National’s Energy Policy

Now letThree documents on this. The speech by John Key, the press release by Gerry Brownlee and the 11 page policy document. Key aspects:

  • Plan for realistic levels of future demand growth, because running out of electricity is a risk we are not prepared to take (Labour is saying growth will be only 1.2% despite historial average of 2.2%)
  • Introduce priority consenting for some large energy projects
  • Reverse the ban on new base-load thermal power stations
  • Consider abolishing the Electricity Commission (has been mega expensive)
  • Introduce an Emissions Trading Scheme within nine months of taking office
  • Support a target of 90% renewables for new energy projects, but not at the expense of security of supply
  • Expect no new coal stations unless technologies emerge for carbon capture and storage
  • Introduce a $1,000 per household solar water heating grant and simply consent rules for solar power
  • Invest $25m in seismic exploration over next three years to tap the potential 24 billion barrels of oil equivalent we have

Now let’s look at thermal generation in more detail. 75% of new generation under Labour has been thermal. To pretend you can go from 75% to 0% overnight is nuts. Even Labour sort of know this, and have left wriggle room – their ban is more of a slogan.

The Dom Post reports a leading energy lawyer saying the ban probably would have to abandoned by Labour after the election.

I think everyone agrees the long-term future is renewables, but it will take a while to get there. And the consenting process for hydro takes so long a ban on thermal will see shortages. Just look at this ODT story about David Parker saying no to any more hydro dams on the Clutha. I love wind power but wind alone is not a secure supply. We need more hydro, and until we get that hydro we will need more thermal.

Welcome to the blogosphere Winston

No this is not a joke. Winston is now blogging at winstonpeters.com.

This is welcome. I think blogs allowing two way communications are a good accountabiliy mechanism for politicians, and I congratulate Winston on deciding to launch a blog, despite the risks in doing so.

I do hope people are respectful in their comments on the blog. It is their blog, and while I am sure they will allow dissenting voices, it would be unfortunate if they did not persist due to overly abusive comments.

NZPA quotes WInston:

Mr Peters said he could not be too critical of the blogging phenomenon — which he said was like talkback radio — as he had one as well (www.winstonpeters.com).

Winston is a bit of a natural talkback host, so he might become a natural blogger. However unlike talkback, it is a lot harder to cut people off on a blog 🙂

Electoral law litigation

John Bishop at NBR looks at the chances of litigation post-election, quoting electoral law expert Hayden Wilson of legal firm Kensington Swan:

Electoral petitions in previous elections have not affected the overall outcome of an election, as the impact had been confined to just one electorate seat in each case. That changes under MMP.

“The most obvious example is Tauranga. If New Zealand First gets three or four percent of the party vote nationwide, but Winston Peters doesn’t win back Tauranga, he’d have all the incentive in the world to litigate the result,” Mr Wilson says.

“And if he were to get an election result overturned, he’d bring back a group of MPs which would change the whole make up of Parliament, and potentially who forms the government.”

Now Hayden is I think incorrect here. The assumption he is making is that if a party on election night (or 2 days later at the return of the writs) does not qualify for list seats in Parliament (you need 5% party vote or at least one electorate seat) and it later qualifies (by way of winning an electorate seat in a electoral petition), then the allocation of list seats is redone.

I actually wondered about this scenerio last election. What would happen if NZ First got 4% and lost Tauranga, but then won it in an electoral petition. Would they just get the MP for Tauranga or would they also get four list MPs on top, which they would have got if he had been declared the winner on the election night?

Well I asked the Chief Electoral Office what they would do in this scenario, and their advice to me was that ther is no mechanism to revise the allocation of List MPs. The Electoral Act puts an emphasis on certainity, and once the List MPs are allocated, an electoral petition in an electorate seat can not cause the allocation to be revised.

Another issue over-looked is that not all sucessful electoral petitions lead to the losing MP being declared the winner. If the petition is about whether certain votes should have been allowed, then the court can declare the loser the winner, on the basis of receieiving more valid votes. If the petition is about over-spending, then a sucessful petition merely means the MP loses his or her seat and a by-election is called.

