Dominion Post Winners, Losers and Wallies

The Dominion Post has a weekly feature where the give out winner, loser and wally of the week. It had a break and seemed to only start back up in June 2009. Previously they also scored some of the exchanges.

I’ve gone through the archives, and extracted out their awards, and some stats for you, covering 2009:

Winner of the Week

  • Key and Sharples got three times
  • Joyce and Power twice
  • Labour MPs only got award twice out of 22 weeks it was awarded

Loser of the Week

  • Bill English got four times
  • John Key got three times

Wally of the Week

  • Rodney Hide and Treasury three times each
  • David Garrett, Phil Goff, Michael Laws twice each

The gift that keeps on giving

TV3 reported yesterday:

Labour MP Chris Carter is tonight defending a planned two-and-a-half week trip to Europe as just doing his job.

Mr Carter was much-criticised for his hefty travel bills when he was a minister, but now Carter is off to observe the upcoming UK elections.

And that is not parliamentary work. Chris is Opposition Foreign Affairs Spokesperson, and overseas travel to meet with foreign Ministers and MPs on international policy issues is a legitimate work expense.

But spending over a week observing the UK elections is not – that is party political.

If the election observing was just for a day or two, of a trip with legitimate parliamentary purposes, then I don’t think it would be an issue. But observing (which really means learning campaign strategies to try back home) an election is not a legitimate parliamentary purpose.

Mr Carter was dubbed the ‘Minister for Overseas Travel’ when he was in office, spending $131,000 over a year. Now in opposition and with the spotlight on MPs’ spending, Mr Carter has had to be more careful.

No wonder Whale has dubbed Chris the gift that keeps on giving. On top of his huge number of trips as Education Minister, we’ve also had many trips in Opposition – few having anything to do with his parliamentary duties.

Mr Carter told 3 News the only taxpayer-funded part of the trip is the heavily-subsidised return airfares to Europe he’s entitled to as a long-serving MP, and he’s likely to fly business class.

Which is by fat the biggest cost.

Mr Carter says the trip is all work.

Eight days observing the UK elections is not parliamentary work. It is Labour Party work.

I empathise with Chris. I love foreign elections. I’ve even been to a couple, and would love to be in the UK for their elections. A mate of mine has in fact gone there. But he has taken unpaid leave from his job, and paid his own way. And when I have travelled to observe elections, I have funded my own way.

If Chris wants to observe the UK elections for Labour, then Labour should fund his travel.

Mr Carter told 3 News he would be disappointed if we did this story about his European trip. He pointed out he hadn’t been overseas this year, and as Labour’s Foreign Affairs spokesman, travel was part of his job.

Well that is a lie, and I am amazed Three News did not pick it up. Chris was in the Carribean and New York for two and a bit weeks earlier this year.

And travel is part of the job for a Foreign Affairs spokesman – I agree. But only for portfolio related events, and observing the UK election is not a parliamentary task.

As I said, if the UK elections was just for a day or two, then no big fuss – people get weekends off – even on overseas trips. But as far as I can tell, the UK elections are the main rationale for the trip, and the fleeting visits to other countries are secondary.

He says 3 News is unfairly targeting him because of his past spending, and says other Labour MPs have indeed been overseas on holidays this year without media attention.

Of course Chris gets more scrutiny, which is why he should be more restrained. It’s just like people notice a reformed alcoholic having a drink, but in this case a travelaholic.

Mr Carter wouldn’t say who, but it is understood David Parker went to Cuba for more than two weeks and David Cunliffe was hosted by the Japanese government last week.

Dobbing his colleagues in won’t go down well with them I suspect.

But Mr Carter says the scrutiny won’t stop him doing his job, and he intends to go to Pakistan and India later in the year.

And if he is there not to observe elections, but discuss regional security issues, trade policy, foreign policy etc then I support such travel. But the UK trip should not qualify, and I am amazed Phil Goff approved it.

Legal Aid Changes

Simon Power has just announced some changes to the legal aid system. The two major ones are:

  1. A new quality assurance framework where legal aid lawyers will have to demonstrate competency to a selection committee on objective criteria.
  2. Expanding the Public Defence Service to Wellington, Christchurch, and Hamilton.

The Auckland Public Defence Service has been quite successful, so good to see it is expanding.

Hopefully the competency demonstration requirement will help solve the problem of delays caused by incompetent counsel (which it seems is mainly a South Auckland problem).

Editorials 7 April 2010

The Herald weighs up large trucks on roads:

According to the Ministry of Transport, trucks carrying heavier loads on our roads “will help to improve road safety, while reducing road congestion, operating costs and vehicle emissions”.

The statement is a highly contrary one to critics of the move, who foresee only an increased threat to safety. They are apt to point out that trucks are involved in 16 per cent of all road fatalities despite comprising only 4 per cent of the vehicle fleet.

The MOT rationale is I presume that it is safer to have a fewer number of heavier trucks on the road, than a larger number of lighter trucks.

Allowing trucks to carry loads of up to 53 tonnes – an increase from the present limit of 44 tonnes – from next month can only, they say, make matters worse.

Basic physics supports their view. Heavier trucks will take longer to stop, thereby creating heightened danger for any motorist caught in their path.

That individual truck may be more dangerous, but it does not mean the trucking fleet as a whole will be more dangerous.

But physics are not uppermost in the ministry’s mind when it talks of safety. It hangs its hat on the productivity equation – that a given amount of freight will be carried on fewer trucks.

Safer roads, it says, will be the product of an estimated 20 per cent decrease in the number of trips by trucks, as will be an increase of productivity of between 10 and 20 per cent.

I’d rather have fewer trucks on the road, even if they are heavier.

The Dom Post looks at Auckland Mayors today:

Aucklanders sometimes wonder why the rest of the country rolls its eyes when contemplating shenanigans in the City of Sails.

