General Debate 24 June 2009
Actually only the 23rd over here still!
The ODT reports:
The longest sentence for animal cruelty in New Zealand was imposed on a Dunedin man yesterday.
Jeffrey Hurring, 19, a supermarket shelf-filler, was sentenced in the Dunedin District Court to 12 months’ jail for killing an 18-month-old male Jack Russell dog in Dunedin on February 2 this year.
He was also barred from owning an animal for 10 years.
Sadly with parole he may be out in a couple of dozen weeks.
Hurring admitted killing the dog, named Diesel and owned by a friend, by first trying to strangle it using a chain, his hands and his feet.
When the dog did not die after 30 minutes, he poured petrol down its throat, stuffed a pillow-case down its throat and finally hit it on the head with a spade.
The impact broke the dog’s back and jaw, killing it.
How absolutely monstrous.
Actually only the 23rd over here still!
I’m due to arrive in DC in a few hours and guess I’m glad I wasn’t there a few hours earlier:
WASHINGTON – A Metro train smashed into the back of another at the height of the Monday evening rush hour, killing at least six people and injuring scores of others as cars from the trailing train jackknifed into the air and fell atop the first.
One of the fatalities was a female train operator, Metro officials say. The woman’s name has not been released.
D.C. Fire Chief Dennis Rubin says more than 70 people were transported to hospitals. Of those, two people have life-threatening injuries and 50 are classified as “walking wounded” injuries.
One train basically fell on four carriages of the other train. Amazing not more people died.
One can’t be sure, but this sounds like a beat-up:
A Nelson man has laid a complaint with police that the city’s MP, Nick Smith, assaulted and abused him.
However, Dr Smith says it was he who was pushed and shoved and he now intends to make a complaint to police too.
Police say they hope to interview Dr Smith today.
Ross Cooper said he approached Dr Smith on Rutherford St just before noon on Saturday, when he saw the environment minister leaving the market.
Mr Cooper, who is on a partial invalid’s benefit, wanted to talk to the MP about his “disgusting” power bill.
However, he claimed Dr Smith, who was getting into his car, would not talk to him.
Dr Smith tried slamming his door twice, hitting Mr Cooper’s shoulder, and abused him, swearing at him to go away, Mr Cooper said. “I was leaning over on the car doorway, showing my bill,” he said. “He wanted to push me aside to get going.”
Mr Cooper said he had a sore shoulder as a result but was otherwise uninjured.
And the other side:
Dr Smith said he had been due to pick up his children and go on to the opening of Motueka’s community hospital on Saturday, and had told Mr Cooper this. He said he had a look at Mr Cooper’s power bill and told Mr Cooper to arrange an appointment to see him through Dr Smith’s office.
Dr Smith has had previous dealings with Mr Cooper.
That is interesting.
“He refused to allow me to leave. He pushed and shoved me and refused to allow me entry to my car.”
Dr Smith said he had tried to get into his car, including via the passenger door.
“I feel I was assaulted in that I was simply trying to get in my car because I was running late.”
Unless there is more to this than meets the eye, I can’t see it as significant.
UPDATE: NZPA report the Police say there is no case:
A number of witnesses were spoken to and confirmed Mr Cooper was agitated and acting in a loud and aggressive manner towards Dr Smith over his power bill.
Mr Winter said the witnesses also said Mr Cooper was trying to prevent Dr Smith from closing the door of his vehicle and driving away.
He said Mr Cooper was known to Dr Smith, whom he had previously tried to assist but who had repeatedly abused and intimidated his electoral office staff over a period of a decade.
Maybe Nick should have done a Prescott!
The next item to look at is MPs expense allowances. Every MP gets an expense allowance of $14,800. Only the Speaker at $18,400 and the PM at $19,700 get a higher allowance.
A mistake the media often make is thinking this is an expense claim limit, and that somewhere there is a record of each MPs expenses in relation to this allowance. There is not, so demanding MPs reveal what they spend it on is rather silly.
The expense allowance also came about in 2003, and replaces the old daily allowance and former expense allowance. The allowance is designed to cover out-of-pocket expenses incurred on parliamentary business. Not travel expenses, but the smaller stuff such as:
The IRD has approved the allowance as reflecting the genuine expenses of MPs, and it is not treated as remuneration – hence no tax is paid on it. If you assume a six day working week, it is around $50 a day. I understand it is paid on the same frequency as their salary.
