Article on InternetNZ
For those who want a bit of info on what InternetNZ is about and does, there is a useful article in the Herald by Adam Gifford.
As Winston rails against power prices, and blames then on the electricity reforms, Audrey Young dips into history to remind us that NZ First voted for and supported the reforms!
Mr Peters cranked up similar sentiment in his keynote speech to his party’s annual conference on July 20.
“With power prices going through the roof, why are we not amalgamating the power companies created during the mindless National Party reforms?”
Mindless National Party reforms? Max Bradford? Yes, but Mr Peters has created the fiction that New Zealand First opposed them.
In fact Mr Bradford had strong support at the time from National’s coalition partner from December 1996 to August 1998, New Zealand First.
Now was this grudging support?
And not just the sort of passive support a party gives when it might be swallowing a dead rat or a dead fish of a policy.
When Mr Bradford as Energy Minister held a press conference to announce his reforms, New Zealand First deputy leader and energy spokesman Peter Brown was at his side.
Mr Brown, who is still energy spokesman and deputy leader of New Zealand First, said during the third reading: “This bill will deliver cheaper power prices for the consumer. It will start with the split of ECNZ. With the baby ECNZs, Contact Energy and the private generators, we will have true competition in this country for wholesale electricity … Innovation and efficiency will come in, and the price will go down. The splitting of the lines and the energy business will ensure that the price will go through to the consumer at a lower level. That will be a win-win situation for the consumer.”
Sounds like hearty support to me.
Audrey concludes:
So the next time Mr Peters asks an audience “who did it?” the full answer is that he could not have done it without New Zealand First.
More journalists should do this. The major parties are held to account for their voting record, but often NZ First attacks something that they voted for previously, and it escapes without scrutiny.
For those who want a bit of info on what InternetNZ is about and does, there is a useful article in the Herald by Adam Gifford.
Been a while since it hailed in Wellington. A nasty wee night outside.
Salient has an open letter to VUWSA – the organisation that all Vic studenrs are forced to fund. Salient normally goes soft on VUWSA as they fund them, so they have to be pretty peeved to do this:
As you failed to hold an Initial General Meeting this year, and have so far failed to hold an Annual General Meeting to pass last year’s budget, students have not been afforded the forums they need to discuss your structural issues.
Pah – democrarcy – who needs it.
We’re cool with you pulling pranks, like offering $10,000 to whoever arrests Condoleezza Rice, but you have to earn the right to pull these pranks by otherwise running your organisation well, and often you don’t.
I’m never cool with compulsory fees going on such pranks.
Although we don’t write about every little problem you encounter, given the lack of any general meeting this year, it’s worth discussing some of these issues now.
Here are two examples. At the end of last year, former President Geoff Hayward decided to spend over $22,222.22 (which is a much less funny number when it is students funds) to upgrade VUWSA’s van, with the support of current Education Vice-President Paul Brown. Although they did this without the proper authority, the payment could not be reversed and VUWSA was stuck with the bill.
Similarly, at the snow games party in late 2007, VUWSA held a competition in which they gave away a snowboard. However they failed to give the snowboard to the person who won it, and the winner subsequently took VUWSA to court at the beginning of this year. Hayward’s successor as President, Joel Cosgrove, then failed to turn up on the appointed court date. Good one guys.
This is what happens when you don’t have to work for your money.
NZ Angels (they invest to assist start up companies etc) have been interviewing various parties about their investment policies. Their latest MP was Doug Woolerton. They state:
I was disappointed with Doug’s grasp of the issues – he didn’t seem to know much about how startup companies or investors think, nor about the taxation system or general finance. His answers to my questions were long on generalities and short on specifics, often seemingly hedging as if he was unsure of not only what to say, but what was being discussed. And I was completely taken aback by his use of obscene language in a podcast which would be permanently available to billions of Internet users globally. No hidden microphones here, everything was above board.
