Should Fiji be banned from the Wellington Sevens?

NZ has put in place a range of sanctions against Fiji. However they have not banned Fiji from attending the Wellington Sevens.

The Government claims it has no power to do sobecause it is an international tournament but as No Right Turn points out, they can simply refuse travel permits and visas.

The effect on Fiji of doing this could be massive and seriously undermine support for the Govt. Not being able to be in the Wellington Sevens would be as big as it gets in terms of disappointing Fijians.

However the price to pay is that Wellington could lose the hosting rights, either temporarily or permamently.

Is that a price worth paying? It might not change the outcome of course.

It’s very pleasing to see so much resistance in Fiji to the coup. It’s one thing to declare yourself Dictator, but it is another to try and run a country when the police and civil service won’t obey you. And great kudos to the media for refusing to be censored.

Ultimately he may find he has to actually start shooting people to get co-operation, and if so that will cement Bainimarama as a total villian.

I had a great debate on Monday night (at TVNZ Agenda Xmas Party) with Chris Trotter about the coup. He made the point that the changes Bainimarama wanted from the Government were all good ones – protecting minority Indian rights, keeping the Speight supporters out of power etc, and the debate was do the ends justify the means.

My response was that in some very rare cases military intervention can be desirable – for example the Army in Turkey is seen as the guarantor it stays secular. But that any action should be a last resort. If the Quarese Government had been in power for 4.5 years of a five year term and was doing stuff it had no mandate for, then maybe a case could be made. But they had won an election only six months ago, and had campaigned on the very policies they were implementing.

Don Brash Writes

Don Brash has responded to the Hager claims in his e-mail newsletter.

Its becomes more and more clear that Hager did not have access to a single insider, let alone six of them, and the book is based on the e-mails alone. One speech he quotes Brash as giving, was in fact never delivered – it was only drafted. An insider would know that.

2006 Census Stats

I love all the data you can get from the census. It’s invaluable for politics, for polling and just for knowing about your country. Hell I’d have them annually if I could 🙂

A few interesting facts from the 2006 Census:

* We have 4,027,947 people living in 1,471,746 dweelings which is an average of 2,74 people per dwelling
* 14% of NZers identify as Maori
* The Asian population has increased 50%, and is now 8.8%
* A massive 11.1% of respondents went out of their way to write New Zealander as their ethnic group (this is much higher than I expected – 2% in 2001)
* NI pop is up 8.1% and SI 6.7% which should mean an extra NI seat unless they have had a disproportionate number swap to the Maori roll
* We have 744 North American Indians in NZ, 201 Pitcairn Islanders, 108 Estonians, and 39 Falkand Islanders.
* The Iwi with the most members are Ngapuhi at 122,211, Ngati Porou 71,907 and Nga Tahu 49,185.
* 157,134 NZers do not speak English
* 157,100 speak Maori, 85, 428 Samoan, 53,757 French, 24,090 Sign Lanuage, 44,589 Hindi, and 15,873 Gujarati
* For primary means of travel to work, 8.3% work at home, 10.3% were not at work, 58.6% drove, 4.6% were passengers, 3.0% went by bus, 1.0% by train, 1.0% by motor cycle, 1.9% by bike and 5.3% walked
* The average number of children per female is 1.83. Of those with any children it is 2.67
* The most popular occupation was sales assistant at 93,940. We have 14,493 CEOs, 9,270 hairdressers, 9,084 lawyers, 6,996 sewing machinists, 6,075 Sales/PR Managers and 3,069 market research analysts!
* 36.7% of NZers have no religion, 15.7% Anglican, 14.3% Catholic, 10.9% Presbyterian, 1.8% Hindu, 1.4% Ratana, 1.2% Mormon, 1.0% Muslim, 0.2% Jewish and 0.1% Exclusive Brethren
* Only 2% of households have no telecommunications systems, 74% have cellphones, 60% Internet access
* There are 867,696 male-female couples, 2,655 male-male couples and 3,516 female-female couples. Hence only 0.7% of official couples are same sex.
* 112,758 households have no motor vehicle but 222,204 have three or more
* The median age is 35.9 years, but for Maori only 22.7 years
* 23.7% of Maori speak Maori
* The number of people living in the Willis Street Area Unit has increased 51% since 2001, and up 22% in Thorndon.