Sunday newspaper reports about the behaviour of North Shore Mayor Andrew Williams illustrate why. He has been accused of public drunkenness, urinating in a public place and driving the mayoral car after he had been drinking one night. …

The mayor has built for himself a reputation of volatility and irascibility, particularly when his will is crossed. Still, he won’t be North Shore mayor after October.

I suspect many North Shore residents are counting down the days.

Mr Williams says he will run for the super-city but won’t say if he’ll contest the mayoralty – probably the second-most-important political position in the country. If he does, he is unlikely to win. New Zealand might love its iconoclasts, but this job is too important to entrust to someone of his ilk.

Little risk there I would say.

The Press calls for Easter trading reform:

If there is one area of the law which is crying out for a thorough re-examination it is the Easter shop trading restrictions.

Once again over the past long weekend Labour Department inspectors were out and about, attempting to enforce a hotchpotch trading regime which is riddled with inconsistencies. …

Then there is the view that with liberal retailing hours at other times of the year it is not too much to reserve Good Friday and Easter Sunday as, generally, shopping-free days, along with Christmas Day and Anzac Day before 1pm.

Yet loosening the restrictions on Easter Sunday or even Good Friday would not compel New Zealanders to head to the cash register. Those who choose, instead, to spend time with family could still do so.

Provided there are safeguards to ensure that reluctant employees could not be coerced into working, then it is high time that the traditional justifications for trading restrictions be scrutinised to determine whether they remain relevant.

Absoultely. And once the change had been made, everyone will wonder why we didn’t do it years ago – just like weekend shopping.

The ODT focuses on the military:

While the air force’s lack of strike-force capability remains a joke, significant expense and effort has gone towards better equipping the navy and army – only for poor judgements and decision-making to undermine much of the progress. …

HMNZS Canterbury, the multi-role ship in this little fleet, had so many defects that manufacturer BAE Systems paid the Government $84.6 million to repair them.

A scathing independent review last year said the ship’s poor performance in high seas would now just have to be accepted. …

How disappointing that one of the army’s latest purchases did its best to outdo the worst of the navy’s larks.

The army spent $590,000 on bullets that were unfit for use in the army’s guns, and had to resell the ammunition for $350,000.

Not to be outdone in magnitude of waste, the army’s light operational vehicles were 63 months late, cost $37 million more than planned and had a string of difficulties.

Now the Government is looking at selling 35 of the 105 because it believes too many were bought.

It was obvious from the beginning we have too many LAVs.

My personal view is that without a strike capability, there is no reason to maintain the RNZAF as a separate service, and our remaining planes and choppers should be integrated into the Army and Navy.

Backbenches

Rudman on Easter

The best reason I heard over Easter for repealing the shop trading restrictions, is it would deprive Newmarket Business Association CEO Cameron Brewer of a media opportunity!

In Wellington, the restrictions have little impact. Cafes are open. Restaurants are open. You can go to the movies. Lots of food on sale at dairies and garages. Bars are open. It is only a few retailers that are affected, and a bunch of them just open anyway and see the $1,000 fine as a cost of doing business.

Anyway Brian Rudman points out the silliness of the current laws:

On Good Friday and Easter Sunday it was perfectly legal for me to drive across town to the Royal Easter Show, gorge myself ill on candyfloss, and gamble away my money on such so-called games of skill as “Pluck a Duck” and “Flip a Frog”.

But woe betide the supermarket which dared open its doors to sell me a toilet – or bread – roll.

Once again we’ve been through the time that transcends all understanding, the annual Easter trading laws fiasco.

The two days a year when a weekend market on Wellington’s harbourside can open, but a farmers’ market in Hamilton is threatened with a fine of up to $1000 for each stall that opens.

A time when Parnell and Queenstown shops could open, but not their competitors in neighbouring Newmarket and Wanaka.

The law is a mess as it does not in fact help staff have an Easter break with their families, because Easter Saturday and Easter Monday are normal trading days.

And bizarrely if you do work Easter Sunday, it is not a public holiday, so you get paid nothing extra.

The status quo is in fact quite anti-worker. The unions resist any changes mainly because in some regards they are very conservative beats, that resist most changes.

Here’s what I would propose to get same sane laws over Easter:

  1. Declare all four days to be public holidays – Good Friday, Easter Saturday, Ester Day and Easter Monday.
  2. Law states no employee (except essential services) can be forced to work any of the four Easter days.
  3. No restrictions on any store opening
  4. If a store does not open, Any staff normally rostered on for those days of the week, get paid a normal days wages – as for all other public holidays
  5. If a store does open, staff who choose to work get penal rates (generally time and a half) and a day in lieu

This proposal is extremely generous to employees. It gives them two extra days of public holidays, gives them the right to choose to work on all four days (as the moment they have no choice if a store opens), and gives then public holiday pay rates on all four Easter days.

An employee who chooses to work on the four Easter days, would get effectively paid for 10 days – two weeks of income for four days work.

The Yang Liu case

The Herald reports:

Yong Ming Yan – also known as Bill Liu, Yang Liu and William Yan – has pleaded not guilty to 12 charges relating to false declarations on immigration papers and using fake identities to obtain a passport. …

The Herald was first to report the criminal charges against Yan, a development which was embarrassing for several MPs who assisted his successful bid for citizenship.

The Herald may be first to report the criminal charges, but one should recognise that the entire story was broken by Ian Wishart.

Yan became a New Zealand citizen in August 2008 under the name Yang Liu. But he changed his name days later, and was granted a passport in the name of William Yan.

Passports in two other names were earlier seized by investigators. He was granted citizenship in a VIP ceremony in Wellington last year after lobbying from former Labour MP Dover Samuels, who regards him as a close friend.

