Idiots deserve each other

Someone posted a comment on Phil U’s blog, pretending to be me, telling Phil he is banned from Kiwiblog and making comments about his family.

Phil is not banned. He has been free to comment here since his one week suspension ended a week ago.

Rather than check with me whether the comment was genuine, Phil has now posted a long rant about how vile and odious I am.

It would have required minimal intelligence to work out it was a fake. I do know Phil’s e-mail as he has used it to register on my blog. I would hardly announce he was banned in a comment on his blog. And most of all I would never make make comments about the custody of his son.

The fact Phil was willing to believe all this, speaks more about him, than me. Very very sad.

Question Time

I thought of trying to cover question time from Parliament (you can apply for a one day pass) but wasn’t sure if they have a power supply handy there, so decided to watch it on TV and blog it from home.

Wilson is speaking now, defending her decision yesterday to take Peters’ word that Hide’s question was covered by a case before the courts. She is saying she had no choice but to take the word of an MP, as it is extremely serious if an MP misleads the Speaker.

Annette King has chosen today, of all days, to make a Ministerial statement that tazers are being introduced. This is a good decision, but MPs are suspicious of the timing. By making the statement today, it leads to a debate which delays question time and general debate. She could easily have delayed the decision until tomorrow.

Brownlee is laughing at the ploy saying King just announced a decision that isn’t even final, but just in principle. He is pointing out that many more major decisions never get Ministerial statements, and there was no need for it to be made today

Brownlee is right – it is a ploy to give Clark and Peters more time to work out their stories. The decision is being made by the Commissioner, not the Minister.

Gerry finished by suggesting the tazers may be used on Winston later in the week.

You know it is a setup to delay, when Dail Jones then gets up and says he agrees this is a serious issue which should be debated by the House.

… Fuck I am bored with tazers. Bring on the main show.

Rodney is now using the tazer debate, to attack Peters. Cullen is running interference for Peters which gives you some idea of how desperate they are to cling on.

… Now onto question one. Question Two is the big one.

Clark has said she does have confidence in the Minister of Foreign Affairs!!!! She is clinging to him.

She is not even suspending him. She says she will just wait for the Privileges Committee to report.

Clark keeps saying there is a conflict of evidence. But that does not mean she can not act. She knows Glenn is telling the truth, and is just trying to cling on to power.

Dail Jones is desperate. He is suggesting the Owen Glenn letter is a forgery. Fuck the man is a moron or does a good job of impersonating one.

Key has pointed out that if she is implying Owen Glenn paid to the Privileges Committee.

Peters is clinging to the fact that Glenn donated to his legal fees not NZ First. But that is a red herring for the issue of his denial that he did now know of the donation until July 2008.

Peters is basically calling Glenn a liar. He may regret that.

God Clark is desperate. She is saying that as the letter is to the Privileges Committee, not from it, there is nothing for her to do.

Clark keeps talking about waiting for teh trial. But this is not about whether or not Peters broke standing orders. It is about whether or not he is a liar. And she sacked Lianne Dalziel for lying and David Benson-Pope for lying, without needing a “trial”. She is using the Privileges Committee inquiry as an excuse for inaction.

Someone shoot Dail Jones. He is now asking for all the National MPs on the Privileges Committee to be thrown off it. Clark is almost agreeing. No-one can say National is going soft – that is for sure!

Wilson is doing better today I have to say.

Okay onto the next question. Who cares. General Debate will be fun.

Workers’ Rights

The letter

Yes yes yes yes yes!!

Owen Glenn has told the truth in his letter to the Privileges Committee.

Mr Peters sought help from me for this purpose in a personal conversation, some time after I had first met him in Sydney.

Bang.

I agreed to help in the belief that this step would also assist the Labour Party, in its relationship with Mr Peters. I supported the Labour Party.

Of course having Labour’s major donor fund Winston, helps Labour. This might explain why Labour has been trying so hard to not have the facts come out.

There is a wider issue I will return to about the propeity of Labour’s major donor also donating to Winston’s legal expenses and allegedly attempted to the Maori Party, and the pressure it can put on them to keep Labour in office.

I understand that Mr Henry is Mr Peters’ lawyer. I do not know Mr Henry. I do not believe that we have met. I do not recall that I, or my assistants, had any discussion or communication with Mr Henry other than to receive remittance details.

If Glenn is correct, this means Henry has not told the truth in saying he contacted Owen Glenn and solicted the donation himself.

Mr Peters subsequently met me socially at the Karaka yearling sales, I believe in early 2006. He thanked me for my assistance.

This has Peters dead to rights.

One has to remember that Winston has not just told a minor fib to get out of a situation.  He (if you beleive Glenn) has lied massively and repeatedly to everyone. He feigned outrage at his press conference. He held up the no sign. He demanded Tim Murphy and Audrey Young be sacked for exposing the truth. He defamed them by suggesting they fabricated the e-mail.

I’ll be writing a lot more on this, but for now I just want to say thank God Owen Glenn told the truth, when there would have been huge pressure on him to be evasive or even deceptive. For that alone, he should be made Consul to Monaco 🙂

Feelings of inadequacy

Later this morning is a final panel session on MMP. One of the panelists, Chris Finlayson, can’t make it due to select committees – so I was asked last night if I would be a replacement.

I stupidly said yes, before checking who else was on the panel.

Sir Kenneth Keith is on the panel. Not only is Sir Kenneth arguably our most emiment jurist (he now sits on the International Court of Justice), he was on the original Royal Commission on the Electoral System. Great I get to look stupid in front of NZ’s most emiment jurist!

Now don’t get me wrong. I like to think a know a fair bit about electoral law and MMP. Possibly more than 99% of the population. But everyone in the room is in the other 1%!

MMP Symposium Part II

No Right Turn has blogged all the speeches from last night, including links to some of the papers for those interested in electoral issues.

