Obama in Afghanistan

The Herald reports:

President Barack Obama has told American forces during his surprise visit to Afghanistan that US lives would be at risk if the Taleban retake control of the country.

Not just US lives.

Karzai promised that his country “would move forward into the future” to eventually take over its own security, and he thanked Obama for the American intervention in his country.

He told Obama he has begun to establish more credible national institutions on corruption and made clear he intends to make ministerial appointments more representative of the multiple ethnic and geographic regions of the country, according to a US account of the meeting.

Obama’s trip was intended to emphasise US demands that Karzai deal with corruption and cut the flow of money from poppy production and drug trafficking that is sustaining the insurgency. The US also wants Karzai to create an effective, credible judicial system and to halt cronyism and rewards for warlords in government hiring.

I think Iraq is on track to be a relatively successful country by 2020. Afghanistan, I am not so sure about – but I agree with Obama this is no time to quit.

The urinating Mayor walked past a public toilet

This little screenshot has the red line showing the path you would take to go from GPK to the Council offices, as Mayor Williams did on Thursday. It is not a long distance – around 500 metres.

Now we already know that the Mayor could have used the toilets at GPK. We also know he could have accessed the Council building, and used their toilets, rather than urinate outside.

But what many may not know, is that he would have actually walked past a set of public toilets – where the thick green arrow is. According to locals, there is a tourist i-site at this location, with a public toilet.

So just 200 metres after passing perfectly good public toilets, the Mayor decides he needs to urinate outside his own Council building. This just makes it worse.

I note with amusement that the North Shore City Council website has a front page poll on whether there are enough liquor bans in public areas. Maybe they need a liquor ban within 500 metres of the Council offices!

Free Trade vs Free Aid

Amelia MacDonald of Takapuna Grammar has been selected as Phil Twyford’s Youth MP for this year’s Youth Parliament. Each of the 11 contenders had to do a short video on “what they thought NZ should do to make the world a safer, fairer and more sustainable place”, according to Phil at Red Alert.

Amelia’s video is above. I want to argue an alternative point of view to what Amelia advocated. Now if people comment, I don’t want any negative comments on Amelia – just a discussion of the topic. Personally I’m a huge fan of young people taking an interest in politics, and think the Youth Parliament is an excellent way to foster this. Anyone who gets to be selected as a Youth MP, has my respect – even if I disagree with their views.

Incidentally I thought her video was very quirky and well done. But turning to the substance:

I actually agreed with her on the need for armed intervention in Sudan. But sadly China blocks UN action there – one of the problems of needing a UN mandate.

Amelia calls for fair trade, but says this should happen through education, not through cutting off ties with China. Now while I think fair trade is more a slogan than anything else, I am pleased to see realism that cutting trade links is not the way to go.

At 3:50 Amelia says we need to stop importing so much un-necessary stuff, and asks why on earth is it necessary to be importing oranges from California when Kerikeri can do it perfectly well.

This is where I seriously disagree with the notion that importing is bad. But before we talk importing generally, let me address the specific – one reason we import Oranges from California is because they are seasonal, and that is the only way to get them 12 months a year.

More generally one country’s imports is another export’s. If we take a position that one should discourage imports, then we are asking for our dairy, lamb and wool exports to be blocked by other countries.

But more importantly it is about comparative advantage. Let’s use an example of apples and oranges for the US and California. If NZ produce apples for $1/kg and the US produces apples for $2/kg, while NZ produces oranges for $3/kg and the US does oranges for $2/kg also.

The best use of resources is for NZ to produce apples and the US to produce oranges.

Amelia says “less importing means more money for our economy to be spent elsewhere”. This is not always the case. Often NZ will be better off importing something, and exporting something else.

Amelia goes on to say that the money saved from importing can be used to increase aid for developing countries.

My view is that free trade would do far more for developing countries that free aid. The EU and US have massive protectionism in place against imports from developing countries, and that the best thing they could do for Africa, would be allow them to sell their goods in Europe – even if it undercuts local suppliers.

Why have China and India reduced massively the number of citizens they have in absolute poverty, compared to Africa? Because they have freed up their economic, and embraced trade.

This is why even left wing parties like Labour, sign free trade deals with China. Because trade benefits people in both countries.

