Kirk confirms retirement

National Party President Judy Kirk has confirmed she will retire at National’s Annual Conference in August:

National Party President Judy Kirk has today confirmed she will step down from the position of President at the National Party’s Annual Conference in August.

“The Party is in great shape and well positioned for the future,” says Mrs Kirk.

“When I was elected President in 2002 the Party was facing very challenging times. But with the success at the 2008 General Election, I feel I have met all of my objectives in the role and that it is an appropriate time for me to step aside.

“I am very proud of my time as President and all that the Party has achieved over the last seven years, culminating in the election of the John Key National-led Government last November. I am absolutely confident that our Prime Minister and his cabinet will do a tremendous job for New Zealand.

Judy’s departure from office will be in stark contrast to Mike Williams, whose antics damaged Labour so badly during the campaign. As I blogged at the weekend:

Judy took over in 2002, and it has been a most sucessful six years under her presidency. The party vote has gone from 21% to 45%, but also the membership has soared to what I think is an 18 year high. Judy is well known for always stressing the importance of the party vote, and of members.

Judy’s six to seven years as President is the longest any President has served since I joined in 1986.

Which Labour MP once said this?

Comrades,

Let us never for get we are a socialist party. We stand oppossed to a capitalist system based upon the exploitation of the many by a few. …

We want socialism to be a reality in New Zealand. …

We should not be frightened of alarming wealthy business interests. …

Multinationals threaten our economic and political sovereignty …

It’s a wonderful speech, The MP also quotes W B Sutch.

Make your guesses as to who it was. They said this just five years before they were elected to Parliament.

Ngai Tahu infighting

Somewhat ironically (in terms of timing), tonight there is a function to commemorate the 10th anniversary of the Ngai Tahu settlement. I was very pleased to be invited, but sadly have a clash as I also have the AGM of the Institute of Directors tonight.

Ngai Tahu have achieved some great things with their settlement, and are a real economic powerhouse. However, as with any group, they are not immune from infighting and this current bout appears to be quite bad. It will be a shame if it detracts from their considerable achievements.

The Herald reports on the latest episode, being some impolite e-mails from Ngai Tahu Chair Mark Solomon, which have upset some in his local runanga.  Solomon may not survive, due to anger at the sacking of Wally Stone who chaired the Holding Corporation.

Busted Blonde at Roar Prawn, who is Ngai Tahu, has been covering the issues in depth – she is firmly in the camp calling for Solomon to go.

Of a different view is Richard Parata – a former Director of Ngai Tahu Holdings Corporation. He responds to BB here.

A common border

I’m a fan of there being a common border with Australia, so one can travel between the two countries as if it was a domestic flight. It is great, in Europe, being able to cross country borders with no passport checks etc.

Ironically I’m just old enough to remember being able to travel to Australia without a passport – the requirement to have one only came about in the early 80s I think.

Anyway good t0 see Rudd and Key wanting to make a decision this year on a common border – rather than wait until 2015.

Nine to Noon Politics

Today’s politics segment with Laila Harre, Matthew Hooton and Kathryn Ryan was a very interesting lesson. I enjoy it because both participants are willing to praise MPs from the otehr side of the spectrum, and disagree with MPs from their own side.

I found Laila Harre’s words today very interesting, especially as Laila has been a Minister in a Labour-led Government and is the head of the reasonably militant National Distribution Union:

I have to say sitting through the summit, I found it difficult to imagine the Labour Party under Helen Clark really taking a risk like that which was to give a group of people an open brief in a very public way to propose some ideas and solutions. …

I don’t think there was ever a willingness [by Labour] to take those kinds of risk. … Labour’s objective at the Knowledge Wave conference was to keep it as tight as possible.

I actually felt that in terms of my political experience anyway this was the first time I personally been engaged in a genuinely tripartite process at a New Zealand level … I’ve never seen anything looking like that in New Zealand.

