Very sad

The Herald reports:

The Treasurer of the Parliamentary Press Gallery has stepped down after admitting he used press gallery funds for his own personal use.

A statement from the executive said NZPA reporter Ian Llewellyn made the admission in writing.

I was stunned when I read this last night, and am incredibly saddened by the revelation.

I’ve known Ian for over a decade, and regard him as an excellent journalist and a really good guy. This is so out of character for him that I almost couldn’t believe it.

According to the executive, Mr Llewellyn said he had been in financial difficulty but had made some repayments.

While financial difficulty is no excuse, a thought that crossed my mind was that if Ian had crossed over to the dark side (comms/pr) he would have been better off financially, but NZ has been better served by the fact that not all the experienced journalists do cross over. Again, this is no excuse.

Press Gallery chairwoman Jane Patterson and deputy Vernon Small said they were extremely disappointed at the breach of trust by a longstanding office holder and colleague.

As much as my thoughts are with Ian, I also feel very sorry for Jane and Vernon. Having to deal with this must have been very unpleasant for them. Also Ian’s NZPA colleagues especially will be finding this tough.

The Press Gallery intends to ask an independent auditor to examine the accounts covering the period in question, the statement said.

“Given the watchdog role the Press Gallery plays, it intends to handle this matter as openly as possible, and is intending to seek advice from the police.”

Yeah, there really is no choice but to do it publicly.

The statement said Mr Llewellyn has promised to pay back any missing money.

“The Press Gallery voted today to recommend to the Speaker of the House that Mr Llewellyn’s accreditation be suspended pending the outcome of the audit.”

Ouch. I can’t even recall the last time that happened. I’m not sure if it will ever be feasible for Ian to return to the gallery, but I do hope there is a way he can remain with NZPA. It would be sad to lose Ian from journalism, and he is paying a high price in terms of publicity for what he did.

Rugby World Cup Odds

The TAB has announced the following initials odds for the Rugby World Cup:

New Zealand $2.20
Australia $4.00
South Africa $4.75
France $9.00
England $15.00
Ireland $15.00
Wales $20.00
Argentina $25.00
Scotland $100.00
Italy $250.00
Fiji $250.00
Samoa $500.00
Tonga $500.00

The current IRB world rankings are:

  1. NZ
  2. South Africa
  3. Australia
  4. France
  5. Ireland
  6. Argentina
  7. England
  8. Wales
  9. Scotland
  10. Fiji

How unpatriotic would it be to put some money on South Africa?

Finally

As I have previously blogged, my productivity has decline in the last few weeks since I discovered the new Blackberry has Sudoku on it.

After conquering the easy and medium settings, I was pleased at the weekend to beat it on the hard setting.

Even better, today I managed to beat it on the genius setting.

The only bad thing is I now have to find something else to waste time on.

Electoral (Administration) Bill Report Back

The Justice & Electoral Select Committee has reported back on the Electoral (Administration) Bill.

Their recommendations are:

  • The Electoral Commission remain an independent Crown entity
  • rejected making it an Officer of Parliament, as it has a responsibility to deliver smooth running elections, and a Minister, not the Speaker, should be responsible for the performance of that function
  • Key change is the the three Electoral Commissions are ow effectively appointed by Parliament, rather than the Minister of Justice. This is a key issue which myself and other submitters asked for.
  • A minor change is that the Chief Electoral Office can not be the Deputy Chairperson. This is a suggestion I made, so it does show the value of taking the time to make submissions.

Personally I still a bit nervous that a Government with a majority in the House could force through appointments which do not have widespread support, but hopefully future Governments will place a premium on the desirability of consensus around any names they place before the House.

But overall the Select Committee has nicely improved the bill, and it should get passed into law without difficulty.

It will be interesting to see in due course who the three Commissioners are.

Goff on Auckland

Phil Goff has made a speech outlining his vision for Auckland. Let’s look at the substance:

Labour will legislate to enshrine real decision making powers for local boards.

In principle I support the boards having their powers certain and legislated for. I think the Government erred in leaving it to the Council, even though they did state a principle of subsidiarity.

However Goff has not stated what are the powers he would legislate for local boards, so it is somewhat meaningless.

And we will review the ward boundaries and talk to communities about whether single rather than multi member wards would better ensure that all communities are fairly represented and feel their voice is being heard.

Now again in principle I agree with Labour. I think single member wards are better than multi member wards. The main reasons, being it is easier to select one Councillor from a smaller area, than multiple Councillors from a larger area. You get better informed voting.