While well intentioned, I don’t think the solution for poverty in Africa is to trade less, and give more aid. I think it is to trade more, and allow countries to become sustainable without aid. Singapore used to receive aid, as did Taiwan, Hong Kong and South Korea. Aid is necessary for many countries, but it is not a long-term solution. The long-term solution is good governance, property rights (to attract investment) and trade.

Could be an interesting court case

The HoS reports:

The prostitute given $2.4 million by fraudulent banker Stephen Versalko is far from the high end of the escort business.

Instead, she is a mother of one who worked at an Auckland brothel, the Pelican Club, and is closer in age to Versalko’s 49-year-old wife Megan than the many of the other prostitutes that she used to work with.

The prostitute’s daughter, like Versalko’s only girl, is a teenager.

While the Pelican Club charges its staff out at $210 an hour – although clients can pay up to $1500 a night – the women earn considerably less. By comparison, celebrity stripper and escort Lisa Lewis once advertised her services at $7000 a night.

The ASB Bank is now suing the prostitute for the $2.4m Versalko paid her.

Now this could be a very interesting court case.

Presumably any money paid to the escort, for actual services, she should be able to keep. Just the same as any money he paid to a doctor, or if he had gambled it at Sky City.

But it seems apparent that Versalko paid the escort a lot more than he had to commercially – ie he gifted money to her – possibly through coercion.

So if it goes to court, the court may have to decide what is the appropriate rate of return for prostitution, so it can work out how much on top of that was a gift.

I predict a well attended court for a commercial case!

The urinating drink driving Mayor

Whale Oil has long suggested (OK, this is Whale – he stated) that some of the more bizarre texts and e-mails from North Shore Mayor Andrew Williams occur while he is under the influence. This has always been denied. Today’s story in the SST by Jonathan Marshall, kills the credibility of those denials:

By chance, the Star-Times observed Williams drinking barside at Takapuna’s GPK bar and restaurant around 10pm on Thursday. He talked to a couple at the popular eatery and could be heard referring to himself in the third person. He said he was North Shore’s mayor and enjoyed his role.

And has been having an extended sulk that mean old Rodney and the Government have taken his job away.

Inquiries with two bar staff revealed Williams had been drinking red wine at the establishment since 4pm. Six hours later Williams left GPK alone and headed down Hurstmere Rd towards the offices of the North Shore City Council, where he has been mayor since 2007.

On his way he stopped, pulled down his trousers and urinated on a tree outside the council offices.

Having the Mayor down trou and take a piss outside the Council offices just makes your city a laughing stock.

And you have to wonder how pissed one has to be to do such a thing, considering he could have gone inside to use their toilets.

Williams then headed for the council underground carpark, collected his mayoral vehicle and drove home to Campbells Bay, a 6km trip.

Williams appears to have got home without incident.

This is potentially the most serious aspect. Now it is possible to drink for six hours and be under the legal limit. However the urinating outside the Council offices strongly suggests a considerable degree of drunkenness.

Shortly after Williams arrived home he sent an email to members of his council’s executive team in which he commented on a scheduled visit the following day by Hide and acting Housing Minister Maurice Williamson.

“These two individuals deserve any and all appropriate comments in relation to the rape and pillage of the North Shore by this Auckland takeover. I have only utter contempt for both of them,” Williams’ email, sent at 11.38pm, says.

I understand the North Shore Council staff were in fact totally professional, and very embarrased by the e-mail their drunken Mayor had sent out to them all.

But eight hours later, when Williams appeared on TV1’s Breakfast, co-host Paul Henry asked the mayor if he respected Williamson.

“Maurice is a good guy, I like Maurice,” Williams replied.

So either he is lying, or he was so drunk when he wrote the e-mail, he does not remember it. Unless he often says “I have only utter contempt” about people he says he likes and is a good guy.

Yesterday, outside his home, Williams told the Star-Times he had not been drinking on Thursday night but a few minutes later said he might have been, he just couldn’t “recall”.

He said he didn’t know if he had been drinking at GPK, and when challenged he responded: “Oh really? That’s interesting.”

So he denied he had been drinking initially and then said he can’t recall. To be fair to him, it is possible he can’t recall.

