Online reporting banned

I’ve just been interviewed by Radio NZ on the ruling by Judge Harvey that media are allowed to report the names of two murder accused, but that online media can not. The interview should be on Morning Report tomorrow.

Now Judge Harvey is not some fuddy duddy Judge who does not understand the Internet. He is in fact probably the most tech-savvy Judge we have, and he is the author of the main textbook on Internet law in NZ. I actually first met the Judge many years ago through Usenet, the Internet newsgroups.

Judge Harvey seems to be trying to do a middle course between total name supression and no name supression. It is an interesting concept, but one that does raise significant issues.

As far as I can tell he is not worried if potential jurors hear the name on the news tonight or in the newspaper tomorrow, but doesn’t want them to be able to Google the name (and I have just done Google searches on their names) once the trial starts. The issue of jurors doing research on defendeants on Google is a growing problem.

However by banning the names online, this may lead to overseas blogs reporting the names deliberately. In fact overseas newspapers may also do so, as this ruling may be one of the first in the world – to apply only to Internet media.

It also gives local media a challenge. It is pretty obvious the NZ Herald has to remove the name from its web version of its stories. And TVNZ and Radio NZ can not have the names in their web stories. But does TVNZ and Radio NZ etc have to remove the names from the digital version of their audio and video files? They will not be picked up in Google, but are online. Also are there issues with live streaming of their broadcasts?

Blogs may have some issues also, as commenters may have mentioned the names of accussed, but the blog owner may not be aware those names are the names that have been supressed. Oh it goes without saying I will be unimpressed if anyone mentions their names on this blog.

I hear various media are looking to appeal the decision. It is certainly going to be fascinating either way for those of us interested in technology and media law.

High Court hearing on Electoral Commission and EPMU

I’ve been at the Wellington High Court all day, listening to arguments in the court case over whether the Electoral Commission was correct to allow the EPMU to register as a third party, or was the EPMU a person involved in the administration of the affairs of the Labour Party.

There is a significant barrier for the plaintiff (National) to overcome. Courts are traditionally reluctant to second guess the decisions of specialist or expert bodies such as the Electoral Commission. The court will only act if they Commission has clearly made an error in law, or reached a conclusion that is so unreasonable it is untenable. So if the action fails, it does not necessarily mean the Court has decided the Electoral Commission made the right decision. It means that the decision was a reasonable decision to make.

Obviously National, as plaintiffs, think it was an unreasonable decision and that there were errors in law. National probably had three major strings to its case:

  1. The Electoral Commission erred in not obtaining a copy of the EPMU constitution which states in their Rule 23 that the National Executive (or a sub-committee of it) shall appoint all delegates from the EPMU to Labour Party committees at national, regional and electorate level. This goes against the contention that EPMU members are there just as members, not representing the EPMU
  2. The Electoral Commission erred in interpreting “involved in the administration of the affairs of a party” as menial administrative tasks and not governance. The analogy of a company director was used – they sit on the board and govern, but are considered to be involved in the administration. There is no case law anywhere on this point, so it was argued from first principles and dictionary definitions. I have mentioned elsewhere that under the Commission’s interpretation even a Party President could be seen as not involved in the administration, which makes the whole ineligibility clause almost meaningless.
  3. That while Andrew Little was elected Affiliates Vice-President by the Labour Conference, he is bound by the EPMU rules to act in the best interests of the EPMU. But also, even putting aside the nature of Andrew’s role on the National Council, there is no question the EPMU has direct representation on all 69 Electorate Committees, all the local body committees and all six Regional Councils, and that this constitutes involvement in the administration of the affairs.

It would be a brave person who predicts the outcome, as Justice MacKenzie was giving nothing away with his body language and asked no significant questions to either side. As I said above, it is a very significant hurdle to get over, to persuade the Court to “second guess” (and Crown Law pushed strongly that they should not do so in this case), but I thought the lawyers for National did a good job arguing the case that this was one of those times where they should. But again, no predictions on outcome from me.

Of course I am more than an interested bystander as I wrote the original letters which raised the eligibility issue, so I smiled at the number of times the words “Farrar affadavit” came up in court.  Regardless of the outcome, it will be a very interesting judgement to consider.

Will the Greens sacrifice themselves for the ETS?

As previously stated, I think the Greens have informally already decided to back the ETS, despite the failure to get any significant concessions.

The PM has said:

If the emissions trading scheme did not pass into law, the Prime Minister said she would make it a “major election issue”.

Now if I were the Greens, I’d be thinking about why on Earth they would possibly want to remove the biggest most important issue as an election issue? They are hovering just above 5%, and are about to take away their biggest issue and basically portray themselves as no different to Labour. Have they thought about the message it gives to Green supporters? It is, vote for us and achieve the same as voting for Labour on the most important environmental issue of our lifetime?

