Ads that never make it to air

One nice thing about having been involved at the national level for the last few campaigns is that you sometimes get to see the ads that never get used, especially the hyper-aggressive attack ads. I can recall watching a couple of these and almost crapping myself at the thought of the ad being broadcast, yet a litle part of me wanting to see people’s faces when they watch it.

Anyway below is a GOP ad which was produced but never aired in the US. It makes fun of the Democrats having given the North Korean dictator a basketball signed by Michael Jordan in 2000, as a sign of goodwill so they will not produce nuclear weapons.

I suspect more people may end up seeing the ad on You Tube than if they had used it!

Hat Tip: Drudge

Seven down, one to go

Labour are now the sole party refusing to pay back any illegal or unauthorised expenditure, as United Future today announced they will pay back any sum identified by the Auditor-General.

So if we had medals, they would be like this:

Gold Medal – no unauthorised or illegal epxenditure

Progressive

Silver Medals – have already paid it back

National
Maori Party

Bronze Medals – have said they will pay it back, once confirmed in the final report

ACT
Green
NZ First
United Future

Last Place – still assert they are above the law

Labour

UPDATE: United Future are not in fact agreeing to pay back any sum the Auditor-General finds is illegal or unauthorised. In a move of supreme arrogance they have said they will pay back only $4,960 which they agree with, and ignore the other $40,000ish unless explicitly instructed to by the Speaker. The Auditor-General is a neutral official and if he finds money was illegally spent on an unauthorised purpose, then it must be repaid regardless of what the former Labour Party President thinks.

The great tax plunder

crownrev.JPG

This graph shows dramatically how much extra money the Government has taken in. The late 90s with tax cuts saw revenue stay fairly flat, but since then under Labour it has increased wildly.

In six years tax revenue have gone up 62.4% and total crown revenue is up 84.3%. And how much do we get back? 89 cents a week in 2008! Think if the tax take had “only” increased by 50% over six years instead of 62.4%. That would mean $4b a year having stayed with taxpayers.

Of great concern to those who believe in a relatively small state, crown revenue as a percentage of GDP is at a record 48.8%. Yep only 1.2% off the state being bigger than the private sector.

More political super-heroes

With National’s David Bennett having labelled his foe “Spider-Man”, this has inspired David Slack to assign more super heroes and villians to political figures. He has:

Black Widow: Helen Clark
Iron Man: Don Brash
The Guardsman: John Key
Kro: Rodney Hide
Moloids: Civil Servants
Maelstrom: Trevor Mallard
Red Skull: Ian Wishart
Professor X: Russell Brown
Dark Phooenix: Laile Harre
Wolverine: John Tamihere
Mr Sinister: Heather Simpson

Oh yeah, and myself as the Green Goblin 🙂

As a comic book fan for many years I have to say Mr Slack has picked the characters well. Especially Kro!

A wasted opportunity

Last year’s surplus has been confirmed at $11.5 billion, indicating New Zealand missed a golden opportunity to reduce the taxation burden on New Zealanders.

Without even touching a cent of Government expenditure, the Government could have delivered multi-billion dollar tax cuts to taxpayers.

What this shows is that no matter how large the surplus, Labour will never deliver significant reductions in taxation, They see it as their money, not our money.

The more useful OBERAC surplus of $8.6 billion started life as a projected $3.854 billion surplus for 05/06 in the 2001 DEFU. The May 2004 budget said it would be $4.994 billion. At the start of the year in question it was projected to be $6.665 billion. And even just a few months ago in the 2006 budget it was forecast at $6.977 billion. It’s grown like a tumour – $1.7b in six to ten weeks from the budget in May to the end of the year at 30 June.

This reinforces my long held view that Treasury are far too conservative with their forecasting. It also indicates that any suggestion future tax cuts are unaffordable because of the relatively smaller forecasts over the next few years, should be ignored. The projected surpluses will double in size on average, plus they have a $2 billion per year slush fund included in them for new expenditure.

National has said that tax cuts will be incremental, and this is of course no different from the 2005 policy which was to be introduced over three or four years. But on today’s figures we should be talking about some pretty large increments – certainly much more than Labour’s 89c a week personal tax cuts.

Send in Spiderman

Hone only helping Hones

I suppose it is inevitable when you have race based rolls and seats, but Hone Harawira refuses to assist any person who comes to his office seeking help, unless they are on the Maori roll.

That is his right of course, but nevertheless regrettable and divisive.

I’ve never heard of an MP in a general seat who would refuse to help someone who is on the Maori roll, not the general roll.

John Carter sums it up well (and John is known as an outstanding MP in terms of working to help locals with problems):

I think it’s an honour. I’m paid by the taxpayer to assist anyone in New Zealand, regardless of who they are, what their background is, no matter what their ethnicity is.

But to be fair to Harawira, this can be seen as a logical consequence of having race based rolls and seats.

