PDT on the Internet

Internet policy people will be interested in the interview the Herald did with Peter Dengate-Thrush, the NZers who chairs ICANN – the global allocator of domain names and IP addresses. Some extracts:

In terms of safety is the web getting better or worse?

“The internet is neutral about these things – it’s really a question about the users. One of the reasons I’m participating in this is to assist with the constant requirement for user education – in this case we’ll be educating the educators. It’s a bit like saying is fire a good thing or is the wheel a good thing. It’s good when it’s done properly.”

That’s a great response. The Internet is no more good or bad than fire or wheels are.

What are the biggest threats to our internet freedom?

“The biggest threat to the internet itself is developing the wrong culture along the lines that I was just talking about. If we get that wrong, it’ll be humans and the way that humans use this particular tool that will cause the problems. You’ve got to be clear – there’s nothing inherently good or bad in the technology itself, it’s what we choose to do with it.

Indeed.

Our own stupidity that could trip us up?

“Yes. The sort of threats at the moment come from people attempting to impose controls and that runs into all the usual problems that we’ve struggled with over the centuries of this civilisation.

“Where the boundaries are between harmful knowledge and harmful expression and the right to freedom of expression. Getting the balance right is always very difficult. It seems clearer in war time for example when there’s an acknowledged crisis, civil liberties are curtailed. Absent those circumstances we struggle to be as clear as we can. Another clear example is the universal prohibition on child pornography and the exploitation of children. Those don’t cause much debate – it’s in political expression and inciting racial hatred and these sorts of areas where the current debate is raging.

I think religious expression is very much a topical issue also.

Do you think we’ll be left with another toothless [copyright] law with one test case that will fall over at appeal and leave us back at square one?

“There’s a worse case than it being toothless and that’s it being very toothful – ISPs having to go around closing down all sorts of relatively routine and safe and stable websites because they happen to be hosting – even if it’s against their knowledge – some infringing material.

The new law removed any penalty for filing a false takedown notice, so the potential for misuse is considerable.

Should it be up to ISPs to police the behaviour of their customers? It’s almost like Transit NZ being blamed for a road crash.

“Occasionally Transit are responsible for that if they’ve designed the road badly, but in this case, I take the view that ISPs have a role that’s supposed to be no greater that that of other citizens in relation to infringements. I particularly disagree with the thrust of the current amendment, which turns the ISPs into enforcement agents for copyright owners. I’m a copyright lawyer and I’ve acted for copyright owners and I’ve written on the value of copyright to the community. It’s not an attack on copyright but we do need to get the balance right between copyright interests and the rights of ordinary citizens and what’s good for the internet industries.

For an intellectual property lawyer, he speaks a lot of sense šŸ™‚

Buchanan on Obama

Paul Buchanan had a perceptive article in yesterday’s Herald on Barack Obama’s foreign policy challenges:

Barring some unanticipated event, Barack Obama is set to become the 44th President of the United States.

I think it will take something quite big to remove his lead.

Obama has sounded off against free trade agreements in order to court domestic constituencies. He has railed against Chinese dominance in the US consumer market and called for measures to stop the export of US jobs. This puts him at odds with Senator McCain and leading sectors of the US business community as well as foreign trading partners such as New Zealand. He will therefore have to reverse the US’s commitment to free trade, or betray his protectionist promises and abandon his working class supporters once in office.

This will be fascinating. We probably have not had a protectionist in office since Jimmy Carter. Arguably Bush was semi-protectionist in action if not in rhetoric. McCain would be the most pro free trade President the US has had.Ā  I suspect Obama will drop much of his protectionist rhetoric in office, but will not see out any free trade opportunities. I see very little hope for a successful WTO round under Obama.

The same is true for Obama’s stance on Israel. He claims that he will break the deadlock in US Middle Eastern policy by taking a fresh critical look at its relationship with Israel, but then pledges that his administration will never do anything to compromise the special bond that the US has with the Jewish state. He promises to address the Palestinians as full partners in the peace process, then speaks of a unified Jerusalem, contradicting the Palestinian stance on the sacred city. He cannot have it both ways. He will have to backtrack on at least one of his promises which augurs poorly for the prospects of real change in the status quo.

I can’t see him sticking with his undivided Jerusalem pledge.

Senator Obama, like so many others, speaks of eliminating oil dependency. Yet he opposes offshore and land-based drilling in the US. Although the Saudis, Kuwaitis and various smaller Emirates understand that election rhetoric destined for domestic consumption does not mean a shift in ongoing relations, it does mean that continuance of these relations could have negative domestic repercussions down the road.

Obama may find, like Kevin Rudd, that people blame the Government for a lack of supply.

Over-reliance on the military because of the failure of “soft” power or multinational approaches makes the president and his foreign policy advisers beholden to the uniformed command. Obama’s limited and tenuous relationship with the US armed forces means that he assumes office having to establish a rapport with the military leadership before asking them to fulfil their obligations to the country and constitution. Obama’s refusal to recognise that the so-called “surge” strategy has borne fruit in reducing levels of violence and promoting indigenous political solutions to post-invasion nation-building efforts in Iraq only complicates the picture. This leaves the possibility that the military will obey his commands, but that does not mean that it consents to his authority.

It will be interesting for how long Obama will be able to stick to his line that the surge has failed.

All of which is to say that contrary to the hopes of many inside and outside of the US, an Obama presidency will not necessarily bring with it an immediate change to more positive international relations. The way he handles his first policy crisis will determine whether that becomes fact or fantasy.

