More on National and Environment

Auditor-General’s Report done

The Controller and Auditor-General has announced he has completed his report on on his inquiry into advertising expenditure in the three months before the 2005 General Election.

However it will now be released on Thursday instead of Tuesday. The reason for this is to allow the Speaker’s response to the report to be tabled at the same time.

The news does not look good for Labour. Their last desperate attempt to avoid repayment had been to ask Kevin Brady to only report his findings in his role as Auditor-General and not in his role as Controller which necessitates the Vote Minister reporting the breach to Parliament. The announcement today says:

The Auditor-General Kevin Brady has decided to exercise his powers under the Controller function to direct the Speaker of the House of Representatives (the Speaker) to report to Parliament.

Oh Thursday is going to be a fascinating day.

Brash on Tax

Don Brash gave the keynote speech this morning to the tax conference of the NZ Institute of Chartered Accountants which I have been attending. He was somewhat surprised to see me there, asking if I had become a tax accountant in my spare time 🙂

Some key quotes are:

From the outset, [the busines tax review] it was hyped by the Ministers of Finance and Revenue as being a big and bold review, the bigness and boldness of which might frighten its readers. When it arrived, however, the Review turned out to be anything but big and bold. In fact it was an embarrassingly lightweight document. It was like being promised a Lamborghini and getting a Lada!

Let me say that we would support a proposal to drop the company tax rate to 30%. This was in fact a key plank of our tax policy at the last election. We think the headline corporate tax rate does matter, given we are competing for capital with countries spread right across the globe. Across the OECD, the trend is for corporate tax rates to decline. The average company tax rate in the OECD is now 27%. A cut in the company tax rate would make New Zealand a more attractive destination for capital, and boost business investment.

The reality is that Michael Cullen has long been opposed to tax cuts, and in particular to business tax cuts. Pressure from Labour’s coalition partner United Future might have brought him to the tax cut well, but we should wait and see whether he is really prepared to drink from it.

As we’ve also recently seen with the KiwiSaver Bill, having the Government come in at the last minute and make major changes to tax bills, after the Select Committee has heard submissions, makes a mockery of the tax policy consultation process. It will be poor law-making indeed if people are not to be allowed to make submissions on these latest proposals, and have them analysed properly by the Committee.

Finally, I would like to talk briefly about National’s position on tax more generally.

If there is one message I would like to leave you with this morning, it is that National’s overall policy on tax remains the same as it was last year and the year before that, and the year before that.

Put simply, we remain committed to lowering tax rates over time. I’ve always been of the view that if New Zealand is to be a more prosperous country, with per capita incomes approaching those of the top countries in the OECD, then we need to reduce tax rates. In particular, we need to substantially reduce personal income tax rates.

This is not to say that such reductions can or should be achieved overnight, or in one large round of tax cutting. A National Government would have other priorities as well, in education, health, law and order, defence and the environment, amongst others, and we believe in effective public services and strong public institutions.

What we need to do is to embark on a programme of incremental tax reform, reducing the tax burden over time as we can afford it. In this regard, Australia is an excellent example to us, having either cut tax rates, or increased tax thresholds, in each of the last five years.

In contrast, we have been standing still, if not going backwards. The shame is that over recent years we have had every opportunity to lower tax rates. Every surprise in the tax take has been on the upside. The Government has had an embarrassing amount of tax revenue to spend, with Core Crown revenue growing more than 60% over the past seven years. But it still couldn’t bring itself to allow those who earn the income to keep a little more of it.

But while our overall tax policy has not changed, the precise formulation of our policies will have to wait until closer to the next election, when we see what shape the economy is in.

Labour and ACT are trying to paint this as some sort of backdown on lower taxes but they are being silly. Anyone who thinks Don Brash is not serious about cutting taxes, doesn’t know him very well. All that has happened is that specifics can not be pledged until the level of surplus and debt in 2008 is known. Treasury estimates this far out can vary by billions so one has to wait for firmer figures.

