The new improved slush fund diagram

Labour’s problem with men

National has more support than Labour with men and women. It has a credible 12% lead in the Herald DigiPoll with women and a massive 36% lead amongst men. Labour is down to 25% support amongst men, and the Herald looks at a case in point:

There’s only one solitary Labour voter left in the panelbeating workshop of Auckland Panel and Print _ and he’s leaving the country because he can’t afford a house in New Zealand. …

This illustrates nicely how Labour has lost much of its working class support. Unless Labour can lifts it male vote by 8% or so, it is hard to see that it could win.

National loses in the hospitality stakes

Journalists tend to enjoy (or not find as onerous) the National Party conference as traditionally they understand the meaning of hospitality and have the media room well stocked with refreshments and nibbles. And no this is not the media being precious – but when you beaver away for hours on end, it is nice to have some sustenance.

But alas this year the cupboard is not just bare, but missing in action. Apart from two bottles of water there is nothing. No crackers, no biscuits, no fruit juice let alone the usual beer, wine and hot savouries.

And it is even worse inside the hall on the media bench – they have not even supplied water!!

Grumpy, hungry, thirsty journalists are not the sort I would want covering my conference!

UPDATE: National’s reputation is upheld, as refreshments are being made available – and not due to this blog post. A staffer tells me that they never provide them until after lunch (don’t want journos starting drinking too early in the day) but that said refreshments were planned and provided for. So I happily retract any implications of inhospitable behaviour from our fine hosts 🙂

Fran digs up the quotes

Oh I do love journalists who do research. Fran O’Sullivan has found these quotes:

Where’s the audit trail? Precisely into which account went this cheque?”

“On whose behalf was the cheque to be held and what happened to this money? Is there any significance that … was in serious financial trouble?”

“Why is the Serious Fraud Office taking so long to find the answers to these questions?”

“I say the whole thing stinks.”

Fran tells us that we might expect these to be quotes from Bob Jones or Rodney Hide asking about the investigation of NZ First finances. But in fact they are quotes from the Rt Hon Winston Peters in 2002 demanding the SFO get to the bottom of National’s funding.

Fran notes:

This is the real reason why Peters should be judged guilty by his political peers of the “H” word – hypocrisy.

By failing to publish a clear audit trail showing just how Sir Robert’s $25,000 donation found its way from the Spencer Trust into NZ First’s coffers, or the way in which the amount was disbursed on NZ First’s behalf, Peters invites a tsunami of disbelief which might easily be turned back by a simple disclosure.

As to whether the SFO will investigate:

The SFO, which is now deciding whether it should formally investigate Hide’s complaint, will tread carefully.

But it must be consistent.

It launched a formal investigation into National Party donations in 2002 after a former official – assured of anonymity – revealed the party still had unanswered questions over discrepancies between the amount its fundraiser had expected from Fay Richwhite interests and what arrived in the party’s accounts in 1996. …

The SFO ultimately cleared the National Party of any wrongdoing.

If Peters, his party and his lawyers have nothing to hide they should demand answers to the questions.

Otherwise they lay themselves open to new claims that “the whole thing stinks”.

The SFO decision will be pivotal.

Law & Order Forum

National are about to wrap up their law & order forum. No major policy announcements, but a couple of minor ones. The main speech was from Simon Power and the key points were:

  • Fairness is National’s main aim for the criminal justice system, and what people currently don’t get
  • Violent crimes incidence has increased 44% since Labour took office
  • Labour have blamed violent crime on the the 1991 Budget, the sun and the moon and the latest “blame” is on urban design
  • Helen Clark this year promised a victims’ charter – as she also promised in 1994!
  • Summarised policy announced to date including increased penalties for gang members, wider use of DNA testing, on-the-spot protection orders, Tasers, reverse Labour’s bail law changes, extend Youth Court to 12 and 13 year olds, and allow private management of prisons (was massively successful last time)
  • Announced National would abolish Labour’s Sentencing Council and redirect the $5.8 million saved into a fund for victims of crime. Says the Council’s role is to reduce the nominal length of prison sentences by 25% and that no need for a lawyer of bureaucracy between Parliament and Judges.
  • Also will abolish the Criminal Justice Advisory Board and redirect that $250,000 also to victims of crime.