Google and You Tube

Today’s news that Google has purchased YouTube for US$1.65 billion is a good reminder of how a quality product can beat a good brand on the Internet.

We saw this with Google itself. Prior to Google most people used Alta Vista for searches. It si now basically defunct.

Google has many great products. But last year when they launched Google Video, their site wasn’t that great. You Tube on the other hand had better features, better viewing, great use of tags etc and within months almost everyone was using You Tube instead of Google Video.

This is the great thing about the Internet. Quality is rewarded. You can produce the bets hamburger in the world but you won’t overtake McDonalds for market share without a couple of decades to spare and a huge marketing budget. On the Net market share can flow and ebb within weeks.

You Tube has 100 million (yes million) video clipes viewed a day, with an additional 65,000 also added on daily. Juha estimates their bandwidth is 200 terabytes a day!

Anyway the three founders who set this up are now all massively rich – because thay had an idea and a vision and followed it through. Capitalism at work 🙂

A lack of gravitas

Just been observing a classic case of lacking gravitas in the House. Normally the House would hear the views of the NZ Foreign Minister on the North Korea nuclear test with interest and respect.

But Winston couldn’t help himself. He did around ten points of order in a row trying to demand absolute silence during his answer. Instead of just ignoring a couple of quips as he was standing up, he can’t help himself (just like with the McCain interview) and he leaps in.

The more Peters objected, the more a National MP would interject and sure enough he would react again. When Peters finally got around to trying to actually say what NZ was doing, he actually started giggling in response to one interjection by (I think) Brownlee.

A minority of one

The Sunday Star-Times had a good interview with Gerald Hensley who has just published his memoirs. A must buy for political junkies.

There was a wonderful line from the interview where Hensley asks Lange why he failed to get cabinet agreement to a visit from the USS Buchanan. Lange said that he was in a “minority of one” on the issue.

Hensley goes to to note how the previous Prime Minister regarded being in a minority of one as a comfortable working majority 🙂

Absolutely classic, and true!

Quoting the Progressives

From the NZ Herald:

The only party that did not spend election money illegally, the Progressives, says it was not hard to keep within the rules during the last campaign.

And when it was unsure, it asked the office of the Auditor-General himself, Kevin Brady.

Former list MP Matt Robson, who could perhaps still be in Parliament if the Progressives had dipped into leader Jim Anderton’s parliamentary budget, said “there was no ambiguity”

.

Vodafone buys Ihug

One of my ISPs, Vodafone, has just purchased my other ISP, Ihug, for $41 million.

Juha has the news, as one expects.

This is a very very smart purchase for Vodafone. It gives them the No 3 ISP and it also gives them a company which provides fixed line calling. The advantage to Ihug is an owner with some very deep pockets to invest.

So a very good deal for both companies. Potentially not quite so good for the market as more and more ISPs are getting purchased by larger ISPs and/or telcos.

But Ihug and Vodafone both have good records of innovation, and for now at least Ihug will remain a seperate company with its own CEO which is good.

Ihug have been my primary ISP for just over ten years since I discovered the Net in 1996. Hopefully they will be around in another ten.

North Korea does nuke test

Radio Live Breakfast

I’m on the Radio Live Breakfast Show tomorrow with Martin Devlin discussing the pledge cards and Auditor-General’s report. Should be on at around 7.20 am.

UPDATE: Thanks to North Korea I’m now on at 6.40 am. Another reason to hate Kim Jong il.

Sep 2006 Polling Newsletter

Curia‘s September 2006 Polling Newsletter will be out this evening with the latest summary of the polls in New Zealand, the US, the UK, Australia and Canada.

You can subscribe to the newsletter at this page.

pollsep06.JPG

The graph above shows the monthly average for the polls since the election. The Sep result is interesting when you break the National-Labour gap into the first half and the second half of the month. The gap was only 1.9% in the first half and 8.1% in the second half – reflecting what a turbulent month it was.

ASPA Awards

The ASPA Awards were held at the weekend. ASPA is the Aotearoa Student Press Association and the awards are sponsored by the Listener.

The award winners are:

Best Cartoonist: Jeremiah Yen – Craccum
Best humour writer: Nicholas Holm – Salient
Best news writer (unpaid): Claire Barry
Best news writer: John Hartevelt – Critic
Best Cover: Craccum
Best editorial writer: Ryan Sproull – Craccum
Best education series: Salient for its coverage of the financial issues of the Victoria University of Wellington Students Association.
Best feature content: Salient
Best feature writer: Ryan Brown-Haysom – Critic
Best Design: In unison and Salient
Best small publication: Magneto
Best publication: Critic (Salient 2nd,. Craccum 3rd)

Congratulations to all the winners and nice to see Otago and Vic leading the way as usual. The quality of student newspapers has certainly improved since I wrote for Critic and Campus News in the late 80s!

