A new Russian war

Over the past few years as Russia has clamped down on opposition and the media, I’ve kept a vain hope that it wasn’t necessairly a return to the days of the Soviet Union.

But their war against Georgia shows that the bad old days are back. Sure – not to the same extent. The old USSR will never return, but it seems obvious Russia desires control of territory outside its borders.

I don’t think anyone knows where this will end. Will they take over Georgia completely or just parts of it? Will the US or NATO station troops in Eastern Europe? What will happen if Georgia does join NATO?

How did he think he could get away with it?

Men often cheat. This is hardly news. And politicians are no different – in fact if anything are more prone to cheating due to thenature of a job where they live away from home.

But I am still somewhat amazed when it is revealed that a senior US politician has been cheating on his wife – how could they think they would get away with it when there are 100 journalists following them about.

So John Edwards’ political career is over. The fact his wife is dying from cancer (and he had exploited this) makes it far worse for him than a normal affair. Add onto that the fact he lied repeatedly about it, and his Finance Chair was paying off the woman (from campaign funds I presume) and the man who calimed to the father of the child of Edward’s girlfriend – well I can’t see a rehabilitation around the corner.

I have to say I can’t imagine Obama ever cheating on Michelle Obama. And McCain’s cheating (hopefully) is in his past.

Preview of National’s welfare policy

The NZ Herald and Dom Post preview National’s welfare policy which will be released today. Key aspects so far:

  • DPB recepients whose youngest child is six or older spend at least 15 hours a week working, training or looking for work
  • Allow beneficiaries to earn $100 a week before their benefits abate – an increase $1,000 a year.

Both seem pretty sensible to me. Will be interesting to see the full policy.

Tauranga Poll Results

For those who missed the poll on One News, I have the results on curiablog.

Obviously the great news is that Simon Bridges is 20% ahead of Winston Peters. Peters is facing a crushing from someone born around the time Peters was first elected to Parliament.

What I also found also of interest is the party vote results with NZ First at only 6%. Last election they got over 13% so this is a loss of over half their support.

General Debate 10 August 2008

A late link to TGIF

Ian Wishart has released the first edition of his new weekly e-newspaper – TGIF. The first edition is available for free. As web designer Dennis Smith has noted, it is quite large (8.5 MB), but probably hard to have it much smaller and retain the quality.

The lead story focuses on this quote from Ruth Dyson:

“Shifting the focus from social welfare to social development is about considering the wellbeing of the whole population, and communities within that population, rather than solely focusing on the traditional family group. We must cater for the diversity, we know exists. By this I mean the range of relationships from single, couples, triples, blended, de facto, and so on. That’s where we’re going with social policy.”

Now this is not just something Dyson blurted out, or was secretly taped saying in a sting operation. This was in her speech notes on the Beehive website. They have since taken it down, which suggests the Government knows it is embarrassing. That is in itself worthy of questions as the Beehive website is meant to be a record of all Ministerial speeches, and not just selected ones.

Now I’m a fan of the TV series Big Love, but really I don’t think the Government needs to be catering for the polygamists. In fact in most countries they actually tend to discourage polygamy, while Ruth seems to want the NZ Government to cater for it.

10 economic propositions

Paul Walker blogs a list of 10 economic propositions accepted by almost all the top economists:

  1. The market economy is the most efficient of all economic systems.
  2. Free trade helps economic development.
  3. Good institutions help development.
  4. The best measure of a good economy is its growth.
  5. Creative destruction is the engine of economic growth.
  6. Monetary stability, too, is necessary for growth; inflation is always harmful.
  7. Unemployment among unskilled workers is largely determined by how much labor costs.
  8. While the welfare state is necessary in some form, it isn’t always effective.
  9. The creation of complex financial markets has brought about economic progress.
  10. Competition is usually desirable.