However by-elections can lead to the seat swapping hands, which can lead to a change to who has a majority in Parliament, so there will still be an incentive to have electoral petitions – esp as the law is so unclear.

Mr Wilson said the Electoral Finance Act was having a chilling effect on campaigning.

“We’ve seen an increase in the number of people asking whether some action or statement they wish to make would be permitted or not under the EFA.

National’s Wellington Central candidate, former ACT MP and lawyer, Stephen Franks agrees that the Electoral Finance Act is depriving voters of important information about the candidates.

He says voters aren’t seeing a lot of the normal activities expected four months out from an election.

This part is absolutely correct. Linda Clark also wrote on this issue in the Listener. The EFA has almost muzzled the ability of electorate candidates to even get their name known to voters. The $20,000 limit was ridiculously low to start with (50c a voter) as a limit for three months. As a limit for all year, it has killed off almost all communications.

Mr Franks expects candidates will do more face to face meetings because they don’t count against the candidates spending cap, but signage and mailouts were a different matter.

“I was looking to have an electorate office with the usual 2.4m x 1.2m sign.

“The Electoral Commission wrote to candidates saying that signs like that were a campaign expense, and the Commission assessed the value of standard sign at $6 per sqm which was over $17 a day.

“Including construction and removal that came to about $4 600 for a four month campaign. That was almost a quarter of the campaign allowance for just one sign.”

“Alternatively with the campaign spending limit at $20 0000, I could have sent one postcard to about two thirds of the electorate,” he said.

The limit should be at least $1 a voter for a 90 day period. Even that is just enough for two direct mail letters.

Hot Lesbian Photos

Key in Dunedin

The ODT reports on John Key’s visit to NZ. Dunedin is the most left voting city in New Zealand, so the report is interesting:

An assured National Party leader John Key kept to the party message during a visit to Dunedin yesterday.

He showed no signs of any nervousness about the forthcoming election campaign.

In earlier visits to Dunedin, Mr Key appeared to lack some self-confidence and had leaned heavily on the local knowledge of list MP Katherine Rich as he was introduced around the traps.

Speaking without notes, Mr Key delivered from memory the bulk of the speech he gave at the recent party conference in Auckland.

Questions posed to him by members of the Otago Chamber of Commerce attending the “meet the leaders” forum were answered without hesitation.

A number of people have said that John is often far better speaking without notes.

But it was out on the street that Mr Key showed how much he had grown as a campaigner.

During walks in the lower half of the Octagon, George St and the Meridian shopping centre, Mr Key (without being accompanied by Mrs Rich) had no problem walking up to people, shaking their hands and exchanging pleasantries.

Ducking and diving into shops and over to people walking along the street, he showed a campaigning prowess he had not previously demonstrated in the city.

On walking into a hairdressing business, Mr Key was handed the telephone and proceeded to have an impromptu conversation with a caller.

He finished by telling the manager the appointment was all booked in.

People called out, “Good luck, John”, as he walked along George St.

I wouldn’t get too excited about this, and start predicting two two Dunedin seats are about to become marginal, but as I said this is a very leftish city not known for welcoming National leaders.

In another ODT story, they report that it is highly likely National’s list (due on Sunday) will result in at least one National MP in Dunedin.

The Press on National Benefits Policy

The Press says National’s Benefits Policy is a good start.

It is widely accepted now that long-term dependency on welfare benefits should be avoided where possible, writes The Press in an editorial.

Numberless studies have shown that while any benefit system worth the name must provide a safety net for those in genuine need, staying on a benefit for a long time is not good, by many measures, for society or individuals.

Indeed those who move from welfare to work gain the most from it, yet of course some call it beneficiary bashing.

The policy proposed by National this week, which would alter some of the incentives currently in place, has been, perhaps predictably, denounced by Labour as a return to the policies of the 1990s and an attack on beneficiaries. It is hardly either of those things, although how effective some of the proposals would be and how they would work in practice may be open to question.