You can listen to the podcast at the link above. The language is indeed very coarse – amazingly so for an openly taped interview where it was known it would be made available on the Internet.
MacDoctor has an interesting post on sickness benefits. He observes:
It is my experience when I do GP locums, that sickness beneficiaries fall into the same categories. There are genuinely ill people, many of whom will eventually gravitate to invalid benefits. There are genuinely sore people who have long-term recovery problems from old injuries. But about a quarter of beneficiaries are undoubtably “swinging the lead”. They are the lower back pains that flounce into your office and flop into a chair without a single grimace. They are the asthmatics who apparently can go to gym or karate, but wheeze whenever they are near work. They are the depressives who laugh and joke with you as you fill in their form.
The 25% estimate would equate to around 10,000 people.
Now people might ask why doctors give out certificates. MacDoctor explains in full, but the summary is:
The real reason that all GPs blithely sign sickness benefit forms, even though we know they may not be genuine, is that we don’t know that they are not genuine, we only suspect. For most of the suspicious cases, you would need a number of investigations, or a specialist opinion to confirm your suspicion. Your patient will either refuse to go, or make appointments with the specialist and then simply not attend. And there is no way you can force them.
His solution:
The only way this can stop is if you compel sickness beneficiaries to have an annual (or six monthly) medical with an independent doctor, preferably a specialist. This is not only good politics, it is actually good medicine, as specialist review of long-term illness is good clinical practice. Frankly, I don’t see this as being unpopular with sickness beneficiaries, apart from the ones milking the system. The majority of them would love to get better and go back to work, if they could.
National’s policy is that after 12 months on teh sickness benefit you see a designated independent doctor.
Yay e-mail is on again!
No Right Turn has some useful quotes from the Royal Commission on the SM system. Incidentally one friend IM’s me and asked me what does SM stand for apart from as part of BDSM. When I replied it was supplementary member they giggled that it was almost as dirty 🙂
NRT is upset that a story described the Royal Commission as viewing SM as having “real merit”, and quotes them in rebuttal. However when I look at the conclusion, I think “real merit” is not an unfair description, Of course it was not the preferred option, but here is the Commisison’s conclusion:
2.114. Conclusion. The Commission recognises that SM has considerable appeal. It improves on the plurality system in a number of ways. First, it would give representation to significant minor parties. Second, because almost all of the list votes would count towards the election of candidates, electors in safe seats would have a more effective role than under the present system. Third, it would enable the parties, particularly major ones, to protect a limited number of particularly able members in marginal seats. Fourth, it would provide a way of increasing the number of MPs but avoid the disruption to constituency boundaries that would be caused by a significant extra number of single-member constituencies. Fifth, it would, because of the list, be likely to enhance the representation of Maori voters as well as voters belonging to other special interest or minority groups. Sixth, it would lessen somewhat the disproportionality between major parties.
2.115. Nevertheless, the Commission is of the view that SM does not go far enough in meeting the fundamental objections to the plurality system in respect of the relationship between seats and votes. Those objections would still be powerful under SM, even though minor parties might be somewhat better off. We are reluctant to rule out SM altogether, however, until we have seen whether either MMP or STV can overcome the objections to both plurality and to SM without introducing too many disadvantages of their own.
They said they are not ruling out SM, listed many benefits from it, but said it doesn’t go as far as MMP or STV in terms of the relationship between seats and votes. Yor can quibble over whether you describe that as “real merit” or “some merit” or “worth considering” but their conclusion is a good summary of the pros and cons.
And that is what I was seeking to do yetserday – get some debate going on the pros and cons, and looking at what the impact would be. If a majority do want a referendum, then I would rather it on MMP vs SM (or MMP vs STV) than MMP vs FPP. My concern is that FPP may win, and that would be a backward step.
I challenged people to describe NZ First, using the usual two cows analogy. Many great answers. Here are some of my favourites:
They are just some of the answers. One can read them all at the link above.
