Power against raising drinking age

Very pleased to see balanced and sensible view from Simon Power on alcohol issues:

“But in the end we have to ask ourselves how broad an issue this is when it is such a critical part of offending and if you want to drive the crime rate down in New Zealand you can’t do that without having a discussion about alcohol,” he told Radio New Zealand.

Of course. The challenge is how you target those who can not handle alcohol, without needlessly interfering with the vast majority who can enjoy a night on the town without incidence.

“I don’t think that you can have a serious discussion about reducing offending in New Zealand without asking yourself some serious questions about the proliferation of liquor licensing in New Zealand.”

One has to be careful to generalise. I don’t think the fact that many cafes now serve wine, or you can have a beer at Downstage is creating problems.

Mr Power said he did not personally believe raising the drinking age is the answer to the problems.

The issues of parental responsibility and education were important and raising the purchasing age did not deal with the issue of drinking in homes.

Absolutely. I tend to favour a law change that targets irresponsible supply of alcohol to minors. It would be hard to word, but worth doing in my opinion.

“I can’t be convinced that you need to walk into a bar for the first time at 3 o’clock in the morning to have a drink. It just seems to me that the range of hours that we’re making alcohol available are very very wide.

I don’t think many people get their first drink at 3 am. However if one is having a night out dancing in Courtenay Place, then you are still going at 3 am. Maybe you could have bars remain open, but not serve alcohol – but realistically they won’t stay open if they are not making enough money to pay wages and costs.

Orr on Super Fund

NZ Super Fund CEO Adrian Orr has an op ed in the Herald. Interestingly the Herald notes he won’t do an interview with them – only an op ed.

Before I respond, I should make clear that I think the Fund’s “Guardians” have generally done an excellent job. The fact the fund has made less money than we would have got by paying off debt, is because of the global economic recession – not because of bad decisions by the fund managers. All funds have been hit.

They key issue for me is whether one should borrow money to invest in the Fund, when the whole rationale for the Fund was that it would be “surplus” funds that gets invested. Anyway Orr says:

Investing for future retirement income is just one activity the Government does. It is equally valid to talk of government borrowing in order to fund tax cuts, or pay for schools and hospitals. All of these activities are funded through tax revenue and borrowing. This is an everyday practice across households, businesses and governments globally. In fact, the New Zealand Government has done well, with one of the lowest government net debt positions in the OECD.

I think this is somewhat misleading. Investing in the Super Fund is not a core Government activity such as paying for schools. It was set up specifically on the premise that it would be funded out of operating surpluses. It is not just a competing expenditure like schools.

And if you look at th Treasury accounts, the contributions to the Fund are not expenditure. They are shown as the line after the Operating Balance, which is now heaving negative.

The Government has been running a public debt programme throughout the entire life of the fund. The fact that the Government’s operating accounts have gone into deficit makes no difference to the investment proposition of the fund.

I disagree. Borrowing to pay for capital expenditure is very different to borrowing for operating expendiiture. Let’s use a household example.

Household A has income of $100,000 a year and expenses of $60,000. So it has a surplus of $40,000.  It decides to borrow $400,000 to buy a house. So it is taking on debt, but it is running a surplus to allow that debt to be paid back. Hence while not stictly rational, it is quite reasonable that it may stick $10,000 of its surplus into a savings account and $30,000 into debt payments.

Household B has income of $70,000 a year as the husband has lost his job. And their expenses are $80,000 a year. And they still owe $200,000 on their mortgage. So every year they have to borrow $10,000 to just pay the household bills, and borrow $20,000 to meet the interest on the mortgage. Now in this scenario, would you also borrow a further $10,000 to stick into a savings account? Of course not.

The fund is a simple concept. The Government has legislated to invest money today to gain a return over the long term. That return is to be used in the future to smooth the tax burden of the rising cost of superannuation income.

Yes but it is not going to smooth the tax burden anymore. If we have a decade of deficits and debt, then we will still need to massivley increase taxes in the future to pay for it.

One measure of financial success is whether the returns to the fund over decades (not randomly selected days, weeks, months, or year-to-year) are above the cost of government borrowing.

Yes, and sadly the returns over the entire life-time of the Fund are around half the cost of borrowing. Now this is not the fault of the Guardians, but a consequence of the recession. But it is a fact.

When it comes to saving for the future, there is no free lunch. If we don’t save now the retirement payments time bomb in the future simply grows.

