Praise for Lockwood

John Armstrong praises Lockwood Smith for what he calls his “democratic bombshell”:

Take a bow, Lockwood Smith. At long last, the House has a Speaker who seems serious about removing the blight on New Zealand’s democracy – the increasing tendency of Cabinet ministers to thumb their noses at the constitutional convention that they are accountable to Parliament.

Smith dropped a bit of a bombshell on the first sitting day of the year when he expressed displeasure with Labour Minister Kate Wilkinson’s reply to an Opposition question about the minimum wage, and then instructed her to answer the question again.

Such a practice is almost unheard of. You could see the jaws of National Party colleagues collectively dropping in shock.

I am 100% with Lockwood on this. His ruling does not apply too all questions, but only to the pre-notified primary questions and only when they are asking something factual, rather than an opinion. In those circumstances, one should get a proper response. Now of course the Minister should be able to robustly swipe back at the Opposition also, but this should be on top of giving the actual answer, not instead of.

Such interventions will not win Smith plaudits from his colleagues. They sat in Opposition for nine frustrating years complaining about Labour ministers diving for cover when the political heat was on.

Now in Government, they would expect the boot to be on the other foot. That it isn’t may be unfair on National. But stopping the parliamentary rot meant someone had to start somewhere at some time. Smith has done the right thing by serving notice that he expects ministers to lift their game. The onus is now on him to continue in the manner in which he has begun.

I seem to recall the Herald’s Political Editor saying she thought Lockwood would bomb as Speaker. I look forward to her next blog 🙂

In a more minor change Lockwood has also changed the route the Speaker’s procession will take every sitting day at 2 pm. Rather than go straight from the Speaker’s Office to the back entrance to the House through a private corridor, it will now go through the main lobby, allowing the public to see it.

This met with support from all sides, but funniest comment was Dr Cullen who suggested Lockie make it clear that the press gallery can not ask questions of the Speaker during the official procession. I doubt even Duncan Garner would be quite that cheeky!

Electoral Finance Act Repeal may be unanimous

The Herald reports that the repeal of the Electoral Finance Act may be unanimous. Only the Greens have to decide on whether they will support it.

It would be most appropriate for it to be repealed by 122 votes to zero. A symbolic burial.

Will the Police manage to make decisions on outstanding cases before the law is repealed?

The introduction of the repeal bill is set to be tomorrow. And it should be gone some stage during next week.

It has been suggested that there should be some drinks organised to celebrate the repeal. That is a fine idea, and we may try and organise something in Wellington and Auckland around the time of the third and final reading of the repeal bill.

Sir Roger’s prescription

Sir Roger Douglas gave the now famous Orewa Rotary Club speech last night. His full speech is here.

The Herald reports:

Act MP Sir Roger Douglas is proposing a new low-tax option for taxpayers in which the first $30,000 of income would be tax-free – but only if they pay for their own retirement, health care and welfare insurance or costs.

Income over the $30,000 tax-free threshold would be at a flat tax rate – 15 per cent – to be phased in over 15 years.

The Douglas plan would cut corporate tax rates to the same 15 per cent.

Sounds a good idea to me. Encourage people to look after themselves.

There are fish hooks though. The Centre for Independent Studies had a seminar on this a couple of years ago, and the challenge is how do you cope with people wanting to move from one option to another. Should the decision you make at 18 be unchangeable throughout your life? But if you let people change, they might take the low tax option when healthy, and then when older the high tax option.

The other challenge is what if someone has gone for the low tax option and pledged to look after their only health and retirement costs – yet they lose their savings. As a society do you let them die because they can’t pay for their health care?

As I said, I am very supportive of the principle, and like the notion of people choosing. It would be good to have some further research done on how one might practically have such a system work.

Sir Roger outlined his opt-in proposal to the Orewa Rotary Club.

He would inflation-proof the tax-free income so the $30,000 threshold would rise at the rate of inflation.

But rates would vary for income-earners with dependent children: the threshold for a couple with one child would be set at $50,000.

Families would have a guaranteed minimum income, so that if they earned less than the tax-free threshold they would receive a tax credit up to the threshold.