Oh I could spend days going through all these tables!

National backing electoral reform

National has agreed to back electoral law changes to prevent donations through trusts and third party advertising, but has sensibly pointed out that the electoral law changes needed are not just in those areas, but also much higher penalties for breaches of spending caps.

At the end of my Electoral Act series, I blogged some recommendations for changes to the Act. They are:

* Increase maximum penalties under the Act for corrupt practises from $4,000 to $1 million and from one year to three years in jail.

* Increase the penalties for illegal practies from $3,000 to $100,000

* Remove the Police from having a role in prosecutions.

* Amend the Electoral Act to allow parties, not just individuals, to be held liable so different people in a party can’t just point the blame at each other.

* Amend the Electoral Act so prosecutions can be commenced within 12 months, not six.

I will be very interested in exactly how Labour plans to limit third party advertising during campaigns, because I can’t see a way to effectively doing this without affecting free speech. National should be very wary of the details in this area before agreeing to support them.

Spam Bill passes second reading

The anti-spam legislation passed its second reading yesterday. Pleasantly surprised it was passed unamiously (on a voice vote).

The law will come into effect six months after the third reading, so probably in June 2007.

One of the possible outcomes from the law, will be a central point where one can send spam to, to help in trackdown down major league spammers. In Australia the anti-spam agency has actually crated a plugin for Outlook which allows you to report spam to it (crucially it forwards it on with the full headers included) with the click of a button.

Fiji Coup

In the old days, it was very clear if a coup had happened. Soldiers seize Parliament, close down the press and play songs non-stop on radio and TV – and you know you have a coup.

But the latest Fijjian one is harder to call. The PM is under house arrest, yet still in charge of the Government.

Most annoyingly how can one book cheap post-coup holidays, until it is clear that the coup has happened.

A frantic week

The remaining four days of this week are pretty frantic. I’ve just checked into a hotel in Auckland, and got three meetings during the day up here, then on National Radio’s The Panel from 4 pm to 5 pm.

Then at 6 pm is the Agenda (TVNZ) Xmas Party. Could be a late one!

Unfortunately early tomorrow I have to catch an early flight to Wellington for an InternetNZ meeting, then a meeting with TUANZ and then a client meeting. And Wednesday evening is that Nats’ Xmas Party.

Thursday is back to Auckland and due to returning concert goers there are no seats left, so driving to Palmie it looks like and flying up from there which will be a pain. Meetings until 7 pm, so staying overnight.

Then Friday have an Electoral Commission seminar on Maori participation which kicks off at 10 am. By chance this is at Wgtn Airport so at least I’ll be able to head straight into it when I land!

I think I’ll have to delay catching up on sleep until the weekend!

Rudd defeats Beazley

Rudd’s election may be good news for Australian Labor. Beazley couldn’t beat Howard but Rudd will have some chance of doing so. But whether he can unite his party behind him is the big question.

Very very tragic though that Kim Bezely learns his brother has died minutes after the vote to roll him.

Fun in London

It was a fun two weeks in London. I didn’t do any tourist stuff this time, and felt like an old hand navigating my way around.

I stayed near the Docklands in the East End, which saw me every day tube to Tower Hill and have a lovely walk past the Tower of London through St Katharine’s Docks to the apartment.

london1.JPG

These are the docks. The apartments on the waterfront would be very very expensive.

london5.JPG

The tower on a typical day.

london4.JPG

This is a statue of the Roman Emperor Trajan in front of some of the original city wall. of Londonium.

The only thing that was really bad in London was it gets dark a bit after 4 pm. That’s seriously weird.

Currently in Hong King so almost home. Was somewhat late for the flight from Heathrow, in that I got transported at high speed on one of those indoor buggys to my departure gate. Was quite fun actually, and best of all my upgrades came through so it was the joys of business not cattle class.

