Herald on Spending

The Herald editorial says:

Now, as Mr English admitted this week: “We have ended up with the worst of all worlds.” We have Labour’s level of public expenditure and we are about to get National’s level of taxation.

Something has to give. If National will not postpone tax cuts due in April, it must trim some of the programmes it has inherited. The most costly of them, interest-free student loans, free childcare, KiwiSaver subsidies and the upper reaches of the Working for Families grants, should be means-tested more tightly to avoid taxing people to provide benefits they could pay for themselves. None of these would be politically painless and one or two are policies John Key has promised not to touch.

But National needs to cut core public spending to match its tax cuts even as it considers borrowing a much larger amount to fund counter-recessionary spending.

This is just plain misleading. Is the editorial writer not aware that National already cut public spending to match its tax cuts? National primarily cut the KiwiSaver subsidies, to fund the tax cuts. This must be known to the editorial writer (Labour harped on about it non stop during the election), so why is it ignored?

And National’s policy, with the wisdom of hindsight, was 100% correct. Because the billions that were to go into KiwiSaver subsidies would have been locked up for decades. Instead they are adding to the fiscal stimulus so badly needed now.

To clarify what it is doing, its Budget needs to present the public with two accounts: one for the temporary relief it is borrowing, including the cost of capital for infrastructure, the other to bring core public spending into line with the permanent changes to income tax rates and thresholds.

National’s tax cuts have been paid for by reduced spending. That has already been done. The problem is not the level of tax rates, but the level of income earned, and hence the amount of tax collected.

Now I fully agree, we should restrain spending now – but only in ways that do not break election promises. And frankly I am getting sick of Herald articles and editorials continuously calling on National to break its election promises. Because I’m bloody sure there have been a lot of editorials in the past condemning parties that did break their election promises. There is a degree of moral hypocrisy at play here.

I agree interest free student loans is stupidity. However National made a promise not to start charging interest again, during this term of office anyway. I want National to keep all its promises, not just the ones I agree with.

Fallow on Broadband

Brian Fallow makes some good points on broadband:

Going further than the current programme of laying fibre to the cabinet, taking fibre to the home is estimated to cost a further $6.2 billion, of which the Government is contemplating stumping up about a quarter.

Brian is quoting the Castalia report, which I covered on Saturday. That estimate is based on using telcos only to do fibre to the home. It has been estimated the cost drops by around $2 billion if you bring utility lines companies into the equation.

But we have something of a tradition of being penny-wise, pound foolish when it comes to infrastructure investment.

We are paying a stiff price for neglecting investment in the national grid.

Auckland would be a better-functioning city right now if it had gone for light rail when Sir Dove-Meyer Robinson advocated it and/or had completed its highway network.

Indeed.

Sceptics of the Government’s plans are on firmer ground perhaps when they question whether they would pay off in lifting the country’s unimpressive productivity levels. Surely fibre to the workplace is what counts there.

However the boundary between home and workplace is becoming fuzzier.

If the aim of this exercise is to deliver infrastructure that will be as important for the coming century as roads and power lines were for the last one, then part of that future-proofing should take account of carbon costs and the gains to be had if telecommunications can be substituted for transport.

When your home Internet connection means you can access the office LAN as quickly as if you were in the office, and when it means you can be video-conferenced to one or more colleagues more quickly that it would take to walk down a corridor, then you will have a significant exodus of people going from work to working from home.

Details about how it will be structured and intersect with existing players are on the non-existent side of scant at this stage but Communications Minister Stephen Joyce is promising more information within a matter of weeks.

“It is a plan to proceed over 10 years, to achieve a step change and do it faster than the market would otherwise do it,” he said.

“The argument is it provides a competitive advantage to New Zealand as a whole to get this infrastructure in ahead of some other countries.”

It is not too much of a simplification to say that, historically, the things which have really propelled the New Zealand economy forward have been technologies which overcome or mitigate the tyranny of distance, like refrigerated shipping in the 1880s or jet travel in the 1960s.

It is hard enough to achieve productivity gains through economies of scale or scope given our small size and remoteness.

We are the only OECD country that is both very remote and very small. To stay competitive we do need to be ahead of the pack when it comes to technologies that, as Steve Joyce said, mitigate the tyranny of distance.

We’re all doomed!

Well according to Sue Bradford.

You should have seen the faces in the audience at Backbenches last night, when Wallace Chapman asked the panel how bad they thought the current recession would be.

