Herald likes the i7

Pat Pilcher at the Herald seems to like the i7 also:

The elves at Intel must’ve been extra busy, as they’ve managed to crank out a whole brand-spanking new line of totally re-designed CPUs.

Because CPUs are essentially the engine powering your PC, any new releases are potentially huge news, and I’m pleased to report that Intel’s latest bit of silicon goodness, code-named Nehalem (but officially called Intel Core i7), is very massive news indeed, sporting serious speed to burn – and then some.

I’m almost cursing myself for geeking out in Melbourne on some great compututer games running on the i7 chips. Because since then I have almost obsessively wanted to go out and a buy a whopping big kick ass PC loaded full of games.

The problem is I am a compulsive person. If I start a new game, I won’t stop playing it until I have completed all levels – and if that means 20 hours non-stop, so be it.

This is why I have only one game on my laptop – a simple battle strategy game that takes only around 30 to 60 minutes to win at. It has 10,000 different world setups so it never is the same challenge.

Anyway back to the i7:

The review Nehalem processor I was sent clocked in at a fairly zippy 3.2GHz. If it were a car, the Nehalem would have so much raw horsepower that Jeremy Clarkson would probably experience a spontaneous trouser accident. Some fearless geeks have already managed to overclock it to a positively searing 4.05GHz – this would leave Clarkson very red-faced, not to mention brown-jockeyed.

Benchmarking-wise, the single Nehalem powered motherboard came pretty close to wiping the floor with the SkullTrail motherboard which was powered by two 3.2GHz Core 2 Quad QX9770 CPUs.

Putting the Core i7 through its paces with Sisoft Sandra’s benchmarking application saw it score an astonishing 102530, which is only marginally slower than the 116498 scored by the Skulltrail.

Considering that that the Nehelem’s score was achieved with only half the processor cores of the Skulltrail, this is very impressive indeed.

My current laptop is two years old. I normally wait three years to buy a new one, but the HP has turned out to be disappointing, so may upgrade it a year early. I travel so much with it, I go for small and portable.

I don’t currently have a desktop at home. I have several at work (which is very close by) and don’t really need one for home. But a dedicated gaming one is tempting. On the other hand maybe a playstation for the flat screen TV?

Ministry Demographics

(Image stolen from NZPA Images)

Have been crunching some numbers on the new Key Ministry. I’m going to profile the entire Ministry of 28, the Cabinet of 20, and the Front Bench of nine.

Gender

The Ministry has eight female Minister, and 20 male Ministers, so just one female Minister less than the last Government. That’s 29% female. The Cabinet is similiar with 30% female and the front bench is 22% female.

Age

The average age of the Ministry is 51.6 years. The youngest Minister is 39 and the oldest is 67. Two Ministers are in their 30s, nine in their 40s, 13 in their 50s and four in their 60s.

For the Cabinet the average age is younger at 49.5. Only one Minister in Cabinet is in their 60s.

The front bench is younger still with an average age of 47.6, and an age range of 39 to 55.

Ethnicity

There are four Maori Ministers and one Asian Minister. Maori Ministers make up 14% of the Ministry – around the same as their share of the adult population.

Terms in Parliament

This is how many previous terms of Parliament there have been since they became an MP (2008 entrant = 0, 2005 = 1, 2002 =2 … 1987 = 7).

The average number of previous terms for the Ministry is 3.6. Steven Joyce has the least at zero previous terms and Peter Dunne the most at eight previous terms.

For the Cabinet, the average previous terms are 3.2 and for the front bench the average is 3.7. One three of the nine front benchers have been Ministers before.

Island

23 of the 28 Ministers reside in the North Island and the South Island has just five Ministers. However their 18% share gets better within the Cabinet only where they make up 25% of the Cabinet. And on the front bench the South Island has one third representation – greater than their population share.

Area

Auckland supplies a whopping 13 Ministers, so no more complaints about Wellington lecturing to Auckland when Auckland makes up 46% of the Ministry. They are also 45% of the Cabinet but 22% of the front bench.

Wellington and Christchurch get three Ministers each. Within Cabinet though Wellington drops to just one Minister – Chris Finlayson.

Provincial MPs make up five Ministers and Rural MPs four Ministers. That’ 32% of the Ministry from outside the big three cities. Within the Cabinet they make up 35% and on the front bench comprise 55%.

I’ll also do a profile of former occupations also at some stage, but may cheat and see if I can steal that from Saunders Unsworth who do an excellent summary of MPs former occupations as part of their book of profiles.

When Phil Goff announces his new line up, I’ll also profile them.