Clark does not want climate change as a major election issue. Her record on emissions is so hollow, Nicky Hager could turn it into a sequel. Emissions under Helen Clark have grown faster (in relative terms) than under George W Bush or John Howard, The last thing she wants is climate change as an issue. National will quietly probably be quite glad if the Greens back it, and it goes through. So it will be good for Labour and National, and bad for the Greens politically.

Have the Greens considered what they could grow their vote to, if they said the ETS doesn’t achieve enough, and we won’t back it. They could campaign on Labour’s disasterous record with carbon emissions, how National would be little different and only a vote for the Greens will make a difference on climate change. With a good campaign manager they could get 10% of the vote I reckon.

Toad makes similiar points of g.blog. I’d also point out that under Labour’s ETS no major emitting sector comes in until 2011 anyway, so a year’s delay in the legislation is not the same as a year’s delay in a sector coming into an ETS.

My advice enough is not Trojan Horse advice – it is the advice I would give the Greens if I was their campaign manager. I don’t actually have a strong concern about the differences between the desired Greens ETS, Labour’s ETS and a National ETS. The ETS is a very long term game, and I don’t get too excited over a year’s delay or not for a sector.  NZ’s actual impact on carbon emissions is close to zero. We need an ETS so we do our part as a good global citizen, and so we do not get affected by environmental trade barriers. But let us not think that transport coming into the ETS in 2009 or 2011 will affect global temperatures at all.

Mayor Mark

Saturday’s Dominion Post had three article on Mark Blumsky.

The first confirms that Mark will stand for Mayor of Wellington in 2010, as Kerry Prendergast is not seeking a fourth term.

The second is about Mark’s term as an MP, and how unhappy he has basically been as an Opposition MP, and plans for the future:

Mr Blumsky’s future plans are mapped out on a long list. Among other commitments, he’s on the board at his daughter’s school, has bought the New Zealand rights to an electronic game cards product, and is considering two franchises. He is also a business adviser and he’s setting up a Cuba Precinct Business and Residents Association.

All worthy causes and interests, but his eyes are on a bigger prize, with a mayoral election in October 2010.

In the corner of his third floor office, Mr Blumsky has a fat red folder bulging with scraps of paper. It’s titled “Wellington Flavours,” and in it he has squirrelled away a year’s worth of ideas on what he’d do if he won the mayoralty again.

There are speeches he’d give, articles on successful cities, and pamphlets from councils around the world.

And the third is about that mystery attack in 2005:

Mark Blumsky says he has met the “lovely young man” who punched him in the face, blackening his eye and denting his campaign as a National candidate for Wellington Central in 2005. …

Mr Blumsky said a woman later called him and revealed her boyfriend was the assailant.

They arranged to meet, and the young man, who was 17 at the time, said Mr Blumsky had caught him smoking cannabis in the stairwell and had confiscated it.

The young man punched Mr Blumsky, sending him hurtling down the stairs.

“Story is: I tried to take his joint off him.”

Mr Blumsky said the youth was “a lovely young man” and very apologetic.

The youth had told Mr Blumsky that he was too young to be in the bar, and that was why he had run off.

Some people will by cynical about this, but Mark told me soon after the incident about the girlfriend of the assailant coming forward. She didn’t want her boyfriend to be arrested but was very sorry for what had happened. Mark didn’t want to break her trust by giving her name to the media, and it was thought that revealing what she said, without naming her, would not convince those who thought the injuries were not the result of an assault, and would just keep the story alive for longer.

The Transmogrification story

Aaron Bhatnagar has written a book, which political junkies would find fascinating – the inside story of how John Banks came back from his thrashing in 2004 to win by a massive majority in 2007.

Aaron has not yet chosen how he will publish it, but he is blogging some of the chapters. Up so far are Chapter 1 (Well dressed for the collapse), Chapter 4 (The city starts to turn), and Chapter 6 (Polling starts). I had some involvement with the campaign, and it was one of the most fascinating ones I have experienced.

Most campaigns are like most wars – the plan changes the moment the first bullet is fired. The Banks campaign had a strategy and plan that was basically never deviated from. The early polling (which was my role) showed the extent of Hubbard’s unpopularity and that Aucklanders were willing to give John a second go. This meant that a campaign could be developed that pushed a positive message from Banks, and almost ignored Hubbard. There was no need to remind people of how bad Hubbard had been – they already knew it.

