The Dunes Symposium

Today and tomorrow I am attending The Dunes Symposium on Waiheke Island, so will be blogging about some of the sessions.

The symposium is not primarily for members of the actual BRT, but for new and emerging business leaders, and is a sort of introduction to public policy issues, and how they can impact business. The opening session had a good quote from James Madison in 1788:

If men were angels, no government would be necessary. If angels were to govern men, neither external nor internal controls on government would be necessary. In framing a government which is to be administered by men over men, the great difficulty lies in this: you must first enable the government to control the governed; and in the next place oblige it to control itself. A dependence on the people is, no doubt, the primary control on the government; but experience has taught mankind the necessity of auxiliary precautions.

Following that stressed that the majority of interactions today are voluntary co-operation, but when there is market failure, intervention can be justified. The test should be whether the intervention actually produces more benefits than costs.

We have sessions later today on constraining government regulation and an economic state of the nation analysis by a former Treasury Secretary. Tomorrow addressees by a Labour and National Party candidate, a university debating team debate on if Australia is the luckier country, a tax policy session, a Maori Economic Development session, and a session on the buy back of Rail.  I really enjoy these policy discussions and debates, so always appreciate when I get to attend.

A seat bigger than France!

Boundary changes in Queensland has seen the Mount Isa seat double in size to 570,500 square kms. This is 20,000 kms larger than all of France!

I used to think Damien O’Connor had it bad with a 12 hour drive from the south to the north of his West Coast-Tasman electorate.

In terms of the size of NZ, the seat is twice as large as NZ!

UK Conservatives warn against borrowing

I was interested to read in the Telegraph that the Conservative Shadow Chancellor, George Osborne is attacking Gordon Brown for his reckless plans to increase Government borrowing.

What fascinated me most was the level of debt:

Under the rules, the Treasury is only supposed to borrow a maximum of 40 per cent of the country’s gross domestic product.

So the UK debate is about whether exceeding 40% of GDP is prudent, while in NZ Helen and Michael preach the end of the world if it is 22% instead of 20%.

Of course Helen is also on the record as having advocated more borrowing when debt was 57% of GDP, so her position on this issue is so flexible, she could get a gold in gymnastics at the Olympics.!

NZ Herald on National’s list

The NZ Herald editorial says about time:

When the National Party published its candidate list on Sunday a greater ethnic diversity was immediately apparent. Six Maori, three Asians and a Pacific Islander have been placed high enough on the list to get into Parliament if National polls as well as it expects.

I am guilty of this myself, but I amused how Asians are all lumped together, when in fact in winnable places are a Chinese, a Korean and an Indian Sikh. All quite different races and cultures. But hey as I said, I do it myself sometimes.

Samoan Peseta Sam Lotu-Iiga, Korean-born Melissa Lee and Indian Kanwal Bakshi can probably count on joining Pansy Wong, too long National’s solitary representative of immigrant communities.Indeed, she has been almost a solitary Asian voice in Parliament, for Labour has supplied only the Pakistani Ashraf Choudhary, who has been practically silent, and the smaller parties have offered no seats to non-Maori minorities.

Is Choudary still an MP? My goodness.

National’s list, incidentally, still looks light on women; only four rank in the top 24, from which a cabinet would be likely to be drawn.

There is still some way to go. It looks like women will comprise 26% to 28% of National’s caucus, much the same as is currently the case. This is more than double the international average for female parliamentary representation. The problem is not so much where women are placed on the list, but that not enough stand to be a candidate. I may touch on this at some later stage.

As for the top 24, it would be very foolish to assume that the top 24 are automatically the Ministerial pool.

Though only one Maori, Georgina te Heuheu, ranks in the top 24, three more, Tau Henare, Hekia Parata and Paula Bennett, are in positions for an almost certain return to Parliament and two others, Rugby Union director Paul Quinn and Tauranga prosecutor Simon Bridges, will make it if National wins 60 seats. Six of 60 would be an advance on the present three of 48.