Super Fund

I feared when Dr Cullen set up the Super Fund, that politicians would try and interfere with investment decisions. One can just imagine the Greens wanting to invest it in a chain of hemp stories, NZ First in export industries, Maori Party on their pet causes. Of course the effect would be a lower rate of return and the 80 year olds get their pension cut as we’ve run out of money.

Not true to form the Greens are demanding the Fund stop investing in ExxonMobil, because shock horrot they don’t agree with the Greens on climate change and fund groups which are sceptical.

Considering the huge variety of things the Greens want to ban (fast food, large easter eegs etc), I can’t see the fund making much money if they get their way.

Blue-Greens

Vernon Small previews the Blue-Greens conference this weekend, and likely directions for National on environmental issues.

With Labour having done a u-turn on environmental policy, the door is open for National to attract votes from the more conservative end of the environmental spectrum. The indications look promising based on the conference agenda.

Direct-to-the-consumer drug advertising

The Government is looking to ban Direct-to-the-consumer drug advertising.

In a society which values free speech, any ban on advertising has to meet a high threshold to be justified. the burden of proof has to be on the Government to justify that the level of harm from not banning such advertising is so great as to warrant a ban. This is a vital point – the onus is not on drug companies to prove they should be allowed to advertise, the onus must be on the Government to justify a ban.

Unlike No Right Turn, I don’t see any evidence to support a total ban. There are standards of advertising which require adverts to be truthful. There are health standards any drugs advertised must meet. One could even develop a more rigorous advertising code for drug advertising.

Banning advertising is an assault on free speech. Now free speech is not without limit – the classic example being no right to shout Fire in a crowded theatre. But a ban on advertising should be the last resort.

The trend in recent years has been empowering health consumers so they have more information on which to make decisions – not just relying on health practitioners. Again restricting information should be done very very reluctantly.

Masochist Quote filled

There’s been a few dozen very generous offiers of moderation assistance from readers. I don’t have time to respond to each of them yet, but will do so next week.

My intention at this stage is to conduct a trial for six weeks or so. At the end of the trial I’ll evaluate the pros and cons of the trial. I am very open minded on this issue, and my natural inclination is as little moderation as possible.

Another way I may be able to manage things better is by use of Typekey to authenicate commentors. Typekey will allow me to whitelist most people making comments with new posters being delayed until vetted, and after say three good posts they automatically get added to the whitelist.

My problem is I can’t get Typekey to work on the blog. I had an authentication key and have plugged it in, but it always gives anb error message when used. If there are any experts out there in Movable Type/Typekey please yell out ([email protected]) and I can give you access to the backend so you can work out what is wrong. And yes Sarah I am thinking of you 🙂 but anyone with experience will do!

More Foley accusations

A former chief of staff to disgraced former US representative Mark Foley has alleged he approached House Speaker J. Dennis Hastert’s office over three years ago, and repeatedly implored senior Republicans to help stop Foley’s advances toward teenage male pages.

If this is true, and it has been denied, this could cause a massacure at the mid term elections. A very very badly managed issue for the Republicans. They should have told Foley the moment they heard of this issue to tidy up his act, or resign.

No promotion for Helen

Looks like Helen won’t be “ascending” to the UN Secretary-General job. The UN Security Council latest straw poll has South Korean Foreign Minister Ban Ki-moon with 14 favourable votes and one no opinion. This is the first straw poll which had permament members with veto rights using a differently coloured ballot. None of the Big 5 were oppossed.

So on the 9th he will formally be nominated for the role by the Security Council, and this will then go to the 192 member general assembly for ratification.

Despite being a Cabinet level Minister, Ban is actually a professional diplomat.

David Cameron on Civil Unions

Iain Dale blogs approvingly on the following extract from David Cameron’s leader’s speech to the Tory Party Conference.