Sue answered that she thought it would be worse than the Great Depression of the 1930s, and further that it would last for the rest of her lifetime!

I guess the bright side is that a never ending great depression would be excellent for reducing carbon emissions.

Double Backbenches tonight

Tonight at the Back Bencher pub there are two Back Benches … one is a Special at 8pm on the Job Summit, the other is the regular Back Benches, filmed live just after 9pm.

The panel for the Back Benches Special is a mix of politicians and business experts … Trevor Mallard, Sue Bradford, Phil O’Reilly from Business NZ and Charles Finny from the Wellington Chamber of Commerce. They’ll discuss the effects of the recession on us and what some of the solutions might be.

The regular Back Benches will look at the first 100 days of the John Key government, the report on Corrections and whether the NZ Maori Team should go to South Africa? The panel will be Peter Dunne, Heather Roy, Russel Norman and Chris Hipkins.

I’m going along – should be interesting to see the earlier one especially as hopefully not just squabbling MPs 🙂

Sir William Birch

Normally I’d just comment on the post, but as No Right Turn doesn’t allow comments, I have to respond here.

In a tribute to Jeanette Fitzsimons, Idiot/Savant says:

But I also like her because she’s an unashamed wonk who seriously knows her stuff. It’s a rare quality in a politician – Bill Birch reportedly didn’t even know how to read a graph

Now I have no idea where the hell that comes from, let alone why I/S would repeat something so stupid, but I can’t let it go unchallenged that Bill Birch was some sort of lightweight politician who had no grasp of policy or detail.

Quite the opposite in fact. It is well known that when he was the (junior) Finance Minister to Winston’s senior role as Treasurer, Birch took care of all the detailed stuff, and Winston read the executive summaries.

But his eye for detail went far beyond that. I used to flat with Treasury staff, and I remember one story of the first time they had to sit in on a Birch bi-lateral.

The general rule of thumb at Treasury was that a vote analyst should only worry about stuff greater than $2 million.

Anyway in the first bilateral, not only does Birch go into every line in detail, demanding it be justified, he recalled the previous year they had stuck away $500,000 in some contingency account, and asked if that was still needed, and if not, he wants it back.

Now imagine how stunned the vote analysts were, that the Minister of Finance knew their votes to an even greater detail than they did!

So the suggestion by I/S that Sir William did not know his stuff, is ludicrous and preposterous. One could well criticise him for his policies, but to suggest what I/S did, is more a reflection on him that he spoils a nice tribute to Jeanette with an un-necessary and inaccurate swipe at someone who hasn’t even been in politics for a decade.

Editorials on Jeanette

Two editorials praising Jeanette. First the Herald:

Jeanette Fitzsimons’ decision to retire from the leadership of the Green Party in mid-year signals the end of an unconventional political career. In any other party, her outstanding qualities – high intelligence, intense application to problems and solutions, fairness, integrity, compassion, always civilised in debate – would have ensured her senior ministerial positions.

But Jeanette Fitzsimons would not be in any party. She was an environmentalist before she was a politician and left academic life only to further the cause. As the founding co-leader of the Green Party she, perhaps more than anyone in the party, has kept it out of close coalitions that would have given her ministerial positions but would also have required compromises from the party and associations it might regret.

I think they regret that Helen chose Winston as a preferred coalition partner over the Greens! I wonder if Helen regrets it though?

Jeanette Fitzsimons and her initial co-leader, the late Rod Donald, built a party that seems to have a durable appeal not just for its environmental idealism but for the collegial, almost non-political, style of its organisation and campaigning. It has “co-leaders”, quaintly of each sex, and gives its MPs room to pursue their own priorities. Sue Kedgley has her food safety campaign, Sue Bradford her concern for the welfare of beneficiaries, Keith Locke his suspicions of security services.

And Jeanette was one of those rare Green MPs whose priority was the environment!

The Press is equally positive:

During her 14 years as co-leader of the Greens, Jeanette Fitzsimons emerged as one of the most respected political figures in New Zealand, writes The Press in an editorial. She did not achieve this by practising the politics of ego, abuse and bombast, which have been all too common in Parliament. Instead her political style was based on her ideals, her integrity, a reassuring rather than threatening manner, and her unfailing politeness. Even politicians from other parties who disagreed with her policies found much to admire in Fitzsimons’ approach to politics, and her impending retirement as co-leader leaves a big gap for her party to fill.