Labour would label a ham sandwich as a return to the policies of the 1990s, if National made it. It is their focus group tested slogan to be applied to everything.

The proposal that single parents on a benefit should at some point have an obligation to begin to look for work, if implemented, would not be extreme. Indeed, it would put New Zealand more in the mainstream of welfare thinking around the world.

It is Labour who is at the extremes with their policy.

A later OECD study, addressing the notion that allowing single parents to stay out of paid work benefited their children, reiterated the organisation’s belief that it was in the best interests of all, including single-parent families, to engage in paid work as this was the most effective way to reduce the risk of family poverty, enhance child development and give children the best possible start in life.

So why is Labour against reducing the risk of family poverty, enhancing child development and giving children the best possible start in life?

The test of any policy is, of course, how it would work in practice and this policy still needs to be fleshed out. As with the work tests that Labour has introduced for the unemployment benefit, there would be increased administrative costs with National’s proposals and it is unlikely that any large savings would be made. If, however, it is likely the long-term social results would be beneficial, as the OECD suggests they would, then the proposals deserve consideration rather than kneejerk dismissal.

Indeed.

Caption Contest

Scum

Physical violence against your partner is bad enogh, but what sort of scum assaults his partner, when she is pregnant?

Sadly, around 10% of women, according to University of Auckland research, are assaulted at leaset once when pergnant. And this is physical assault – not some wider psychological definition of abuse.

The natural instinct to protect a pregnant woman is so strong, that I really can not understand how anyone could ever overcome that to hit a pregnant woman. Any domestic violence is unacceptable, but violence involving a pregnant partner is even more difficult to fathom.

I wonder what links there are between domestic violence to a pregnant mother, and child abuse once the child is born? I suspect there is a nasty cycle of abuse and violence there.

General Debate 14 August 2008

Will NZ support nuclear proliferation?

A interesting test is coming of Labour’s rhetoric on nuclear issues? They campaign relentlessly against all things nuclear. They say they want the world to go anti-nuclear.

Yet strangely, they appear to be on the verge of granting an exemption from the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty to India, due to pressure from the US and India.

Phil Goff himself says this will weaken the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty, yet this is under active consideration.

Now imagine if this was a National Government in office. Labour would probably be denouncing the Government for its lust for uranium and demanding we veto any waiver.

So this will be an interesting test for Labour – will its anti-nuclear rhetoric be as hollow as its carbon neutrality rhetoric?

Venezuela slips further from democracy

The Venezuela Government has banned 272 candidates from the upcoming election, on the grounds they are “suspected” of corruption.

By coincidence these include many key opponents of Chavez. Just another step in his attempts to slide away from democracy.

Of course this will not reduce the hero worship for Chavez from many on the left. What is that old saying – democracy is just a means of gaining power.

Agenda dumped for Olympics

Good God. TVNZ have cancelled this week’s Agenda for repeats of the Olympics.

Is this an example of the Charter at work?

I mean it is not as if there isn’t an election about to be held. Oh wait, there is.

I could understand if it was for live Olympics. But 10 am Sunday in NZ is 6am Sunday in Beijing so it is definitely only repeats.

Two months before an election, TVNZ dumps for a week the only in depth political show for sports repeats.

Our tax dollars at work.

Ten best sex scandals

In the wake of John Edwards cheating in his cancer (but it was in remission) stricken wife, The Times has done a list of the ten best political sex scandals. They have five who got caught and five who did not.

  1. The Profumo Affair (if you don’t know what that was, go back to school) – Secretary of War John Profumo with Christine Keeler who was also sleeping with a Russian spy.
  2. Gary Hart (should be known to everyone over 30) – challenged the media to follow him, so they did – right to Donna Rice.
  3. Bill Clinton and Monica Lewinsky. Her surname became slang for a blowjob. Also had the wonderful lawyerly defence that he did not lie when he said he had not had sexual relations with her, as he had not recipricoated her fellatio with cunnunlingus.
  4. Lord Lambton – snapped in bed with two prostitutes in 1973. Said it was the pressure of the job and a battle over titles which made him do it, as he “sought to soothe this obsession by engaging in frantic activities such as gardening and debauchery”. Hmmn gardending doesn’t look that soothing to me 🙂
  5. Eliot Splitzer and Ashley Alexandra Dupre – a very expensive hooker