Pledging yourself to another means doing something brave and important. You are making a commitment. You are publicly saying: it’s not just about me, me me anymore. It is about we – together, the two of us, through thick and thin. That really matters. And by the way, it means something whether you’re a man and a woman, a woman and a woman or a man and another man. That’s why we were right to support civil partnerships, and I’m proud of that.

This is a welcome step forward for the Conservative Party.

Even Enemies Have Rights

Even Enemies Have Rights is the title of a NZ Herald column by former Labour PM Mike Moore.

Is it about the US treatment of illegal combatants? No. It’s about NZ Labour and the Brethren.

Moore dislikes the Brethren. He says they have some appalling views, their views on the role of women and God in society are medieval, and are reactionary and cruel.

Moore however defends their right to spend their money as they see fit, within the law. He asks why is there a deafening silence from those who campaign for civil liberties?

Because, from a liberal perspective, it’s hard to defend people who oppose everything you stand for. All the more reason to stand up for your opponents’ rights. That’s what makes us better than them.

The threat to change labour law because the Brethren are “enemies of the state”, as Stalin once described opponents, is dangerous.

If you oppose the Government, will the next step be to investigate their tax status? Have they a tax privilege and preference as a church? But then what?

These are political responses to a political threat, a slippery slide to the kind of Peronist politics we witnessed during the worst excesses of the Muldoon National Government, when police reports on MPs, and Security Intelligence Service reports, were made public by the Prime Minister.

Communists and their foul practices did exist in New Zealand. They did their best to destroy us social democrats. However, it was wrong to destroy their civil liberties in the name of wider freedom in New Zealand.

It says a lot when even your former Leader compares your behaviour to Muldoon!

The truth is coming!

The Google CEO, Eric Schmidt, has predicted during a UK visit that in the near future voters will be able to check instantly whether or not statements made by politicians were correct.

A similiar service already exists in the US. The excellent Fact Check site is used by millions and was even cited by US Dick Cheney in a debate. It’s not instant but it’s pretty quick.

Our own civil rights struggle

Masochists Wanted

I am seeking two to four masochists moderators for Kiwiblog. The role of the moderators will be to remove or edit any comments which breach the comments policy for the blog , and to warn and if necessary suspend posters who breach the policy.

A number of people have said that they believe the comments section can be made more useful with a tighter clamp down on things. I’m willing to give this a try to see how it works, but don’t have the time to do it all myself.

So I’m after up to four people who are willing to give up some of their time to help out. I’m thinking we do a two month trial and then review how sucessful, or otherwise it has been.

Moderators will be given access to the backend and have the ability to edit, delete and blacklist. We’ll draw up amongst ourselves cleqar criteria for these and also decision making procedures (such as least two moderators to agree to blacklist someone).

If you are interested in helping out, e-mail me [email protected]. Selection will be at my sole discretion.

Brash complains to Police over Electoral Act investigation

Don Brash has written to Police Commissioner Howard Broad outlining a list of concerns about the investigation which failed to lay charges for Labour’s over-spending.

This is an area I know more than a little about. If you go through my Electoral Act archives, you will find a very detailed analysis of the huge flaws and blunders the police made with their investigation. My conclusion was that it was either incompetence or cowardice.

This was not a marginal call. It was not a borderline case. It was a slam dunk. A prosecution would have taken ten minutes of court time. Does the pledge card influence people to support Labour? If so, then Labour have over-spent.

The Police did not make one or two minor mistakes with their investigation – they stuffed up almost every single aspect of it. They looked at wrong clauses, they used wrong definitions, they failed to gain necessary information, and right up until their announcement of no action they were displaying a fundamental ignorance of the law. Words fail me for how appalling the investigation was. My conclusion is that the Police should have the power to prosecute for electoral offences taken off them and handed over to the specialist enforcement agencies.

For the record their decision not to prosecute National over the GST error was also clearly wrong (I suspect they did so to balance up not prosecuting the other offences). National said it admitted responsibility for the error, and it should have gone to court for judgement and a fine.