I suspect Labour’s concerns are more on trying to gain control of the Auckland Council. The fact is the ward boundaries have been determined by the Local Government Commission, and should be given a chance to see how they work.

Rather than insist on single Councillor wards just for Auckland, I’d rather Labour pushed a policy of single member wards for all local bodies.

We will restore to Auckland the power to make its own decisions about the structure and powers of the seven council-owned companies that will manage three-quarters of the rates revenue provided by Aucklanders.

Now again, I have some agreement here with Labour. I do think it was essential that the Government and the ATA set establish initial CCOs. It would be an absolute disaster to just have elected Councillors take office, and no CCOs in place. They would spent their entire first term just trying to work out what to do. There would also be a serious risk of failure in key areas such as transport if there was not a unified CCO ready to go on day one.

But I don’t see why the initial CCOs need to have legislative backing to remain permanently, and the Council should in the future be able to make it own arrangements. So my solution would be to have the legislation setting up the initial CCOs expire after five years. Then from 2015 onwards, the Council can modify them as they see fit, having had the experience of seeing how they work.

We will legislate to ensure all Aucklanders have a say in a binding referendum before strategic assets can be sold.

As I have said time and time again, I’d contemplate supporting such a measure if it was balanced – demanding a referendum for both the purchase/construction of such strategic assets and their sale.

Labour though refuse to consider that the public should have a binding say on massive purchases that put up rates bills.

It is insane that Auckland Councils are buying shares in two Australian Airports, with no need for permission from ratepayers. Yet under Labour’s proposal they will need permission to sell shares in said Australian Airports.

I will invite the Mayor of Auckland to attend Cabinet committees for significant decisions relating to Auckland.

Well that would probably be almost every meeting ever held. So the Mayor will have to find an apartment to live in, in Wellington as he or she will spend more time in Wellington than Auckland.

And why stop there? Why not the Mayor of Christchurch and Dunedin also? And Hamilton?

The last idea is populist nonsense. The remaining issues raised by Goff are areas where improvements can be made, and I am supportive of that. Having said that, let’s see how the initial Council goes, before demanding change.

What is most surprising about the speech, is what Phil did not mention. Why did Phil not mention the Maori seats? Labour’s policy is to legislate for reserved seats for Maori on the Auckland Council? Has he forgotten that policy? Why on earth would he not even mention their policy in a speech about the changes he would make to the Auckland Council?

Crossing the political divide

news.com.au reports:

CONTROVERSIAL politician Troy Buswell will today face the media for the first time since a Greens MP revealed their affair.

Mr Buswell, who gained international notoriety for sniffing a female staffer’s chair and drunkenly snapping another’s bra, stayed silent on the scandal yesterday, but is expected to comment at 11am (WST).

He was last night staying at the home of a friend and colleague, Energy Minister Peter Collier amid reports his wife had already walked out on him. They have two sons.

Mother-of-three Adele Carles told The Sunday Times she had a “stupid” affair with the 44-year-old Liberal earlier this year that lasted several months. Both were married.

What is surprising in this, is not that MPs have affairs, but in this case it was a conservative MP (and the Treasurer) and a Green Party MP.

Less surprising may be that it involved Buswell. His known antics include:

  • snapping the back of a female Labor party staffer’s bra-strap
  • sniffing of a chair of a female Liberal staffer
  • crawled around on his hands and knees pretending to be the Liberal staffer’s husband while groaning and writhing in sexual pleasure
  • sexist remarks to a retiring Liberal MLA
  • “squirrel gripping” (grabbing the testicles of) a Liberal MLA

Could you imagine an MP in NZ, surviving such antics? Western Australia though is a different place.

Editorials 26 April 2010

The Herald looks at Pharmac:

The drawing up of free-trade agreements is always an exercise in compromise. Sometimes, unpalatable concessions have to be made with an eye on the bigger picture. …

At the forefront of American concerns will be two issues – the strength of our dairying industry and the role played by Pharmac, the Government’s drug-buying agency.

The US farming lobby will want little conceded, while American pharmaceutical companies want Pharmac’s role drastically reduced.

The drug companies say an end to New Zealand’s anti-competitive drug-funding system would give its people quicker access to new and expensive medicines.

US drug companies can introduce these new and expensive medicines at any time. Whether or not they gain a subsidy from the state is another issue.

Trade Minister Tim Groser has described Pharmac as “an outstandingly successful public institution”, which has saved taxpayers hundreds of millions of dollars. The estimated savings in a five-year period are enough to have built the Starship hospital.

