Let’s have the UN decide

Idiot/Savant at No Right Turn wants the UN to decide if NZ is meeting its obligations under the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights.

He explains:

It will allow individuals to bring complaints directly to an international body. So for example, if the government hadn’t decided to change its mind, the “Herception heroes” could have argued that PHARMAC’s refusal to fund their preferred drug violated their right to health, and complained to the UN about it.

I can think of nothing more ridicolous than having a UN panel, probably made up of representatives from Zimbabwe, Iran and Russia deciding whether or not the NZ Government should fund Herceptin.

Further thoughts on Police informant story

We now know that at least one activist has been working for the Police, and also that several activists worked for private investigators.

I wonder if it is possible that some of the smaller activist groups are 100% made up of informers? 🙂

Trevor Loudon has blogged the reaction on Indymedia to the revelations.

Also Bryce Edwards has blogged an e-mail from three years ago raising concerns about Gilchrist.

The Dom Post reports what John Key said on Breakfast:

Mr Key today said police investigations were an operational matter and the Government could not direct who it investigated.

But the spying allegations raised some concerns, he said.

“I think the main point here is we would need to be satisfied as any New Zealander would that those being investigated were worthy of investigation, in other words, they present a real or credible risk to the safety and security of communities, not just a group the police target because they feel like it,” he said on TVNZ’s Breakfast programme.

He said he would be concerned if frivolous investigations led to a loss of public loss of confidence in the police’s judgment.

“I wouldn’t like an individual group like Greenpeace to be targeted,” he said on Newstalk ZB.

However, he would be more comfortable if it was individuals who were being investigated rather than organisations.

But he said police based their actions on a wide range of information and even environmental groups could “undertake quite violent behaviour”.

And Judith Collins is sounding more concerned than initial reports suggested:

Mrs Collins said she wanted to know the facts before deciding whether an inquiry was needed, but would be concerned if innocent people were being watched.

She has asked Mr Broad for a report at their weekly meeting today. “I would be very concerned if law-abiding groups and activities were being spied on.”

It will be most interesting to see if anything eventuates. Ministers need to be very careful about second guessing the Police, but there certainly seem to be some questions that need answering.

RIP Bettie Page

Auckland Office available

The Christchurch Power List

The Press on Saturday published a power list of the 50 most powerful people in Christchurch. I’ll resist suggesting this will be followed up by the Southland Times publishing a power list of the 100 most powerful people in Gore!

The top 10 are:

  1. Bob Parker, Mayor
  2. Mark Solomon, Ngai Tahu Chairman
  3. Andrew Holden, The Press Editor
  4. Bruce Irvine, Christchurch City Holdings Ltd Chair
  5. Tony Marryatt, City Council CEO
  6. Kerry Burke, Regional Council Chair
  7. Tony Sewell, Ngai Tahu property manager
  8. Lady Stewart, benefactor
  9. Gerry Brownlee, No 3 in Cabinet
  10. Stephen Collins, company director

Call for Power to launch inquiry into Peter Ellis case

The Press reports that Justice Minister Simon Power has been urged by his former colleagues Katherine Rich and Don Brash (and author Lynley Hood) to launch a commission of inquiry into the Peter Ellis case.

They ask Power to consider appointing an Australian judge to reconsider the case, believing it would be difficult for a New Zealand judge to approach it without prior knowledge or involvement.

The trio also ask that a judge be given the power to recommend a pardon for Ellis if he or she found that a miscarriage of justice had occurred.

Rich said an inquiry into the Ellis case was essential. “Two former prime ministers, 12 law professors, 10 Queen’s Counsel and thousands of other petitioners have already expressed their concerns. This case will not go away until a final review is done.”

Phil Goff expressed support for an inquiry in Opposition, but did little in Government but rubberstamp what the Ministry of Justice advised. This is a real opportunity for Simon Power to show some leadership.

I am not normally a sceptic of juries finding people guilty. I think they got it right with Watson, Bain, Lundy, that antiques dealer etc etc. In fact normally I think juries find too many people not guilty.

But with Peter Ellis, I am aghast at how he was found guilty. I have read many many articles and the Hood book on the case, and each time I am staggered at how flawed the process was.

Simon Power has a great opportunity to restore faith in the justice system. I hope he takes it up.

Herald on 90 day bill

The Herald Editorial says:

Workers should welcome it because there can be no better incentive to additional employment than a reduction in the risk that a new employee represents to a small business.

And as some have said, it gives confident employees the option to use the law as a positive, and say “Look give me a chance, and if you are not happy, you can let me go within 90 days”.