That’s generous praise. It shows that you can disagree with some of John Key’s policies but praise him for his leadership style which is very different to what we have had in the past.

Both Hooton and Harre praise the national cycleway proposal.

Hooton also ripped into borrowing $2 billion a year to stick into a savings fund. Harre declares she has never been much of a supporter of the Fund as future superannuation provision will always depend on economic health of country. Says it is a no brainer to suspend contributions.

Hooton also says the 2010 and 2011 tax cuts should not occur if we still have large deficits. I think it all depends on how large the deficits are, and how sucessful one has been in clipping low priority spending. At this stage, it is very premature to be making declarations, as Matthew does, about the future tax cuts. The time to decide would be early 2010. And from my point of view suspending or cancelling the tax cuts would be your last resort – only if the deficit was on a track to disaster.

Vatican rejects apology

Reuters reports:

The Vatican has rejected an apology from a bishop whose denial of the Holocaust caused international uproar between Jews and Catholics, saying it did not meet its demand for a full and public recanting.

Good.

Williamson told Swedish television in an interview broadcast on Jan. 21, “I believe there were no gas chambers”. He said no more than 300,000 Jews perished in Nazi concentration camps, rather than the 6 million accepted by mainstream historians.

In his statement on Thursday, Williamson said, “I can truthfully say that I regret having made such remarks, and that if I had known beforehand the full harm and hurt to which they would give rise, especially to the Church, but also to survivors and relatives of victims of injustice under the Third Reich, I would not have made them.”

Yes he has apologised only for the hurt, not for the views. I also found it interesting he could not bring himself to mention “Jews” in his apology. That would be too much for an anti-semite.

I’ve now worked out why he is such an anti-semite:

The row over Williamson has led many to take a closer look at the SSPX, its view of Jews and its future in the Church.

The Vatican says that before the SSPX can be fully readmitted into the Church, its leaders and members must first accept the teachings of the 1962-1965 Second Vatican Council, which urged respect for Judaism and other religions.

One of its key documents, “Nostra Aetate” (In Our Times), repudiated the concept of collective Jewish guilt for Christ’s death.

This explains a lot. He actually believes the Jews did kill Jesus and are collectively guilty for it. What a nutter.

Little confirmed as President

Voxy reports:

Labour Leader Phil Goff today warmly welcomed Andrew Little as the new president of the New Zealand Labour Party.

Mr Little, national secretary of the Engineering, Printing and Manufacturing Union, was elected unopposed today. He takes over from Mike Williams, who has retired after eight years in the role.

“The election of Andrew Little to the role of party president is a significant step in the renewal process taking place in the Labour Party since the last election.

Andrew is doing the job on top of his duties as EPMU National Secretary, and is a declared candidate for 2011 (or before). So which current MP said this in 1976:

“We need a dedicated and full-time president and secretary neither of whom should be an MP or have parliamentary ambitions. These positions are important in their own right.”

The answer is over the break.

Continue reading »

Life in prison

The National Post has an interview with Conrad Black about life in a Florida prison. He describes his typical day:

I get up just after 7 except on the weekends and holidays when it is possible to sleep in. I eat some granola and go to my workplace where I tutor high school-leaving candidates, one-on-one, though sometimes I have to deal with up to four at a time, around my desk, and talk with fellow tutors and other convivial people. I lunch around 11 with friends from education, work on e-mails, play the piano for 30 to 60 minutes, return to my tutoring tasks by 1, return to my unit at 3, deal with more e-mails, rest from 4 to 6, eat dinner in the unit then, and go for a walk in the compound or recreation yard for a couple of hours, drinking coffee well-made by Colombian fellow-residents, and come back into the residence about 8:30, deal with e-mails and whatever, have my shower etc., around midnight, read until 1-1:30 a.m. and go to sleep. On the weekends it is pretty open.

Sounds quite nice doesn’t it?