Mr Groser has also said that, as the principal economic adviser at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade, he had negotiated with the US on Pharmac 10 years ago and had seen no need to make concessions.

That is reassuring. But the issue will doubtless be raised again, as New Zealand covets a free-trade agreement with the US. Hard choices will have to be made.

The Government has already bowed to pressure and allowed some slippage in Pharmac’s integrity. With the taxpayer uppermost in its mind, it should hesitate before venturing further down that path.

I agree Pharmac is of great value to New Zealand. The gains from a free trade deal would have to be significant for us to agree to changes to Pharmac.

The Press remembers ANZAC Day:

The history of Anzac Day remembrance has been shaped by memory and ideals – memories and ideals that have changed over the decades since the landing on the Gallipoli Peninsula in 1915.

The commemoration therefore has reflected the great alterations that New Zealand has undergone in those 95 years.

Yesterday’s services saw the men and women of World War II and will continue to see many of them in future years. But their number is dwindling and thoughts thus turn to the Anzac Days of the future. …

Voices last week were raised, predicting a decline in turnout over the coming decades, but that is unlikely to eventuate. The respect for what our fighting men and women achieved and the honour they brought us is now deeply and uncontroversially embedded in the nation’s psyche.

The Press pages on New Zealand’s military history, which we printed in the lead-up to Anzac Day, are but one example of this. They were prized by readers, and schools have taken them in large numbers. A hunger exists for hearing again the old tales of valour and service.

The men and women who performed those deeds will not be forgotten and Anzac Day will live on in their honour.

While on TV, once again I found Maori TV did best.

The Dominion Post looks at Fiji’s proposed media restrictions:

The primary function of Fiji’s proposed new media regulator is “to encourage, promote and facilitate the development of media organisations and services”. It sounds reasonable.

There is just one problem. In order to perform its duties the Media Industry Development Authority is being given the power to fine and lock up journalists, editors and publishers, censor news reports, search premises, seize documents, and shut down news organisations.

Coating a dictator’s iron fist with a veneer of legality does not soften the blow.

The commodore is labouring under a misapprehension. The misapprehension is that he is the big man in the Pacific.

He is not. He is a tinpot dictator who has gained power at the point of a gun and is destroying his country’s economy and prospects and the institutions, already weakened by three previous coups, that underpin good government.

The news media is one of them. Journalists, editors and publishers will bear the immediate brunt of the latest restrictions, but the real losers are the Fijian people, who have already lost the right to learn what is happening because of “emergency” regulations put in place last year.

Free speech is a fundamental pillar of democracy. “Were it left to me to decide whether we should have a government without newspapers, or newspapers without a government, I should not hesitate a moment to prefer the latter,” said Thomas Jefferson, the author of the American Declaration of Independence.

Another great Jefferson quote.

Outed for being straight

From Philadelphia:

It’s happened so often that it’s now a cultural cliche: the gay politician pretending to be straight. In most parts of the nation, homosexuality or bisexuality is a clear electoral liability.

Not in Center City’s 182d state House district. There, it’s a badge of honor.

Veteran Rep. Babette Josephs (D., Phila.) last Thursday accused her primary opponent, Gregg Kravitz, of pretending to be bisexual in order to pander to lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender voters, a powerful bloc in the district.

Heh that is a new one. Pretending to be bisexual to gain votes.

Kravitz, 29, said that he is sexually attracted to both men and women and called Josephs’ comments offensive.

An easy way to solve the issue though. Kravitz just needs to pash a hunky guy in public. I doubt any straight guy would do that just to win votes.

US gives up on space

Gwynne Dyer writes:

In the real world, the United States is giving up on space, although it is trying hard to conceal its retreat. Three Americans with a very special status – all have commanded missions to the Moon – have made their dismay public.

In an open letter Neil Armstrong, the first person to walk on the Moon, Jim Lovell, commander of Apollo 13 and Eugene Cernan, commander of Apollo 17, condemned President Barack Obama’s plans for the National Aeronautics and Space Administration as the beginning of a “long downhill slide to mediocrity” for the United States.

What has changed?

The letter was timed to coincide with Obama’s visit to Cape Canaveral to defend his new policy, which abandons the goal of returning to the Moon by 2020, or indeed ever.

The idea of a permanent base to the Moon was a good investment in the future.

So for the next decade, at least, the United States will be an also-ran in space, while the new space powers forge rapidly ahead.

And even if some subsequent administration should decide it wants to get back in the race, it will find it almost impossible to catch up.