The concept of people paying no tax until they are earning the minimum income they need is very sound. It avoids the deadweight costs of churn where you pay taxes to then get soem of it back in welfare.

Quotes from Hansard

From Hansard today:

Hon Phil Goff: Can the Prime Minister—or the country—have any confidence in the transparency and honesty of the Minister of Finance, who, while ramming through legislation before Christmas without subjecting it to the scrutiny of a select committee, deliberately suppressed and withheld from the public and parliamentarians the advice he received from his own ministry that the fundamental parts of that legislation were deeply flawed?

Hon JOHN KEY: Yes. I have complete confidence in the Minister of Finance. If we want to have concerns about Ministers of Finance, maybe we should have concern for a former Minister of Finance, who may well find himself in breach of the Public Finance Act.

Ouch. Does JK know something or was it just a general reminder? Remember you can be prosecuted for breaching the Public Finance Act.

Hon Phil Goff: Can the Prime Minister categorically assure the House that National is not concealing Treasury advice or other departmental advice against any of the legislation now being introduced in the House today under urgency?

Hon JOHN KEY: Yes, I can confirm that the Government is not concealing any briefings or hiding anything from the House. If the member wants to talk about concealing things, maybe he should go and ask people in his own research unit about that, because the last time I saw them they were concealing the booze from the parliamentary Christmas party.

There were gasps to that one. Talking of which what has happened to the thieves?

David Garrett: Can the Minister confirm that the prefab prison—when it is built—will not have underfloor heating, plasma televisions in every cell, and expensive gymnasium facilities, and that criminals in those facilities will be required to work?

Hon SIMON POWER: I can advise that there will be no underfloor heating or plasma televisions in a new prison. Inmates will have appropriate exercise facilities, rather than the type of gymnasium I saw at one of the new prisons built by the previous Government. It seemed flash enough to charge a joining fee and for yearly membership.

Heh annual gym membership fee indeed.

Sandra Goudie: Has the Minister received any other feedback on the cost savings from building prefabricated modular units?

Hon SIMON POWER: Yes. The Leader of the Opposition has criticised the Government’s plan to save taxpayer dollars, stating that “If you are short-sighted enough to build something cheap and nasty you will be rebuilding before very long.”, and “When you are building a public institution, you build it to make it last.” That is a surprising claim, when the four prisons built under Labour, where costs blew out by half a billion dollars, have already racked up $9 million in repair bills.

Amazing what you learn once you are n Government.

Hon Annette King: Can she confirm that rather than sitting on its hands, as she claimed, Labour in Government reduced the unemployment rate from 7.5 percent to 3.8 percent through active labour market policies that saw 140,000 fewer people on the unemployment benefit, and if the previous Government’s policies did nothing, which programmes has she cancelled since she became Minister?

Here Annette tells a big porkie. Labour did not reduce the unemployment rate from 7.5%. It was 6.2% at the end of 1999 and at the end of 2008 it was 4.6% – a 1.6% reduction that averaged 0.18% a year reduction. Incidentially the unemployment rate under National declined by 2.5%, which was an average 0.28% a year reduction. And if you discount the nine months of 1991 before National’s policies such as the ECA kicked in, then the reduction was 4.7%, or an annual 0.57%.

Bottom line is Annette lied, and that the unemployment rate declined far more under National in the 1990s, than Labour during their nine years.

Hon Darren Hughes: Why did the Minister reopen the debate on Transmission Gully when it was the preferred route of the previous Government, and continues to be the preferred route of the Wellington region; and is it not a little hollow to claim, as he tried to yesterday, that the Crown contribution was unfunded, when it has been earmarked in the Crown accounts since 2005 when the Wellington regional transport package was first announced?

Hon STEVEN JOYCE: I raised it because the previous Labour Government, which was in office for some 9 years, raised expectations regarding this route that were unfunded at the time that it left office. It suggested that $400 million would be allocated to complete the $1 billion project, but left the remaining $600 million to be funded by local bodies in the region. A regional fuel tax was talked of as a means by which that might happen; I am informed by the ministry that a Wellington regional fuel tax in the order of 13.5c per litre would be needed to fund the $600 million that the Government of the time left unfunded, so it could be described as more of a wish than a plan.