Hat Tip: B K Drinkwater

CYF taking babies at birth

The Dom Post reports:

Child, Youth and Family took 66 at-risk babies less than a month old into its care last year and 15 of them were taken the day they were born.

In more than half of the cases, older brothers and sisters were already in care, figures provided to The Dominion Post under the Official Information Act show.

The number of custody orders involving newborns has more than doubled in the past five years. In the 2003-04 year, 32 were taken into state care.

And I say good on them – the kids may grow up safe. Parents with a history of child abuse, do not have a right to keep inflicting misery.

I am reminded of the pregnant 14 year old who has twice been arrested for drink driving. I find it impossible to believe she could safely raise her children – even if they survive the pregnancy.

I am reminded of the words of a friend of mine who is a journalist. She described how she cried when she heard Antonie Dixon had killed himself. She attended his trials, and explained she didn’t cry for the sociopathic killer he had become, but for the tortured abused childhood he had to endure.

It was a salient reminder that so much of our crime (and “underclass”) is due to abusive childhoods, and that we need to be more aggressive in protecting at risk kids. And no, that does not mean passing an anti-smacking law – which was a gaint distraction from the real problem.

Police bars

Kate Newton in the Dom Post has an article on Police drinking culture and Police bars:

Stations built since 2005 do not have bars, but there are still 28 police bars throughout New Zealand and new stations can have beer fridges or liquor cabinets.

The price of alcohol sold at police bars varies from station to station, but is generally cheaper than at a public bar. Wellington Central police station bar sells beer for about $3 a stubbie.

Boisterous jug sessions are still a part of police culture after shifts and are used by general duties staff to unwind from the rigours of the job and to help bond the team.

The sessions usually involve “punishing” officers for minor indiscretions by forcing them to down beer.

Police Association president Greg O’Connor has defended the bars, saying they are a safer environment for police to have a few drinks than at the local pub.

I think it is unrealistic to see policing as a job where you just go home on the bus at the end of the day. Police work is often very shitty work. You are at constant risk of being assaulted. Your life can literally depend on your colleagues. You work shifts at all hours of the day and night. You are battling criminals with your colleagues, so obviously form strong bonds with them.

I have no problems that Police officers when off duty will bond over alcohol, and yes it will be quite boozy. It is unrealistic to expect much else.

What I do expect is that they will not drive home drunk. This is where the Police seem to still have a problem, with the controversy over the Superintendant who refused a breath test once he was home.

So I say to the Police – party away. But grab a taxi at the end of the day.

Unions plan “name and shame” campaign

The CTU is planning a “name and shame” campaign against employers that “exploit” workers under the new trial period law.

I don’t actually have a problem with this. Community reaction is one of the factors that is an influence on business decisions.

The vast majority of businesses will use the law responsibily. Many will not even ask for such trial periods in contracts, and generally there is no logicial incentive to dump a new employee if they are performing well. It costs money and time to recruit and train staff. The notion that there will be masses of employers sacking new workers on Day 89, just because they can, is ridicolous.

However there are some bad employers out there. They actually piss me off a lot, because it is the “bad” employers who lead to calls to regulate this and regulate that.

If an employer really does “exploit” a new employee, sacking them on whim, then unions have every right to highlight this.

But I would warn the unions to be careful about assuming all, or even most, dismissals during the 90 day period are “exploitive”.  That new sales rep may have proved unable to make any sales. That new cleaner may just be generating too many complaints from clients. Or that new staffer might just be an arsehole who is disrupting everyone else in the office.

In the end, what I am saying is each situation should be judged on the facts, not just given a pre-determined label.

Mallard’s prosecutor

I suspect Trevor Mallard enjoyed this weekend story:

An accountant who brought a private prosecution against former Cabinet minister Trevor Mallard has been ordered to serve six months’ home detention for tax fraud involving almost $50,000. …

McCready pleaded guilty to 12 charges of filing false income and GST returns and filing a false income tax return to evade payment. He had originally pleaded “absolutely, positively not guilty” to a larger number of charges, changing his plea on the first day of trial last month. …

Lawyer Noel Sainsbury said that, though it might be true McCready did not leave his home much, detention still was a barrier to his liberty.