One of the reasons I love polling is it does give you a glimpse of what is happening with the public, and the detailed breakdowns by ward showed some amazing turn-arounds with both Banks and C&R being competitive in areas that were traditionally hostile.

Anyway I’ll let Aaron carry on telling the story, but link through from time to time. As I said, most students of politics will find it an interesting read, regardless of whether or not they are a Banks fan or not.

Shock horror: SST turns on PM

The Beehive must be in crisis mode. The Sunday Star-Times launched a savage attack on the Prime Minister in yesterday’s editorial.

Their editorial was full of praise for the Prime Minister and her handling of Foreign Affairs. It was an editorial worthy of a nobel peace prize nomination. But they ruined it towards the end, with just two words. They conceded the Prime Minister was “not perfect”.

Such savage press criticism can not be tolerated. I am sure the PM’s Office will be complaining to the Press Council and asking the Sunday Star-Times to justify its editorial position that the Prime Minister is “not perfect”.

Mission Australia

The CEO of Mission Australia writes in the Herald about the smear and fear campaign about his organisation and National:

I thought I’d headed a team of people whose main objective was transforming the lives of homeless people, getting kids off drugs, mending broken families and finding work for the long-term unemployed.

Turns out, if you believe some commentators and politicians, I’m actually the head of an organisation hell-bent on nothing less than the destruction of New Zealand’s community voluntary sector.

If you believe the lunatic fringe, Mission Australia is in secret cahoots with John Key and National to become a “super contractor” of community and employment services in New Zealand – wiping out all small community and tangata whenua-based welfare groups before us – should they become the Government this year.

The lunatic fringe can describe so many groups and people – he should be more specific!

Mission Australia is a charity with a history of close to 150 years of transforming the lives of individuals and families in need.

We work in hundreds of communities around Australia – metropolitan, rural and remote. We employ local people to manage services that meet local needs.

We’re a diverse group – more than 30 per cent of our staff are from non-English-speaking backgrounds, and 3 per cent are indigenous (indigenous Australians make up 2.5 per cent of the country’s total population) and more than 5 per cent of our employees have a disability.

And a number, like me, are Kiwis. We have no ambitions other than to eliminate disadvantage and create a fairer society.

Heartless bastards. That is the role of the Government, not the private sector. How dare they interfere?

One of the accusations made against us is that as a large charity we operate at the expense of smaller groups. I would love our critics to point out just one instance where this has occurred on my watch.

On the contrary, I can point to several hundred millions of dollars that have gone to small grassroots organisations because of our advocacy. Mission Australia partners many smaller community groups to deliver services around the country.

We use our experience and resources at the strategic level, our partners then roll out programmes using their local knowledge.

We also use our “backroom” expertise in research and social policy, IT, finance and human resources to lift a range of burdens from our partners, freeing them up to do what they’re best at – helping people in need.

But but but if big business means evil business, then big charity must mean evil charity?

I said in an interview with the New Zealand Herald recently that Mission Australia, given the right opportunity, would jump at the chance to work in New Zealand. Why? We believe we can do a better job of helping disadvantaged New Zealanders.

If we do come to New Zealand it will be in partnership with local community groups – including tangata whenua.

As a New Zealander, I don’t share the arrogance of some my countrymen in the social sector who think we can’t learn from the experience of community service organisations from abroad. Or that needy New Zealanders can’t benefit from small tangata whenua community groups partnering larger agencies – even those from Australia.

By all means, let us debate the future of New Zealand’s community voluntary sector – under a National or Labour government – and how best we can help people in need.

But let’s base those talks on fact and not unfounded scaremongering and outright lies.

But that is the basis of the Government’s entire election campaign? You know state house eviction notices and the like. Mission Australia will just be another victim if they make a worthwhile target.

The history of the Internet in NZ

Anthony Doesburg reviews “Connecting the Clouds” which is a history of the Internet in NZ, by Keith Newman.

The book was launched last Thursday in Wellington. I was somewhat gutted I was in Auckland and unable to attend, as I actually helped commission the book, proposing some years ago to InternetNZ that we should get such a book written while all the original pioneers were still around.

As Anthony notes, Keith Newman more than delivered, with the 100,000 word project expanding to 400,000 words.

The book will not make the best seller lists, but for those with an interest in the Internet and its development, it should be a fascinating read. Like most books, it is best to have the hardcopy so one can read in comfort, but it has also been made available online at nethistory.net.nz, which will be kept updated into the future. It is in wiki format which will allow others to contribute over time to it.

Tolls for new roads

Maurice Williamson on Agenda yesterday confirmed that National would look to speed up construction of new roads with private-public partnerships and tolls.