It is possible that after the election National will have more Maori MPs than Labour.

McCain vs Obama

Obama has been refusing to go head to head with McCain, despite earlier areeing to do so. This editorial may give an idea why:

The stark differences between the two came through the most on the question of whether there is evil in the world. Obama spoke of evil within America, “in parents who have viciously abused their children.” According to the Democrat, we can’t really erase evil in the world because “that is God’s task.” And we have to “have some humility in how we approach the issue of confronting evil.”

For McCain, with a global war on terror raging, there was no equivocating: We must “defeat” evil. If al-Qaida’s placing of suicide vests on mentally-disabled women and then blowing them up by remote control in a Baghdad market isn’t evil, he asked: “You have to tell me what is.”

Fair point.

Asked to name figures he would rely on for advice, Obama gave the stock answer of family members. McCain pointed to Gen. David Petraeus, Iraq’s scourge of the surge; Democratic Rep. John Lewis, who “had his skull fractured” by white racists while protesting for civil rights in the 60s; plus Internet entrepreneur Meg Whitman, the innovative former CEO of eBay.

Bland answer No 2.

When Warren inquired into changes of mind on big issues, Obama fretted about welfare reform; McCain unashamedly said “drilling” — for reasons of national security and economic need.

Always a good question.

On taxes, Obama waxed political: “What I’m trying to do is create a sense of balance and fairness in our tax code.” McCain showed an understanding of what drives a free economy: “I don’t want to take any money from the rich. I want everybody to get rich. I don’t believe in class warfare or redistribution of the wealth.”

Again Obama gives a bland response.

To any honest observer, the differences between John McCain and Barack Obama have been evident all along. What we saw last weekend was Obama’s shallowness juxtaposed with McCain’s depth, the product of his extraordinary life experience.

The question is will Obama be able to go all the way to election day with bland generalisations about fairnness and change. Possibly he will.

Glenn to co-operate

Very pleasing to read in the Dominion Post that Owen Glenn has said he will co-operate with both the Privileges Committee and any SFO investigation:

Mr Glenn last night revealed that he had already provided written statements to both the SFO and parliamentary privileges committee, which is conducting an inquiry into whether Mr Peters breached Parliament’s rules by failing to disclose the donation.

Mr Glenn would “cooperate with each body, as may be necessary”, a statement from his office said.

Good to see him doing the right thing.

But in a new development on Monday, Mr Henry disclosed that he personally footed the bill for $40,000 in costs awarded against Mr Peters after the electoral petition failed – which might also be considered a gift that should have been disclosed.

In a twist yesterday, however, Mr Peters said Mr Henry had now had a chance to check his records – and discovered that he had since been reimbursed by Mr Peters.

It would be useful for a copy of those records to be given to the Privileges Committee. If it was all reimbursed within the same year, then indeed there may not be a debt paid off on Peters’ behalf. If it was not all reimbursed within the year, then there may be issues.

Is No 5 Jim Hopkins?

A well connected birdie has whispered to me, that the mystery number five candidate on ACT’s list may be Jim Hopkins.

I have no first hand knowledge of the accuracy of this, but if true would be a plus for ACT. Hopkins certainly seems to be close to ACT politically, and has always had a fairly strong political interest. He has been the MC for the policy focused Sounds Symposium for many years.

He would be one of the few people who could genuinely increase the party vote for a party, based on his profile. And if he did become an MP, the debating chamber would become a far funnier place to listen to.

So it will be interesting if it is true. And good for ACT if it is, in my opinion.