Home detention as a punishment for someone who doesn’t leave their home much. Hmmmn.

Editorials on Super Fund

Two differing editorials on the Super Fund. The Herald sort of supports maitaining contributions:

The fund has lost the last two years’ worth of contributions in the downturn.

But it needs to be remembered that these losses exist only on paper.

It is easy to say they are only paper losses, but the fact remains that the Fund has earnt less money since it started, that one would have got by paying off debt. It is about opportunity cost. The Fund has actually left NZ less well positioned to pay for future superannuation.

Equally, it is misleading to single out the fund when talking of borrowing. It is simply part of the Government’s spending programme, some of which will be funded by tax and some by resort to the debt market. It would be just as rational to talk of tax cuts, or health or education for that matter, being funded by borrowing.

I disagree with this analysis. The Fund is not just another type of spending. It was set up specifically to be funded out of surplus income – the whole idea was to save money now to prevent having to borrow it later. It was never about borrowing money now to save.

It is important to stress that this whole question is about payments into the fund, not payments out. It is highly irresponsible of the Labour Party leader to suggest that the level of pensions might be at risk, now or in the future. This fund, as Phil Goff well knows, will do no more than partially fund future pensions when the bulk of the baby-boom moves into retirement.

Here we agree.

The Government needs to estimate whether the accumulated debt from borrowing to make a contribution this year would nullify the fund’s likely earnings on the borrowed sum over the next decade.

By this logic, if the Government thinks it can make more in the fund, than the cost of borrowing, it should borrow say $50 billion, and that way make heaps of money.

The ODT starts better:

At first glance, it defies logic to borrow money in order to save, so those commentators now calling for payments to the New Zealand Superannuation Fund to be suspended – either indefinitely or until the economy turns around and the country is once again able to run budget surpluses – are advocating from a position of some strength.

When the country is stretched, as it is likely to be in the coming months when the worst effects of the recession hit home, with businesses failing, unemployment figures rising and true hardship beginning to reveal itself on our urban street-corners, can the Government really afford to be putting $2 billion worth of liquidity away into a leaking piggy bank – and to be borrowing for the privilege? In such times of economic hardship, the answer would appear to be a firm “no”, but then for some economists and politicians, the concept of a super fund was always undesirable and illogical.

Absolutely the answer is no.

Labour opposes a suspension of payments, as do others who argue for a long-term investment view.

Just as many ordinary householders pay mortgages and at the same time save for their own superannuation through investments in bonds and equities – when economic orthodoxy suggests they would be better off ridding themselves of the mortgage first – it does not necessarily follow that governments should never borrow to save.

This is a false analogy. The key difference is the Household is in surplus. In fact it is so much in surplus it is able to pay its bills, save for the future and repay debt. This is very different to the Government that is so badly in deficit it is having to borrow billions just to pay the day to day bills.

If a government is able to borrow at a low interest rate, and with a reasonable degree of certainty predict a generous margin on the return, might this not make sense?

As I said above, why stop at $2 billion a year. Let borrow trillions and make ourselves all really rich.

The argument that S92A is needed for free trade agreements

Steven Joyce is quoted in the Herald as saying:

“I completely understand where people are coming from on both sides of the debate,” says Joyce – speaking before the delay was announced – “but there are some wider trade-offs for the country around this stuff as well.” Overseas trade agreements require New Zealand to have such a law, although he thinks the Labour-led government, which passed the Act in its dying days, went too far.

Several people have made this argument, but it is overlooking a rather salient point – namely that we do not have an FTA with the United States – in fact we are not even in the queue to have one. And as far as I know, no current FTA or treaty requires us to have such a law.

So let us look at what will happen, if one day the US does sit down to negotiate a FTA with NZ. It is quite correct that the US will demand our laws reflect the demands of their intellectual property industry.