Walker concludes:

Sorman closes this piece by noting that one of the hardest ideas to translate into language that public opinion will accept is the fact that even the best of all possible economic systems is still imperfect. Markets are one of the many human institutions that are the result of human action, but not of human design. But they are based on people and without perfect people you are unlikely to get perfect markets. But for all these imperfections, we have yet to find a better economic system.

Market economies are indeed not perfect. But as Paul Walker says, no-one has found a better system. It reminds of the Churchill quote about how democracy is the worst possible way to choose a Government – except for all the other ways!

Politics round-up

Matt McCarten labels the last week as a great week for Labour, and is hoping for many more.

The SST tries its best to talk up the nonsense about Bill English plotting a coup against John Key, but English is 100% unequivocal:

English told the Sunday Star-Times he was happy to flag the possibility of being leader for the rest of his political career and he would never challenge Key for the job: “No ifs, no buts, no maybes.”

But the SST continues to attempt to cause problems for National, with Hager and Hubbard reporting on rumours that Don Brash could be appointed High Commissioner to London if National wins.

Key discussed giving Brash the top job in either London or Washington when he replaced him as party leader in 2006. Since then this has firmed into Key planning, if elected, to offer Brash a three-year posting as high commissioner to London, a position that costs the taxpayer about $600,000 a year.

Here is where you can tell the SST is trying to make the story as negative as possible for National. Instead of reporting on the salary for the job which is $130 to $170k they report on the total cost of having a High Commissioner in London, as $600,000 sounds better than under $130,000.

Only later on, do they report the salary. The $600,000 is a meaningless figure unless the SST thinks NZ should do away with having a High Commissioner. There is a difference between salary and work related costs.

As for the substance of the story, I refer people to my previous post on Government appointments of politically connected persons. It is all about quality and quantity.

Olympics

When Wellington weather is crap, a buffet of Olympics watching is well timed. The rowing heats especially have been superb watching even though the Kiwis have generally crushed their opposition to date.

Emma Twigg’s race was probably the closest as she came from behind to lead in the last 150 metres or so.

The swimming has also been a must see – especially Michael Phelps to see if he can win eight medals again.

Once again I love My Sky. Just fast forward through to the races you want to see!

SFO talks to Bob Jones

July 2008 Public Poll Averages

Later in the weekend, the July 2008 polling newsletter will be released. The two main graphs for NZ are below:

The gap between National and Labour narrowed from 23% to 18%. National is hovering at just over 50%.

NZ First is at a two year high, having broken past 4%. Most of the polling was prior to revelations over funding, but regardless they have been going up since the budget.

The full newsletter is only available by e-mail. If you would like to receive future issues, go to http://listserver.actrix.co.nz/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/polling-newsletter to subscribe yourself.

Interesting random questions

Kiwi Party policies

NZPA reports the Kiwi Party is having its inaugural national conference today. Some of the reported policies are:

  • Government subsidies for marriage preparation courses
  • Establishing a Royal Commission to address family breakdown
  • Repeal the Prostitution Reform Act
  • Raise the minimum wage from $12 to $15 an hour;
  • Introduce income splitting for married couples with children
  • Make houses more affordable by releasing more building land as new houses should cost $190,000
  • Sell 20 percent of State-owned Enterprises to investors who were resident in New Zealand

A mixture of the most stupid from the left (minimum wage to $15) and the right (repeal Prostitution Reform Act).

To be fair the policy to release more land for building is commendable, as is allowing Kiwis to invest in SOEs.

Election Dates

John Armstrong takes a considered look at possible election dates. The short version:

  1. October 18 – may mean some appointments have been within the three month period when they should not be made
  2. October 25 – Labour Weekend
  3. November 1 – All Blacks vs Australia to screen at 4.30 pm Hong Kong time which is 9.30 pm NZ time
  4. November 8 – four days after US election
  5. November 15 – Canterbury Show Weekend

I still do not rule out an even earlier election than this, because of the Privileges Committee.

Half a billion of Ecstasy

Self-rule for Tuhoe?

