Part Fees

The Herald reports:

The Government has confirmed that accident victims may have to pay the first $50 or $100 of their costs.

The move is under consideration as part of a second round of changes to the accident compensation scheme next year.

Accident Compensation Corporation chairman John Judge says requiring victims to pay an insurance-style “excess” of $50 or $100 for each claim would cut ACC costs by about $1.6 billion over the next 10 years, reducing the need for further levy increases.

ACC Minister Nick Smith said he had been briefed on the proposal, but no decision would be made on it until a wide-ranging “stocktake” of the scheme, led by former Labour Finance Minister David Caygill, was completed next July.

“It’s true that there is a very large transaction cost in ACC, with more than 1 million claims a year,” he said.

“The concept [of a $50 or $100 excess] would need to be carefully balanced with regard to low income earners for whom a $50 or $100 excess might prevent them getting medical attention.”

I understand the cost of processing those minor sub $100 claims is greater than the actual claims themselves, so the problem is quite clear.

However it is worth considering more generally the issue of part fees. As a starting point, I consider almost all Govt funded services should have part fees, as you get distorted decision making in their absence.

The prime example of this is the scam tertiary courses which have diverted so much tertiary funding. When the Govt pays 100% of the course costs, then the institution will simply target signing up as many people as possible, and they will sign up if there is no cost.

Now part fees should not be high enough to discourage people who would genuinely benefit from a Government service, and this is a valid concern.

And there are some situations where there should be no part fees at all. For example kids borrowing books from a library is a classic example.

In related news, 93 year old Sir Owen Woodhouse is reported as being upset with changes:

The father of New Zealand’s accident compensation scheme, Sir Owen Woodhouse, says changes announced last week are “uncaring and predatory”.

Sir Owen, 93, says proposals to double and treble levies on heavy motorbikes and mopeds, and to push accident victims back to work on much lower incomes than they earned before their accidents, breach the principles of the scheme he authored as head of a royal commission in 1967.

I think Sir Owen has just shown us the real problem with ACC. He has spoken out against both the increase in levies and the reduction of benefits. Now you can’t have it both ways. It is quite legitimate to say there should be no reduction in benefits, but then you have to accept that that levies will increase to around $45 a week for an average family. But if you do not reduce benefits, then levies have to increase even further. There is no magic pot of gold to fund the scheme.

Sir Owen’s 1967 report proposed a single flat-rate levy on all employers and another flat rate on motorists, on the basis that everyone benefited from the work of people in risky industries such as aerial topdressing.

Sorry, but wrong an unrealistic view. Firstly industries with higher work accidents should cover those costs, so that the prices of those goods or services reflect that.

I own a polling company. Over the last five years my ACC bill has been a large five figure sum. During that time not a single accident has occurred, or claim filed by a staff member. And Sir Owen is saying we should pay even higher ACC levies to cover not just workplace accidents in other clerical type firms, but workplace accidents in freezing works.

Yesterday he disputed claims by ACC Minister Nick Smith that levies needed to reflect different accident rates in different industries and different kinds of vehicles because that would give employers and motorists more incentive to be safe.

“We are saying people are willing to risk killing themselves for the sake of a few dollars of saved premiums. That’s just ridiculous,” he said.

“I think it’s simply shocking that they are proposing to load people on bicycles and this kind of thing with the extra amounts they are talking about.”

Well if you are saying you want less people killed on the roads, then yes the motorcycle premium makes sense as their injury rate is 16 times that of motorists.

Where I do have some sympathy for motorcyclists is if they own multiple bikes. What might be worthwhile is for the Government to look at a system for all vehicle registrations where the first vehicle per person pays the full license fee, while any subsequent vehicles pay a lower fee.

Gap increases to 33%

Tonight’s TV3 poll has National 33% ahead of Labour. And this poll was taken during one of the messiest periods on record for National. It is consistent with the Roy Morgan poll published earlier this week that has a 29.5% gap.

This is the equal highest in a Tv3 poll, the same as they got in Feb 2009. In Feb 2009 the Government was very much in honeymoon mode. Since then there has been a budget that cancelled tax cuts and super fund contributions, a huge by-election loss, a Ministerial scandal, the smacking referendum, investigations of two backbench MPs, controversy over the Auckland Super City, Bill English’s housing problems, infighting between Government support parties, and the Rugby World Cup fiasco. And despite all that Labour is still at 27%!