You might ask why MPs should get their meals paid for? Well it is for the same reason that if your employer forces you to spend a couple of days away from home, they cover your meals. Their costs would be a lot less if they could eat all their meals at home, but this is not posible when you are in Wellington half the time.
Now it is not common for “employees” to be paid an expense allowance rather than merely claim work related expenses. So why are MPs treated this way?
I suspect the biggest reason is administrative convenience. Unlike most “employees” who may only travel a few weeks a year, MPs are incurring expenses every day. It would probably take scores of hours to process all the receipts, record down exactly what they were for, and pay out on them.
Some organisations operate on a similiar basis to MPs – they pay a “per diem” for average daily expenses rather than reimburse on actual expenses.
One advantage of paying an expense allowance, is you avoid what we have seen in the UK where MPs try and maximise their expenses so they can claim more money.
There are downsides to this approach. It means some MPs probably get to save a bit of money, as their actual expenses are less than their allowance. And other MPs (especially those who are harder working and do more) arguably end up out of pocket as their expenses exceeds the allowance.
Overall I think the approch taken by the Remuneration Authority (and IRD) is a sound one. They did some emperical research a few years ago as to the average expenses incurred by MPs, and have set the allowance accordingly. It can’t be rorted, and provides certainity.
Now again this expense allowance is only for incidentals. There are separate funding arrangements for travel and accomodation which I will detail.
I was fascinated to read this article in The Press by Martin van Beynen. He sat through the entire Bain trial, as a reporter. He starts off saying:
After sitting through almost every minute of the David Bain retrial, I was quite convinced Bain killed his family on June 20, 1994, by executing them with his .22 semi-automatic rifle.
And further:
I thought many of the defence arguments had been exposed as almost ludicrously implausible and its experts revealed as endorsing some very strained interpretations of the evidence.
I’m glad he shared his views. He notes:
Not that the police case was without flaws. If the police had kept samples taken from Robin Bain’s hands, and also removed and retained carpet that contained a crucial bloodied footprint, the result might have been different.
David Bain’s lawyers were able to argue that the police had removed an opportunity for him to prove his innocence, but the police’s lack of diligence could also be seen as a great stroke of luck for Bain.
I said something similiar – that David Bain should thank the Police as their errors did help his case.
Several aspects about this jury should worry us all.
The two jurors a man and a woman who were seen to congratulate Bain after the verdicts and who went to his celebratory party were the same two who spent the last three weeks of the trial paying little attention to the evidence and closing addresses. They giggled and wrote messages to each other.
The man would often sleep through parts of the afternoon.
Appalling.
Initially, the woman was so disturbed by the images shown as evidence that she turned her computer screen away. By her own admission, she spent the first two weeks of the trial in tears, and the trial lost half a day because of her anguish.
Was she capable of emotional detachment in assessing the evidence?
Withnall presses strongly for compensation for Bain. I doubt whether Bain will apply for compensation because he must be aware, even if his legal team is not, that he was extremely lucky to get the verdict he did.
I hope he does apply for compensation, so a QC can advise on balance of probabilities if he is innocent or not.
Many people have said to me that the verdict doesn’t really matter since Bain has served 13 years in jail anyway. In a way they are right.
I don’t see much point in Bain serving any more time in jail. However, we need to keep reminding ourselves that five people were killed and the character of Bain’s father, Robin, has been irretrievably besmirched.
We are now going to get countless articles and books about how the innocent Bain was persecuted by a conspiracy among the authorities. I am sure a David v Goliath film is also in the offing.
That Bain faced what I regarded as an overwhelming case will be lost in the fog of legend-building and self-justification.
This is one reason I also keep covering the issue.
You might ask what makes me so certain Bain brutally killed his family in 1994 in Dunedin. For that, you have to go back to the trial evidence.
The reasons I am sure Bain killed his family are twofold.
The first is the incredible coincidences that we have to accept if Bain is innocent.
For instance, we have to accept, just for a start, that the following facts all have perfectly innocent explanations not connected with the death of the Bain family Bain’s clear and recent fingerprints on the murder rifle, the bruises on his face and torso, the blood of his brother on his clothes, a 20-minute delay before ringing the police after finding bodies, hearing his sister gurgling (and failing to help her), convenient changes in his story, a lens from damaged glasses (of no use to anyone else and found in his bedroom) turning up in his dead brother’s room, bizarre behaviour before and after the killings, not noticing the blood all over the laundry and putting the jersey worn by the killer in the washing.