They then had a forum afterwards with Power, Chester Borrows, Kate Wilkinson and Chris Finlayson. It started off somewhat farcically with Simon Power asking questions to his associates. I joked to a journalist that having the Spokesperson interview his associates is hardly going to result in probing questions! But to be fair Simon managed it with humour and after an initial round of questions, they had delegates ask any questions they want. Confirmed National will keep the SFO if it is not abolished by the election.

Where did the $158,000 go?

The Dom Post has been trying to track down the nine charities NZ First claimed it donated $158,000 (identified by the Auditor-General as illegally benefiting NZ First) to. All 45 big national charities talked to have said they never got a cent.

I imagine someone has checked this out, but there is no chance the Spencer Trust is a charity is there? 🙂

ODT on Cybersafety

The ODT has a useful editorial on the issue of cybersafety:

Arguably, no single innovation has changed the shape of modern life quite as much.

The Internet is one of the most remarkable “inventions” of our times.

It has altered utterly the possibilities for, and nature of, communication, that most basic of human interactions.

And it has changed it at all levels of society: in academia, in the military, in business, in politics, in finance, in the media, and in education.

Few, if any, realms of endeavour are untouched by it.

I try to think sometimes if any other invention has changed the world as much as the Internet. Maybe fire? Or the printing press?

Both major political parties, Labour and National, appear to see it as critical to economic growth and international competitiveness.

Indeed, but with somewhat different approaches.

But like any new technology, especially one so ubiquitous in its applications, it brings with it a host of “issues”.

Many of these arise in the social arena, a fact underlined by the Queenstown conference: “Cybercitizens: Risks, Rights and Responsibilities of Participation in the Information Age”.

Cyberbullying, cybersafety, social networking, child pornography and online grooming were all officially or unofficially on the agenda.

NetSafe is to be congratulated for raising awareness of attendant Internet “problems”, many of which are becoming all too real: a conference report in this newspaper on Thursday canvassed the matter of “complicit victims” – children as young as 12 actively seeking sexual contact with adults on the Internet with little idea of the consequences of their actions.

Netsafe do a wonderful job in this area, and unlike some other bodies have a very balanced approach.

Research in the United States showed 55% of people valued their online communities as much as their offline – or real-life – interactions.

Shocking though this may seem, it is fast becoming a reality that an older less “wired” generation must learn to accept, while helping to devise safeguards that will assist their children to negotiate the vast repository of unsuitable, potentially damaging, or downright dangerous material that is perennially a mouse click or two away.

All the best advice appears to be that imposing blanket bans is ineffective and counterproductive.

They are indeed both ineffective and often counterproductive.

Because, like it or not, the Internet is now part of the fabric of all our lives.

It has changed the nature of communication, and it is changing the nature of society.

Indeed. How did we survive before blogs? 🙂

72nd Nats Conference starts

They have just started the 72nd National Party Conference. The Town Hall is packed with 700 people registered for the conference.

Wellington Mayor Kerry Prendergast opened the conference and got a good round of applause when she “accidentally” referred to John Key as Prime Minister.

John Key’s main speech is tomorrow. Cracked a joke that the only Spencer he knows anything about is Frank Spencer. Made obligatory reference to hoping for an All Black victory tonight.

Announced National will build on Labour’s tax cuts – will take them as stage one, but will have a second tranche six months later in April 2009 and a third tranche in April 2010. Very popular announcement.

UK Conservative Party Leader David Cameron sent a video address. Talked of using centre right principles to deliver social justice – what the left promise but do not deliver. Said we are on brink of a post-bureaucratic age with the Internet able to empower information to individuals etc. Need policies to limit government and expand freedom.

Ralston now blogging

Fairfax have out together a good mixture of bloggers at their Business Day site. They have Nick Stride and Nick Smith from the Independent. Shareholder activist Bruce Shepherd, professional protester John Minto, Vernon Small from the Dom Post and the pugnacious Bill Ralston. Most of these blogs are now added to the blogroll.

Bill blogged yesterday on Winston’s latest allegations:

He claims he is being persecuted by a media conspiracy. In the House, referring to the time when I headed news and current affairs, he alleged: “TVNZ have had two private investigators, detectives, sniffing around since they were sued for defamation some years ago, an action which is still alive today.”

This is completely untrue. In my time at TVNZ we never hired any private detectives to investigate him. Winston is fond of calling people ‘liars”. I will simply call him “mistaken”.

