Finally CHP story hits the media

I see the story about a Christian Heritage official minimising what Capill did, has finally hit the media. Only six days or so after I blogged about it 🙂

I love how NZPA do not use the term blog but the fuller term “weblog site”. Makes it sound far more respectable!

The Maori Seats

Just to prove they are not all members of the borg, or vast left-wing conspiracy, two Public Address bloggers have been debating the Maori seats.

Keith Ng advocated they are a bad thing, with his main points being:

* overhang meant voters who had enough votes for four MPs ended up electing six
* Maori seats encouraged distortionary tactical voting
* Maori electorates are not really electorates, and the interests that these MPs represent are not geographical, but ethnic. They are list seats by another name, a kind of proto-proportional representation
* Maori are 15% of voters and do not need minority protection as this can be a significant voting bloc. However they do not vote as a bloc, so why have seats on the basis they do.
* Finally that the Maori seats assume that Maori have more politically in common with other Maori than with any Pakeha – that a rich, conservative, provincial Maori man has more in common with a poor, anarchist, urban Maori woman than he has with a rich, conservative, provincial Pakaha man and hence assumes that, fundamentally, our political interests stem from race.

I thought the most interesting observation from Keith is that the seats are not really geographic seats but in effect a different form of list seat.

Then Che Tibby (he’s a guy by the way!) responds to Keith. He however makes a number of mistakes in his points.

Firstly he says the South Island is an gerrymander as it always get 16 seats. This is not a gerrymander as it does not give South Islanders more MPs per capita, it merely uses the SI population as a starting point to decide the total no of MPs.

Then he says that the electoral population used to determine seat sizes is based on the number of people registered on the roll. This is incorrect. It is based on the total population, including children under 18. This is very significant.

Thirdly he says as the population of the North Island grows, the number of Electorate seats, both Māori and General, increases. Again not quite correct. It is not if the NI population grows, it is whether it grows faster than the SI population.

Che says Māori electorates have essentially the same number of voters as general seats. No they do not. Because it is based on total population, they have far far less voters, because Maori have a much higher proportion of under 18 year olds. I think it is a real issue that seats are based on the total population, not the adult population. So the fewer number of voters per Maori seat is not just based on low turnout, but on the way the electoral populations is defined.

Bizarrely Che argues the seats are not a racial gerrymander because Keith Ng could enrol in them if he wanted to. Well yes he could, and one can enrol a dog as a voter also, but that doesn’t mean that by law he is not meant to be enrolled in a Maori seats as he doesn’t have a Maori great great great grandparent. They are by law reserved to New Zealanders who have some Maori ancestry.

Keith Ng has responded. He quotes Graeme Edgeler as saying Maori are 18% not 15% of the population. Well Stats NZ estimates as at 31 December 2004 Maori population was 622,400 out of 4,062,500 which is 15.3% so not sure where 18% comes from. However amongst adults 18 and older there are only 360,300 Maori out of 2,995,640 adult NZers which is 12.0%.

So worth noting there are 21/122 MPs who are Maori, or 17.2% of Parliament, and this is off a voting base of only 12.0%. Now personally I have absolutely no issues with Maori being over-represented in Parliament, as I don’t believe in quotas. I’m far more worried about over-representation from professional unionists! But it does underscore the point that any notion of needing the Maori seats because Maori are under-represented is not borne out by the facts.

Keith responds to claims that his problem is with overhang, not with the Maori seats. He points out that having voluntary opt-in seats – such as the Maori seats – *encourages* overhangs and almost amounts to DIY-gerrymandering. Follow the links to see his reasoning, as it is too eloquent to summarise here 🙂

More on Internet Governance

I have blogged a lot about the attempt to have a UN body given governance authority over the Internet. Some have seen it as US vs UN but this is incorrect. While the US does presently have policy authority over the root name servers, it actually has never used this except in relation to .us. Everything else is delegated to ICANN which is far far far from perfect (in fact deeply flawed in many areas) but does allow the non governmental sector a significant voice in running the Internet.