The Herald reports on an aspect of the terms of negotiation between the Crown and Tuhoe, which is to provide clarity regarding their constitutional relationship.

Calls from Maori activist Tame Iti for self-government arrangements for the Tuhoe tribe similar to those Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland have in the UK have been backed by a leader likely to negotiate the tribe’s Treaty settlement. …

“It’s one of the things which has been consistent since the 1870s: Tuhoe’s regard for their nationhood and their independence.”

However, before formal negotiations proper began the iwi had to decide what specific arrangements of self-government it would like to see, Mr Kruger said.

He said nations had existed within nation-states for hundreds of years and while other iwi – for example, Te Atiawa or Ngati Toa in Wellington – might struggle to make a compelling argument for self-government because of the large number of non-Maori in their areas, Tuhoe’s geographical isolation changed things.

The United Kingdom is certainly an example of having countries within a country.  But I am unsure one can draw the analogy too far. As noted in the article, the presence of non-Maori in an area is a huge issue.

You see self rule in Scotland and Wales etc is not based on bloodlines, or ethnicity, or nationality – but simply location. An englishman living in Edinburgh has just as many rights to vote in Scottish elections, as a native Scots.

There are around 30,000 Tuhoe, and currently it seems only around 6,000 live in their traditional lands. I am unsure how many non-Tuhoe live there, but I could not imagine a situation where non-Tuhoe living there would be allowed to become second class citizens with lesser rights of representation.

It is also worth noting other differences between Scotland and Tuhoe:

  1. Length of self-rule – Scotland existed as a country for around 1200 years before 1707. it is unknown how long Tuhoe was a distinct tribe in NZ, but far far less
  2. Population – Scotland has 5 million residents and only around 6,000 Tuhoe live in their traditional lands
  3. Legal System – Scotland, despite being part of the UK, continued to have its own legal system

I’m not oppossed to devolution of powers in cases that are appropriate. But in the UK the devolution has been to all citizens in an area, not just those of a particular ethnicity.

Paris for 2016

The Dominion Post editorial endorses Paris Hilton for US President in 2016:

Her recreational predilections, as revealed on the sex video 1 Night in Paris, should not prove a bar. Bill Clinton might not have had the video camera out, but he was, as Hillary euphemistically observed, “a hard dog to keep on the porch”, and Mr Kennedy’s lustre has not been diminished by revelations that he, too, was prone to wander.

It’s the same story with a brush with the law that saw Ms Hilton briefly jailed for probation violations after driving drunk. After all, George W Bush was fined for drink-driving in 1976. The key is how it is handled, and she followed Mr Bush in showing suitable contrition by announcing she would go to Rwanda to help after her jail sentence. Strangely, she has not managed to make the trip yet, but then broken promises are stock in trade for politicians. …

Sadly, she does face one insurmountable problem. While the US Constitution does not require you to be a “wrinkly white-haired guy” to be president, you do have to be 35. At 27, Ms Hilton misses out. Roll on 2016.

Helping terrorism?

I meant to cover this earlier, and Murray McCully’s newsletter is a good reminder:

Revelations this week that NZAid has provided $121,500 of taxpayers’ tsunami relief cash for the Tamil Rehabilitation Organisation (TRO) raise serious questions about both the aid and security policies of the Clark Government. The TRO has for some time been widely regarded as a funding front for the Tamil Tigers, outlawed as a terrorist entity in most like-minded jurisdictions, but not in New Zealand. The TRO, too, has increasingly been targeted by authorities, and its operations suspended in several countries. So why is New Zealand so far out of step? …

NZAid paid over a cheque for $121,500 in tsunami relief funding to the Tamil Rehabilitation Organisation (TRO) back in 2005. But even then NZAid should have been on notice that the TRO was regarded as a fund-raising front for the Tamil Tigers terrorist activities.

In 2005, the British Charities Commission removed the TRO’s charitable status because it had “not been able to account satisfactorily for the application of funds.” On 1 October 2006, the Swiss Police arrested the TRO Secretary at the French border carrying 18 million Euros in cash, destined for the Tamil Tigers.