I think Obama will have more positive relations initially than Bush (or McCain). But as Paul says the test will come with his first crisis. What does he do when North Korea starts building nukes again? Or when Iran declares itself nuclear capable?

One pissed off columnist

An e-mail by David Cohen on a journalism list alerted me to this wonderful e-mail from The Times’ restaurant reviewer Giles Coren to the sub-editors. Read the whole thing, but here are the highlights:

I wrote: “I can’t think of a nicer place to sit this spring over a glass of rosĆ© and watch the boys and girls in the street outside smiling gaily to each other, and wondering where to go for a nosh.”

It appeared as: “I can’t think of a nicer place to sit this spring over a glass of rosĆ© and watch the boys and girls in the street outside smiling gaily to each other, and wondering where to go for nosh.”

There is no length issue. This is someone thinking “I’ll just remove this indefinite article because Coren is an illiterate cunt and i know best”.

He does not hold the language back!

Well, you fucking don’t.

This was shit, shit sub-editing for three reasons.

1) ‘Nosh’, as I’m sure you fluent Yiddish speakers know, is a noun formed from a bastardisation of the German ‘naschen’. It is a verb, and can be construed into two distinct nouns. One, ‘nosh’, means simply ‘food’. You have decided that this is what i meant and removed the ‘a’. I am insulted enough that you think you have a better ear for English than me. But a better ear for Yiddish? I doubt it. Because the other noun, ‘nosh’ means “a session of eating” – in this sense you might think of its dual valency as being similar to that of ‘scoff’. you can go for a scoff. or you can buy some scoff. the sentence you left me with is shit, and is not what i meant. Why would you change a sentnece aso that it meant something i didn’t mean? I don’t know, but you risk doing it every time you change something. And the way you avoid this kind of fuck up is by not changing a word of my copy without asking me, okay? it’s easy. Not. A. Word. Ever.

I love the Yiddish references.

2) I will now explain why your error is even more shit than it looks. You see, i was making a joke. I do that sometimes. I have set up the street as “sexually-charged”. I have described the shenanigans across the road at G.A.Y.. I have used the word ‘gaily’ as a gentle nudge. And “looking for a nosh” has a secondary meaning of looking for a blowjob. Not specifically gay, for this is soho, and there are plenty of girls there who take money for noshing boys. “looking for nosh” does not have that ambiguity. the joke is gone. I only wrote that sodding paragraph to make that joke. And you’ve fucking stripped it out like a pissed Irish plasterer restoring a renaissance fresco and thinking jesus looks shit with a bear so plastering over it. You might as well have removed the whole paragraph. I mean, fucking christ, don’t you read the copy?

3) And worst of all. Dumbest, deafest, shittest of all, you have removed the unstressed ‘a’ so that the stress that should have fallen on “nosh” is lost, and my piece ends on an unstressed syllable. When you’re winding up a piece of prose, metre is crucial. Can’t you hear? Can’t you hear that it is wrong? It’s not fucking rocket science. It’s fucking pre-GCSE scansion. I have written 350 restaurant reviews for The Times and i have never ended on an unstressed syllable. Fuck. fuck, fuck, fuck.

This is a man who takes his columns and language seriously!

In NZ, the sub-editor would probably win a personal grievance for hurt feelings šŸ™‚

World Internet Project

Those who like facts and figures will have no end of them in the NZ report as part of the World Internet Project. It is probably the most comprehensive study of NZer’s use of the Internet. Some interesting stats:

  • 79% of NZers use the Internet
  • 15% of users are online for over 20 hours a week (half a fulltime job)
  • 66% of users have broadband
  • 71% of users say the Internet is an important source of information, compared to 52% for newspapers and television
  • 10% of NZ Internet users have a blog (this is a very high figure internationally)
  • 28% of users use Facebook or other social networking sites
  • 25% of users have made friends with someone online and half of those have gone on to meet them in person
  • 15% seek info about political parties or MPs online
  • 43% support Government funding to enable wider Internet access while 34% oppose it
  • Almost 80% of teenagers visit social networking sites, and 40% of those in their 30s do so.
  • Over 30% of Asian users have a blog, compared to under 10% for Pakeha and around 3% for Maori
  • Around 20% of those in their teen or 20s have a blog, and slightly more females than males
  • The more you earn the less likely you are to blog

It will be interesting to see how it has changed in a few years.

UPDATE: Paul Reynolds has a great post on what theimplications of the suvey are for NZ.

COG gone

The Coalition for Open Government has announced it has effectively wound up.

I am surprised. They were such strong advocates for the Electoral Finance Act, and they haven’t had a word to say on current political finance issues.

Never mind – I am sure they will reappear if National wins, to defend the Electoral Finance Act. After all – someone has to.

And Winston gets his attack wrong

Winston has been attacking the media for several weeks alleging they have their facst wrong, the Herald editor and political editor should resign in disgrace etc.

So you would think Winston would be careful when he accuses others of wrong-doing. But no displaying the same wrongness he accuses the media of, he targeted Craig Foss:

Mr Peters attacked National MP Craig Foss, tabling Companies Office records in which Mr Foss was listed as owning 2,524,750 shares in Cynotech Holdings.

Mr Peters questioned why Mr Foss’ shareholding was not listed in the Register of Pecuniary Interests in which all MPs are required to declare their financial interests.

