General Debate 09 November 2025
Law News reports:
The government has ditched retrospective legislation that would have hobbled a multi-million banking class action, accepting a Parliamentary select committee’s advice to back down rather than pursue the controversial change.
Scott Simpson announced the U-turn on Monday after Parliament’s Finance & Expenditure Select Committee outlined its position on the retrospective provisions of the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Amendment (CCCFA) Bill.
“Through the select committee process, it was suggested that ongoing court cases be exempt from these provisions. The committee considered this carefully and recommended that approach, and the government parties agree,” Simpson said.
Pleased to see the Government do the right thing. The CCCFA law was a bad law. However it was the law of the land, and ANZ didn’t comply with it, and has to face the legal consequences of that. You don’t retrospectively change the law to kill off a lawsuit that has been active for four years.
Stuff reports:
Labour is promising to make cervical screening free for everyone, if elected, through its previously-announced Medicard scheme.
Health spokesperson Ayesha Verrall said the move would help prevent cancers and avoid costly hospital treatments.
I’ve pulled out the data for deaths by cancer over the last ten years. The numbers are:
Stuff reports:
NZ First leader Winston Peters says the party’s bill that would ban the public sale and use of fireworks would be a bottom line in any future coalition agreement.
This is the issue you pick to be a bottom line? LOL.
The Post reports:
The Government is considering a crackdown on inner-city homelessness.
Rumours of an impending move to criminalise homelessness emerged earlier this week, prompting Opposition MPs to question Prime Minister Christopher Luxon in the House about incoming legislation.
Luxon, on Tuesday, said there were no Cabinet decisions or discussion on the topic of banning people homelessness in central business districts.
But on Wednesday it became clear Government ministers have been considering an intervention, possibly in the form of a “move on” law, to shift problematic behaviour out of city centres, particularly a “bedraggled” Auckland.
Those who choose to sleep on the streets often have intensive drug and/or alcohol problems. There is no easy magic fix that will cure them.
But having them sleep and live in front of businesses in CBDs creates victims. Potential shoppers and staff feel intimidated, especially if asked for money. Some of their behaviour, influenced by drugs and alcohol, is threatening. They cost businesses money and custom, and make people avoid going into city centres.
So giving the Police the power to move those on who have problematic behaviour is a good thing, in my opinion.
The Herald reports:
A naked pensioner was arrested after he was spotted riding through an upmarket Auckland street.
Police were called to Tamaki Drive about 1.40pm today after reports of a naked man riding a bicycle in the area.
A 65-year-old man was arrested for offensive behaviour, police said.
On a local community Facebook page, people said they saw about eight police officers and four police vehicles swarm the area.
Eight police officers and four vehicles – all to apprehend a naked cyclist!
Amazing story at Radio NZ, where they turn the fact that there are heaps fewer kids growing up in motels into a bad news story!
It seems clear that the Tamihere faction wants to expel Mariameno Kapa-Kingi and Takuta Ferris from Te Pati Maori, and possibly to also waka jump them from Parliament, causing by-elections.
At first glance they should be able to do this, as you only needs a two thirds majority in caucus to expect MPs under the Electoral Act. So four of of six in favour would qualify.
But there may be another aspect to it, which could be interesting. The criteria for expelling an MP is that:
the parliamentary leader reasonably believes that the member of Parliament concerned has acted in a way that has distorted, and is likely to continue to distort, the proportionality of political party representation in Parliament as determined at the last general election
Now at the 2023 election, Te Pati Maori’s share of the party vote only entitled them to four MPs. They won six electorates so two seats are overhang. You could argue that having two MPs leave Te Pati Maori doesn’t distort the proportionality of Parliament,. but actually enhances it!
Something I have been interested in is trying to get a better understanding of what life was like for Maori in New Zealand before Abel Tasman made contact in 1642. By then Maori had been in New Zealand for around 400 years. Some people dismiss Maori civilisation back then as Stone Age, while others point to the skill (and courage) it took to paddle to NZ in wakas, and other aspects of Maori matauranga.
To try and put things in perspective I asked ChatGPT to list 100 inventions or innovations that occurred in ancient times (before 0 AD). This list itself is quite fascinating. The list is:
It’s fascinating how ancient so many of these inventions or innovations are.
I then asked it to assess which of these were known to exist in Maori civilisation before Abel Tasman. Now this is ChatGPT so it may have some stuff wrong. But again very interesting to see in one list what was and wasn’t present.
So of the 100 historic inventions or innovations, around 26 were present with Maori.
I have just had the privilege of spending a week on Hamilton Island off the north Queensland Coast. It was easy to get to – Auckland-Sydney-Hamilton Island (where 5 significant flights arrive every day).
It is a tiny place – 5km long by 3.5km wide. But the airport hosts planes with up to 300 passengers, the ferry from Airlie Beach is 45 minutes.