Capable and conscientious workers have nothing to fear. In the ordinary course of business employers do not go to the trouble and expense of hiring somebody only to dismiss them lightly and go through the whole costly, time-consuming exercise again. In an ideal world recruitment methods would be foolproof and the need for a probationary employment period would not arise. But in the real world the best selection procedures will occasionally fail to ensure a job applicant is reliable and temperamentally suited to the job.

Indeed. In fact it can take, oh a couple of months sometimes, to really work out if someone is suited to a job.

The same is true for the applicant, of course. But if the job or boss proves unbearable the newly hired employee can leave at will. Despite the passage of the “fire at will” law, as critics call it, it is a fair bet the number of employers who invoke their newly acquired right will be a fraction of the number of employees who quit a job without warning, due notice, discussion or reason.

And even if there is a notice provision in an employment contract, this is almost impossible to enforce in the vast majority of cases should an employee quite suddenly.

That can happens to the best employers at any time. Small business owners can be left scrambling to cover a sudden departure as they urgently seek a replacement. There is nothing the law can reasonably do to prevent it, but the right to quit at will should be remembered when labour unions rail at the 90-day probation bill.

Heh, “quit at will” – a nice phrase.

Select Committee Chairs

The full list of Select Committee Chairs is online now. They are:

  1. Commerce – Lianne Dalziel with Peseta Sam Lotu-liga as Deputy. Dalziel is an excellent choice, and Sam is being marked for promotion.
  2. Education & Science – Allan Peachey with Chris Carter as Deputy. Allan’s educational background makes him a natural choice. I doubt he’ll be working much with his Deputy!
  3. Finance & Expenditure – Craig Foss with Chris Tremain as Deputy. The Hawke’s Bay takeover is complete! The chairmanship of this Committee is normally seen as the final step before being a Minister.
  4. Foreign Affairs, Defence & Trade – John Hayes with Jacqui Dean as Deputy. John is a former MFAT staffer so knows the subject matter well.
  5. Government Administration – David Parker with Jacqui Dean again as Deputy. Parker was a very sucessful businessman but has not impressed so much in Parliament, but this role will be little challenge.
  6. Health – Paul Hutchison with Ruth Dyson as Deputy. Dr Hutchison is a natural choice for Health. The tenaciosu Ruth Dyson may challenge him, and the contribution of a former DHB CEO (Kevin Hague) will be interesting to watch.
  7. Justice & Electoral – Chester Borrows with Simon Bridges as Deputy. The former cop turned lawyer and the former crown prosecutor will be a strong team. Bridges likely to takeover when Borrows becomes a Minister.
  8. Law & Order – Sandra Goudie with Clayton Cosgrove as Deputy. Goudie and Cosgrove may agree on more than they they disagree.
  9. Local Government & Environment – Chris Auchinvole with Nicky Wagner as Deputy. Very interesting to have the MP for West Coast-Tasman chairing the Environment committee.
  10. Maori Affairs – Tau Henare with Hone Harawria as Deputy. Both have been MP for Te Tai Tokerau. If Tau wins promotion, then Hekia Parata could well become Chair – unless she gets promoted to Cabinet at the same time – or before.
  11. Primary Production – Shane Ardern with Colin King as Deputy. The affable Ardern will bring first hand experience to the role.
  12. Regulations Review – Charles Chauvel will bring is legal skills to this low profile but important committee.
  13. Social Services – Jo Goodhew with Katrina Shanks as Deputy. Goodhew is another who is likely to use Chair as a stepping stone to Cabinet.
  14. Transport & industrial Relations – David Bennett, who needs a job now that Winston taunting is no longer.

Peter Dunne was already announced as the ETS Review Chair.  Labour are chairing three select committes. Somewhat surprisingly neither ACT nor Maori Party are chairing any – but that might be as their senior MPs are mainly Ministers.

Good

The Herald reports:

Prime Minister John Key has said he will meet the Dalai Lama when he comes to New Zealand next year – one week after China retaliated against the French president for doing the same.

The Dalai Lama will be visiting Auckland on December 6 next year to speak at Vector Arena and lead a session on Buddhist teachings.

“The Prime Minister will treat the Dalai Lama in the same way as any other significant visitor, and will meet the Dalai Lama should his diary permit,” said a spokesman for Mr Key.

Good. We can not have a foreign country dictate who our PM can or can not meet.

Further law changes to come

An informative article in the Herald on further law changes, and possible timings. The summary is:

  • Repeal Biofuels law (this law was oppossed by the Parliamentary Commissioner for the Environment, and similiar laws overseas have caused massive starvation as land is converted from food production to biofuels) to go through all stages
  • Giving Police power to issue on-the-spot protection orders to go through all stages
  • EFA Repeal Bill to be introduced in February (yay)
  • RMA amendments to be introduced in February, and advisory group to be named this week
  • Other laws expected to be introduced but not passed this week are the transitional relief package, DNA testing of persons arrested, no parole for worst offenders, new sentences for the Youth Court and a victims’ levy on criminals

That should keep the Law & Order Select Committee busy!