That’s a nicer editorial than most people get as their funerals!

A feature of Fitzsimons’ approach was that she worked as part of a team. This is a stark contrast to some other parties, notably New Zealand First, which rose to prominence on the back of the same cult of personality surrounding its leader, Winston Peters, which subsequently destroyed it.

The Greens were the first third party into NZ that did not depend on their leader for survival. NZ First, Alliance, Progressive and United Future all do. The Maori Party do not. The ACT Party are a bit in between. They have a genuine brand, but would struggle to survive without Rodney holding Epsom.

Having said that Jeanette’s going will not help the Greens, but it won’t destroy them.

Even as Fitzsimons must be praised for her role, the future issue for the Greens is who should replace her as female co-leader, with sitting MPs Sue Bradford and Metiria Turei both contenders. In the eyes of some sections of the public, if not Green members, an impediment for Bradford could be her sponsorship of the anti-smacking legislation. Turei is less well-known, yet this need not count against her in the Greens, as Norman was not a headline figure when he became co-leader. For Turei, being Maori and from the South Island could be assets for the party’s future. The only certainty is that whoever does prevail will find it a hard challenge to follow in the footsteps of Jeanette Fitzsimons.

Another factor is Turei is 38, and Bradford is 56. Now 56 is far from over the hill, but it does suggest a medium term leader rather than a long term leader.

Samoan PM attacks Bainimarama

AAP reports:

Tuilaepa Sailele, prime minister of Samoa, has launched an unprecedented attack on his Fijian counterpart, Frank Bainimarama, claiming the military man has no plans to relinquish the leadership.

“I strongly believe that Bainimarama has no intention of relinquishing power and returning Fiji to democratic government,” Tuilaepa told the New Zealand Fairfax newspapers on Tuesday.

“Therefore, that’s a clear indication that Bainimarama has no intention whatsoever of holding general elections and returning his country to democratic rule.”

He also said the commodore was “stealing public money” by appointing himself as finance minister and paying himself F$200,000 (NZ$213,000) in unclaimed leave.

The Samoan leader mocked Bainimarama’s “ridiculous” full military garb and the need for an army, saying “perhaps Bainimarama fears a combined canoe attack from Tuvalu and Kiribati,” its closest neighbours.

Wow, that is pretty stinging.

I have considerable sympathy for the purported goaals of the Commodore – a non racial constitution, a census, democratic elections. However the problem is he does indeed seem to have no intention of ever holding elections. If he wants sanctions to be lfited, he needs to spell out a time-frame and commit to it.

Vernon Small says Cullen to quit soon

Vernon Small seems to have an exclusive at Stuff:

Former finance minister Michael Cullen is expected to quit politics in the next two months. …

But party sources said Dr Cullen’s departure was imminent, and would certainly be before the May 28 Budget.

Former Tasman-West Coast MP Damien O’Connor is next on Labour’s list and would be first in line to take Dr Cullen’s seat.

Miss Clark’s resignation would trigger a by-election in Mt Albert. List MP Phil Twyford is seen as the front-runner to be Labour’s candidate. Next in line to replace him would be former Auckland Central MP Judith Tizard.

Everyone assumes Damien will accept the list spot. I certainly think he will. I do wonder if anyone has actually asked him?

There may be one small complication for Damien. The Taito Philip Field trial is in April I think. Now I don’t know if Damien will be a witness, but it is possible. And there could be some embarrassing stuff come out on two fronts. The first is why Damien approved such a massively high proportion of requests from Field. The second is his insistence he was not warned about what Field was doing, despite numerous warnings sent to his office.So Labour may want to delay Cullen going until after the trial.

Judith Tizard returning, would be of course wonderful. Every party in Parliament has edged away from her daft s92A law. But wonderfully Judith was on radio yesterday giving it her full support.

At some stage I’ll write the “eulogy” for Michael Cullen – probably when he does announce his resignation. The term “flawed genius” is what most comes to mind as the theme.

The NZ Super Fund

The growing debate over the NZ Super Fund, is an excellent example of how politics has to manage perception, as much as reality.

I doubt even Dr Cullen would disagree that if we did not already have his “Cullen Fund”, he would not propose one in today’s circumstances.

I mean could you imagine getting up, just at the time credit rating agencies are warning that they may downgrade our credit rating, and saying “Hey I have a great idea – let’s borrow an additional $20 billion over the next ten years, so we can invest it in a loss making fund”? I mean, you would get laughed out of the House.