Asked if he had been working on Thursday evening, Williams replied: “I can’t recall. I might have been. I go to meetings every day, every night.”

Meetings? Like these:

Further inquiries that evening at GPK revealed the mayor was a “very frequent visitor”, “possibly one of our most regulars”, said one waitress.

That’s a lot of meetings.

Questioned about why he urinated on his way to collect his mayoral vehicle, Williams said: “I’m not going to talk about it.”

Maybe he genuinely can’t remember it also? That happens when you have drunk to excess.

When news broke last year of Williams’ early morning texts to Key – which the country’s leader branded “aggressive” and “obnoxious” – the mayor blamed painkillers.

He denied suggestions the texts were sent because he was drunk, saying he had not been intoxicated since his 21st birthday.

So he decided to take a piss outside the Council offices stone cold sober?

Maybe he was also on painkillers on Thursday!

In August 2008 Williams collapsed at a Devonport Naval Base function and lashed out at attending ambulance officers. He was hospitalised. Williams later insisted he had “no recollection” of it and was just “exhausted” from an overseas trip.

There does seem to be a real pattern here.

The revised Three Strikes Law

The report back from the Select Committee is here. The key principle is still:

  1. 1st serious offence – normal sentence and parole
  2. 2nd serious offence – normal sentence, no parole
  3. 3rd serious offence – maximum sentence, no parole

However there are a few tweaks about offences with life sentences.

If you get a third strike for say rape, then the penalty would be 20 years without parole. A court can decide that would be manifestly unjust, and allow parole – but still the maximum sentence. So they would be eligible for parole in 14 years or so.

If the third offence is manslaughter, which normally has life as a maximum sentence, the requirement is a minimum imprisonment of 20 years, and if that is manifestly unjust, then a minimum imprisonment of 10 years.

If murder is a stage two or three offence, then the sentence will be life without parole. If this would be manifestly unjust, then the minimum period of imprisonment is at least 20 years.

Also they clarify that at a third strike the court can sentence an offender to preventative detention, with a minimum no release period of at least what their third strike would have been (unless manifestly unjust). This means a serial sex offender for example can be given preventative detention, rather than a finite term.

So what does this mean for a number of offences. Graeme E will correct me I am sure, where needed, but at a glance a likely scenario is:

Indecent Assault

  1. 1st strike – three years (court of appeal starting point), with parole at two years
  2. 2nd strike three years, no parole
  3. 3rd strike seven years, no parole. If manifestly unjust parole eligibility at 4 years eight months

Aggravated Robbery or Wounding with intent to do GBH

  1. 1st strike – four years, parole in two years eight months
  2. 2nd strike – four years, no parole
  3. 3rd strike – 14 years, no parole. If manifestly unjust parole eligibility at 10 years four months

Rape

  1. 1st strike – eight years, parole in five years four months
  2. 2nd strike – eight years, no parole
  3. 3rd strike – 20 years, no parole. If manifestly unjust parole eligibility at 13 years four months

Manslaughter

  1. 1st strike – not sure if there is a sentencing guideline, so say 15 years, parole in 10 years
  2. 2nd strike – 15 years, no parole
  3. 3rd strike – life, with parole eligibility in 20 years. If manifestly unjust parole eligibility after ten years

Murder

  1. 1st strike – life, parole eligibility after ten years
  2. 2nd strike – life, no parole. If manifestly unjust parole eligibility after 20 years
  3. 3rd strike – life, no parole. If manifestly unjust parole eligibility after 20 years

Now it seems there may be some way that if even 20 years non parole is also manifestly unjust, it then falls back to normal sentencing for murder.

The threshold of manifestly unjust is historically quite high. For example, a Judge can use it at the moment to not issue a life sentence for murder, and I can’t recall the last time that occured.

Also worth stressing is that the strikes happen regardless of what were the other strikes. So they do not have to be strikes of the same offence. The 1st strike might be indecent assault, the second strike rape and the third strike manslaughter.

Also the first strikes may not even result in a custodial sentence. The figures above are starting points for those offences. It may be a 1st strike avoids jail – but they will still get told the consequences of further strikes.