Labour’s Chris Carter and National’s Pansy Wong also wrote letters of support for his citizenship. Rick Barker, the then Internal Affairs Minister, was also on the list of politicians who knew Yan.

And while slightly embarrassing, they had no idea that Liu was wanted on criminal charges, had been deported from Australia and had multiple fake aliases.

Because of this, he passed the file to another minister, Shane Jones.

Mr Jones overruled Internal Affairs advice that Liu – now Yan – did not meet character requirements and granted him citizenship.

Among the reasons officials gave for opposing Yan’s citizenship application was that they did not know his true identity as he had two names, two passports and two birth dates.

This is where the scrutiny should be. Shane Jones did know all of this. DIA was absolutely insistent that Liu should not be given citizenship. They talked of him being under criminal investigation.The Immigration Service said he should not even have residency, and wanted to revoke his residency status,

Yet Jones went ahead and made him a citizen. Why? Well he won’t say.

Labour MPs in 2009

I’ve done the above table ranking the productivity of the 44 Labour MPs, in 2009, on three criteria. They are:

  1. No of press releases issued, and the associated rank (1 is most, 44 is least). This is based on a search of Scoop for their name in releases from Labour.
  2. No of news stories mentioning them, and the associated rank. This is based on a search of the NZPA database for political stories mentioning them.
  3. No of written questions asked by them, and the associated rank. This is based on a search of the Parliamentary PQs database.

So you can see the output and rank for each category, plus an overall rank based on an average of the three category ranks.

To some degree the three categories represent inputs, outputs and outcomes. The written PQs are the inputs – the grunt work you do to find out information for your portfolio. Some MPs actually abuse the facility, but overall it is a reasonable indicator of activity.

The media releases are the outputs – how often an MP is actually putting a statement out there for the media to pick up.

The news stories are the outcomes – how often activity by that MP actually makes the news. Of course not all news stories are positive ones, but overall a harder working MP will get more news stories.

I have not surveyed the number of oral questions they ask, or the number of speeches in the House. The reasons for this is that the leadership tend to allocate these out or roster people on for these. It is not the same as MP generated activity.

People may wonder why I have only done these for Labour. Well Government backbenchers are not actually encouraged to do press releases (except on local issues) or ask PQs. It is only for an Opposition party, these stats make sense. I did a similar survey of National MPs in 2008.

So what do these stats tell us, starting from the bottom:

  • Ashraf Choudhary is in bottom place. Originally I had him with even lower stats as I was searching on Choudary, not Choudhary, but even after I corrected for this, he remained on bottom place.
  • Next two lowest are Rajen Prasad and Raymond Huo.
  • Steve Chadwick is Senior Labour Whip, so she is not expected to be doing a lot of releases.
  • Carol Beaumont and Stuart Nash have little activity for new MPs wanting to win electorate seats.
  • Nanaia Mahuta has had family issues, and Damien O’Connor only entered halfway through the year, explaining their fairly low ratings.
  • Phil Goff’s rating is a bit misleading. He has put out by far the most releases and had many times more news stories. However he is only ranked 9th as he has done almost no PQs. Now in reality he is in 1st place, as the Leader never does his own PQs – they are done by other MPs.
  • Very interesting that Grant Robertson is in No 2 place. Is he already Leader in Waiting?
  • Shane Jones can be a talented performer, but his lack of activity is part of the reason why his colleagues are unlikely to make him Leader. He prefers to rely on his natural showmanship, rather than do the hard yards to a degree.
  • In terms of press releases the top five are Goff, G Robertson, Chauvel, Anderton and Cunliffe.
  • In terms of news coverage the top five are Goff, King, Shearer (due to by-election), Cunliffe and Mallard.
  • Those MPs who have done less than 250 (average one per work day) PQs, releases or stories are (in order) Prasad, Choudhary, Chadwick, Horomia, O’Connor, Huo, and Dalziel.

Now these are a fairly crude measure of activity. I’ve used them because they are totally quantifiable, not because they are necessarily the best way to rank MPs.

Having said that, there is some correlation. MPs seem as future Ministers such as G Robertson, Twyford and Chauvel are in the top ranks, while I don’t think anyone is betting money on when Ashraf Choudhary will become a Minister!

I’ll update these in early 2011, and people can see what changes, if any, there has been.

How many weeks since an Obama Press Conference

In New Zealand, the PM has a formal press conference every week, and often several standups on top of that.

How many weeks do people think have gone by, since President Obama held a full press conference at the White House?

Blog Bits

  1. The oldest blogger on Earth, 99 year old Elvira S Oliver, has blogged on visiting Christchurch and the wonderful time she has in Christchurch in 1964. She can’t remember the names of everywhere she went, but readers may be able to work out where they were and comment on her blog.
  2. Joshua Drummond got sick of firms not even reading his CV, so he has turned it into a comic book. Check it out – it is seriously creatively cool. Joshua is Waikato based and look for media opportunities. His comic book CV would make a good news story about how to stand out!
  3. Check out the Yike Bike. it is a battery powered bike that folds up into well a circle and fits in a shoulder bag. This is seriously cool. Like the Ford Model T it comes in black only! This will become huge I reckon.
  4. Its past April 1st, but had to highlight the Education Directions blog post on how Steven Joyce has appointed himself Chairperson of all 20 polytechnic councils. Incidentally the ED Blog is truly essential reading for anyone interested in tertiary education policies and politics.
  5. Whale blogs his own graphical media rating system.
  6. The Onion is at its wicked best with its news story on how the Catholic Church has vowed to reduce paedophilia to acceptable levels by 60% over five years to the target five children per thousand clergy.

10/10

2010 ANZAC of the Year

The Royal New Zealand Returned Services Association has released:

The Prime Minister John Key announced today that Christchurch man Lieutenant Colonel (Lt Col) John Milbanke Masters ONZM MC JP has been awarded the inaugural ANZAC of the Year award.