The party’s transport spokesman, Maurice Williamson, said yesterday that commuters could face bills of up to $50 a week for tolls of $3 to $5 a trip on new motorways or similar “roads of national importance”.

But he believed that most people, if given a choice between tolls or queuing on free roads, would gladly pay.

Also free roads are not free. They are just funded through petrol tax. I think it is vitally important that users of roads pay for them, and tolls are better at doing that, plus will allow for some roads to happen, which would not have happened otherwise.

He believed an obstacle to public acceptance of tolls had been removed by a new law requiring all money raised from fuel taxes to be paid into the national land transport fund.

“I think New Zealanders will now say, ‘Well okay, if it is going to provide a solution to a problem I face and you are not stealing my petrol tax, well then I’ll go for it’.”

Another policy Labour stole from National!

Transport Minister Annette King accused Mr Williamson of not thinking his toll plans through properly.

She said that even if the $365 million Albany-to-Puhoi toll road, to open early next year, had “maximised” use, a $2 toll would still pay only half its cost.

So what? Half is better than none.

But she said the Labour-led Government believed strongly there was a place for PPPs.

But I thought they were evil privatisations in drag?

Mr Williamson listed these possible candidates for tolls:

  • Auckland’s next crossing of the Waitemata Harbour (expected to cost at least $4 billion).
  • Auckland’s motorway tunnels through Waterview on the western ring route ($1.9 billion).
  • A 19km motorway extension to Warkworth or beyond ($1 billion-plus).
  • Completion of the Waikato Expressway on State Highway 1 ($1 billion).
  • Kopu Bridge, on the way to Coromandel Peninsula ($32 million).

Don’t forget Transmission Gully!

Hickey says end the property tax break

Bernard Hickey in the HoS calls for an end to being able to deduce investment property lossess off your personal income tax:

It is the elephant in the room of New Zealand politics. Everyone knows it, yet our leaders refuse to address it, partly because they and their generation benefited personally through the massive house price inflation it created.

I’m talking about the abuse of the tax system by property investors that has allowed them to establish various types of trusts and loss attributing qualifying companies (LAQCs) that make losses on investment rental properties to reduce their personal income tax bills.

This was among the major reasons for the property investment frenzy of the past six years that drove house prices to unaffordable levels and has now created the conditions for a bursting of that bubble.

It would be good to see some hard data on how much of the price increases can be credited to the tax treatment, and how much to land supply etc.

The Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet wrote a report on house prices and affordability in March. It showed landlord numbers rose more than 100,000 to 300,000 in the decade to 2006. The report estimates the $149 billion of rental property generates a tax benefit of at least $700 million for property investors, with the potential for up to $1.8b of tax benefits.

The Reserve Bank has asked the politicians to consider ring- fencing these investment property losses to remove some of the hot air pumping up the housing bubble.

But there isn’t a politician addressing the issue seriously.

Well I doubt anyone wants to lose the 300,000 votes such a move would result in.

Could such a change be grandfathered in? That would be inequitable but possibly the only way politically to do it.

Obama picks Biden as VP

Barack Obama has chosen Senator Joe Biden as his Vice-Presidential candidate.

Biden is 65 years old and one of the more experiences Senators – especially in foreign policy. He sought the Democratic nomination 20 years ago in 1988 and was briefly a candidate this time also.

He entered the Senate when I was five years old – in 1973, so has served 36 years there. His age when elected, 30, is the constitutional minimum to be a Senator.

Unlike Obama (who was not in the Senate then), Biden voted in favour of the resolution authorising war in Iraq in 2002.

His 1988 presidental campaign was derailed by plagiarism scandals.

Often VP choices are made to balance the ticket – make it more electable. The Biden choice is of course also about electability, but more about negating fears of Obama’s inexperience that appealing to a specific demographic. It seems a pretty solid choice. The only downside is he undermines Obama’s brand as being about change, but I doubt it will seriously impact that.

The Green charade

Some people have suggested I am too cynical in thinking the Greens consultation is a charade, and it is a PR stunt for a decision already made. However Bill Ralston points out an interesting aspect:

I suspect it is largely a stunt to gain them more publicity because they are languishing in the polls and urgently need to galvanise some voter support.

This suspicion was reinforced when Jeanette Fitzsimons was asked if her caucus was split on how the party should vote.

She replied she would not know until next Tuesday’s caucus because she had not spoken to her MPs.

Good grief. There are only half a dozen of them and the carbon footprint from six phone calls to find out what they thought would not be too great, surely?

Fitzsimons and her cunning co-leader Russel Norman are trying to drag out the issue with this bit of theatre to gain maximum media coverage in the run-up to the election.