Wintringham also at fault

The Dom Post reports:

A woman who blew the whistle on Mary Anne Thompson’s doctored CV six years ago was hushed up by the country’s top civil servant and told to stop digging further.

Thompson was ordered to pay a $10,000 fine and do 100 hours’ community service after pleading guilty yesterday to one charge of using a document with intent to defraud.

An appropriate penalty.

In an exclusive interview with The Dominion Post, Thompson says she is hoping for a second chance and would desperately love to return to the civil service, where she carved out a reputation as one of its brightest stars.

What may weigh against this is not so much the fake CV, but the issues around the immigration Service, while managed by Thompson.

Executive recruiter Lilias Bell was the first to stumble on Thompson’s secret, after a tipoff caused her to question Thompson’s claim to a doctorate from the prestigious London School of Economics.

Mrs Bell had been hired by the State Services Commission to recruit a new chief executive for the Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet – one of the most prestigious and sensitive jobs in the civil service. Despite Thompson having clearances from the Security Intelligence Service, digging by Mrs Bell revealed that there was no record of her ever receiving her doctorate.

But after Mrs Bell flagged the issue with then state services commissioner Michael Wintringham, Thompson withdrew her application and Ms Bell was told to cease her investigation. In court documents, Mr Wintringham revealed that he was worried about the damage that news of the inquiries would do to the reputations of both Thompson and the State Services Commission.

So he hushed it up, and in the end did far far more damage by doing so. If Wintringham has done his job, this may have been all avoided.

He left the commission shortly after, passing on Mrs Bell’s inquiries to his successor, Mark Prebble, only when Thompson landed in strife at the immigration service.

Prime Minister John Key said he was “extremely surprised” that Mr Wintringham did not pass on the information earlier, “and a little disappointed”.

That is putting it mildly. Wintringham was the head of the civil service, responsible for all senior appointments and he failed HR 101 – file notes. Even the most junior HR person knows you do file notes on anything like this. He effectively hid information from his successor, through his failure to do a file note about the doctorate.

Mr Wintringham said yesterday that he had questioned Thompson about her doctorate and she was adamant it was legitimate. After that, there had been no reason to pursue the matter.

I’m sorry – but how can one conclude this. If someone is adamant it is legitimate, then the obvious response is to ask them to prove it, and ask for a copy of their degree.

Thompson is at fault for claiming she had a degree she did not have, but Wintringham shares some blame for knowing the truth, and covering it up.

Opps

The Herald’s Diary reports:

Oops. Phil Goff issues a statement claiming “the usually media-friendly” Prime Minister seems to have disappeared off the political radar in the past few days. “What could possibly be the reason behind this strange disappearance?” the Labour leader asks with a measure of sarcasm. Well, one reason was John Key paying his respects to the late mother of one of Goff’s MPs. Key held formal press conferences on Monday and Tuesday, plus the usual pre-caucus meeting media scrum on Tuesday morning. On Wednesday – a day he usually spends in Wellington when Parliament is sitting – he flew to Hamilton for the tangi of Lady Raiha Mahuta, widow of one-time Tainui leader Sir Robert Mahuta and mother of Labour’s Nanaia Mahuta.

I’m amazed Goff did not know this.

Bailey’s Mother

NZPA report:

Kurariki’s mother says arrest “might be the best thing” for her son after he failed to appear in court.

TV3s’ Campbell Live presenter John Campbell visited Kurariki’s home yesterday, where he spoke to his mother, Lorraine West.

Kurariki had got “all dressed up” for court yesterday morning, Ms West said. When she was told her son may be arrested, she said it “may be the best thing” and that he had been “getting on my nerves”.

When she told her son to behave he would say he was nearly 21 and to stop nagging, she said.

“I’m always on at my friends, ‘Who’s got a gun with one bullet?’ That’s all I’d need, I’d shoot him. I brought him into this world and I’d shoot him.”

I know Bailey has done some awful things, and is probably heading towards a life of crime. But I still think it is shocking his mother would talk about him like that to the media. And saying you hope he is sent to jail as he has been “getting on your nerves”.

Welcome back Greer

Pleased to see Fairfaxer Greer McDonald return to the blogosphere with her new “lady in the red” blog.