Hmmn, well this could be an issue. But …..

In a statement to Parliament, Mr Foss, said the shares were registered in the name of the Foss Family Trust, and this was included in his disclosure of interests.

He also tabled a statement from the share registry confirming the trust had owned the shares – worth about $423,000 at yesterday’s prices – since April 2003.

So if we use Winston’s own rhetoric, shouldn’t he apologise and resign as he kept demanding the Herald do? I suppose the difference is the Herald story was true.

Peters also targeted former Green MP Ian Ewen-Street:

Mr Peters, who has come under hard questioning from the Green Party over the donations, also brought up the case of former Green MP Ian Ewen-Street and his partner Sue Grey.

In 2003, Mr Ewen-Street stood down from a select committee inquiry into the scampi industry, citing potential conflict of interest after he began a relationship with Ms Grey, who was a lawyer appearing before it.

Yesterday, Mr Peters described it as “improper behaviour”.

Now on this issue, Peters is correct that it was improper behaviour. I said so at the time:

I’m shocked that Green MP Ian Ewen-Street absents himself from hearing evidence on the Scampi inquiry due to a conflict of interest, yet took part in the final deliberations.

Considering the conflict of interest was that Ewen-Street was rogering the lawyer for one of the parties, I’m amazed he felt he could take any part at all in the deliberations.

But two wrongs do not make a right. The actions of Ewen-Street in 2004 do not mean Peters can do what he likes in 2008.

The “massive difference”

The Herald reports:

New Zealand First leader Winston Peters insists that there is a “massive” difference between his party getting funding from corporate donors via secret trusts and other parties getting it.

He won’t say what, but is promising to spell it out in Parliament today. …

Outside the House, Mr Peters was asked what the difference was between his party getting large donations from corporate donors via secret trusts and other parties getting it.

Mr Peters said the difference was “massive”, but that the reporters were not capable of understanding it. He said he would explain it today.

I agree with Winston the differences are massive. To help Winston explain, let us look at some of the differences:

  1. NZ First has railed against such trusts for 15 years
  2. The NZ First Leader personally benefits from some or all of the trust donations, not the party (payment of legal fees)
  3. The NZ First Leader personally solicits money for such trusts (Sir Robert Jones and Professor Wright testifying)
  4. The NZ First Leader’s parliamentary staff collect money for such trusts (Meurant and McClay)
  5. The NZ First Board have no idea the trust even exists (President says he has never heard of it in eight years on the board, nor has the Deputy Leader)
  6. Donors think by donating to the trusts they are donating to NZ First (Owen Glenn and Sir Robert)
  7. The trusts are so secret that no-one even knows they exist until the media expose them (for which they are told they should apologise and resign)
  8. The trusts do not declare any donations to NZ First
  9. The trusts are run by the personal lawyer and the brother of the NZ First Leader
  10. The trusts are not declared on the Register of Pecuniary Interests

So that is massive differences indeed between other parties and NZ First. Sadly for Winston his funding arrangements are less transparent and more covert in almost every aspect possible.

EPMU allowed to register – again

I’ve just been told by a journalist that the Electoral Commission has decided to allow the EPMU and four other unions which have chosen to be affiliate members of the Labour Party to register as a third party. This means the five of them can collectively spend $600,000 attacking National on behalf of Labour.

I think the Electoral Commission has got it massively wrong – again. Their decision that “person” in the EFA excluded organisations got over-turned by the High Court quite comprehensively.

On this issue, I am astonished that they could have reached a conclusion that the EPMU is not involved in the administration of the Labour Party, when there was documented evidence they take an active role in selections, conferences and the like. They in fact have a constitutional entitlement which probably makes them the most powerful member after the President.

The Electoral Commission was required to turn down any third party application unless they were posiively satisifed they were not involved in a party’s administration. This meant that if it was a borderline call, it should still have been turned down. And I don’t think it was even close to borderline.

My arguments on the EPMU’s involement with Labour are here. The Electoral Commission decision is here. At this stage they have given no reasoning for their decision.

I won’t decide on any next steps until I have read the rationale for their decision.

There have been many decisions the Electoral Commission has taken which I have supported. There have also been several where I disagreed with their decision, but believe it was a reasonable decision nonetheless.

This decision, and their earlier one which the High Court over-turned on the EPMU, fall into a category where I don’t think any reasonable person could reach the conclusion they have.

The Obama pilgrimage

A very good piss-take at the Times on the Obama fawning:

When he was twelve years old, they found him in the temple in the City of Chicago, arguing the finer points of community organisation with the Prophet Jeremiah and the Elders. And the Elders were astonished at what they heard and said among themselves: ā€œVerily, who is this Child that he opens our hearts and minds to the audacity of hope?ā€

In the great Battles of Caucus and Primary he smote the conniving Hillary, wife of the deposed King Bill the Priapic and their barbarian hordes of Working Class Whites.

And so it was, in the fullness of time, before the harvest month of the appointed year, the Child ventured forth – for the first time – to bring the light unto all the world.

He travelled fleet of foot and light of camel, with a small retinue that consisted only of his loyal disciples from the tribe of the Media. …

Thence he travelled west to Mount Sarkozy. Even the beauteous Princess Carla of the tribe of the Bruni was struck by awe and she was great in love with the Child, but he was tempted not.

On the Seventh Day he walked across the Channel of the Angles to the ancient land of the hooligans. There he was welcomed with open arms by the once great prophet Blair and his successor, Gordon the Leper, and his successor, David the Golden One.