Can there be any credibility around the statement that the six Greens MPs have not even discussed what their position should be? I mean seriously? So who decided to ask the public for consultation? Wouldn’t that have been a Caucus decision?

I am so convinced they have already decided to back the scheme, despite their failure to get any meaningful concessions, that I was planning to offer $1,000 to someone willing to bet that they would decide not to back the ETS Bill.

I was going to let the market decide the odds, by letting people state how much they would be willing to pay me if the Greens announce they are backing the ETS Bill, and the highest bidder wins. So if someone was willing to give me $100 (and that was the highest bid) if the Greens back the scheme I’d give them $1,000 if the Greens do not back the scheme. I suspect no one would be willing to go much over $100, or 10:1 odds as they near certain to lose.

Sadly however such a harmless little bet would land me in breach of the Gambling Act 2003, so I can’t do it. However people are welcome to post how much they would have been willing to bid as a bet for a chance to get $1,000.  But you would have lost that money to me should the Greens announce on Tuesday they will be backing the ETS Bill despite gaining no significant concessions.

Another secret trust fund!

Tim Selwyn will need to update his diagram, as the Herald on Sunday has unearthed another secret trust fund for NZ First.

The documents firstly confirm the existence of the Winston Peters Fighting Fund Trust.

This was established in February 1993 specifically to pay legal costs associated with Peters’ legal battles – such as the high-profile defamation action taken against him by businessman Selwyn Cushing.

This trust, of which Peters is listed in the documents as one of three trustees, is separate to the secretive Spencer Trust, which Peters has said he had no knowledge of.

The story has more information about the bills that were sent to the trust for paying.

So in the last few months we have now learnt of the following ways big business funds NZ First and Winston Peters:

  1. Directly to NZ First by breaking up their large donations into smaller ones through using different company accounts
  2. Through Brian Henry by donating money to Brian Henry who then doesn’t charge Peters
  3. Through the Spencer Trust, which Peters’ staff solicit money for
  4. Through the Winston Peters Fighting Fund Trust

How many more funding routes are there to be discovered?

The Privileges Committee should be very interested in this latest trust. Based on its name, it would appear that Peters has a beneficial interest in the Trust. Does it still exist? If so, it should have been declared on the Register of MPs Pecuniary interests if Peters is a beneficiary of it.

If it no longer exists, when did it get wound up? Was it just before the Register was established?

Cheaper iPhone plans

All about Winston

So many articles, so where to start. First is the Herald editorial on racing:

When Winston Peters was appointed Racing Minister in 2005, he was warmly welcomed by leaders of the industry. “He’s going to be good for racing,” said high-profile breeder Sir Patrick Hogan. Even he, however, may not have realised the degree of beneficence.

To the contrary it is possible the degree of beneficence was precisely known!

Then we have Fran O’Sullivan who calls Peters a coward basically:

If Winston Peters was man enough he would apologise to leading New Zealand political journalists for the outrageous way he attacked them for questioning whether Labour’s major donor Owen Glenn had contributed anonymous funds to New Zealand First.

New Zealand now knows the vile allegations and innuendo that Peters accused journalists of spreading early this year were not that far off the mark. But Peters’ continuing reliance on bravado and counter-punches instead of confronting the real issues means his political reputation is punctured.

Peters actually suggested the NZ Herald had fabricated the e-mail from Owen Glenn.

It’s abundantly clear that Peters’ political interests and those of his party have been served by plenty of cash from wealthy donors, contrary to the public picture he has painted.

The claims he made early this year that New Zealand First had had no big-business backing since its inception have been exposed as fatuous.

Indeed, it is quite possible the NZ First receives a greater proportion of its income from big business than any other party, if you include the Spencer Trust and Brian Henry in the mix.

The cost of the Selwyn Cushing lawsuit has been estimated to be $445,000. Where did the money for that come from?

But unfortunately the Peters donations furore does obscure the real scandal the NZ First leader continues to duck. The party’s refusal to send a cheque to the Crown for the $158,000 in unlawful spending at the 2005 election is breathtakingly cynical.

Doling out this money – which rightfully belongs in taxpayer’s coffers – to a swag of unnamed charities doesn’t cut it for a politician who made his name on challenging commercial malfeasance. He should not be let off the hook.

Indeed. And now John Armstrong:

He answered questions with questions. He deemed questions which he considered outside the committee’s terms of reference to be irrelevant and therefore not to be answered.

It was less the Spanish Inquisition and more like A Game of Two Halves.

As always, everyone else made allowance for Peters’ verbal pugilism – just as the teams on the television sports quiz tolerate Matthew Ridge’s exhibitionism. MPs are so accustomed to Peters’ stroppiness that no one on the committee would have found his behaviour out of the ordinary.