RIP John Drake

Ralston on National

Bill Ralston writes:

National is doing exactly what it pledged to do – a 90-day probationary trial for new employees of small businesses, tax cuts, changes to KiwiSaver, amending bail laws, toughening sentences for violent offenders, new numeracy and literacy standards for schools, and reinstating the wrongly sacked Hawke’s Bay District Health Board.

Can it please stop? It is ruining my carefully cultivated cynicism about politics. For decades I have watched governments come and go, promising much, delivering little, usually managing to find some lame excuse for never doing what it promised to do during the election campaign.

No broken promises here – it’s all abour trust.

Not only is it implementing its platform, it also occasionally shows signs of common sense, sensibly abandoning policies when closer inspection shows them to be flawed. The reversal of the cap on the building of new state housing is a great example of this.

National had talked of halting the creation of new state houses, concentrating instead on upgrading existing homes because of the health hazards many posed to tenants.

When it became clear that more new state houses would, in fact, have an even better effect on the health budget it did not hesitate to announce a new building programme.

This, of course, had its opponents crying about “U-turns”, but what moron would stick inflexibly to a plan that won’t work? Surely it is better for a government to say, “We were wrong, this is a better way to go,” than cling to an unworkable strategy?

I am amused by Labour attacking National for saying it would build more state houses, after earleir saying it would just keep the number of houses constant. It’s like attacking National for spending more money on Health than they said they would!

The SST Police spying story

The SST has a collection of fascinating stories on how the Police have been spying on various protest groups for many years, through a paid informant who was active in the groups.

The informant, Rob Gilchrist, was exposed by his (presumably ex) girlfriend Rochelle Rees. Rochelle is an animal rights activist and also got well known for her Google Bomb against John Key.

Gilchrist, in one of the more stupid acts known to mankind, asked Rochelle to help fix his computer. Now if you are spying for the Police, and communicating with them via e-mail, asking your girlfriend (one of those you are reporting on) to fix your computer is monumentally stupid. He also gets stupid marks for not using a Gmail or web based mail account for his spying, so that there is little trace on the computer.

So who were the Police spying on. According to the SST, it was:

  1. Anti-Bases Campaign
  2. Auckland Animal Action
  3. Beneficiaries Action Collective
  4. GE-Free NZ
  5. Peace Action Wellington
  6. Greenpeace
  7. People’s Moratorium Enforcement Agency (GE Free)
  8. Save Animals from Exploitation (SAFE)
  9. Save Happy Valley
  10. Wellington Animal Rights Network

I do wonder how much overlap of membership there is – some people may belong to all 10 groups 🙂

So should the Police be spying on these groups, if they are protest groups. Well the answer is, it depends.

If they never set out to break the law, and organise legal protests, then the Police should be taking no interest in them. Presumably that is what Forest & Bird are not there or the World Wildlife Fund.

If however the groups have a deliberate strategy of breaking the law, of commiting damage, of theft etc – then the mere fact they are a protest group doesn’t make them immune from the law, and doesn’t mean the Police can’t use informants to find out what illegal activities are planned.

So do the ten groups above all take part in organised law breaking activities? I’m not sure they do. Save Happy Valley certainly does and I have no problem with the Police monitoring them, if done within the law. But I suspect in some of the cases, the Police would be stretching it to justify their surveilance through an informant. The question I would ask is whether the use of Gilchrist as an informant actually prevented any crimes? I not, then they should not be spying n the groups. If however they were planning illegal activities, some surveillance can be argued as justified

There are a number of interesting questions, especially about Gilchrist himself who is profiled here.

  1. How did he become a Police informant – did they turn him, or did he offer? If he offered out of the blue, then no surprise the Police said yes.
  2. Was he informing just for the money of $600 a week, or did he disagree with what these groups did?
  3. He is reported to have been a ringleader is advocating some of the illegal protests. Could this not be entrapment if he promotes some form of illegal direction action to the others, and then gets them arrested?
  4. Did anyone ever wonder how he managed to live for so many years without working? Did they just assume it was the generous welfare state?
  5. Did he pay tax on his informant income?
  6. How many other spies are there in these protest groups?
  7. Does anyone else find it ironic that it was under a Labour Government, that all the leftie groups were spied on?

Another bill passed

Well for a party that Labour claimed had no policy, National certainly seems to be implementing a lot of it.