Exactly – the series of “coincidences” was enormous. And then van Beynen looks at the Robin did it theory:
However, the best evidence relates to the implausibility of Robin Bain shooting his family and then himself. If David Bain is not the culprit, Robin had a settled night in his caravan (we know this by the amount and quality of urine in his bladder) and then got up about 5.50am, after David had left on his paper round.
Despite David admitting he hated his father and siding strongly with his mother in every dispute, he was the one Robin wanted to spare, so he had to be out of the house. …
In the caravan, he listened to the radio, which he probably switched on before getting up.
His first stop on the way to the house where his family slept was at the letterbox, where he removed the newspaper.
Once in the house, he went to David’s room, where he took the rifle from the wardrobe and then looked for the key to the trigger lock. Although he scattered a few bullets around (David had more than 1000 rounds of ammunition in his wardrobe), he found the key in a pot on David’s desk with ease and carefully ensured other items were left in place.
He also put on David’s white dress gloves, forgetting he did not want to implicate David and also overlooking that, since he was going to end it all, it wouldn’t matter much if people knew it was him, anyway. …
Stephen, pumped up with adrenaline, fought for his life, but Robin, belying a frame described as cadaverous, soon had the better of the brave teenager, strangling him first with his T-shirt and, when he was incapacitated, putting a bullet through the top of his head, like he had done or was to do with Laniet. …
He went back to the caravan, perhaps having already neatly placed his blood-spattered clothes and blood-soaked socks in the laundry basket. He did not wash his hands.
To meet his maker, he chose an old pair of light-blue tracksuit pants, an equally delapidated T-shirt, an old business shirt, a brown woollen jersey and a thick hoodie. He also donned a green knitted beanie. He put on clean socks and shoes, but no underpants.
Then, he went back to the house to take his own life.
Time was marching on.
David would soon be home from his paper round and he still had to write his message on the computer.
He turned the computer on (David must now have been nearing the house) and waited 40 seconds for the computer to bring up the page for him to write his suicide note not to explain himself but to exonerate David. “Sorry you are the only one who deserved to stay.”
Then, despite executing his family in textbook style, Robin chose an extraordinarily unusual way to take his own life, placing the rifle muzzle against his left temple on a strange angle.
A shot and he was falling, spilling blood and brain matter, which somehow got on to curtains that were a long way from where his body was found.
And the spare 10-shot magazine just happened to land on its narrowest edge, right by his right hand.
Despite clutching the rifle with his unclad hands to shoot at least some members of his family and then himself, the rifle did not have a single fingerprint belonging to him, even on the steel of the silencer.
Who did it? David or Robin?
In my view, the decision wasn’t that hard.
What a great article. And remember van Beynen actually heard all the evidence.
I’m going to do a series of a dozen or so posts on MPs salaries, expenses and funding. The purpose is to increase awareness and education of what MPs are paid, what they cost, what budgets they have available and associated issues. I have found that most of the reporting on this issue is rather superficial (as dictated by the medium), so am hoping this will help provide a more balanced comprehensive view.
MPs Salaries
The headline salary for an ordinary MP was set in 2003 to be $110,000. Those with additional responsibilities get paid more – with the Prime Minister’s salary then being $305,000.
What almost no-one knows is that the salary is calculated as part of a total remuneration package, and the “perks” such as superannuation subsidies and some air travel are deducted from the remuneration level, to get to a base salary. So when you see an article on how MPs get a 20% superannuation subsidy (if they put in 8%), you should be aware that if the subsidy did not exist, MPs would simply get paid 20% more. The superannuation level does not affect the total cost to the taxpayer (unless they are on the former gold plated scheme which closed off in the early 1990s).
So what is the total remuneration package for an MP? The 2003 determination that details all this doesn’t appear to be online, but the Remuneration Authority kindly sent me a copy – which is uploaded here – parl-s-a-det-2003
In 2003 the Remuneration Authority said it was $142,700. The components were:
1. Salary $110,000
2. Superannuation $22,000
3. MPs Domestic Travel $1,500
4. Spouses Domestic Travel $3,400
5. MPs/Spouses International Travel $5,800
So again this is something very few people realise. The average value of the personal benefit of free travel has been calculated and is deducted from an MPs remuneration to calculate their base salary.
Now you may wonder how the Remuneration Authority calculates the private benefit of the travel entitlements. Well the IRD did it for them. The IRD estimated:
• Domestic MPs Air Travel – $30,296 per member and 5% is of personal benefit
• Domestic Spouses Air Travel – $7,516 and 45% is of personal benefit
• MPs and Spouses International Air Travel – $5,780 per member and 100% is of personal benefit
Now this system is not perfect. You could argue why should some MPs get paid less, because other MPs have (for example) spouses. But I don’t think married MPs should have to pay for them to see their spouses occasionally during the week. So averaging out the personal benefit and deducting from their remuneration is a sensible approach.