Oh and while talking things students, I must point out this week’s presidential column in Salient by Nick Kelly. Nick, who lost re-election to Geoff Hayward, slams Labour and Young Labour accusing them of wanting to control student associations so they can serve Labour not students. Not exactly what you call losing graciously. He also makes serious accusations about the competence of his predecessor.

Oh yes he also calls for a workers’ revolution to end capitalist oppression 🙂

National Radio

Was a fairly fiery debate on National Radio this morning in their politics segment.

I am a huge fan of Kathryn Ryan (it has been painful having her away for a few weeks) but for once I have to criticise her for not having done her homework on the pledge card issue.

She has made the same mistake as the Police in thinking the issue of whether the pledge card should have been paid for by the taxpayer, affects whether it is an election expense under the Electoral Act. It does not.

The Chief Electoral Officer clearly advised Labour prior to the election that advertising can be classified as an election expense, regardless of who pays for it. The Parliamentary Service Handbook makes it clear that some parliamentary expenditure can still be counted as an election expense. And finally the Wairarapa Electoral Court ruled that some parliamentary expenses of Boorman, counted as alection expenses also.

Two media criticisms

Two events last week were, I believe, poorly covered by the media.

The first was Winston Peter’s ridicolous attack on Don Brash, labelling him evil for the comments over bloodlines. The fact that Peters said the same thing six years ago was a major story. If the media can tut tut for months over whether Don should be calling Labour corrupt over the pledge card, they should be highlighting the hypocrisy of what Winston said, and the fact his comments can only be seen as a way to demonise Don Brash – not actual outrage over what he said.

The honourable exceptions go to the NZ Herald and NewstalkZB for their coverage. The Dom Post however almost totally ignored this.

The second relates to the Brash letter to the Police Commissioner. I heard and read more coverage of Annette King accusing Brash of various sins than what Brash said. There has been almost no analysis of the substance – was the Police investigation competent. Unless one read it on the Internet, the average NZer would have no idea of the substance of why Brash wrote that letter.

Who is leaking?

Already there appear to be leaks as to what is in the final Auditor-General’s report. Now this is curious as unlike the draft report which went to 120 people, there are, from what I can tell, only two copies of the final report.

One is held by the Auditor-General and one is held by the Speaker.

So if there are leaks, which one is leaking?

ACT may go with Labour

ACT has said it would go into coalition with Labour if Labour signed up to significan tax cuts.

This is pretty sensible stance to take from ACT’s point of view. By leaving open the possibility you could go with either major party, you increase your relevance and bargaining power. The Greens are the clasic case of being impotent and taken for granted because they ruled out ever ever supporting National.

However ACT do also need to be aware that changing one’s status from definite ally to probable ally, does mean you can’t complain when National says that the only way to make sure your vote will help kick Labour out, is to vote National and not for a minor party.

Who stole the e-mails?

On Agenda yesterday Winston Peters alleged “An insider stole them from inside the National Party, the National Party know who that person is.”

Don Brash has said this is rubbish and said Peters has a duty to go to the Police if he knows who committed a crime.

Labour rightfully deplore the EB hiring private detectives to look for dirt on them. How they can justify having their Government using e-mails stolen from the Leader of the Opposition is outraegous. In the USA a candidate found to be in possession of materials taken from an opposing candidate is pilloried if they do not immediately return them. Politics should be higher than using stolen e-mails to score political points.

If Labour and NZ First do not return the stolen e-mails, then they can have no cause for complaint if private detectives are following them around.

State owned THL to buy Ihug?

The SST speculates state-owned Transmission Holdings Ltd may be about to buy the ISP Ihug.

It’s certainly a logical area to get into – Ihug’s retail operations could work well with THL’s network infrastructure.

However it has to bring into question for how long should THL remain owned by the Government? The Government is best to act as a disinterested party concerned about the national interest and regulatory framework, not as the owner of one of the commercial competitors.

Keisha Castle-Hughes pregnant

Saturday Night BBQ

Well someone remind me in future the game “I have never …” should be banned, or at least never played in polite company.

One of the more interesting BBQs I’ve been to. Mainly because when Grant said the BBQ was brand new, he meant it is still in the box and has to be assembled. Four hours leter we finally had it working, mainly thanks to the arrival of John who cheated and actually followed the instructions rather than go off instinct like the rest of us.

Was amused to get back to my hotel sometime after midnight, to find that the Sunday Star-Times had already been delivered. Less amused to find that the front page photo of me was not the semi-decent one I had supplied, but instead the most dopey photo of me in existence. Grrrrr. In the past this could lead to a blood feud lasting generations.

Ouch – shot 68 times

A fugitive gunman who killed a US Deputy was shot 68 times when located by police.They fired 110 shots at him, so that’s around a 60% hit rate.

Polk County Sheriff Grady Judd lamented “That’s all the bullets we had, or we would have shot him more,”

Could you imagine the uproar if that was said in NZ by a police officer!! 🙂

Hat Tip: Scott Adams