The ACT List

ACT has released its party list. The top 12 are:

  1. Rodney Hide
  2. Heather Roy
  3. Sir Roger Douglas
  4. John Boscawen
  5. It’s a secret
  6. Hilary Calvert
  7. Peter Tashkoff
  8. John Ormond
  9. Colin du Plessis
  10. Shawn Tan
  11. Ron Scott
  12. Aaron Keown

I used to think they would have Sir Roger at No 6 to encourage people to give them 5%, but after Rodney said on Agenda he would be in the top three, I figured he would be No 3. It would have been a bad look to demoate Heather from the No 2 spot. I have a lot of regard for Heather and hope she would be a Minister if the election outcome allows it.

Smart to have a second woman in the top six

They have not put Kenneth Wang on the list to boost his chances against Pansy Wong in Botany. I can’t see it working as unlike Rodney winning Epsom, there is no strategic reason for National voters in Botany to vote for Kenneth. If Kenneth wins the seat, then ACT just get one less List MP. In fact on current polls Kenneth winning Botany would keep Heather from returning to Parliament. I guess they are trying to appeal to Asian voters to get two Asians into Parliament by vote splitting.

Quite a smart move putting John Boscawen high up, as his profile from his anti-EFA campaign is quite high. It also aligns ACT with the popular opposition to the EFA!

Hilary Calvert seems to be the new name. Don’t know much about her, but CV looks useful. Who will be No 5 is interesting. Maybe Derek Quigley? 🙂

Australian briefing background on Clark

Oh this is hilarious. An Australian moron has handed out to the media, copies of the confidential background briefing on Helen Clark. The Herald reports:

The notes added: “She does not trust those outside a small circle in Labour and her chief of staff, Heather Simpson, is known as the second most powerful person in New Zealand (known as H2).”

It says her views are “generally left wing, with foreign policy perspectives forged during the Vietnam War”.

Nothing too surprising there. It could be worse. DFAT did this once before and left in a room the entire set of briefings on various Pacific leaders. That was real warst and all stuff – including how one Premier was known as Mr 10% as that was his bribe/cut on all contracts 🙂

Power Cut

In a long long saga the third power cord for my HP laptop has just died. The last two have some sort of design defect that they fray away. At present I sometimes can get some power, but it literally sparks and crackles when I do, as the wiring is exposed.

I asked for a replacement cord a few days ago, knowing I would need a new one by today as I am up on Waiheke Island for five days. But the supply company sent it by amistake to the retail store in Dunedin I originally got it from – instead of direct to me.

And then the Dunedin store couriered it to me, but it didn’t get to me in time, so they are trying to get it redirected to me on Waiheke.

If things go well, I will have power to the laptop again by Friday afternoon. If they do not go well, I might not have it working until Monday.

This means little or no blogging until it is fixed. So don’t expect much content on Thursday especially, if any.

UPDATE: In a minor miracle there is somehow enough of a connection left that power still flows through. It is having the interestign side effect of freezing the touch pad, but is workable. So for next two days will treat power cord like a fragile vase and move it about as little as possible,and it may just survive until its replacement.

No charges over Labour pamphlet

NewstalkZB reports:

Police have decided not to prosecute Labour over one of its pamphlets that breached the Electoral Finance Act.

The Electoral Commission had deemed that the “We’re Making a Difference” pamphlet, distributed at Waikato University in March, was an election advertisement but had not referred it to police as it decided to use the first breach of the Act as a caution.

A complaint was laid by a member of the public and after completing enquiries police say there was insufficient evidence to proceed to lay a prosecution. They say information obtained about the pamphlet indicates it was not generally available for public distribution.

I am not surprised. The Electoral Commission also met yesterday and made decisions on a number of complaints and issues. Will be interesting to review them, when published.

More eco bulbs exploding

The Press has more reports from Canterbury residents of exploding eco bulbs:

Epileptic Philip Haythornthwaite said he was “lucky to have avoided a fire” at his Shirley home after two of the bulbs suddenly overheated.

Haythornthwaite, 49, was suffering from a seizure at the time but came round to find bulbs in his living room and hallway had overheated and blackened “virtually simultaneously”.

The incident spurred him to send an email around the offices of charity Epilepsy New Zealand warning members not to use them.