Raymond Miller was especially interesting, on how by 2011 36% of voters will have known nothing but MMP. His paper had lots of polling data about attitudes to MMP broken down by various demographics.

Constitutional Law expert Professor Philip Joseph is now speaking on future constitutional challenges. He is outling five changes under MMP.

  1. Indirect election of Governments. The public used to effectively elect the Government, and it would be known within a couple of hours of election night. Now the effect is to elect a Parliament and Parliament spends a few weeks negotiating a Government. He emphaised this means the public are often surprised by the Government that emerges such as Nat/NZF in 1996 and in 2005 Labour campaigned with the Greens but ended up appointing Peters and Dunne as Ministers – something no-one would have expected before the election.
  2. Government formation. Only in 1999 was the shape of the Government known on the night as Labour and Alliance got 63 seats on election night and had said they would go into coalition together. Ironically they shrank to 59 seats when the Greens later qualified for representation.
  3. Minority coalition Government. Four of the five coalition Governments have been minority Governments. Only National-NZF was a majority Government.
  4. Collective responsibility. MMP has shown that collective responsibility is not a constitutional convention but merely a rule of pragmatic politics.
  5. Government and Opposition reconfigured. These labels are more flexible now.

Joseph then touched on the issue of the Maori seats. He asserted that retaining the seats will inflate the parliamentary representation of Maori beyond their relative population base and will create a permament overhang that will skew MMP proportionality.

Professor Joseph pointed out there are currently 22 MPs of Maori descent, representing 19% of Parliament – well above the 14% of the general population that Maori comprise. Eliminating the Maori seats would have Maori make up 12.4% of Parliament, only 1.4% below their population share and hethinks the 2008 election will see even that small gap disappear – without relying on the Maori seats.

He also touched on the possibility of overhang in the Maori seats leading to a situation where National might get 50.1% of the vote, but be unable to form a Government due to the increased size of Parliament. This would create considerable resentment and a backlash.

Another challenge Joseph alluded to is that one day there will not be enough list seats to ensure proportionality. So long as the NI populations grows faster than the SI, then every five years the number of electorate seats will increase, and the number of list seats diminish. Already under MMP the number of list seats has fallen from 55 to 50.

Three solutions are identified:

  1. Increase the size of the House to greater than 120
  2. Abolish the Maori seats, and have seven more list seats
  3. Reduce the number of electorates, which will increase the size of the largest electorates considerably

Finally Joseph looks at whether MMP will survive in light of National’s referendum pledge. He thinks it will as he doubts National will get the numbers in Parliament, even if they form the Government, to have the referenda.

Nigel Roberts is now talking on the alternatives to MMP. He is doing what I in fact did on my blog some weeks ago, and look at what would have been the results of the four MMP elections if done under MMP.

Roberts identified five problems with MMP as he sees it:

  1. One seat threshold
  2. Treating minor parties and independents differently
  3. Overhang
  4. Closed Lists
  5. Backdoor MPs

He pointed out you can fix these without a referendum – only need for changing the system.

Says one seat threshold is unfair. Christian Coalition got no seats on 4.3% in 1996 yet NZ First got five seats on 4.3% in 1999.

With issue 5, could do as in Wales and people can be an electorate candidate or list candidate – but not both.

EMA Advertisement referred to Police

The EMA earlier this year ran some newspaper ads trying to stop the changes to KiwiSaver legislation, which would have made it illegal to take account of KiwiSaver contributions in a total remuneration package.

The EMA ran the ads a few days before the parliamentary debate on the law change, and they did not mention voting – they encouraged people to lobby the Government and MPs. The ad (copied from The Standard) is below:

Now the Electoral Commission has just ruled that in their opinion the advertisement is an election advertisement, that the EMA Northern have broken the law in running the advertisement, and have referred them to the Police for prosecution.

Now for all those who claimed that the Electoral Finance Act would not restrain issue advocacy, you may wish to rethink your positions.

The key aspect here is the EFA is based on the effect of an advertisement, not the intent of the advertisement. Because of the “Stop Mallard” sign it was thought it could end up influencing some people against Labour.

What this really means is you can only run an issue based advertisement in election year if it is not too hard hitting. That is hugely advantagous to the Government who can push through bad laws, and opponents have to hold back in their criticism of the law changes, in case they break the law.

Because they stood up for their members on a bill before Parliament, the EMA faces a police investigation and probable prosecution. Just another reason the Electoral Finance Act should be repealed.

MMP Symposium

I’m live blogging this from Victoria University where a symposium on MMP is being held in conjunction with the University of London.

An impressive collection of political scientists, lawyers and academics are in attendance, along with a couple of disreputable bloggers.

The symposium is tonight and tomorrow morning. The first session tonight is about the effect of MMP on the parliamentary process, on political parties and on the Executive.

Dr Ryan Malone from the Law Commission is first up, talking on the effect of MMP on the parliamentary process. He has pointed out how MMP makes opposition parties compete harder for media coverage, as there is no longer just one Opposition.

A lot of focus on how a Government has to get the numbers for every Bill now, and also due to agreements with parties may have to support some bills unwillingly – at least to select committee stage.

Another major change has been that the Government no longer has a majority on select committees and doesn’t chas as many of them. This gives more power to Parliament.

Related to this, is that the Opposition and minor parties can also force through hostile amendments during the Committee of the Whole stage.

This has all led to slow down the legislative process. From 1987 to 1996 an average of 160 government bills a year were passed. From 1997 to 2006, it was only 107 government bills a year. For those who want less laws, that is a good thing!

Associate Professor Andrew Geddis is now talking on how MMP has changed the legal status of political parties. Somewhat surprisingly, he is arguing that in fact the status of political parties under the law has not changed greatly due to MMP. There are more regulations for parties, but they remain essentially private bodies.