Now these are the numbers used in 2003. What are they in 2008? Well sadly the Remuneration Authority only reports annually the change in base salary, not the change in total remuneration package. This is a pity, as if they were to republish the calculations every year it would educate more people about how the “perks” are deducted from MPs remuneration.
But we do know the salary for a backbench MP is now $131,000 so we can estimate their total remuneration package in 2008. It would be:
1. Salary $131,000 (a 19% increase over five years)
2. Superannuation $26,200 (20% of salary)
3. MPs Domestic Travel $1,800 (assume 19% increase)
4. Spouses Domestic Travel $4,000
5. MPs/Spouses International Travel $6,900
This is an estimated total remuneration package in 2008 of $167,900 for a backbench MP. So base salaries and total rem packages (estimated) for each job in 2008 bis:
1. Backbench MP $131,000 salary; $167,900 total rem
2. Deputy Committee Chair $135,300; $173,060
3. Committee Chairs $144,500; $184,100
4. Nat/Lab Junior Whips $144,500; $184,100
5. Maori/Act Whip $144,500; $184,100
6. Assistant Speakers $144,500; $184,100
7. Progressive Leader $144,500; $184,100
8. Green Whip $148,100; $188,420
9. Green Leader $157,100; $199,220
10. Deputy Speaker $169,900; $214,580
11. Labour Senior Whip $175,420; $221,204
12. Labour Deputy Leader $176,170; $222,104
13. National Senior Whip $180,400; $227,180
14. Minister outside Cabinet $204,300; $255,860
15. Leader of the Opposition $243,700; $303,140
16. Speaker $243,700; $303,140
17. Cabinet Minister $243,700; $303,140
18. Deputy PM $276,700; $342,740
19. PM $393,000; $482,300
The Remuneration Authority notes that the remuneration package for a backbench MP is now roughly in line with comparative jobs. They say that at the upper levels, they lag behind – for example the PM’s salary being relatively low for the immense responsibilities that go with it. However yet to meet a PM who is in it for their salary.
My next post will be on MPs expense allowances, and then will go through centrally funded expenses (such as travel), and bulk funded expenses (such as constituency offices etc). I expect close to a dozen posts all up – the intent is to inform, and to be balanced.
Colin Espiner blogs:
None of which stops Sharples from trying, however, and nor should it. I know that he should as an Associate Education Minister toe the Government line, but personally I expect Sharples to be a passionate advocate for his people. As long as Key doesn’t actually agree to this hare-brained idea, I’m happy for Sharples to push it.
For one thing, it’s good to have a debate about the place of education in our society, and remind ourselves that it’s pretty much the only thing that is going to get us out of the economic backwater in which New Zealand now resides.
Education is part of it, yes.
And it’s true that Maori participation statistics in tertiary education are appalling, and something needs to be done about it.
They are not appalling. They are in fact far superior to any other ethnic group in NZ. I blogged a few days ago on this, and the Maori participation rate is 50% higher than the Pakeha rate. Possibly Colin meant to refer to university participation rates only, but the terms are not interchangeable.
And even the university participation rate is not “appalling” – it is 80% of the Pakeha rate. I think Colin is too used to just assuming Maori health and education statistics are “appalling”, without checking them out.
I just think Sharples has the wrong end of the stick. There’s little point letting more Maori into university if they are simply going to fail.
Here I agree.
A better question might be why so few Maori make the grade to get into university in the first place. And I suspect that can be traced all the way back through the school system to early childhood and the child’s parents. I’m sure Sharples would argue that is all the system’s fault, and perhaps part of it is. Though I think Maori could probably shoulder some of the blame as well.
And here I absolutely agree.
As I say, though, the debate is a needed one. Just recently Canterbury University vice-chancellor Rod Carr had a good serve at the Prime Minister for cutting funding in real terms to universities and polytechnics, and I think this issue is going to become a hot topic in the months to come.
Personally I would rather the Government put the additional $750 million it shovels into the health black hole every year into tertiary education instead. I reckon it would pay huge dividends.
But here I disagree. If I had $750 million to spend I would put the vast bulk of it into early childhood education, literacy and numeracy at primary school etc.
The Herald reports:
The number of New Zealanders saving regularly has dropped in the past four years despite more than a quarter of adults joining KiwiSaver.