The NZ Super Fund was agreed to on an assumption that we would have a permament structural surplus, and out of that surplus could put aside around $2 billion a year. Maybe there would be the occassional year of deficit, but the consensus was that from 2000 to 2020, there would be lots of large surpluses, and hence why don’t we save some of that money to help pay for the cost of future superannuation from 2020 onwards, when an ageing population will make it harder to cover the cost.

So the whole idea was to save money now, to avoid having to borrow money later.

But we have the stupidity (highlighted by Michael Littlewood this week, but something I have been campaigning on for some time) of borrowing $20 billion over the next decade, to put into the NZ Super Fund. So we are borrowing money, so we can save money, so we won’t have to borrow money? Confused? You should be.  Sounds more dodgy than a hedge fund.

But we now have the politics. In an ideal world, everyone would understand that continuing to borrow money to put into the Super Fund will not in any way affect whether or not future pension levels stay the same. John Key has made a “promise to resign” signed pledge that he would resign if they ever cut the pension level. And in fact his atx cuts have helped boost pensions.

But if he does the sensible thing and say “Oh it is stupid to borrow money (and risk a credit downgrade) to try and save money” and we are going suspend contributions until the books are back in surplus”, then Labour and others will launch a campaign of fear and confusion (remember their 2005 one about National evicting state house tenants) telling pensioners that this means their future pensions are at risk. And some people will believe them.

We see this today in the Herald with Phil Goff demanding the PM come clean on his plans for the Super Fund. And this is simple because Key said they have not changed their position, but they have yet to discuss the issue yet.

John Armstrong warns National to tread carefully:

John Key and Bill English ought to think very carefully before tampering with the New Zealand Superannuation Fund – even if the political risks of doing so may seem relatively slight at first glance. …

A short-term stop on contributions would avoid English having to borrow the money to fund the annual payment into the six-year-old fund. That would make it just a little easier for him to write a Budget which gets international credit rating agencies off his back. It might not be too difficult to convince people that it does not make much sense to borrow money to build up the fund – especially when world financial markets continue to nosedive.

Indeed. But …

There are further reasons not to tinker with the contributions. The first is whether the Government will have the political wherewithal to restart them them once they have stopped. More important, however, is the (mostly) all-party consensus on superannuation policy. It took an age to reach. It will not take much to dissolve it. …

Labour know it is daft to borrow money to save money. Phil Goff is not stupid. But Phil Goff wants to be Prime Minister. So sure as hell he’ll try and politicise what should be a sensible non-controversial move (a temporary suspension of contributions until we are back in surplus) into the equivalent of slashing pensions.

And Martin Kay in the Dom Post reports Peter Dunne is saying don’t do it:

Government support partner Peter Dunne is urging National not to tamper with the New Zealand Superannuation Fund, warning that it would again make state pensions a political football. …

“There’s an argument that because, at the moment, this might have to be funded out of borrowings rather than surpluses, it’s a bit dumb to be doing it. There’s some truth in that, but at the same time, it seems to me that if you’re going through a slow patch economically, given the role that superannuation has long-term, this is the one time not to be putting its future into some jeopardy or doubt.”

So you have the perception in conflict with the reality. You know borrowing to save money achieves nothing in terms of making future super more sustainable. But you know it will lead to a nasty campaign of fear if you suspend contributions.

So I guess you ask, the question the other way around. Sure borrowing to save money doesn’t actually achieve anything, but does it actually do any harm? The cost of the borrowing will be pretty close to the returns from the fund. So it isn’t like a bad policy which actually costs the taxpayers money. It’s just a bad policy that achieves nothing.

So maybe it just isn’t worth the hassle? Just keep the stupid status quo.

Mind you, I’d like a journalists to aggressively ask Phil Goff some questions, such as:

“Mr Goff, if you think the Government can guarantee superannuation by borrowing $2 billion a year to put into the Super Fund, why don’t you advocate the Govt borrow $20 billion a year to put into the Super Fund? Then we could triple the pension”

“Mr Goff, why did your party call for a WINZ staffer to be reprimanded for suggesting a beneficiary borrow money to pay off her debts, yet you advocate the Government borrow money for much the same thing ?”

“Mr Goff, do you think households should follow your advice and borrow money to pay off their mortgages, rather than suspend contributions temporarily”

I suspect the Government will stay with the status quo, as it is just too much hassle for too little gain.

