Public Coups

Childcare Policies

Political Animals

Oh this is so unfair. Jane Clifton has published a book and I won’t be able to read it until I am back. I absolutely love Jane’s writing (she is truly world class) and used to buy the Listener just for her column alone.

At least I have something to look forward to when I get back. Any friends of mine who wish me to bring them back some chocolates could do worse than buy me a copy, which I will swap for said chocolates at airport 🙂

Redistribution

Sent by James. Very good.

A young woman was finishing her first year of college. Like so many others her age, she considered herself to be a liberal Democrat and was for the fair redistribution of wealth. She felt deeply embarrassed that her father was a life-long Republican, which she opposed openly. *

*One day she was challenging her father on his beliefs, particularly his opposition to higher taxes and more entitlement programs. In the middle of her heartfelt diatribe, based upon lectures she had from her left-wing professors at school, he stopped and asked her, point blank, how she was doing in school. *

*She answered rather haughtily that she had a 4.0 GPA, and let him know that it was tough to maintain. She had to study all the time, and rarely had time to go out and party. She barely had time for a boyfriend, and didn’t really enjoy many college activities because of spending so much time studying. In addition, she continued, she was taking a very difficult curriculum. *

*Her father listened and then asked, “How is your friend Mary?” She replied, “Mary is just getting by.” She continued, “She barely has a 2.0 GPA,” adding, “and all she takes are very easy classes and she never studies.” Explaining further, she continued emotionally, “But Mary is so very popular on campus, college for her is a blast. She goes to all the parties, and very often doesn’t even show up for classes because she is hung over.”*

*Her father then asked his daughter, “Why don’t you go down to the Dean’s office and ask him to deduct a 1.0 off your 4.0 GPA and give it to your friend who only has a 2.0.” He continued, “That way you will both have a 3.0 GPA and certainly that would be a fair, equal distribution of GPA.” *

*The daughter, visibly shocked by her father’s suggestion, angrily fired back, “That wouldn’t be fair! I worked really hard for my grades. I did without, and Mary has done little or nothing. She played while I worked real hard!”*

*”Welcome to the Republican Party,” her father said smiling.

An amusing anti-blog rant

Labour FUD

Someone sent me a parody last week of Labour’s billboards suggesting a slogan of “Vote Labour or the kid gets it”.

Someone at Labour obviously thought that NZers would react well to such threats, and to my great amusement their new billboards show a pair of blue National scissors threatening to cut the strands and hence kill the baby.

Can I suggest Labour produce as many of these billboards as possible. I suspect most NZers will get pissed off with the implicit message.

Clark on Security

Damn Jet Lag

Now part of NZ’s documentary heritage

Received a letter over the weekend from the National Library seeking permission to take copies of this blog, as a site of interest to all New Zealanders.

I’m actually think it is very funny to think my rants here will now be stored alongside Michael King’s History of NZ! Actually I approve of the general intention to retain copies of electronic materials, but admit to having some concern that in 20 years time some turd will jump up and say “Oh yes but Mr Farrar on 3 May 2005 you said X” according to the National Library.

Nevertheless I have of course given permission. The copying includes all files including images, so the photos of the new ultra-blond Miss Ten (coming to a blog near you soon) will be archived for all history also 🙂

Biting Satire

Someone has done a satirical Ashraf Choudary blog after his comments that the Koran is correct in saying gays be stoned to death.

I did have to laugh at the poll on the preferred method of execution for homosexuals, giving a choice of:

* Stoning
* Hanging
* Electric chair
* Lethal injection
* Hospital waiting lists
* Tax increases
* Bunda (beats me what that is)

Just hope Archbishop Tamaki is not reading blogs, as it may give him some ideas!

NZ First

The polls currently show NZ First likely to get significantly in excess of 5%, and quite possibly doing well enough that both National and Labour would need their support to form a Government.

This post looks at what form such support could take, what portfolios NZ First might want if in coalition, and also which of their MPs might be Ministers.