And that is why the first man on Mars will be probably Chinese or Indian, not American.

I suspect he will be right. And the nationalism that will surround that will be massive.

Summary of Phil Goff on The Nation

  1. Will increase income tax
  2. Will not decrease GST
  3. Happy to work with Winston again

Wow, that’s a winning compeition.

What I found interesting was that Goff offered up that he was happy to work with Winston again – this was not in response to a question on NZ First.

I wonder if we are going to see Labour start to lend assistance to Winston, hoping that he can get them back into Government.

Goff also told one fib:

BARRY But didn’t Winston Peters embarrass you in government?  I mean there were many things that he did behind the scenes as I know that you would have probably gone along with, and one was this Declaration on Indigenous Rights, now as I understand it was Winston that basically said no you’re not going there and the Labour Party swallowed it.

PHIL Not so, that is absolute…

BARRY Well I was told by a very senior member of the Maori caucus.

PHIL Well the very senior member is wrong, and I’ll tell you why it was wrong, was we made that decision long before Winston was a coalition partner of the Labour Party.

Now this is contradicted by Charles Chauvel who blogs:

It’s well-known in Labour circles that I thought we should have acceded to the Declaration when we were in Government. Around the time that the new ALP Government was deciding that Australia should do so, I spent time with Rob McLelland, Australia’s Attorney-General, and Stephen Smith, its Minister of Foreign Affairs, discussing the mechanics of their intended accession, and the statement of reservations that would be made at the time on Australia’s behalf. It seemed to me that we could do something similar in New Zealand, so that accession could take place, in an honest and forthright way, preserving the paths already taken here in an attempt to redress past historical wrongs. The Labour cabinet here received strong official advice to the contrary, and in the end that advice prevailed.

So let us look at the dates here:

  1. 19 October 2005 – Winston becomes Foreign Minister in Labour-led Government
  2. 29 June 2006 – DRIP finalised and adopted by UN Human Rights Council
  3. 13 September 2007 – UN General Assembly passed DRIP
  4. 3 December 2007 – Rudd Government takes power
  5. 3 April 2009 – Rudd Governments endorses DRIP

So when Goff says Labour made their decision long before Winston was a coalition partner, he is clearly and absolutely wrong. Chauvel makes it very clear that in late 2007 or early 2008 Labour were still considering the issue.

The only way Goff could be telling the truth is if Labour decided its vote on the declaration two years before the UN General Assembly vote and eight months before it was even finalised!

The power of Facebook

Jen McCreight responded to the claim of the Iranian cleric that girls dressing unmodestly have been causing earthquakes:

I have a modest proposal.

Sedighi claims that not dressing modestly causes earthquakes. If so, we should be able to test this claim scientifically. You all remember the homeopathy overdose?

Time for a Boobquake.

On Monday, April 26th, I will wear the most cleavage-showing shirt I own. Yes, the one usually reserved for a night on the town. I encourage other female skeptics to join me and embrace the supposed supernatural power of their breasts. Or short shorts, if that’s your preferred form of immodesty. With the power of our scandalous bodies combined, we should surely produce an earthquake. If not, I’m sure Sedighi can come up with a rational explanation for why the ground didn’t rumble.

It seems a most worthy scientific experiment.

And in just a few days, the Facebook page for the event has 145,000 confirmed attendees.

I suspect we will see a lot of coverage of this event on TV!

Southpark Censorship

Once again Comedy Central has censored Southpark. Four years ago they banned the show from being able to show from showing a harmless depiction of Muhammad (was just him giving someone a fish) in their Cartoon Wars episodes.

The episodes were about appeasing people who threaten violence is wrong, but it didn’t work. This time in episode 201 Comedy Central have even refused to allow the name of Muhammad, after the Southpark creators cunningly discussed him onside a bear costume.

This has nothing to do with religious tolerance. Comedy Central have allowed the show to show Jesus Christ defecating on an American flag. Their decisions are purely appeasement in the face of threatened violence from extremists. The sad thing is they don’t realise that what they do, encourages the extremists. It shows threatening violence wins.

In similar news, Reuters reports:

A Dutch court has acquitted a Muslim group of inciting hatred with a cartoon that questions the Holocaust, in the latest case to provoke debate about freedom of speech in the Netherlands.

The Arab European League (AEL), which published the cartoon on its website, was cleared of insulting Jews because it was not aiming to dispute the Holocaust but to highlight perceived double standards in free speech.

And that is the right ruling,

The AEL cartoon shows two men, beneath an ‘Auschwitz’ sign and beside several bodies, saying the victims might not have been Jewish but the target was six million – the number of Jews killed in the Holocaust.