I suspect it is not just me, but that no one is getting e-mail on Vodafone/Ihug at the moment.
The one good thing of getting so many e-mails, is when you have not had an e-mail for over two hours, you know it is a fault. Even the webmail is empty so Vodafone is having problems receiving e-mail it seems.
Their system status claims no problems, and God knows how one actually finds the phone number to call for their helpdesk. They make it as hard as possible to locate it seems.
A viewer alerted me to this question from last year:
R Doug Woolerton: Does the Minister agree that any law, including electoral law, requires the participants to do what is morally right as well as what is legally right, and does she think that this is the reason the National Party is having so much trouble interpreting the Electoral Finance Bill?
Now maybe Doug Woolerton might like to explain for us how NZ First is doing what is morally right by operating a secret trust fund that donors pay into, so that not only is the identity of the donor hidden, but the identity of the trust itself is hidden from both the party and the public.
I was an advocate of getting rid of the travel perks for former MPs, as there was little rationale for them.
However I do think that former Governor-Generals and Prime Ministers are in a different category. The Dom Post reports:
Former prime ministers and governors-general will rack up $920,000 in perks this year under a gold-plated scheme that provides unlimited free flights and annual payments.
The sum includes an estimated $520,000 in flights alone for one year, in a scheme that Internal Affairs predicts will cost taxpayers just over $10 million during the recipients’ lifetimes.
Former PM and GGs often have a continuing role in public life. They are asked to support various charities, speak at conferences etc. Jim Bolger says:
“One of the arguments [for the allowances] is you’re never not a public figure any more. You are always a public figure once you’ve been prime minister and-or governor-general. That carries with it certain responsibilities.”
The $10 million figure is the normal trick of take an annual figure and multiply it by expected years until death to make it sound much larger.
A wide range of reactions to National’s Benefits Policy. Taking them in no particular order.
Bll Ralston displys his outraged liberal roots and agrees with Helen Clark that it is beating up on single parents:
Frankly, less than 4000 adhering to the government breast on a more or less permanent basis is extremely few. In an effort to eradicate these last few bludgers, as it sees them, National will spend many millions of dollars in bureaucratic terms policing its new “back to work” system, counselling the DPB recipients and ensuring they really are making a buck for themselves.
Colin Espiner blogged yesterday and calls it Don-lite – watered down from Don Brash, but still different from Labour. He concludes:
There will be the usual objections from beneficiary advocates but National’s welfare policy won’t lose it any votes and may even pick up a few. It will be interesting to see how Labour responds. My pick is it won’t have too much to say.
Simon Collins has a useful look at the party differences:
It [Labour] believes the welfare state exists to empower those who would be powerless without it. For sole parents, the domestic purposes benefit gives them the power to leave unhappy or abusive relationships, and to balance paid work and unpaid parenting in the ratio that suits them and their children.
In contrast National, as John Key put it yesterday, believes in “a genuine safety net in times of need”. It thinks people should be moved on as quickly as possible.
I don’t think National in beliefs or policy encourages people to stay in abusive relationships. The DPB still exists. The difference is, having once moved out, whether or not one is forced to seek work at some stage, or can you stay on it for a decade without ever seeking a part-time job? But Collins is right the views are seen as “empowerment” vs “safety net”.
As his [Key’s] policy pointed out, New Zealand’s refusal to work-test sole parents is now out of line with all Western countries except Australia, Britain and Ireland, all of which have signalled moves to start work-testing.
Yes, as with the 90 day trial period policy, this is standard practice in the developed world.
Collins also has quotes from various advocacy groups:
Family First director Bob McCoskrie, an invited guest at the policy launch, said making parents work part-time made sense, but only if implemented with discretion.
“We’d want to make sure that the work requirements are within school hours and not within the school holidays. Otherwise we are going to have a lot of unsupervised kids.”
Case Managers will need some discretion.