Winston has repeated this ridicolous claim several times now. Journalists should call him on it, and to use his own language ask for substantiation? Apart from his fevered imagination, does he had a shred of proof that TVNZ has hired private investigators against him?

If Helen Clark or John Key made an allegation like that, and could not back it up, they would be hounded out of their jobs.

Ralston then turns if TVNZ hiring of Phil Kitchin a few years back:

Winston might want to pause here and think hard about the multiple Qantas Award winning Kitchin’s track record. I hired Phil after a story he wrote broke open the Pipi Trust and exposed then MP Donna Awatere Huata’s fraudulent activity. Donna and her husband went to jail as a result.

Kitchin came to work at TVNZ and broke the Louise Nicholas story (simultaneously published in the Dom Post).  A couple of former police officers and other sexual offenders are still doing time as a result of that investigation.

In fact Kitchin’s investigations in various TV and print stories have put several people behind bars, including the murderer of a small baby, and sparked those things Winston once loved – police investigations and Commissions of Inquiry.

Yes Winston has called for such things in the past. And there is one thing Winston has called for which I think is a good idea. Winston would agree it is also, as it is one of NZ First’s 15 fundamental principles:

An independent anti-corruption commission will be established to enable New Zealanders to have confidence that their institutions are working properly.

I think that is one NZ First policy which is well overdue for implementation!

And the nominees are …

The Republican Movement has announced the top ten nominees for the position of President of New Zealand. A mock election will be run online later this year. The nominees are:

  • James Belich
  • Jim Bolger
  • Sir Douglas Graham
  • Sir Robert Jones
  • Sir Kenneth Keith
  • Don McKinnon
  • Claudia Orange
  • Vincent O’Sullivan
  • Dame Kiri Te Kanawa
  • Sir Wilson Whineray

The first round of voting will see five candidates eliminated. Then there will be a series of further votes until there is a winner.

I’m not sure who my preference would be at this stage. Possibly Dame Kiri as she would be wonderfully politically incorrect at times!

Colin on Rodney

No not a proposed scene for a gay movie, but a reference to Colin Espiner’s blog post on the fall and rise of Rodney Hide:

There’s one politician who has emerged from the disgraceful episode involving the hypocritical Winston Peters and his wealthy donor mates head and shoulders above the rest.

I have to say I have been one of those extremely happy that Rodney is still an MP, and has been willing to tackle Winston head on. It is a good reminder about the value a minor party can bring – they can do some stuff more easily.

It’s not Prime Minister Helen Clark. She has invented a new, low standard for ensuring Peters remains in his ministerial BMW – that of illegality. As Vernon Small pointed out in the Dominion Post this morning, nowhere else in the western world (except possibly Fiji or Zimbabwe) has illegality been the test by which ministers remain in office.

This is the key. The test should not be that no-one has yet been sent to jail or even charged. It is about standards as a Minister. Ministers are accountable to Parliament and to the public, through the media. No other developed country would tolerate a senior Minister who believes himself above accountability.

It’s not John Key. He has been almost as complicit in his own way as Clark in condoning Peters’ behaviour – partly because National is in a rather large glass house in terms of its own frequent evasions of the electoral law, but mostly because Key is too worried he will need Peters after the election to condemn him outright.

I think that is a bit harsh. Now don’t get me wrong – I would like National to have been tougher on Peters from an earlier stage. But if you do look at what Key has said, he has tied any future co-operation with Peters to whether or not Peters provides acceptable answers to the issues raised by Bob Jones and others. Now if one asked Key if he thought the answers to date were acceptable, he would I am sure say no – which means that there is a line in the sand. Not quite one where I would place it, but if Peters refuses to answer the issues raised, then the natural conclusion is that National is ruling him out as an option.  But they have done it in a way where Peters will effectively make that decision – not him.

It’s not the leaders of United Future or the Maori Party, who have said nothing about Peters’ deceptions. It’s not even Green co-leaders Russel Norman and Jeanette Fitzsimons, who have raised the issue in Parliament but done nothing about it outside the House.

It’s ACT leader Rodney Hide. The perk-buster from Epsom has recovered his sense of purpose over the donations scandal, and he is the only politician who has been pushing Peters for answers both inside the House and out.

Warranted praise indeed.

OK, he looks like Ted Bovis from Maplins Holiday Camp in the old BBC telly show Hi-de-Hi!, in his silly yellow jacket that his staff can’t persuade him to remove. But he’s talking a lot more sense.