I am amused that Greer has gone from having one blog (one being single) which was effectively about her lack of sex, to another about which is effectively about her lack of money 🙂

David Bain compensation

Personally I can’t wait for a QC to be appointed to investigate the case, and declare, on the balance of probabilities, whether it was Robin or David who killed the Bain Family.

If a senior QC really finds that on balance of probabilities it was not David, then he deserves compensation.

And if the QC does not make that finding, then it may effectively clear Robin’s name, and David will become our own OJ Simpson – legally acquitted by found on the balance of probabilities to have been liable.

A suggestion for Kevin

I blogged previously on former ACT member Kevin Campbell, who resigned after his comments referring to the PM as “John the Jew” were highlighted by me.

I thought that was the end of the saga, but he has sent an open letter to Rodney Hide and a large number of ACT members complaining about well basically everything, which includes this paragraph:

“I referred to the prime minister in a blog as John the Jew. I admit it wasn’t a smart comment and it could be viewed negatively by some, but it was off-the-cuff and not intended to be racially offensive in any way. Even so I offered John Key my genuine apology which he accepted with thanks. The matter should have ended there but I underestimated my opponents to the board, which included you and the party president, you chose to escalate the issue into something unsavory to discredit me and damage my election chances.”

This generated a response from one ACT member, which is just too wonderful to keep hidden:

It’s pleasing to see that you realise it wasn’t a smart comment, and even more pleasing to see that ACT chose to escalate the issue to the point that you resigned. Its also a relief to read that the comment was off-the-cuff; had it been the result of careful consideration, ACT would have had to consider even more drastic measures.

Given your obvious continuing interest in politics, and a clear talent for self-exculpation, I’m trying to think of how you could resuscitate your political career. Iran seems the obvious place. Even then, you would have to be careful to ensure that you limited your “off-the-cuff” religious slurs to foreign politicians in a fairly limited set of countries. Check with the President there (Ahmadinejad) before you repeat this sort of performance. He’s not a model of diplomacy but he hasn’t yet made an apparently sneering comment about the religion of anyone above him in the pecking order. Good luck.

xxxxxx xxxxx

PS: Have a look at your genealogy. If you go back far enough, you may find a Jewish ancestor.

I’ve yet to be informed if this helpful suggestion will be acted upon.

Mining under Labour

Quoting a release from Gerry Brownlee:

Labour’s hypocrisy over mining has been laid bare, says Energy and Resources Minister Gerry Brownlee, after new figures released by Crown Minerals today showed Labour approved more than 200 permits for mining on the Conservation Estate.

“This from the party that launched a campaign yesterday saying it was explicitly opposed to mining conservation areas – not just Schedule Four land, but conservation land full stop,” Mr Brownlee said.

Labour’s pledge of opposition to mining on conservation land is similar to their ax the tax campaign.

200 permits in just nine years!

“But if that wasn’t enough, we also have the release today of information that Labour approved a mining consent on land considered special enough to warrant Schedule Four status, the very behaviour Phil Goff has been decrying as unthinkable.

“It turns out Labour approved a permit in 2006 for mining gold, garnets and other gemstones on 168.5 hectares of land at Hart Creek, inside Paparoa National Park.

And they mined national parks.

“The information shows Labour were happy for mining to take place on 21,961 hectares of land, meanwhile the government is seeking approval to release a mere 7,058 hectares of Schedule Four land, of which as little as 500 hectares might be mined,” Mr Brownlee said.

My view is that mining applications should be decided on a case by case basis – as both Labour and National have done in the past. Economic benefits need to be weighed up against conservation value for each site.

Figures released by Crown Minerals [attached] show 218 permits were approved under a Labour government for mining inside Department of Conservation land between December 1999 and October 2008.

That is an average of one permit every fortnight was issued under Labour for mining on conservation land. I repeat one permit every fortnight.

The light at the end of the tunnel is not a train

The Herald reports:

New Zealand’s economy accelerated in the fourth quarter, growing at the fastest clip in two years as manufacturing revived and companies built up inventories that had run down through the recession.

Gross domestic product expanded 0.8 per cent in the final three months of 2009, according to Statistics New Zealand, matching the median in a Reuters survey. Growth in the third quarter was revised up to 0.3 per cent from 0.2 per cent.