The award was instituted by the Royal New Zealand Returned Services’ Association (RNZRSA) to recognise the ANZAC qualities of comradeship, compassion, courage and commitment.

Lt Col Masters was chosen from nominations received from throughout New Zealand.

RNZRSA National President Robin Klitscher said Lt Col Masters was an excellent choice as both his career in the Army and after were guided significantly by the traits the award sought to recognise.

“He is a decorated Army officer who served for 27 years. During that time he was awarded the Military Cross for rescuing a wounded Gurkha Warrant Officer under extremely difficult circumstances. He was also made a life member of the Gurkha Regimental Association’s Sirmoor Club – an honour normally restricted to Gurkhas.”

As well as seeing service in Borneo, Lt Col Masters served in Vietnam as the seventh battery commander of the New Zealand Artillery Battery, a position he still held when the Battery returned to New Zealand in May 1971.

After retiring from the Army in April 1983 Lt Col Masters held several senior management roles in business.

“But he retained his interest in the Army and its soldiers; indeed in all veterans,” Mr Klitscher said.

“He was heavily involved in Rannerdale War Veterans home and was instrumental in raising substantial funds to allow the home to stay open and to be upgraded.

“His personal testimony to the Health Select Committee was crucial to breaking open the facts of exposure to chemicals during service in Viet Nam, thus enabling follow-up investigation into the matter to take place on a firm footing. He was subsequently a Trustee of the Viet nam Veterans and their Families Trust; and has also been a panellist assisting with War Pension applications.”

In 2002 Lt Col Masters was appointed an Officer of the New Zealand Order of Merit (ONZM).

The award is a bronze statuette based on the famous Gallipoli image “Man with the donkey” and designed by official New Zealand Army artist Matt Gauldie.

What an excellent award concept, and a very worthy inaugural winner – noth for his service in Borneo, but also for his concern for the welfare of his fellow veterans.

A summary of how he won his military cross in Borneo is here. An extract:

Eventually the CSM struggled to his feet and they slowly and quietly moved off, John carrying the wounded CSM for about an hour and a half in short spells of five or ten minutes, until he was quite exhausted. They stopped and lay down for a planned hour’s rest but after a while, the CSM reached out for a stick and pulled himself to his feet and announced that he would try and walk for himself. Considering the obvious pain he was in and the blood loss, it was an amazing show of strength and will. Mind you, the CSM was no fool as he knew that John obviously couldn’t carry him all the way back to the border. John decided to take no chances and lashed the compass to his wrist so that it couldn’t be lost in the mud or swamp as they stumbled along.

By now it was early afternoon and the CSM managed to keep going until some time after 1600. John walked ahead with his weapon ready and compass permanently in his hand; he had made a conscious decision not to deviate from that bearing come what may. They rested briefly and then, as the CSM was all but out on his feet, John carried him for about another two hours. However progress was slow as the CSM was now in great pain and John’s strength was starting to fail him.

It took 54 hours for him to get out, and then go back in to recover the CSM. The CSM subsequently went on to father three sons.

We should be proud of the service of Lt Colonel Masters.

Labour are spamming

I have had this confirmed from two independent sources now, so it is not a mistake -Labour are spamming people.

Wellington Central MP Grant Robertson has a petition to Keep the Sevens in Wellington. You are required to provide an e-mail address to sign it. There is no privacy statement associated with the petition.

Some time after you sign this, my reader complained to me that he had received an e-mail from Grant Robertson. I investigated that e-mail, and actually concluded that it was not spam. It acknowldged signing the petition, encouraged the signer to promote the petition to other people and also said:

Also, if you want to keep up with other issues and events in Wellington Central, you are more than welcome to join my main mailing list here: http://labourparty.org.nz/page/s/wgtncentral

Now my response to the reader was that this was not spam. A one off response, linked to the petition I deemed appropriate, and it merely offered the opportunity to go on Grant’s main mailing list.

However on the 26th of March, the petition signer got another e-mail. This one was not from Grant Robertson and not about the Sevens.

It was from Chris Flatt, the Labour Party General Secretary, and all about mining. An extract:

Stop John Key’s plan to mine our National Parks
Last year the National Government announced it would review Schedule 4 of the Crown Minerals Act. That might sound innocuous. But it’s the first step towards the devastation of our National Parks by commercial miners. …

Campaigns cost money

Can you spare $20 to help fund resources for this campaign, please?  I assure you it will be put to good use fighting National’s plans to mine our precious conservation estates.

You can make a secure donation now. Please visit: https://secure.labourparty.org.nz/donate

Let’s get going!

Chris Flatt – Labour Party General Secretary

Now my reader is absolutely 100% clear that he did not ask to be placed on the Labour Party mailing list. The only way they have his e-mail is from the petition.

So what has happened, is that all the good citizens of Wellington who signed the petition to save the sevens, have been added onto the central e-mail database for the Labour Party.

In terms of what Internet users define as spam, this is definitely spam. Labour are spamming people who have not consented, and they should stop this practice immediately.

Grant’s practice of a singular e-mail acknowledging their petition, and offering the chance to subscribe is an acceptable practice. But Grant, or someone in his office, has obviously passed on all those e-mail addresses to Labour Head Office, even if they did not take up the offer to join a mailing list.

So be warned. If you sign a petition promoted by a Labour MP, you may end up being spammed by them.

I’ve considered whether Labour have broken the law on this. The law only makes it an offence to send commercial unsolicited e-mails. Now Labour are soliciting money, which could be seen as commercial, but the Act has a narrow definition which is basically promoting goods, services, land or a business opportunity.

So it is not against the law, but it is spam, and probably against the terms and conditions of the ISP that Labour use.