Type of Support

There are three main types of arrangements a Government could have with NZ First. They are:

(a) Coalition, with NZ First having Ministers in Government
(b) Formal Support on Confidence and Supply
(c) Ad Hoc Support

A coalition would set some high level goals, details Ministerial appointments, and cover some policy commitments. It would not be as detailed as the 1996 coalition agreement, but would be more specific that the 1999 Labour/Alliance one which basically just said we pledge to be nice to each other. This is what the media’s default expectation is, but it is not the only option.

A formal confidence and supply agreement could be attractive to NZ First as they could claim victory for some specific policy goals, but not have to actually be held responsible for the Government’s performance. They would agree to vote with the Government until the election, as long as policy is generally acceptable.

An ad hoc confidence and supply situation is what I call the all power and no responsibility scenario where NZ First say we want you to announce your plans every Monday, and then we’ll announce on Tuesday what we’ll pass into law and what we won’t. Also no guarantee we won’t being the Government down at some stage if we think they are losing touch.

Portfolios

If a coalition is the preferred option, what portfolios might NZ First want or get?

Prime Minister – not even the remotest possibility with either party. Anyone who claims otherwise is either clinically insane or a paid liar. No-one of credibility thinks either National or Labour would agree to power-sharing if that is the price. Both parties would bluff NZ First to trigger another election rather than agree.

Deputy PM – almost guaranteed to be conceded. The reason for this is that the portfolio is almost meaningless in a coalition government. It is merely a title of respect to the leader of the minor party, but in no way do they actually run the country when the PM is overseas. Having worked on the 9th floor, I can assure people that the staff keep in close contact with the PM when overseas and an Acting PM does little other than symbolic stuff. If the Deputy PM is from the same party, then the role has some teeth, but in coalition it is a nice title only. I don’t mean that in a demeaning way, but just to point out they get their power as leader of the minor party, not as Deputy PM.

Finance/Treasurer – Neither party will make Peters the senior finance role. And I don’t think he will ask for it this time – economic issues are not a big campaign issue for him now.

Foreign Affairs – NZ Herald speculates this would be conceded by either party, and I agree. Key is whether Peters wants it. In favour is the idea at 61 he wants to be a statesman and Foreign Affairs is a portfolio where you generally get to appear in the news a lot, and almost always in a positive light. Against is the fact he shows no signs of “settling down”.

Economic Development – highly likely. NZ First believe in handouts and I am sure they would love to announce cash handouts left right and centre. A good way to be involved in most economic policy without being seen to be in charge of the economy.

Social Services – maybe an Associate, but unlikely to want full portfolio

Health – have to be mad to want to be Health Minister, but Associate Health with focus on oldies is a distinct possibility.

Education – Could well get with Labour the full portfolio (Mallard would love to lose it I suspect) or at least one of the three sectors – early childhood, schools and tertiary. With National English would have to have full portfolio but could well work with NZ First in one or more sectors.

Maori Affairs – With National highly likely – preferably Peters himself but others with credibility are Peters Sr, Paraone etc. Labour might concede this portfolio also as a foil to Maori Party, but far less likely to as their own Maori Caucus would all defect to Maori Party (in fact I suspect many of them will defect anyway if they lose their seats and come back as List MPs only)

Police – NZ First very likely to want a law and order portfolio. Police is more popular (announcing new cops etc) than Corrections (explaining prison escapes).

Defence – With National the portfolio or an associateship is quite possible, far less likely with Labour.

Immigration – highly unlikely NZ First will want this, as they would have to actually do something other than rhetoric, and they don’t want all the tactics they have used turned back on them.

Ministers

Peters would be Deputy PM. He needs a significant portfolio on top of that and Foreign Affairs or Economic Development are most likely.

Peter Brown as NZ First Deputy Leader would have to be a Minister, but God knows what one could give to him. Maybe Senior Citizens and an associate or two. He would be a key ministerial target for any opposition.

Brian Donnelly is a very easy choice for Education. He could also capably work in other portfolios.