Since 1974, the only time a party has had a bigger gap than 33% was the May to Aug 1990 Heylens for National. Note this was pre multi-party MMP.

The poll also reveals that John Key is at 56% as preferred PM, and Phil Goff a very distant third at 5%, around half Helen Clark at 8%. Now there is something wrong when you have been Opposition Leader for a year, and you can just make half of your predecessor who doesn’t even live here anymore.

The 51% gap between Key and Goff is also unprecedented. The closest we have seen is a 41% gap in February 2003 between Clark and English. So the gap is 10% higher than a poll taken after National had its worst ever election result, and in the year English was rolled.

When TV3 had similar results in February 2009, I blogged:

“Now a week is a long time in politics, and the next election is 33 months away. Goff is under no threat for now. But if he doesn’t make some traction towards the end of the year, he may find the summer of 2010 is BBQ at Dave’s place”

Up until now I have consistently said that I think Goff is very likely to lead Labour into the 2011 election. I am now thinking these last two polls have changed things.

As a comparison, in Australia Malcolm Turnbull is considered unlikely to survive until their election, which is only a year away.  And the Coalition is only 15.5% behind the Labor Party – not 33%.

There is no clear successor to Goff, and there was a covenant that he would be safe until the election. However I suspect several senior MPs will be texting New York asking for guidance, as to how long they should hold off for.

Personally I don’t think Goff is the issue for Labour – he may just become the scapegoat. I think Labour continues to be massively out of touch with the electorate. They don’t realise the global recession changed the political landscape.

Issues like RWC broadcasting is a beltway issue. It may not be at the time of the RWC, but it is for now. The economy is still the number one issue.

Now Labour is on the wrong side of spending cuts. Even Gordon Brown has caught on that the public are now pro spending cuts. But Labour keep positioning themselves as the enemies of fiscal responsibility.

Likewise on ACC, they think the public are on their side on the proposed changes. They do not realise how many people resent the amount they are being forced to pay in ACC levies, for little benefit.

And even with industrial disputes, Labour has misread much of the public mood. Labour have got involved with almost every industrial dispute in NZ, supporting demands for higher wages. They do not realise that most of NZ recognises a recession with growing unemployment is a time for restraint. People are more worried about keeping jobs, than pay increases.

A couple of years ago these issues would all have been winners for Labour. In boom times with massive surpluses people did want more spending, wider ACC coverage, and higher wages for all workers. But Labour’s inability to understand that the global recession has changed things, is why New Zealanders are saying they are irrelevant.  Labour are relying on the old Muldoon adage that the average person wouldn’t know a deficit if they tripped over one. Today people are more economically literate and when you have a $10 billion deficit, policies of tax more, spend more and borrow more don’t resonate.

If Goff wants to survive, he needs to reposition Labour into a more realistic position. I think he personally may understand this, but whether he can carry his caucus with him is the challenge.

Mixed race marriages

AFP reports:

AN interracial couple in Louisiana have been denied a marriage license by an official who considers their union morally wrong, according to local media.

“I’m not a racist,” Keith Bardwell, a justice of the peace in rural Tangipahoa Parish, told the Hammond Star.

“I do ceremonies for black couples right here in my house. My main concern is for the children.”

Mr Bardwell told the paper that he believes interracial marriages do not last and that the children of such unions are not accepted by either the black or white community.

Now of course Bardwell is bonkers to think it is his job to decide whether or not a couple should be able to get married, based on his beliefs. He does the classic groupist error of applying a generalisation to everyone (and of thinking it is his decision anyway).

It did get me interested in what is the prevalance of “mixed race” marriages and whether or not their divorce rates are higher than “same race” marriages.

In NZ we have traditionally had a high rate of mixed race marriages, as all modern Maori New Zealanders have at least one European ancestor. I do wonder if we have current stats on this – presumably the census data could reveal this.

In the US, only 2.8% of black women and 6.6% of black men had a white spouse. While 41% of Asian women have a white husband and 36% of Asian men have a white wife. So a big difference in prevalence depending on the races involved.

In terms of divorce rates Wikipedia says:

Marital stability studies published on the Education Resources Information Center found that White female-Black male unions are more prone to result in a divorce than White-White marriages are, while Black female-White male marriages show similar or lower risks of divorce than White-White marriages.