Yet any member of the public delivering the string of insults to committee members which Peters did would have been called to order.

Peters claims of a Spanish inquisition just shows how unused he is to the idea of accountability. He has for 15 years run his party without question. He has secret trust funds which his staff solicit money for, and his party president and deputy leader know nothing about.

He was not bound by the normal laws of politics. He freely broke them without penalty. That has changed – dramatically so in the last month as NZ First has been found to be as solicitous of donations from the wealthy as other parties that it so long accused of being venal and corrupt.

If Peters tries to take the moral high ground again, then laughter is the only appropriate response.

The Dim-Post also sums things up well:

What is interesting about this arrangement is that Brian Henry is a scion of the famous Henry family who, along with the Fletcher’s and the Todd’s, were one of the wealthiest and most influential industrial dynasty’s in New Zealand history. Wikipedia has an extensive entry on the family.

So this is yet another case of Peter’s benefiting from the largese of the super-rich, a group he still claims to be waging a one man war against. There’s no way of knowing the value of Mr Henry’s legal services to Peters over the years but it seems reasonable to assume the amount runs to many hundreds of thousands of dollars.

Winston Peter’s claims to have been the prey of a conspiracy of secretive, elite businessmen but with the New Zealand First leader recieving clandestine donations from Owen Glenn, the Vela family and Sir Robert Jones and free legal services from an industralist heir it looks more and more as if Mr Peters is a member of a covert super-rich conspiracy rather than a victim.

What more can one say?

The Families Commission

Simon Collins at the NZ Herald looks at what may happen to the Families Commission:\

New Families Commission head Jan Pryor is surprisingly relaxed for someone whose new empire may be wiped out in a few months time.

Her predecessor, Dr Rajen Prasad, also 62, is tipped to be named on Labour’s election list next Saturday.

That would be an interesting twist to the term rejuvenation.

For National, the most likely election winner, this may be the final insult from a body it has never liked. National MP Judith Collins has not forgotten that Prasad attacked former National leader Don Brash after his 2005 Orewa speech for “driving a wedge” between families on domestic purposes benefit and other families.

By contrast, she says, the commission has never criticised any Labour policy. She is coy about whether National will again propose merging the commission with the Children’s Commissioner as it did at the last election, but it’s clear that the commission is fighting for its life.

I have a list of three commissions which could go – electricity, tertiary education and families. It is a growing list!

The smacking vote

As expected, the anti-anti-smacking petition got the required number of signatures, and a postal referendum will be held within 12 months – probably the first half of 2009.

It is a pity that signatures were not gained a bit earlier, so that it would have been even harder for Helen Clark to not hold the vote alongside the general election.

I suspect the referendum will have only around 20% voting in favour of criminalising a smack as part of good parental correction, and 80% against. The turnout will be interesting.

The challenge will be for the Government in office at the time. Refusing to make any change at all to the law could be politically risky. The sensible compromise would be what should have been the compromise all along – the Borrows amendment.

No Right Turn on Tan

Idiot/Savant takes a principled stand on the suspension of Shawn Tan by the EPMU, due to his candidacy for ACT:

That’s just not on. It’s unfair, it compromises the right of everyone to participate directly in our democracy, and if the political shoe had been on the other foot – if Tan had worked for Business NZ and was standing for Labour – they would be shouting this to the heavens.

Indeed you could just imagine the outcry. It would probably be led by, umm, unions such as the EPMU.

But quite apart from being unfair and hypocritical, it is also illegal. “Political opinion” is a prohibited ground of discrimination in the Human Rights Act. Employers are forbidden from refusing to employ someone, offer them less favourable terms and conditions and opportunities, or terminate or subject them to any detriment, on the basis of their political beliefs. While there is rightly an exemption for work of a political nature, it only covers political advisors to politicians or candidates, or employees of a political party. And as the Electoral Commission noted a few weeks ago, the EPMU isn’t the Labour Party.

And that case goes to court on Monday incidentally.

S21(1)(j) is the section in the Human Rights Act that prohibits discrimination in employment on the basis of political opinion.

The Electoral Act also goes to some length to protect the rights of people to stand for Parliament. s52 deals with how ever state servants are allowed as of right to stand for Parliament, with some provisions about how they are only temporarily stood down.

I/S concludes:

The EPMU should give Tan his job back. And otherwise, they deserve to be taken to the cleaners over this.

It would be a fascinating court case. Presumably the EPMU would not represent Mr Tan against the EPMU. I suggest he joins UNITE!

There are many many issues I disgaree with NRT on, and some of his posts enrage me, as I am sure mine sometimes enrage him. But posts like the above is why he remains the most respected voice on the left in the blogosphere.

