.

So this makes it easy. Humans need to wipe out cows in order for us to survive. Let the killing begin.

I suggest we need incentives, so how about the UN pays a bounty of say US20 per cow killed. That will solve global warming for only US$30 billion!

Tony Blair on multiculturalism and integration

Tony Blair has given a very thoughtful and important speech on balancing multiculturalism and integration. And it is very much a balancing game. A country with no variety is boring, bland and static. But likewise a country with no common shared values and no integration between cultures is a recipe for conflict. The challenge is to get the balance right,

Some key lines from Blair:

We like our diversity. But how do we react when that “difference” leads to separation and alienation from the values that define what we hold in common? For the first time in a generation there is an unease, an anxiety, even at points a resentment that our very openness, our willingness to welcome difference, our pride in being home to many cultures, is being used against us; abused, indeed, in order to harm us.

Integration, in this context, is not about culture or lifestyle. It is about values. It is about integrating at the point of shared, common unifying British values. It isn’t about what defines us as people, but as citizens, the rights and duties that go with being a member of our society.

It is true there are extremists in other communities. But the reason we are having this debate is not generalised extremism. It is a new and virulent form of ideology associated with a minority of our Muslim community. It is not a problem with Britons of Hindu, Afro-Caribbean, Chinese or Polish origin. Nor is it a problem with the majority of the Muslim community. Most Muslims are proud to be British and Muslim and are thoroughly decent law-abiding citizens. But it is a problem with a minority of that community, particularly originating from certain countries.

The whole point is that multicultural Britain was never supposed to be a celebration of division; but of diversity. The purpose was to allow people to live harmoniously together, despite their difference; not to make their difference an encouragement to discord.

We should share a common language. Equal opportunity for all groups requires that they be conversant in that common language. It is a matter both of cohesion and of justice that we should set the use of English as a condition of citizenship. In addition, for those who wish to take up residence permanently in the UK, we will include a requirement to pass an English test before such permanent residency is granted.

Again let us not be foolish, in our desire not to cause offence. Of course the extremists that threaten violence are not true Muslims in the sense of being true to the proper teaching of Islam. But it’s daft to deny the fact that they justify their extremism by reference to religious belief.

We know migration has been good for Britain. We acknowledge the extraordinary contribution migrants from all faiths and races have made. We are a nation comfortable with the open world of today. London is perhaps the most popular capital city in the world today partly because it is hospitable to so many different nationalities, mixing, working, conversing with each other.

But we protect this attitude by defending it. Our tolerance is part of what makes Britain, Britain. So conform to it; or don’t come here. We don’t want the hate-mongers, whatever their race, religion or creed.

If you come here lawfully, we welcome you. If you are permitted to stay here permanently, you become an equal member of our community and become one of us. Then you, and all of us, who want to, can worship God in our own way, take pride in our different cultures after our own fashion, respect our distinctive histories according to our own traditions; but do so within a shared space of shared values in which we take no less pride and show no less respect. The right to be different. The duty to integrate. That is what being British means. And neither racists nor extremists should be allowed to destroy it.

I will miss Tony Blair when he retires.

Kill kids and save the planet!

A greenie group has said families should limit the number of children they have to no more than two, to save the environment.

Only a slight step away from China’s one child and you get a toaster policy.

As it so happens, every western country except I think the US has a birth-rate below the replacement rate. We need to be having more children, not less.

As Tony Alexander says, the ultimate rationale from this advoacy is that havign no humans at all would be best for the planet!

Parental Responsibility

I almost can’t believe what I read sometimes.

A group of young teenagers spent 14 hours drinking bourbon and beer, and then went driving. After being spotted by Police they sped up to 180 km/hr until they finally crashed – putting them in hospital.

So what are the reactions of the parents:

Father: “They’re not grounded, I don’t do those sorts of things.”

Mother; “It’s only the first time.”

No wonder those kids don’t have a future. Parents who think 14 – 17 year olds drink driving, fleeing Police, and crashing the car so they are hospitalised is no big thing, it just gets a warning.

Spiders Attack

Call my suspicious and cynical, but are there really over 22,000 spider attacks a year which require ACC attention?