As I said, I hope Labour will publicly state they will not spam people in future, and explain why they did so on this occasion.

UPDATE: Labour Party General Secretary has e-mailed a response:

In response to your post, we apologise unreservedly to those who received the mining email as a result of signing the sevens petition. This happened because the bulk email tool that the Party uses is also used by Labour MPs for other purposes, such as Grant emailing people to update them on progress with the sevens petition.

A staff member used the database of signatories without Grant’s knowledge or approval. This is highly regrettable and I can assure you and other readers that it will not happen again.

Good to hear it was an error by a staff member, and not deliberate.

MPs Children Travel

The Herald reports:

Greens co-leader Metiria Turei is backing a plan to expand the travel perks for MPs’ children which potentially opens the way for MPs to claim for taking their children on holiday.

Parliament’s Speaker, Lockwood Smith, revealed last week that he was considering changing the rules to allow the children to travel anywhere in New Zealand to join their MP parent rather than just between their home and Wellington.

School-aged children now get four return trips to Wellington a year to allow them to see their MP parent while he or she is working in Parliament.

However, Dr Smith said most children could travel only during the school holidays – when the House was in recess and few MPs were in Wellington.

He believed more flexibility was warranted but said he did not intend to make it more expensive or expand it beyond the equivalent of four trips a year. A financial cap was one possibility.

The current policy seems reasonable to most people. The job requires MPs to spend half their year in Wellington, so their school age kids can travel down once per term, or more likely once per school holidays.

It is tempting to then go along with the argument that as few MPs are in Wellington during school holidays, the travel policy should be more flexible and wllow them to travel to other areas to be with their MP parent.

However I think this does change the nature of the policy, from a clearly work related policy, to something that could end up subsidising private holidays – and that is something which I don’t think is appropriate.

Any rule change could stipulate that the perk was to be used only when the MP was on work trips rather than private holidays.

She said MPs often spent the holiday recesses working elsewhere around the country rather than in their hometowns.

Ms Turei said she had no issue with limiting the number of trips, but it made sense for children to travel to wherever their parents were, rather than just Wellington.

“That’s the point, really. Especially for those who have younger children, it can get difficult to see them.”

If the Speaker does change the eligibility, then Metiria’s suggestion of only allowing it to accompany an MP on a work trip has merit, as that would be more palatable than what will be seen as a subsidy for private holidays.

Something that the Speaker may wish to reflect upon, is how the Remuneration Authority currently treats the policy on dependants’ domestic air travel.

You see the Remuneration Authority calculates a total remuneration level for an MP, and then deducts off that total package, the private value of some of the perks.

For example 5% of the average cost of MPs’ air travel is deemed of private benefit, as is 45% of the average costs of spouses’ air travel and 100% of MPs’ international air travel. So these are all deducted from the total remuneration package to calculate an MPs salary.

What I find interesting is what the Remuneration Authority said in their last detailed determination in 2003 on dependents’ air travel:

Dependants’ domestic air travel

4.5 The average cost of this per member is $2,208. The IRD has assessed that all of this constitutes remuneration. The Authority has made no allowance for this in the calculation of the package value as it believes that members should be able to have their children visit them in Wellington at the taxpayers’ expense.

So unlike even an MPs own air travel (which is deemed 5% private) the Remuneration Authority had determined that allowing children to travel to Wellington (four times a year for school age) is a legitimate 100% work related necessity.

But if this is changed to include travel to outside of Wellington, then I would suggest the Remuneration Authority would find that there is now a private benefit to this, and deduct a portion of the cost off an MPs salary calculation (as they do for 45% of spouses travel).

So if the Speaker does make the change, then it may result in MPs having it effectively deducted off their salary – regardless of whether they use it or not.

Invalids Benefit

The Herald reports:

Work and Income has quietly started bumping dozens of people off the invalids benefit, months before tough new work tests officially come into force, say beneficiary advocates.

They say people with long-term mental illnesses, some of whom have been on the invalids benefit for years, are being bumped down to sickness benefits because they may be capable of part-time work or study within the next two years.

The invalids benefit is only for people with conditions that will last for at least two years and who cannot work regularly for at least 15 hours a week.

Well if people are capable of part-time work of 15 hours a week, they shouldn’t be on the Invalids Benefit.

Most of the people on the Invalids Benefit are amongst our most deserving. They are genuinely unable to work due to their health problems, and probably will never be able to work. To some degree I actually wish we can do more for them.

But some of those on the Invalids Benefit are able to work, at least part-time. We often see remarkably fit criminals who are listed in court documents as invalids beneficiaries.

the growth in this benefit has been pronounced. Have a look from the beginning:

It really started to take off around 1981. I’m sure it wasn’t all injuries from the Springbok Tour that has seen it go from 10,000 to 85,000.

Now wait a minute, some of you may be saying. Hasn’t the population increased also since 1929. Well yes it has.

As the benefit is for those aged between 18 and 64, one should compare it to the working age population of the same range. Stats NZ only has data back to 1991 publicly available, so I start the next graph there:

As one can see, the number of recipients of the Invalids Benefit has more than doubled as a proportion of the working age population. This is not a sustainable trend.

Is 3% of the population, or 1 in 30 adults aged under 65 really incapable of even part-time work? Certainly some are – I know some people on the IB who are absolutely incapable of 15 hours a week. But is it 1 in 30?

The special Electoral Select Committee

Last week the House established a special Electoral Legislation Select Committee, to consider the electoral finance and the MMP referenda bills.

It is set up to specifically include all seven Parliamentary parties, to try and continue the consensual approach Simon Power has fostered in this area. The difference between this and Labour’s approach to the old Electoral Finance Act is massive.