Borrowing to save, is not saving. It is like me borrowing $10,000 on the credit cards and claiming I am a saver as I have $5,000 in a low interest savings account.

A government is in a great position to benefit from investing over decades, more so than any individual. It can focus on the long term and, hence, make investment decisions not available to many. It can capture this premium. It has the ability to ride out the tough patches and avoid “fire sales”.

Here I agree. Mind you the Iceland Government might not.

Right now, the earnings prospects for long-term investors have also just improved significantly. This is especially so for a young Super Fund like ours, with the weight of money ahead. The global recession has seen asset prices fall and the rewards for accepting investment risk rise to historical levels.

This is probably right, but have we hit the bottom of the market? I’m not at all sure. I think Europe is looking very vulnerable.

That’s not to say investment opportunities may be better again in 12 or 24 months’ time. But, as long as we are able to buy more as value opportunities arise, and not be forced to sell assets at “fire sale prices”, we will succeed in our task. History also teaches us that the best time for investment returns is after significant downward corrections. We must make sure NZ is positioned to benefit whenever this occurs. Stopping out now would ensure we suffer the downside and miss the inevitable leg up.

And in 24 months or so, maybe contributions could be restarted (if they are ever suspended – who knows what the Govt will do).  But until the Government can start to make inroads on reducing the deficit, so it tracks back to a surplus at some stage, I would rather have lower debt by not making contributions.

UPDATE: Brian Fallow makes similiar arguments to Orr in his column today. I think he is wrong also :-). He also argues that investign in the Fund is just liek any other sort of expenditure and that you not argue it is all being borrowed. Again I disagree – the contributions were designed to be funded out of operating surpluses.

City Vision campaigns for higher rates

The Herald reports that Auckland City Council is joining the list of organisations that recognise the severity of the economic recession, and have pledged to keep overall salary levels constant.

But City Vision is upset:

The freeze has upset the left-leaning City Vision ticket and the Public Service Association, which represents 500 council staff.

“This council has no moral right to penalise workers to keep rates down,” said City Vision councillor Cathy Casey.

Says it all really. Cr Casey not only wants higher rates for “workers”, but also for herself:

City Vision believes staff should get a pay rise this year and wants councillors to take a 3 per cent pay increase from the Remuneration Authority.

What part of recession is so hard to understand. Thousands of Aucklanders are going to be losing their jobs and their income, and Cr Casey wants to make it even harder for them to be able to pay their rates.

Pruning ACC

The Government is reported as looking to end free physiotherapy and medical misadventure claims, in an attempt to protect employees from having to hand over an extra $27 a week into ACC.

I have always believed very few things should be free (to the user) – it totally fucks up the normal incentives around deciding on how necessary something is. Free physio is a perfect example of why this is so:

The free service was budgeted to cost $8.9 million extra a year when it was introduced in 2004.

But physiotherapy costs had gone from $58 million a year then to a projected $139 million this financial year.

Dr Smith said these costs were expected to increase further, to $225 million by 2011/12.

So the cost of physio has increased 800% more than projected since being made free.

But is it paying for itself by a healthier workforce:

Officials had told him there was no evidence the free physiotherapy service had increased rehabilitation rates as it was intended to do.

But maybe it has to stay free, to help poor people:

Since becoming free, use of the service had “occurred disproportionately in higher socio-economic areas”.

Nope.

Other free things that should go are interest free student loans (but not this term as have promised not to) and free off peak travel for pesnioners.

I have heard stories of transport operators milking the free off peak travel programme. You see they get paid for every person who travels. So the are spending huge amounts of money advertising to pensioners to come travel for “free”, as a way to boost income for them.

A lot of the problems in the tertiary sector with scam courses would have been solved with even a minimal $100 minimum free for every course.

Anyway back to ACC:

Up to 50 extra ACC entitlements introduced by Labour were being reviewed.

They included those introduced last year, such as cover for mental injury arising from traumatic workplace events and weekly compensation for seasonal and casual employees.

Dr Smith said he would be making changes to the ACC board – chaired by former union leader Ross Wilson – which “needed a fresh start”.

There was an “underlying culture issue within ACC in that it has shifted from being an insurance operator to being more of a welfare system”.

And then of course we have Labour:

Labour’s ACC spokesman, David Parker, said the changes would force New Zealanders to take out private accident insurance or pay from their own pockets for entitlements the Government cut.