The old Electoral Act had minimal regulation of parties – just what they could display on election day, and that they could make submissions on boundaries. All the focus was on candidates.

Peters v Collinge established that political parties were largely private bodies, and that their rules were not generally open to challenge – only whether or not they followed them.

Payne v New Zealand National Party this year reinforced that approach, so long as they met the minimal requirements in the Electoral Act 1993 to have some provisions for members to be involved in selections.

Geddis looks at whether the greater regulation of parties (registration, spending caps, donor rules) is due to MMP, or whether the introduction of MMP was just convenient to do so, and these may have eventually happened under FPP. The UK did so in 2000, despite remaining under FPP.

Geddis concludes it was more a growing awareness of the importance of political parties in elections that led to their increased regulation, rather than MMP per se. I had never considered it quite like that before,but upon reflection I think he is right.

Finally in this session Professor Jonathan Boston spoke on how has Executive Government functioned under MMP. He focuses on agree to disagree provisions in coalition agreements, and that these worked fairly well up until 2005.

He describes the 2005 arrangements as novel and unorthodox with a coalition agreement, two supply and confidence agreements and a co-operation agreement. Also how two party leaders would be Ministers but not formally part of the Coalition Government, and how MPs not in the Executive would be Spokespersons for the Government on some issues.

He looks at the principle of unanimity within the Executive or at least the Cabinet (collective responsibility) and concludes it has under MMP been progressively modified and significantly weakened.

John Adams

I loved watching the John Adams mini-series. It has ignited a passion to read more about some of the US founding fathers and I have now read the book the mini-series is based on, a biography of Jefferson and a book on the Johnson impeachment saga.

Anyway hopefully a NZ TV station will show the series here at some stage, now it has been nominated for a staggering 23 Emmies. I reckon it will win many of them also.

Hansard of Hide re Peters

This is from Hansard, and is protected under Parliamentary Privilege:

RODNEY HIDE (Leader—ACT) to the Prime Minister: Does she stand by her answer given in oral question No. 4 from the Rt Hon Winston Peters on 10 April 2003 that “This Government does not tolerate corruption. Any allegations are investigated.”?

Rt Hon HELEN CLARK (Prime Minister) : Yes.

Rodney Hide: Will the Prime Minister therefore assure the House that the Serious Fraud Office will be able to assess and investigate, unimpeded, the claims of corruption by a businessman, repeated on several occasions to Dominion Post reporter Phil Kitchin, that this businessman was one of several people to whom Peter Simunovich gave $9,999.95 in 2002, to pass on to New Zealand First in exchange for Winston Peters’ “shutting up about his allegations of wrongdoing against Simunovich Fisheries”, and that “Sure enough, within a couple of weeks Winston Peters did shut up.”, and that the man’s statement and details were provided last week to the Serious Fraud Office, and that the businessman himself was concerned for his personal safety?

Rt Hon Winston Peters: I raise a point of order, Madam Speaker. You have just heard a very serious allegation from a member who, typically, failed to name anyone other than one company. But the critical person is the one he claims to be a businessman, whose life is under threat, apparently—unless it is from Rodney I cannot imagine from whom. But, I want to know, is that a fair question in this House?

Madam SPEAKER: Well, unfortunately, yes, from time to time allegations are made, and that question falls into that category that is permitted under the Standing Orders.

Rt Hon HELEN CLARK: The relevant question to me was “Can such allegations be fully and independently investigated?”, and the answer is, of course, yes.

Madam SPEAKER: Supplementary question, Rodney Hide. Oh, point of order, the Rt Hon Winston—

Rt Hon Winston Peters: No, I want to ask a supplementary question.

Rodney Hide: Well, you can take your turn.

Rt Hon Winston Peters: It is my turn.

Madam SPEAKER: Would you both sit down, otherwise you will both leave the Chamber and no one will be asking the question, which will solve the problem. Be seated. I called Rodney Hide before I saw the Rt Hon Winston Peters, so I will call Rodney Hide and then we will take the Rt Hon Winston Peters’ question.

Rodney Hide: Does the Prime Minister think it a good look for her Government to be abolishing the Serious Fraud Office just as it is assessing the complaint made by a former business associate of Peter Simunovich that her Minister of Foreign Affairs, Winston Peters, went to see Peter Simunovich to show him the evidence of corruption he had against Peter Simunovich and stated that through a payment of $50,000, “we would just slowly get rid of it”, or will she just keep accepting her Minister of Foreign Affairs’ word that he has done nothing wrong—

Continue reading »

TV3 has details and footage

The TV3 site has details and video footage of question time.

ACT leader Rodney Hide was ejected from the House today after trying to ask Prime Minister Helen Clark whether she would think it appropriate if her Minister of Foreign Affairs, Winston Peters, had allegedly received payments in 2002 from businessmen acting on behalf of Simunovich Fisheries. …

Hide’s ejection prompted a debate led by Bill English, Gerry Brownlee and Michael Cullen regarding the appropriateness of the Speaker’s decision. Brownlee questioned whether or not the Speaker should also accept Hide’s word that he had received evidence against Peters. However, the Speaker ruled that because of his direct association with any case currently before the courts, Peters’ word must be trusted ahead of that of the ACT Party leader. She also noted that if Peters was found to have misled the House, he would then be the recipient of applicable consequences. …

Early in the investigation against Simunovich Fisheries, Peters had been one of those accusing the company of corruption. However he later withdrew his allegations after claiming that the corruption case did not stand up to scrutiny.

Peters has previously asserted in 2004 that both he and NZ First had not received any donations from Simunovich Fisheries. However, more recently Peters could not confirm or deny that any donations had been made to NZ First by Simunovich Fisheries or its owners. During the 2003 inquiry the fishing company told the select committee that it had not offered any “campaign funds” to Mr Peters or his party.

Busted Blonde also has details.