Nice headlines

Watching the NZPA newswire today has been fun:

  • 10:15 19/11/2008 CLARK RESIGNS OUTGOING GOVERNMENT’S WARRANTS
  • 11:55 19/11/2008 PRIME MINISTER JOHN KEY
  • 12:19 19/11/2008 KEY AND MINISTERS SWORN IN

Just in time for Christmas!

Anderton all but joins Labour

Jim Anderton has announced he is forming an Opposition coalition with Labour and will be the coalition Agriculture Spokesperson.

Why doesn’t he just admit his party serves no useful purpose, and join Labour again.

Beehive turns blue

Now someone is on the ball. At exactly 12.30 pm the Beehive website changed colour from red to blue 🙂

The PM’s website isn’t updated but that one is maintained by the PM’s Office, not by Ministerial Services, so I guess will have to wait until staff are confirmed.

Are Labour shafting Ross Robertson?

I’ve heard from a fairly reliable source that the highly respected Ross Robertson will not be nominated by Labour as an Assistant Speaker, but instead Sue Moroney is favoured.

This is not confirmed. Moroney seems a competent sort, but Roberston is held in high regqard by most MPs as a very fair Assistant Speaker. It has been suggested to me some MPs are angry with him for not retiring and letting new blood come through, so they will punish him by taking his prized role off him.

I guess we’ll find out by early December when the roles are elected.

A code of conduct for Ministerial staff?

The Press reports:

Massey University’s Dr Richard Shaw and Victoria University senior lecturer Dr Chris Eichbaum said they were concerned about the risk of politicising New Zealand’s neutral and expert public service.

Bit too late to be worried only now.

Eichbaum said a significant number of new ministerial staff were about to start work in the Beehive, many of whom had no experience of working within government.

Dr Eichbaum, whom I have blogged on previously, is a former staffer to at least three Labour Ministers, including Helen Clark and has been reported as being a member of the Labour Party for the last 20 years.

They needed a formal induction process with guidance on the rules and conventions governing their relationship with ministers and a code to clarify their role, he said.

“Who’s going to tell them what the rules of the game are and kinds of things they have to be wary of doing like giving direction to public servants, which they don’t have authority to do, or filtering advice which they can’t do?” said Eichbaum.

My suggestion would be to do the opposite of what David Benson Pope’s office did, and they will be fine.

Actually more seriously, the suggestions by the two academics is not at all a bad one. Ministerial staff do have a role not well understood or defined. In theory they are employees of the Department of Internal Affairs and bound by the same code of conduct as all other civil servants. But in reality many of them are operating in a highly political role, and it would be useful to have that role better defined.

The two researchers have actualy published a very interesting paper on the role of Ministerial staff. Their research found the most the most common activities done frequently were:

  • Assist with oral and written questions 97%
  • Convey Minister’s wishes to officials 91%
  • Read advice from officials before passing onto Minister 89%
  • Respond to OIAs 78%
  • Accompany Minister to meetings 78%
  • Meet with PMs Office 69%
  • Broker meetings with Minister and interest groups 66
  • Ask officials for advice on an issue 63%
  • Assist with Budget round 59%
  • Assist with Coalition consultation 59%
  • Meet with officials to develop policy 50%
  • Raise/debate policy with Minister 50%

The full paper is worth a read. Back to the news story:

“Here we have a vital institution, the Beehive, with very important decisions being made and lots of people with very little experience and we are going to leave them to find their own way?”

The tone here is somewhat unfortunate and patronising, and damages what is essentially not a bad idea. Firstly many of the current Opposition staff are highly experienced in Parliament and Government. Secondly I expect a number of former Ministerial staffers from the 1990s will return with their experience. And thirdly not all Ministerial staffers are political and National Ministers will keep on some of the current staff.

Having said all that, some clarity of role in the form of a code of conduct is not a bad thing. Some staff may not realise that every request they make of someone, is treated as a request by the Minister. Any actions they take, will be assumed to be approved by the Minister.

Trade vs Aid

The NZ Herald has a nice line in the debate about helping the third world:

It has been estimated that barriers to trade in developed economies cost poor nations more than $100 billion a year, about twice what rich countries give in aid.

I’m not optimistic of progress though with a protectionist President and Congress in the United States, and the loss of Mandelson as Trade Commissioner for the EU.

Nia Glassie’s hell

Catherine Masters in the Herald has written a story bringing together all the different elements of the hell that was Nia Glassie’s final days.

There have been a number of high profile abuse cases, but this is the one that I think I will never forget.

Other deaths of toddlers have been awful, but due to a mixture of neglect and violence. The Glassie case can only be seen as group sadistic torture.