“I am very, very concerned for people who have a disability and that we will have something coming into the house which is not reliable,” he said. “I think it could have been very dangerous and I think I am lucky I am still here and the house did not go up in smoke.”

Maybe the eco-bulbs are exploding on purpose? Perhaps they are on strike in sympathy for their incandescent colleagues who are facing extinction?

Tourism back-taxes

NBR has a disturbing story:

Inbound Tour Operators Council of New Zealand president Brian Henderson said that the IRD had reneged on a formal written agreement signed in 2001, about the GST tax treatment of the fees that operators charged to overseas wholesalers for arranging tours.

The industry followed initial advice that the fees should be zero-rated, but the IRD had since changed its mind.

IRD officials said last week that they would seek back taxes initially around $50m, but they reduced that to two years’ worth or around $30m, Mr Henderson said.

Paying back taxes would put some members out of business.

This is the reality for many small businesses. They simply won’t have the money to pay taxes they have not budgeted for.

I have no issue that the IRD can change its mind about how the tax laws work. But it would seem much fairer to only apply their new thinking from the date they publish it to all affected taxpayers, and not to apply it retrospectively when it contradicts their previous advice. A hallmark of the law is meant to be certainity.

One News covered this last night, as did Three News.

Media on Henry and Peters

The NZ Herald reports:

The immediate past president of the Bar Association, Jim Farmer, QC, says the Law Society could be interested in the way Mr Henry is paid. …

Mr Henry told the committee that none of Mr Glenn’s $100,000 was used to pay for the $40,000 paid to Mr Clarkson’s solicitor for the costs settlement in March 2006.

How can he know this? If $100,000 from Glenn went into Henry’s bank account and he paid $40,000 to Clarkson from the same account, then it is all mixed in together. Possibly the $100,000 went into his business account and he paid the $40,000 from his personal account – in which case that conclusion would be more warranted. This would be the correct way of doing it, as the $40,000 Henry paid is not a tax deductible expense. It was not a debt he owed, so he should have paid it out of his after tax income, not his pre-tax income.

And while they are not issues for the Privileges Committee, I have received expert advice that the $40,000 payment was a gift to Peters and should have had gift duty paid on it by Henry. If Henry failed to pay gift duty on it, then Peters is liable for the gift duty.

Dr Norman raised the question of the $40,000 costs and said yesterday he had received a tip-off that it could be an interesting line of questioning. He said the $40,000 payment was more clear-cut than the Owen Glenn donation. “It’s absolutely black and white.”

Mr Peters had a personal debt and Mr Henry paid for it, he said.

“If you have got a debt and someone pays it for you then you should declare that someone had paid it, even if you don’t know who did.

Russel Norman is quite correct that the $40,000 is black and white compared to the other issues.

“There is just some pool in which debits and credits seems to float. It’s incredible – in the order of hundreds of thousands of dollars both ways – and it is very hard to prove anything.”

One question is why is it done in this way? Why not set up a legal trust with some trustees to fundraise for the legal bills? Have WInston declare his beneficial interest in the trust. That is how Nick Smith did it, and would seem to be a far more appropriate way to do it.

Dr Farmer described the relationship as “extremely unorthodox”.

Being paid by some third party [Owen Glenn] and the client not knowing was unheard of, he said.

So was the personal payment of $40,000 by Mr Henry.

“I think it might be of concern to the Law Society,” Mr Farmer said.

“Is it right for a barrister to receive $100,000 from a third party where there has never been a fee note rendered to the solicitor instructing him? I would have thought the Law Society would have real concerns about that.”

The president of the Auckland District Law Society, Keith Berman, said it was also very unusual.

“The issue which is uncertain is whether Brian is handling money on behalf of a client or just receiving money in payment of a bill. But as I understand it, he doesn’t issue a bill.”

Interesting issues indeed.