A Retirement Commission survey carried out in March and April has found that only 49 per cent of adults aged 18 and over are now saving regularly, down from 53 per cent in the commission’s first survey in 2005.
Although 29 per cent have joined KiwiSaver, this has been partly offset by declines from 23 per cent to 18 per cent in the numbers in personal superannuation schemes, and from 16 per cent to 14 per cent for those in workplace super schemes.
This is what some predicted may happen – KiwiSaver seems to be just changing the way people save, but not increasing the number of people who save.
The HoS approves of Chris Finlayson’s appointment of Peter Jackson to review the Film Commission:
It’s impossible to imagine anyone better qualified to undertake a review of the New Zealand Film Commission than the country’s most prodigiously successful filmmaker, Peter Jackson. The Minister for Arts Culture and Heritage, Chris Finlayson, announced this week that the maestro from Miramar will lead a ministerial review “to ensure it is best able to serve the needs of the local industry and community”.
In an ideal world, the commission would long ago have sought advice from one of the most successful filmmakers in history, especially since he is just round the corner. But that would have required some pride-swallowing – and a corporate decision to feed the hand that had bitten it.
Jackson, it will be remembered, has occasionally been a trenchant critic of the commission. He even publicly “disinvited” its then chief executive Ruth Harley and chairman Barrie Everard to the Wellington premiere of part two of the Lord of the Rings trilogy, calling them “self-serving bureaucrats”.
Jackson is not a diplomat.
The terms of reference are a mixture of bureaucratspeak (“facilitative role”; “cultural content objectives”) and noble-sounding phraseology, which are unlikely to bog down Jackson, who is a plain speaker and a man of action. The fact that he is charged with working out how “active industry professionals” can be more involved in setting the commission’s direction is heartening. And it is something he has plainly taken on board: pointedly, he has said he will consult local filmmakers, “so the review reflects the thoughts and opinions of the writers, producers and directors the commission was created to support”.
Bottom up consultation – always good.
Assuming that the review is sincerely motivated and that the Government is not looking for findings that will justify later funding cuts, Jackson’s presence is encouraging. The prolific moviemaker is not notably short of things to do, so he plainly thinks he has something to offer and will tackle the review with the passion and vision that are his trademarks.
The commission is now more than 30 years old: as John Barnett remarked this week, when it was established movies screened with intermissions and no one used the word “digital”. It is high time for a rethink – and there is no better man to be doing the rethinking.
The good thing about having Jackson do the review, is it will be almost impossible for the Government to ignore.
During late May and early June we had trumpeted that the honeymoon is over for the Government with the “week from hell” over Christine Rankin, Mt Albert mistakes, the Richard Worth affair, cancelled tax cuts etc.
Yet the Roy Morgan poll taken from 1 to 14 June finds no significant change in support for the Government and Opposition. National leads Labour by 19%. Also an increase in those saying NZ is heading in the right direction.
So if the honeymoon is over, I’d say National will be pretty happy with those post-honeymoon numbers.
The HoS reports:
A Government MP has been reprimanded for lewd conduct just weeks after the resignation of National’s Richard Worth.
Act MP David Garrett was spoken to by party leader Rodney Hide after making sexual comments to a female member of the party’s Parliamentary office.
Hide said last night he had cause to speak to Garrett after learning the fledgling MP had made “off-colour” remarks. He said he hoped the incident would not lead to the end of Garrett’s career as a member of Parliament. …
Hide said the matter could be escalated to the Parliamentary Service – which employs the staff member – if there was a formal complaint. He had met with the staff member to assure her any complaint she made would be handled properly.
Hide said Garrett was “a guy who has come from a rough, tough background”.
“I explained to him we set high standards in our Parliament across all parties.
“It is a learning experience in becoming an MP. I said it is good he can learn quickly – because he has to.”
Act president Michael Crozier said he had been unaware of the incident but expected a report to be made to the party’s board when it next met in a few weeks. “David has a lot to learn. He really hasn’t been in the Parliamentary side of politics before. You have to learn quick.”
University of Otago political scientist Bryce Edwards said Hide could not be faulted for his handling of the incident. But he said the incident was a “blow” for Act and the National Government.
Rodney sounds pretty unimpressed. As he said, you need to learn quickly what you can and can’t say when you are an MP. That’s one reason I’ll never be an MP – my sense of humour is far far too black to survive such a standard.