Another guest, Mercy Mission founder Barbara Stone, said she agreed with the work requirement “as long as it’s in school time and there is someone at home for the children for the rest of the time”. She said it was hard to get jobs for sole parents, who often had low self-esteem.
The focus should be on work during school hours only. But a part-time initial job may boost the self-esteem and confidence so that a full or near full-time job is easier to obtain once the kid or kids are older. Having a total break from the workforce for 10 years makes it much harder.
Housing Lobby spokeswoman Sue Henry said she was upset that John Key had “regurgitated” the work requirement policy that National implemented in the 1990s. “Quite frankly, latch-key kids and youth gangs and transience are a direct byproduct of taking the stick to beneficiary families [in the 1990s],” she said.
Yes there were no gangs before the 1990s. What a sensible contribution.
But Parenting Council chairwoman Lesley Max said the requirement for sole parents to work 15 hours a week was “consistent with the norm that exists across society as a whole”.
And who would argue with Lesley?
John Armstrong looks at the policy also:
Something old, something new, something borrowed, something blue – a much paler blue in the case of National’s bits-and-pieces patchwork welfare policy.
Heh that could apply to many National policies!
The latest policy is archetypal John Key. It promises things Labour would happily do itself – such as making the annual inflation-related adjustment of benefit rates a legal obligation on governments, rather than just convention.
Yet in forcing part-time work obligations on some sickness beneficiaries the policy has enough to be identifiably National in origin. But not so much that it frightens centre-ground voters.
Labour and the Greens ritually slammed the policy as an attack on beneficiaries. Some in National’s ranks must think “if only”.
As I said, a sensible combination of carrot and stick.
The Herald editorial is reasonably negative on the policy:
It [solo mothers breeding to get the DPB] is probably as much a myth as the Labour Party’s idea of the average employer. That is to say, there are instances of benefit abuse just as there are rogue employers, but to treat the whole beneficiary class as though they are avoiding paid work would be as foolish as legislating labour arrangements for all. Nevertheless, that is what National proposes to do with sole parents, invalids and sickness beneficiaries.
It is an interesting analogy, but somewhat flawed. Not all sole parents, invalids or sickness beneficiaries are being work tested. Only those DPB recipients whose children are aged over six, and only that small minority of invalids or sickness beneficiaries who have been medically assessed as capable of part-time work. The editorial concedes this later down, so the rhetoric of “treat the whole beneficiary class as though they are avoiding paid work” is somewhat hyperbolic.
For sickness beneficiaries the policy seems fair enough. As the economy has strengthened and the unemployed have faced more stringent job-seeking requirements, the numbers on sickness and invalids benefits have risen suspiciously high. They have needed only a doctor’s note, and even if the doctor assesses them to be capable of part-time work, they have been under no obligation to seek it. National intends to change that.
Some praise amongst the grumpiness.
But there will be cases where the time and cost of taking a low-paid job put added stress on a sole-parent family for little if any financial gain. It is doubtful that society gains from that stress, or that it is worth the trouble the ministry might take to enforce it.
Single mothers with good earning capacity are normally anxious to return to paid work as soon as child care allows. National’s efforts will be felt mainly by those with few skills and poor earning capacity and, frankly, Mr Key ought to have more important things to do. This policy does more to stroke the shibboleths of party supporters than meet any pressing social need. He should return to topics that count.
The policy is pretty standard in the developed world. And having an extra 30,000 or so people in the workforce will help close the gap with Australia.
The Herald reports on a guide put out by the Catholic Church for the 2008 election. They don’t endorse a party or candidates,but do have a checklist of issues people should ask about and take into account.
I’ve managed to locate a full copy of the guide. Here are some of their statements, and my scores:
Every abortion involves taking one person’s life for another person’s reasons.
0 for DPF.
The Church supports stem cell research using adult stem cells or umbilical cord blood, but not creating embryos for the purposes of research and other people’s medication and then discarding them.