UPDATE: I’m impressed and a bit amazed. The Greens have come out supporting a suspension of contibutions (as have ACT). NZPA report:

And Greens co-leader Russel Norman said any responsible government would reconsider contributions.

“I think people will understand we’re in a very difficult position,” he said on Radio New Zealand.

One can support the principle of the Super Fund, yet agree that it is stupid to currently pay into it, when we are forecast to have to borrow every cent we invest into it for the next decade. Will Goff now accuse the Greens of trying to undermine superannuation?

ASB’s $1 billion jobs fund

What a very smart move by ASB. Their pledge to set aside $1 billion for cheap (5%) loans to small and medium businesses (and farmers), if it will save and create jobs is inspired.

Yes, it will mean a dip in profits in the short term. But it will do wonders for their brand, which will be of greater value in the long term. Especially doing it at a time when people are very negative on banks.

The Herald reports:

The “concessionary” rate would affect ASB’s profitability, Mr Pink said, “but obviously we are still looking after our shareholders”.

“There is a balance between profitability and the needs of customers and the community. I guess we’ve just swung that balance towards the needs of customers and the community.”

ASB has moved to seize the moral high ground in the competitive banking business by announcing the fund days before the Government’s jobs summit on Friday.

Prime Minister John Key welcomed the plan as “just the sort of creative private sector idea I have been seeking in the lead-up to this week’s jobs summit”.

The PM did say a number of times, that he expected banks to be socially responsible, in exchange for the government guarantees on their deposits. I suspect he’ll be pretty delighted with this as a response.

“As I’ve said many times, the summit is not only about what the Government can do. It will bring together people at the coalface of the economy who can make a real difference as we navigate these difficult economic times.”

Too many people think the Government can just wave a magic wand, and create jobs. It can’t. The Government can help create an environment which is job friendly, but it can not force consumers (both globally and domestically) to spend more money on NZ produced goods and services.

ASB is showing what the private sector can do.

New iPredict Stocks

iPredict has some new stocks. But before we go into them, I find interesting the movements in this stock:

goff

This is Lead.Goff.09, which pays off if Goff is replaced as Leader in 2009.

Now I don’t think Goff is toast  in 2009 (2010 may be more interesting though) and in fact have short sold 350 shares against.

But the market has shifted the share price from around 11c, to almost 18c, which is a significant increase. This is obviously a reaction to the two TV polls.

Anyway to the new stocks:

  1. Greens Leadership – Bradford is at 28c and Turei at 79c. That seems about right to me. Incidentially one could make asmall amount of money by selling both stocks (for 107c) and then buying one of them back at 100c when it closes. It is guaranteed money. But I’m not doing it as I’d think I can do better than a 7% return.
  2. Three Strikes Bill – The market says there is a 70% chance National will vote for the three strikes law & order bill at its second reading. I would not want to invest in that stock until I get a feel of select committee hearings.
  3. S92A Disconnects. This stock is on whether an Internet user will be disconnected under s92A by 1 Sep 2009. I have short sold 100 shares, indicating I don’t think any disconnections will occur by then. Current price is 30c.
  4. UNDP.Clark is the stock on if Helen will get the top job. Current price is 60c, so investors think she has a pretty good chance. I’m not betting – yet.
  5. Winston has two stocks – one on him remaining sole Leader of NZ First and one on him sharing the leadership. I’ve purchased both stocks? Why? Near guaranteed money. Winston as sole Leader is at 45c and Winston sharing leadership is 26c. You can buy both for 71c, and if one of them comes true, you get $1. The only way you won’t get paid out, is if Winston is not in any Leadership role at all by the end of 2009. There is a small chance of that but way less than 29%, I would say. Plus I’m happy to lose money if by doing so it means Winston has retired 🙂

I thought it might be interesting to look at the economic stocks for once. I don’t tend to focus on them so much as I am a better politician than I am an economist 🙂

But they are interesting as to what the market is expecting:

  1. OCR – 98% say it will dip below 3.5% this year, and 94% say it will go below3.0%. Also at the March 12 RBNZ announcement, 50% are predicting a 100 point lowering, 19% 75 points, 13% 50 points, 2% 25 points and 16% say other – meaning zero or over 100.
  2. Mortgage Rates – 95% say the floating mortgage rate will drop below 7.0%, 94% below 6.5%, 88% below 6.0%, and 81% below 5.5%. This is for June 2009. If they get that low I may start looking to buy property.
  3. Inflation – for March 2009 the average price is 32c which means 3.2% predicted. June 2009 is 2.6% and Sep 2009 is 2.0%. So the market thinks inflaion is heading well down. Of course 1% is what we should be aiming for.
  4. Unemployment – the predicted rate for March 2009 is 5.5%, June 2009 5.7% and Sept 2009 is 6.5%. Nasty.
  5. Exchange Rate – predicting that in March 2009, NZ$ will be 52c against the US$.
  6. GDP – 95% probability of negative growth in Dec 2008 quarter, 93% for Mar 2009, 73% for Jun 2009 and 63% for Sep 2009. Depressing – the majority view is that the recession will last at least two entire years.

What would be interesting is to see somewher how iPredict did on previous economic data – was the level immediately before release of the key stat, correct?

Clark shortlisted for UNDP job

As expected, Helen Clark has made the shortlist for the UNDP Adminstrator job. NZPA reports she is now in New York for an interview with the UN Secretary-General.

Hard to know her chances, as it depends of course on who ther other candidates are. Also whom influential countries like the US support.

Blog Bits

  1. The Dim-Post blogs on how the Greens always resort to state coercion to any problem.
  2. Boingboing blogs on how the UAE is considering legislation that will make it a crime to publish anything that would harm the economy.
  3. Tumeke has a montage of all the blacked out sites yesterday.
  4. Bill Ralston blogs on how TVNZ had 80+ “leaders” and that this is where budget cuts should be made.
  5. Steven Price criticises the Bill of Rights vetting process, for not flagging S92A of the Copyright Act.
  6. Gordon Campbell at Scoop gives good insights into the Greens leadership.
  7. Roar Prawn calls for Mark Soloman to go as Head of Ngai Tahu, after the sacking of Wally Stone.
  8. Cactus Kate is not impressed with Air NZ’s Business Premier class.

Hosking on Greens

Rob Hosking at NBR has a good column on the politics of the Greens:

Green co-leader Jeanette Fitzsimons, who has become a sort of organically grown, carbon-credit-worthy grown fig leaf for what is basically a radical left-wing party, is leaving politics.

Fitzsimons herself, with her background in environmental science rather than radical politics, along with her public image of being everyone’s favourite great-auntie (and a palpable, and genuine decency) had become a front-woman for what is basically a radical Marxist party.

Strong language, but three of their senior MPs – Locke, Bradford and Norman are or were Marxists. And Turei, despite having worked as a lawyer, is definitely on the far left.

It has become something of a cliché to describe the Greens as water melons – green the outside and red on the inside. It’s a bit more complex than that.

Better to think of them as traffic lights – red one minute, green the next, and a sort of funny orange colour when Sue Kedgley accidentally eats a food additive.

Heh.

Fitzsimons has argued the Greens are not really left-wing because they “reject the model of the big all powerful state that makes all decisions for people, in favour of a community model that empowers.”

How does that sit with, say, Sue Kedgley’s calls to ban pretty much everything she does not think we should eat or drink?

I think you can make a case that the Greens are the most authoritarian party in Parliament, now NZ First have gone. They see the role of the state as to force New Zealanders to live their lives in a particular way.

And then Hosking looks at Turei:

Then there’s the two candidates vying to replace Fitzsimons. Metiria Turei, seen as the most likely successor, framed much of her maiden speech around an address by radical US academic Noam Chomsky, who said those of us in western democracies are “in a cage” and “we’re going to expand the floor [of the cage], meaning we will extend to the limits what the cage will allow.

And we intend to destroy the cage. But not by attacking the cage when we’re vulnerable, so they’ll murder us. You have to protect the cage when it’s under attack from even worse predators from outside, like private power. And you have to expand the floor of the cage. These are all preliminaries to dismantling it….

“We too, in Aotearoa, live in a cage.”

Is this the cage that the Greens keep constructing, to ban things they do not approve of?

The voluntary bonding scheme

National’s voluntary bonding scheme was made public yesterday, with this fact sheet. Key details for the health sector are:

  • Open to any doctor, nurse or midwive who has graduated since 2005
  • Doctors have to work in a hard to staff area for two years and then commit to a hard to staff speciality (which may move them to a different area)
  • Nurses need to work in a hard to staff speciality while midwives in a hard to staff location.
  • Hard to staff areas for Doctors are Southland, West Coast, Whanganui, Northland, Wairarapa, Lakes DHB, Tairawhiti DHB, Wairau Hospital, Whakatane Hospital and Thames Hospital
  • Hard to staff specialities for doctors are GP, General Surgeon, Internal Medicine, Psychiatry and Pathology and for nurses are Theatre, Intensive Care and Cardiothoracic
  • Doctors will get $15,873 gross or $10,000 net a year. Midwives $3,500 net and Nurses $2,833 net.