Compare that to what is happening at the WSIS conference, where China, Brazil and Iran managed to force the Chair to exclude all further civil society
and private sector participation
in the drafting groups. The compromise that they could attend but not speak was not even acceptable to these countries that want to set policy for the Internet.

Luckily for InternetNZ, our Executive Director has been made a member of the official Government delegation, so he presumably has been able to stay in the room. But it speaks volumes about what role the private sector will play in the Internet policy if China, Brazil and Iran get to set the rules in future. None.

There was a period I was so disenchanted with ICANN I thought the ITU might do a better job of it. I still find ICANN hugely disappointing in many areas (yet happily for InternetNZ it is mainly the gTLD issues not the ccTLD issues they are stuffing up), but the more I observe about the motivations and actions of those pushing for ICANN’s role to be transferred or supervised by a UN body, the more I believe this would be one of the biggest setbacks for free speech worldwide.

Luckily there is nothing the Chinas and Irans of this world can do, to force a transfer of authority. However the risk is that at some stage a compromise is done which will start the process off. If the UN sets up a global Internet forum (sounds harmless eh) and it starts making recommendations on allowable content etc, ICANN could find it politically very difficult to not go along with such recommendations.

Key things to watch out for is what comes out of these meetings known as Prep Com 3, and what is recommended to go the big WSIS meeting in November where heads of governments will attend and ratify outcomes.

What US state should I live in?

Hmmn, not too impressed with Louisiana. It must have picked that because I love clam chowder and parties!

You scored as LOUISIANA. THE BIG EASY IS FOR YOU…LOUISIANA

LOUISIANA

75%

UTAH

58%

California

50%

NEW YORK

50%

WASHINGTON

50%

FLORIDA

50%

NEVADA

33%

WYOMING

8%

What state should you live in?
created with QuizFarm.com

NZ Herald links

As reported the NZ Herald is not blocking access to old stories (it is to new opionion articles though), it has merely made its internal search engine generate links which require paid access. One can use Google search engine to get around this.

A clever chap or chapette invented a little script which will take the NZ Herald internal search engine link and transform it to a direct free link. This appears to be legal because the NZ Herald has decided to make both links available – it merely finds them for you.

As with most Net wars, the NZ Herald has moved to plug this loophole, but the author is promising a second version which will use a different method.

Greens and Business

Taito Phillip Field

Aaron Bhatnagar has good coverage of the latest on the dedicated MP for Mangere. It has been amusing to see some on the left defend his previous actions on grounds of cultural sensitivity. I look forward to seeing which culture supports you using your position as an MP to make a $135,000 profit out of a family which came to you in need.

I think there is no longer a question that he will not be reappointed to a Ministerial position. Clark is not stupid. But the real issue is should he resign as an MP? His actions in hiring someone for $1.20 an hour, illegally paying his wife and then ripping off constituents with housing problems all relate to his work as an MP, not as a Minister.

Labour should not be allowed to get away with saying

New Zealand Day

UK Telecommunications

Incidentially this is post no 3,000 for Kiwiblog!

As 027 does not work in the UK, Telecom arranged a UK loan phone for me. I think it sums up how much price gouging happens in NZ, that it is *cheaper* for me to call people in NZ from my UK mobile phone, in the UK, than it is to call people in NZ from my NZ mobile phone when in NZ. Yes seriously.

One of the flats I am staying at tells me they have 8Gb wireless! My current abodes has a neighbour with wireless also

Hate Speech

Up up and away

In a couple of hours I’m flying to Auckland and then London. Will be away for a month on a long awaited holiday. A wee bit of business and politics while over there but mainly relaxing and catching up with lots of friends.

I don’t expect to be blogging again until Wednesday NZST. And it will be probably very light blogging as, unlike when I am overseas at conferences with broadband, I’ll be relying on dial-up access and cybercafes as I’ll be crashing with friends, not staying in hotels.

Camera is travelling with me, so be prepared to get bored with lots of photos of London, England, Scotland and Ireland and maybe France.

Three reasons to stay in Iraq

Question?

Political Test

This test is a bit like the political compass, but a different set of questions. I saw it on Risawn’s site where she got 50% socially permissive and 61% economically permissive.

As you can see below I am 80% socially permissive and 88% economically permissive.