Dail Jones. Most likely of the new intake to get a portfolio as he was an MP in the early 80s. A bit eccentric so nothing too major – maybe an associate in welfare?

Craig McNair – the Deborah Morris of the new NZ First, without the sex appeal though. Maybe Youth Affairs if NZ First push for a large number of Ministers.

Ron Mark – a very easy choice for law & order or defence portfolios.

Pita Paraone – Maori Affairs maybe or a mid level portfolio like Internal Affairs

Jim Peters – Fisheries or Local Government

Doug Woolerton – Agriculture/Rural maybe.

I don’t actually expect NZ First would press for the huge number of Ministers they had in 1996, as they know inexperienced Ministers become liabilities. If it is a coalition, I would suspect they would only seek five Ministers staying with the proven performers.

The overall issue for any agreement though will not be the details of portfolios and Ministers, but quite simply can you trust Winston not to bring the Government down at some stage before the 2008 election? His track record is very bad, having shown a total inability to ever go into an election saying this Government is doing okay, and one has to worry that if the polls get tough at any stage, he will once again destabalise from within as an attempt to disassociate himself the Government.

It’s all the media’s fault

Helen Bain in the SST writes about how the media are to blame for NZ First going with National, the 2005 budget fiasco and Zimbabwe.

Helen forgot the following items, also the fault of the media:

* Assassination of JFK
* Introduction of the term “front bum” to polite NZ society
* Skateboarding

Boy do they have a lot to answer for.

All aboard the Natmobile

Around Luxembourg

Went into the conference centre today to register and orientate ourselves. It is normally used by the EU so is huge. One room has 250 desks with a phone at each desk. Will take some photos tomorrow.

Went to the shopping mall next door for lunch. Was very amusing as the waiter could not (or did not) speak any English at all, until the very end when Keith asked me if she should add 10% on as a tip, and the waiter who was walking past replies “yes”. Typical French type attitude.

The mall had a huge supermarket where we stocked up on various supplies to reduce the hotel costs. The staff actually get around on roller blades, it is that big. Could you imagine what OSH would do back home with such an employer – think of the safety risks!

Finally headed back to the hotel. We assumed that using the official shuttle would mean the driver would know where the hotel is, especially as city is fairly small (80,000). But despite even showing him the name and address in the booklet he had no idea and took 30 minutes of driving around the city until I recognised a landmark and navigated from there.

Meeting later today the MFAT staffer who is representing the Government, and planning strategy for the week. The recent announcement by the US Government that they will not hand over control of the root zone, means there will be a huge amount of lobbying go on, ranging from those who want the UN to run the Internet to those who want no Governments involved at all.

Sounds like a good game

Despite our best efforts the Novotel Luxembourg can not find a channel which shows the All Blacks vs Lions test match.

Therefore Keith and I, are in the bar watching beach volleyball on the big screen, yet listening to the radio coverage over the laptop from NewstalkZB.

If anyone happens to have recorded the game in digital format, please let us know, as would love to grab a copy (have free broadband wireless here).

Score is 31-19 and game almost over. Well done All Blacks!

Oh and in the beach volleyball Brazil are beating Argentina. May the best tanned team win!

Kiwi Pundit hits out

Walk the walk, stop talking the talk

Oh this peeves me off. It is all so typical.

The Dominion Post reports Helen Clark as saying she has “had a gutsful” of Australian tactics preventing imports of New Zealand apples, and positioning her as being on their side.

Hello – you are the Prime Minister, not an observer to this issue. If you really have had a gutsful you would refer the issue to a WTO Disputes Panel. We are almost guaranteed to win, but instead it has just been referred to some commitee for discussion. Typical kick for touch do nothing response.

And yet another …

G-Man is doing well on the billboard front – with this one contrasting attituds on homosexuality!

Remember it is all in good humour.

I really do hope someone has the time to collect all these up. I quite seriously think one could get a museum or something to do a post-election display.