The NZ Herald editorial praises the scheme:

The use of voluntary bonding in many countries bears testimony to its effectiveness. It is timely that the Government has introduced a comprehensive scheme here, not just for doctors as it promised before the election, but also for nurses, midwives, teachers and veterinarians. …

During the latest junior doctors’ dispute, bonding was often mentioned as a means of stopping the drift to Australia. The National Party made it part of its election manifesto. Commendably, it has enacted its proposal quickly, adding cash incentives for those who do not need student loan writeoffs. Some may quibble at these extra payments but they are, in reality, compensation for compromised career paths. As such, the Government scheme should go some way to solving the country’s medical and educational staffing woes. Whether it is tailored sufficiently well to have the maximum impact is another matter.

It will be interesting to monitor how many people take it up

Herald reports on s92A delay

The NZ Herald reports on the delay to s92A:

The Government has stalled a proposed law to enforce copyright on the internet after a “web roots” protest that blacked out sites yesterday.

Prime Minister John Key conceded that Section 92a of the Copyright Act could be “problematic”, and suggested it could be thrown out.

The clause would require internet service providers (ISPs) to disconnect users who download pirated material such as movies or songs.

The clause has been widely condemned as “unworkable” and allowing “guilt by accusation” because there would be no independent scrutiny of claims made by copyright holders against users.

Opponents say it could unfairly punish businesses or families when the downloading is done without their knowledge by an employee or family member or by someone hacking into their connection.

They also have a photo of a blacked out Kiwiblog!

I’m so very pleased that National has acted on this issue.

Yay

I understand the Attorney-General, Chris Finlayson, Prime Minister, John Key has announced that S92A of the Copyright has been delayed by Order in Council until 27 March.

If agreement on the TCF code can’t be reached by then (presumably between the TCF and the three main rights holders groups), then it may remain suspended.

Great to see National take action on this issue, after listening to concerns. And also well done to all those involved in highlighting the problems with S92A, especially the positions being taken by certain rights holders groups that they should be allowed to both make the complaints, and adjudicate on its validity.

Fitzsimons confirms retirement

As predicted in the newspapers yesterday, Jeanette Fitzsimons has announced she is stepping down as Green co-leader in June.

The Greens are going to have to think hard about their choice and strategy. They only have to drop 2% to be out of Parliament, and they failed to significantly attract votes in 2008 from what I call “ethical lefties” who were appalled by what Labour had done, but didn’t want to vote centre-right. In the end many more ex-Labour voters went to National instead of the Greens.

Elections for the new co-leader will happen on 30 May and 1 June.

Sounds like a good futures market for ipredict!

Sue Bradford and Metira Turei have both confirmed they will stand for the position.

Domestic travel to Australia

Littlewood’s Five Suggestions

Superannuation expert Michael Littlewood has five proposals for the Government:

  1. Review the need for the New Zealand Superannuation Fund
  2. Change the NZSF’s investment strategy
  3. Stop pre-funding the ACC’s liabilities
  4. Remove the rest of KiwiSaver tax breaks
  5. Fix the income tax system

I very much agree on (1). We are now borrowing every dollar we invest in the fund. At a minimum contributions should be suspended.

In (2) Littlewood proposes that there be no minimum proportion to be invested in NZ (as National proposed) but instead it should be directed to “invest in new businesses or in the growth of existing businesses that, for example, have export potential.”

I disagree with both National, and Michael. I want the NZ Super Fund Trustees to focus on just one thing – maximising returns over the long term. This fund is designed to help fund future Superannuation.

If there is a desire to have the Government invest in businesses to help with job growth (I am not convinced), then that should be done from a seperate fund – maybe through NZ T&E.

Also not sure I agree on (3) but open to persuasion. I don’t think we should move to full funding of liabilities too quickly, but it is a desirable end goal. Partly because it would also allow private sector to compete fairly also.

On (4) I agree. The employer contributions provide enough of an incentive to go into KiwiSaver – an effective 1:1 subsidy.

And totally agree on (5) that the tax system needs a total overhaul.