Rodney and Heather Interview

When Rodney and Heather were in the UK they met up with top UK blogger Iain Dale, and were interviewed for 18 Doughty Street TV.

Without the time pressues of commercial TV, it’s great to be able to have a more in depth interview. A nice watch for a relaxing Sunday.

Helping MPs pay it back

Some Labour MPs are saying they may not be able to afford paying back the money owing. Well I have a solution to help them out.

A backbench MP looks to be up for $5,900. Well if Labour moves to introduce National’s 2005 proposed tax cuts, then they’ll be paying $5,000 less tax which would almost cover their debt.

This way all working NZers would benefit from their actions, not just the 50 of them!

The tale of two pledge cards

A fascinating phenonema on Trade Me. There are two Labour Party pledge cards up for auction.

The first is being sold by the Labour Party itself. It specifically asks people to bid as much as it was worth for them.

The result – one bid of $20.

Then we have an auction of the exact same card. However this one is being sold to help fund the Darnton v Clark lawsuit and reminds people that as they have already paid for it once, why not pay for it again.

There have been 66 bids, with the auction now at $425.

The public have spoken!

By the way do you check out the questions and answers on the Darnton v Clark auction. There’s almost 100, and many of them are very very funny.

Hat Tip: Whale Oil

By popular demand …

I’ve had over two dozen people e-mail, text or call me asking me to link to Fran O’Sullivan’s column, so by popular demand, here is Fran on the battle of Helengrad.

The first four paragraphs are below:

We won. You lost. Eat that!” No, we’re not talking about Finance Minister Michael Cullen’s crowing over Labour’s dirty election victory.

We’re talking about the roar from the courageous journalists, bloggers, National Party MPs, gutsy public servants, and lawyers who dug deep into the electoral-spending scandal.

They faced down vituperative abuse from the Prime Minister, her colleagues, and minor party leaders until sufficient public pressure was created to force the political parties to dip into their pockets and pay back the $1.17 million they purloined to fund advertising campaigns for last year’s election.

More than a bit of champagne has been quaffed in Wellington this week, as those who have put their reputations and careers on the line to do battle with Helengrad toasted a victory that was sorely needed if New Zealand’s reputation as a corruption-free country was to be maintained.

Independent life does exist in NZ First!!

Dail Jones has been re-elected President of NZ First, despite Caucus putting up their own candidate, MP Barbara Stewart, against him. This is quite literally possibly the first time ever a vote in NZ First has not gone the way Winston wanted it.

It had been widely reported the Caucus wanted Jones gone as he spoke openly about the need to prepare for life after Winston. And he even again referred to this issue in his conference speech, remarking that Peters, like Jones was in his mid 60s.

Treating Labour like a taxpayer

Labour have said they will repay the $824,524 but not until 30 June 2007. Very nice of them to unilaterally decide their own repayment schedule.

Incidentially I think people should be extremely sceptical of their agreement to repay, until the money is in the bank. This is the same party which wrote to the Chief Electoral Officer before the election and said we will agree to include the cost of the pledge card in our election return. And then a few weeks later wrote again to say they had changed their minds.

Anyway if Labour were a taxpayer (instead of a taxstealer) and were owing money to the IRD, how much money would they have to be paying back?

First of all we start in Sep 2005 with a debt of $824,524. There’s an immediate penalty of 1% and a firther penalty of 4% seven days after it is due. Therefore $41,226.20 is added to the bill. Then a firther 1% penalty each and every month until June 2007. The total penalties come to $214,376.24.

Then we have use of money interest. The current rate is 13.08% and it is applied to both the principal and any penalties (but not to compunding interest itself). This sees around $10,000 a month average in interest which totals by 30 June 2007 the sum of $ $228,367.59.

So if Labour were subject to the same regime inflicted on taxpayers, their total debt would have gone from $824,524.00 to $1,267,267.83.

Now they may also get a penalty for the original error. The IRD scale is:

* Lack of reasonable care 20%
* Unacceptable tax position 20%
* Gross carelessness 40%
* Abusive tax position 100%
* Evasion 150%

One can debate where on the scale Labour would be. I’d go for gross carelessness myself.

And if one really struck the IRD Inspector on a day when they were grumpy, they could get hit with a further 25% for obstruction. You could argue the attacks on the Auditor-General by the PM constitute obstruction.

Easter Trading

he NZ Herald reports on a submission against trading on Easter Sunday. What struck me was the arrogance of the arguments out forward:

“I feel that people can manage surely one day without the shops being open.”

Hmmn, so this one person has decided to speak on behalf of all NZers.

“I’m sure the shops aren’t making any extra money by being open on a Sunday.”

And now she speaks on behalf of all business owners

“I think people can change their shopping day to another day.”

And now she decides for all New Zealanders again.