I don’t want to politicise this awful case, but National had pledged to bring in a sentence of life without parole for the worst killers – they estimate it would be used only two or three times a year. This would be one of those cases – those responsible and found guilty of murder should never ever be let out. If you read the story, you will see that redemption and rehabilitation do not form part of this story.

Some extracts from the sad sad story:

What was done to Nia was callous and violent, perpetrated by a group of no-hopers who lived and partied together, who smoked pot together and who for one reason or another didn’t like the little girl they failed to protect.

Nia Maria Glassie was three. They thought she was ugly.

They kicked Nia in the head, and she points to the front of her head.

Sometimes Nia would bleed but they don’t care about it. They just keep on smashing her, she says.

They put her in the corner and they kick her to the wall and she gets bumps on her head.

The worst thing, in this child’s mind, was when Michael Curtis lifted Nia to the ceiling by her neck and her hips and when she touched the ceiling, he let her go.

Another child tells how they spun Nia on the clothesline as fast as they could. Her voice is soft and shy.

They put her into the drier, too, she says.

And the defendants:

The defendants don’t look appalled. Perhaps they’re bored. Though, sometimes in court they laughed and whispered and often they tried to stare down the reporters covering the trial.

The torture again:

The woman asks the second girl more about the clothes drier.

You turn it right up, replies the girl, and it gets hot then it dries your clothes.

Nia was screaming, she says, so they put her on the clothesline and they spinned her as fast as they could so she could fall off.

She did fall off, the little girl says. Three times. On her head.

They put Nia in the drier like “a ball”, the girl says.

They turned the switch, the one with lots of numbers on it, up too high and Nia kicked the door open but they just put her legs back in. …

And back to those responsible:

The abuse was normalised and it escalated. The brothers didn’t play sport or work, there was booze and pot, though no suggestion of P.

They didn’t have much money so were home a lot and found ways to entertain themselves. …

Lisa Kuka, it seems, grew from a nice little girl into a woman whose life revolves around men and who demonstrated a frightening submission to them.

She was the 17th of 19 children. …

I wish there were simple answers to these horrors. Sadly there are not.

UPDATE: Dave Crampton at Big News has a long post on the background to the Glassie household.

Fran on the economy

Fran O’Sullivan looks at the recent National-ACT agreement. She covers some of the tensions around spending reviews, but notes that is not the big issue. The big issue is:

Where Act has scored is in getting an agreement out of National to make a concrete goal of closing the income gap with Australia by 2025. This will require a sustained lift in New Zealand’s productivity growth to 3 per cent a year – something that has so far eluded this country.

It is an ambitious target.

To get some focus on this ambition a “high-quality” advisory group will be formed to probe into the real reasons behind New Zealand’s decline in productivity performance, investigate the kind of institutions that Australia sports to drive its superior performance and report annually on progress made towards the 2025 goal.

Frankly, this is the real winner in the National-Act agreement.

The advisory group should move quickly to examine the runs on the board that the Australian Productivity Commission has notched up. The commission undertakes exhaustive investigations into various sectors, interviewing the key players before coming up with in-depth recommendations. It has been a powerful force in driving efficiency into Australia’s economy over the past 15 years.

If such a commission is set up here, it would be great to do it in such a way, the Goff led Labour Party would support it. That doesn’t mean that you agree to implement whatever they come up with, but that you don’t undermine and ridicule them if they ever propose something unpopular.

We saw this with the NZ Institute. They were a darling of Labour, and then they dared to suggest we should be a “fast follower” in terms of climate change responses and the wrath of Helengrad descended on them, and they were marginalised.

Both National and Labour need to realise that if they set up a NZ Productivity Commission, it will sometimes recommend stuff they don’t like. And the challenge for them will be to disagree with the message, but not shoot the messenger.

Economic Literacy

The Visible Hand in Economics gives a neat lesson in economic literacy on the issue of productivity growth.

Paul Walker also joins in, dismissing the argument that merely increasing productivity doesn’t necessairly boost GDP or wages, and they quote Paul Krugman of all people:

Economic history offers no example of a country that experienced long-term productivity growth without a roughly equal rise in real wages. In the 1950s, when European productivity was typically less than half of U.S. productivity, so were European wages; today average compensation measured in dollars is about the same. As Japan climbed the productivity ladder over the past 30 years, its wages also rose, from 10% to 110% of the U.S. level. South Korea’s wages have also risen dramatically over time. (“Does Third World growth hurt First World Prosperity?” Harvard Business Review 72 n4, July-August 1994: 113-21.)