But think of the damage we have done to our negotiating ability, by already giving them everything they wanted – before we even are in the frame for an FTA.

If we ever do get to negotiate an FTA, this is what you want:

US Govt: Now we turn to your intellectual property laws. We want you to force ISPs to terminate Internet users who we think infringe copyright from our struggling Hollywood music and movie studios.

Tim Groser: Well that will be very unpopular back home. Our Government would get a lot of flak for that.

US Govt: But this is crucial. We insist that you have such laws.

Tim Groser: Well I can try selling this to Cabinet and Parliament, but I need some real wins to counter it.

US Govt: Like what.

Tim Groser: Well this will piss off around 80% of NZ – every NZers who uses the Internet. That is around 3 million people. Now you have only 1.2 million beef farmers and 1.5 million sheep farmers, so if you agree to all tariffs on beef and lamb disappearing by 2015, then I think I can sell this back home.

US Govt: Good try. We can’t do 2015, but how about lamb goes to zero tariff by 2018 and beef by 2023.

Tim Groser: I think we have a deal

You get the general idea. You don’t give away one of your strongest negotiating points, years in advance of even negotiating the free trade agreement. That is not in NZ’s national interest.

Obama’s Budget

I thought Obama had been doing pretty good so far in his term to date. But when it comes to his budget, I think it looks to be a disaster of gigantic proportions.

Here are some key facts on the budget:

  • The projected deficit of $1.75 trillion is four times larger than the next largest deficit in history
  • The $3.6 trillion of expenditure represents the Federal Government spending around US$25,000 on behalf of every American man, woman and child.
  • The deficit is almost 50% of government expenditure. So around half of what Obama is spending, he will borrow money for.
  • The deficit will be around 12% of GDP. That makes our projected deficits look minor – would be like a NZ$25 billion deficit
  • The budget is actually a “rosy” scenario, with an assumed 3.2% economic growth next year.

I think this budget may doom Obama to being a one term President. It is a massive increase in spending, that is quite literally unfunded.

Now let it be said that Bush was also a fiscal disaster. He also failed to restrain spending much. The best recent President in terms of achieving a balanced budget was Bill Clinton.

Of course Obama may not get his budget through Congress. The Republicans are geared to fight this, and many of the moderate Democrats will be worried about having to justify this in 2010 elections.

Three Strikes Law may breach Bill of Rights

The Herald reports that the Attorney-General has advised that the “three strikes” bill breaches the Bill of Rights. That will be one of the factors National will grapple with in deciding whether to support it beyond select committee.

I’m not sure on this, but wouldn’t the AG have given his advice at the time of introduction or first reading? I’m wondering why it has just now been reported. Mind you, the advice is not yet available on the Ministry of Justice site.

As Attorney-General, Mr Finlayson is required to report any bill that appears inconsistent with the Bill of Rights.

His concerns relate to the inconsistencies it would lead to, such as “the imposition of a life sentence for offences that would otherwise be subject to a penalty of as little as five years”.

This is of course deliberate. The intent of the three strikes law is basically a value judgement that if you have committed a third crime that is so bad, it results in a sentence of at least five years, then you are judged likely to carry on offending indefinitely. The third strike is designed not so much to punish, but to protect the public.

The select committee hearings will be vigorous I am sure.

UPDATE: I’ve been informed that the Attorney-General’s advice was tabled when the bill was introduced – so this story is now some new info. Also the advice may not yet be on the MOJ website, but it is on the Parliament site.

Basic errors on One News

Some incredibly basic facts wrong with the One News story on the trial periods law. The presenter said:

It means bosses can sack employees after a 90 day probation period

Three massive errors in just one sentence.

  1. It is during, not after the 90 day probation period. There is a massive difference.
  2. No mention at all that it only refers to businesses with under 50 20 staff, which excludes off memory around 40% of workers
  3. Also no mention that it is not in any way automatic. The law merely provides that an employer can seek to have such a clause in an employment contract. Many employers will not.