And the five who did get away with it:

  1. Francois Mitterrand – actually had two families, and this was basically never published until his daughter was pictured at his funeral.
  2. JFK – Marilyn Monroe and scores or hundreds others.
  3. FDR and Lucy Mercer. Mercer was 23 when it started in 1914 and they broke off after ELeanor found out but possibly rekindled during WWII, as she was with him when she died. It seems FDR’s daughter helped get them back together!
  4. Lord Boothby had lots of affairs, and probably fathered one of the sons of his party leader – Harold MacMillan’s wife. He is thought to have fathered three children with the wives of other men, but also had an affair with Ronald Kray – the gangster.
  5. John Major. I have been reading Alastair Campbell’s diaries and just got to the day where he says he learnt of Major’s affair with Edwina Currie. Says it was one of the few times in politics he was genuinely stunned.

Hat Tip: Andrew Bolt (who poits out all the US ones are Democrats!)

The worst movies of the last decade

I watched the Bee Movie with my four year old niece last night and it was very charming. Animated films have just come into their own in the last few years. Not as good as Finding Nemo, but not bad. I am looking froward to the Star Wars animated film.

Anyway turning to bad films, Stuff has the worst films of the last decade:

1998: Jawbreaker
1999: Chill Factor
2000: Battlefield Earth
2001: Corky Romano
2002: Ballistic: Ecks vs Sever
2003: Gigli
2004:  Twisted
2005: Alone in the Dark
2006: Basic Instinct 2
2007: Because I Said So

I am glad to say I have not seen any of those films. I was planning to see Basic Instinct 2 but the reviews usefully warned me off.

Phelps breaks the record

Michael Phelps has just got his 4th gold medal at these Olympics for a total of 10 Olympics golds. Four atheletes had won nine gold medals each (including Carl Lewis) but he is the first to win 10, and may go on to win 14.

So far he has won gold in the 400m individual medley, 4 x 100m freestyle relay, 200m freestyle and 200 m butterfly. He competes later today in the 4 x 200 m freestyle relay, and later in the 200m individual medley, 100m butterfly and 4 x 100 m medley relay.

What is also amazing is all four gold medals to date have broken the world records. He now holds six world records.

In 2004 he got six golds and two bronzes. The two bronzes were both in races he has already got gold for in 2008. However the relays depend on the whole team, so nothing is certain.

UPDATE: And in the 4 x 200 m freestyle relay Phelps got the team off to a huge start and they smashed the world record to get the gold. First ever relay under seven minutes – more than five seconds off the old record.

Back Benches

Back Benches is, as usual, on tonight on TVNZ7 filmed live at the BackBencher. The MPs tonight are:

  1. Steve Maharey, Labour
  2. Heather Roy, ACT
  3. Russel Norman, Greens
  4. Judy Turner, United Future

The topics are:

  1. National’s welfare policy (despite no National MP there so I predict Steve and Russel will call it an evil return to the 90s, Heather will call it Labour lite, and Judy will just ask for people to be nicer to each other 🙂
  2. China and the Olympics
  3. Herceptin – should it be funded for a year

The show starts just after 9 pm, so best to be there around 8.30 p.m.

Coverage of Georgia

Danyl at the Dim-Post is frustrated by the priority TVNZ One News gives to the Olympics over the Russian invasion of Georgia. He suggests TVNZ are so Olympics obsessed we might see this:

Wendy: Shock in the middle east today, as the Antichrist appeared in the sky over the ancient town of Meggido in Israel and declared himself ruler of the earth. The five mile tall radioactive dragon is currently engaging the US 82nd airborne in mortal combat. We’ll have that story for you in a moment, but first let’s cross live to Simon Dallow in Beijing.