As I said back in May, there have been other cases involving Labour Ministers – specifically Helen Clark, David Benson-Pope, Pete Hodgson, and David Parker. In those cases the decisions made not to prosecute, while debatable, were reasonable decisions to make. I have actually said they were on balance the right decisions. They were certainly decisions on which reasonable people could disagree.

This case is vastly different to those other cases. It was not a marginal call. The only issue for debate should have been whether to makes the charges illegal or corrupt practices.

If anyone wants to defend the adequacy of the Police investigation, I strongly suggest they read the 33 posts I made, and the linked police reports before they kneejerk conclude it should be defended. It really is an indefensible botched job.

If any media want some expert commentary on the issue, I am happy to provide it. I can almost quote the police reports from memory!

UPDATE: No Right Turn agrees there is legitimate course for complaint, and that the basic failure of the police to enforce the law calls the competence of our police into question. He rightly notes that little can now be done except to change the law, but it would help the police credibility if they acknowledged their investigation was sub-standard.

UPDATE2: Am on NewstalkZB at 6.10 commenting on the issue.

DPF in Christchurch

I’m in Christchurch from Friday to Sunday, attending (believe it or not) a tax conference. This finished lunchtime Saturday so will be catching up with friends Saturday evening. Not sure how many bloggers or blog readers are around in Chch, but if anyone wants to do drinks on Saturday afternoon, I’d be persuadable!

Fixing a leaky tax system

The Centre for Independent Studies has published a short paper on how to fix NZ’s leaky tax system.

The paper focuses on the increased avoidance and evasion since the top tax rate was increased by Labour from 33% to 39%. This has seen the following:

* 50% increase needed in IRD funding over the last five years
* The number of loopholes is increasing, not decreasing
* Trustee Income grew 256% from 1999 to 2004 (it is taxed at 33%)
* Greater use of companies to avoid higher tax rate – 71% in company tax as against only 16% increase in non PAYE income tax
* A 6.3% decrease in the number of taxpayers earning over $1 million (they are going into tax shelters)
* A huge increase in the number of taxpayers who cap their income at $60,000

The IRD themselves have warned the IRD warned that they were at full capacity and that one of their key challenges was keeping up with ‘demonstrable shifts in customer behaviour in response to current policy setting.’

The CIS reminds us that a broad-based low-rate system with few loopholes is the most efficient. When the top tax rate was lowered in the 1980s from 66% to 33%, tax revenues actually increased!

The simple answer is to abolish the 39% tax rate. It is probably costing more in compliance costs, than the revenue it brings in.

The NZ Institute of Chartered Accountants has joined the debate, saying a complex system ultimately benefits few at the expense of all.

Miss World 2006

DPF Broadcasts

Awatere-Huata gets a bonus

Sigh. The Pipi Foundation has given Donna Awatere Huata a bonus of $60,000 for work allegedly done two years ago (when she was meant to be an MP!).

Good to see the Government has stopped any direct funding of Pipi.

UPDATE: Donna says she will turn the bonus down. Good. Mind you John Tamihere once said the same thing!

Christian Heritage Party winds up

Last June I blogged that there was no future for Christian Heritage and they should wind themselves up.

Today they agreed with me, and have announced they are closing down.

They did manage to have one MP in Parliament for a few months, but otherwise their legacy will remain the betrayal of their values by their founder Graham Capill.

I can’t say I will miss them.

The vilification of Don Brash

If Labour had passed so called “hate speech” laws as they wanted to, then they would arguably by the first people in the dock right now for their language against Don Brash.

In the last couple of weeks, members of Helen Clark’s Government and party have labelled Don Brash

* cancerous
* corrosive
* evil
* malignant
* malevolent

This sort of demonisation is almost without parallel in a western democracy. Not even the US President gets described in such terms by Democratic lawmakers. In Canada, UK, Australia, Ireland, Sweden etc such language would never ever be used against a major political figure.

Even going back to the days of Muldoon in NZ, and I can’t recall Muldoon having to resort to such labels for his opponents. And Muldoon’s conduct should be seen as a low, not a high.