The AEL said the cartoon was part of a campaign it launched in 2006 to show “the double morals of the West during the Danish cartoon affair.” The image came with a disclaimer on the website saying the AEL did not support the views of the cartoon.

Except the AEL have been proven wrong about the double morals. No one has been killed, or even threatened over their Holocaust cartoon. There have been no burning of flags or storming of embassies.

The mad President of Iran tried to make a similar claim a few years ago by hosting a Holocaust cartoon competition. To his great dismay dozens of Jewish cartoonists submitted entries, rather than protest against it.

The best response to censorship is this:

After Comedy Central cut a portion of a South Park episode following a death threat from a radical Muslim group, Seattle cartoonist Molly Norris wanted to counter the fear. She has declared May 20th “Everybody Draw Mohammed Day.”

“As a cartoonist I just felt so much passion about what had happened I wanted to kind of counter Comedy Central’s message they sent about feeling afraid,” Norris said.

Norris has asked other artists to submit drawings of any religious figure to be posted as part of Citizens Against Citizens Against Humor (CACAH) on May 20th.

On her website Norris explains this is not meant to disrespect any religion, but rather meant to protect people’s right to express themselves.

The best way to stop the Islamic extremists threatening violence unless you censor, is if the response to their threats is to triple and quadruple the number of outlets who show the cartoon.

It should be a point of principle for every media outlet in the free world, to show such images, to show that threats will not work.

Ambassador’s Blog

US Ambassador David Huebner has a blog, and I am finding it a good read.

In is latest post he talks about Benjamin Franklin and Thomas Jefferson:

Franklin was a Renaissance man who could not be pigeon-holed.  He was an author, editor, business man, inventor, soldier, satirist, philosopher, statesman, politician, post master, and diplomat.  He developed the concepts of the modern fire station, ambulance service, and public lending library.  He served as America’s first ambassador, and was effective in securing the alliance with France that helped insure the success of our Revolution.

And Jefferson:

Likewise, Jefferson was a brilliant man who made his mark in many different fields – as a farmer, architect, inventor, educator, philosopher, archaeologist, diplomat, and statesman. Jefferson served as America’s first Secretary of State (under George Washington) and as President for two terms. Jefferson was a fierce advocate of the rights of individual citizens and the individual States, and his struggle against Alexander Hamilton and the Federalists over the development of a strong central government still resonates through America today. Jefferson is consistently rated by scholars as among the very greatest of American Presidents.

When President John F. Kennedy hosted dinner for a group of four dozen Nobel Prize winners, he famously commented, “I think this is the most extraordinary collection of talent, of human knowledge, that has ever been gathered together at the White House – with the possible exception of when Thomas Jefferson dined alone.” (White House Diaries.)

That is one of my favourite quotes.

The class and I spent much of our time reading through the Declaration and discussing the meaning, power, and novelty (at least back then) of its various clauses.  We talked about the courage it took – and still takes in various places around the world – to risk being imprisoned and killed for simply speaking your mind and seeking freedom.  We spent a good bit of time discussing what it means to say that governments “derive their just powers from the consent of the governed,” or to say that it is the absolute right of the people “to alter or to abolish” governments that become “destructive” of the interests and rights of the people.

The Declaration of Independence is Jefferson’s masterpiece. How it survived a committee so well, is a miracle.

We also examined the structure, history, and current application of the U.S. Constitution – the oldest and shortest written constitution in use on Earth.

I knew it was the oldest on Earth, but not that it is the shortest. It is worth remembering that the US was unique in having a written constitution and no monarchy – a form of Government that is today the most common we have.

Remembering those who died in service

I don’t think today’s generation can ever truly grasp the sacrifices made by previous generations. Today a single solider getting wounded in combat is a front page story.

How would we have coped with wars when the dead numbered not in single figures but in the tens of thousands. When not only did everyone lose someone they knew – everyone lost multiple friends and family.

So today I think of the following New Zealanders:

  • The 6,500 who served and 229 who died in the Second Boer War
  • The 103,000 who served (over 10% of our population) and 16,697 who died in WWI – the highest casualty rate of any country
  • The 204,000 who served in WWII, and 11,625 killed – the highest casualty rate in the commonwealth
  • The 1,300 who served in the Malayan conflict, and the 15 who died
  • Those who served in the Indonesia-Malaysia conflict
  • The 5,094 who served in Korea, and 33 who died
  • The 3,890 who served in Vietnam, and 37 who died
  • All others who have served

It is hard to comprehend having 42% of service age males, fighting overseas in a war, but that is what happened in WWI.