Simon: Thanks Wendy, well, no medals for New Zealand as yet but American swimmer Michael Phelps . . .

A five mile tall radioactive dragon would be quite cool!

For those who do want to read more about Georgia, Nevil Gibson at NBR blogs on the history of the region and a breakdown of the players:

Abkhazians: Hate the Georgians and have their own language. They are more likely to be Muslim. Their land was ceded to Georgia by Stalin in 1931 (incidentally, the Soviet dictator was born in Gori, which is just south of Ossetia and is now under Russian control). Fought a civil war to resist a Georgian takeover after the collapse of the Soviet Union and now have a unrecognised independent “state.”

Ossetians: Speak an Indo-European language, unlike others in the region, and like the Abkhazians fought a civil war against the Georgians to achieve autonomy under Russian protection. The northern half of Ossetia is in Russia and the two parts are linked by the Roki tunnel, a popular smuggling route.

Mingrelians and Svans: Two groups of Georgians who speak different languages and live at the western end of the country next to Abkhazia.

Khevsurs: Have always been Georgians and speak Georgian. Are neither Christian nor Muslim.

Neither Christian nor Muslim? Hell they must be Jews then, so now we have someone to blame 🙂

Happy 10th anniversary tomorrow

Media bias in the US

JafaPete points me to a Rasmussen survey which finds 55% of Americans find media bias is a bigger problem than big campaign contributions. Not surprising in light of the current presidential campaign.

So does this mean NZ should have a media version of the Electoral Finance Act? 🙂

Well Rasmussen also found:

22% believe it would be a good idea to ban all campaign commercials so that voters could receive information on the campaign only from the news media and the internet.

This is the ultimate endpoint for the EFA – leave it all to the media, and stop all spending. Nicky Hager advocated spending controls should be in place every day of every week or every year.

Anyway back to media bias. I don’t think we have a huge problem in NZ, but there are some problems. It is natural that some editors and journalists have worldviews that influence their reporting. The problem is when they are not open about it. NBR for example is unashamedly a newspaper of the centre-right. I would say that the Sunday Star-Times is very much a centre-left publication – but they don’t acknowldge that explicitly.

The Herald on Sunday is whatever it takes to sell more copies 🙂

It would be very interesting for someone to do some quality research on media bias in NZ. I recall a decade or so ago a survey of all major media outlets, where each was asked to self-rate their editorial and reporting position. One could redo that,and then do a survey of journalists on how they rate each media outlet on the same scale.

So what else is faked

China has made great strides in recent years, but one is reminded of how big the remaining gulf is, with the story over the fake singing at the Olympics opening:

The girl in the red dress with the pigtails, called Lin Miaoke, 9, and from a Beijing primary school, has become a national sensation since Friday night, giving interviews to all the most popular newspapers.

But the show’s musical designer felt forced to set the record straight. He gave an interview to Beijing radio saying the real singer was a seven-year-old girl who had won a gruelling competition to perform the anthem, a patriotic song called “Hymn to the Motherland”.

At the last moment a member of the Chinese politburo who was watching a rehearsal pronounced that the winner, a girl called Yang Peiyi, might have a perfect voice but was unsuited to the lead role because of her buck teeth.

So, on the night, while a pre-recording of Yang Peiyi singing was played, Lin Miaoke, who has already featured in television advertisements, was seen but not heard.

The one good thing is that the musical designer who revealed this, felt he was able to do so without disappearing into the night as once would have been he case.

But really to have politburo members choosing the child singer!

And the fireworks were also faked in part:

Officials have already admitted that the pictures of giant firework footprints which marched across Beijing towards the stadium on Friday night were prerecorded, digitally enhanced and inserted into footage beamed across the world.

Now again the good thing is through blogs and elsewhere Chinese citizens are able to debate whether or not they think these actions were good, or not. But they do do real damage.

People like me wonder if the hosts are so willing to fake the singing and fake the fireworks, how much confidence can you have in them to have discouraged steroid use and the like? The technology is always somewhat ahead of the detection, so even the best efforts of international authorities will be limited if a host country condones anything in its desire to be the best.