Both major parties in Australia understand the importance of productivity growth. That is why they support the Australian Productivity Commission.

The challenge for John Key is to have policies that will help productivity growth.

Constructive Criticisms

Inevitably things are not as heated and there is less to oppose, when the party you support is in power. And Winston is gone. But I would rather slit my throat than become a rabid cheerleader who thinks the Government can do no wrong, just because of the change of power.

I’ve just done a quick check, and since the election, I have:

  • poked fun at the role of Associate Minister for the Rugby World Cup
  • suggested the Deputy Speaker should be from the Opposition
  • criticised the deal with the Maori Party for extra staff for Maori electorates
  • criticised the size of the Executive several times
  • highlighted and criticised a new ACT MP
  • praised Phil Goff three times!
  • advocated a free vote for Speaker and praised Cullen as a potential Speaker
  • criticised Rodney for his comments on Sunday about John Key
  • called for an inquiry into new National MP Kanwaljit Bakshi (and Shane Jones)
  • praised Labour and Helen Clark for their leadership transition
  • advocated for major portfolios to be within Cabinet

Now of course overall I will be agreeing with the Government far more than I disagree with it. That happens when your get the Government you campaigned for. But as Keith Holyoake once said, even he only agreed with 80% of what his Government did. So I imagine I will also be very keen on 80% of what the Government does, be luke warm to cold on 15% and pretty unhappy with a few decisions.

That is the nature of politics.

It drives me mad to see all these left wingers now talking about how bad the Electoral Finance Act is, yet said nothing at the time. The world will not end if you publicly disagree with your party. Obviously it helps if the disagreement is made respectfully, but one can agree to disagree.

Associate Minister for the Rugby World Cup

So what are the duties of the Associate Minister for the Rugby World Cup? My guesses are:

  1. Reserving the good seats
  2. Official tour guide for English WAGs
  3. Talent Scout for the Parliamentary Rugby Team
  4. 10% commission on corporate box sales

Colin Espiner eating his blog

Watch Colin Espiner eat his blog. Very funny.

Colin blogs about it here, and Stuff has run a story on it.

Big thumbs up to Colin for being a good guy, and going through with it. I hope he had a good audience watching it live. Thanks to Whale Oil for converting it to You Tube so one can embed it.

Lindsay Tisch to be nominated Deputy Speaker

This really annoys me. Not that Lindsay Tisch is to be nominated Deputy Speaker, but that I only found about it by listening to the audio/video (thanks Scoop) of John Key’s press conference.

It wasn’t in the official media release, but John Key announced it early on at his press conference. Now there were 30 or so journalists in the room, so why didn’t a single one of them actually report it? Hell why attend the press conference, if all you are going to do is write stories based on the press releases, and overlook any new material from the actual press conference.

Anyway it looks like Lockwood for Speaker and Lindsay Tisch for Deputy. There are two Assistant Speakers, with one traditionally being from the Opposition – presumably Ross Robertson. I’d guess Eric Roy may be the other Assistant Speaker.

It hasn’t been a tradition, but it would be nice if the Deputy Speaker (rather than the Assistant) was from the Opposition. Clem Simich did very well as Deputy Speaker.

Seats over 20,000 sq km

One of the smaller items in the agreement with the Maori Party was the agreement to fund a third out of parliament staff member for the seven Maori seats and any general seat over 20,000 sq kms.

I wondered what seats would qualify, and Homepaddock has the answers:

  1. Te Tai Tonga – 161,443
  2. Clutha-Southland – 38,247
  3. West Coast-Tasman – 38,042
  4. Te Tai Hauauru – 35,825
  5. Waitaki – 34,888
  6. Ikaroa-Rawhiti – 30.952
  7. Kaikoura – 23,706

So only three of the seven Maori seats are over 20,000 kms. Next we have

  1. Waiariki – 19,212
  2. Te Tai Tokerau – 16,370
  3. East Coast 13,649
  4. Taranaki-King Country 12,869
  5. Hauraki-Waikato – 12,580

You could cut the line at 15,000 but if Hauraki-Waikato gets a third staffer, shouldn’t East Coast and TKC?

And then we have the seventh Maori seats – Tamaki Makauru at 730 sq kms.  There are a further 21 general seats between Tamaki Makauru and Hauraki-Waikato.

To be fair to all large seats, the agreement should be modified to be either:

  1. Only three of the Maori seats and four general seats over 20,000 sq km
  2. Five Maori seats, and four general seats over 15,000 sq km
  3. Six Maori seats and six general seats over 12,500 sq km
  4. All seven Maori seats and 27 general seats over 730 sq km

It is hard to justify a third staffer for Tamaki Makauru, when it is so much smaller than the other Maori seats.