The TV news tonight should be interesting.

Coalition Options

I’ve added a new feature onto the party polls at curiablog. Under Coalition options I’ve listed the easiest (as in least number of parties in order of difficulty) scenarios for a National-led Government and Labour-led Government using the seat projection for a poll.

For example the latest TV3 poll had:

Projected Seats
  • National 60
  • Labour 46
  • Green 7
  • NZ First 0
  • Maori 6
  • United Future 1
  • ACT 3
  • Progressive 1
  • Total 124
This then led to the easiest coalition options being:
Coalition Options
  • National 60 + ACT 3 = 63/124 – majority possible
  • Labour 46 + Progressive 1 + Greens 7 + Maori 6 + United Future 1 = 61/124 = no majority possible
I am assuming (and welcome feedback on the assumptions) that ACT would only go with National and Progressive only go with Labour.
For National the next options after ACT, in order of ease, are United Future, Maori Party, NZ First and Greens. The order of Maori Party and NZ First is debatable, but I think correct at the moment.
For Labour the next options after Progressive in order of ease are Greens, NZ First, Maori Party and United Future. Again the order of Maori Party and NZ First is debatable, but I think correct at the moment.

The idea of the coalition options is to show whether a National-led or Labour-led Government is firstly at all possible on the results, and secondly the minimum number of parties needed (in order of ease) to form a Government.

Disgraceful

That is the politest word I can find for Margaret Wilson’s interference in the House today, where she stopped Rodney Hide even finishing his questions in relation to incredibly serious matters. She played partisan politics to protect the Government.

It is a new low for Parliament in my opinion.

I will blog the transcript when it comes out.

Greens are supporting ETS Bill

Well it was obvious from day one the consultation was a sham. I feel sorry for all those who actually took the time to write in. The Greens have announced they will be voting for the ETS Bill. I wish it had been legal for me to bet $1,000 on that outcome – it was so obvious.

NZ First are in the bag also, so the ETS will be passed into law.

Now I’m not one of those who thinks having an ETS is necessarily bad. My preferred approach would be a carbion tax initially, but an ETS is probably inevitable. Of course the actual design of the ETS is very important – this is effectively about legislation for a complex new set of taxes and permits and issues such as forestry offsets, the profit the state stands to make from it etc should be worked out, before it is passed. They won’t be, so it will be a flawed beast and I suspect Parliament will have to revisit it often.

The Veitch leaks

Quite a bit of discussion regarding the ongoing media stories in the Veitch case. Bill Ralston wants an investigation:

What ever happened to the laws of sub judicae? The weekend’s Sunday Star Times and Herald on Sunday both reported at length on the nature and detail of the charges faced by Tony Veitch.

In theory the sub judicae rule bars any public comment on a matter before the courts that is likely to influence the case. Failure to observe this rule means the publisher and anyone else involved in publicising the material could face contempt of court charges.

The reason for the rule is simple: pre-trial publicity can potentially sway a jury.

The Sunday papers had far more information than was made public in Veitch’s first and only court appearance. They detailed the nature of the alleged assaults and the context in which they supposedly occurred.

Steven Price is less concerned:

Some defence lawyers have been getting their knickers in a knot about reporting on the Veitch case in yesterday’s Sunday Star-Times and Herald on Sunday.

Can’t say I share their concerns. Certainly, now that charges have been laid, publishing material that tends to create a real risk of prejudice to Veitch’s trial will be a contempt of court. But there doesn’t seem to be much in these stories to create such a risk.

They essentially summarise the police allegations. It looks like they came from the police summary of facts. The papers reported them as allegations. They note that Veitch denies them. They don’t get into assessing the evidence. They have reported no more than is almost certain to come out in depositions. Any trial is a good long way away, so any possible effect on jurors is almost sure to dissipate.

Russell Brown also thinks the leaks are getting too much:

That’s three weeks by my count. Three weeks of stories being placed with the Sunday newspapers by persons unknown, but — at the least in the case of the last lot — very likely to be playing for Team Tony Veitch. Because, frankly, there aren’t many other people it could be. …

Perhaps I’m being unfair to all three reporters. Perhaps they all came up with the same information through their own initiative and contacts. Maybe both sides are working them (and it may well be that the first media outreach in this sorry business came from the Dunne-Powell side). But it looks a lot more like they’re now allowing themselves to be used in a methodical public relations campaign by one side: that of the celebrity accused. And they, and their editors, should think about that.

I do wonder if this court case will see higher bills from the lawyers or the PR teams 🙂

UK Politics

Out of the blue I got sent this photo yesterday by another attendee at the Paris IDU Party Leaders Meetings. Quite nice to have the photo to go with my Thatcher one!

In the latest poll in the UK, Cameron’s Conservatives have 46% compared to 25% for Labour under Gordon Brown. This would give them a massive projected 220 seat majority with Labour losing over 200 seats and the Lib Dems over 30 seats. With that sort of majority (if they get it) Labour will be in opposition for at least two terms.

I was sad to read in the NY Times today, that Carol Thatcher has revealed that Margaret Thatcher is suffering from dementia. It seems to be affected her less than Ronald Reagan’s, as she does still “have good days” and was certainly lucid a couple of years ago at the IYDU Council Meeting when I briefly met her.

Dementia is an awful infliction on any person, and I would not want it on my worst enemy. There is some sort of awful irony that both Reagan and Thatcher, who helped free so many people from totalitarianism, spent their final years afflicted by a prison which has no chance of liberty.