Colin James on National’s candidates

Colin James touches on some of National’s new candidates in his column yesterday:

… the parliamentary party’s future looks brighter now than for a very long time. That is not because National is streets ahead in the polls and odds-on to lead the next government. It is because there is an impressive crop of late-20s to early-40s new candidates: Nikki Kaye, 28, in Auckland Central, part-Maori Simon Bridges, 31, in Tauranga, Amy Adams in Selwyn, Sam Lotu-Iiga of Maungakiekie and Louise Upston in Taupo, all 37, Todd McClay, 39, in Rotorua, and Michael Woodhouse in Dunedin North and Melissa Lee, both 42, on the list.

Most of these hold multi-degrees, some with first-class honours, and have useful life experience. In intellectual potential they look more like a Labour intake than a traditional National one. Add Harvard- and Oxford-alumna Hekia Parata, 49, and media mogul and campaign chair Steven Joyce, 45.

The class of 2008 looks to be indeed a good one. I just hope as many of them make it in as possible.

So when National ranks its list on Saturday it has rich pickings. A Prime Minister Key reshuffling cabinets would have quality replacements for old lags he could not avoid initially appointing.

Indeed. If National wins in 2008, I would not expect initial Ministers to serve a full nine years (if re-elected). Rejuvenation is key and I would not be surprised if by 2011 the majority of Cabinet is taken from the classes of 2005 and 2008.

The message to Labour when it does its list on August 30 is that to stay competitive it will not be able to afford passengers. That is a crunch test for Clark.

Labour have a real challenge. Will they protect incumbent MPs as they usually do, or put enough new blood higher up the list, so that they will come in even if they get a poor result.

Upton on Mapua

I have not followed the Mapua fiasco as closely as I should, but Simon Upton does the job in the Dom Post yesterday:

I’ve just read the report of the Parliamentary Commissioner for the Environment’s investigation into the Mapua contaminated site clean-up. It is a short report – just 49 pages of widely spaced text. But it is a bombshell. It would be hard to imagine a more comprehensive indictment of a central government agency.

Hmmn, I must find this report. A quick Google and here it is.

The ministry appears to have had no understanding of appropriate roles and responsibilities and no technical competence to perform the role it took upon itself.

Maybe the Environment Ministry was too busy purging its ranks of anyone who had a boyfriend who works for John Key?

The problem was not confined to environmental management. The commissioner, Jan Wright, has felt compelled to write to her colleague the auditor- general inviting him to investigate some of the contractual failings she uncovered. The list of shortcomings is breathtaking.

So is anyone being held responsible for these?

As a result, the plant almost certainly pumped toxins into the environment but because of flaws in the way monitoring of the project was set up, we will never know what or how much harm was caused, though the community was almost certainly exposed to dioxins.

Meanwhile, groundwater contamination exceeded thresholds for more than three years. According to the commissioner, the ministry took no effective action to address the discharges despite requests from all those charged with monitoring the process.

And this is not the nasty private sector, but the Government’s own Environment Ministry!

The ministry helped design a sophisticated set of accountabilities and monitoring processes which it promptly flouted, having turned itself into the principal operator. Not surprisingly, the local council had difficulties treating the ministry – which was funding the project and at the top of the statutory hierarchy – like any other resource applicant.

Indeed. One reason why policy and operations are often best in seperate agencies.

Ministers have every reason to be very angry with the way in which the project was handled. How can any of us have any confidence in the ministry’s ability to protect the environment when its own performance has been so woeful? The ministry’s new chief executive, Paul Reynolds – who is in no way responsible for this toxic legacy – should waste no time in completely reviewing the roles and accountabilities of those around him and see to it that he gets some technically literate people on board fast.

I thought the Ministry’s main job was to produce propoganda for the PM’s Office on how NZ is going to be the first carbon neutral nation on Earth. This is far more important than actually protecting the environment!