Nice line – more of a wish than a plan.

Hon Lianne Dalziel: Does the Minister agree in principle with the proposal for the Government to provide alternative funding for community law centres to ensure they do not need to drastically cut services at a time when demand for those services will inevitably increase; if not, why not?

Hon SIMON POWER: I can assure the member that I am taking this matter extremely seriously. This Government is committed to access to justice for all, not just for those privileged few who can afford to access such redress as that offered by, for example, the Supreme Court. Coincidentally, the drop in community law centres’ funding is roughly equivalent to the $4.3 million that was committed by the previous Government to the bronze plating of the new Supreme Court.

And that’s a home run!!

What I found most interesting is that Lockie is taking a strong line with Ministers about answering the question, if it is the primary question. He basically said that if the primary question is asking for some fact or figure, the Minister must provide that as they have hours to prepare for it.  I think it is excellent that he is raising the bar in this way.

I repeat what I said earlier: where primary questions are laid down clearly, members of the public expect an answer. When Ministers are answering questions, they can expect that the answers they give may be further questioned by members of the Opposition.

I was worried about how Lockwood may go as Speaker as he was not a lawyer or a standing orders expert. But he seems to have turned a potential weakness into a strength, noting today:

Mr SPEAKER: I do not need any further assistance on this matter. I do not want to take up further time of the House. Had the Prime Minister not wished to answer the question, he could have made it very clear that he believed the question was out of order. The Prime Minister seemed to answer it with some enthusiasm. That entitled the Leader of the Opposition to ask a further supplementary question, and I believe that is the way the House should flow, in good order. We do not need to get too precious and pedantic about these things.

This is like a good rugby referee – making sure the “game” keeps flowing. Of course one has to follow the rules, but a but of latitude is a good thing.

Of course not having Winston there does make it a lot easier!

Booster Seats

Readers (with kids especially) might want to check out this paper about how the use of booster eats in cars can reduce injuries to kids. This isn’t about infants but kids up until the age of ten years who are too short for seatbelts to best prevent injuries.

This video above shows the problem.

The House today

Lots of good speeches on the tragedy in Australia.  The House unanimously passed without debate the motion from Jeanette Fitzsimons asking the Remuneration Commission not to give MPs a pay rise next year.

I’ll cover any questions if they are especially interesting. So far they don’t look promising!

UPDATE1: Hmmn John Key seemed to hint that Dr Cullen may have breached the Public Finance Act. This suggests the inquiry into the non reporting of the ACC blowout could be completed or in draft form.

Had to laugh when Goff kept going on about the Government concealing advice before bills are voted on (the hypocrisy here is massive, as Labour would sometimes refuse OIAs for months on end on bills they put forward), and Key hits back with how ironic it is that Goff is concerned about concealing things, as just late last year his staff were concealing the alcohol they were stealing from the Xmas Party. Key also said they are not concealing any advice.

UPDATE2: Every question Darren Hughes asked of Steven Joyce referred to him being “hollow”. This must be their new master strategy. It will work just as well as their attempt to label John Key as slippery.

PSA supports EFA repeal

Despite supporting the Electoral Finance Act at the time, the PSA has now come out and said it supports its repeal. Better late than never.

But of course, there is a sting. They want taxpayers to fund political party campaigns, rather than members and supporters.

It is silly to keep pushing for taxpayer funding of political parties, because all the parties have such a huge conflict of interest on this topic. Putting aside the argument for and against, it would be improper for parties to vote themselves money without the voters approving it. So if you want state funding of political parties, then either get the public to vote for it in a referendum, or have political parties make an explicit manifesto promise that they will introduce it, so if those parties win they have a mandate to do so.

What should not happen is political parties voting themselves money with no mandate from the public.