Tamihere on Labour

John Tamihere writes:

A document was released by a Labour Party member asking how Labour could make itself more relevant and meaningful to the New Zealand population.

The problem the present Labour Party has is it no longer understands who it represents, what it represents, and why it exists.

Over the past 30 years our society has changed dramatically.

The old debates about Labour left and capitalist right are no longer apparent.

The large number of so-called working class people have now migrated to the middle class. As a consequence, describing your politics in a class way is no longer sustainable.

Further, the great socialist and communist experiments – whether in Tanzania, Romania or Russia – have fallen over, most symbolically with the fall of the Berlin Wall in 1989.

By default, Labour’s politics are now determined by its well-organised factions – the women’s and gay divisions of the party.

It has drafted in a number of MPs who have studied poverty and the working class but have never come from those areas of difficulty.

It would be interesting to compare how many MPs have working class backgrounds today, as opposed to 20 years ago.

Nanny State v Rugby World Cup

The SST reports:

Tough new alcohol laws would make New Zealand an “international laughing stock” during the Rugby World Cup – but it is understood the government is secretly planning to override any attempt to spoil the party.

Auckland mayor John Banks says the Law Commission’s proposal to ban entry to bars after 2am would damage New Zealand’s interests as host of next year’s tournament.

The proposal, just one of the commission’s recommendations to toughen liquor laws, “doesn’t fit with Auckland’s role as host city for the cup”, Banks told the Sunday Star-Times.

Can you just imagine the scenes. NZ has won the Rugby World Cup. A million Kiwis are celebrating in town, and then suddenly nanny state says you can’t walk down the street and enter another bar to catch up with your friends.

World Cup Minister Murray McCully is also understood to be concerned at the effect on the cup of the commission’s proposals. Sources told the Star-Times he is preparing a World Cup Empowering Bill which will make it easier to obtain liquor licences at cup venues.

One source claimed that under the bill a temporary commissioner would grant special world cup liquor licences. It was not clear what premises would be eligible – while “fanzones” such as at Auckland’s Aotea Square, where matches will be broadcast on huge screens, would be included, normal bars may not.

Rather than have special laws for the Rugby World Cup, surely we should have laws that are fit for purpose all year long. Is the Government really going to impose nanny state laws on us in advance of the Rugby World Cup, but lift them just for the Cup?

The owner of Auckland’s Sale Street and Chapel Bar and Bistro, Luke Dallow, slammed the proposed restrictions as “pathetic” and warned they would make New Zealand the laughing stock of the world.

“We have to grow up. We’re an international city. In the great cities of the world they don’t have these restrictions. It is bizarre and archaic… we’re all adults here and we have to make our own decisions.”

This is the problem with a one size fits all approach. I’m not against certain communities being able to have restrictions in their area, if they have problems. But imposing a nationwide closing time and entry time is lowest common denominator thinking.

Banks said it was “absolutely important that we front-foot Auckland as a premier host city and as an internationally competitive metropolis, which means that we have to have sensible liquor licensing laws. If you close all licensed premises at an arbitrary hour of 1 or 2am you simply move the problem from bad licensed premises on to streets that become bad”.

I suspect violence will increase if bars are forced to adopt a no entry policy. You’ll need heaps more bouncers if people can see a bar is still open, but they can’t go inside to rejoin their mates.

Also I wonder how it will work in areas where bars have outside seating? Will they put barbed wire up to keep people from sitting down?

They don’t get it

The HoS reports:

Glenn Sims, managing director of Redflame Media and producer of The Apprentice, last night defended his star: “I’m not worried about Terry’s credibility because all these attacks are Tall Poppy syndrome.”

All the stuff/rumours about Terry’s past are probably tall poppy syndrome. But the inability to pay his bill is not an attack – it is a matter of fact.

TVNZ was also standing by the top-rating show. Spokeswoman Megan Richards said: “Serepisos’ private affairs are his own business, and we will not be commenting.”

What nonsense. When you are promoting him as one of the most successful businessmen in NZ, and someone who people would aspire to work for, then it is absolutely relevant whether or not he can pay his bills or not.

TVNZ had undertaken due diligence prior to Serepisos’ being picked for the show.

Did that include a credit check?

General Debate ANZAC Day 2010

Cash crisis for Serepisos

The Dom Post reports:

The Apprentice star Terry Serepisos is being chased by creditors and is struggling to pay about $2 million in unpaid rates and ground rents to Wellington City Council.