The combination of those three errors is grossly misleading.

Then even worse they have a long-term beneficiary (he has mild autism) saying he is desperate for a job, and that somehow this will make it more difficult for him. In fact it is the opposite – it means an employer can give him a chance (despite his autism) without risking a costly personal grievance if it does not work out.

Then One News goes on to call it the “hire and fire” law, a term used only be opponents of the law.

A pretty disgraceful piece of journalism. The opening sentence alone would almost be worth a BSA complaint. The other stuff is of course debatable, but the openeing sentence was flat out incorrect.

The true cost of Dr Cullen’s train set

One News tonight has revealed the true cost of Dr Cullen’s train set. The purchase price was a massive $690million.

On top of that we have $473 million of subsidies needed over the next five years, $764 million of upgrades and $275 million for metro services.

So all up that is $2.202 billion!!

Thanks Michael. No wonder the Aussies refer to the sale as “Sale of the Century”. It will be that long until the next time they find some Kiwis stupid enough!

Blog Bits

  1. NBR Editor Nevil Gibson blogs about the Jobs Summit (which he attended) and the beatup over Swazi.
  2. Steven Price says that s92A did not mean guilt by accusation. I disagree with him, but agree that the solution should be some sort of dispute resolution scheme.
  3. MacDoctor does an excellent fisking of the claims that drinking causes cancer.
  4. And Aaron Bhatnagar also fisks claims by City Vision in Auckland.
  5. Chris Trotter defends Wanganui staying Wanganui, saying that even if the name was originally spelt differently, most names change over time and are not invalid for that.
  6. Poneke blogs that some very ungrateful passengers (probably due to “grasping lawyers”) are trying to sue US Airways for trauma over Flight 1549 where Captain Sullenberger saved all their lives after a bird strike. Incidentially anyone who has not seen the Katie Couris interview with Sullennberger should – a must see – especially when they reunite passengers and crew.
  7. No Right Turn is outraged at the Police cover up over a senior office refusing a breath test. I agree.

Editorials on first 100 days

Both The Press and the ODT review the first 100 days. The Press says:

In reality the Government has ticked off most, if not all, of its promises about what it would do in its 100 days of action.

About half a dozen of these pledges have been in the law and order area, including the introduction to Parliament of high-profile feel-good measures to tighten parole for repeat violent offenders and to curb the drug trading by gangs. But the Government has also made good on its vows to pass its tax package, introduce a bill to reform the Resource Management Act, review state sector spending and pass a relief package for those made redundant. In addition, it has honoured health and education promises, including the voluntary bonding system for teachers, doctors, nurses and certain other medical staff.

For good measure it has repealed Labour’s perfidious Electoral Finance Act, which was one of the most undemocratic laws passed in recent New Zealand history.

And we must remain vigilant against future attempts.

The ODT:

The progress to date, however, shows a Government with impressive energy and a single-minded focus that belies Mr Key’s easy-going manner.

I remember all those on the left proclaiming Clark would destroy Key in the campaign, and how even if he won he would be a weak and vacuous Prime Minister. They seem to have gone quiet.

For it is the Opposition that seems frozen in the headlights of the looming economic juggernaut.

In times of imminent crisis, conventional wisdom requires a degree of national unity and in meeting this expectation the Labour Party in particular has appeared unremarkable.

The news of Helen Clark’s application to a top United Nations post and rumours of Michael Cullen’s possible early departure cannot have helped.

But it should also be noted that the country seems genuinely to be enjoying the change from the managerialism of Miss Clark to the affability of Mr Key.

This has put Labour Party leader Phil Goff in a difficult position, reflected in the party’s terrible recent polls: damned if they do rail against policies, many of which do not differ hugely from their own, and damned if they don’t.

Mr Goff also suffers by the closeness of his association with Miss Clark, and a similar personality: a highly competent politician, but lacking the easy charisma of the prime minister.