You are a

Social Liberal
(80% permissive)

and an…

Economic Conservative
(88% permissive)

You are best described as a:

Libertarian

Link: The Politics Test on Ok Cupid

Well done Christian Heritage

Christian Heritage have released a statement where they distance themselves from Mark Munroe’s views on the Capill case, and reveal he has been asked to resign as their policy director.

The key aspect, has been succinctly made by Ewen McQueen:

“Like most New Zealanders I am dumbfounded that anyone would want to continue debating the technicalities of the Capill case and what sort of penalties are appropriate or not appropriate. The crimes were appalling. The court made its decision. For the victims

Coalition Options

Stuff reports that both the Maori Party and the Greens may pass up on coalition.

The Maori Party never were going to seek coalition, so this is no surprise.

The Green stance is one of realism, not desire. NZ First and United Future both effectively are vetoeing the Greens being in Government.

What one can not rule out is a Labour-Progressive-United Future Government. Why? Mutual benefit?

From Labour’s point of view it needs to not just be in Government but also pass legislation. Having United Future in coalition will make most bills pass easier. Also it will force United Future to vote for their picks for Speaker and Select Committee Chairs. Finally it also makes it look like Labour is moving to the centre and rejecting extremes.

From United Future’s point of view, it is the chance to increase support at the next election. If they are not in Government, they will be merely on of four parties propping up a third term Government, and probably the one with the weakest brand. I can’t see how they could possibly increase their vote from that position. But if they have Dunne as a Minister, they can attempt to take credit for initiatives in his policy areas.

Blair on Kyoto

It’s all Pakeha’s fault

A book co-authored by the chairman of the Kotahitanga Community Trust, a taxpayer-funded charitable organisation, claims the following:

* The health system is racist and opposes activities like smoking and eating fatty foods simply because Maori enjoy them.

* Calls for taxpayers to provide Maori with pills to prevent illnesses like diabetes and heart disease instead of expecting Maori to stop smoking or start dieting and exercising.

* labels as “house niggers” and “Uncle Toms” Maori who disagree with them.

* says cervical screening “contravenes significant cultural norms” and has been imposed on Maori by Pakeha.

* claims Maori babies do not benefit from routine childhood vaccination against diphtheria, tetanus, whooping cough and polio

“Anti-gambling research is rubbish. It can be seen as just another example of the health Nazis looking to extend their empire,” the book says.

The Trust received around $300,000 of Government funding last year. And while the taxpayer did not fund this book directly, you do have to wonder whether an organisation with such extreme views is actually helping health outcomes at all.

Making Clem the Speaker

I think the first challenge for National should be to get Clem Simich made Speaker, instead of Margaret Wilson. Simich is well liked by most MPs and seen as scrupulously fair, so this is not an impossible task. However National needs to start pushing his candidacy before Labour signs minor parties up to agreements which include a requirement to vote for Labour’s nominee for Speaker.

Wilson will be guaranteed 51 votes from Labour/Progressive. And despite all their noble squeals about MMP and independence, the Greens will vote for a partisan Labour speaker over a neutral National one any day. So that is 57 votes.

National and presumably ACT will vote for Simich which is 51 votes. So the parties to target are NZ First, United Future and the Maori Party.

The fact Clem is technically part-Maori may help with the Maori Party. But the stronger argument to make to them, is that voting Simich for Speaker will be a perfect way of showing to their voters that they will not be Labour’s lapdogs. And a neutral Speaker will help them in the House as they ask questions to the Government. So if Maori Party on board that is 55 for Clem.

NZ First will probably need little encouragement to vote for Simich over Wilson, especially with the antipathy between Peters and Wilson. It also needs to be sold to them as a way to be seen as independent, despite voting to keep the Government in office on supply and confidence. So with NZ First you have 62 for Clem and 57 for Wilson.

If you get NZ First and Maori Party then you don’t need United Future. However would be best to talk to them at an early stage and try and persuade them to not include voting for Speaker in any support agreement with the Government. Labour need the minor parties more than they need Labour, so this should not be hard to achieve.