A Dominion Post investigation has learnt that the council has met regularly with Mr Serepisos – but he has yet to settle the substantial debt.

It is understood Mr Serepisos has told the council he is struggling to pay – and if the council takes action to recover the money it could jeopardise the Wellington Phoenix football franchise he owns. Mr Serepisos said yesterday that he had pumped a total of $5 million into the football club, which this week received a five-year extension to continue in the A-League.

I have to say that one shouldn’t make sponsorship commitments, if you can’t provide the support promised. Not paying rates, so one can continue the sponsorship is not an enduring solution.

Mr Serepisos said he had spent vast sums promoting Wellington, bankrolling the Phoenix and working with several charities and the community.

“I’m pouring in millions and millions of dollars to promote this city and doing all these things I do. And I feel a little disheartened that a handful of people are taking pot shots at me.”

Which is all great, and I think the Phoenix are great. But the obligation is to meet your legal and contractual obligations first. If you are unable to pay your rates, because of the Phoenix sponsorship, then you are not sponsoring the Phoenix – I am – along with all the other ratepayers who do pay our rates.

And it goes without saying how bad a look it is for The Apprentice TV show, to have the boss in the media for being unable to pay his bills. Maybe the winner should make sure they get the $200,000 in advance!

Another Dom Post story also has details of other creditors claiming they have not been paid.

General Debate 24 April 2010

ACT on Palmer Report

Great release from Rodney and Heather:

“The Law Commission’s reported proposals on alcohol are frankly ludicrous”, ACT Deputy Leader Heather Roy said today.

“They cannot possibly pass the government’s tests for good regulatory and tax policy.”

“It seems the Commission wants to take New Zealand back to the days of punitive excise taxation and nanny state regulation of shop trading hours, closing times for bars and the purchase age.

“We have been there and done that with alcohol policy and it didn’t work,” Mrs Roy said.

Since liberalisation that commenced in 1989, consumption per head has declined significantly and there has been no increase in hazardous drinking. The vast majority of New Zealanders have a responsible attitude to alcohol.

“The tourism, hospitality and entertainment industries, and New Zealanders at large, have hugely benefited from less repressive policies on alcohol over the past 20 years. Imagine overseas visitors coming to New Zealand for the Rugby World Cup and finding it closed.”

Any law changes will be passed before the RWC. It will be interesting to see how that contrasts with plans for the RWC to be hosted by 4 million kiwis, and venues like party central.

ACT Leader Rodney Hide said “The Government needs strategies that target the small percentage of drinkers who cause the problems. This could include better enforcement of existing laws, greater penalties for drunken and disorderly behaviour, banning orders and public naming and shaming of serious offenders, stricter welfare policies for alcohol and drug abusers and less access to services such as ACC.”

This is the key. I’ll support measures that target problem drinkers, rather than those that target everyone who likes to have a drink.

As one example, I think introducing a drinking age of 18 (with an exception for direct parental supervision) would do far more in targeting the problem, than raising the purchase age to 20, making it illegal for a 19 year odl to buy a bottle of wine.

At present it is totally legal for 14 year olds to get pissed on spirits, if done on private property.

Vodafone responds

Vodafone have sent a response to my recent post on their pricing change:

Got a prepay mobile with Vodafone? Give up your landline

Last week we released a new add-on called Talk that lets Vodafone Prepay customers talk for up to 200 minutes a month to landlines or to Vodafone mobiles for $12.  We want to encourage our mobile customers to use their voices rather than their fingers, and their mobiles rather than their home phones.

Certainly Talk has got a reaction.  A range of parties have expressed a view, including the Minister, the Commerce Commission, TUANZ, 2degrees, and the blogosphere.  Even DPF himself has weighed in.

I want to make three points.  First, why we are launching Talk.  Second, why it is good for competition.  And third, what the implications are for the Minister’s decision on mobile termination rates.

Why Talk

Talk is a great deal.  In particular, you should buy Talk and give up using your landline.  You pay too much for it anyway.

We all know that New Zealand mobile users are very keen on text messaging.  New Zealand has amongst the lowest prices and highest usage for text in the world. But the same enthusiasm doesn’t extend to talking.

Our research tells us that three quarters of customers wait till they get home to make a call longer than five minutes.  Talk is part of our response, letting customers get on with what they want to do with their mobiles.

This is not the only change we are bringing to prepay this year.  Recently we introduced cheap international calling rates for our top destinations, but it began in 2006 with Best Mate TXT2000, $2 for 2 hours off-peak, and the introduction of Family in 2008. There is much more to come.