Tracy Watkins writes in the Dom Post:

But Mr Henry’s disclosure that he personally paid the $40,000 in court-ordered legal costs against Mr Peters means it could be considered a gift.

Mr Peters and Mr Henry were at odds over who made the payment, with Mr Peters suggesting he had paid it himself.

How can you not know whether or not you paid $40,000 to Bob Clarkson? If it was $400 maybe, but $40,000?

Welcome Heather

SST Editor takes job at Law Commission

Sunday Star-Times Editor Cate Brett has resigned to take up a job as Senior Policy and Media Adviser to the Law Commission.

Fairfax have denied the rumour that they have appointed Nicky Hager as the new Editor 🙂

Professionally, I’ll be very interested in Brett’s new work:

Ms Brett, who has a long-standing interest in media law, is currently researching the impact of new media on free speech, including suppression and contempt of court.

I have on my list of things to try and organise, when I have the time, is a seminar involving Internet, media and legal industries regarding exactly those issues. The existing laws seem very unworkable in the Internet age. I don’t mean that Internet sites are exempt – but that Internet publishers often breach supression orders because they don’t know the detail of the supression order. There is no mechanism for publishers to check if something is supressed.

Fightback against anti-Americanism

A group has been formed by some Londoners to fight anti-Americanism, and they have launched a website.

They have a useful myths page, including:

  • Myth: America is not a truly free and open society
  • Myth: Black Americans are held back in a country plagued by racism
  • Myth: America refused any involvement in World War II, when the freedom of Europe was at stake, until the December 1941 bombing of Pearl Harbour forced her to participate
  • Myth: America is exceptionally ungenerous in its aid to developing nations
  • Myth: America is a violent, high-crime society

They also expose how ill-informed many people in the UK are on the US:

  • 80% think the US sold Saddam Hussein more than a quarter of his weapons. In fact it was 0.46%
  • 58% think polygamy is legal in some parts of the US
  • 52% think the US more often sides with non-Muslims and non-Arabs in wars, when in reality “during the last half-century, in 11 of 12 major conflicts between Muslims and non-Muslims, Muslims and secular forces, or Arabs and non-Arabs, the United States has sided with the former group”

They also have a huge range of briefing papers on what the US has done for the world.

This is not a site saying America is perfect or that US Governments have not done some bad things. It is about adding some balance to the anti-Americanism out there, reflected in the poll results.

ACT Party List out tomorrow

More on Peters and Henry

Observers at the Committee were unanimous that Brian Henry performed very well. They also signalled out Russel Norman for praise, saying he asked the key question on the Clarkson costs. And despite what some feared, National MPs were not shy in putting questions to Peters and Henry – especially Brownlee and Mapp. Labour MPs I am told either said nothing or asked patsy questions.

A few more thoughts:

  1. It would be an incredibly bad look for Owen Glenn to refuse to take part by video-conference, considering he was honoured by the NZ Government, has a business school building named after him, and is so attached to NZ he wants to be our Consul to Monaco. Any refusal to testify will imply cover-up and guilt by Glenn – even if he has done nothing wrong himself (which I think is the case).
  2. There is little doubt Henry paying a $40,000 debt to Bob Clarkson on behalf of Winston Peters is payment of a debt which should have been disclosed. Ignorance of your own chequebook is no defence.
  3. Other payments by Henry on behalf of Peters may count as a gift or payment of a debt? It is one thing not to charge for your time, but who paid the court filing fees in the defamation case? These fees can come to many thousands of dollars.
  4. Could Brian Henry have paid off the $40,000 debt to Bob Clarkson without Owen Glenn’s donation? It is one thing not to charge for your time, but quite another to pay actual costs. If the Glenn donation preceded the payment to Clarkson (and I understand it did) then Glenn is still the person who effectively paid off that bill. Not necessarily from a legal aspect, but in a practical sense. If someone gives me $100,000 and I use $40,000 of it to pay off my mate’s debt, then that debt relief came about because of the donation.
  5. Does Henry paying the $40,000 debt to Clarkson constitute a gift to Peters on which gift duty should be paid?