It’s nice we can do something for the Tamil Tigers. The spirit of giving.

Not sure this is a good thing

Have a friend down from Auckland and staying with me for the weekend. She told me that when the taxi driver dropped her off, he commented that she was staying at the place which had the party last week.

It is true I did have a party last Thursday, but I didn’t think it was particularly noticeable. All the guests must have used the same taxi company as they told her they did several trips to it!

Blog Bits

Four interesting blog pieces – all from “professional” journalists also. First off is Nick Stride, editor of The Independent:

Deputy Prime Minister Michael Cullen was on even shakier ground when he tried to paint National leader John Key’s debt raising and infrastructure investment strategy as a ruinous policy designed to hide borrowing to fund tax cuts.

If memory serves, it wasn’t so long ago Labour was attacking National for the speed with which it was pushing national debt levels down to 30% of GDP.

Now it’s on the attack over plans to lift that ratio from 20% to 22% a rise so insignificant it will barely register at the sovereign rating agencies.

The fact is, New Zealand ranks high among OECD countries in terms of its debt-to-GDP, and in the bottom half in terms of its infrastructure. It therefore makes perfect sense to allow the two to come a little closer together, to everybody’s benefit.

It’s true, as Vernon Small points out in his column on page 24, there’s no free lunch; the extra debt envisioned by National will have to be serviced, reducing the amount government can spend elsewhere.

But it’s not a zero-sum business in which a dollar spent on infrastructure is a dollar that must be taken from health or education. According to research conducted in 2004 by Macquarie Research Economics, every 1% rise in infrastructure spending can be expected to lift GDP 0.5%.

This is what the debate should be about – whether the return on the capital and the interest on borrowing is a good investment – will it lead to higher economic growth. Instead we have had a near Taliban like mentality – that any extra borrowing is madness and Muldoonism.

The Dom Post’s Vernon Small also blogs on this issue:

Yes, National’s plan to increase gross debt to 22% of GDP is conservative. But maintaining it two percentage points above Labour’s target does bend the party-political continuum.

Since when did centre-right parties run a looser fiscal regime than centre-left ones?

It is somewhat ironic. My non serious answer is since Labour started believing in tax cuts. My serious answer is that centre right parties see a difference between borrowing and expenditure on social spending, and borrowing for expenditure on capital works.

No, National cannot credibly say it is raising $750 million in borrowing only for infrastructure and not for tax cuts. Residual borrowing is the net impact of a complete revenue raising and spending programme, though there are good accountability reasons why politicians should explain how new programmes affect the mix.

Finance Minister Michael Cullen is also happy to let debt rise over the next few years, driven by a tax-cut programme. So it is a relativist, not absolutist, debate. They may as well argue they are borrowing to cover the impact on government revenue of the current recession.

Yes if National is borrowing for tax cuts, so are Labour. As I did a long winded post on last weekend, you have a current account and a capital account, and the cashflow funds both those things.

He isn’t a blogger but Keith Rankin writes in support of infrastructure spending:

Helen Clark and Michael Cullen are describing National’s proposal to borrow in order to fund infrastructure projects “incredible”, meaning foolhardy and irresponsible. (“Key unveils plan to borrow, PM dubs it ‘hilarious”‘ – NZ Herald August 4, 2008.) All Clark and Cullen are doing is showing how out of touch they are with economic reality.

Financial crises happen when lending slows down significantly in financial markets. The problem usually is a lack of credible borrowers. This is precisely the time that borrowers such as governments funding infrastructure need to step up to the plate.

Governments need to spend more and borrow more precisely when the private sector is spending less and borrowing less. This was the most important lesson of the Great Depression in the 1930s.

Ben Thomas writes on the so called secret agenda:

All of which is a roundabout way of saying the scandal that did erupt – the audio files of English and the Smiths, Lockwood and Nick – was outrageously overplayed by the media and National’s parliamentary opponents.