Competition

2degrees has argued for years that it cannot compete without a laundry list of regulatory concessions.  2degrees has not deviated from this line despite the numerous changes that have been made to accommodate it. But with several hundred thousand customers after just over six months, 2degrees is already one of the most successful new entrants in the world.  I see the Commission this morning reported 2degrees’ market share at 4% as at 31 December.  Five percent market share in a year would be very good performance.  So 4% percent in around six months is remarkable.

The real question is not what our competitors think, but whether they can match or better Talk.  Clearly they can, and they will if they think that doing so will gain them an advantage in the market.

Comparison between headline retail rates and mobile termination rates is not helpful.  Operators offer lots of different products, some are higher priced, others are lower priced.  All three mobile network operators offer products that are cheaper than MTRs.  Some examples:

•             Telecom offers calls from a Telecom fixed line to a Telecom mobile for sixty minutes for no more than a dollar.  If calls are long this could easily generate a very low average price (hat tip: Steve Biddle).

•             Vodafone allows unlimited calling between all connections on one business account in return for a monthly fee per connection.   Clearly this also generates a very low average price if usage is high.

•             2degrees offers its customers text messaging to any other 2degrees’ customer for 2 cents a text.  Under our agreement with 2degrees, we are required to pay more than four times that amount to text a 2degrees customer.

The Commission does have a cross-check between mobile termination rates and retail prices in its final report.  It’s not based on the level of any particular retail plan; instead it compares industry average retail on-net mobile prices with mobile termination rates.  Talk shouldn’t affect that average.

Decision

The Minister needs to decide what to do with the Commission’s termination rate recommendation.  He can send it back to the Commission for more work or accept the undertakings as recommended by the Commission.

Accepting the undertakings means lower mobile prices from October.  Voice termination rates would fall from 14.4 cents (already lower than the UK) to just under 10 cents, and then again to just over 8 cents on 1 January with more falls over time.  The undertakings cut text prices to zero.

Sending the report back to the Commission for more work means termination rates stay where they are for a longer period.

The Minister’s decision is quite straightforward.  His best choice is to take the money on the table now, accept the undertakings and reduce mobile prices from October.  If the Commission wants to look further at retail pricing and the relationship with mobile termination rates there is nothing to stop it doing so.

Hayden Glass
Public Policy
Vodafone NZ

We all await the Minister’s decision with interest. In the meantime, the debate will continue!

Copyright madness

Many readers will have seen various Downfall parodies. They have become an Internet cult. Hundreds of people have inserted their own subtitles over a four minute clip where Hitler goes beserk at his generals.

I especially enjoyed three of the parodies – Clark, Peters and Tizard in the final weeks of the 2008 campaign. Thankfully they are still up, but many other parodies have been removed due to a copyright complaint by Constantin films.

The clip above is a parody of the fact You Tube is removing the parodies.

AP report:

On Tuesday, the clips on YouTube, many of which had been watched by hundreds of thousands, even millions, began disappearing from the site. Constantin Films, the company that owns the rights to the film, asked for them to be removed, and YouTube complied.

Martin Moszkowicz, head of film and TV at Constantin films in Munich, said the company had been fighting copyright infringement for years. Jewish organisations have also complained about the tastefulness of the clips, he said.

“When does parody stop? It is a very complicated issue,” Moszkowicz said. “So we are taking a simple approach: Take them all down. We’ve been doing it for years now. The important thing is to protect our copyright. We are very proud of the film.”

The clips were in no way a commercial threat to the film. Not a single person would have not purchased the film, because of a four minute parody extract. On the contrary, it has exposed parts of the film to millions.

There is a real debate about whether the parodies would be allowable under the US fair use laws. However the DMCA can make You Tube liable if they do not err on the side of caution and remove them. It is a pity that this doesn’t go to a Judge. It does highlight the danger of adopting US style notice and takedown laws.

Abraham Foxman, national director of the Anti-Defamation League, said the league was “delighted.”

“We find them offensive,” said Foxman of the videos. “We feel that they trivialise not only the Holocaust but World War II. Hitler is not a cartoon character.”

On this issue I respectfully disagree. The parodies do not disrespect the Holocaust in my opinion.

For years, the meme has held an unusually steadfast position in internet culture. While most online parodies come and go overnight, new Downfall spoofs have been continually created for years.

It’s not known exactly how many have existed but estimates run in the hundreds.

I’ve seen a dozen myself. If done well, they never get boring.