Toad on why the centre-left lost power

Toad from the Greens has an insightful piece as to why the centre-left lost power:

  1. The Taito Phillip Field Affair Allegations of misconduct against Field had been simmering since just before the 2005 election. Instead of implementing a proper investigation with the teeth to interview witnesses under oath, Clark implemented an Claytons inquiry that was widely perceived as a whitewash designed to clear Field. Then despite further very serious allegations, Field was retained in the Labour Caucus right through to February 2007, creating a perception of tolerance of impropriety and possible corruption.

    Dead right. It was a disgrace, and even after the Ingram report they defended Field with Cullen saying he was just working harder for his constituents than National MPs did. Richard Prebble showed the correct way to respond to allegations of corruption around an MP – Helen Clark did the opposite.
  2. The pledge card Labour’s handling of the pledge card and the Auditor-General’s report was appalling. The should have simply admitted “we got it wrong, and we’ll pay the money back” (as the Greens did). Instead, they allowed the pledge card affair to drag on interminably, and were subjected to daily allegations in Parliament of corruption. They hadn’t actually done anthing that most other political parties had done, but their reluctance to own up to their mistake and put it right undermined public confidence in them as a Government.

    They only conceded to pay the money back after they had taken all the flak for resisting. And the attacks on the Auditor-General were disgraceful.

  3. David Benson-Pope Much like Taito Phillip Field actually, although the allegations were not so serious. The perception was created, through Clark’s continued tolerance of Benson-Pope through the “tennis balls affair” in which he had quite clearly been economical with the truth. He was finally dispatched in July 2007 after allegations of him lying to Parliament over matters relating to the appointment of a Communications Manager in the Ministry for the Environment. Clark said at the time, “The way in which certain issues have been handled this week has led to a loss of credibility and on that basis I have accepted Mr Benson-Pope’s offer to stand aside”. Pity for her that she didn’t realise he had lost credibility much earlier.

    Benson-Pope clearly lied about the tennis ball incident, with 11 or so pupils recalling it. And the issue was not whether or not he was a perfect teacher – it was that he called his former pupils liars and denied an incidents. He created all the problems for himself by the way he went on the attack.

  4. The Electoral Finance Act This was handled by Labour in the most appalling way. The original Bill was so poorly drafted that Justice Minister Mark Burton deserved the sack for allowing a Bill that was such a shambles to come before Parliament. He was later quietly stood down, but by that time the damage had been done. Labour railroaded the Bill through Parliament, refusing to consider very pertinent submissions from organisations such as the Human Rights Commission or suggestions from the Green Party who were left with a “take it or leave it” option. This allowed the right to create the perception of the Electoral Finance Bill, and consequently of Labour, being undemocratic – a task which the NZ Herald took up with great gusto.

    Here I will have a go at Toad. The bloody Greens voted for the EFA, and they voted against many good amendments that would have made it a lot better. They sacrificed any moral high ground on electoral issues with their shameful kowtowing to Labour. If the Greens had the backbone at the beginning to say we won’t vote for this at first reading unless you consult with all parties, then the EFA would never have happened. I’m actually getting sick of how many people on the left are now decrying the EFA, when they never spoke up at the time.

    And while the final EFA was bad enough, I agree Mark Burton should have been shot for letting the original EFB through – that was the most draconian law I have ever seen with statutory declaraions needed to send an e-mail to a mate on a topical issue.

  5. Winston Peters Need I say more. Clark stood by Peters as allegation after allegation of impropriety and, in the last few weeks, even corruption emerged against Peters. In her first and second terms he would have been promptly dispatched, at least temporarily, for allegations of far less substance, but her continued tolerance of him as a Minister allowed her and her government to be tarred with the same brush as Peters.

    Here at least the Greens can take a bow, and did put some heat on Clark. Clark’s legacy will always be tained by her disgraceful defence of Peters, and her total lack of concern with the evidence from the Serious Fraud Office and the Muerant papers about possible policies for cash.

Helen’s legacy

The UN has just published the 2006 greenhouse gas data. It will be another two years for us to see the full impact of Helen’s legacy of total rhetoric and no action. But here are how different countries compare between 1999 and 2006.