The Green Party “consultation”

As I blogged at NBR, I think the Green Party consultation is a sham, and the decision is already effectively made.

Chris Trotter is assuming it is genuine, and unimpressed with the leap away from Burkian principles:

Basically, this is avoidance behaviour on a truly disreputable scale. The Greens know that the ETS falls well short of what they believe (and what all the evidence suggests) is necessary. Equally, they know that nothing better is on offer from any party with the power to deliver on its promises. They have bitter memories of what happened to them the last time they took a stand on principle against Labour (over the issue of genetic modification) and don’t want to repeat the experience. Realistically, they appreciate that backing the ETS is the only viable political decision they can make. But they don’t want to make it. So, in a politician’s version of making another cup of coffee instead of going out to dig the garden as promised, they have appealed to “the people” for guidance.

Trotter then uses one of my favourites quotes from Edmund Burke:

Your representative owes you, not his industry only, but his judgment; and he betrays instead of serving you if he sacrifices it to your opinion.

Chris goes on to ask where was this commitment to follow the people when they foisted the anti-smacking law on a populace that didn’t want it. So he concludes:

Really, the whole Green Party deserves a damn good smacking!

And Danyl at the Dim Post in unimpressed:

Aren’t the Green MP’s supposed to be experts in this very area? Don’t they claim to know more about it than almost everyone in the country? And haven’t they specifically been elected on the basis of this expertise with the expectation that they can make informed decisions about environmental policy?

They’ve spent the last three years lecturing the country in a condescending manner to ‘buy kiwi made’ and not to smack your kids – but when it comes to the issue that is the raison d’etre for their party they’re little lost sheep.

As Paula points out this might just be a stunt, or a bargaining strategy. If that’s the case its a conspicuously stupid one.

It is a stunt, and I feel sorry for all the people who take the time to e-mail in their views on a decision that has already been made in substance, if not in form.

A dispatch from Yes Minister

Today’s Dispatch from Helengrad is up on the NBR website. I’ve titled it a “Yes Minister consultation” in reference to the farce of a consultation the Green Party are undertaking on the Emissions Trading Scheme, when it is obvious they have swalled a king size dead rat and are going to back Labour’s ETS despite winning no major  concessions. The bulletpoint summary is:

  • Best Play of the Week: Greens get an A- for their u-turn on the ETS
  • Worst Play of the Week: A D to the IRD for their retrospective application of a change of policy on GST in the tourism sector
  • The Winston and Brian scandal/show gets an A- with the best yet to come with Owen Glenn
  • A rock bottom E- to the Electoral Finance Act for creating so much uncertainty that the Health Ministry has delayed portions of their cervical cancer public health campaign. Madness.
  • And Colin James gets promoted to Honorary Blogger and gets a B+ for raising the worthy issue of a fixed date for elections. I support this and also push for term limits!

Comments and feedback welcome over on NBR.

More on ACT list

At dinner last night were candidates 1, 2, 3 and 4 on the ACT Party List. Someone joked I should get a photo with them and announce that I am the secret No 5 candidate 🙂

There has been some discussion as to why long time stalwart and candidate Lindsay Mitchell was not on the list. Lindsay explains on her own blog that she refused the No 14 spot as she was No 9 in 2005, and didn’t feel her performance warranted a demotion. Lindsay certainly has been tireless in advocating for ACT, and has a lot of sympathy for her position.

Idiot/Savant at No Right Turn compares the 2005 and 2008 lists. His table starkly illustrates the change. Of the top 12 candidates in 2008, only two of them (Rodney and Heather) were even candidates in 2005. In fact only seven of their top 30 candidates were candidates in 2005.

I met yesterday their No 10 candidate, Shawn Tan. Shawn struck me a very nice and dedicated guy, but has been the subject of some criticism as he was a Green Party activist for many years. Shawn has posted a response as a comment on the earlier thread. Some interesting quotes:

No, I haven’t lost my heart; neither have I experienced premature brain growth. My point is, my ideals used to be utopian ones, based on the theories I read during my tenure as an undergraduate university student. Having been in the workforce for approximately two-and-a-half years, and in fact having worked in the union movement for virtually that entire period, let’s just say my eyes have been opened to the disjunct between leftist theory and the workings of the real world. My ideals today are therefore based on pragmatism and common sense – values and principles embodied by the ACT Party.

And even better:

ACT’s stance on Law and Order is indeed what convinced me to join, though not the only reason why I joined, the ACT Party. My association with ACT is quite simply the culmination of a journey of self-discovery, ‘quarter-life crisis’ and cultural reconnection that began at the end of last year, and precipitated by the ‘South Auckland saga’.