Umm Mr Parker – if the employee levy increases to 4% of gross income, then that is going to take a shit load of money from NZers pockets. As detailed:

* An average household earning $67,028 with two cars now pays $938 a year for the earner’s levy and $510 for motor vehicle levy – a total of $1448.
* In 2013, National says the same household will pay $2681 for the earner’s levy and $1170 for the motor vehicle – a total of $3851.
* National says the household will face a total increase of $2403 a year ($46 a week) in ACC levies.

So Labour is happy with the average household being whacked for $46 a week more. That’s real caring.

Back Benches tonight

I won’t make it as I have too much work on, but for those in Wellington who can attend, the panelists tonight are:

  • Rodney Hide (ACT)
  • Metira Turei (Greens)
  • David Bennett (National)
  • Darren Hughes (Labour)

Topics are the Jobs Summit, youth violence and KiwiRail.

Starts around 9 pm at the Backbencher.

ACC costs out of control

acccosts

This graph shows it all – the massive blowout in costs under Labour of ACC.

The liability for these costs has just been reported as increasing by $2.58 billion. What does this mean, if no changes are made:

  • An 185% increase over five years of the levy on employees
  • A 71% increase for employers
  • A 129% increase for motor vehicle owners
  • Over five years this would see someone on the average wage who owns a vehicle paying $1,696 a year more.

So Labour’s Acc liability will take more from the average household, than they would have got from Labour’s tax cuts. Remember you never win with Labour.

Foreshore & Seabed Act may be toast

Attorney-General Chris Finlayson has announced the members of the panel to review the Foreshore & Seabed Act. They are:

  • former High Court judge and Waitangi Tribunal chair Justice Edward Taihakurei Durie
  • barrister Richard Boast, an Associate Professor at Victoria University specialising in property law and Maori legal issues
  • Hana O’Regan, an educationalist specialising in Maori culture and identity

The panel’s job TOR is to determine:

a) What were the nature and extent of the mana whenua and public interests in the coastal marine area prior to Attorney-General v Ngati Apa [2003] 3 NZLR 643

b) What options were available to the government to respond to the Court of Appeal decision in Attorney-General v Ngati Apa [2003] 3 NZLR 643

c) Whether the Foreshore and Seabed Act 2004 effectively recognises and provides for customary or aboriginal title and public interests (including Maori, local government and business) in the coastal marine area and maintains and allows for the enhancement of mana whenua

d) If the Panel has reservations that the Foreshore and Seabed Act does not provide for the above, outline options on what could be the most workable and efficient methods by which both customary and public interests in the coastal marine area could be recognised and provided for; and in particular,
how processes of recognising and providing for such interests could be streamlined

Now without in any way suggesting the three panelists will pre-judge the issue, and not do a thorough job, I would be amazed if a panel including Judge Durie and Hana O’Regan came back at the end of the day and said “Yes we agree the best thing for the Government to have done was to legislate away the rights of Maori to test claims to title in court”.  That is highly unlikely.

The panel is to report by 30 June 2009, and the Government has said they will make decisions by the 31 December 2009.

I will not be surprised if we see a Foreshore & Seabed Repeal Act in 2010, and a very happy Maori Party.

Of course agreeing to repeal it is the easy part. What you replace it with, is considerably harder.

Medical Ethics

An article full of revelations appeared on Monday by Shaun Holt on medical ethics in NZ. He explains:

As an experienced medical researcher and an ex-member of an ethics committee, I am likely to know about the ethical requirements of medical research. Last year I submitted an application for a simple study to see if honey could help treat a common skin infection in children that is otherwise very difficult to treat. Only 15 children were required for the study, and all the caregivers had to do was to apply the honey, cover with a dressing and see if it seemed to help.

Sounds about as simple as you can get. It is 1,000 miles away from let’s not treat this women for cervical cancer so we can see how effective the treatment is.

In order to apply to the ethics committee, I had to consult a Maori health provider to make sure there were no cultural issues if any Maori children took part and see a justice of the peace to sign a statutory declaration.

The application itself needed around 9000 words to complete and over 350 pages had to be submitted. For a study which could not be any simpler and had almost no chance of causing any harm, the application process took longer than doing the study would have.

This is the first stage of distress. Consulting a Maori health provider should not be mandatory – common sense should apply. And God forbid how you need 350 pages for such a simple study. Think of not only the cost to the healthcare system, but also the research that never happens due to such bureaucracy.