Helen talked of reducing net emissions to zero. Kyoto is about getting them back to 1990 levels. But surely Helen managed to at least keep them constant? Nope. From 1999 to 2006, this is the net increase (including offsetting with land use and forests) for various countries:

  1. Sweden -61.8%
  2. Norway -31.8%
  3. Estonia -23.4%
  4. Monaco -21.4%
  5. Finland -9.2%
  6. France -6.3%
  7. Belgium -5.3%
  8. Hungary -4.6%
  9. Slovakia -4.5%
  10. Poland -4.3%
  11. Denmark -3.4%
  12. Netherlands -3.2%
  13. United Kingdom -2.6%
  14. Germany -2.0%
  15. European Community -0.9%
  16. Portugal 0.9%
  17. Japan 0.9%
  18. United States 0.9%
  19. Italy 2.7%
  20. Ireland 3.0%
  21. Liechtenstein 3.9%
  22. Iceland 5.3%
  23. Bulgaria 6.2%
  24. Greece 7.0%
  25. Australia 8.2%
  26. Czech Republic 8.6%
  27. Switzerland 8.8%
  28. Canada 11.0%
  29. New Zealand 12.0%
  30. Spain 18.0%
  31. Turkey 33.3%

Only two industrialised countries (excluding those who are below their Kyoto targets) have a worse record than New Zealand under Helen Clark.

We are also at 33% over our 1990 Kyoto target. The US is only 14% over, and Australia 7% over. The United Kingdom is 16% under.

If Labour try to claim any sort of moral high ground on climate change, just remember these facts. Helen Clark’s record was one of the worst in the world on carbon emissions.

Sage advice from Upton

Simon Upton’s column is always a good read:

And Miss Clark certainly demands respect. Until well into her final term, I was expecting her to win a fourth election. If there is a prime minister in recent history who could have pulled it off, it was she.

There will be all sorts of tipping points and missteps diagnosed with the benefit of hindsight. But right at the outset of the Key administration I would like to highlight an issue of political chemistry that was to my mind insidiously corrosive for Labour.

Very simply, it was the most partisan government since Sir Robert Muldoon’s. And that partisan edge became very wearing.

This is something that has been under-reported.

Miss Clark’s political dna was not predisposed to reaching out any further than the minimum required by MMP’s arithmetic.

Upton suggests four things:

Make it an explicit policy that appointments to the boards of Crown-owned entities will be made strictly on merit. By definition, there will be Labour-leaning appointees who should continue to serve. But it would be entirely reasonable to ask all appointees to be prepared to offer their resignations so that reappointments can be the subject of proper scrutiny. That some of Miss Clark’s egregiously political appointments followed on a long tradition of such appointments by previous National administrations doesn’t enslave Mr Key to that tradition. He could change the game.

I find it incredible Mike Williams has not resigned all his boards yet. How can he serve John Key’s Government when he tried to dig up dirt linking John Key to a massive fraud scandal?

Announce that, from here on, the award of honours will be left in the hands of the governor-general. There can be no harm in our head of state (with some appropriate wise advisory committee) honouring worthy citizens without the party political advice of the government of the day.

Or maybe as a compromise have the very top honours like Order of New Zealand reserved for the Governor-General to decide. However as the PM appoints the Governor-General, this may just result in more partisan appointments as Governor-General.

Decide from day one that there is no need to make every Government press release a partisan declaration. Miss Clark’s media machine turned every announcement into a triumph for “the Labour-led Government”. It was tacky and dreary.

God yes.

Mr Key should make it clear from the outset that he expects public servants to provide free and frank advice that his Government will be happy to accept or reject as it sees fit. This is higher risk because the Official Information Act provides officials with an opportunity to game ministers by offering them explosive material that will swiftly find its way into the public domain. There is no easy answer here, but trust and candour can go a long way. I have reached the view that many policies are best developed in full view, with papers being placed on a ministry’s website before decisions are taken.

I would have all Cabinet papers go automatically on the web after six months.

Other things that would be good for the new Government to do:

  • Not set up sham inquiries designed to find no wrong doing.
  • Actually try and provide answers in the House that have some connection to the question asked
  • Not delay OIA requests for months on end

Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince Trailer

Lots of praise for Key Ministry

There’s so many positive stories I don’t know where to start. Alphabetically maybe with Audrey Young yesterday:

Popular Westie Paula Bennett is the big winner as Minister of Social Development and Employment – one of the biggest jobs overseeing the biggest ministry with the biggest budget.

It has gone to someone with just three years as an MP who has drawn on the DPB herself in the past as a solo mother .

Key said it was not it risk. It is but it one worth taking. She proved herself an able politician quickly in opposition embarrassing plenty more seasoned MPs in Government in early childhood education.