Rugby vs Politics

Mike Heine has a very humourous comparison of rugby and politics including:

Johnny Wilkinson = Helen Clark
Richard Loe = Trevor Mallard
Sean Fitzpatrick = Don Brash
Reuben Thorne = Bill Gudgeson
Justin Marshall = John Tamihere
A tacklebag = George Hawkins

Go read – it ha spictures also.

Wanker of the Week

Has to go to Archbishop Tamaki who just hours after the London bombings, tried to capitalise on them by saying “we have been enduring a type of terrorism of another kind – acts of terrorism against the family.”

Oh yes, lowering the drinking age is just the same as sticking some bombs in a tube station and killing or injuring 700 people.

Flights

In Luxembourg and about go to sleep having just finished my 4th flight in 36 hours.

Had near disaster (and not of my making) at Auckland Airport. There were some last minute changes to my tickets and they were meant to be sent to my travel agent Thursday morning for me to pick up. However they got sent to a law firm by mistake and could not be located in time.

What this meant was that Air NZ agreed to let me fly up to Auckland without a ticket, and then at Auckland I would pick up from Air NZ the tickets for the whole journey. Now as there was only 75 minutes between scheduled arrival and departure I was nervous about having time to do this, and got travel agent to check with Air NZ if my luggage could still be checked all the way through from Wellington. They said it could.

However at Wellington Airport they then said I could not, as they needed to see the tickets for the later legs, so I had a maximum of 75 minutes to disembark, pick up my luggage, transfer to the International Terminal, pick up my tickets, check in, and clear security and passport control in time.

Murphy’s law is the flight is delayed 20 minutes. So my margin has shrunk to 55 minutes. Then at Auckland Airport there are no free gates (due to Chch Airport having been closed) so we spent 15 minutes just sitting on the tarmac. I now have 40 minutes.

I sprint to the luggage and wait over ten minutes for the luggage to turn up. It is now less than half an hour before the international flight leaves and I have not even checked in. There were others on the delayed flight for NZ2 to LAX but all of them were already checked in and bags checked through.

I collect up bags (which includes a heavy box of NZ tourism pamphlets) and forget any idea of waiting for shuttle and grab taxi telling the driver I don’t care what he charges me, just to get me there quick.

At the international terminal I go to sales and pick up my tickets and then rush through to checkin. As expected they told me the flight closed 20 minutes ago. It is now around ten minutes until departure.

Once again the Farrar charm comes to the rescue and they get a manager to reopen the flight, and also personally escort me through a back route into the gate area. I think we ended up breaking several security rules by missing hand luggage checks.

Flight takes off a few minutes after I boarded. I seem to be making a habit of these late entries, but for once this was was 100% not my fault.

The London bombings happened during the flight to LAX. Only found out online once I arrived. Was a bit surprised they did not announce the news on the plane, but in hindsight I suppose you don’t really want to tell passengers about terrorist bombings while still in the air.

Security took two hours to get through at LAX and then 11 hours to Frankfurt. A two hour stop there and a very quick (and small) flight to Luxemburg.

In all I read one book, viewed eight airline movies, viewed four laptop movies, read nine newspapers and five magazines during the flights.

Now to see if any news blogging needed, and then to get some sleep so I am up in time for the All Blacks vs Lions test match!

Scum

I have just got to a lounge in Los Angeles and MSN went crazy with friends telling me about the London bombings. Barely able to comprehend who could do this with 700 injured and 40 dead.

Only here for an hour or so, and then to Frankfurt. Security at LAX was very tight – I now know why.

So far no-one I know seems to be injured. Small mercies. My thoughts go out to all those with family and friends there.

Away

What will Winston do?

Rodney is predicting that Peters will go with Labour, if he holds the balance of power.

I agree, and said back on June the 18th that I thought it was 75% likely Peters would choose Labour.

Now to be fair I have since lowered the probability a bit to around 65%, but still think that is the way he will jump.

In the end no-one knows for sure except Winston. As Don Brash says – voting for NZ First is like tossing a coin – no certainty of outcome.

G-Man has a billboard