NZ Herald editorial

The NZ Herald editorial is so outstanding, I am repeating it below word for word. Kevin Brady deserves our thanks indeed.

Editorial: Honourable man stands his ground

Friday October 13, 2006

Few public officials have performed their duties more bravely and honourably than the Auditor General, Kevin Brady, in investigating unlawful election spending by political parties. His report yesterday, confirming that all but one party in Parliament mis-spent taxpayers’ money promoting themselves in last year’s election campaign, was a powerful example of an independent watchdog standing up for the public. Yet what is remembered of the Brady inquiry will be the circumstances of its preparation and completion as much as the consistency of its verdict.

It is hard to recall an instance of a public servant, an officer of Parliament no less, being subjected to the menace and derision heaped on Mr Brady since his draft view was leaked in mid-year. The Labour Party and its leader, Helen Clark, in particular, reacted with a venom that has been well documented once it became clear Labour had dipped into taxpayer funds to the tune of perhaps $800,000 for electioneering purposes. Not only was Mr Brady second-guessed, and the judgment of the Crown’s top lawyer, then-Solicitor General Terence Arnold, scorned, but Helen Clark challenged Mr Brady’s right to speak publicly to the Herald and elsewhere about his inquiry. Labour was not alone, and the leader of its tiny support party United Future, Peter Dunne, forever removed his claim to being the voice of common sense by also attacking these officials. Other parties and individual MPs were quick to claim errors by the Auditor General in their own cases and tried to paint the inquiry as flawed and collapsing under the weight of their responses. Much was made of Mr Brady’s view being at variance to the clearing of previous such spending by his office, and the Prime Minister and others tried to put words into his mouth about the need for retrospective legislation to validate the unlawful spending.

In the final report, presented to Parliament yesterday, Mr Brady confirmed a substantial portion of his earlier findings. He and his staff held their nerve despite a campaign of disinformation by a club of the politically powerful who were willing him to abandon his draft views and accept their contortionist justifications. His inquiry necessarily hit the rawest nerves in the political sphere – those of party leaders and their blurred accountability between the parliamentary and the party political – and the response he engendered was fierce.

Part of Mr Brady’s concern reported yesterday focuses on the failures of the Parliamentary Service to administer correctly the spending from these leaders’ budgets. He is right that there was a failure to stop illegitimate spending, but the service has as its commissioners, or board of directors, MPs from these same parties that were demanding that money be released. It is in an invidious position. Still, as Mr Brady has shown, public servants are there to act on behalf of voters, not politicians, and the service needs to take a hard look at its values.

It goes without saying that Labour, and all other parties exposed for the misappropriators that they are, had to pay back all taxpayer money. Spare us the spin, the attempts to curry favour with the public for undoing a wrong with a right.

Voters will never know how the election results were affected by this unlawful free-for-all. Without Mr Brady’s integrity, independence and fortitude, they might never have got to the bottom of what was, truly, a scandalous episode. His refusal to be cowed makes him a leading contender for any accolade of New Zealander of the Year, 2006.

Trade Me Pledge Card Auction

Ensuring the small parties pay back

Regardless of whether or not political parties agree with the Auditor-General’s decisions on what expenditure was illegal, refusing to pay money back is not an acceptable option.

You either seek a judicial review of his findings, or you respect the rule of law. Many taxpayers do not agree with IRD decisions on what they owe, but they don’t get to decide whether or not they pay.

NZ First, United Future and the Greens are looking very hestitant about paying back their respective debts of $157,934, $71,867 and $87,192.

I have a proposal. If any party refuses to pay their money back, a group be formed to fund-raise the exact amount owing, and that money be spent during the election campaigning against that party specifically on the issue of their putting themselves above the law. For United Future this campaign would focus on Ohariu-Belmont, and for the other parties it would be targetted either nationally or in seats where their Leader is standing.

I have no doubt we could raise the money. There are a lot of very very angry people about. And we don’t just want paid advertising – we want people attending every Meet the Candidate’s meeting in every electorate getting up and reminding people about any refusal to pay back illegal funds. We want letters to the editor etc. We want the major issue for voters considering supporting those parties to be this issue. We want every candidate for those parties to have to defend the non-repayment of illegal taxpayer funds.

Labour have finally done the right thing (in paying it back – does not nullify doing it in first place though), and it is unacceptable that the other parties do not do the same.

New billboard

PAY IT BACK!!!

This video will remain at the top of my blog until 2 pm Thursday 19 October when the Speaker will report back what parties have agreed to pay the money back, or at any earlier time when it is made clear. Remember everyone to blog or e-mail links to it to keep the pressure up for all the parties to pay it back!

UPDATE: Labour listened to my advice in the Sunday Star-Times, which was to announce they were paying it back the same day as the report comes out. Helen CLark has just confirmed Labour will pay it all back. Excellent. Need to keep pressure on NZ First and United Future to do the same.