Most people are celebrating Paula’s story of having been a young Maori solo mother, working all sorts of low paid jobs to earn some extra money, educating herself, becoming an MP, winning Waitakere and then becoming Minister of Social Development. It’s a great aspirational story. Alas, the bitterness has not ended with the election campaign, with Clinton Smith labelling her “thick as two short planks”.

Luckily for Labour, Phil Goff is showing his smarts. Goff has resisted the urge to criticise the Cabinet – knowing that doing so may just make him look churlish. He has said he’ll hold them to account, but will give them a fair go in the job.  I am starting to get quite positive about Labour under Goff’s leadership – the mea culpa over the EFA and now this.

Colin Espiner blogged:

John Key’s announced his new Cabinet lineup. It’s not a bad one, either. I think he’s picked through the talent available very well.

Colin also updates us:

On another matter, thanks to everyone who has posted suggestions on helping me eat my words. After much deliberation, I have settled on the suggestion provided by Lizbeth of making a “coalition smoothie” from my blog. I’ll be doing this on video in the press gallery kitchen on Tuesday lunchtime. We hope to have it posted on the Stuff website early afternoon.

Like John Key, I’m keen to try out my kitchen cabinet whiz.

I think Colin should invite the Maori Party MPs to witness it 🙂

On the Greens G-blog, Stevedore blogs:

And Key seems to be giving it his best shot. The arrangement he has put together seems to reflect what people voted for. The cabinet he has announced looks a lot more diverse, fresh and representative than it threatened to be a few months ago.  The whole thing looks stable and consultative.  Which is exactly what MMP should provide.

Tim Selwyn at Tumeke provides lots of provocative commentary.

Barnsley Bill invents a new term – a SDMILF. Oh dear. Paula may need to warn the Diplomatic Protection Squad!

John Armstrong writes this morning:

The message is loud and clear: to survive as a minister in John Key’s Cabinet, you’re going to have to perform.

That will make a nice change.

Key has taken a less sentimental approach to Cabinet construction than previous Prime Ministers, with somewhat more emphasis on talent and ability and slightly less stress on loyalty and length of service.

Indeed. Although some appointments could still be seen as sentimental – but overall many fresh new faces.

The Herald has a summary of business and industry reaction, and lobby groups here.

The Herald editorial calls the Ministry solid and safe:

The line-up looks to be a good mixture of fresh faces and experience. …

As Associate Minister of Maori Affairs, Georgina te Heuheu will have a seat at the Cabinet table while the minister, the Maori Party’s Pita Sharples, will not. They will have to be in tune. So will Paula Bennett and Tariana Turia, minister and associate minister respectively of social development and employment. Ms Bennett, who has known life on a benefit, is the most unexpected of Mr Key’s appointment and perhaps the most inspired.

The Dom Post editorial calls it the bold and the new.

John Key has shown wisdom beyond his political years by tempering boldness with caution in naming his new ministers, The Dominion Post writes.

In opting for the promise of a Steven Joyce over the experience of a John Carter, Mr Key is reflecting his own rise to the top after only six years in Parliament. Time served is not an indication of talent.

However, neither has he left out in the cold any of those who would have reasonably expected to make it. There would have been dangers in doing that. Mr Carter, along with Maurice Williamson and Richard Worth, his fellow ministers outside Cabinet, have all been given a clear signal that this is as good as it will get.

But they have not been humiliated. Left to languish on the back benches, they could have devoted their time to sowing discord and undermining the leader who failed to give them anything else to do.

Being a Minister outside Cabinet is still a hell of a lot better than not being a Minister at all.

Mr Key’s decisions in allocating ministerial positions underline that he is seeking to advance his agenda through consensus rather than by bulldozing it through. The naming of his ministers is a good start to his administration.

Yep.

The only quibble is that he convinced himself he was unable to trim his ministry from a bloated 28. Maintaining an executive of that size means that his plans to reduce the Wellington bureaucracy will be greeted with a measure of justified cynicism.

I also wanted it less than 28. But as one can see, there were enough upset MPs anyway. Technically his promise is to keep the Wellington bureaucracy from growing further, so keeping the Executive the same size is consistent.

Martin Kay in the Dom Post provides useful commentary on each Minister.

An odd report in the ODT, with Dene Mackenzie bizarrely labelling the Cabinet a move to the right. Dropping Lockwood Smith and Maurice Williamson from Cabinet is as far from a move to the right as you can get. Replacing Judith Collins with Paula Bennett is Welfare is not a move to the right. Giving Bill English infrastructure is not a move to the right.

So when Dene says:

His new Cabinet, which will be sworn in tomorrow, shows a bias to the Right despite moves during the election campaign to position National as a centrist party.

could someone ask him for an example?