And suddenly, with the men appeared the archangel Gabriel and the whole host of the heavenly choir, ranks of cherubim and seraphim, all praising God and singing: ā€œYes, We Can.ā€

Read the whole thing, It is very well done.

Wellington Central Campaign Launch

So much for an explanation

Well Winston stood up and asked for leave to do a personal explanation. This was granted and everyone waited for him to well explain.

Alas he just launched a barrage of abuse at the media, and then sat down having revealed nothing at all. Rodney tried valiantly to point out that a personal explanation should be used to explain – not just a free whack at the media.

The highlight was when Gerry Brownlee did a point of order asking for leave for a representative of the media to be allowed to respond šŸ™‚

Hutt South Billboard

Is Fairbrother a candidate or not?

I was not the only one puzzled by Russell Fairbrother getting himself elected the president of Napier Grey Power. His election has been voided as politicians are ineligible to hold office.

But what is very curious is his response:

Mr Fairbrother said he believed the rules forbade political candidates, not MPs.

Fairbrother is of course the Labour Party candidate for Napier.

Now to be fair he has as much chance of winning back the seat he lost in 2005, as Britney Spears has to win Mother of the Year. But he realy should not concede the election until after the ballots are cast.

Quote of the Day

From Colin Espiner:

Asked whether she planned to urge Peters to be straight with the public at her meeting today, Clark said: “I think there is such a long history of the nature of Mr Peters’ relations with the news media that that might be asking for a state of affairs that is not possible to achieve.”

Did the Prime Minister really just say that it is Impossible (not possible) for her Minister of Foreign Affairs to be straight with the public and the media?

Tui strikes again

Taken from Whale Oil.

It is arguable the billboard is illegal under the Electoral Finance Act as it cost over $1.000, can reasonably be seen to persuade people against Winston, and is not authorised or done by a registered third party.

The NZ First funding diagram

Bomber Bradbury Tim Selwyn at Tumeke has done this nice little slush fund diagram to help people understand how it all works. Good job.

If there is a second edition, one could add on Ross Meurant next to Roger McClay as a collector of money, and also the Vela family as funders.

Clark distancing herself from Peters?

The Herald picks up a shift from Clark:

Prime Minister Helen Clark distanced herself from Foreign Minister Winston Peters last night, implying he could be judged to be hypocritical if his New Zealand First Party accepted donations from secret trusts.

And she also offered the bare minimum in terms of expressing confidence in him.

Clever Helen. She must be very worried about the revelations to date.

Asked if she viewed Mr Peters as hypocritical given his long-time railing over big political donations from secret trusts, Helen Clark said it was a political issue that would be judged in the court of public opinion.

“Stands have been taken over a period of time which could be read as being in contradiction to what is emerging in the public arena.

That means yes.

Meanwhile, a former New Zealand First staff member said yesterday that in a discussion about Sir Robert and donations in the 1990s, Mr Peters asked for Sir Robert to be referred to as “X” in case the offices were bugged.

The staff member, who did not want to be named, said Mr Peters also had the office swept for bugs.

Another former staff member, Rex Widerstrom, said he recalled discussions of a $50,000 donation from Sir Robert in 1995 and the Spencer Trust being used “like a code word” for Mr Peters’ litigation fund.

One wonders just how much has gone into the Spencer Trust over the years, and how much has gone into NZ First itself?

A witness to a 2005 discussion between Sir Robert and Mr Peters about the donation, Professor Malcolm Wright of the University of South Australia, said yesterday that Mr Peters had tried to get $50,000. But he had got only half of that after the property magnate caved in out of “mateship”.

Mr Wright, who was working for Sir Robert, said they met Mr Peters and his “offsider” – understood to be former National MP and former Children’s Commissioner Roger McClay – “over a few drinks”.

Mr Wright said Mr Peters was out of the room when the donation was first discussed and came back and “quite aggressively asked who raised it” before having a long discussion that included Mr Peters trying for $50,000.

Professor Wright’s recollection seems excellent.

Roger McClay is going to need to speak up at some stage. The simple question is why was he soliciting money for the Spencer Trust while employed in the parliamentary office of Winston Peters?

The questions for Winston are simpler. I use a famous quote:

What did the president he know and when did he know it?

No more one pagers please

Colin James has beaten me to the punch, on the issue of National’s one page policy papers:

So in behind the bland one-pagers lies quite a lot of study, consultation with outsiders and internal shadow cabinet debate. A 34-page paper backed the workplace relations one-pager. Law and order policy was well footnoted.

That applies in all major policy areas. In some, such as education, welfare and the environment, the background papers have been reworked over some years. Immigration and local government papers have been honed down. In some, as in housing, science and in a complex set of policies on infrastructure, some work remains to be done. In some, the background is essentially a statement of principles.

In 2006 Key, freshly leader, backed an English programme to publish discussion papers, to be refined into policy after feedback (much as Kevin Rudd did in Australia). But only a handful emerged before the health paper’s bungled release last September abruptly ended the process. Now some policy is being released without the supporting papers. Outsiders have to take on trust that the policy is based on solid thinking. Key read out to me the workplace relations paper’s headings but I have not seen it.

Having previously worked in Parliament, I was pretty certain that there was a lot of work and detail behind the one page policy summaries, and Colin has confirmed this is the case – which is good.