So Bardwell is wrong with his generalisation also.

As I said, I would be interested to see what the prevalence of mixed race/culture marriages are in NZ, and if there are differences in the divorce rates. Anyone know of any studies already done?

A great story

From the BBC:

Around the world millions of children are not getting a proper education because their families are too poor to afford to send them to school. In India, one schoolboy is trying to change that. In the first report in the BBC’s Hunger to Learn series, Damian Grammaticas meets Babar Ali, whose remarkable education project is transforming the lives of hundreds of poor children.

At 16 years old, Babar Ali must be the youngest headmaster in the world. He’s a teenager who is in charge of teaching hundreds of students in his family’s backyard, where he runs classes for poor children from his village.

The story of this young man from Murshidabad in West Bengal is a remarkable tale of the desire to learn amid the direst poverty. …

But Chumki is now getting an education, thanks to Babar Ali. The 16-year-old has made it his mission to help Chumki and hundreds of other poor children in his village. The minute his lessons are over at Raj Govinda school, Babar Ali doesn’t stop to play, he heads off to share what he’s learnt with other children from his village.

At four o’clock every afternoon after Babar Ali gets back to his family home a bell summons children to his house. They flood through the gate into the yard behind his house, where Babar Ali now acts as headmaster of his own, unofficial school.

Lined up in his back yard the children sing the national anthem. Standing on a podium, Babar Ali lectures them about discipline, then study begins.

Babar Ali gives lessons just the way he has heard them from his teachers. Some children are seated in the mud, others on rickety benches under a rough, homemade shelter. The family chickens scratch around nearby. In every corner of the yard are groups of children studying hard.

Babar Ali was just nine when he began teaching a few friends as a game. They were all eager to know what he learnt in school every morning and he liked playing at being their teacher. …

Now his afternoon school has 800 students, all from poor families, all taught for free. Most of the girls come here after working, like Chumki, as domestic helps in the village, and the boys after they have finished their day’s work labouring in the fields.

Is that not simply an amazing story?

Copyright and Cellphone tunes

The EFF report:

As we reported in June, ASCAP believes that when your cell phone’s musical ringtone sounds in a public place, you’re infringing copyright. A federal court yesterday firmly rejected that argument, ruling that “when a ringtone plays on a cellular telephone, even when that occurs in public, the user is exempt from copyright liability, and [the cellular carrier] is not liable either secondarily or directly.”

The greed and stupidity of some is almost beyond comprehension.

The ruling is an important victory for consumers, making it clear that playing music in public, when done without any commercial purpose, does not infringe copyright. That’s thanks to Section 110(4) of the Copyright Act, which exempts public performances undertaken “without any purpose of direct or indirect commercial advantage.” In the words of the court, “customers do not play ringtones with any expectation of profit.” This ruling should also protect consumers who roll down their car windows with the radio on,

No doubt they will propose you should have your car confiscated if you wind down your window, and allow people to hear the radio.

remember, ASCAP once demanded royalties from Girl Scouts for singing around the camp fire!

And this is why they are becoming so hated. They beat a retreat on that one at least, without going to court.

The court also found that cell phone carriers do not publicly perform when they download a ringtone to a phone (the carriers already pay 24 cents in royalties for the reproduction of the ringtone, but ASCAP was hoping to double dip by charging a public performance royalty on top of that).

This is key. They had been paid for use of the song as a ringtone. They wanted to also be paid if the phone rings in public!

Global opinions on Obama

Adam Smith at The Inquiring Mind blogs on confidence in Obama in 25 different countries, and notes that despite his Cairo speech (cited as part of the rationale for the Nobel Peace Prize), he still ranks negatively in the Muslim world.

As always I am interested in the raw data. The question asked was whether they were confident Obama would do the right thing in world affairs. His net ratings (positive less negative) are:

  1. Kenya +89%
  2. Germany +88%
  3. France + 83%
  4. Canada +79%
  5. Nigeria +78%
  6. UK +76%
  7. Japan +76%
  8. South Korea +69%
  9. India +68%
  10. Brazil +56%
  11. US + 50%
  12. Spain +50%
  13. Indonesia +49%
  14. Poland +41%
  15. Argentina +35%
  16. Mexico +22%
  17. Russia -3%
  18. Lebanon -4%
  19. Egypt -5%
  20. Israel -13%
  21. Turkey -19%
  22. Jordan -27%
  23. Pakistan -38%
  24. China -39%
  25. Palestine -52%

So Russia, Muslim countries and China not persuaded yet.