In fact, my alias ‘bledback2life’ was chosen to educidate my transition (some would say transmogrification) from the Greens and the Left to ACT and the realm of liberalism. I juxtaposed the concept of bleeding/blood loss with that of resurrection, in a deliberate act of oxymoronic temerity, in order to illustrate that it has been the exorcising of my Marxist demons, and the purging of Leftist ideology, from my mind and body which has allowed me to be cleansed and thus feel alive once again.

I’ve always been a civil libertarian, even when I identified with various leftist schools of thought. Now that I have embraced economic liberty too, only now can I truly call myself a coherent and consistent proponent of freedom in a holistic sense.

Yes economic liberty and social liberty are natural partners.

Shaun says one of the catalysts for his conversion was Sue Bradford blaming some murders (in 2008) in South Auckland on the policies of Roger Douglas and Ruth Richardson. It was the final straw it seems.

Now NBR has what may become a very big story about Shaun. Shaun is employed by that independent third party, the EPMU. NBR reports Shaun has been stood down because he is standing for ACT. The right to stand for Parliament is a fundamental right, and employers are on very dangerous grounds when they try to limit it, or even worse dictate what parties are acceptable for employees to stand for. The EPMU staff have a clause in their collective contract stating staff must get permission of the national executive to stand for Parliament. It would be a very interesting court case that tested the legality of that clause.

Former SFO Director on Peters

The founding director of the SFO, Chas Sturt, has said that the SFO should use its power to compel documents:

The Serious Fraud Office should be using its special powers to investigate the Winston Peters donation controversy, says its founding director, Chas Sturt.

Mr Sturt said the publicly available information about donations intended for Mr Peters’ NZ First party met his “smell test” – making it suspicious enough for the SFO to use the statutory power that can force documents to be produced. Mr Sturt said this would allow SFO investigators to check the “paper trail”.

Now Mr Sturt has some history with Peters, but he is right that independently checking the paper trail is crucial with these issues.

But the SFO has not ruled out using those powers, if it decides to launch a full investigation. It may find there is enough evidence already out there to launch a full investigation, without invoking their powers at this stage.

If however they do decide there is nothing to investigate, then the non-use of their powers to verify information could seem unusual. But from all accounts they are taking their duty very seriously, and have been doing in depth interviews with relevant players.

Chris Trotter blogging

Very pleased to welcome Chris Trotter to the blogosphere. And not only is Chris posting, but he is also responding to the comments left there.

By the election, will there be anyone not blogging? I guess once Colin James starts a blog, we know the takeover is complete 🙂

McCain in the lead

The latest Reuters poll has McCain 5% ahead of Obama. Now one should not take too much from one poll, but the RCP average of all polls has Obama’s lead over McCain down to just 1.2%.

Much more significantly is the electoral college count, and for the first time ever, McCain leads – by 274 votes to 264 for Obama. It is too close to call of course, but what is significant is the race is now becoming too close to call.

Obama will be picking his VP next week and ten have his convention. I suspect he will get a huge boost from the convention – especially as his address will be to 65,000 people in a stadium.

Then we get to hear McCain’s VP and his convention. He will then get a boost in turn. Around mid September the polls may start to give us some idea of how the final race is looking.

Productivity

Very interesting session on the economy, with a focus on how to increase productivity. The guest speaker highlighted five issues:

  1. Changing the balance of exposed and sheltered sectors, as exposed sectors tend to have higher productivity
  2. The behaviour in the sheltered sector and how it imposes costs on the exposed sector
  3. Market and Government failures
  4. Capacity constraints
  5. Random luck, culture

There was an in depth look at the health and electricity sectors. The health sector has had a huge decline in productivity. Now it was acknowledged that some of this is simply having to pay higher wages to retain staff.  But reference was made to an upcoming study which is looking at outputs per medical staff, and that the findings are quite depressing – something like a 15% decline. There are real structural problems in health.

Also of concern was the detail of how the Health Ministry has stopped publishing much of its data, and how they tried to charge $12,000 under the OIA for supplying some productivity data. The speaker advocated amending the OIA to force more info into the public domain, and also amending the Statistics Act to increase the power of the Government Statistician to force Govt Depts to supply info for statistics they feel are of public interest.

The role of the Electricity Commission was also focused on, and the mounting evidence that it has been removing transparency with caving into private pressure from Ministers and, in turn, applying pressure to generators to put prices up (so backup supply can be triggered) and then pressuring them to put prices down again. I am leaning towards the view the Commission can not be reformed, and should simply be abolished. For $90 million a year it is not adding value.