Steve Crow wins again

Steve Crow has won in court, but really he was going to be a winner regardless of the court ruling.

The publicity given to Mr Crow’s porn empire by Family First, Auckland City Council and others has been invaluable. He literally could not pay enough for all the free publicity. Rather than try and get the boobs on bikes parade banned, they should demand a share of the profits from his sex expo.

Why does Crow do boobs on bikes? To publicise his sex expo. He loses money on the actual parade – it is free. He doesn;t give a damn about whether or not the parade actually happens – he just wants the publicity about it.

He is secretly parying that Cathy Casey and co do lie down on the road to try and block it. It would be a god send for him. Guarantee a better TV story.

Mr Crow is a very smart man.

Also a very smart man, is public law specialist Dean Knight. Dean blogged last week that there was almost no chance of the Council being able to block the parade under the Bill of Rights. Dean concluded:

I am very confident in saying that, to the extent that the bylaw requires citizens to seek prior approval from a state body for a protest in a public place, it is patently inconsistent with the Bill of Rights and other fundamental common law rights, and is therefore unreasonable and invalid. There was, rightly, a public outcry a few years ago when Wellington City attempted to do this; it backed down. Also, it’s the very thing that many folk are pointing the stick at the Chinese government at the moment with the Olympics in Beijing. The requirement of prior approval is outrageous, particularly in the light of the restriction of protests and so forth.

He goes onto say:

It gets a little more complicated when one deals with other expressive activities. The reality is that we grade the nature of the expression and place differing degrees of importance on different types of speech. Political protest at the top. Speech lacking in intrinsic value at the bottom, arguably things like pornography etc. Commercial-related speech somewhere in the middle. That’s a wee bit controversial but probably accurate. In this case, we might see the full range of expression. Principally, the parade is related to a commercial activity. But it’s also got a pornographic titillation element – something slightly gratuitous. And, given the previous controversy and dealings, it’s also probably capable of being regarded as a protest or similar political assembly.

His colleague Steven Price then details a conversation he had with Dean on the legal issues:

Steven: You know what? I think it might depend on the amount of jiggle.

Dean: I think that’s right.

Steven: If there’s more jiggle, then it looks more sexualised – so arguably more lewd and offensive. Then controlling the parade fits better with the purposes of the Local Government Act, and the offences of offensive behaviour and indecent exposure. You’ve got less wiggle room for an argument based on the significance of the speech. More jiggle – less wiggle.

Dean: No, I disagree. If there’s more jiggling, there’s more of a political component to the protest. It is deliberately provocative. It underscores the parade’s message being more open about sexuality. It emphasises that the protest is defying convention, and the council’s attempts to scotch it. There’s less reason to protect an unjiggly naked protest, because the nakedness is less central to the protesters’ purpose. Jiggling provides better grounds for a defence for boobs on bikes. More jiggle – more wiggle.

Now’s that a legal conversation you don’t get to have very often!

Finally Steven notes:

Such is the stuff of academic discourse. Though it’s fair to say that Dean doesn’t normally evince this degree of interest in women’s breasts.

I burst out laughing when reading that. Those who know Dean probably did likewise. Others should be able to work it out!

As it so happens, I will be in Auckland tomorrow. Despite what some might think, I won’t be there for the Parade – for two reasons. Firstly the plastic fantastics that were on display last year look pretty awful from what I saw in the photos – you can’t beat natural. Secondly I actually think partially covered up is far far more sexy.

Peters has breached the Register Rules

I won’t be able to cover this in more detail until this afternoon, but from the media reports to date of the Privileges Committee, it is obvious that Peters has broken the rules of the Register,just not in the way thought.