The study was rejected by the committee and around 40 points were raised, most of which were either wrong or not relevant to the ethics of the study. For example, I was told to consult at least two more Maori health providers and to have systems in place for interpreters, even though the study was to be undertaken by a few GPs who would ask their own patients with this condition if they wanted to take part.

Almost enough to make you weep.

It is no surprise he writes:

Medical researchers are hugely frustrated by the quality of the ethical reviews of their proposals, the work required for an application and the time taken for the responses and approvals. One of our leading orthopaedic surgeons has said the greatest impediment to medical research here is the growth of the ethics committee process.

We owe Dr Holt our thanks for speaking up. Hopefully the powers that be  will take note.

Hat Tip: MacDoctor

Broken Windows

A fascinating article in the Boston Globe:

Researchers, working with police, identified 34 crime hot spots. In half of them, authorities set to work – clearing trash from the sidewalks, fixing street lights, and sending loiterers scurrying. Abandoned buildings were secured, businesses forced to meet code, and more arrests made for misdemeanors. Mental health services and homeless aid referrals expanded.

In the remaining hot spots, normal policing and services continued. …

Controlled experiments – yay.

The results, just now circulating in law enforcement circles, are striking: A 20 percent plunge in calls to police from the parts of town that received extra attention. It is seen as strong scientific evidence that the long-debated “broken windows” theory really works – that disorderly conditions breed bad behavior, and that fixing them can help prevent crime.

A 20% fall is huge. So maybe the 300 extra frontline Police for South Auckland could be deployed to make a difference.

The study also found:

The Lowell experiment offers guidance on what seems to work best. Cleaning up the physical environment was very effective; misdemeanor arrests less so, and boosting social services had no apparent impact.

And further:

As Witts, the patrol officer, drove around the city last week, she pointed out evidence of success. A brick apartment building that once racked up 100 calls to police in a three-month period has, she said, had just one incident over the last six weeks. Gone, she noted, are the unregistered cars in the parking lot, the broken fence, and the code violations in the building – as well as problem tenants and crime.

The full article is worth a read.

The exchange rate

Kiwi Foo Camp

A belated post about the great experience that was 2009 Kiwi Foo Camp.

The first question people have, is what does Foo stand for.  Foo stands for Friends of O’Reilly – that being Tim O’Reilly of O’Reilly Media.

Kiwi Foo Camp is a local version organised by Nat Torkington (and his wife) who works for O’Reilly. It is for “technology industry people and policy makers”.

This was the first one I had been invited to – they are invite only, and I was thrilled to be invited and pleasantly surprised by how many people I knew there – and even more pleased to meet dozens of new people.

There are a number of great things about Foo Camp. The first is that there are no stupid people there. Yes, I know that sounds a bit wanky, but what I mean is everyone there was interesting, and interested. It is a retreat for those who are intellectually curious. You get to have a range of discussions that are stimulating, and fascinating. You also learn how much you don’t know.

The second great things is there is no agenda. It is an un-conference. What do I mean by that? Well when we get there on Friday, we work out the agenda by ourselves. And no not by sitting in a big circle – more like a human Wiki.

There are six classrooms available and around twelve slots on Saturday and Sunday morning. So they have up on the wall the 72 session slots. And any attendee who wants to speak on a subject just writes on a large sticky what their topic is in a sentence, and sticks it in a slot. And eventually you have all 72 slots filled.

But even better, you can change things around. For example there was a session on fibre to the home and on copyright laws at the same time in different rooms. So I just unilaterally moved one session to another time. And other people could and did move sessions about so they could attend the ones they want. And whatever we end up with by end of Friday night is the agenda, so to speak.

There were sessions on everything from highly geekly programming stuff, to digital photography to surviving the recession to ideas for Bill English to grow the economy etc etc.

On Saturday evening we had a great debate with Russell Brown, Rod Oram, Bernard Hickey and others debating “Is New Zealand fucked?”. The debate itself was funny enough, but at the end every audience member could also get up and speak for 30 seconds on their view – but they had to start with “Fucked” or “Not Fucked”. Apart from the hilarity of hearing the F word around 300 times, there was also some great insights into NZ.

I observed a great game of Werewolf, with around 30 participants on Saturday Night. Next time I’ll join in, now I know the rules.