And another 0. Very strongly in favour of embryo stem cell research. Their potential is incredible.
Those who support euthanasia and assisted suicide sometimes seek our support by claiming they are acts of mercy. The Church in contrast sees this as an abandonment of people who most need our care and protection, particularly when they themselves are concerned not to be a burden to others.
And a hat trick of zeros.
Some employment policies and practices affect family life. For example, families can be deprived of adequate time together, workers may have experienced a reduction in job security and real wages, and children and young people may not be sufficiently protected.
Another zero for me as they rail against liberalising shop trading hours.
Psychologists point out that a father’s love and a mother’s love are different and that each contributes differently to a child’s development. The Church continues to recognise and respect the need for a child to receive both kinds of love.
This leads into their opposition to same sex marriage and adoption. And yet more zeroes for me.
Ten years ago the Churches joined together in the Hikoi of Hope to ask the government to give more weight to the impact of the economy on people’s lives in the areas of employment, poverty, housing, health and education. New Zealand now has the lowest unemployment figures in the OECD, but this has not been reflected in improved living standards for the poorest New Zealanders, and inequality continues to grow. Our Catholic social tradition recognises that the effect on the poorest and most vulnerable members of our community is the measure of our public policies.
And another zero as the words Hikoi of Hope wants to make me vomit. They show no understanding of a country’s need to create the wealth, to be able to share it. Instead they just advocate for higher taxes and higher benefits.
A truly humane society would ensure that people have times of stillness to see more deeply into life; times of quiet to hear from the heart; time for wonder, beauty and thanksgiving – and other things the Treasury cannot count. These are dimensions of life and of being truly human that are squeezed out when the market forces which should be in our service, somehow become our master.
And now they blame poor old Treasury for the fact some people work hard. Yet another zero.
Their other sections are on asylym seekers, international aid, cultural diversity crime and environmental justice. I’m going to save time and give myself a zero for all of them.
The Catholic Church has that rare ability to advocate for almost everything I disagree with. On most social issues they are reactionary and conservative while on economic issues they are to the left of the Alliance. They are equally hostile to social freedoms as they are to economic freedom. My views on the churches can get very passionate because of that.
This must be why when I was entered the church in England where Shakespeare is buried, that my friends expressed surprise that my feet did not catch fire 🙂
Many people will have seen ads on Sunday by John Boscawen continuing his campaign against the Electoral Finance Act. As I have said, I doubt there will be a vote against repealing it after the election, and then work could commence in good faith on a replacement which not only is clearer, but doesn’t have the restrictions on every-day advocacy and such low spending limits.
The NZPA database has 716 articles on the Electoral Finance Act since 1 January. Almost without exception, they are all negative.
Even worse is the hypocrisy since then of Peters and Clark, who claim it was all about stopping secret donations. That wasn’t even in the original bill, and since it got passed we have learnt a lot about how NZ First are the masters of the secret donations.
Most people know the cow meme:
Economic Models explained with Cows
SOCIALISM
You have 2 cows.
You give one to your neighbour.COMMUNISM
You have 2 cows.
The State takes both and gives you some milk.FASCISM
You have 2 cows.
The State takes both and sells you some milk..NAZISM
You have 2 cows.
The State takes both and shoots you.BUREAUCRATISM
You have 2 cows.
The State takes both, shoots one, milks the other, and then throws the milk
away…A FRENCH CORPORATION
You have two cows.
You go on strike, organise a riot, and block the roads, because you want
three cows.
The challenge is to use the cows to describe NZ First 🙂
Sweeney Vesty has just sent me a press release, which I’ll quote below:
Elliott International, L.P., together with funds under common management (“Elliott”), a 30-year-old private investment firm and shareholder in Telecom Corporation of New Zealand Ltd. (TEL.NZ), today nominated two local, independent, candidates to the Board of Directors to provide new thinking and new ideas regarding the future strategic direction of the company.