It was revealed that Brian Henry personally (according to Henry) paid the $40,000 damages/costs to Bob Clarkson. Now one can argue about whether or not the work Henry does for Peters is or is not a debt whether invoiced or not, but there can be no argument that a court judgement directing Winston Peters to pay $40,000 to Bob Clarkson is a debt from Peters to Clarkson. It was not an order for Brian Henry to pay Bob Clarkson or Winston’s solictors to pay Bob Clarkson. It was an order for Peters.

And Brian Henry says he paid that debt on behalf of Winston Peters. Now regardless of whether or not he did so using the money from Owen Glenn (which I will come back to), Brian Henry should have been declared as someone who discharged a debt on behalf of Peters. His 2005 or 2006 returns were incorrect as Henry was not listed as having paid the $40,000 debt.

Now Peters may claim he did not know Henry paid it. Well even if that is true, the issue is should he have known? Surely a man who was Treasurer would know whether or not he made out a $40,000 cheque to settle the costs – a debt which was in his name. You can’t just say I never realised someone else paid my $40,000 debt.

Section 19(1) states:

It is the responsibility of each member to ensure that he or she fulfils the obligations imposed on the member by this Appendix.

There is a lot more analysis to be done of the testimony, including whether Owen Glenn should have been listed also, but there seems little doubt Brian Henry should have been, and Peters breached the rules of the Register in not doing so.

Finally

Trifecta Girl and I had drinks tonight. This may seem unexceptional as we have been friends for around 12 years and friends have drinks.

But it was somewhat exceptional. I am not exaggerating when I say we have been trying to catch up for drinks for around 18 months. One or the other of us has had to cancel on around 25 to 30 occasions.  It has been like the worst series of coincidences. It had become a black joke between us that we would never actually manage to catch up, as without fail one of us would cancel a few days before or even on the day. I was responsible for the last cancellation which was on 30 July.

Anyway when Trifecta Girl phoned me at 2 pm today, I answered the phone with abuse assuming she was about to cancel. Instead it transpired she was just checking I was still on for 5.30 pm. I was, and we realised finally we were going to actually manage the impossible.

And hooray we did manage some nice Pinot over two and a half hours, congratulating ourselves over our achievement. And firmly resolving to catch up more often, as we had such a great time. My target is a catchup within six weeks, and no more than three cancellations 🙂

Veitch arrested

The Herald reports Tony Veitch has been arrested on seven charges:

Broadcaster Tony Veitch has been arrested on six charges of assault between 2002 and 2006 and one count of injuring with reckless disregard. …

The charge of male assaults female carries a maximum penalty of two years imprisonment for each count, while injuring with reckless disregard carries five years.

He will appear in Auckland District Court today.

I think it is good he has been charged, because issues of alleged domestic violence are criminal issues. This is the forum it should have gone to originally – a judicial one. I say that without indicating any belief in guilt, innocence or mitigating factors.

Martin Hirst at Ethical Martini blogged on the growing PR war between the affected parties. I am not surprised Veitch’s wife and family have started to hit back through the media, as they almost had no choice considering the campaign against Veitch that had dominated for weeks and months.

While I am not surprised, and understand why they are fighting back in public, I remain very uncomfortable at how the whole thing has played out in public. This is why it is good there will be a court process to determine the facts.

The conduct of the Police is also becoming an issue. First there was the apparent tip off to TV3 of the search on Veitch’s house, and then the accidentially recorded message from an officer who seemed to be taking an unprofessional enjoyment in bringing Veitch down.

If Veitch assaulted Dunne-Powell, he should be found guilty of the appropriate charges. However the punishment should take into account the wider picture, which is still very murky.

Latest newspaper and magazine numbers

The latest set of newspaper and magazine readership stats are out, so time to go behind the spin on them.

In February I explained the difference between readership and circulation.