Three of them were reportably from tarantulas, which is unusual as we have none in NZ. Maybe those happened overseas.

What would be interesting is any stats on how many people have made more than one claim in the last two years for spider bites.

Cellphones in Cars

Just because you are somewhat moronic to text message while driving a car, doesn’t mean that all cellphone use in cars is dangerous.

There is a difference between taking a 30 second phone call while at traffic lights, or moving slowly through town and trying to text message and drive at the same time. Whether or not use of a cellphone is risky depends on numerous factors – your speed, the road conditions, the length of the call, whether you are calling or receiving, whether you have hands free, whether you have a passenger.

A total ban on cellphone use is the last option, not the first option. Many many NZers gain great benefits from being able to communicate whil in a vehcile. For some businesses it is essential.

Here are some steps the Govt could take, before advocating a ban (which may not even change behaviour and just lead to lots of fines):

1) Advertising Campaign targetted specifcally at consequences of having phones distract you while driving

2) General blitz on all driving activity where driver appears to be distracted

3) Handing out warning pamphlets to drivers seen driving and on the cellphone about the risk of accidents due to distraction

4) Prosecuting more people for accidents where avoidable distractions were a factor

5) Increasing the penalties and threshold for driving and/or having an accident when distracted

Top Ten Youtubes

Stuff has an article from the Sydney Morning Herald which lists the top ten videos this year on Youtube.

What is interesting is they have embedded the videos into the story which is much better than just linking to them. It’s not often you see material which is not just a copy of a print article. It also suggests that there is some system for sharing web content between Fairfax publications.

A victory for free speech

The Government has backed down on its plans to ban advertising of medicines. This is a good thing. For the Government to ban speech (of which advertising is a part) it has to prove to a very high standard that a failure to do so will result in considerable harm. On this issue there was no substantive evidence to back a ban.

Disclosure: I have done some work for British drug firms helping them advocate the UK should adopt the same law as New Zealand in allowing such advertising. However my views on my blog are my own, not my clients, and the work was for the UK, not NZ.

Edwards on Holmes

Herald New Zealanders of the Year

Protection Orders

The Dom Post reports that there has been a big decrease in the number of protection orders being sought, and that this is thought to be due to their cost and lack of effectiveness.

Having once had reason to apply for such an order myself, I would agree with the criticisms. I found the process confusing and the Police gave basically no advice apart from saying you need to go to court. I tried at first to do it all myself but ended up having to involve a lawyer. And if the order is resisted, it can take months before there is a resolution.

My preferred form of protection order is a powerful handgun, but of course if you use one even in self-defence you end up in court as Greg Carvell has. Inicdentially you can donate to Greg’s defence fund here. Carvell, people may recall, shot a man weilding a machete trying to rob his gun store.

Digital Copyright

The Government has released its digital copyright bill.

There is some very good stuff in there such as legalising format shifting. At present it is illegal to copy a song from a CD your have purchased to your ipod.

However other parts of the bill don’t look so flash, especially the anti-circumvention provisions. InternetNZ is in the process of getting advice on the bill, and more detailed responses will follow.

For now Russell Brown has a good summary of some key issues.

Working to improve this legislation is likely to be one of the major priorities for InternetNZ next year.

Well done Chris

Victoria University Law Student Christopher Bishop has won the youth section of the Wellingtonian of the Year award. Well done.

Chris was the organiser of a major debating tournament – the Australs – and did a first class job with it. By coincidence he was also the spokesperson for the recent Keep It 18 campaign.

More Ethnic Seats

Tariana Turia is quoted in the Dominion Post as saying she wants Pacific Islanders to be able to move onto the Maori Roll, or have their own seats.

This is very revealing about Turia (and should ring some warning bells about the Maori Party). She actually supports further parliamentary seats being allocated on race – not just for Maori. Now many people are okay with the Maori seats because they think (mistakenly) that there is some sort of Treaty obligation to have them or on the basis of indigenous rights or simply because we already have them and don’t want to offend by removing them..

But if you argue for other races having seats, you are advocating for a race based parliament and society – a Fiji or South Africa model. This is one reason why we should move to end the Maori seats also – it does create a bad precedent.