The hotels – we stayed at the Reef View – are high quality and very well serviced.
We ate at 10 different venues- every meal and all wait-staff were of high quality.
We took two boat trips. One was to Whitehaven Beach – which was beautiful re the fish life and the Monitor Lizards. The other was an all day adventure to a part of the Great Barrier Reef – where we snorkeled for 4 hours and had a superb time.
As a declaration of interests – I own three, very small, tourism businesses in the Bay of Islands.
My strong opinion is that NZ needs a SUN destination in the same way that Queenstown provides a Winter destination and is also working hard to be an all-year round venue.
The Far North is the poorest part of NZ with appalling education, NEET, employment and social welfare stats. A few rich (and semi-rich) people go to the Bay of Islands, buy some form of property and then try and make sure no one else arrives in paradise.
Here is a summary of what Hamilton Island means to the Queensland and Australian economy.
Simeon Brown and Chris Bishop have done some good work with proposed roading improvements to the Far North.
A much more significant improvement would be to make the Kerikeri Airport fully international and have flights coming in from Sydney, Brisbane, Adelaide, Melbourne, Singapore, Hong Kong – every day. In ten years Northland could go from the poorest to the wealthiest NZ province.
Alwyn Poole
[email protected]
Radio NZ reports:
The long-delayed International Convention Centre in Auckland has formally been handed over to SkyCity several years behind schedule.
It marks a major milestone in a project, that when works began in 2015, was supposed to take 38 months.
“We’re delighted to finally have the keys,” SkyCity chief executive Jason Walbridge said.
The convention centre has not just taken extra time, it has also taken extra money.
Here’s the great thing – thanks to Steven Joyce the convention centre delays and cost blowouts have not cost taxpayers a cent. He worked out a deal where the private sector took all the risk.
So Auckland and New Zealand will benefit from having a dedicated convention centre that can attract global conventions – and no billion dollar bill for taxpayers!
The 2025 Marsden Fund grants have been announced, and finally they are now overwhelmingly going on hard science, rather than politics. I’ve updated my comparison table below.
| 2008 | 2017 | 2023 | 2024 | 2025 | |
| Science | 88% | 80% | 72% | 73% | 92% |
| Humanities | 8% | 11% | 13% | 7% | 6% |
| Maori | 3% | 5% | 8% | 17% | 3% |
| Identity | 1% | 2% | 5% | 3% | 0% |
| Political | 0% | 3% | 2% | 1% | 0% |
As the Royal Society got more woke, less and less went on science, and more on woke projects and the like. In 2023 and 2024, 1 in 4 grants went to non-science areas. Now with a new ministerial direction, this is down to 1 in 12.
This is why who makes up Government does matter. Here’s some of the great projects being funded that may have missed out previously for nonsense such as $360,000 to collect disabled indigenous stories about climate change!
We should thank Judith and Shane for getting science funding focused back on science!
Stuff reports:
Lal wants the same for others, including those with barriers to education: Māori and Pasifika peoples, women, people of colour, LGBTQI+ and disabled students.
Those on the left repeat slogans like this as a creed, and seem to ignore the reality. Oh certainly Maori and Pacifika have worse educational outcomes than others, but in no way do women. To the contrary here is how men do compared to women in education:
If these differences were the other way around, they would be the subject of media stories almost every week.
It is also very questionable if LGB NZers face significant barriers to tertiary education, as the data suggests twice as many LGB young people go to tertiary education than non LGB.
I’m all for reducing barriers to education, but they should be based on reality, not ideology.
For the avoidance of doubt, the abuse Aria Lal has received is disgusting, and something no-one should have to put up with.
Stuff reports:
But Ottrey had only positive things to say about the Prime Minister, remarking that Luxon – who used to lead Air New Zealand as chief executive – was “so great at engaging” with her team and and other businesspeople.
“He’s so great at engaging with all of the people that we have here, but also, he knows his business, and he knows what it is to help companies like us trade with the world. We need to do that in New Zealand because that’s our way to prosperity.”
Ottrey is also a business advisory councillor for APEC, the annual Asia Pacific Economic Cooperation summit – this year hosted in South Korea – where Luxon spent the past few days. The event brings together leaders from nations on the Pacific rim, including the two largest economies: China and the United States.
While the size of New Zealand’s economy pales in comparison to those superpowers, Luxon managed to score face-time with the leaders of both countries. President Donald Trump even went so far as to tell reporters: “I like your man from New Zealand.”
Luxon also oversaw a relationship upgrade with the host nation, South Korea, which is currently New Zealand’s fifth largest trading partner. And while those sorts of deals involve a team of officials and don’t happen overnight, Ottrey gave Luxon’s administration credit.
“The way the Government is moving, increasing the number of bilateral and multilateral arrangements we have is really, really good for our businesses, because it gives us opportunities… and removes barriers to do businesses in those countries,” Ottrey told Stuff.