The Board candidates, who will stand for election at the Annual General Meeting on October 2, are Mark Tume, from Wellington, an experienced director with a banking and funds management background, and Mark Cross, from Auckland, who has a global financial markets background specialising in utilities. The candidates have agreed to stand on the basis that, if elected, they will be independent and will represent the interests of Telecom and all of its shareholders. Elliott believes that the candidates’ understanding of investor needs will create a cooperative and energetic environment between the Board and its shareholders.
“For almost a year we have been trying to talk to Telecom about some of our ideas and concerns regarding the affairs of the company. Telecom’s share price has been in decline over the past few years and once again, following disappointing year end results, its share price is around a fifteen year low. In our view, Telecom’s performance languishes behind that of other key telecommunications players in the international market, and we believe this is partly due to an unclear and outdated strategy. Shareholders and customers remain dissatisfied with Telecom’s progress,” said James Smith, a portfolio manager at the fund.
Elliott believes that the appointment of Mark Cross and Mark Tume will provide a fresh perspective to the current challenges Telecom faces. Both Mark Cross and Mark Tume have considerable strengths in the finance and investment industry, strong commercial and strategic acumen and unique skills that will provide extra depth and new ideas for Telecom. Their expertise in financial strategy will be of particular value to the Board.
According to Elliott, Telecom needs to take immediate and serious action to improve its situation and to consider and debate new ideas that will benefit customers and shareholders.
One idea that Telecom has been asked to consider by Elliott over the past year is ‘structural separation’ — the next logical step in the operational separation process that Telecom began earlier this year. This idea involves a simple structural split of Telecom’s retail business (‘NewCo’) from the remaining wholesale and network business of Telecom (‘NetCo’). This structural separation idea was first proposed by Elliott in November 2007 when Elliott and other interested groups publicly commented on Telecom’s operational separation plan. The proposal is still available on Ministry for Economic Development’s website at http://www.med.govt.nz/templates/ContentTopicSummary____32573.aspx.
Since that submission, Telecom’s management and the Board have been provided with extensive research and analysis on the structural separation proposal, including reports from global consultancies on key feasibility issues – regulatory and legislative implications, cost, and technical issues. The research also outlines the significant benefits the proposal could bring for Telecom, its shareholders and customers.
Now what this is about, is a minority shareholder saying we think Telecom would be more profitable if it does full structural separation (something I think is also beneficial for Telecom and for consumers), and as Telecom won’t agree with us, we are going to try and get two Directors on the board who will look at supporting this.
Now Elliott are not one of the top 20 shareholders, so their chances of success are somewhat limited. But with this board challenge, they will force other shareholders to consider the issue of whether Telecom would be better off with structural separation.
Dean Knight has the full details, but here is the short version:
For people who are interested in a systematic assessment of the MMP, the New Zealand Centre for Public Law, in conjunction with Institute of Policy Studies, Victoria University of Wellington
and the Centre for New Zealand Studies, Birkbeck, University of London, is hosting a symposium on MMP and the Constitution on 26 and 27 August 2008 (simultaneously video-cast in London, with a number of international speakers):New Zealand Centre for Public Law
GBLT1 and GBLT2,
Government Buildings
15 Lambton Quay
Victoria University of Wellington, Wellington
New Zealand
6:30pm-10:00pm, Tuesday 26 August 2008
7:00am-10:30am, Wednesday 27 August 2008Centre for New Zealand Studies
ST274 and ST275, Stewart House
32 Russell Square
Birkbeck, University of London, London
United Kingdom
7:30am-11:00am, Tuesday 26 August 2008
8:00pm-11:30pm, Tuesday 26 August 2008
The programme is here. And one can register here. $25 for students, $175 for academics and a fairly expensive $250 for others. I was going to attend until I saw the $250 cost. That’s too much for me, just to cover the event on the blog.
After years of insanity, there is some hope in Zimbabwe. The Telegraph reports that a deal is close which will see Mugabe remain President, but many powers transferred to Morgan Tsvangirai as his Prime Minister.