So what would NZ’s 120 seat Parliament look like on a Turia model, where races get to have reserved seats for them. It would be:

NZ Europeans 66
Mäori 16
New Zealander (open to anyone) 12
Chinese 4
Samoan 4
Indian 3
Cook Islands Maori 2
Tongan 1
English 1
Korean 1
Dutch 1
British 1
Australian 1
Niuean 1
European 1
South African 1
Filipino 1
Scottish 1
Irish 1
Japanese 1
German 1
American 1
Fijian 1

I hope Turia’s comments receive widespread scrutiny. The Maori Party have had glowing reports of their first year in Parliament (which is deserved) but when their co-leader comes up with such an obnoxious and repugnant proposal, it should be publicised, scrutinised and decried.

Third Party Advertising

The Government seems to have realised that laws to ban third party advertising during elections are not workable and would probably breach the free speech provisions of the Bill of Rights Act.

Instead they wish to instigate spending limits and official returns. Now in theory this might be attractive (if a party has a limit, why not a third party) but in reality of little effect.

As an example take the Exclusive Brethren. If you have a $100,000 limit, then they could just have ten of their members spend $100,000 each. Likewise the unions could do the same by spreading it around different unions. I’m not sure any limit will be effective.

But more difficult is how do you define what is and is not third party advertising? Is it meant to cover paid advertising and pamphlets only? How will blogs for example be covered? A blog could produce far more responses for a third party than a newspaper advert, yet if you try to force blogs to register and limit what they can say, you’ll be joining the ranks of Iran and China. Would an e-mail campaign by a third party be counted?

I await specific proposals with interest, but I am sceptical that a workable law that doesn’t infringe on free speech can be easily found.

1 September 2008

Parliament has voted 104-9 to set a deadline for filing historical Treaty of Waitangi claims of 1 September 2008.

This means that there has been over 20 years to research and file claims – more than enough.

The key challenge now for Government is to resource the Waitangi Tribunal and the Negotiations Unit so that claims can be fairly and finally settled without undue delays.

Looking at the vote figures, it looks like Greens and Maori voted against and somehow NZ First abstained and did not vote.

Paris wants a baby!

Trans-Tasman MP Ratings

Trans-Tasman (a truly excellent publication) has done it annual ratings fo MPs. NZPA has a story on them.

I always like to analyse data so have put all the ratings into a spreadsheet and here are the average ratings for each party (2+ MPs), with the change from last year:

Maori 5.1 (+0.8)
National 4.7 (+0.2)
United Future 4.5 (+0.5)
NZ First 4.5 (+0.5)
ACT 4.3 (-0.7)
Labour 4.2 (-0.2)
Green 3.9 (nc)

That’s a pretty fai reflection in my book in that Maori Party is well regarded, National has had improvements in its performance, and Labour’s average is lowered by the large number of non-performers.

The Green rating overall seems harsh when you consider their poll ratings, but this is probably more driven by leftwing voters digusted with Labour, than any particular parliamentary performance. Also Russel Norman has not been ranked, and he has done pretty well and would lift their average up if he was an MP.

In terms of individual MP, some extremes are:

Top – Helen Clark, John Key and Bill English on 8.0
Second – Tony Ryall, Winston Peters and Phill Goff on 7.5
Bottom – Taito Phillip Field on 0.0
Second Bottom – Brian Connell on 0.5
Third Bottom – George Hawkins, Ashraf Choudary and Charles Chauvel on 1.0 each
Biggest Drop – Rodney Hide from 6.0 to 4.0
Biggest Increases – Lockwood Smith and Pita Paraone up 2.5 each
Second Biggest Increases – Simon Power and Jackie Blue up 2.0 each

For each party top performers are:

Act – Heather Roy 4.5
Green – Jeanette Fitzsimons 6.0, Metiria Turei 4.5
Labour – Clark 8.0, Goff 7.5, Cullen and King 7.0
Maori – Pita Sharples 6.0, Tariana Turia 5.5
National – Key and English 8.0, Ryall 7.5, Rich, Collins and Brash 7.0
NZ First – Peters 7.5, Woolerton, Paraone and Donnelly 4.5
Progressive – Anderton 5.5
United Future – Dunne 5, Copeland 4.5