Top 10 Convention Moments

Real Clear Poliics has a list of the top ten convention moments. They are:

  1. 1932 DNC – FDR
  2. 1964 RNC – Barry Goldwater
  3. 1968 DNC – Chicago anti war riots
  4. 1948 DNC – Hubert Humphrey in favour of racial integration, leading to Dixiecrats walkout
  5. 1976 RNC – Ronald Reagan impromptu speech
  6. 1980 DNC – Ted Kennedy speech
  7. 1960 DNC – JFK acceptance speech
  8. 2004 DNC – Barack Obama
  9. 1992 RNC – Pat Buchanan with his culture war speech
  10. 1896 DNC – William Jennings Bryan giving a rousing speech arguing against the gold standard

Interesting that most of them are not speechs by the winner, but by others. I suspect the Ted Kennedy speech at the 2008 DNC convention could become historic (and I say this not liking Kennedy). With Obama seen by many as an heir to JFK, a speech by the last surviving brother will have significance. And the reality that Ted Kennnedy is dying, this will be his last convention, and with his death will go that generation of the Kennedys. I suspect it will be very raw and powerful.

The Family Party want more money

The Electoral Commission announced on 19 May 2008 its determination for the 2008 broadcasting allocation.

I blogged on the allocations here. The allocations, in a relative sense, favour the smaller parties with the two major parties getting 62% of the allocation despite getting over 80% of the vote.

The Alliance Party was one of ten parties who got $10,000 to spend on broadcasting time, $7,000 for a production package for the opening address and 1 minute for the opening and no time for the closing. They are challenging this allocation in court, and it will be heard on 15 September.

I blogged in June that the Alliance was already getting $10.36 a vote while Labour got $1.07 a vote, so I doubt they have any chance of sucess with increasing their $17,000 allocation. They are also challenging the decision for some of their money to be on a production package – and they may have a better chance of success there. One also can not rule out that they may gain some sympathy to their argument they should have some time allocated for a closing address – no matter how short.

The Alliance are asking for each of the non parliamentary parties to go from $17,000 to $32,000. This would cost $150,000 and they propose Labour and National lose $75,000 each.

A new twist is that the Family Party (Destiny in drag with 1,052 members) have also joined the lawsuit, and are asking the Judge to increase their $17,000 to $100,000 plus seven minutes in total for opening and closing. They are pushing shit uphill to be honest, but I do find their reasoning amusing:

  • They made 0.3% in two polls
  • They plan to win Mangere
  • They are the only Christian party, and Christians make up half of NZ’s population
  • The Government has passed some laws they don’t like, and ignores public opinion (which is true but has nothing to do with broadcasting allocations)

I am looking forward to the arguments in court!

No Right Turn vs Chris Trotter

I wouldn’t be human if I didn’t confess to a small amount of pleasure in seeing Idiot/Savant at No Right Turn and Chris Trotter bash the crap out of each other. It’s like having a local Iran-Iraq war to enjoy 🙂

But that is unfair to both of them, as they are both two of the commentators from the left I appreciate the most, for their willingness not just to regugrgitate party press releases, but criticise others on the left when they see fit. Also there are some important issues being discussed amongst the name throwing:

Chris initially blogged on how the Greens’ consultation exercise was “avoidance behaviour on a truly disreputable scale” and “Really, the whole Green Party deserves a damn good smacking!”.

For what it is worth I agree with Chris on this point.

I/S responded in this post, saying:

Meanwhile, Chris Trotter goes absolutely feral at this exercise in democratic consultation, calling it “avoidance behaviour on a truly disreputable scale” and declaring that the Greens need a damn good smacking. But then, we all knew that he has a basic problem with democracy (one he even confirms today)…

The two links at the end are to the imfamous Trotter column on how Labour’s overspending was “couraegous corruption” and to a blog post this week saying maybe we should support Bainimarama’s proposed reforms in Fiji, rather than leave them to a new democratic Government.

And on this issue I am strongly with I/S on the courageous corruption issue, and also generally with him on the Fiji issue. Ironically several rightie bloggers are in agreement with Chris on Fiji.

Anyway Chris responds to I/S in this post called “The Multiple Personalities of Idiot Savant”:

The most disappointing aspect of “No Right Turn”, however, is Idiot Savant’s propensity to condemn individual’s with whom he disagrees for espousing ideas they do not subscribe to, and indulging in sins they have never committed.

I have been on the receiving end of these sorts of false charges more than once over the past few months. According to “No Right Turn”, Chris Trotter is an out-and-out opponent of democracy.

Now, that’s a pretty serious charge to level at someone who proudly describes himself as a social democrat, and who has, throughout his career, been an active champion of a host of democratic causes.

Chris is a social democrat, and he is right NRT does go overboard with his thesaurus when he disagrees with you. I’ve received a few of these myself.

But, and I say this with respect, Chris does sometimes appear to put too much emphasis on the “socialist” part of social democrat and not enough on the “democrat” side. We all can be guilty of pushing the ends justify the means inappropriately, but Chris does sometimes seem to treat the democracy side as maybe a means to an end rather than an end in itself. The pledge card and Fiji issues are legitimate examples of where he has gone beyond what I would regard as prudent advocacy. But anyway back to Chris’ defence:

The Sunday Star-Times column, once again, has been deliberately misrepresented by Idiot Savant. The substance of that column – the inadequacy of our electoral finance laws to prevent those with access to large amounts of cash from effectively “buying” an election – is completely ignored. Instead, Idiot Savant concentrates his attack on my willingness to forgive Helen Clark for using parliamentary services funds in a final, desperate, (and ultimately successful) bid to head off a cash-rich National Party poised to inflict enormous damage on New Zealand society.

Idiot Savant’s insouciant defence of National’s “right” to plunge New Zealand into racial strife, if that is what 50-percent-plus-one of “the people” want is interesting. It suggests that democracy and majoritarianism are one in the same thing. That if you can secure a temporary majority in the House of Representatives, then there is no moral obstacle to you sweeping away the rights of whole categories of citizens whose parliamentary defenders find themselves temporarily in the minority – even to the extent of causing those citizens real and lasting harm, and passing laws that make it next to impossible for them to ever again reclaim their rights (I’m thinking here of the whole Rogernomics/Ruthanasia episode).