Kiwi Foo Camp wasn’t just a talkfest. It is also where key people came together to further the anti S92A “guilt by accusation” campaign. We had a great session brainstorming ideas (such as the Blackout), and also had a session on the long term issues around copyright law internationally and domestically. Kiwi Foo Camp made a real difference to stopping S92A having come into effect last month.

The Kiwi Foo mailing list sort of got hijacked after the event to co-ordinate the campaign, and at its peak there were 200+ messages a day – almost impossible to keep up – but worth it.

So all in all, a great experience was Kiwi Foo Camp. And big kudos to not just the organisers such as Nate, Jenine and Russell – but also the wonderful catering squad who fed us so well.

Other blogs coming out of Foo Camp are this post by Lawrence Millar (NZ Govt CIO), The Strategist and Artifical Code.

Blog Bits

  1. Not PC is outraged that Frog Blog has called Nick Smith a libertarian.
  2. ACT candidate Lindsay Mitchell is not happy with ACT MP David Garrett’s call to change the Bill of Rights if it proves inconvenient.  To balance things up for David I should give him kudos for defending and debating the Three Strikes law over at Public Address.
  3. Rob Hosking lashes Labour and Treasury for the ACC non disclosure.
  4. Peter Gill points out that there is no NZ company that has experience in designing and building heavy diesel railway locomotives, so it is silly to complain they are being built overseas.
  5. Roar Prawn highlights how Jade Corporation had a 31% in half year operating revenue, and notes the chairwoman is Ruth Richardson.
  6. Peter Dunne blogs an absuive e-mail/letter he received. I think more MPs should blog their abusive correspondence. You could sell a book consisting of the best of them.
  7. New blog worth following is Alastair Campbell. Yes, that one.

Having a lawyer as Attorney-General

An interesting interview with Chris Finlayson about his role as Attorney-General, with regards to the Bill of Rights Act:

Attorney-General Chris Finlayson says he is simply “doing his duty” by raising concerns about possible breaches of human rights by his own Government’s law and order regime.

Mr Finlayson has found that the plans to give police unfettered power to take DNA from those they arrest and the “three strike and you’re out” law both have apparent inconsistencies with the Bill of Rights.  …

But when performing the function of Attorney-General – sometimes called “the Government’s lawyer” – he said it was important he acted independently.

“The Attorney-General must not be swayed by party political considerations but must objectively come to certain conclusions.”

Absolutely. The AG is generally exempt for collective Cabinet responsibility when it comes to the performance of the legal side of his job.

He said this independence was missing during the “failure of the system” when the Electoral Finance Act was introduced by the previous Labour Government and the Attorney-General – Michael Cullen – did not report its apparent inconsistencies with the Bill of Rights section on freedom of expression.

Mr Finlayson believed this failure was “political”.

“I just thought the freedom of expression issues were so obvious that a first-year law student would be able to identify them. And history has proved that completely right.”

I of course agree, as did the NZ Law Society and the Human Rights Commission.

The Attorney-General bases his opinion on whether a proposed law would breach the Bill of Rights on advice from the Ministry of Justice or, when it it is justice-related legislation, the Crown Law Office.

In the case of the Electoral Finance Act, the Crown Law Office concluded that it was consistent with the Bill of Rights.

Mr Finlayson, a leading lawyer before becoming an MP, said he was prepared to dissent from the advice he received.

“I don’t take the view that I’m some kind of automaton and just sign off on what is given to me. I will examine the matter carefully.”

This is fascinating. A non lawyer as Attorney-General (such as Dr Cullen was) would feel compelled not to second guess the advice from officials. But Finlayson has clearly stated that if thinks the legal opinion is not up to scratch, he will substitute his own opinion.

This is, in my opinion, quite correct. The role is indeed not of an automaton. Of course one would expect the AG to reveal both his advice and the officials advice, if they differ.

Good

I blogged last month, re Victoria Stevens:

She managed to wrestle with Police after barking like a dog and swearing in front of the widow of the man her son is accussed of murdering.

So I am forced to wonder, what is the actual nature of the condition that meks her unable to work? After all, it took four police officers to subdue her, and she still manage to kick the court room doors open as they removed her.

I hope someone from MSD/WINZ takes note, and perhaps refers her to an independent doctor for confirmation of this mystery condition that makes her permanently unable to work.

The Dom Post reports today:

Mrs Stevens, 43, confirmed yesterday that she had been contacted by the Social Development Ministry and asked to make an appointment with an accredited doctor to prove she was eligible for a benefit.