Another question asks about overall favourability of the US, and tracks it from 1999. The data below shows the change between 2009 and 2008 (or 2007 if not polled in 2008) which presumably reflects the Obama effect.

  1. France +33%
  2. Germany +33%
  3. Indonesia +26%
  4. Spain +25%
  5. Mexico +22%
  6. UK +16%
  7. Argentina +16%
  8. Nigeria +15%
  9. Brazil +14%
  10. Canada +13%
  11. India +10%
  12. Japan +9%
  13. South Korea +8%
  14. Jordan +6%
  15. China +6%
  16. Egypt +5%
  17. Lebanon +4%
  18. US +4%
  19. Kenya +3%
  20. Palestine +2%
  21. Turkey +2%
  22. Poland -1%
  23. Russia -2%
  24. Pakistan -3%
  25. Israel -7%

So Obama has had US favourability rise greatly in Western Europe and South America. Asia had had a modest improvement, and Middle East countries a very small improvement only.

One thing I found interesting is that the US under Bush had a 87% favourability rating amongst Kenyans. Bush actually delivered huge aid to Africa.

The 2010 Pew data will be interesting.

Blog Bits

  1. Nandor Tancos says Keith Locke’s Head of State bill should go to a select committee to generate debate, but does not want it passed without an exploration of wider constitutional issues.
  2. Bryce Edwards has a comprehensive piece on the splintering of the Greens, and how the Greens have become more centrist with their mission being to “save capitalism” as Russel Norman put it.
  3. Tim Watkin blogs on the significance of what US Assistant Secretary of State Kurt Campbell said on Q&A. The media all missed that he effectively said Obama will announce his position on trade at APEC.
  4. Cactus Kate has fun at my expense.
  5. Liberty Scott blogs on how Geert Wilders was greeted in the UK with chants of “burn in hell”, “Sharia for UK” and a banner saying “Sharia is the solution, freedom go to hell”.
  6. Busted Blonde is abused by Bob Jones.
  7. Whale Oil finds look a like logos for Telecom.

Brown spends up big in bid for power

Nope not Gordon Brown, but Len Brown. His spending is already into six figures it seems, and he is planning a million dollar campaign.

Where are the Labour Party and Green Party people condemning big money in politics, and demanding law changes to stop him “buying” the election?

Brown has already spent between $150,000 and $200,000, according to his rival, Auckland Mayor John Banks – but Brown has dismissed this as at least $100,000 too high.

Brown also denied that his funding had come principally from former Auckland City mayor Dick Hubbard – however the cereal king has paid a small sum.

Brown predicted yesterday that his campaign would reach the million mark.

So who is funding Brown? Surely this Labour Party member will reveal all.

While there will be a cap of $70,000 on all campaigns, that only covers the last three months before the election.

Now think about this. A national campaign has a spending cap of $2.4 million for the last three months and the fact National ran some billboards just ahead of that time period worth around $250,000 saw Labour force through a law change to stop such a thing. So National spent an extra 10% of the regulated period budget before the regulated period. While Labour Party member Len Brown is planning to spend an extra 1300% before the regulated period.

Bulk Funding

Trevor Mallard blogs:

Anne Tolley will announce a progressive introduction of bulk funding for schools starting soon with the staffing component for guidance and careers counsellors being abolished and a small increase going into the bulk operations grant.

Now it comes from Trevor, so it is hardly reliable, but we can all keep our fingers crossed that it is actually true.

Bulk funding is in fact how almost every other part of society operates.

Hospitals don’t have their staff paid out of one budget on a fixed scale, and an operations grant for everything else.

Universities don’t have their staff paid out of one budget, and an ops grant for everything else.

It is pretty much only in the school sector that you have this abnormal arrangement.

Dom Post on Police Chases

A good editorial:

The grief of parents who have lost sons and daughters, killed in high-speed police chases, is wholly understandable.

But, in the wake of an Independent Police Conduct Authority report questioning the value of many police pursuits, one fact needs to be borne in mind.