Parliament has now passed the following laws:

  1. Taxation (Urgent Measures and Annual Rates) Bill – Tax Cuts on 1 April 2009

  2. Employment Relations Amendment Bill – the probation period bill

  3. Bail Amendment Bill – reversing Labour’s law change that made it easier for offenders to get bail

  4. Education (National Standards) Amendment Bill – increases maximum fines for parents of truants and allows for setting of, and reporting against national literacy and numeracy standards

They are now debating the Sentencing (Offences Against Children) Amendment Bill, that will direct the Courts to take into account additional aggravating factors when sentencing for violent offences against children aged under 14.

Another time bomb for the new Government

Something else Labour forgot to mention before the election – Eden Park probably won’t be ready in time for the 2011 Rugby World Cup because of the time taken to get consents.

And this is Labour who claims the RMA doesn’t need reform!

The new Government may have to pass a special law over-riding the consent process for Eden Park. Let’s hope not, as that is unfair to residents – but not having Eden Park ready in time is not an option.

No controversy over this one

The Emery verdict will be somewhat polarising. The sentencing of Liam James Reid will not be with a non parole period of 26 years and preventative detention for his crimes of murder, rape and attempted murder.

In theory he could be released when he is 62, and that is too soon. That is why I support National’s law change to allow the very worst killers to be given life with no parole. But the non-parole period is a minimum and I suspect no Parole Board will ever release him.

The tragedy is he was ever free to kill Emma Agnew after 61 previous convictions.

The Bruce Emery case

The NZ Herald has a good summary of the Bruce Emery case.

I tend to think the jury got it right with manslaughter. A life sentence for murder would be too much, but neither should there be no consquence for the fact his actions killed a 15 year old tagger. Taggers are scum, but being a tagger should result in a fine, not death.

Labour votes to repeal their own law

In 2007 Labour changed the bail law to make it easier for people to get bail, even if they had previously offended while on bail.

National pledged to repeal this, and did so a few minutes ago.

But here is the interesting thing – Labour voted to repeal their own law – it passed 106-7. Now that’s a flip-flop.

Phil Goff is very worried about Labour being seen as soft on law & order. I suspect he will push Labour to vote for most of National’s changes to parole and bail.

Idiot Lawyers

Three idiot lawyers – Helen White, Simon Mitchell and Greg Lloyd – have just done a scare-mongering press release about the new probation period law. Their ignorance of the law they criticise seems to be reason never to use them.

In a statement issued today, the lawyers say that the new act exposes everyone who starts a new job in a company where there are fewer than 20 employees to the risk of being sacked without even being told the reason, let alone having any ability to do anything about it.

Wrong. They have the most basic fact wrong. It is not everyone who starts a new job. It is only if the employer wishes there to be a trial period of up to 90 days, and only if the employee agrees to it.

For example, think about a hairdresser who is so good at the job that he/she is attracting all the customers from a nearby competitor. Under these new provisions, a rival salon could poach the hairdresser with promises of more money. Two weeks’ later the hairdresser is sacked – as allowed under the law. It turns out that the new employer’s real intention was to damage a rival’s business and used the hairdresser as a pawn.

How stupid is this example. If the hairdresser is so good at their current job, why would they agree to a trial period with the competitor? You wouldn’t. You’d say that if you want me that badly, then no trial period.

We advise workers:

* Not to accept a position with a company of fewer than 20 employees if they can’t afford to lose the job.

Again moronic stupidity. They have the most basic law wrong. Their advice should be not to accept any employment contract with a trial period in it. But scaremongering against all small businesses is stupid and wrong.

So who do these genius lawyers work for:

Simon Mitchell (Unity Chambers)

Greg Lloyd (National Distribution Union)

Helen White (Unity Chambers)

So one is a union lawyer. How about the other two. Is SImon Mitchell the same Simon Mitchell who purchased the evidence in Paintergate for Helen Clark’s office so they could burn it? And Helen White I presume is the former EPMU lawyer? So is this factually wrong advice politically motivated?

Here’s my advice. If you get offered a job with a small business, don’t quit your previous job until you have signed the employment contract for your new job, and if your employer insists on a trial period, and you don’t want one, then stay in your current job.

Section 67A makes it very clear that the trial period is not automatic:

67A When employment agreement may contain provision for trial period for 90 days or less
(1) An employment agreement containing a trial provision, as defined in subsection (2), may be entered into by an employee, as defined in subsection (3), and an employer as defined in subsection (4).

NZPA have already run this press release almost word for word as a story. They should also read the actual law, and also perhaps research the actual background of the lawyers rather than cite them as a neutral group of lawyers.