It seems to me that an ethical distinction should be drawn between actions that tend towards the safeguarding of people’s rights, and actions which tend towards their demise. And that those who indulge in the former are much less deserving of condemnation than the latter. Abraham Lincoln suspended the right of habeus corpus during the American Civil War. Does that make Lincoln an enemy of democracy? If Idiot Savant is to be consistent, then he would have to argue that it does.

And this is what concerns me. That anti-democratic actions which “safeguard people’s rights’ are held up as acceptable. And who decideds what actions safeguard people’s rights? Not the majority of the people, but presumably Chris and his fellow travellers? I think it is incredibly risky when you become so convinced that the rightness of your views, over-rides democracy.

The Lincoln example is a red herring. There is of course debate about Lincoln’s actions, but even putting aside the near universal acceptance of greater state powers in times of war, as far as I am aware he never defied the Supreme Court or was impeached for his actions – as provided for under the law. But trying to rationalise Labour’s over-spending (in the face of three pre-election warnings by the Chief Electoral Office) on the basis of Lincoln’s civil war actions is ridicolous.

On Fiji, Trotter is on somewhat stronger (but still shaky grounds IMO) responding:

Once again Idiot Savant seems to be operating in a totally mechanistic ethical universe. Bainimarama staged a coup d’etat – ergo he is a bad man. And, anyone who defends his actions is ipso facto also a bad man. But this completely overlooks the reasons for Bainimarama’s coup. It suggests that a corrupt government, plus a constitution that makes it virtually impossible to deal effectively with government corruption, plus a record of reactionary military intervention against any democratically elected government foolhardy enough to try – should all be ignored. Likewise the appalling track-record of Australia and New Zealand in relation to the coups which preceded Bainimarama’s. Indeed, Idiot Savant’s ethical universe is so mechanistic that even raising these issues, and suggesting that a different approach by the NZ government might actually result in democracy being restored to Fiji earlier than under the current policy, is enough to earn you the label of an anti-democrat.

Chris concludes:

I simply cannot believe that the same person/people who post the eminently sensible and thought-provoking commentaries on select committee hearings, government reports, economic trends and vexing legal issues, are also responsible for these unpleasant and ill-considered attacks. If he/she/they are, then Idiot Savant would appear to be suffering from a very serious case of multiple personality disorder.

He/she/they should see someone about it – soon.

Now to be fair to Chris, I sometimes also wonder how we get the calm legal analysis and the implicit approval for people to desecrate Margaret Thatcher’s corpse once she dies, from the same person. However I don’t think name calling is particularly helpful. I more generously just note Idiot/Savant is umm very emotional passionate on certain issues such as climate change, and Margaret Thatcher  etc.

In the final chapter (to date) I/S responds:

So, according to Chris Trotter, I’m mentally ill for calling him on his undemocratic tendencies. I guess that barb struck home, then.

Ouch.

More troubling is Trotter’s attitude to electoral democracy and the rule of law. Despite characterising himself as a social democrat, he makes excuses both for overthrowing governments by force and for evading electoral spending limits. Neither attitude is consistent with democracy.

On the former, the overthrow of the Chilean government on September 11 1973 wasn’t wrong because (to put it crudely) Allende was on the left and Pinochet was on the right; it was wrong because usurped and denied the will of the Chilean people, as expressed through free, fair, and democratic elections. The same applies, mutatis mutandis, to Fiji. Fiji’s electoral system is far from perfect, and should be improved – but it is good enough to convey popular legitimacy. The Fijian government was not engaged in wide-scale human rights abuses or genocide; it was simply pursuing policies the military leadership did not like. I didn’t like them either, but there was still absolutely no justification for a coup.

Only in the most extreme circumstances should the military get involved in politics. To be fair to Chris I don’t think he has argued otherwise – he has been pointing out some inconsistencies between how NZ has responded to the four coups. The real tragedy IMO is that we were unable to prevent the first coup in 1987.

I/S continues:

On the latter, the purpose of electoral spending limits isn’t to prevent the right from buying elections, but to prevent anyone from doing it, on the basis that money interferes with a free vote. The fact that in 2005 National was quite legally evading those restrictions by spending up large before the three-month limit kicked in highlighted the fact that the law was in desperate need of reform, but it did not justify breaking it. As any kindergarten teacher will tell you, two wrongs don’t make a right, and “they’re doing it too” is no excuse. Neither do I accept his argument that violating electoral law was necessary in order to “head off a cash-rich National Party poised to inflict enormous damage on New Zealand society”. This is dangerous logic, which has been used to justify a hell of a lot more than electoral overspending, and its more than a little reminiscent of Kissinger’s infamous “I don’t see why we need to stand by and watch a country go communist due to the irresponsibility of its own people”.

Yep. And finally:

The link between the two positions (in fact, all three) is arrogance. Trotter thinks he knows better than the Fijian people what sort of government they want, and he thinks he knows better than the New Zealand people what sorts of policies we want, and he’s quite willing to countenance extreme measures to impose his vision on us. That’s not democratic – in fact its the exact opposite. Democracy is predicated on the moral equality of all people – everyone has interests, and no-one’s interests count for more than anybody else’s, so we get “one person, one vote”. Once you give that away, and start saying “your interests are illegitimate so we can overturn them if we don’t like them”, you’re giving away the farm. And of course you don’t have a leg to stand on if it happens to you (and here I note that Trotter would be screaming to high heaven if the BRT hired Blackwater to overthrow the government and give itself a tax cut. But that just shows his hypocrisy).