What the Speaker says

The Speaker recommends four things:

1) Validating Legislation (even if all paid back)

2) Reimbursement – Wilson says it is not normally required but in this case must be “considered seriously” to maintain public confidence in Parliament.

3) Fix Up Parliamentary Service Processes

4) Temporary legislation to define better what expenditure is legal

She doesn’t accept all the legal advice on which the Auditor-General based his opinion, but accepts his conclusions.

The next key date is Thursday next week when Wilson will report back to the House which parties have agreed to pay the money back!

Stolen Money per vote

Andrew in comments has done a neat table showing how much money was stolen (okay illegally spent) per vote received per party. It is:

1. NZF; $1.16 per vote
2. United; $1.05 per vote
3. Labour; $0.82 per vote
4. Green; $0.67 per vote
5. Act; $0.52 per vote
6. National; $0.01 per vote
7. Maori; $0.001 per vote
8. Progressive – no theft

Also people may be intrested in what proportion of total advertising was found to be illegal per party. It is:

1. Green 69.6%
2. NZF 66.7%
3. Labour 66.1%
4 United 47.7%
5 ACT 10.4%
6 National 8.1%
7 Maori 1.8%
8 Progressive 0.0%

A stark difference between the first four parties and the last four.

Extracts from the Report

The Auditor-General doesn’t mince words. He lashes The Parliamentary Service for their interpretation of the rules, but also makes it very very clear MPs have ignored his warnings and committed flagrant breaches.

I am concerned that I found a substantial amount of material that amounted to electioneering. A number of advertisements and newsletters expressly solicited votes. However, even where no express soliciting of votes occurred, a large number of advertisements contained material that could only be described as election platforms and promises. I was particularly disappointed to find that the Service paid for significant amounts of newspaper advertising by some parties in the last week before the General Election. That advertising was incontrovertibly of an electioneering nature, and I could not discern a legitimate parliamentary purpose for it.

I have found the nature and extent of electioneering advertising expenditure put through the Service by MPs and parliamentary parties disturbing. In this regard, party-generated advertising produced by Leaders’ offices was of most concern.

I find it hard to accept that, despite my 2005 Report and the message to be careful about advertising expenditure in the pre-election period, behaviour did not change.

And the numbers are …

Tenth birthday for MMP

Ten years ago today we had our first MMP election. My memories of the day was how unusual it was not to know who had won the same night, ACT making to Parliament by both making 5% and winning an electorate seat, and how 23% of the electorate voted for NZ First or the Alliance!

The NZ Herald gets comments from a range of people, a column by FPP campaigner Brian Nicolle and also a column by former FPP campaigner Helen Clark.

I do strongly beleive that there should be another referendum on whether we keep MMP (the public have a right to confirm their choice) but I would note vote to bring back FPP.

What would be very interesting is to have a choice between MMP and STV.

Manukau City Council Prostitution Bill

This bill was defeated 46-73 yesterday. The bill would have given one local authority the powers to not comply with the laws passed a couple of years ago on prostitution.

No Right Turn has the details of how each MP voted. I always find it interesting, even though it is a personal vote, to collate them by party.

Labour voted four votes in favour and 45 against. The four in favour were Hawkins, Field, Swain and Robertson.

National voted 31 in favour and 16 against. Against were Paula Bennett, Blumsky, Brash, Connell, Finlayson, Goodhew, Hayes, Henare, McCully, Power, Rich, Simich, Lockwood Smith, te Heuheu, Wong and Worth.

No other party split their votes. As expected NZ First and United Future block voted in favour and the Greens, ACT and Maori Party block voted against. Oh yeah can’t call Progressive a block vote but they voted against.

I’m quite pleased with the National vote as it indicates the “liberal” segment in Caucus is less anaemic than before the last election. Not that everyone voting against is liberal – some may just not like exemptions for one council, but it is a healthy sign. I should point out that I in no way want a Caucus where it is 100% “liberal” (in the classical sense) as National’s strength comes from being a broad church of conservative and liberal values. It’s about having a sound mix.

ACT Board Member Resigns

The NZ Herald reports that Andrew Fulford, Central region board member for ACT, has resigned from ACT’s Board after just six months.

Fulford’s criticism’s are that the party was dominated and encumbered by its libertarian wing, not the Douglas faction which he belongs to. This is not surprisingly as most of the Douglas faction have left or gone inactive.

He also says the Board has become a glorified electorate committee for Epsom.

I’m surprised that Mr Fulford has taken so long to realise Rodney has strong libertarian tendencies. It’s hardly a state secret.

An excellent compromise

Chester Borrows has put forward an amendment to Section 59, which I think will be acceptable to all but the zealots.