It’s a useful reminder that the PM has a very strong business background, and can use it to benefit New Zealand.
The 46th Vice-President of the United States has died, aged 84. He was arguably the most powerful Vice-President in the history of the United States. This was partially because he had no interest in becoming President. If you look at all elected former VPs, you have:
His lack of ambition to be President is part of why Bush gave him so much authority. The rest was probably his background. He had been Chief of Staff to a President and Secretary of Defence to another.
He was probably more hated by the left than Bush. Many saw him as the power behind the throne. I used to joke that Bush was unlikely to be assassinated, because that would result in President Cheney.
He once joked he didn’t mind being called Darth Vader, as that was one of the nicer things Democrats called him.
Andrew Little has announced his appointments for WCC. There are six Labour Crs, four Green Crs and six independents. Let’s look at how he has allocated things.
Not much to criticise there. Seems to be a good start that he wants to unite, not divide. I also like that the appointments are only for 18 months, so that he can shuffle around if things are not working.
He’s also put a stop to the nonsense of fencing off the ocean, so again a good start.
The Herald reports:
A rookie constable leaked police intelligence to her gang member boyfriend shortly after starting her new career, the Herald can reveal. …
Knowing her boyfriend’s gang affiliation, Smith sent him the name of someone she described as a “snitch”.
She had arrested someone for minor traffic and theft offences in August 2022.
After transporting him to the police station, Smith sat in on an intelligence-gathering interview conducted by one of her colleagues.
During the interview, the suspect disclosed the addresses of properties in west Auckland that he believed were being used to manufacture drugs.
After the meeting, Smith messaged her Killer Beez boyfriend and disclosed the identity of the “snitch” she had arrested.
“His name’s [redacted] he was giving intel at work … names of some cook houses out west,” Smith wrote in a message.
This is incredibly serious. Revealing the identity of a snitch to a gang member could result in the snitch being wounded or killed. She should face serious criminal consequences for what she did.
The Herald reports:
The Oxford Union is, in its own estimation, “the world’s most prestigious debating society”, where international guests and speakers have sat for pointed interviews and stood for lively debate in its hallowed halls since 1823.
Guests have included Bernie Sanders, Ronald Reagan, Ricky Gervais, Mother Teresa, Albert Einstein and Michael Jackson – and, just this May, Charlie Kirk, the firebrand conservative American activist who was killed in September.
Today, the Oxford Union president-elect, a 20-year-old student who appeared to celebrate Kirk’s killing, has been removed from office.
He lost a confidence vote that has drawn attention among student members and thousands of alumni from around the world who are eligible to cast ballots by proxy.
Sky News reports that 501 voters had confidence in George Abaraonye, while 1228 wanted to remove him.
Pleased to see Oxford Union members know right from wrong.
What was shocking about Abaraonye’s reaction is that Kirk wasn’t some unknown political figure to him. He had actually met and debated Kirk at Oxford just a few months earlier. I can understand (but still condemn) such a reaction in response to the shooting of a stranger whose politics you disagree with, but you almost have to be a sociopath to have actually met someone, had a very civil debate with them, and them instinctively celebrate the fact they have been shot.
Dave Armstrong writes:
Meanwhile, who would have predicted the tumult on the left? Labour has largely avoided controversy, helped by having a safe, if unspectacular, pair of hands in the form of Chris Hipkins – and no new policy to bicker about. But the Greens and Te Pāti Māori are starting to look like models of dysfunction.
Greens have lost one third of their caucus in under two years, and Te Pati Maori are trying to deselect some of their own MPs.
Hipkins will be hoping things get so bad for the coalition that Labour and the Greens get the required number of seats to govern without TPM.
He can hope for that, but 0 out of 67 polls since the election have shown that as possible.
The problem for Labour will be the scaremongering tactics the right will use if Labour suggests working with TPM. Peters and Seymour are masters of stirring up anti-Māori sentiment, as we have seen this term.
Here Armstrong conflates things. Being anti-TPM is not being anti-Maori. TPM do not speak for all, or even most Maori.
The Post reports:
Two long-discussed Wellington roading projects — worth a combined $6.4 billion — have taken a major step forward, with investment cases signed off and fast-tracking confirmed.
Newly released plans show the Wellington tunnels project – which includes a second Mr Victoria tunnel – is expected to cost up to $3.8b and a new Petone to Grenada highway $2.6b.
Four lanes for both tunnels will make sure a huge difference in Wellington. And a direct link between Petone and the Northern Suburbs will also be massive.
But the catch is you’re likely to have to pay for it.
The investment cases for the high-profile projects included them being toll roads. Bishop also said congestion charging was on the table.
Great – we should pay for it. When it takes me an hour to get from Kilbirnie to Johnsonville, I’d happily pay $10 to make it less than half an hour. Hell I’d pay $30.