In a democracy, the proper judge of the consequences of electing a particular party is not Chris Trotter, but the electorate as a whole. Sometimes we get it wrong and we make a mistake, just like we did in 1990. But that’s our right, and the joy of democracy is that it is self-correcting: if we make a mistake and elect a government which does things we really don’t want, we chuck them out and get someone better – just like we did in 1999. It’s an imperfect system, but its far, far better than the alternative of coups and self-appointed philosopher-kings deciding what’s good for us and what we “really” want without bothering to actually ask.

I don’t actually think at the end of the day Chris probably disagrees with much of what I/S says. In fact I would hope few NZers disagree with his conclusion. Chris I think has a tendency to think aloud (Hell if people could read my thoughts, I’d be in all sort of trouble 🙂 and sets out to be provocative.  He goes too far in pushing the boundaries, in my opinion, especially with the courageous corruption column, and shouldn’t be too surprised when people respond with passion and even anger to some of what he says.

Anyway a good victory for the blogosphere that we can have such a full and frank exchange.

Dim-Post on National

Danyl at Dim-Post hits the mark wonderfully (and painfully) with this satirical post:

Senior National Party staff members were in damage control last night after an embarrassing gaffe by yet another MP. National leader John Key now says he was wrong in announcing that small-businesses would be made exempt from KiwiSaver employer donations under a National government. …

Communications manager Kevin Taylor denied that Key had merely revealed publicly what the party was planning to do privately.

‘John is not involved in high level policy discussions so he is not privy to what our policies are on this matter,’ Taylor said. ‘I’m giving the people of New Zealand my personal assurance that John misspoke and that his views do not reflect those of the party.’

Key’s blunder has forced the National Party into a guarantee that it will not interfere with KiwiSaver employee contributions in its first term of government, an announcement that was made by policy adviser Grant Johnston in the wake of Key’s blunder.

‘It is regrettable that statements were made on this issue by someone who is not in the loop and does not set policy,’ Johnston said. ‘Hopefully this should set the record straight.’

Although the polls suggest that Eagleson, Taylor and Johnston are set to triumph in the upcoming election, continued blunders from their MP’s still have the capacity to damage the party. The ongoing problem of MP’s announcing policy remains a constant threat to National’s election prospects.

This one almost made me cry with laughter. Dayl really should be getting paid by someone to write this stuff.

Own Goal

The Dom Post reports:

Labour MP Russell Fairbrother has been left red-faced after attacking his National Party rivals for erecting electoral hoardings “weeks early” – only to discover it was him that was late.

Mr Fairbrother, a list MP based in Napier, issued a media release yesterday accusing Napier MP Chris Tremain of putting up his hoardings six weeks early.

“The National Party is quick to accuse others … when they suspect they may have been in breach of the rules,” Mr Fairbrother said.

“But when it comes to their own election campaign, it is clear they couldn’t care less what the bylaw says – they just go ahead and do whatever suits them.” Labour hoardings were ready but would not be going up ahead of time.

Later, he said his campaign manager had rung the city council to check and had been told hoardings were allowed six weeks before the election.

The period is actually three months.

It is nice of Russell to be trying so hard to give Chris Tremain such a large majority.

Watching mediawatch

Karl du Fresne has a look at National Radio’s Mediawatch:

There was never much room for doubt about the politics of Russell Brown, who originally hosted it. Peacock, who took over, seems an affable and intelligent sort of bloke and I couldn’t claim to know what his politics are, other than to repeat the observation that his programme has a tendency to assume ulterior motives for just about everything the privately owned media do. But the recent recruitment of two other contributors to Mediawatch raises some questions.

Jeremy Rose, like Peacock, is a likeable fellow (well, he’d have to be – he’s a mountain biker), but I’m sure he’d be the first to acknowledge that his politics are more pink than blue. He was closely associated with City Voice, a markedly left-leaning free paper founded by Simon Collins (now of the New Zealand Herald) which struggled heroically but unsuccessfully to find a niche in Wellington during the 1990s.

I remember City Voice fondly. It was indeed markedly left-wing, but was a good read all the same as a newspaper focused on Wellington City. And while talking matters media, I should praise the work Simon Collins does on the Herald. Simon is I am sure, still left wing. However the reporting he does for the Herald I have found to be very balance, and if one didn’t know Simon from his City Voice days, you might struggle to guess his leanings – which is how it should be

More recently, Mediawatch has started carrying contributions from Adelia Hallett. Hallett has a respectable background in journalism but also happens to be a former media officer for the EPMU, the union that covers journalists (or at least those journalists who have chosen to remain unionised). It strikes me as slightly odd that of all the people who might work for Mediawatch, Radio New Zealand happens to have chosen two with leftist associations.

Others might say it is not odd at all!

Today’s programme featured an item in which Hallett editorialised disapprovingly on an arrangement whereby a reporter for The Radio Network sits in on the daily editorial conferences of the Northern Advocate, which is owned by the same media conglomerate (APN) – the implication being that by sharing news, the two arms of APN are reducing competition (and ultimately threatening jobs). The item included critical comment from Tony Wilton, whom Hallett described as an “industry veteran”, but who is far better known these days as a long-standing official of … why, the EPMU.

In the “interests of full disclosure”, Mediawatch revealed at the end of the item that Hallett was a former deputy chief reporter of the Northern Advocate. But it evidently thought it not worth mentioning that she was also a former employee of the EPMU, a fact some listeners might have found just as interesting.

This is not to say that the arrangement between The Radio Network and the Northern Advocate was not a legitimate issue for Mediawatch to investigate. But when a programme consistently plays up stories that reflect badly on privately owned media while appearing to treat its host broadcaster as immune from criticism, when it appoints reporters with leftist political connections and doesn’t make all relevant disclosures, you have to suspect there is an unbalanced agenda at work.

A programme that sets itself up as a media watchdog – and a taxpayer-funded one at that – has to be squeaky clean. It has to ensure that it meets all the standards it demands of other media outlets in terms of fairness, balance, consistency and integrity, and then some. Can this be said of Mediawatch? Sadly, I don’t think so.