He correctly notes that almost evryone wants the same outcomes:

* To send a message that child abuse is wrong
* To stop parents who moderately and seriously assault their children from hiding behind Section 59
* To not criminalise good parents who occasionally smack their children

Borrows also describes the differing approaches as being about whether “protection afforded to parents and children should be enshrined in legislation or left to government agencies to make social policy by way of guidelines.”

He rightfully says laws should be made by Parliament, not by unelected officials, so proposes two amendments to Section 59. They are:

1) Requiring a judge to decide if Section 59 can be applied in the circumstances of the case, and then the jury would decide if the force used was reasonable, providing a filter so juries cannot misapply Section 59 out of sympathy

2) Defining reasonable force as no more than ‘transitory and trifling discomfort’, which drastically lowers the bar on the level of force that can be justified by Section 59

I really like the “transitory and trifling” definition as it is a very significant change to what is allowed. If MPs vote for a repeal instead of this amendment that means they want parents to be prosecuted for applying “transitory and trifling” discipline.

Shortland Street

For those who didn’t see it, Shortland Street got fairly brutal last night with the pregnant CEO of the fictional hospital being blown into many many small pieces by a car bomb.

The NZ Herald has an lengthy review of the episode and the direction the show is taking.

Plane flies into New York high-rise

Shit. A plane has flown into a New York high-rise. It may not be terrorism as it is a light plane only and the building faces no structural problems. Several apartments are alight – no casualty toll yet.

UPDATE: May be a helicopter.

UPDATE2: Was a plane but almost certainly an accident.

D-Day

Today is D-Day for Labour. The Auditor-General’s final report is out at 2 pm and Labour’s stance is still a refusal to pay it back, even though retaining such a stance will be politically suicidal.

The NZ Herald editorial looks at how Labour will try and fudge the issue. An extract:

The least Labour can do when Kevin Brady’s final report is tabled today is offer to pay the money back. It would be heartening to hear also a public admission of guilt and regret but that seems unlikely. The Prime Minister and her colleagues will probably continue to maintain they used her departmental funds in good faith and that Mr Brady should have given them a clearer warning that they could not. The offer to repay the money will be a grudging concession to public opinion rather than a genuine realisation that what they did was wrong.

It was not “corruption”, as the National Party has been calling it, but it was something almost as bad. It was a complete disregard for the spirit of the rules. Labour read the rules literally to permit anything that did not expressly ask for votes or campaign contributions. It regarded any other campaign publicity as a fair call on the taxpayer. It is the attitude that public funds are to be exploited to the maximum rather than kept strictly for their intended purpose.

The editorial incidentially confuses the issue of the DPMC budget with the Labour Leader’s budget – it isn’t material to the debate, but it is something they should have picked up.

Audrey Young looks at what the Speaker may do, and concludes she is unlikely to require her fformer colleagues to pay the money back. That will need public pressure to achieve.

The Dominion Post editorial also repeats it call for Labour to pay the money back.

Comparative Surpluses

NZ is one of the smallest countries in the OECD, which makes a surplus in the lague of $11.5 billion all the more extraordinary. The surplus is an incredibly high 7.3% of GDP and 22.1% of Crown Tax Revenue.

If other countries were running a surplus at 7.3% of GDP, this is how large their surplus would be (in NZ$):

Australia $74.8b
United Kingdom $232.7b
United States $1.320 trillion

No other OECD country would have a Finance Minister claiming he can’t afford tax cuts with that level of surplus. They would be laughed into oblivion.

So what would be a good level of surplus? I think 1% of GDP is a prudent level to have. One also has the Cullen Fund which is around 2% of GDP, so even with that one could make do with a surplus half the size of the current one. And that is without touching even a cent of government expenditure.

Further Field allegations

An afdadavit was read out in Parliament today about Labour’s Taito Phillip Field and his constituency “work” as far back as 1994. NZPA reports:

“I recall meeting Mr Field at his Mangere office sometime in 1994.

“I spoke to him about an immigration matter. He told me it would have to be done in the Samoan way. I recall he mentioned the term fa’alavelave (correct) but he then told me the more money I could find, the better the outcome would be in the long run.

“I was unable to give him any money, because I had nothing.

“My very clear understanding was that if any money was to be paid, it had to be paid to Mr Field for his help on this immigration matter.

“On the basis of what Mr Field said to me, I believe he intended to keep some of the cash for himself.”

The affadavit has been handed to the Police. It is worth noting though that as repugnant as the behavior above is, it may not necessairly be illegal. It is an issue of political ethics and the solution is a political solution which lies with the Labour Party.

People may also wish to note that the person making the accusations is someone who marched against the National Government in 1998/99 on the Hikoi of Hope.

If this has been going on for 12 years, for how long have his colleagues known about the stories, rumours and allegations? I bet you that when TVNZ first aired these issues 13 months ago, a few of them were not surprised!