She had spent years in an abusive relationship and suffered from arthritis, weak bones and emotional difficulties, she said.

She saw a Hastings doctor yesterday. “I don’t care what people think. It’s emotional and physical. That’s all I’m going to say.”

She would not say how long she had been a beneficiary.

Very impressive that she managed to wrestle four police officers despite her arthritis and weak bones.

Good to see MSD doing the right thing and referring her to an accredited Doctor.

New Stuff

Xtra pinged in court

The Herald reports:

Telecom’s Xtra has been fined $45,000 and ordered to pay $10,000 in costs for breaching the Fair Trading Act by lying to its customers.

Xtra, New Zealand’s largest internet service provider, was convicted in the High Court in Wellington today on three charges of misrepresenting “that its pricing, conditions attached to its services or its billing systems had been approved by the Commerce Commission.”

To be fair to Xtra, it was undisciplined call centre staff at fault, rather than a deliberate strategy of Telecom’s to claim something that did not exist. But as it happened on three occasions, that was enough to get pinged.

The judgement is online, and there are some interesting parts to it. The lawyer for Telecom suggested one witness was unreliable as her history of perceived bad service from Telecom might have influenced her recollection. Judge Broadmore responded:

I add that it is somehing of a low blow on Mr Heron’s part first to elicit from Ms Temple that she had had a number of contacts with the Telecom help desk which had caused her frustration for various reasons including notably the lengthy delays awaiting connection to a representative; and then to invoke that frustration, engendered by Telecom’s own conduct to impeach her credibility.

Ouch – a bit of a spanking there.

Change for ACC

The Herald reports:

Finance Minister Bill English yesterday said ACC’s “liabilities are blowing out, rehabilitation rates are dropping, claims costs are out of control and levies are going through the roof”.

Sounds like a good case for those that pay the premiums having a choice of insurer.

United Future President joins National

One of my spies has just informed me that the United Future President, Denise Krum, resigned a short time ago off the United Future Board, and has joined the National Party. Her replacement is Deputy Leader Judy Turner.

I also understand that two other board members resigned last week. This adds to the speculation that United Future will not be around after the next election. In some ways it is a pity – they have a proven track record of being a moderate and reasonable coalition partner, but I guess the centre has just got too crowded.

Denise is what I regard as a good catch for National. I blogged in September:

Denise is UFNZ Party President and seems quite an able sort. She did quite well appearing for UFNZ for the broadcasting allocations.

Denise was ranked No 3 on the United Future list in 2008.

Another free trade agreement

John Key and the President of Korea have announced they will begin work on a Korea – New Zealand Free Trade Agreement. This is excellent – Korea is a major trading partner.

This is no surprise, as work started on this last year with an economic study into the benefits of having an FTA. But good to see NZ making such good progress with Asian countries on trade issues.

The economies that are scaring me are the EU and the US. The EU is under massive pressure with tensions between old and new Europe. And some countries may end up being forced out of the Euro. And the US just looks set to drown in a mountain of debt.

We may turn out to be grateful of our location down under.

Dim-Post on Opposition Leader

A classic Dim-Post:

Rumours, speculation and wild gossip swirl through the gray streets of the nations capital this week, with businessmen, civil servants and fishwives all speculating on the secret identity of the Labour parties noble and courageous new leader; the only man in Wellington brave – or foolish – enough to defy the terrible might of the Key administration.

The National Party has vowed to seek out and destroy the noble yet unknown politician who has captured the hearts of the political left with his quick-witted press releases and bold opposition to suspending superfund payments – but with his identity a mystery the bumbling attempts of the fiendish Nats are doomed to failure.

Deputy Labour leader Annette King has denied knowing the name of the dashing masked hero but has confirmed that under extraordinary circumstances she can contact him, revealing that she alerts him to a crisis either by wearing a red carnation in her corsage when attending balls, placing a vase of the same flowers in her bedroom window at midnight or messaging his facebook page. …

King laughed merrily at suggestions that her old friend and colleague Phil Goff is the shadowy champion of the left. ‘Poor old Phil? Not in a million years. He couldn’t even make it to Andrew’s press conference because he locked himself in his office bathroom. Phil is sweet and trusting and has a good command of trade and defense issues but he could never match the bold flair and derring-do of our mysterious new captain,’ she said sighing and staring out her rain-streaked office window at the stormcast Wellington skies.