As much as I would like to see Mugabe put on trial, a peaceful solution is desirable, and if it has to involve immunity for Mugabe and his henchmen, so be it.
While anyone is better than Mugabe, it is worth noting Tsvangirai is no angel, and Zimbabwe path back to relative peace and prosperity could be a very long one.
John Key has just delivered a speech, where he outlines National’s Benefits Policy. A summary is in this press release, and also they have released the full 11 page background paper. Very pleased to see the full papers released.
So the major aspects:
Looks to me a very good moderate policy, with the right mixture of carrots and sticks. The left all too often go all carrot and no stick, while the right do all stick and no carrot.
The Press reports:
The Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry has received an assessment of the impact of the Government’s flagship climate-change policy on the value of land handed to iwi under Treaty of Waitangi settlements.
Officials are refusing to divulge the monetary figure placed on the estimated loss in value contained in the assessment by senior Christchurch-based valuer Donn Armstrong, of Forest Land Consultants.
However, Maori say they could be owed as much as $2 billion in compensation, because land currently in forests will not be able to be converted to other potentially more profitable uses.
So we are starting to get to the beginning of the end of settling historic grievances, with compensation likely to be around $1.5 billion.
And the ETS could create a new contemporary grievance of up to $2 billion?
This is why NZ needs to be very careful as we proceed with an ETS. Again, we need to develop one or risk trade sanctions, but need to ensure the costs are proportional to the benefits.
Also we should consider what our Kyoto obligations mean in light of Russia’s invasion of Georgia. You see there is a high possibility that we would have to purchase carbon credits off Russia as we will be well above our 1990 emissions levels. So we may end up giving Russia hundreds of milllions of dollars of hard cash, which they can use to fund their war in Georgia. Yep, there is no mechanism for excluding Russia because they have gone nasty – if they have the carbon credits, they will get billions of dollars in hard currency for them.
I was curious as to how the four elections we have had under MMP, would have gone under SM. It was relatively simple to redo the St Lague formula to calculate this, so below are who each election would have turned out under SM:
In 1996, National and NZ First went into a coalition with a 61/120 majority. Under SM this is still a likely outcome but they would have had 64 seats instead of 61. NZ First were not that keen to go with Labour if they were dependent on the Alliance and Labour/NZF was 56 MPs so this problem still existed.
Overall it is hard to see a different outcome under SM.
In 1999 Labour and the Alliance formed a minority Government with 59 seats out of 120. They were backed by the Greens to give them 66/120 on supply and confidence.
Now under SM Labour could have governed alone. It is possible they may have chosen to go still do a Coalition with the Alliance, but I suspect they would have been treated like the Greens – supporting players outside Government. Ironically if this had been the case, it is likely the Alliance would not have disintegrated on the Afghanistan issue. If they had not been in Government they could have oppossed troops, like the Greens did. I suspect Anderton’s ego made a bust up with Harre and McCarten inevitable at some stage, but perhaps not as early as 2002.
In 2002, Labour formed a minority Government with Progressive having 54/120 seats. They had confidence and supply from United and Greens giving them a total of 71 seats. Under SM they could have governed alone.
In 2005, Labour formed a majority Government with Progressives, NZ First and United having 61/120 seats. They also had agreement to abstain on confidence and supply from the Greens and a non formal abstention from the Maori Party meaning they could win confidence votes 61 to 50. National tried to put a Government together also which was in theory possible with National, ACT, United Future, and Maori Party having 57 seats but they could not get NZ First which would have given them 64.
Under SM, Labour, Progressive, NZ First and United Future would only total 59 seats so Labour would have been a minority Government relying on abstentions from Green and Maori Party. Arguably more likely is Clark may have gone left instead of centrist and done a Labour, Progressive, Green, Maori coalition which would give her 62 seats.