I had begun to worry that Hide had become so narcissistic over his weight loss and various stage performances that he had disappeared up his own ego. The excruciating appearances on TVNZ’s Good Morning programme, the dancing, the Pollyanna-ish reinvented “let’s not be so beastly to each other” Rodney saw him lose his mana and his political nous along with the kilograms.

But in the past two weeks he has gone a long way to redemption. It was Hide who demanded that the Speaker consider a breach of privilege case against Peters. And Hide who, in a stroke of genius, yesterday complained to the Serious Fraud Office, thereby ensuring the story will live on for a few more days.

Heh the Hi-de-Hi reference is so spot on.

There may be another reason why the Yellow Coat of Epsom has a spring back in his step. National is giving Hide plenty of room to play on the centre-Right at the moment. The Working for Families announcement was an absolute gift. Judging by some of the comments on this blog, there will be a few disgusted National voters heading ACT’s way over the decision to continue to deliver welfare to upper-middle-income earners.

It will be very interesting to see whether ACT receives a boost in its polling over this. Hide has been in the news nightly. It’s sometimes difficult to pick up rises in very small sample sizes, of course, but I think ACT is still likely to register an increase.

Indeed the move to the centre does leave room for ACT. However I would have expected them to have started rising before now to be honest.

There is no question Hide will win Epsom again. National will barely bother to contest it. That means every vote for ACT counts. If Hide can continue the momentum and not slip back into the self-indulgence he has often displayed in the past year, ACT could yet be back with several new MPs after the election.

The ultimate irony for Peters would be if it is his nemesis who ends up around the Cabinet table and not him. At least Hide could say he’d earned it.

That would be an irony indeed.

Another Tui ad

Okay this oen isn’t an official one. I got it from Paul Walker.

This one however is real, but alas it may be short lived. The Herald reports:

A Tui billboard saying “When Winston says no, he means no – Yeah, right” has brought a warning that it may breach the Electoral Finance Act.

The billboard is in the Tauranga electorate Winston Peters is desperate to win, and the Electoral Commission told the Herald it would write to brewers Tui saying it could be “election advertising” against him.

I am not surprised. It was pointed out during the hearings on the then EFB that commerciakl advertisements could be caught up. And alas satire is also covered.

Tui brand manager Jarrod Bear said the brewer had not received any correspondence from the Electoral Commission and was not considering taking the billboard down.

Asked if Tui was aware of the legislation when it came up with the billboard, Mr Bear said, “Not particularly, no, not the finer details of it.

“It sounds a little bit crazy and it’s definitely not our intention to be campaigning in favour of one or the other.

Also intentions have little to do with the application of the law.

The possibility that Tui billboards making satirical political references would breach the act was raised while it was being put through Parliament last year. Whether the Tui billboard is an election advertisement depends on whether it can reasonably be seen as trying to persuade people either to vote for Mr Peters, or against him.

Let us look at the exact clause – good old s5(1)(a)(i):

means any form of words or graphics, or both, that can reasonably be regarded as … encouraging or persuading voters to vote, or not to vote, for 1 or more specified parties or for 1 or more candidates or for any combination of such parties and candidates:

Now note the test is not what the intention of the creators is. The test is simply whether that particular form of words or graphics ends up encouraging or persauding people not to vite fir Winston.

And it is hard to argue that a billboard which suggests he does not tell the truth, or is evasive or deceptive does not have an effect in encouraging people not to vote for him. It is a very negative attribution.

So alas the end result maybe that all of election year, Tui can not do billboards which take the piss out of a politicans. Says who? Well the politicians who passed the law.

Alice in Blunderland

NBR has my weekly column up. It is titled Alice in Blunderland and of course covers the ongoing farce around NZ First.  Awards and Ratings were:

  • Best Play of the Week: Clayton Cosgrove gets a B- for the Real Estate Agents Bill compromise
  • Worst Play of the Week: National gets a D- for pledging not to change Working for Families
  • Scandal of the Week: Winston continues with an A+
  • Patsy of the Week: Marian Hobbs scores a B+ for her question on marine protection
  • EFA Breach of the Week: Bill English gets an A+ for revealing 13,000 potential breaches of the EFA on Government websites
  • Blog Analysis of the Week: Goes to Adam Smith on the failure of the Doha Round

One can comment over at the NBR site.