The story was as follows: an unknown person, who claimed later to be unaffiliated with any political party, attended the Friday night social event posing as a National Party member and engaged the three senior MPs in conversation around left-wing touchstones: state ownership of Kiwibank, nuclear power and Working for Families.

The conversations were recorded and played on the broadcaster as evidence suggesting that National had a “secret agenda.”

Fine. Except the recordings disclosed no such thing. They were evidence of absolutely nothing except a slightly looser verbal style than MPs would present in a formal media interview or Parliament. This is a story about language.

The Smith & Smith conversations especially were hyped up massively. They were quite unexceptional.

At it’s most basic, there is syntactic precision: there was little effort made in the media to differentiate a secret recording of a conversation (as in this case) from a recording of a secret conversation (which may have yielded something much more interesting).

A useful point.

English conceded he would eventually prefer to sell off Kiwibank “but not now.”

In fact absolutely nothing in English’s comments was inconsistent with National’s declared policy. Lockwood Smith was accused of revealing the hidden agenda when he said “Once we have gained the confidence of the people, we’ve got more chance of doing more things.”

He even said, “We may be able to do some things we believe we need to do, perhaps go through a discussion document process – you wouldn’t be able to do them straight off.”

In other words, National may have a secret plan to, er, consult with the community and gauge public opinion before implementing new policy.

Yes, how a public policy consultation process is proof of a secret agenda, I do now know.

The reality is the secret agenda meme is all about trying to associate a negative brand with a party. I will touch more on this next week, but is is the equivalent of the “Have you stopped beating your wife” question.

There is a very relevant example of a major political party in government pursuing a deeply unpopular policy in the face of public opposition, and refusing to abandon it despite repeatedly being told it is not what voters want. It is the Labour government’s push for state funding for political parties.

Labour has never campaigned in an election on this policy but it is a fond wish of the prime minister and her party.

It’s also a policy that is widely detested by the public, and has been soundly rejected every time its prospect has been floated either through official comments or strategic leaks.

Labour’s secret agenda for state funding – indeed. They don’t have the guts to make it a manifesto promise, because they know it is as popular as anthrax.

Finally back to Vernon Small again, who asks where the dividing line is between bloggers and journalists, with the catalyst being my accreditation as media at the National Party conference. It is an interesting issue (especially to me), but somewhat academic. This is the fourth or fifth National conference I have attended as media. I’ve also been in budget lockups as media, attended tax conferences, spoken on media panels at media conferences, and get invited to cover conferences and seminars on a very regular basis.

I’ve commented over on Vernon’s blog on a couple of issues he raises.

Observations

  1. Slicing your finger with a sharp knife is relatively painful
  2. A surprisingly large amount of blood can flow from a very small cut. And keep flowing. And keep flowing.
  3. It is very difficult to put on a band aid one handed, as the other hand as it is covered in blood. Eventually teeth play a part!
  4. Typing without your left forefinger is challenging as it is a digit one uses a lot naturally.

Espiner on Happy Ruth

Colin Espiner blogs on how Ruth Dyson is always seeing the bright side:

Everyone loves an optimist, so Labour’s Ruth Dyson must be amongst the most-loved MPs.

Her press statements on rising unemployment are always full of good cheer, and Dyson somehow seems blithely unaware of the gloomy economic conditions.

Back in May she caused something of a stir by putting out a press release headed “Labour Force Survey Reflects Stability In The Face Of Economic Challenges”. You’d have thought the unemployment rate had defied the economic downturn and things remained sunny. In fact, the survey reported the biggest jump in jobless in nearly 20 years.

Likewise, today’s next quarterly report on the unemployment rate, which finds an additional 7000 people have lost their jobs in the past three months and the unemployment rate now up another 0.2% to 3.9%, is welcomed by Dyson in a release entitled “New Zealand Economy in Good Hands”.