99% of NZers are not interested in the details. In fact they won’t even remember too much from the one pagers – the average voter will have a vague idea of half a dozen key policy pledges probably.

But the 1% do not want the detail behind them. The 34 page backgrounder on workplace relations for example probably has some great details on how the 90 day trial period works overseas, the issues around the Holidays Act etc. Releasing the background paper doesn’t detract from the one page summary – it complements it. It demonstrates the work done by Spokespersons and staff over the last two years.

Yes, Mallard will jump up and down over a minor detail on page 27 and scare monger about it. But Trevor will scare monger on the smell of an oily rag. Don’t let the fear of scare mongering detract from showing to pundits and the public that the policies National is campaigning on are based on extensive research.

So can we have the full policy background papers please. If you don’t want to release them on the day of the main policy that is fine, but can we have them at some stage.

Will Peters attack?

The Press reports:

Rather than answer questions about the Spencer Trust however, Peters is expected to highlight large corporate and personal donations to the National Party’s Waitemata Trust and to “name names” under Parliamentary privilege.

This is to be expected. I doubt Peters has any knowledge of donors to the Waitemata Trust, and suspect he will just name all the businesses and businesspeople he doesn’t like.

Peters fails to understand there is a difference between him making an allegation under parliamentary privilege, and the media reporting on documents which prove donations (such as the Glenn e-mail and the Vela cheque) and of course direct testimony from donors such as Sir Robert Jones.

The other issue of course is that the Waitemata Trust’s donations to National have been declared every year on their donations return.

Now don’t get me wrong. I am a supporter of closing down trusts as a way to hide identity of donors. My submission on the EFA said as much. I think anyone who gives over $10,000 a year should be disclosed (note the EFA allows up to $46,000 in one year without disclosing identity).

But if Winston thinks his issues will go away, by making some allegations under parliamentary privilege, he may be surprised.

National announces two list only candidates

National has announced two of its list only candidates. They are Steven Joyce and Melissa Lee.

Steven will be a very popular choice – he played a key role in the 2005 campaign which lifted National’s vote by 18% or so, and is an incredibly capable and talented individual.Ā  He is also the Chair of the 2008 Campaign Committee so this gives him an incentive to get a really good result!

Melissa Lee is a member of the APN Board of Directors. And no before the conspiracy theorists get excited, that is not APN Media but the Asia-Pacific Producers Network.Ā  Ms Lee is the host of Asia Downunder and has 20 years of broadcastign and journalism experience.

Steven also has a background with broadcasting – In the late 80s he co-founded and then became CEO of what is now Radioworks NZ Limited, building it up over 14 years to a sharemarket capitalization in excess of $100 million.

Editorials on Peters

Two editorials saying it is time for proper answers from New Zealand First. First The Press:

… in the present row, Peters’ reputation is being severely eroded by his refusal to give a clear and full account of the large sums paid to his party.

The circumstances of those transfers are so suspicious and the issues so significant that few people other than his most one-eyed followers would doubt that an explanation is needed. Without it, the impression is left that an important party and a main participant in the Government has been the beneficiary of secret payments, large in amount and made for unknown reasons and with unknown consequences.

We don’t even know what the Spencer Trust spends it money on. At least with the Waitemata Trust there is a clear paper trail that it makes donations to National and discloses them. There are no donors to the Waitemata Trust saying “Hey we though this money would get passed on and it wasn’t”.

Doing that will depend on Peters addressing fundamental issues: how much has been paid by various donors and which entities associated with the party have received it; who were the donors; to what purpose has the money been put; have the donations and their dispersal been legal?

It is probably unrealistic to expect the identity of donors to the Spencer Trust to be disclosed, but someone has to front up on why Winston and his personal staff were soliciting money for it, and how has that money been used.

Events, though, may be conspiring to derail his plans. The sense is that more disclosures will be made and the survival of the Government has been brought into play. That latter issue means the Prime Minister is a participant in the business, and she has it in her power to be decisive in deciding its outcome.

Helen Clark has managed to distance her party from the row, but the longer it continues, the more likely is Labour to be damaged. New Zealand First is a main coalition partner a connection that risks guilt by association in a nation already suspicious of Labour’s conduct of electoral matters.

Labour often attacks National on its former secret trusts. It will never be taken seriously on such issues again if it continues to sit there saying it has no issues with the NZ First arrangements which are far far less transparent.

And the Dom Post:

The labyrinthine funding affairs of NZ First need to be publicly unwound, The Dominion Post writes.

NZ First leader Winston Peters has campaigned long and hard against secret trusts and the role of big business in funding political parties, and for transparency. Now, when it is his own behaviour that is being questioned, he favours stonewall and bluster, rather than revelation and explanation.

And the notion that he knows nothing at all about a trust he solicits money for, named after his namesake, his staff collect money for, and his brother runs is insulting our intelligence

Mr Peters has, in the past, called for an investigation of a trust that gave the National Party $50,000, railed against the non-disclosure of donations and proposed legislation requiring that all donations above $500 should be disclosed.

As recently as last year he fulminated against the role of covert money in politics.

And it appears no party has more covert money than NZ First – in two weeks we have learnt of two secret trusts or funding sources which benefit either Peters personally or his party.

It also means doing more than simply calling the claims “unsubstantiated rubbish,” offering the view that Sir Robert’s memory is failing and protesting that he has no involvement with the Spencer Trust. These are serious issues that deserve a serious response, rather than the aggressively delivered but content-free dismissals that have been offered so far.