But King’s loyalty to her hapless, bumbling friend may yet pose a threat to Labour’s secret hero; sources within National have revealed that the parties senior strategists are setting a trap for the masked Labour leader, forcing King to lure him out of hiding by threatening to attack Goff in the House if King does not co-operate.

‘She knows that Goff is too naive and good natured to defend himself and that the Nat’s will tear him apart, so she’s trapped into sacrificing her leader to save her friend,’ a senior National staffer said, speaking off the record before twirling his mustache and chuckling darkly.

As of press time the evil scheme appears to have been unsuccessful; Deputy Prime Minister Bill English and senior cabinet MP’s Simon Power and Murray McCully thought they had trapped the Labour leader in a Select Committee hearing but when they entered the room they found only Goff, slumbering gently in the corner.

Danyl really should be given a column in a newspaper. And his ending:

The National MP’s dashed their hats to the ground and swore in frustration. Upon awaking Goff insisted to them that he was Labour’s mysterious hero, at which the men laughed uproariously and clapped Goff on the shoulder.

‘But I’m the leader,’ Goff told them. ‘I’m head of the party goddamn it. Why won’t anyone listen to me?’

The real identity of the opposition leader remains a mystery.

They seek him here, they seek him there …

Labour’s new interfaith portfolio

An intriguing press release from Labour:

Luamanuvao Winnie Laban has been appointed as Labour’s spokesperson on interfaith issues

“This role is about linking in with the interfaith movements around the country and internationally, to build greater understanding and peace,” Winnie Laban said. …

“New Zealand has a diverse range of faiths and it will be my role to attend interfaith meetings, as I did on the weekend and listen to the concerns of the many different cultures and religions represented.

“During times of economic hardship many people turn to the church and faith communities to provide leadership, support and compassion and Labour recognises the significant role faith plays in many people’s lives.

A reader who alerted me to this release posed an excellent question.

Are the chinless scarf wearers welcome at Labour’s interfaith meetings?

I think we know the answer.

ACC shortfall should have been disclosed

The Government has published the report by Michael Mills into the non disclosure of the $1.5 billion ACC funding shortfall in the statutory Pre-Election Fiscal Update.

The report finds that the shortfall should have been disclosed, so in effect the requirements of the Public Finance Act were not met by the then Government.

The report finds that back on 4 August 2008 the ACC Board determined it would need more Crown funding, and that this was communicated to the Minister of 14 August 2008. They specifically advised of their intention to seek $1.559 billion over the next five years including $306 million in the *current* year.

Treasury advised Michael Cullen of this on 1 September 2008.

The inquiry also found that the “limited powers” regime in the leadup to the election was not a constraint on the Government’s ability to consider the appropriation increase prior to the election.

The bottom line is that Treasury was wrong not to include the $1.5 billion shortfall just because Cabinet had not formally approved it. The report says any material risk over $10 million should be included if there is a reasonable expectation that the good or service beeding funding will have to be provided. Treasury has agreed to abide by this in future.

Blog Poll on Cabinet Front Bench

I’ve started what I hope will be a regular feature – a blog poll which allows readers to rate how they think the frontbench Cabinet Ministers are going.

You can vote on the left on all nine front bench Ministers. You don’t have to vote on all of them.

It goes without saying that a blog poll is totally unscientific, and this will be no exception. However that is not to say they may not be of some value.

The idea for them comes from the excellent Conservative Home blog in the UK. They have been running such polls for a couple of years – allowing supporters to rate the Conservative Shadow Cabinet. The latest results are here.

While unscientific, they can produce two useful pieces of info. The first is a general perception (whether correct or not) of which Ministers are rated highly, and not so highly. But also (and more usefully) how their ratings change over time.

Now this will merely be a blog of Kiwiblog readers. And while there are many National supporters here, there are also many ACT/Libz supporters who regard National as commie sellouts and a fair few lefties who still see National as evil capitalists. So if a Minister gets a lowish score, I would not read too much into it.

The idea behind this is not to be judgemental about a particular Minister, but to provide feedback on perceptions of performance that may or may not be useful.

I would ask readers to vote in good faith, and only vote once (polls close Monday midday). Yes I know you can delete cookies or vote from a second computer, but I can usually detect you doing so, and will publish IP addresses of anyone abusively tryng to stack the poll.

At this stage I have done frontbench Ministers only, as I don’t think there is enough info in the public domain for people to be able to rate some of the other Ministers yet. This could change with time.