Blog Bits

From around the blogs:

  1. Dim-Post blogs on how Obam has found a way to balance the US budget – requiring all his Cabinet members to pay tax 🙂
  2. Homepaddock tells us of Waitaki MP Jacqui Dean having to stop some escaping cows with her parliamentary truck!
  3. Alf Grumble MP grumbles about the decision of the Employment Relations Authority that telling your boss to “stick his job up his arse” does not constitute quittin.
  4. Karl du Fresne blogs on how John Key is changing the political landscape.
  5. Matt Nolan has a depressing chart showing why the US recession may be the worst in recent history.
  6. Bryce Edwards has a compulsory read blog on he future of NZ First.
  7. Bernard Hickey encourages Dunedin residents to have a rates revolt to stop $188 million stadium.
  8. Bruce Simpson at Aardvark suggests a ccode of practice for the media and blogging industries to deal with attrbutions.

The aftermath

fire2

This photo from news.com.au shows a neighbourhood destroyed.

There are over 130 dead, 800 homes destroyed, 333,000 hectares burned and up to a third of the entire state charred. There is talk of any arsonists being charged with mass murder.

Our 100 firefighters are on the way. You can also donated to the Red Cross appeal – either direct to Australian Red Cross or through NZ Red Cross. I’ve just donated A$100. One can donate online at either site or to donate NZ$20 just call 0900 33 200. Red Cross never deduct any admin costs from targeted donations, so every cent you give will go on actual relief.

So far more than $1 million an hour is being donated. Isn’t that magnificent. But it is such a terrible tragedy. The death toll alone is awful, but the manner of death, the property damage, the impact on the whole country just compounds it.

The Murdoch owned News Ltd has donated one million dollars to the relief, as have AMP, Telstra, Woolworths and most of the banks.

Key becoming hard for the left to demonise

John Key was the target of the most uniformly negative campign in New Zealand’s political history. Labour went 100% negative with their TV ads – and all of them targetting Key as someone you can’t trust – a nasty “hard right” person pretending to be moderate.

So what have we seen from John Key in the last few weeks:

  • A transition package for those who lose their jobs firmly aimed at those with the most need (unlike Labour’s that would have helped people couple on $200k)
  • A commitment to flying a Maori flag next Waitangi Day
  • Warm engagement at Ratana and Waitangi
  • Despite suffering the worse assault at Waitangi of any PM, declares nothing will keep him returning
  • Is a good enough sport to get up and dance with two drag queens at Big Gay Out
  • Increase the minimum wage, allegedly against the recommendation of his own Labour Minister
  • Calls for a report by the Inspector-General of Intelligence and Security into why they kept monitoring Green MP Keith Locke
  • An RMA reform package that doesn’t even seem to have Labour opposed to it.
  • Backs Helen Clark for a top UN job
  • Backs a Green motion to have a parliamentary resolution supporting a pay freeze for MPs, so long as it is a year at a time.

Now people will debate each of these individual issues as to whether or not they agree.

But I’m fascinated by what it means at a more strategic level.

This makes it very hard for Labour to again repeat their tactics of demonising Key as some sort of two faced neo-conservative in drag.

In fact it even makes you wonder what Phil Goff has to offer, apart from his daily whine that the Government needs to be doing more.

Labour can not credibly pledge to spend more than National – not with $50 billion of borrowing scheduled. I doubt they are stupid enough to campaign in 2011 on increasing taxes. They won’t reverse the RMA changes etc etc.

Of course there will be some areas of difference, but to get a Government thrown out after one term you need to make a pretty compelling case that they are a disaster. Labour’s real hope is that the economy will bomb so bad, National will get blamed for it. But what if by 2011 it is in recovery?

Now some on the right will say what is the point of National in Government if he does stuff that the left like. I would remind people that while Key is doing a lot of stuff people on the left like and approve of, he is also implementing National’s manifesto almost line by line – tax cuts. RMA reform, freeze of bureaucrat numbers, spending scrutiny, tougher law & order policies, 90 day trial period,  rolling back (a bit) of nanny state etc.

The other thing I am finding fascinating is how irrelevant Phil Goff seems at the moment. What I mean, is when is the last time you saw a column or even a blog post about Phil Goff. There’s still scores and scores being written about Helen and her legacy.