What options did National have, if this was SM? On 51 seats they need 10 to make 61. Assume ACT and United Future and they are at 55 seats. Maori Party would give them 60 but they would still be one seat short.
So under SM, the Alliance may have never disintegrated, and the Greens may have got their long desired coalition agreement in 2005, as Clark would have been unable to get a majority just with NZ First and United.
And in no case would there have been a different major party in Government.
The Weekend Herald reports John Key as saying he does not favour a return to FPP, but is leanign towards SM which is a semi-proportional system.
“I’m leaning towards Supplementary Member,” Mr Key said. “It allows for proportionality while ensuring it’s not the dominating factor. You get the best of MMP without it being overpowering. That is the reason why.”
I also don’t support a return to FPP, but think both STV and SM have merit. MMP has worked well in many ways, but there are areas where it does not. I think the biggest weakness is the huge power given to so called centrist politicians such as Peters. There is no doubt he would have been sacked from his Ministerial role by now, if it were not for MMP.
For those who do not know how SM works, it is very similar to MMP but with the vital change that the allocation of list MPs is done by having them supplementary to the electorate MPs. In practical terms it means that under SM every electorate won by a party is a net gain for thet party. Under MMP if you win an additional electorate, you get allocated one less list MP.
SM is used in around 16 countries including Japan, Georgia, South Korea, and Taiwan.
Anyway it is worth taking a look at SM, the pros and cons of it. No electoral system is perfect with only positive attributes. So what are the pros and cons of SM:
Pros of SM
Cons of SM
There are probably more pros and cons that these ones. Feel free to add them below.
An interesting book called The Boss Benchmark by Allison O’Neill. Some examples of when bosses go bad, and how to avoid it.
It appeals to me, because I have been lucky enough in my life to have had some of the best and worst bosses in the world. The great ones inspire you, while the bad ones teach you what not to do when you become a boss.
Today’s Dom Post Editorial:
However inquiries into Winston Peters’ party funding turn out, one point is certain. The system for funding political parties needs grassroots overhaul and a multiparty accord, The Dominion Post writes.
The overhaul should at least bring an end to secret donations and repudiate an idea much beloved of the prime minister – state funding of political parties. MPs filch enough now from taxpayers’ pockets. Were the work of party hacks to be totally taxpayer funded, it would create an elite that never allowed newcomers on to Parliament’s floor. The Maori Party could never have gatecrashed had its supporters had to match cash given to the old guard from the public purse.
Bringing an end to secret donations is easier said than done. Doing so may lead to the donations flowing to the MPs personally, rather than their parties.
I of course am against state funding of political parties. The Dom Post is right that such funding would make it much harder for newcomers to make it into Parliament – it helps entrench incumbent parties.
So here is an idea to make it fairer for newcomers. As the current parliamentary parties have a huge advantage through parliamentary resources and free media, why not restrict the broadcasting allocation to parties not in Parliament? Why should parties who are in the media every day or every week get assistance with their election campaign? I’d rather that money goes to the parties trying to break into Parliament.
The act must go. It has had only humour value since January 1, when it came into force, because the typically cautious public servants who must administer it have hamstrung Labour and those parties that voted for it probably more tightly than it has hogtied its opponents. To see Progressive leader Jim Anderton pinged for an advertisement advising of a BZP ban was exquisite.
The act’s critics foresaw the current muddle. The law is undemocratic and the way it was imposed an exercise in arrogance.
As bad as the substance of the law is, it is indeed the way the Government negotiated the original Bill in secret with no public input that did the most damage. It differed from the antics of certain third world countries only by degree – it was a blatant attempt to use electoral law to screw over its enemies.
New Zealand likes to believe this small but modern democracy is largely corruption-free. It is thus dispiriting to learn that some at the centre risk operating in a way that would make an African despot proud.
I think we are well overdue in having an Independent Commission against Corruption – a body with wide powers that can investigate Ministers, MPs and senior Government officials.