Meeting Margaret Thatcher

Well it’s no surprise that the highlight of the two weeks in London was meeting Margaret Thatcher (or Baroness Thatcher more formally).

We were extremely privileged to have her attend. On medical advice she rarely does functions since 2002, but she has always had a soft spot for the IYDU, of which she is incidentally the Patron.

The reception was held in a private apartment next to the Thames. But that under-states it. The apartment takes up the entire second to top floor of one of the largest buildings and you get the most magnificent view up and down the Thames from all four sides of the apartment.

It’s hard to put into words what meeting Margaret Thatcher is to someone like me who started to follow politics just as she became UK Prime Minister. She shows how one person can make a difference. Her impact was huge on both the UK and the world.

When I was at school, most of the population believed that a global nuclear war against the USSR was probable in the next couple of decades. Movies were done showing this. The doomsday clock was updated regularly (I doubt anyone has checked it for the last ten years). If you’re on the centre-right like me, you thank Margaret Thatcher and Ronald Reagan for winning the cold war and not surrendering with unilateral disarment as many wanted. And even my American friends concede Mrs Thatcher was the dominant one of the pair.

Now if you think those of us from the Anglo-sphere were keen to meet Lady Thatcher, well that is nothing compared to the huge number of Eastern Europeans in attendance. They quite literally see her as the person who did more to secure their freedom than any other person.

With so many in the room, obviously one didn’t get much time with her, but I did mention how I had worked for NZ’s 1st female Prime Minister (of whom she approved), and of course thanked her. She posed of course for a group photo with Kiwis and Aussies.

thatcher.JPG

I’ll blog more photos of the meeting and functions later. Plane back home about to leave!

Cigar Trouble

I blogged about the stories regarding National’s Associate Health Spokesperson Jonathan Colman yesterday, but somehow the post never appeared, so I’m retyping my thoughts up.

My first reaction is that the man who whinged to the media is a pillock and should be facing criminal charges. According to their own testimony (ie without even hearing the other side of the story) they:

(a) yelled abuse at Colman for him smoking a cigar in a private box which was not theirs
(b) squirted water at him
(c) then punched him

If some **** stranger squirted water at me, I’d tell them where to go also. Sadly though MPs have to be more restrained, which is just one of many reasons why I would not be a good MP.

I do think it is a bad idea for anyone with the portfolio of health to be smoking, and/or accepting tobacco hospitality. That’s not a good look.

For other MPs though, I do not believe there is any real issue. I’d sure as hell not turn down U2 tickets from BAT. Hell I’d even accept them from the Labour Party.

Now some get excited that MPs are somehow getting “brought” when they accept minor hospitality such as rugby or concert tickets. That is ridiculous. You don’t buy policies for $200. The going rate is at least $500,000 🙂

As one example I have in the past been the recipient of some lovely hospitality from BAT. Nevertheless I am quite avidly anti-smoking and if I was ever an MP I would happily vote to increase taxation on it to as high as possible, without creating a black market in it. I would of course balance that with tax cuts elsewhere!

The Libertarian Alliance

By coincidence, the annual conference of the Libertarian Alliance was in London on the last weekend of November, and I was invited to attend so happily did so. The Libertarian Alliance “is a non-partisan group fighting statism in all its forms and working for the creation of a truly free society”. They don’t stand for Parliament themselves, and are very inclusive – welcoming all strands of libertarianism.

The conference was in the ancient halls of the National Liberal Club.

NLC1.JPG

A young Winston Churchill – one of the more famous former Liberal MPs.

NLC2.JPG

One of the lounges.

I really enjoyed the two-day conference. The range of speakers and topics was fascinating – from Space Entrepreneurship to Radical Islam to Sex Freedom.

The session I found the best was the one on whether Radical Islam and the West are in a culture war, and that very rare thing happened – my views changed somewhat, or refocused anyway, as a result of it.