The latest data is on on both readership and circulation. What I look for is the change from a year ago (for some circulation figures the comparison is nine months ago). In descending order of readership increases we have:

  1. Investigate Magazine: 23.3% increase in readership, no circulation figures
  2. Herald on Sunday: 19.6% increase in readership, 1.7% increase in circulation
  3. North & South: 13.4% increase in readership, 5.2% increase in circulation
  4. National Business Review: 5.4% increase in readership, -5.1% decrease in circulation
  5. NZ Herald: 4.8% increase in readership, -3.6% decrease in circulation
  6. Metro: 4.7% increase in readership, -2.6% decrease in circulation
  7. Listener: 4.0% increase in readership, -3.7% decrease in circulation
  8. Waikato Times: 3.2% increase in readership, -2.2% decrease in circulation
  9. Sunday Star-Times: 2.1% increase in readership, -3.5% decrease in circulation
  10. The Press: 0.9% increase in readership, -2.1% decrease in circulation
  11. Dominion Post: -0.8% decrease in readership, -3.6% decrease in circulation
  12. The Independent: -2.9% decrease in readership, -8.7% decrease in circulation
  13. Sunday News: -5.4% decrease in readership, -5.4% decrease in circulation
  14. Otago Daily Times: -9.0% decrease in readership, +0.6% increase in circulation
  15. Computerworld: -13.2% decrease in readership, +1.7% increase in circulation
  16. Net Guide: -14.9% decrease in readership, -39.0% decrease in circulation

Investigate, HoS and N&S all big winners in the readership stakes. NBR, Herald, Metro and Listener all also achieving growth of over 4%.

UPDATE: Worth pointing out that the figures I am using are comparing year on year. If one compares the latest figures to the previous quarter, it does show different trends such as The Independent up from 31,000 to 33,000 which is a 7% increase. However still 3% lower than a year ago.

Editorials on Peters

Both the Dom Post and NZ Herald editorials are on Winston Peters and the Privileges Committee. First the Dom Post:

…Prime Minister Helen Clark should be telling Mr Peters to abandon his usual policy of evasion, bluster and bullying, and answer clearly and honestly the serious questions that surround the funding arrangements of his party.

She should start with telling Mr Peters that his continued presence in her Government depends on him being able to satisfy the privileges committee that he has done no wrong, and at the same time, tell her members on the committee that she expects them to pursue the issue with as much vigour as the Serious Fraud Office is. With 48 per cent of those polled saying he should be stood down, and only 37 per cent wanting him to stay, he is a liability now, and Miss Clark should be minimising the collateral damage to her party by stopping his shenanigans or stopping his enjoyment of the baubles of office.

Alas, I suspect the Labour MPs will ask few questions, or patsy ones if they do.

Now the Herald:

Parliament polices itself through a “privileges committee” of senior members from the different parties. Tonight, the committee begins an inquisition of Winston Peters that should raise questions of financial accountability that he has chosen not to answer in public. The hearing tonight will be open to the press at his request, but neither he nor his lawyer, Brian Henry, is taking the exercise very seriously. Mr Henry has said, “Nothing about the privileges committee bothers me at all. It could be a bit of fun.”

I hope MPs will ask detailed questions, which will allow them to come to a conclusion. At a minimum they need to get very clear details of why the money was donated, who it was paid to, what accounts did it go into, and what bills were covered by it.

The questions these facts raise are too serious to ignore even if the attention is working to Mr Peters’ political advantage. In many other political systems they are questions no public figure could ignore; courts and constitutions would hold him to account. Here we have only the privileges committee, unless the Serious Fraud Office, which Labour and NZ First are about to abolish, decides to investigate.

The MPs on the Privileges Committee need to, in my opinion, ask detailed foreesnic questions over the money, and not let it get distracted by theatrics.

An issue that should also be canvassed is if the rules around the Register of Interests are so flimsy that a $100,000 donation from person seeking a diplomatic appointment from the Foreign Minister, need not be declared by the Foreign Minister if it goes towards his legal bills, then what use is there in having a Register? Can anyone argue that this sort of situation should not be disclosed?