Drivers have a choice when they hear a police siren. They can pull over to the side of the road as the majority do. Or they can try to escape police.

And parents should wonder about their role in the tragedy that ensures, if their kids even consider trying to outspeed the Police, let alone actually doing so.

When chases end in death or serious injury, as occurred 137 times in a five-year period studied by the authority, it is the drivers who tried to outrun the police who bear responsibility for the human toll. That is not something for which they, or their parents, can shift the blame.

And a policy of let them get away if they drive fast enough actually just encourages people to drive even faster when fleeing.

Those with the power to take the risk out of the equation are the individuals tempted to depress the accelerator pedal rather than the brake when they hear a police siren.

It is a power the parents of all driving-age children should remind their offspring of. The consequences of a wrong decision can be tragic for them, their families, their friends, police and complete strangers.

If the Police were allowed to shoot at fleeing vehicles, I’m pretty sure that would reduce the number of police chases also!

What a great idea

The Southland Times reports:

Queenstown’s Pig and Whistle pub will be opening on Labour Day but its 10 workers will not be getting paid statutory holiday time-and-a-half rates.

In fact, they will not be getting paid at all. Instead, staff will take control of the pub for the day, splitting everything in the till after expenses have been paid.

Owner Barry Ellis has offered the same deal to staff at Craft Bar in Dunedin, in a move to circumvent the restrictions of the Holidays Act.

“We would normally close on the day and we thought let’s do something a little bit novel and let them find how it is to run their own business.” …

The staff will have to cover the rent, alleviating Mr Ellis of one expense if he had closed, but he said the real benefit would be strengthening the relationship between staff and managers.

Pig and Whistle duty manager Daragh Cantwell said he was sceptical when the idea was first mooted, realising it would mean waiving wages for the day, but then he had a look at the trading figures supplied by Mr Ellis. “It depends on the day but we think we’ve got a really good chance of doing well.”

He declined to speculate on what riches might be on offer, but said many patrons had already indicated they would be in on Labour Day to prop up the bar.

Seven front-of-house staff and three chefs had democratically planned the menu, entertainment and opening hours, and would evenly split any profit based on how many hours they worked.

I hope they report afterwards, how well it went.

Fran on Key and Obama

Fran compares John Key to Barrack Obama, and not in a good way!

The “Mr Nice Guys” like Prime Minister John Key – and US President Barack Obama – who have soared high on the basis of personal popularity and feel-good vibes – are now finding out the hard way thatthere is more to making a good political hamburger than mere sizzle. …

Less than one year into his reign as New Zealand Prime Minister, Key’s popularity – like that of his party’s – is rocketing high in the opinion polls.

Much more so that Obama incidentially. Obama has only a net 11% positive rating, and the Democrats are polling only 4% ahead of the Republicans nationally.

Like Obama, Key has succeeded in one critical area: changing “the vibe” around his nation’s capital. Like Obama he is perceived as a Mr Nice Guy in large part because he is not his predecessor: Helen Clark in Key’s case, or George W. Bush (Obama).

That is a fair point. Of course John Key hasn’t won the Nobel Peace Prize simply for not being his predecessor!

It is a political truism the crucial strengths that underline a leader’s popularity are also their weaknesses.

Key – like his alter ego – is now in desperate need of the vital machine skills to ensure his Government does make progress on controversial flagship policies.

Key will be hoping he doesn’t have another week like the last one. The public are fairly forgiving of stuff ups, if they are corrected quickly. But if they start to form a pattern, then confidence gets shaken.

Maori Party Leadership

The Herald reports on the organisational leadership of the Maori Party:

Maori Party president Whatarangi Winiata’s plans to retire from the post today appear to have been scuttled after several people within the party asked him to stay on.

Dr Winiata had announced his intention to stand down at today’s annual general meeting in Auckland.

He is two years through his three-year term, but had proposed resigning to allow his successor two years in the position before the next election.

Asked if he had changed his mind, he said he had been approached about it and would stay on if the membership decided it was the best option.

He would wait to hear what the meeting wanted before deciding.

The party’s co-president, retired Maori Land Court judge Heta Kenneth Kingston, was tipped to succeed him.

Dr Winiata has led the party wing of the Maori Party since it was formed in 2004 and having him stay on will help the party’s stability.

The party also has a challenge ahead with its parliamentary leadership. At the 2014 election, Turia will be 70, and Sharples 73. I would expect both will retire at that election.