If Greens pick up a seat off National, and United Future did decide to vote for Wilson, you could have a 61:61 tie. In that case I would expect a deal to be done to have Simich made Speaker.

A near naked Green MP

Battle for control of the Internet

There is a two week long meeting at present in Geneva, where various countries want the UN (or similiar body) to be placed in charge of governance of the Internet.

I like this statement from the US Ambassador, David Gross:

“The United Nations will not be in charge of the Internet. Period.”

Straight talking is a relief!

The new Clark Cabinet

Helen Bain in the SST speculates that Hawkins and Samuels will be dropped from Cabinet, and what a reshuffle may involve.

Now predicting Hawkins will be dumped is about as safe as predicting the sun will rise tomorrow. Her picks of King to Welfare and Mallard to defence sound common sense to me.

If I was Clark, here is what I would do:

Cabinet

1 Clark – PM, SIS
2 Cullen – Finance (but with a deputy he hands over to in 2007), Treaty
3 Anderton – Associate Education (Schools)
4 Maharey – Economic Development
5 Goff – Attorney-General, Education
6 King – Welfare
7 Mallard – Defence, State Services
8 Hodgson – Health, Transport
9 Horomia – Maori Affairs
10 Sutton – Foreign Affairs
11 Burton – Police
12 Swain – Labour
13 Dalziel – CYPFS
14 Hobbs – Environment
15 Dyson – ACC
16 Carter – Conservation & Local Govt
17 Benson-Pope – Justice
18 Cunliffe – Deputy Finance, Comms/IT
19 O’Connor – Immigration
20 Okeroa – Ass Maori,

Outside Cabinet

21 Chadwick – Ass Health
22 Barnett – Ass Welfare
23 Fairbrother – Ass Justice
24 Mahuta – Ass Maori

Dump

Hawkins
Barker
Tizard
Samuels
Duynhoven
Field
Ririnui

This would leave a slightly smaller executive of 24, which would allow people such as Shane Jones or Darren Hughes to be considered for promotion mid way through the term.

Stupid protesters

Anti Iraq war protesters closed down an ANZ branch in Auckland, led by permament protester John Minto.

Why the ANZ? Because they are helping finance some of the rebuilding work being done in Iraq.

Oh how evil. God some people are morons. Regardless fo whether or not one thinks the war was a good idea or not, I would have thought most people would agree helping rebuilding the infrastructure was a good thing. But no, not for Mr Minto.

Naughty MP

National MP Sandra Goudie has upset Jeanette Fitzsimons as she lent moral support to 120 Coromandel locals who dared to clear a mangrove patch without resource consent.

This is the country that now requires building permits for tree huts, and food certificates for sausage sizzles.

Reporting on Polls

A very timely article in the NZ Herald which suggests the problems with polls is not how they were conducted, but the way they were reported.

I have an obvious bias as I own a polling company, but I have long advocated that this is an issue.

In fact when NZ First had a bill to ban publishing opinion polls during election campaigns, I suggested to some of the media, that a reporting code for polls would be a useful compromise.

If we had such a code, here is what I would include in the draft:

1) Reserve the term “poll” for scientific random samples. 0900 phone ‘polls’ and other devices which depend on reader/viewer response should never be called polls but surveys.

2) Always include in the story the level of undecided respondents. One of the most important thing in political polls is seeing who goes in and out of being undecided. Sometimes a party can go from say 35% to 38% without any more people saying they support them, because another party has had some of its previous supporters now say they are undecided.

3) Publish not only the margin of error for the poll, but if you report on any demographic breakdowns, include the margin of error for them. The moe for a 1,000 string poll is 3.2% but for say the Wellingtonians in that poll, it is 10.0%.

4) Always include the time period it was conducted over.

5) Always include somewhere the actual question asked.

6) If the media organisation has a website, include a link to the full poll report from the polling company.

There’s a lot more than that one could do, but it is unrealistic to expect media stories to include the full disclaimers etc a full poll report normally has.

Personally I would also like to ban media from declaring a 1% change in a party’s vote is significant, but that is getting too subjective.

In another article on polling, Janet Hoek also slams reporting of minor parties as being under the margin of error. I have blogged about stupidity of this label on half a dozen occassions.