Where are the excited posts about what a Goff led Government may mean? Where is the analysis about how Goff is doing? The research into what Goff stands for? The stories from former colleagues about how they think he will go.

To be fair to Goff, it is not his fault. Normally when you become a party leader you get a lot of coverage. But as he became Leader at the same time as John Key was negotiating his Government, there was minimal focus on Goff.

But maybe some of it is a lack of excitement over Goff.  I can’t imagine the Greens consider that they will get much from a Goff led Government. And many in Labour have despaired at his hard line on law & order issues. Now this does not mean they are disloyal or plotting against him. They are grateful he took on the leadership at a time when they need an experienced hand. There is no credible replacement for at least the next 12 – 18 months, and maybe not until after the 2011 election. But his challenge will be to convince people that he will offer something fresh and forward looking.

Winston buys bauble back

The Dom Post reports that Winston has purchased his repossessed bauble – the former Ministerial self drive car.

Nothing wrong with that of course. Mind you I do wonder who actually paid for it – it may have been the Spencer Trust 🙂

Music to my ears

The Dom Post reports:

Departmental chief executives were ordered to a meeting with Mr Key and Finance Minister Bill English within days of National taking power and were told to review all spending, so cash could be freed up for the new government’s priorities.

Mr Key confirmed that ministers had been working “aggressively” with officials on the line-by-line expenditure review, and reports by chief executives were now being considered by Cabinet committees.

A hard line appears to have been taken, as Mr Key revealed that he had rejected the first round of savings put up to him by officials and made them go away to find more.

With a decade of deficits and tens of billions of dollars of borrowing projected, it is vital that spending be focused on high quality essential areas.

Well done Herald

Minimum Wage increase to $12.50

The Herald reports on yesterday’s decision to increase the minimum wage to $12.50. As John Key says, it was a balacnign act:

Mr Key said yesterday that they were “concerned that if the wage was to rise too much there would be unemployment”.

“Similarly, no raise at all in the minimum wage would have left the lowest-paid, most vulnerable workers with no increase to offset the costs that they are obviously bearing,” he said. “I think we have hit the right balance.”

Politically the balance is about right. A zero increase would have been a Godsend to Labour and the unions to portray National as heartless. More than 50c during a time when unemployment is rising anyway, could really impact jobs.

Frog Blog comments on the decision, and has a go at Labour for their hypocrisy in refusing to endorse a call for a move to $15 until after National had made their decision.

But there is a price to pay for increasing the wage. The debate has shifted from whether the minimum wage should be increased to “how much should it move to”, and we then face a rash of economic lunacy with Matt McCarten and UNITE seeking a CIR on having the minimum wage increase to two thirds of the average wage within three years.

This would see a minimum wage of $16.40 based on 2008 figures. By 2011 it would mean you are not allowed to employ anyone at all for under $35,000 a year. Nope not even that 15 year old dairy assistant (once they have worked for more than a month).

The communist states tried and failed with their policies that you have to pay everyone the same (or close to the same). The reality is that a 15 year old with no qualifications, no training and no job experience should not be getting anything near the average wage which reflects people with 20 years of experience, training etc.

I worked for a year after school in my fourth form for $1.99 an hour at Woolworths. It was shitty work – I joked the job was to clean up dirt, to get treated like dirt and to get paid dirt. But it was damn good for me as a 14 year old to have a sense of responsibility and having to start earning my own money. So I worked two hours after school every night, every Friday night and Saturday morning. Muldoon ruled then so it was illegal to work Sundays!

Anyway with the policies expoused by McCarten, there is no way I would have picked up that job today. In fact there is no way I would have picked up most of my holiday jobs. The paper run would have probably been illegal too unless as a 12 year old I set myself up as an independent contractor.

It is simplistic and destructive to say the minimum wage should be two thirds of the average wage. It is treating all jobs and all employees as just minor variations, with no regard for individuality.