That means they need to have their successors in place at the 2011 election, and they may struggle to find people of matching profile and mana nationally.

The most high profile current MP is Hone Harawira, but Hone is not seeking leadership and would be an unlikely one. Some say his wife Hilda would be an excellent Leader, but is Parliament ready for two Harawiras?

Te Ururoa Flavell is considered able to potentially step up if he lifts his profile in the next few years. But even if that happens, the Maori Party will still need a new female co-leader and unless they pick up the final two seats off Labour, no way to get them into Parliament in 2011.

Claire Trevett also has a very insightful article on the two current co-leaders and their strengths and weaknesses.

Union rejects ERA recommendation

I have not followed the bus dispute in Auckland very closely, but find this story interesting:

The Employment Relations Authority has made public its recommendations to settle the pay dispute between NZ Bus and Auckland drivers.

The ERA suggested a wage increase of 4.2 per cent for the first 16 months, back-paid to July this year, then 3.9 per cent for the next 14 months from November next year.

Both increases amounted to 70 cents an hour.

The collective agreement would expire on December 31, 2011 after the Rugby World Cup, ERA recommended.

NZ Bus agreed to the recommendations and requested they should be released to the public.

So the employer is willing to accept the ERA recommendation, but it is the union that is not.

I note inflation is now running at 1.2%.

Competition for ACC?

National actually won an election mandate for introducing competition and choice to ACC. It shouldn’t need ACT to push it in that direction.

The 1998 changes were a win-win. Not only did employers get choice, and lower levies, but workplace accidents fell as other insurers provided incentives to employers to have safer workplaces.

Telecom’s new logo

teelcom_300x200

The Herald writes about Telecom’s new logo, and the debate about whether it is a snowflake, or a spark.

The best suggestion I have seen was on Twitter, where someone suggested it represents the small print in the contracts, which is normally denoted by an asterisk 🙂

To be fair, I do prefer the new logo to the old one, which was very dull and corporate.

Hooton on ACC

Matthew Hooton has written on ACC in his opening salvo for NBR. It is only available in the tree version, but some extracts:

In 2001, Australian insurance giant HIH collapsed with debts of around A$5 billion, caused by gross mismanagement, including charging too little for premiums and failing to put enough aside for claims.

The Australian authorities took the matter seriously, including Prime Minister John Howard, who established a royal commission. The company’s principals were jailed for offences including knowingly disseminating false information, filing false financial statements, being intentionally dishonest and failing to discharge their duties in good faith and in the best interests of the company.

I think I know where Matthew is going with this.

This week, New Zealand’s biggest insurer, ACC, reported a NZ$4.8 billion loss on top of a NZ$2.4 billion loss the previous year.

Like HIH, ACC’s crisis was knowingly hidden from the public. The Treasury’s Pre-Election Economic and Fiscal Update, signed by then finance minister Michael Cullen, did not disclose it, a failure subsequently found by an independent inquiry to have breached the Public Finance Act.

Yes my suspicions are correct.

Even worse were the public statements of then-ACC minister Maryan Street.
On June 26, 2008, ACC was apparently strong enough for Ms Street to announce that 400,000 casual and seasonal workers would get improved cover.

On September 11, she had enough confidence in the company’s finances to announce a re-elected Labour government would cut the motor vehicle levy from $254 to $203.

Three weeks later, and just five weeks before the election, Ms Street was at it again, announcing an expansion of ACC entitlements to people over 65.

The most charitable interpretation is that the former university academic might suffer from some advanced form of oniomania that makes her believe that, despite ballooning liabilities and a global financial crisis, it was possible to keep buying new services from ACC, while cutting its revenue, and expect it to remain viable. Alternatively, perhaps she was just telling lies in the heat of a close election campaign.

I had to look up what oniomania is!

Far from turning itself in to the Serious Fraud Office, Labour now has the audacity to launch a new narrative that accuses ACC Minister Nick Smith and ACC chairman John Judge of establishing some kind of conspiracy to privatise the scheme.

Audacity is the nicest word for it. I still think it is a pity the Government did not demand prosecutions for the breach of the Public Finance Act!

Espiner on ACC

Colin Espiner blogs on ACC:

I said I’d post something on ACC, so here goes. Oh dear, what a mess.