Probation Period Bill passed

Parliament has passed the probation period bill by 63 votes to 51.That would suggest the Maori Party abstained.

I suspect in a couple of years people will wonder what all the fuss was about.

UPDATE: An MP helpfully advises me that the Maori Party did vote against. The reason for the low number of votes against is both the Greens and Maori Party were voting under strength. If more than 1/4 of a party’s MPs are absent from the Parliamentary precinct, then a vote can not be cast on their behalf by the Whips. This means the maximum number of MPs a party can have outside the precinct is 15 for National, 11 for Labour, 2 for Greens, and 1 for Maori and ACT.

Frog on RMA

Frog is upset about Rodney Hide wanting to restrict appeals from deecisions of consent panels to directly affected persons.

Frog thunders:

And in a society governed by rule of law, the citizens should be able to appeal the decisions of council hearing panels to the courts. But I guess all Act’s talk about ‘rule of law’ is only when it suits them not when it might stand in the way of making a buck at the expense of the environment.

This sounds superficially appealing, until you realise Frog is not talking about being able to appeal against what Councils do with public land but appeal against what citizens do on their private property.

Does Frog then think I should be able to appeal to the Enviornment Court his or her decision to paint their house a particular colour? Even when I’m not a next door neighbour, but live 1000 kms away?

Those who are affected by a resource consent should be able to follow the legal process around that consent. But I don’t see why me in Wellington should be able to delay for months and years a resource consent in Dunedin, if it has the support of everyone in Dunedin.

A sense of urgency

This week’s Dispatch from St Johnnysburg is online at NBR. I summarise:

John Key is finding that the wonderful plaudits he got for forming a Government in record time, do not extend to passing laws in record time.

The scores are:

  • Best Play of the Week – sworn in on Monday, tax cuts on Thursday gets an A
  • Worst Play of the Week – A D+ for pushing the 90 day probation bill through under urgency turning a positive into a negative
  • Best Maiden Speech of the Week for a Labour MP – Kelvin Davis gets an A+

Feedback and comments can be made at NBR.

2008 Victoria University Post Election Conference

I’m attending the traditional post-election conference organised by Victoria University today. It is normally a fascninating day to attend because it isn’t just media and academics talking about the election, but you actually have the eight campaign managers or nominees attend and talk relatively openly about their campaigns, what worked and what didn’t.

I joked to someone, that it is where everyone gets to pretend they actually had a campaign plan 🙂

I will blog some interesting aspects of the conference. It is under the Chatham House Rule, so no names will be revealed, and comments may be from a presenter or from an audience member.

National

  • Ran a positive campaign which was a huge contrast to Labour as they went all negative
  • Feedback had been people wanted change and were over the current Government but wanted to hear what National was offering – not more criticism of Labour.
  • Every element of advertising was issues based
  • Had far less humour, partly because of the serious economic environment
  • Media and core supporters wanted a scrap. Said campaign was boring and dire. But that was not in National’s interest
  • Billboards were there to highlight the issues
  • Tactical call to approach PM to suggest debates should be head to head. Amused that media report it was PM’s initiative. Were confident that John was a very good debater
  • Media fragmentation meant there were eight debates requested
  • TV ads swapped to attack for four days, but that was issues attack
  • Expected Labour to go negative, but not to degree they did.
  • Labour had heroic self belief in how bad National was, and got more shrill as public did not respond
  • Not a single positive TV ad from Labour
  • Labour used incumbency well with deposit guarantee scheme
  • National caught up later with more announcements in response to the credit crisis
  • Last few days very focused on the reasons for change
  • Key moments in campaign were PREFU, tax policy two days later, shower flow regulations, campaign opening, 1st TV debate, MPs off message in third week, the 100 day plan, the transitional relief plan, the final TV debates, the US election distraction
  • Determined not to fight the last war, unlike some other parties

Labour

  • Labour lost support fairly evenly over New Zealand, but a bit more in Auckland and provinces
  • The loss was a clear loss but not a thrashing
  • A “benign dismissal from office” – more accumulated grievances than anger
  • Time for a change, but not for a big change
  • H-Fee situation poorly handled
  • The trust theme ran up against time for a change
  • Trust was the right issue to run on, but the way it was run was not ideal
  • More use of Internet by both major parties, but not as good a presence as in US
  • Blogs not read by a lot of people, but are read by mainstream journalists a lot and are influential
  • Turnout was down, but not hugely
  • Less passion than other election campaigns
  • National’s policy inoculation was successful, and they ran a largely error free campaign
  • Law & Order was an important issue
  • Shower Head issue was a reminder of previous “Nanny State” issues