The people who should have the most pressing questions are in fact the NZ First Board and Caucus. It appears none of them had any knowledge of the Spencer Trust despite the fact the Leader’s staff was collecting money for it, and donors to it think by donating to it they are supporting NZ First.

Surely at least one of them is concerned enough about their own integrity and credibility that they want a decent explanation? Are they not concerned that possibly hundreds of thousands of dollars has gone into a private fund they know nothing about, and not under the party’s control? What if Peters died suddenly? Would any money in the Spencer Trust go to the party or go elsewhere?

Mr Peters argues that none of the claims made so far contain evidence that NZ First has acted outside the law, but he, more than any other politician, should know this issue is not just about the letter of the law.

It is also about whether a party with a leader who last year warned a Nelson audience of the dangers of “huge funds of secret money seeking to distort our democracy” and argued for “transparency and spending limits” on political spending is prepared to back its rhetoric with its actions. Unfortunately, Mr Peters so far has shown little sign of doing that. Instead his actions suggest he regards transparency as a virtue best practised by others.

Indeed do as I say, not as I do.

Nor can Prime Minister Helen Clark continue to treat the issue as one solely for NZ First. She must accept that Mr Peters is a minister in her administration, as well as the leader of a rival political party, and that it is not possible to fully separate the two roles. The questioning Mr Peters deservedly faced over the funding issues as he held a press conference with United States Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice simply underlines that.

Her message to him today must be explicit: if you wish to continue as a minister, clear this up honestly, openly and quickly.

If Clark allows this to just carry on and on, them more fool her.

Michael Littlewood responds on KiwiSaver

Michael Littlewood has kindly e-mailed me a response to my comments on KiwiSaver. Michael is an expert on superannuation policy and is co-director of the retirement policy and research centre at Auckland University. He has been on almost every expert taskforce there has been on superannuation.

DF:And this law change will make it illegal to pay them more money if they do not go into KiwiSaver.

ML:I think the argument is rather to give KiwiSaver members smaller future pay increases to allow for the cost to the employer of KiwiSaver. The outcome may be the same but there is a different emphasis.

DF: So this is the head of the Unite union agreeing the the EMA Northern that the scheme dsicriminates agaianst the poor, young and old!

ML: McCarten is not completely accurate. The young do get the kick start and also the favourable tax treatment afforded by the PIE tax status of most schemes. However, they don’t get the member tax credit and the employer isn’t obliged to contribute. For the old, yes the employer doesn’t have to pay but the member tax credit continues for some (those who haven’t completed five years). However, all of this wouldn’t matter if the employer could pay members and non-members for the job they are doing, not based on whether employees joined KiwiSaver or not.

DF: Exactly. The overall costs to the employer should be the same.

ML: Non-members (who as McCarten and Thompson acknowledge will tend to be the young and the poor) will miss out in three potential ways – first, there is the direct difference in total remuneration that is the subject of this blog. Secondly, employers that are forced to pay more to members will compensate with lower future pay rises to all. That means both members and non-members will all get less but members will have the compensation of the employer’s contributions and the tax breaks that non-members won’t get. Thirdly, the non-members will, along with everyone else, be paying higher taxes to pay for the cost of KiwiSaver but won’t be getting their share of the taxpayers’ handouts.

DF: It is becoming close to de facto compulsory and I suspect it will become compulsory at some stage.

ML: But compulsion doesn’t magically make things “fair”. If young, poor employees can’t afford the 48 cents an hour now, how does forcing them to pay the 48 cents an hour suddenly make it affordable? It may remove some of the current inequity only because there will be no difference between different groups of employees. And then what about the other unfairnesses of a compulsory KiwiSaver? Will non-employees be forced to pay as well? (Not many countries with compulsion do that for good reasons). If not, their taxes will be higher to pay for the employees’ KiwiSaver. Then there will be the inequity between the old (whose taxes will be higher to pay for KiwiSaver) and younger taxpayers. And what about children who can join KiwiSaver now? (Why that should be so is probably best explained as a legislative accident).

DF: I support KiwiSaver partly because it is an effective privatisation.

ML: But only if you accept that KiwiSaver leads inevitably to an Australian style income/asset test on New Zealand Superannuation. If you really want to know why that’s a bad idea, you need to understand how the Australian system works and why it is that the incomes of most Australian financial planners are dependent, in part, on developing ways to avoid both tests.]

DF: And McCarten is right that it will inevitably lead to a move away from the current universal publicly funded superannuation scheme. A 25 year old today will earn more money in retirement from KiwiSaver and NZ Super than they will during their working life. That is nuts, and inevitably public superannuation will be made less generous as more and more people have KiwiSaver.

ML: think the more likely outcome will be a scaling back of the KiwiSaver incentives. We don’t yet know what National really thinks of KiwiSaver II. If the long term policy drift is back down towards a KiwiSaver I, the alarm about the impact on the future New Zealand Superannuation benefit might be lessened. However, I agree that future governments cannot really sustain both in their present shape.]

DF: Indeed. Employers should be able to offer a total remuneraton package where if an employees chooses not to go into KiwiSaver, the employer can pay them extra cash.

ML: The shame of it all is that, before KiwiSaver I or II, the best evidence we have is that most New Zealanders were saving enough for retirement – see here, here, here and here for examples. My fondest hope is that a new government might wish to adopt the radical notion of evidence-based policy making. Regrettably, there hasn’t been too much of that from either Labour or National in the last 11 years (since the second Todd Task Force in 1997

Thanks to Michael for his comments.