It’s hard to know where to start really. Is it all Labour’s fault for increasing entitlements but not premiums? Or the people at ACC, who seem keen to pay themselves large salaries but can’t apparently count? Or the recession? Or the fully funded model? Or all of the above?

When news first broke earlier this year of a hole in the ACC accounts, many of us – and I include myself – were a bit sceptical of National’s motivation, particularly given that excitable boy Nick Smith was in charge, and he is known for, well, exaggerating from time to time.

But the conspiracy theory peddled by Labour and the EPMU (i.e. Labour) that somehow this is all just a VRWC to derail the ACC, lower public confidence in it, and then sell it to the highest (or any) bidder just doesn’t ring true for me.

I can never work out if Labour is the political arm of the EPMU or if the EPMU is the industrial arm of Labour.

For starters, I can’t believe someone with chairman John Judge’s commercial background is going to put his reputation on the line just to help the Government push a particular political ideology. Judge is not going to claim that the very existence of the ACC is under threat if it’s not.

Second,  there have now been three relatively independent reviews of ACC’s financial position, and all of them have come up with the conclusion that it is in the poo.

I actually laugh everytime David Parker insists you can’t trust the Government’s figures, considering the last Government’s failure to mention the ACC blowout broke the Public Finance Act. This is not an area of credibility for them.

Third, there’s little doubt that the additions made to the scheme by Labour a couple of years ago – including things like lump-sum payouts for the families of suicide victims, and physiotherapy, simply aren’t affordable any more.

An employee on the average wage is now paying over $1,000 a year to ACC. That is a huge amount of money.

Having said all that, I do think Nick Smith has over-egged the pudding a little bit. At least some of the need for the big increases is because of the move towards fully funding the ACC.

Fully funding means that like a commercial insurer, ACC is required to hold enough in reserve to meet the claims it expects to have to pay out on over a given time. It has never operated like this before, but is now required to.

Originally this was to happen by 2014. The Government – and in fact Labour too – wants to push this out to 2019. You could question whether ACC should in fact ever be fully funded, but that’s another argument.

I want to cover this argument in detail one day. Michael Littlewood has written at length that a Government backed insurer does not need to depart from the old model of collecting enough every year to cover payments for that year.

The Government is also going to get some heat over the decisions it’s made, and so it should. The massive increases in levies for motorcycles seems grossly unfair to me, and smacks of National hitting a group of voters it doesn’t think are likely to be National supporters.

Sure, motorcycles are involved in more accidents, but how many of those were caused by car drivers? As a former motorcyclist myself, it was being knocked off my bike by some idiot in a car that prompted me to hang up my helmet.

Even under the changes, motorcyclists are being subsidised by other drivers. A motorcyclist is 16 times more likely to be involved in an accident. Not even if half are caused by motorists, that is still eight times more likely.

Ramping up motorcycle levies also flies completely in the face of all the rhetoric from the Government about reducing congestion, cutting carbon emissions, using less petrol, etc etc. Not to mention parking.

The purpose of ACC is not to incentivise people to cut carbon emissions, reduce congestion etc. You have other taxes and policies for that. The purpose of ACC is to cover the costs of accidents.

I hear National doesn’t have the votes to get the changes through Parliament yet, either, although it probably will manage it eventually because it’s cleverly set up a straw man in the form of even higher increases proposed by ACC that don’t require a law change.

Therefore if parties don’t vote for National’s bill, the Government can accuse them of agreeing to even higher imposts on the public. That is quite clever.

I don’t think it is clever. I think one should get 61 votes in favour before you announce the changes.

Also Whale Oil has a post on a payout to children of someone killed in an accident. I think there should be some initial support, but when did it happen that  ACC funds you until you are 18, if your parent dies in an accident. If your parent drops dead from a heart attack you get nothing, but if it is an “accident” you get ACC. The original scheme was about looking after people temporarily until they could work again – not social welfare.

A triduum horribilis

At NBR today, I blog on the Government’s triduum horribilis. The opening para:

It is hard to recall a more chaotic few days for the Government. It is not that any wheels totally fell off the wagon, but all four wheels seemed to come loose at the same time, with John Key trying to refasten them all simultaneously.

Comments and feedback can be left at NBR.