One of the speakers was Claire Fox, who incidentally was a long-standing member of the Revolutionary Communist Party. She made an excellent case that much of the hatred young Muslims are showing towards the West doesn’t come from reading the Koran, but they are reflecting the self-loathing that is so common in the West – as exemplified by Michael Moore and almost any university faculty in Europe. She said you can’t label Islam as being anti-Science when Greenpeace are far worse offenders with their unscientific opposition to GE etc.

I thought I would come out of the session more firmly convinced that radical Islam (or Islamism) was incompatible with western values of a secular liberal democracy. But Fox convinced me that the situation is not that dire – that much of the problem comes from Western political leaders kowtowing as they did with the Danish cartoons etc.

The session on sexual freedom was great also. The key speaker was John Pendal from the Spanner Trust. John was Mr Leather International 2003!!

The Spanner Trust was formed after a group of gay men were prosecuted for having consensual sadomasochistic sex. Under UK law, any marks or injuries which are more than transient and trifling can be prosecuted – even if consensual. Technically a hickey is an assault. In 1990 16 men were sentenced to up to 4.5 years jail as the result of a 4 million pound investigation into consensual SM behaviour.

Amazing to think one could get sent to jail for consensual activities. It led to a good discussion about laws restricting consensual sexual activities in a number of countries.

So all in all was a fascinating two days. Also was great to meet up with so many libertarians or classical liberals from Europe and the UK, plus renew some old friendships. Europe now has 140 broadly classical liberal think-tanks and the like.

Wasn’t the reason I came over to the UK, but was very glad the timing worked out and I attended.

Another stadium petition

Frank Haden

Very sad to read that Frank Haden is dying of prostrate cancer. The sad irony being that he has campaigned for 15 years or so for the Health Ministry to do prostate cancer screening in the same way they do breast cancer screening.

They also have a long interview with him, about his career.

More PC nonsense

I beleive in a secular state. Many on the left claim to beleive in a secular state also, but they lose their principles when it comes to so-called Maori spiritual beliefs.

The HoS reports on how police and Transit are helping arrange for 10,000 litres of Waikato River water to be sprayed on a motorway to free the spirits of fatal accident victims.

Now this is bad enough, but listen to the weasel words from the Police to justify this:

“There are a lot of people who believe in this”

Bullshit. I’d say not even 1% of Maori actually believe this. They may support it being done as a custom, but I doubt any sane person honestly honestly beleives that God is so capricious that if you die in car crash you stay in limbo for ever until the tapu is lifted in that road. Doesn’t matter than you might be Joan of Arc – no tapu lifting, no heaven. And God knows what he does with all those who die overseas – obviously only NZers go to heaven – every other dead person in the world still has their spirit stuck down here.

PC Plod then says:

“It’s not a religious thing”

I’m sorry, but how is freeing spirits not a religious thing. It’s certainly not an agnostic or athiest thing.

“It’s a Maori belief”

Okay so Mr Plod has redefined this from being religious to being a “belief”. What the fuck is religion except beliefs.

“Everett said there was no cost to police aside from time.”

Yeah and what good is time except to catch criminals.

Incidentially I would have no objection at all to local Iwi wanting to do this, just as I have no objection to Catholics, Anglicans or Scientologists also wanting to practice their beliefs. What I object to is the time and money of the so-called secular state being part of this.

Drugs in Prison

The SST has an interview with the guy who tried to crash his plane into the Sky Tower because his wife had left him. One part I have to highlight:

“Prison’s where you go to get drugs. It’s incredible, I’ve never had drugs in my life. I had the opportunity to experience every type if I’d have wanted.”

No wonder prisons are havign such limited sucess with rehabilitation. Getting prisons drug-free should be a prioirity, even if it means less visitor contact etc.

NZ’s Watergate

Fran O’Sullivan quotes the principal Assistant United States Attorney on Watergate:

“When people cannot get together for political purposes without fear that their premises will be burglarised, their conversations bugged, their phones tapped … you breed distrust, you breed suspicion, you lost confidence, faith and credibility.”