Helen Clark’s Government has engaged in a calculated strategy of personal vilification and destruction of Don Brash’s character. I fail to understand why – do they fear him so much?? Is the shame of having come within a few thousand votes of losing the unlosable election to him, to much to bear?

Regardless of what the motivation is, it is an ugly lowering of already low standards of discourse in politics. It is also a brutal assault on freedom of speech.

One can agree or disagree on the wisdom of the comments Don Brash made (and I’m not one who thinks they were particularly useful) but one should be able to make such comments without being implicitly compared to Adolf Hitler. Those sort of jibes are unworthy of a country’s Foreign Minister – in fact they are unworthy of even a 12 year old.

How can one have a debate on issues around the Treaty when saying something the Government disagrees with gets you labelled cancerous, malignant and evil? This is the speech of hysteria and hatred which Chris Trotter should be concerned about.

New Zealand deserves a better Government than one which labels its primary opponent as evil, sinister, cancerous, malignant, corrosive and malevolent. They are unfit to hold office, if that is their means of trying to retain such office.

Spin Awards

I can’t decide who should win the spin award this week.

Should it be Pete Hodgson for kicking 20,000 off waiting lists to then claim as a triumph new funding which won’t even put half of them back on (and to make matters worse the funding isn’t new)?

Or should it be Annette King for claiming a staggering increase in violent crime is due to a new computer system?

Herald picks up the hypocrisy

The NZ Herald has written a substantive story on the hypocrisy shown by Peters in labelling Dr Brash evil and implicitly comparing him to Hitler for comments which are very similiar to ones Peters himself made in Sep 2000. As far as I can tell online, the Dom Post and Press have not reported this.

Now Peters has said you can’t compare the two sets of comments, but of course you can.

Brash’s comments in Sep 2006were off the cuff and specifically in response to a speech advocating a seperate justice system for Maori. His actual words were:

“The judge’s comments put him at odds with my view of the way New Zealand should proceed,” said Dr Brash. “He continues to talk as if the Maori remain a distinct indigenous people.

“There are clearly many New Zealanders who do see themselves as distinctly and distinctively Maori – but it is also clear there are few, if any, fully Maori left here.

“There has been a lot of intermarriage and that has been welcome.”

Now look at what Peters said in Sep 2000:

* He used blood quantum as the basis on which to get rid of the Maori Seats
* He refers to Maori having “only a few drops” of Maori blood
* He suggests non pure-blood Maori should get less from Treaty settlements than pure bloods
* He challenges the whole notion of Treaty claims and settlements due to the diluted blood quantum

And this was in a pre-prepared speech.

And again in a different speech he repeats the 1 in 512 blood reference. He also says:

The biggest mistake the advocates of the “closing the gaps” programme make is believing that there is a large disadvantaged population in New Zealand clearly defined as “Maori”.

That is an ethnic myth. It’s about as silly and offensive as those who think that all Asians are the same.

There are actually a vast variety of so-called “Maori” people from different socio-economic, geographic and political backgrounds as diverse as those of us with a European heritage.

A single Maori ethnic identity is largely the creation of the ignorant and the bigoted as is the term “urban Maori”.

And how is this for trying to remove identity from urban Maori:

Maori relate back to tribe – to origin and ancestry. They know precisely who ethnically they are.

If you can’t or don’t do that how Maori are you?

Why then in the name of many of these people – Maori in appearance only – are all these social and economic policies being concocted?

Also just last year Peters was attacking the official Stats definition of Maori (which is self-identification) as “shonky” and too large.

Is charlatan the right label for what we are seeing?

VUWSA Election Results

Congratulations to Geoff Hayward on being elected VUWSA President, beating incumbent Nick Kelly. Peter M has the results.

Jeremy proved pretty good with his predictions.

It would be nice if VUWSA with its millions of dollars could put results on its website instead of relying on bloggers for them.