Mike Moore on globalisation

The Herald reports on Mike Moore’s new book:

Mr Moore said more wealth had been created in the past 60 years than in all of history. Hundreds of millions of people had been lifted out of extreme poverty through globalisation.

Yet so many have fought against it. An unholy alliance of the hard left and far right.

Mr Moore said globalisation was “not a policy, it’s a process” and while it could be slowed it could not be stopped. Fascist and Marxist states that arose after the Great Depression had been vicious and protectionist.

And one great legacy of Helen Clark (and Moore and Goff) is firmly placing NZ Labour into the mainstream on globalisation and pre free-trade.

Protectionism was the “crack cocaine” of economics. “It does stimulate you for a while but it is addictive and it will eventually kill you.”

Nice analogy.

The cover has endorsements by former US Secretary of State Madeleine Albright, and former Czech President Vaclav Havel. It was launched jointly by Foreign Minister Murray McCully and Labour leader Phil Goff.

Again good to see bipartisan support for globalisation and free trade.

I worry a bit about where Labour may go, after Goff. Either Shane Jones or David Cunliffe will I am sure be pro free trade. But Andrew Little may not be, as unions are often heavily protectionist.

Crampton on Health doomsayers

A great column in the Herald by Eric Crampton:

Sometime soon, we’ll see a report showing that the social costs of skiing are in the hundreds of millions of dollars. It wouldn’t be hard to produce a number that large. First, show frequent skiers are more likely to have accidents than recreational skiers.

Then, make the critical assumption that nobody could ever rationally decide to take risks – health is all that matters. Frequent skiers then are by definition irrational, and irrational people enjoy no benefits from their ski outings, no matter how happy they appear.

With this “zero benefits” assumption, every dollar spent on skiing by these harmful skiers is a social cost, as is the time these folks spend skiing. Add the realised costs from those folks who do have skiing accidents and you’d quickly have a number in the hundreds of millions of dollars, if not billions.

Such a good analogy.

Any time we make a decision that lets us enjoy a bit of fun but with some risk to our health, that decision is considered irrational and cannot generate any real enjoyment.

Consequently, benefits are either assumed equal to zero or set to an arbitrarily low level.

But is it really irrational to trade off health against other goals? I have a hard time imagining somebody for whom health isn’t a good.

But I similarly cannot imagine anybody for whom health is the only good. We all trade off risks to our health against other goals we seek, all the time.

If you saved a few dollars by not buying the most expensive baby car seat on the market, you decided that the very small extra increase in safety for your child isn’t worth the money.

If health and safety were our only goal, the world would look very different. We would all buy cars made of padded foam rubber and drive very slowly. That we don’t is strong evidence that we have pluralistic sets of values – we are not monomaniacal healthists in our daily lives.

Absolutely. You want a zero road toll. Set the speed limit to 30 km/hr.

If we tally up the social costs of driving with a cellphone, we ought to recognise that accident costs need to be weighed up against all of the benefits that drivers enjoy from being able to take the occasional call while on the road – we oughtn’t have our thumb on the scales by assuming the benefits away.

And this is why I am critical of the Government for their moves here. Nowhere have I seen measurement of the benefits vs the costs of cellphone use in cars.

For every skier who dies in an avalanche, tens of thousands of others took no fewer risks but enjoyed a great time out on the slopes. Their enjoyment ought to count for something.

And, for every drinker who dies in an accident that could have been avoided were he sober, there are countless others who simply enjoyed a good night out.

Yes. And forcing bars to close early (for example) will stop many having a good night out.

Child Discipline Research

Some interesting research from the Families Commission. Only 100 families involved, but still useful results:

The most common disciplinary techniques for under 5s were:

  1. Time Out 82%
  2. Distraction 77%
  3. Rewards 76%
  4. Praise 69%
  5. Withdraw Privileges 60%
  6. Reasoning 58%
  7. Smacking 41%
  8. Shouting 41%
  9. Ignoring 38%
  10. Hugs and Smiles 31%
  11. Make child apologise 18%

They also rated effectiveness:

  1. Time Out 43%
  2. Withdraw Privileges 30%
  3. Distraction 27%
  4. Rewards 24%
  5. Praise 11%
  6. Reasoning 10%
  7. Smacking 9%
  8. Hugs and Smiles 9%
  9. Shouting 5%
  10. Ignoring 5%
  11. Make child apologise 2%