The John Key unauthorised biographies

Well the NZ Herald has finished the second part of what was in total around 15 pages on John Key’s family, history and background. This comes on top of a Sunday Star-Times in depth investigation in Europe and the US of Key’s history as a currenct trader and manager at Merrill Lynch.

None of them turned up anything remotely dubious, which is quite atonishing. Let me tell you that if three journalists spent six months researching my past, there will be much galore. God – just Otago University alone could fill up a chapter or two. Most of us have done really stupid stuff that we later regret and would not have done in hindsight.

One of the NZ Herald stories was on the fight for Helensville. It is all history now but there are one or two aspects to it, I had some knowledge of and can comment on.

Simpson says he briefly considered looking outside of Auckland but for family reasons decided against that. Among the seats Key looked at was Tamaki, held by sitting MP Clem Simich. Party officials convinced him it wasn’t a wise move because Simich had a strong electorate network.

Otherwise known as the Tamaki Mafia šŸ™‚

In May 2001, Key made his first speech on the political stage, addressing a regional conference at Auckland’s Waipuna Lodge before a crowd of about 250 people. Slater liked the content (Key spoke about New Zealand’s place in the international scene), but felt the delivery was unpolished. “His really true character didn’t come through,” says Slater.

John also spoke to a Young National conference around then also, and had an engaging policy proposal – that one should have a literacy test for the dole. The idea being instead of getting the dole, you get paid to undertake tuition so that someone who is unemployed gets taught enough so they can at least have basic numeracy and literacy – to open up job opportunities.

On the day of the candidate selection meeting on March 17, 2002, it is alleged that the start of the meeting was delayed by more than 20 minutes so that a delegate known to be supportive of Key could make it for the vote; normally, the doors to the meeting were locked after 10 minutes.

The delayed delegate was a friend of mine, and he was a bit late to the meeting. His vote wouldn’t have affected the outcome in the end, but if he had not made it there he would not have been popular.

Regarding the door being left open, he said: “I recall that there was one delegate who had phoned 10 or 15 minutes before arrival and said they had been delayed and would be late and was that a problem. We got around that by delaying the meeting’s start by five minutes, then I did an introduction, then I saw the delegate arrive and then proceeded in the normal way.”

The delegate was delayed – the dopey bastard had slept in! And then he proceeded to make up for this by driving along the western motorway at around 200 km/hr and made it just in time!

John Key did so well, he even ended up with Brian Neeson’s electorate chair offering to help him. I like this story:

After winning the candidacy, Key asked Milich to stay on as chairman, an invitation he turned down because he and his wife were heading off overseas for an extended holiday. But before Milich left, he told Key he would help him out any way he could.

“You don’t know where to get billboards from, do you?” Key asked.

“Yeah, we’ll make them. Come around,” said Milich.

For a man who, by his own admission, doesn’t have a handyman bone in his body, it was a galling proposition for Key.

Nevertheless, Key turned up with his son Max and spent the day with Milich, hammering and nailing together billboard frames.

“I had a lot of respect for him after that day,” says Milich.

The other online story is the main 18 page one. I’m interested in the three “swift acts” he took as Leader,as the Herald deccribes them:

First, Key did a deal with chief rival English in which someone else had to lose. In this case it was Gerry Brownlee, the man who had been deputy under Brash and who clearly wanted to hold on to that job. Key cut the deal over a weekend, operating out of his Parnell home, on the phone for hours and occasionally opening his big metal gate to welcome senior party figures in for talks. English was one of them.

By Sunday night Key had managed all the egos to a point where Brownlee was convinced to step aside with English coming into a position of considerable power as deputy leader and finance spokesman. Brownlee retained an important strategic role under Key, who in doing the deal with English for an uncontested vote united the bickering factions of the party.

It is hard to over-state how important this decision was in hindsight. The caucus has never been more unified. It was pretty tough on Gerry Brownlee who had been an effective Deputy to Don Brash. But it also showed Key’s ability to be pragmactic and judge the best course ahead. John would have won a ballot against Bill, but he also needed him to be Finance Spokesperson. And to get him to agree to do that, needed make him Deputy also.

Then came the difficult task of dealing with Brash, who was making noises that he would stay on as an MP if Key gave him an attractive portfolio. For Key, a clean break was better. Having Brash sitting on his front bench was going to detract from the fresh start Key wanted, where he quickly moved to embrace New Zealand’s anti-nuclear policy and soften Brash’s Maori and welfare policies.

But Brash was handing over the leadership in the way that prevented a bloody battle and he could have been forgiven for thinking Key owed him something in return.

Brash waited for a job offer from Key that never came. Just a week after stepping down as leader Brash quit politics altogether. Key had ignored Brash’s repeated statements that he would be willing to stay and in the end the pair met to talk and it was unceremoniously over.

In the eyes of those in the caucus who had been Brash supporters till the end, it was a harsh exit.

I was one of those who at the time wanted Don to be given a senior portfolio so his talents were not wasted. In hindsight it was an emotional response, and Key did exactly the right thing by not making an offer. In hindsight I think it was better for Don also to be out of the place. Don leaving Parliament took all the sting out of the Hollow Men, apart from a few fanatical MPs who still quote it every week.