According to Dave at Big News, the committee is:

  1. National (4) – Amy Adams (Chair), Hekia Parata, Paul Quinn, Chris Tremain
  2. Labour (3) – Lianne Dalziel, Pete Hodgson, Darren Hughes
  3. Green (1) – Metiria Turei
  4. Maori (1) – Rahui Katene
  5. ACT (1) – John Boscawen
  6. United (1) – Peter Dunne
  7. Progressive (1) – Jim Anderton

Not that I expect too many divisions on partisan lines, but note the CR parties have six members, CL five members and Maori Party one member. So neither CR nor CL have a majority.

The appointment of Amy Adams as Chair is notable, as she has only been an MP for just over a year. Amy is hugely competent, and a very strong performer. I expect she will be the first of the Class of 2008 to become a Minister.

Editorials 6 April 2010

The Herald calls for aligning of top tax rates:

It will lower the top rate of income tax from 38 per cent to perhaps 33 per cent, which would leave it still significantly higher than the company rate of 30 per cent.

Aligning those rates should be a primary aim of tax reform. The top income and company rates should be the same for reasons of social equity and economic efficiency.

It is neither fair nor useful to the economy that taxpayers on the same incomes should pay different rates because one puts some costs through a company and the other does not.

Arguably it is more important to align the trust rate and the personal rate.

I think we should aim to align all three, but a 3% difference between company and personal is not huge, considering company tax is inputted.

The rates were aligned for a long time after the 1980s reforms when incentives for tax avoidance were taken out of the system.

The incentives were restored by Helen Clark’s Government as a byproduct of its determination to “tax the rich”.

It introduced a new top income rate of 39 per cent in its first year of office, 2000, and tax-avoidance opportunities returned.

Chief among them are the use of trust funds and personal investment entities that carry a lower tax rate, 33 per cent.

Yeah, that unnecessary tax increase has been a boon for the avoidance industry. Remember 50 of the 100 richest NZers do not even pay it.

The Government expects to be borrowing $240 million a week for the next four years. Tax cuts must be balanced by spending cuts if the red ink is not to get worse.

The economy would gain as much strength from a balanced Budget as it would from competitive company tax rates.

Whatever decision the Government makes on the alignment of income and company rates it should be guided by the implications for its revenue. But if it can afford to align those rates it should do so.

Alignment is tidy, simple and fairer for everybody.

Can’t disagree with that.

The Dom Post welcomes open justice:

Justice Warwick Gendall, presiding in the High Court at Whangarei, was upholding the concept of “open justice” in another way. He said talented Blues rugby player Rene Ranger had no more right to anonymity than anyone else charged with assault. The charge of injuring with intent to injure dates from October, when Ranger appeared in Warkworth District Court after an incident outside a Mangawhai pub. He was given name suppression at the time, after his counsel argued that naming him might end his contract with the New Zealand Rugby Union. Poor lamb.

Justice Gendall was having none of such nonsense and reversed the order.

It is cheering when judges remember that they work in public courts, on behalf of people who have not only entrusted them with dispensing justice fairly and impartially, but who also must fund much of what goes on within their courtrooms. Open justice needs to prevail as often as possible; the circumstances in which secrecy supplants it should be rare indeed. …

The shape of Mr Power’s bill, therefore, will be interesting. It will, this newspaper hopes, make it much harder for the wealthy, the well-known, and those who can engage a judge’s sympathy to hide from public scrutiny. It is a basic tenet of our justice system that everyone be equal before the law.

Again, I agree.

The Press focuses on rampaging crime:

New Zealanders will be disturbed that crime is continuing to grow at an alarming rate. They have become used to statistics that show increases, but not to the sort of large jump recorded in Wednesday’s figures.

That surprise will be the greater because of the tougher measures implemented by John Key’s Government and touted as a means of reducing wrongdoing.

The Government’s defence – that its measures have not been in effect long enough to impact on crime – is reasonable to a degree. But the trumpeting of its tough measures must have sunk into the awareness of most citizens, criminal and law-abiding, and should already be showing a beneficial result if it is the right approach.

The problem for the Government is that it will be able to use the excuse – that its measures need to be given time to work – only once. If the crime statistics continue to grow in the next 12 months, the Government will have to find a more convincing reason to account for the apparent failure of its policies.

Another increase of this magnitude for violent crime would be a problem.

The ODT discusses the case of the Norweians who hunted protected Kereu:

Most New Zealanders would have been horrified to learn of the incident involving Norwegian tourists who posted on the internet images of shooting at a fully protected native wood pigeon (kereru), the bird falling from a tree, and film of one of the tourists holding two dead birds.

Though heavily dependent on tourism, the country does not need or want visitors such as these, but there appears to be no existing mechanism within the prosecution regime whereby they can be banned from returning.

Yet if the perpetrators were to be charged and convicted under Norwegian law, the punishment would be far more in keeping with the crime – up to six years’ jail for having wilfully or through gross negligence reduced a natural population of protected wildlife in Norway or overseas.

It is ironic that they face greater punishment in Norway for what they did in NZ, than what they could face if they were still here.

Fisking Trevor

Trevor at Red Alert says:

The case in point, if the facts as alleged by Norman are accurate, is a pretty clear cut one. David Carter as a farmer in Canterbury has a case currently before Ecan to increase his water rights and therefore the value of his land. He takes part in the Cabinet debate and decision to scrap Ecan and short circuit the system for the decision relating to his farm. About as obvious a conflict as one could get and certainly well over the perceived conflict test.

Now I know Trevor doesn’t let the facts get in his way, but this one is particularly untrue. The facts:

  1. David Carter has no case or application before ECAN to increase his water rights and indeed never has. Total fiction. This is a matter of public record.
  2. The consent to take water from the Hurunui River for his Cat Hill farm is an existing historical one that was transferred into Carter’s name when he bought the property 4 years ago. It has not changed since then.
  3. The Cat Hill property will not be affected either negatively or positively if the Hurunui Water Project proceeds as the farm due to its topography and the fact that it is outside of the catchment zone cannot and would not be irrigated further.
  4. Trevor’s claim that there is a conflict of interest that needed to be declared is utter bullshit. He knows this himself as he has said “If the facts are accurate” which are weasel words for when you know they are not.