Took part in the annual Great Barrier Island polar plunge yesterday. I managed to stay in for the full ten minutes. Just before we all went in someone spotted a couple of fins and as we were debating sharks or dolphins, six dolphins appeared together literally surfing in on the waves. It was an amazing sight. They must have heard the noise on the beach and came close to show off.
After the plunge we were given hot pumpkin soup to thaw out.
This is the view from the house at Whangaparapara. Imagine waking up to that every morning?
Trevor Mallard is not getting a good strike rate with his allegations. Strike One was the allegations that Melissa Lee used taxpayer funds in 2008 to make an election advertisement. Strike Two was that Melissa Lee had pakred on a disabled car park.
The Herald reports on Strike Three:
The exchange turned testy when Mr Mallard, who is Labour’s education spokesman, accused her of giving an “inappropriate one-fingered gesture” across the floor of the House.
But Mr Mallard – who suggested Ms Bennett’s denial could be a breach of parliamentary privilege if TV film showed her making the gesture – was later forced to apologise to her.
Labour staffers rang him to say the film showed she had waved her hand without making the gesture.
So if Bennett’s denial (if incorrect) could be a preach of privilege, could an incorrect accusation also be a breach of privilege?
The Herald reports:
Mr Peters is writing a sports column for Sky Sport Magazine, and his first missive includes one of his trademark political lines: “Let’s get the facts straight about this.” …
Mr Peters’ “last post” column says the great institution of Maori rugby is being neglected. It draws on his personal experience as the captain of Auckland Maori and details the important contribution Maori teams have made to the game and society.
The writing contains several Winstonisms: “Work that out” (twice), “Unbelievable really” and “We need facts, not self-serving, egregious nonsense and attendant unfairness”.
Mr Peters is unable to resist a political swipe while criticising a new book on Maori rugby, Beneath the Maori Moon, by Malcolm Mullholland.
“Facts and words do matter and yet this publication disregards both, qualifying it more for the parliamentary press gallery than as an historic work on a great institution.”
Winston would be a great sports writer – and yes I am being serious. They should also make him a rugby commentator – would be superb.
Mr Peters would not be drawn on whether he would make a political comeback by running for the Auckland Super City mayoralty.
“Unless I say it, then nothing’s true.”
Some would argue the opposite 🙂
The Government will consider adopting a Green MP’s bill to prevent confusing and ambiguous referendum questions, Prime Minister John Key said today. …
Today Green MP Sue Bradford said she was hoping her bill to prevent confusing questions would be drawn out of the next ballot.
The Citizens Initiated Referenda (Wording of Question) Amendment Bill required the Clerk of the House to allow only referendum questions which were “not ambiguous, complex, leading or misleading”.
Where a question was not allowed a person would be able to re-write it until it met the criteria.
Firstly I am suspicious about all this sudden concern in the wording of referenda questions. There have been far more ambigious questions in the past. I suspect this is politicians finding reasons in advance to ignore the result of the referendum – because they know the public do not like the new law.
But putting aside the suspicious rationale, it is worth considering the merits of Bradford’s bill. On the face of it, it would make referenda more useful and hopefully harder to ignore.
But it does give huge powers to the Clerk of the House. Now the Clerk is not the sort of person who would abuse such powers but Bradford’s bill is asking her to make subjective judgements, not objective judgements. It is very subjective as to what is leading or misleading. Any decisions made by the Clerk could lead to political attacks on that office – and that would be regrettable.
Blogging will probably be lighter than normal over the next three weeks.
Don’t miss this. On Friday nights we always watch Homai Te Pakipaki on Maori Television. Last Friday I was floored by this kid. I wrote to Maori TV suggesting they get him up on YouTube – who needs Susan Boyle – and just got a reply saying done, already. I’ve just watched it again and it had the same powerful effect. Made me cry.
He is great – well worth a watch.
From Andrew Sullivan’s blog.
Today’s Dom Post Press editorial is on referenda wording, but that is not the focus of this post. Their editorial says:
Regrettably, although the Clerk of the House of Representatives has responsibility for overseeing the wording of referendums, his powers are limited. He must ensure only that the question clearly conveys the purpose and effect of the referendum and he must ensure that only one of two answers can be given to it. In this case those criteria are met. In future, however, if referendums are not going to be done away with entirely, some thought must be given to tightening the procedure for their wording.
The Dominion Post, of all newspapers, Press should be aware the Clerk is a she, not a he. And even if they did not, it would take ten seconds to check that Mary Harris is the Clerk.
UPDATE: Teach me to be pedantic – I got the newspaper wrong. It was not the Dom Post, but The Press.