It also could have profund inflationary impacts. If you have a minimum wage of $35,000 a year, then sure as hell university graduates are not going to accept $35,000 as a starting salary. Would you accept a job with a law firm that pays the minimum wage? Hell no. So starting salaries for graduates would increase to $50K or so. Which means all the salaries up the chain would increase. And this would all increase the average wage, which would result in a nice spiral of wages increasing with no productiviy gain. And boy watch us export jobs overseas quicker than you can imagine.

MPs pay freeze

The Herald reports:

The National Party isn’t going to support a Green Party proposal to freeze MPs’ pay for three years, as it doesn’t believe the recession will last that long.

The Greens plan to put their proposal to Parliament, possibly tomorrow, and they hope MPs will vote on it.

Prime Minister John Key said today if it was re-drafted for a one-year freeze, National would support it.

“The Green’s proposal presupposes there will be a recession for three years,” Mr Key said. …

“I don’t accept that proposition. If the Greens want to alter it to one year then National will vote for it, and we might vote for it in the second and third years.” …

Green Party MP Keith Locke said he was pleased Mr Key had responded to the proposal in a positive way and the Greens would want to get it through Parliament on a cross-party basis.

I have long advocated that MPs should get pay rises only once every three years, rather than annually. Not because of the recession, but to get rid of the (inaccurate) perception of MPs giving themselves pay rises.

I would change the law so that the Remuneration Commission sets MPs salaries 90 days before a scheduled election, with the new rates to apply for the next term of Parliament.

This isn’t to lower MPs wages compared to other jobs – just to change the timing. So (for example) instead of annual increases of say 3%, there might be a 10% increase for the next term of Parliament.

This is a slightly different issue to “self sacrifice” of increases during the recession. That comes down to showing “moral leadership” and is a sensible action, as there will be less resistance of making savings elsewhere if they are also occuring at the top.

City to Sea Walkway

A group of us did the City to Sea Walkway yesterday.  It was (for me anyway) the hardest of the walks, and I thought it would be one of the easiest.

It goes from Bowen Street to Island Bay and is only 12 km long. Having done the 16 km Northern Walkway, with three large hills in it, I thought this one would be easier.

It wasn’t. Partly because the sun was scorching and the water supply limited. But mainly because the walkway goes up every slope it can find. 20 small slopes is harder than three big ones.

Having said all that, it was great to discover some hidden walkways, and again get some great views.

dpf-001

The start of the walkway by Bowen Street. You head through the historic Bolton Cemetery.

dpf-003

The marks the grave of Harry Holland, the first Leader of the Labour Party. I don’t know why they chose a naked man to go on it!

dpf-005

This is one of the lookout points in the Botanical Gardens. One can spend years going there, and not realise how many paths there are.

dpf-007

The well known view from the top of the Cable Car. You then walk down to Kelburn Parade from there.

dpf-011

This little hidden bushwalk is actually at the back of Kelburn Park, trailing down to Salamanca Road. No idea it was there.

dpf-013

You then leave Kelburn, head along the Terrace and cross into Aro Valley, entering next to the Community Hall, and then heading up Aro Street.  This shot is from Epuni Street. If you don’t know what shoes thrown on a power line means, don’t ask 🙂

dpf-015

From Aro Valley you go through a couple of parks and then hit Central Park, above. A bit of a climb through Central Park and you come out above the Renouf Tennis Centre. Found a good place to watch games on the cheap from.

dpf-020

I was too stuffed to take many photos in the latter stages. We go through a dozen parks or so including the Berhampore Golf Links, eventually ending at Shorland Park in Island Bay. This is Tapu-Te-Ranga Island, which the Bay is named for. I’ve slept on it!!

dpf-021

And the beach at Island Bay. Not often you get people in the water (it opens onto Cook Strait) but it was a bloody hot day.

I took a wee shortcut for the final stage as I was wilting under the heat, so am going to redo it at some stage, just so I can tick off every last hill!

Moore backs Clark for UN post

Hell on Earth

Australian PM Kevin Rudd has described the Victorian bushfires as Hell on Earth, and the analogy is pretty apt, with almost 100 dead to date.

fire1

This photo from news.com.au shows the inferno. What an awful awful way to lose loved ones and/or your property.