A moving poem

The Dom Post reports:

The Chilean Government has apologised to the family of a young woman killed in a head-on crash caused by a diplomat in Wellington 25 years ago.

Luis Felipe Lopez, who was drinking before the crash, claimed diplomatic immunity and was whisked out of New Zealand within days – leaving the family of Sacha Macfarlane struggling to cope with the 20-year-old’s death.

The apology was sparked by a poem spelling out the family’s anguish and an aborted attempt by her father, Kester Macfarlane, to meet Mr Lopez in Santiago last year.

The poem was sent to Chile’s Foreign Affairs Ministry and to its embassy in Wellington, which responded by offering to hold a memorial service. The apology will be officially conveyed at that service today at Old St Paul’s.

Mr Macfarlane, 67, said yesterday that the apology meant a lot to him and his surviving daughter, Nina, who witnessed the crash from a car behind her sister.

“The circumstances and the ensuing publicity surrounding her death caused us unbearable and unnecessary grief,” he said.

“The letter of apology is beautiful. It is a genuine apology, which lays the whole thing to rest as far as I am concerned. It was a little thing I needed to happen after all these years.”

Nice to see the Chilean Government help bring this sad saga to an end.

I’m republishing the poem below, as it really shows how awful the death of a loved one can be:

I was in Santiago the other day,
Mr Lopez, first time in my life,
and I was intending to look you up.
I’m not sure what I would have said
if I’d knocked on your door and found
you home. If a woman, your wife or
even a daughter, had called over
the balcony or the intercom ¿hola?
You see, Mr Lopez, I’m not sure
what I want from you any more.
The phone directory has many Lopez
as you of course would know –
they’re rare where I come from – but just three listed as Luis Felipe.
Perhaps you’re all related: elderly father,
your eldest son and you, Mr Lopez,
the diplomat. Are you still an embassy
man or did you switch your line
of work after the immunity wore off?
I’d been rehearsing our meeting
all these years but, somehow I got
to Chile and my heart wasn’t in it.
What was I going to say to you:
Hi, Mr Lopez, I’d like a word
about my daughter?
Would it hurt if I told you she was
twenty, tall and beautiful, unsure
as some striking people are,
and gifted, an artist with a promising
future. Paintings are all I have.
Hi, Mr Lopez, I could have said,
I’m the father of the girl you killed
when you drove dead-drunk
in a new car in a new country
on the wrong side of a road.
Would it hurt if I told you, last time
I saw her, I promised her oil paints
for Christmas and watched her small plane
until it was just a speck in a summer sky.
You! You crossed the centre line
a third time, saw the headlights and
swerved – not to the left, your side
of the road, which might have
saved her – but to the right,
Luis Felipe Lopez, to the right.
Hi, Mr Lopez, I could have said
in Santiago, please step outside,
I’m going to kill you.
They missed you at the inquest.
The coroner’s man couldn’t get
Sacha’s name right – he called her
‘Sacka’, as if she were a sack of nothing –
but he had yours down pat.
I have one daughter left alive.
On birthdays and death days
and in the early mornings, you are
not far from our thoughts, Luis –
can I call you that? I wonder if
the ‘car accident’, fool phrase,
wrecked your life as it did ours.
What price did you have to pay,
loyal servant of General Pinochet,
for slaughter in a foreign city?
When you hug your own daughter,
do you sometimes think of Sacha.
I sat on the bed in my hotel room
in your city ringed with mountains,
three likely numbers in my hand, and
I knew it was over. To tamp down
my bitterness, concentrate my sadness,
I tried to put myself in your shoes,
to imagine what it must be like
to be a killer. I tried but I cannot.
No, Luis Felipe Lopez,
I do not want to see your face.

Do the Greens want 60 Maori seats?

On Facebook there is a group called Maori 60. It’s description is:

Maori should be equal partners with settlers in the NZ government. There are now 120 MPs. Maori should control 60 seats.

The most prominent member of Maori 60 is Green co-leader Metiria Turei.

That is some heavweight support, to have a party leader join your group.

I wonder how many Green Party voters know that their co-leader does not support a democracy where all votes are roughly equal, but where 15% of the population should have 50% of the seats, and the other 85% have the other 50%. That make a vote from someone with Maori ancestry six times more powerful than a vote from someone who does not have the right relatives.

Gerry on mining

Gerry Brownlee has an op ed in the Herald on mining. Good to see the Government front footing this to put thiings in context:

Try going a day without any goods or services that don’t require or depend on a product that has been mined.

From your inner-spring mattress to your car (or even your bike), computer, cellphone and medical equipment; the activities that make up our day and enhance our lives are in most cases only possible because someone, somewhere, has mined something.

A good point.

Many New Zealanders will not know that mining already makes a sizeable contribution to our economy. Mining in 2008 was a $2 billion industry and contributed $1.1 billion to exports.

Including oil and gas, the mining industry employs around 6000 people – and those jobs are highly productive and highly paid, relative to other sectors of the economy.

Mining is an important part of regional economies such as the West Coast and the Coromandel.

The Government is currently borrowing around $240 million a week and we have more than 100,000 people unemployed. The tradables sector of the economy has been in recession for the past five years.

That is unsustainable and the Government accepts the challenge of improving our economy and living standards.

Labour have already pledged to lower our living standards by cancelling any mining permits on reclassified land if they get elected.

We are therefore proposing to open up to possible mining just 7058ha of land that is currently protected in Schedule Four of the Crown Minerals Act.