Well heading in the right direction but a fair way to go.

General Debate 25 March 2010

Blog Bits

  1. John Ansell highlights unfortunate words from Tiger Woods who announced that after extensive treatment he is “getting back to my old roots” 🙂
  2. No Right Turn exposes Greenpeace fundraising tactics where they write to you, and if you do not respond, they take that as permission to increase your monthly donation. Moral is use automatic payment not direct debits
  3. Not PC has quotes from the late night comics in the US
  4. Whale Oil claims Ewen Gilmour will stand for Auckland Mayor.

Compulsory Medical Insurance

One of the things that many may not realise around Obama’s Healthcare Reform, is that it does not in fact create a public health system. To increase health insurance coverage, it has made it illegal not to have health insurance, with limited exceptions such as hardship or religious belief.

If a Republican President had tried to make private health insurance compulsory, I suspect the left would have decried the reform, instead of supported it. And i guess the right would have supported it, instead of opposed it.

13 states have filed lawsuits claiming it is unconstitutional to force people to take our private health insurance. I suspect this issue will get to the Supreme Court, and you do have to think there is a reasonable chance that may breach the Bill of Rights.

What I find ironic, is that Obama’s reforms have now made the US system almost the polar opposite of the Canadian system.

You see in Canada, it is illegal in some provinces to even have private health insurance. And federally there are laws that forbid hospitals from charging private rates (even if a private clinic).

So effectively in Canada it is illegal to have private health insurance, and now in the US it will effectively be illegal NOT to have private health insurance.

Doubled Up

Around six months ago I purchased the book, The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo.

It then disappeared. I didn’t read it immediately as I had some others to get through, and despite extensive searches and excavations it could not be found. Maybe I lent it to someone I concluded, as I often have people grab books off me.

Anyway on Thursday at Auckland Airport, I walked past a bookshop in the terminal on the way to the plane and saw it on sale. I decided to buy it on the spot so I would have an extra book for the trip, but also so I can see what the hype is about, and decide whether to get the sequels.

So read the book the plane, and it was indeed a good read, so the sequels are on my to buy list. I like how the author only very slowly brought together the two main characters, and the multiple plot threads that linked together. I did guess who killed the niece, and also what had happened to her. I also enjoyed the ending with the bank accounts.

Anyway on Monday I was packing my suitcase on Bintan Island and as I was about to leave realised I had not packed the Dragon Tattoo book. rather than open up the suitcase again, I went to do my normal trick with stuff I have almost left behind, and zipped open the external side pocket to place the book there.

Upon opening the side pocket, I discovered my original purchase of the Dragon Tattoo book!!

I really should remember to check the side pockets when I unpack!

It will be interesting if Customs search my luggage as they will be potentially suspicious of why I am travelling with two identical copies of the same book!

Incidentially if anyone wants a free copy of the book, and can arrange pick up, just e-mail me.

Editorials 24 March 2010

All four editorials are on the same issue today – mining.

The Herald says:

Energy Minister Gerry Brownlee says these locations represent the relative size of a post card placed on the turf of Eden Park’s main field. Conservationists are alarmed, one noting that news of these recommendations was as if the country had been asleep and had awoken again in the dark, mining days of the 1980s.

Both views are overstated.

Mr Brownlee’s because it is not the size but the impact on value and utility of the land that matters. The anti-mining lobby ignores the fact that substantial advances in conservation of the past two decades are largely retained. The country’s habitats will remain better off than before. …

Yet there is nothing in the stocktake about the possible economic upside, either in jobs or general benefits to GDP or direct financial gains for the Crown.

The amounts the Government might expect as royalties from private companies exploiting non hydrocarbon deposits are likely to be small. The absence of an economic case, even theoretical, is an important omission.

National is trying to make its case for elevating real economic advantages of mining over the intangible values of preserving flora and fauna, but it does not do so. …

So far, all we know is the potential downside, a reduction in the area of land given high protection. Without the economic benefits, that grand $194 billion figure is meaningless.

I think this is a very fair point. It would be good to see some figures along the lines of if say $20 billion of minerals was mined, what would be the likely impact on GDP, on the current account deficit, the balance of trade, on jobs, on Crown revenue etc etc, and over what time period.