The illegal acquistion of a year’s worth of e-mails from the then National Leader, Caucus and staff, is something which the Parliamentary Service must ensure never happens again. The variety of sources of e-mails quoted more and more rules out that these were in anyway leaked. It is obvious someone has copied one or more entire personal mail files over, and this could not be done by any MP or political staff member,

National should insist to The Parliamentary Service that enhanced security features are put in place, so they can use e-mail with confidence. Based on what I can see, I would not be confident current e-mails are not also able to be illegally accessed.

Some things National should insist on:

* Full audit trail of every access to a persons’s e-mail file
* IP tracking of where accesses were made from for each user
* Easy Tracking of every forward, delete, copy, print
* Encryption
* Ability to prevent e-mails being printed or forwarded without passwords
* Automatic password prompts after non use for a time
* Random checks on all IT staff and contarctors to ensure all file accesses have been in relation to helpdesk calls

Probably much more than that. A security consultant should be hired to draw up a plan, and the Speaker needs to insist it be implemented asap.

Wellingtonista Awards

The Wellingtonista has the results of their 2006 awards.

Someone voted for me as a write-in candidate for “Most baddest wickedest evilest supervillan of the year” but alas Kerry Prendergast won the title. Would be cool if the title came with a prize such as a vial of polonium-210.

A good first week for Key

Most of the pundits seem pretty impressed with John Key’s first week in the job.

John Armstrong writes:

Key’s ruthless dumping of Gerry Brownlee as his would-be deputy and equally merciless easing of Don Brash out of Parliament altogether smacks of a style not that far removed from the Prime Minister’s own modus operandi.

Key’s decisiveness in part reflects a managerial ethic that new chief executives make a real impact in their first 100 days.

Years of dithering over National’s stance on nuclear ship visits have been blown away in an instant. While the few hawks in National’s caucus might grumble, Labour will no longer be able to exploit the ambiguity and confusion surrounding National’s previous stance.

Murray McCully

Aussies and Apples

Shouldn’t the horse be charged also?

Well done Dr Cullen

Dr Cullen has done well to squash the misguided arrest warrant for Moshe Ya’alon issued by the DIstrict Court. As Dr Cullen points out he is not sought by the International Criminal Court.

It will be interesting to discover (assuming the media ask) who was really behind the court application which was done in the name of Auckland company director, Janfrie Wakim.

National Reshuffle

John Key has announced the reshuffle and it is a wee bit more extensive than expected. Changes are:

John Key – from 4 to 1, drops Finance, gains SIS
Bill English – from 3 to 2, drops Educations, gains Finance
Gerry Brownlee – from 2 to 3, drops Maori Affairs and Treaty Issues, gains SOEs and Energy
Simon Power – from 7 to 4, drops Police, gains Commerce
Nick Smith – stays 5, drops Energy, gains Climate Change
Tony Ryall – stays 6
Judith Collins – from 8 to 7
Katherine Rich – from 9 to 8, drops SOEs, Economic Development, gains Education
Maurice WIlliamson – from 13 to 9

That is the front-bench but Key has announced a full shadow cabinet down to No 16. Major changes are:

Wayne Mapp from 14 to 13 gains Defence and Auckland Issues, loses Political Correctness Eradication
Chris Finlayson from 18 to 14, keeps Attorney-General, gains Treaty Negotiations and Arts
Tim Groser from 17 to 15, gains Trade and Associate Finance
Anne Tolley to 16, from Junior Whip to Chief Whip

I think Chris F wil be very happy – they are the three portfolios he has very significant backgrounds in. Nathan Guy becomes Junior Whip after just a year – also a good move. Chester Borrows gains Police, which should please them and him.

Very pleased to see Katherine Rich get education – will be a nice challenge for her, and more in the spotlight than Economic Development.

Also with Maurice on the front bench, that may be a first to have Comms and IT there.

I suspect Labour will criticise it for Georgina and Tau, who share Maori Affairs, not (yet) being in Shadow Cabinet. However I am sure one of them will be eventually, and Treaty Negotiations will have a real expert with Chris Finlayson.