That is only 0.2 per cent of all the land that is protected in Schedule Four, and it is a tiny amount compared with our total land area.

If prospecting that land showed potential for mining, it’s likely no more than 500ha of the 7058ha would actually be mined. That’s less than the size of the average sheep or beef farm in New Zealand.

But the economic return on that land is many times greater than any sheep, beef or dairy farm.

What I would like to see is an economic analysis for each site proposed in the consultation. I don’t think one can generalise over all sites.

Some people argue that New Zealand would not see any benefit from increased mining and that all the profits go overseas.

Yet the largest mining company in the country, Solid Energy, is 100 per cent state-owned. All its profits go straight towards spending on government services. There are also many New Zealand-owned mining companies active on New Zealand land.

The average ownership structure of resources companies listed on the NZX is 57 per cent New Zealand and 43 per cent overseas ownership. Others that are fully overseas-owned pay both company tax and royalties in New Zealand.

Some argue that the royalties from mineral mining are small, meaning it’s not worth it for New Zealand. But royalties are just an added bonus from mining.

The real benefits from mining are the jobs created and economic activity generated inside the country. That activity generates company tax revenue for the Government as well as economic growth.

This is the data I want to see though, to make a sensible decision. Not just an estimate of mineral wealth, but a range of projections for what mining in a specific area will do for job creation, royalty revenue, tax revenue, increased local consumption, and impacts on the trade deficit, the current account deficit and the level of crown debt.

Now of course it will be ballpark figures as such an early stage, but even that would be good.

Many New Zealanders are rightly concerned about protecting our natural environment and some say mining is inconsistent with that goal. The Government shares this concern and we will make sure any mining on conservation land in New Zealand is done responsibly and carefully.

Mines in New Zealand are subject to strict environmental tests. The higher the conservation value of the land concerned, the stricter the test. That fact will rule out open-cast mines on Schedule Four land.

Modern mining is totally different from its image in the past. Companies are required to rehabilitate the land after they leave and mitigate the effects of their activities as much as possible.

It is worth stressing that point – removing Schedule 4 protection is not an automatic licence to mine. It merely allows an application to be made that goes through the normal RMA process.

The Government believes a small increase in responsible mining could contribute to our goal of improving the economy’s performance and providing high-value jobs.

We want to hear what Kiwis are thinking. I encourage people to have their say by making submissions on the discussion document that you can find at www.med.govt.nz/schedule4.

Don’t complain about a decision, if you don’t take advantage of the opportunity to have your say. If you support greater mining – say so. If you are opposed to any change to Schedule 4, also say so. If you are in favour for some areas, but not others again have your say.

Headline vs Reality

The NZ Herald has a story with this headline and opening paragraph:

Lack of Govt cash kills family-health

One of the groups planning an overhaul of primary healthcare services has given up on creating “integrated family heath centres” because the Government is offering no money to help set them up.

So both the headline and the opening paragraph entirely blame the lack of money from the Government.

But for those who actually wade through the story, you find this nugget:

This bid, by the Greater Auckland Integrated Health Network, initially proposed creating up to 12 integrated family health centres. But in its formal business case to the ministry, the network has now quit that concept in favour of a simpler structure involving three “community health hubs”, after GPs rejected the earlier model.

So it was GPs who rejected the earlier model. Are they blaming it on Government cash:

The network’s spokeswoman, Professor Cindy Farquhar, said, when asked if GPs were concerned by the absence of Government funding for integrated family health centres, “Yes, that was a bit of a challenge. In this proposal there is no new money.”

So the media actually put forward the proposition that it is all about lack of money, and the GP spokesperson merely said “Yes, that was a bit of a challenge”.

General practices are mainly private businesses and the Government has no power to force them to create new types of clinics. It has put up $6 million this financial year, but only to manage the change, not to finance new or altered facilities.

So there is funding for transition costs.

Professor Farquhar said the Auckland network rejected integrated family health centres because they would duplicate existing services.

And finally we get the real reason they GPs voted to go with a modified approach.

Now I am not saying that money is not a factor at all, but the headline and opening paragraph (which is all many people read) give a quite false impression of what led to the decision.

Here comes The Wanderer

DPF has been kind enough to offer me fifteen minutes of fame and is allowing me the opportunity to broadcast some of my ramblings on his blog.

By way of background, I’m a lawyer living in the Middle East, who’s hooked on travelling, books and politics.  I suspect I’ll probably do a bit of posting about life in general, and my travels, in this part of the world- Afghanistan, Qatar and Iran were my three most recent trips and I’ve got to say, I recommend them all. Most of the expats here try to get out of town on at least a monthly basis.

Just so you know, I’m a National party supporter and have been since university when two fellas I met took me under their right wing wings, but to be fair, I’m open to anything sensible.  I’m an independent sort who doesn’t much like being told what to do, I miss my dog, and one of my favourite things about living where I do has been filling my wardrobe with gorgeous dresses.  I mean, no chance I could have afforded a Gucci ball gown back home.  In fact, I’m not even sure if there is a Gucci shop in NZ- perhaps in Auckland. 

I’ve embraced driving like a local (and am consequently concerned about driving outside of the Middle East ever again), like Cactus Kate, I’m a fan of my Fillipina maid, I’ve picked up the habit of going to the Thai salon round the corner at least once a week, and to my surprise, I was disconcerted by the length of the skirts (more like belts) on expats when I was last in Dubai – I guess this place is starting to seep into me. 

I’m also amazed that in my time here so far, I’ve had more visitors from home than I ever got when I lived in a provincial New Zealand city for a few years.  You move a few hours drive away, they forget you.  You move to a tiny country half way round the world and everyone wants to come visit.  Who knew?

Enough of me, next post will be travels, politics or home.