Ruth should have been a Minister when we had the Erebus crash. She may have done a press release highlighting the decline in carbon emissions due to no return trip!

I think Dyson’s skills are being wasted as Minister of Social Development – she could do wonders in the Treasury or the Reserve Bank. Under this minister, Treasury’s report this week warning of recession could have been headed up: “More good news likely on economy” and the bank’s gloomy predictions of 5%-plus unemployment could have been rewritten as “It’s all good here, too”.

Colin does go a bit fuzzy later on with petrol prices though:

Labour will be extremely grateful to whoever bugged the National Party conference for taking bad economic news off the front page. It’s even possible that today’s whitewash from Dyson’s Christchurch colleague Lianne Dalziel on petrol prices will equally disappear with nary a trace, given the media’s perchant for a decent whodunit.

It’s hard to swallow the minister’s recommendation that nothing needs to be done about regulating an industry making $11 billion profits a quarter because it is “fundamentally competitive” and that, essentially, the idea that petrol prices are fast to rise and slow to fall is simply a myth perpetrated by the media.

A more cynical journalist than myself might suggest that the government has several interests in not forcing down the price of petrol; for one thing, the GST take is much higher when prices are high, and for another, the high petrol prices are forcing some vehicles from the road, which is helping with emissions targets.

I think Colin is being a bit hard on Dalziel here. First of all the NZ oil companies do not make $11 billion profit a quarter. The NZ Govt has no power to regulate the global oil companies, which I presume that $11 billion refers to. It is a red herring figure. And a profit figure is meaningless anyway unless one knows what the turnover or capital was. An $11 billion profit on a $1 billion equity company is a universe different to an $11 billion profit on a $100 billion equity company.

Secondly it is a “myth perpetrated by the media” that higher petrol prices leads to much higher GST. Because the money spent on petrol is not spent on other goods and services, reducing GST collected there. Hence overall GST does not rise greatly, if at all, with higher petrol prices.

Colin is right though that the higher petrol prices may help with reducing carbon emissions.

Wellington Zoo erecting fence – to keep people out

Reading the Dominion Post story on Wellington Zoo, brought back some memories for me. They are putting up an electric fence – not to keep animals in, but keep people out.

I have to admit in my silly and foolish youth I did a nocturnal visit to the Zoo, climbing in over a fence. I can’t recall who I was with, but am almost certain it was to impress some visiting female, who I had promised a tour of the zoo to, even though it was 2 am.

It was, in hindsight, rather stupid as we had no idea if the fence we were climbing over led to a walking track or into the lion’s den. Luckily it was the former.

Spent around an hour looking around. We then made the mistake of taking a photo of the baboons. Now having a flash camera go off when it is pitch black does not go down well with baboons who started making some very loud noises. This then set off the other cages, and within around 60 seconds half the zoo was howling. At this stage I decided we should leave and we scampered over to the nearest fence – which also luckily went to the outside – not a den.

I am of course now a respectable member of society, and regret my youthful indiscretions!

The “f” word in Parliament

Margaret Wilson has not surprisingly ruled that you can not say “fuck” in Parliament, even when quoting someone else.

This reminds me of that times Havoc and Wells interviewed the then Speaker Jonathan Hunt, with Hunt in the Speaker’s Chair looking most serious. He then got more and more anxious as they pelted him with questions about what words can one say in Parliament? Can you say fuck? How about shit? How about dumb-arse? etc etc. The list went on for some time until finally they hit on a word which was okay!

20% higher pay in the public sector

A study by Waikato University has found that pay rates in the public sector are around 20% higher than in the private sector.

What is amazing about this is that in most countries, public sector pay rates are well below private sector. This is because they tend to have greater security of tenure, are not linked to earning revenue, and have lots of perks such as longer holidays and funding for tertiary study.

To have public sector pay rates 20% higher than the private sector, shows how merrily the Government has been trying to get the PSA happy. That is the same PSA which will shortly be campaigning against National’s tax cuts.