Goff is highly competent. But different skills are needed as a Minister and as Opposition Leader. He needs to stop lecturing the Government on what he would do if it was him.

Free Trade prospects

The reason we will be hit hard by the global recession is our trading partners are going to buy less of our exports.

Hence it is very good news that despite the recession, NZ is making good steps towards reducing trade barriers. Trade Minister Tim Groser is earnign his pay!

The agreement to start FTA negotiations with India is exciting, but of more immediate impact is the signing of an FTA with Asean nations, initiated by the previous Government.

Trade Minister Tim Groser, who was in Thailand to sign the agreement negotiated under the previous government, said 99 per cent of New Zealand’s trade to those countries would be duty-free within 12 years. When fully implemented, it would mean annual duty savings of about $50 million.

The real gain isn’t just the savings, but also that it prevents those countries hiking up tariffs against us, as a protectionist measure. The current tariffs are quite low, but as I understand it could be lifted to up to 50% before this agreement takes force.

Two Electoral Commission decisions

Two interesting decisions by the Electoral Commission.

The first is hilarious. It is about Richard Green pruning his hedge so it displays “Green”. Yes the EFA even covers hedges. Some quotes:

The hedge does not appear to contain a promoter statement, and there is no evidence that the publication of the hedge was authorised by the financial agent for the Green Party. Therefore if the hedge is an election advertisement then the failure to provide a promoter statement and to have authorisation in writing for that publication would appear to contravene sections 63(2) and 65(1).

Heh, imagine a hedge having to have a promoter statement.

Luckily for Mr Green, the Electoral Commission decided any breach was not wilful, and even if it was, not significant. Interestingly, they didn’t actually determine whether or not the hedge was an election advertisement or not!

Then we have the late disclosure of donations from the Family Party – as previously covered here:

The Family Party have been referred to the Police for possible prosecution. This may be seen as a bit unfair, as the Greens got off for a similiar offence. However that was in the early days of the EFA, and the Commission points to an explicit notice to political parties in May reminding them of the need to report donations that aggregate to more than $20,000 within ten days.

Whether the Police prosecute is another issue. To date the Police have not prosecuted for any offence referred to them.

Ralston on promises

Bill Ralston writes in the HoS:

The first 100 days programme was all about looking competent and appearing to honour National’s election promises.

Sadly, most of those promises were made in an entirely different pre-election economic climate when it seemed like we could afford them.

Still, Key seems determined to stick by those pledges even if it makes Bill English’s job harder when writing the next Budget.

As long as the Government doesn’t back away from its promised tax cuts it will survive even the blackest budget that English may have to devise.

In these times families are looking forward to even a small amount of tax relief and it is the one promise National cannot afford to break.

The Government can take a holiday on making contributions to the Super Fund. It can even axe the damn thing and nick the fast diminishing $12 billion to further boost the economy.

Most people won’t mind the loss of an abstract concept involving billions of bucks.

They will spit the dummy if they find the Government reneges on giving them that extra $20 a week.

Indeed.

There is of course a set of circumstances, where the out year tax cuts would be reconsidered. When everything else has been tried, spending reduced and the deficit still is unacceptably high, threatening the future.  The OBEGAL needs to be able to move back into surplus over time.

Bit what is pathetic is all the commentators and editorials demanding that the tax cits be surrendered immediately – before the Government has even started to make an impact cutting waste, reconsidering contributions to the Super Fund etc etc.

Even the HoS editorial today does the usual job of advocating they should go, and ignoring the reality that National’s extra tax cuts were fully funded by spending cuts:

It is almost dishonest, when people advocate that the tax cuts can not be afforded, without mentioning that National’s tax cuts were fully funded by cutting spending on KiwiSaver – something which actually will help reduce the impact of the recession as the KiwiSaver subsidies would have removed the money from the economy, while the tax cuts will see most of it spent.