The ODT editorial is better:

The immediate response is that Mr Key has continued in his briskly positive mode and got the balance about right.

Now comes the difficult part: moulding this executive into an effective and harmonious team able to put longstanding differences aside and address the many issues facing the country – not least the recession and the international financial crisis.

If anyone inspires confidence with his experience and economic competence it is Mr English, on whom much of the burden will fall.

Overall, very positive responses.

For the musically inclined

More irony from the United Nations

The Washington Post reports on how the United Nations is having a two day conference on religious tolerance. It has chosen Saudia Arabia to chair the conference.

Saudi Arabia:

  • bans the public practice of non-Islamic religions
  • views its interpretation of Islamic law as its sole source of guidance on human rights
  • Muslims who do not follow the official strict and conservative version of Sunni Islamcan face severe repercussions at the hands of Mutawwa’in (religious police)
  • forbids missionary work by any religion other than Wahabi/Salafi Islam
  • Jewish, Christian or Hindu houses of prayer are not allowed
  • the government can search the home of anyone and arrest or deport foreign workers for owning religious icons and symbols
  • Under Saudi law conversion by a Muslim to another religion is considered apostasy, a crime punishable by death if the accused does not recant.

Yes the perfect country to chair a UN conference on religious tolerance – one that executes you if you swap to a non tolerated religion

Hat Tip: Micky’s Muses

Comments on the Key Ministry

Key taking Tourism was pre-announced, and smart as it is key to economic growth and also a feel-good portfolio.

English is the logical choice for Infrastructure, as the money for the capital works goes with Finance. It was either him or Key to do it.

Brownlee is as expected. Power picks up a heavy workload with SOEs and Commerce on top of Justice. Probably had to arm wrestle Chris Finlayson for the Law Commission.

Ryall picks up State Services , and Nick Smith ACC on top of their current portfolios. Both will cope easily.

Collins trade in Social Welfare for Police and Corrections, plus Veterans Affairs where she will be very popular with her Agent Orange work. National Governments die if they are seen as soft on law & order, so her movement these is astute.

Tolley and Finlayson are as expected, but Finlayson moves onto the front bench as the only 2005 intake on it.

Carter and McCully as expected. Groser is no surprise for Trade but usefully is also given international negotiations for climate change and Conservation.

Mapp as expected, and Steven Joyce picks up a very weightly workload at No 14 – Transport, Comms/IT, Associate Finance and Associate Infrastructure. He will be carrying some big expectations.

Georgina te Heuheu picks up a variety of roles from Courts, to Disarmament and will work with Pta Sharples as Associate Maori Affairs.

The big mover up is Paula Bennett. She may only be No 16, but she has the Welfare portfolios under their new names. This is a huge portfolio for an MP who has been in just three years. Having been a “Maori solo mother” herself, Paula will make it very hard for Labour to characterise National as heartless.

Heatley is as expected, and Pansy Wong becomes the first Asian Cabinet Minister and is an Associate Minister in two of her former portfolios of ACC and Energy.

Jonathan Coleman and Kate Wilkinson finish the Cabinet. The years each entered are:

1987 – 1
1990 – 3
1994 – 1
1996 – 4
1999 – 3
2002 – 2
2005 – 5
2008 – 1

So 11 of them entered Parliament after the last National Government. And of the nine who entered previously, only six have been Ministers before.

Outside Cabinet, you have Maurice WIlliamson, Richard Worth, and John Carter. Key has obviously used the spots outside Cabinet to place people he did not have room for in Cabinet. They are all highly likely, I suspect, to be replaced before the full three years is up with some new Ministers from the 2005 or even 2008 intakes.

Logically one would also expect most of the Ministers from the 1990s (except English) to consider retirement in 2011. If some do not retire, then there will be real pressure from the 2005 and 2008 intakes.

So who missed out?

Tau Henare is probably the most upset – he is a former Minister, and was keen to serve again. Lindsay Tisch and Paul Hutchison also missed out, but I expect will chair Select Committees.

And who might move up as vacancies occur? Watch out for Nathan Guy, Chris Tremain, Craig Foss, Jo Goodhew, Chester Borrows, Jackie Blue, John Hayes, Jacqui Dean and others to compete for spots in a couple of years time. Also Hekia Parata and others from the 2008 intake will be chasing those spots also.

Overall it looks a pretty good Cabinet, with some real talent.  28 Ministers is too large though, with some Ministers looking like they have a pretty light workload. And Labour will be a tough Opposition that will target new or vulnerable Ministers, plus try and highlight those Ministers they think are “doing a Tizard”.