The third thing Key did was a no-brainer but it still required an element of toughness. The party’s problem child, Rakaia MP Brian Connell, began talking of returning to caucus after Key took over. Connell had been out in the cold after clashing with Brash about an alleged affair and he told media that he was ready to come back. While the decision rested finally with caucus, Key demonstrated no appetite for bringing Connell back. To this day Connell remains a suspended outsider.

A third tough call. This was one I agreed with at the time, as I thought Brian had caused trouble for not just Don Brash but also Bill English before him, and there was no reason to think it would be different for John.

Having said that, I actually think it is time for the suspension to be lifted. He is retiring from Parliament in a few months, is supportive of the new National candidate for Selwyn and has not been outspoken in the last year. It would be nice for Brian to be able to finish his time in Parliament back in the National caucus.

Trotter on his beliefs

Chris Trotter SST column last weekend generated so many negative responses, that the SST has even put some of them online.

Much better in my eyes is his column in Friday’s Dom Post on what he believes in. Let’s look at them:

A column entitled From the Left conjures out of its readers imaginations a veritable phantasmagoria of political misconceptions. The most common of these is that, being “From the Left”, I must favour the policies Joseph Stalin and Mao Mao Tse- tung.

Problem is, I rejected their credo of Marxist-Leninist communism long ago.

I am curious as to how long ago, and why?

So, what do I believe?

It’s a fair question, and here, for better or for worse, is my reply:

I believe that human societies arise out of need. The need for food and shelter, the need for intimacy, the need for nurturing, and the need for protection – both from natural dangers, and the aggression of our own species. To secure these needs, human beings must work, individually or collectively, but always with the ultimate goal of keeping strong those innumerable threads that bind our communities in a functioning wholeness.

Can’t say I disagree too much with that.

In New Zealand, two peoples co-exist in differing states of awareness of the essential collectivism and dependency of human communities. The indigenous people possess a clear and poignant vision of humanity’s place in these islands. But the colonising peoples could not rest till the ideas and institutions of their respective homelands had taken root in New Zealand. To the extent they succeeded, the conflicts and contradictions of their native lands were also transplanted here.

Resolving these conflicts and contradictions, and discovering the best means of prospering together, is the historic task of the two peoples fated to share these islands Maori and Pakeha.

I think Trotter stereotypes too much here with the “indigenous people possess a clear and poignant vision of humanity’s place in these islands”, but I will agree we do have a duty to work together to resolve past conflicts.

As a social-democrat I am dedicated to furthering in all aspects of my country’s social, political and economic organisation the essential equality of human beings. Social-democracy defines equality in terms of the universality of human need.

Here I start to differ. I certainly believe in doing what we can to get equality of opportunity, but equality of outcome is an impossible nonsense, which takes no account of human nature and differences. The communist states have tried and failed repeatedly in this goal. Even Cuba is backing away from it.

If Chris means all humans have some minimum human rights, then I agree. But the right to have an Ipod is not one of them.

That being so, we must reject all claims hostile to the reality of our interdependence. Individuals and groups who by superior strength or simple good fortune are endowed with wealth and influence, enjoy their advantages on the sufferance of that vast majority whose daily labours make possible a functioning society. Only so long as, in the judgement of the many, the possession by a fortunate few of social, political and economic privileges serves the community as a whole, will those privileges endure. Any attempt by a minority to transform the privileges granted to them by the majority into a system of permanent advantage cannot be deemed just.

And here is where we totally part company. Trotter expresses a view where individuals have no rights – they are allowed to keep their money or property only if the many agree by doing so, it benefits them.

Trotter sees the majority as able to take anything away from the minority, and that minority having no rights. It is the sort of outlook that we see in Zimbabwe where the minority white farmers have had their farms stolen from them. Trotter says the only issue is whether or not it benefits the majority to do so. Now I do not mean to imply in any way that Chris supporters the horrific excesses of Mugabe – I am sure he is repelled by the dictator’s actions. But his views on the rights of the minority, seem to be similar – they have none except those granted by the majority.

As a social-democrat I look to the state, as the institutional expression of our interdependence, to secure for all citizens a healthy and abundant life.

While I look to families to secure healthy and abudant life for most people – with the state being a fallback option and a resource. I also look to business to generate the wealth that really secures an abundant life.

The provision of gainful employment, education, health, housing and protection against adversity are rights due to all New Zealanders. Political institutions are established to secure these rights, drawing their authority from the freely given consent of all responsible citizens.

The state can not provide jobs to everyone – unless one wants to go back to Muldoon. It can set an economic environment in which the private sector creates jobs. It does have a role in funding and sometimes provision of health, education and housing. But that does not mean free PhDs for everyone and a state house for every family. I beleive in targetting assistance to those who most need it.

Those charged with governing our country, hold in trust the resources – both natural and social – that are the common property of all our people.

Can’t disagree with that.

As a social-democrat I cannot countenance the arbitrary dispersal of the people’s resources, nor the slow fragmentation and dilution of their rights. And, while recognising the fundamental kinship of all human beings, I will not surrender the sovereignty of my nation to the interests of foreigners. New Zealand’s destiny, finally, is the enterprise of New Zealanders alone.

Yet Chris seems to say the minority have no rights, unless the majority grant them. No right to hold property. No right to keep most of what you earn.

And I am less concerned with national sovereignity than Chris is. Of course as a country we have it. But more and more peopel of my generation and younger see themselves as citizens of the World. Look at Europe – how mervellous to have 30+ countries joined together with no borders, and the ability to trade and work in any member country.

The great office war