The Press says:

It is true that there are currently 82 concessions for mineral extraction in the total conservation estate, but there are only two mines on schedule 4 land. Ultimately, whether the proposals proceed could depend on the response of the mining industry. Some companies might be deterred by the small amount of land which would initially be opened up for mining, or by the costs of underground mining and other environmental protections.

Faced with a tepid industry response and a political backlash, the Government would have to conclude that discretion is the better part of valour.

It would be interesting to hear from mining companies, which areas they are most likely to want to mine at – ie where they think there is enough minerals to make an economic return on investment. If, for example, no company thinks mining in a particular site is feasible, then why remove from Section 4?

And the Dominion Post:

Ideally, the Government would have been able to test public opinion in lower-value conservation areas, but that does not appear to have been an option. If the Government had excluded from the exercise all the areas to which New Zealanders are emotionally attached, there would have been little left to mine. Mr Brownlee has a public relations fight on his hands.

New Zealanders want to close the economic gap with Australia, but they also like the country, or more particularly the countryside, the way it is.

The challenge facing the Government, and the mining industry, is to convince the public that the industry can now do what it says it can do, rather than what it has historically done. That is, surgically extract mineral resources from sensitive land without laying waste to the landscape, and poisoning rivers and streams. If it can, many of those now burrowing in clothes drawers for old “No Mining” T-shirts will give up the hunt. If it cannot, the Government is doing what it has studiously avoided doing until now – putting itself on the wrong side of an issue with the potential to politicise entire communities.

And finally the ODT:

Mr Brownlee wants a “rational conversation” and argues that the amount of land involved is very small and should be viewed in its proper context.

That is fair comment, but the “conversation” ought not be limited to rhetoric but include a thorough cost-benefit analysis, site by site, and, in broader terms, the potential of mineral exploitation to have a deleterious impact on our other established industries, including tourism, and particularly on the value of the New Zealand dollar and the likely effect on exporters.

It should also include details of proposed royalties and tax arrangements – and the level of present interest by mining companies in the sites.

I find it interesting that to some degree all four editorials are saying much the same thing. None of them have endorsed the proposed changes to Section 4, but none of them have said they should not happen either.

The common theme is more information is needed and the Government needs to make a more convincing case than merely relying on an estimate of potential mineral wealth in each area.

9/10 in 30 seconds

Upton on Environment

Simon Upton writes:

I am shortly to take up a position at the OECD leading its Environment Directorate. …

The OECD was established to help governments with their thinking. While its origins may have been in the reconstruction of Europe after 1945, it has become a genuinely global policy resource with new members (such as Chile) joining as rising living standards dissolve the boundaries of the old “developed” world.

The OECD is one of the more useful global bodies.

As an economics-based institution, the OECD is dedicated to using economic analysis to highlight the tradeoffs its members face. It is easily caricatured (like Treasuries) as an organisation that seeks to reduce everything to dollars and cents. Clearly, not everything can be reduced to monetary values. But many things can be, and to the extent that the costs of alternatives can be placed on a common footing, decision-making should be improved.

To provide one very simple example: work at the OECD has shown that the costs of alternative CO2 reduction policies can vary by several orders of magnitude. Subsidies to biofuels can, in some instances, mean spending hundreds or even thousands of dollars for each ton of CO2 avoided – way above the sorts of carbon taxes that have been discussed and discounted.

And biofuel subsidies or quotas have been shown to have devastating effect on food supply, as land is converted.

Countries may be able offer good reasons for such outcomes. But it is harder to do so when the costs of alternatives are made transparent. This may explain one of the conundrums surrounding much environmental policy analysis. Consistently, the advice is to place a price on scarce resources. If they carry a price, they need to be measured; if they’re measured, they get managed. We don’t tend to waste things we have to pay for.

And this is why I do support putting a price on carbon – either through a carbon tax, or an ETS. It’s the same reason I don’t like tertiary courses which are “free” to the user – you get huge wastage, and the moment people do have to pay for something, you do have an incentive not to waste it.

There is dispute over the indirect warming effects of greenhouse gas emissions, but there is basically no dispute over the direct warming effects. Hence for me the debate isn’t over whether one should have a price on carbon, to cover externalities, but what that price should be.