I think it is a fair call, that Mediawatch, of all programmes, has to be cleaner than clean.

Biden on Obama and McCain

Dunes Symposium continued

Fran O’Sullivan has written a column on the Dunes symposium, which we both attended last week, put on by the Business Roundtable. A lot of focus was on how to lift NZ’s productivity record (and hence national income) and Fran list’s six examples of bad behaviour:

  1. How the current Government has ignored the lessons of the 1980s-1990s relating to public sector management, to the detriment of economic efficiency.
  2. Alarming incursions by Cabinet ministers who have arbitrarily encroached on private property rights in the commercial arena.
  3. Cabinet ministers bypassing Treasury and commissioning advice elsewhere for the re-nationalisation of the railways, without any cost-benefit analysis of whether it made economic sense to do so.
  4. Telling examples of how Kiwi businesses are being tied in regulatory knots by the devolution of powers to overly aggressive bodies.
  5. The major decline in the health sector, where the budget has increased by 54 per cent in recent years yet the amount of elective surgery has declined.
  6. How the Beehive leaned on bodies such as the Electricity Commission and power generators to push prices up during the recent power “crisis” so that the Whirinaki back-up plant could be pulled into action, and then hammered them to drop prices.

I touched on some of these also, in my blog post on day one.

Also on day one was a good session on “bad law making” with several MPs (including one from Labour). Three examples were given of bad laws, and what drove them:

  • Dog control – a response to demand
  • Anti-smacking – elitism
  • Electoral Finance Act – partisan politics

The dog control was cited by all sides as the classic “bad law” where a little girl gets bitten by a dog, the public demand the Government/Parliament do something, and hence micro-chipping is proposed as that “does something” to show MPs care about little girls bit by dogs. Only ACT voted against, and hence they are at 1% because the public think they don’t care about little girls being bitten by dogs!

Some incomprehensible or bad terms which should be avoided in laws was given, such as:

  • Intrinsic values
  • Treaty principles
  • Sustainability
  • Workable competition
  • Price sensitive info
  • Must not abuse a dominant position

They all detract from the principle that the law should be obvious and certain.

One participant suggested that a Regulatory Responsibility Bill was needed to protect the public from “good intentions” of MPs, and that it would have a similiar effect as the Reserve Bank Act and Fiscal Responsibility Act.

The session on taxation was of course also interesting.

One senior partner in a major accounting firm talked about how he always welcomed new staff members by telling them, they had three duties – in order:

  1. A duty to themselves. A realisation that people work to further themselves, and that an employer needs to recognise this – that working for an employer is not the most important thing for an individual.
  2. A duty to New Zealand – that employees (and employers) should look at how they can contribute to New Zealand, that there was a moral obligation to contribute – not just to make money.
  3. A duty to the employer – this comes after the duty to yourself and New Zealand.

This might seem as a surprising position for a senior member of the Roundtable, but most of them are passionate about advocating for policies which will result in a better NZ, and that pushing for better tax policies, is part of this. That pushing for better tax policies, is not about pushing for more or less tax, but a more efficient and equitable tax system.

He defined the efficiency of a tax system as how to collect maximum revenue at minimum cost, and that the current system was a long way off this. The equity side can be met through a combination of tax and welfare.

Day Two also saw a debate between the Victoria and Auckland University Debating Clubs on the moot that Australia is the luckier country. Auckland affirmed and Victoria negated.

Auckland were somewhat helped by Roger Kerr introducing the topic with some slides which basically showed how Australia was kicking NZ’s arse in most areas. This didn’t stop Victoria University from a spirited defence of NZ.

In debating you often have to argue a proposition you don’t personally believe in. But never has this been funnier than seeing Christopher Bishop not just argue for how NZ in the last decade has done better than Australia, but when he starting promoting the benefits of the Swedish big state model, it was just too much for me. Maybe I could handle Bish promoting Swedish models, but not The Swedish Model. When they asked for questions at the end of the debate, I could not resist asking him if he actually believed a single word he had uttered during the debate. He could find only one sentence he stood by 🙂

I used to take part in debating at school and university also. Back then (God that makes me feel old) you could interject at any time, so loud funny interjectors could be devastating. It did often stop the smooth flow of a debate, so I was interested in the convention that has developed where if you wish to interject you stand up, and the speaker at the rostrum either tells you to sit down, or allows your interjection. It looks bad to refuse all interjections so each speaker normally allows a few and responds quickly to them.

The way the speakers dismiss an attempted interjection is quite amusing, as they just say “No, sit down” or make a sit down signal with their hands as they continue speaking. Polly from the Vic team was the best at dismissing interjections as her “No thank you Sir” was delivered with wonderful contempt, and in a tone you would use to instruct a canine.

The honours were shared, with attendees voting that they agreed with the Auckland team, but that the Vic team had performed the best with their argument.

Also on day two, the participants heard from a National and Labour candidate who talked about and answered questions about the future faces and directions of National and Labour. Both candidates were in their 20s or early 30s and performed well, with an interesting observation that as the newer candidates were at school during the ideological big battles of the 1980s and 1990s, they expect there will be less acrimony between them as the start to move into Parliament over the next few years.

People have all sorts of pre-conceived ideas about the Business Roundtable. Some on the left try and paint it at the centre of every conspiracy theory they have. But the reality is the NZBR is quite ordinary. Like thousands of other organisations they divided into small breakout groups, and workshop on flipcharts ideas for improving public policy which get reported back into the main session. There is no secret cabal setting the agenda – in fact the senior established order at the Roundtable seem more open to new ideas and new ways to operate, than most organisations I have observed.

I don’t agree with the NZBR on every issue. Far from it. But I do think our public policy debate in NZ is much stronger for having their input, and that it will be a welcome day when people debate their ideas, not supposed agendas.