Life as a new MP

Jacinda Arden MP does a guest blog at the Hand Mirror on life as a new MP.

Pam Corkery once likened a new MPs first weeks in Parliament to starting a new boarding school. In some ways, she’s right.

You’re thrown into a flurry of inductions covering everything from setting up an electorate office, right through to the correct use of the microphones in the debating chamber (yes, there is indeed a right and wrong way to talk into a mic that doesn’t move). And when the house is sitting in Urgency, which essentially means staying in Parliament Buildings from 9am till midnight, you suddenly find yourself having three meals a day in the same cafeteria, with the same people.

And the cafetaria food isn’t that great, to say the least. I’ve always wanted Parliament to go with a free market and scrap Bellamys and put a food court in. A Subway shop would do very well I suspect!

I’m the youngest member of the new Parliament, a fact I am reminded of on a pretty regular basis. During the election campaign I had my fair share of (usually elderly gentlemen) telling me I was too young to be a candidate. Perhaps in an effort to be constructive, I was sometimes lucky enough get a follow up offer of marriage if I was looking for something else to occupy my time.

Jacinda doesn’t quantify how many offers she received, or more importantly how many she accepted 🙂

The election may be over, but the ‘yuff’ label lingers. The day I was sworn into parliament Radio Live wanted to chat about being ‘young and new’. Much like the gentlemen in my electorate, the interviewer didn’t mince her words, pointing out that my interest in politics from a pretty young age meant I could hardly purport to represent the majority of young people. My response to that is simple – I don’t.

My age, just like my gender, does not give me the right to represent any particular group. But it does give me a sense of responsibility to ensure that young people have a voice in parliament, whether that means ensuring there are platforms for young people to have their say, or by building a greater understanding of the issues effecting young kiwis. Whatever the method, it’s a continuous one. I don’t believe a mandate is simply gifted to you once every three years. It must be earned, and it must be maintained.

I think the Internet through e-voting, e-consultations etc is one mechanism where MPs can engage younger voters mreo effectively.

Electoral Finance Act to be gone in a fortnight

The Herald reports that the Electoral Finance Act will be repealed by the end of next week. Thank God.

The main focus after that will be moving forward on replacement legislation, as I blogged about last week.Anyway the Herald explains:

But the Government will then embark on a cross-party consultation process to rewrite the electoral law.

It has already abandoned the review of the act that was to have been headed by Otago University Associate Professor Andrew Geddis.

Justice Minister Simon Power will take the repeal bill, the Electoral Amendment Bill, through all stages.

He said the plan involved all political parties in consultation.

“We will be taking the Leader of the Opposition [Phil Goff] up on his offer.”

Shortly after becoming Labour leader Mr Goff said Labour had made a mistake in passing the Electoral Finance Act without wider political consensus.

Mr Power said his aim was to have an “enduring legislative framework” for electoral law towards the fourth quarter of next year.

Yeah that is when it needs to be settled by.

Asked how the consultation would take place, he said he would be leading the discussion with each political party.

They would have input into an issues paper that would then be open to public and political submissions.

Totally different to the EFA, when no-one at all (except Winston and the Greens) had any input into the law until the bill was introduced. I’m very pleased to see a commitment to allowing the public (not just parties) to respond to an issues paper, rather than only to have a select committee submission.

$18,500 for Hollows Foundation

The Herald reports on the winning bid of $18,500 for the John Key cast. It seems the wife was not initially that keen!

The winner is a Ganesh Cherian, whose business is making memorial headstones – I guess one business with continual demand 🙂

Just a reminder that people can donate directly to the Fred Hollows Foundation here. The amazing thing with the Foundation is that they can do so much for so little.

Not quite as bad as the Hodgson/Mallard dancing

Many will have seen John Key “dancing” at the Big Gay Out festival. It’s not quite as bad as the infamous Mallard and Hodgson dance routines, but not that far behind.

Someone captured a few seconds on You Tube. It’s from a wee way back, but still enough to have a good laugh at.