General Debate 13 August 2008

New Zealand First Incorporated

Keeping Stock quotes from a Listener investigation into the incorporated society called “New Zealand First Incorporated”:

“But it’s the second arm that is now proving curious. This is the incorprated society New Zealand First Incorporated, set up in August 1993. The unusual aspect of this body is that current party president George Groombridge, immediate past treasurer Brent Catchpole (a former MP and an accountant by profession) and now estranged party founder Brooke McKenzie all believe that this is the party itself.

All three told the Listener thaqt this is the structure through which New Zealand First exists. McKenzie’s signature is first on the founding document.

“It was to be the vehicle for the party; otherwise there wasn’t any point in registering it” he said. “We considered it the best vehicle ond the one least likely for member abuse. It offered transparency if used correctly. Its record was available for public scrutiny and could not be abused by individuals in collusion. So we deemed it the best vehicle.“

Okay, but …

“NZ First Incorporated has diligently filed returns to the Companies Office for the 15 years since 1993. Each year the returns report the same signed statement: that for the financial year “there was no income and no expenditure”. For the entirety of NZ First Incorprated’s existence, the returns say, there has never been a single cent paid into it – nor a cent paid out.“

Now WInston refused to talk to the Listener for their article, but since it was published, he has said the incorporated society exists just to protect the name. This is plausible but somewhat strange as teh name is protected as a registered political party, and one can also invest in some intellectural property protection for it, without needing to register an incorporated society.

NZ First is not alone in having an incorporated society alongside the unincorporated party. The most common reason you do this is for ownership of property etc, as this can be difficult and risky for an unincorporated society to do.

For example, the National Party has had registered since 1955 the New Zealand National Party Centre Incorporated. This is on the public register of societies, and you can even view the latest audited accounts (they only relate to property). They do not file nil returns, like NZ First.

So is NZ First Inc only for protecting the name, or does it act as another vehicle for funds? If NZ First owns any property, in whose name is it?

Labour has an interesting similiar issue also. They have a society called Labour Party Properties Inc. It’s latest annual accounts are a nil return for income and assets. However the notes to their accounts say they own 12 properties on behalf of the Labour Party.

I am surprised they can have the properties owned by the incorporated society, yet have them not appear in the accounts of the society. This is presumably done to hide the value of the assets from the public, despite the fact the law requires accounts of incorporated societies to be public. Their accounts are not audited – I wonder if an auditor would agree with not showing the value of the properties in the accounts?

UPDATE: Whale Oil has some scans from the Listener article.

Secret polygamy agenda denied

Colin Espiner reports that Social Development Minister Rith Dyson is denying any secret polygamy agenda, despite a speech on the Beehive website saying the Government was moving to recognise triples.

Dyson says she never even delivered the speech, and doesn’t even know what triples refers to.

To assist Minister Ruth, we provuide the following from Wikipedia:

  1. polygamy: the practice of multiple marriage (a Greek word)
  2. polygyny: a man who has more than one wife (poor bastard 🙂
  3. polyandry: a woman who has more than one husband
  4. polyamory: having more than one intimate relationship at a time with the consent of all involved
  5. polyfidelity: multiple romantic relationships with sexual contact restricted to specific partners in a group

Of course with same sex relationships, it gets even more complicated. What is the term for a trio of lesbians all joined in a civil union? No it isn’t pay per view 🙂

Asked what the Government’s policy on polygamous relationships was, Dyson said: “The social security legislation is very clear about what a relationship is you’re either single or a couple. A couple is in the nature of marriage, which includes civil union and de facto.

“It’s been the same for years. It’s been tested in court. There’s no interest in changing it.”

An interesting response. The first part is stating what the law is, and the second part is merely saying there is no interest in changing it. That avoids the question of whether the Minister thinks polygamy should be legal? I mean did this speech just appear out of a vacuum?

Finally they ask Judith Collins for comment:

Collins said she was “intrigued” that the Government’s new social development model “now includes something called triples, and my mind just boggles”.

Asked for her view on Government recognition of polygamy, Collins said: “I don’t worry about what consenting adults get up to. I just don’t expect the taxpayer to pay for it.”

Absolutely.