Luddite MPs

The Herald has a report on some UK MPs concerned about You Tube. Let;s look at what they want:

“We are concerned that user-generated video content on sites such as YouTube does not carry any age classification, nor is there a watershed before which it cannot be shown.”

How stupid are these people? A watershed time before some content can be shown? Oh yes that will work. And what time zone should be used, morons?

The MPs expressed their anger that the operators of such sites did not routinely screen clips posted on them by the public.

Oh yes that is so very practical. Let us look at how many videos are uploaded every day – around 65,000. Now if each is ten minutes long, then one person can do around 50 in a day. So these UK MPs think You Tube (which costs $1 million a day to run already) should hire around 1,300 staff just to screen the videos that come in.

Incidentially did you know You Tube concumses more bandwidth today than the entire Internet consumed in 2000?

They said the practical problems of sifting through vast quantities of material could be overcome as technology is being developed that can rapidly spot hardcore pornography when it is uploaded.

Pornography is banned on You Tube. It normally gets reported very quickly and is gone within hours or minutes. Do these MPs really think people spend all their time on You Tube frantically searching for porn in the few minutes it is there before it is deleted?

I mean if people want porn, they will go to Youporn or Pornotube which have nothing but pornography.

“In a lucrative market, the cost to internet service providers of installing software to block access to child pornography sites should not come second to child safety,” the committee said.

Child pornography is sickening and authorities do a good job in prosecuting those who produce or distribute it etc. But the incidence of child pornography on You Tube is incredibly small, and anyone who uploads it will have their IP address given to authorities.

In terms of wider issues around access to child porn, I agree ISPs should restrict access where possible. But any such blacklists should be based on emperical evidence (ie the site has been verified as having illegal material) such as the British Cleanfeed system, and not on automated filters which “guess” is a site has illegal material and ends up blocking legal content.

The committee called for video-sharing sites to include a “one-click” facility that enabled users to report clips appearing to contain images of abuse directly to the police.

Not a bad idea, but which Police? The FBI? Scotland Yard?b

Heath Ledger will win an oscar

Saw Dark Knight on Wednesday. Ledger will win an oscar – not because he is dead, but because he displayed brillant acting which dominated the film and made the other cast look wooden.

The plot is excellent also – the film is a must see. I especially love the part with the two boats. And for the record I would have voted “yes” 🙂

Congratulations Lawrence and Kerry

Aaron Bhatnagar blogs on the results of the Local Government NZ elections which saw Hastings District Mayor Lawrence Yule elected President and Wellington Mayor Kerry Prendergast Vice-President. I expected Lawrence to win the top job as the smaller councils do tend to be a bit wary of the larger Councils dominating.

One can understand they are so wary, when you see what Waitakere Mayor Bob Harvey said:

Yesterday, Mr Harvey wished Mr Yule well – but then launched a fresh attack, saying urban centres were the powerhouse of the economy but would continue to be denied a voice in local government.

“The country survives on the strength of the cities and what we bring to the economy. Local government believes it is based around a bunch of cow cockies,” he said.

“I’d rather have cities than cows. It’s always anti-Auckland, it pulls down the competitiveness of New Zealand. It holds New Zealand back. It’s a bizarre sort of thinking that the cities need to be punished. “The rural sector has always dominated local government. This is the sector with their roads that no one drives on, and places no one goes to.

“They think a farmer from Hawke’s Bay can spend that amount of time profiling local government. That’s what they voted for.”

And people wonder why the term JAFA is so popular. Harvey is arrogant and ungracious.

Is Rodney gay?

The NZ Herald reports on how Winston spent much of yesterday in the House attacking Rodney Hide, and insinuating Rodney may be gay. Let us have a look at Hansard:

Rt Hon WINSTON PETERS: That is a very good question. I think it is important to stick to honesty and transparency in the Pacific, so we should point out that thousands and thousands of dollars—millions, in fact—are owed to creditors who are not being paid for a golf course development near Queenstown that Mr Hide promoted. Mr Hide turned the first sod. How appropriate was that?

Rt Hon WINSTON PETERS: Because the member decided to descend to that level, I will tell the House what is not being honest and transparent—anywhere in the world, in fact. At a recent parliamentary function, an MP pretended that a woman friend was his new girlfriend, introduced her to the press gallery as such, and also introduced that same person in a Koru lounge as such, when he knew, demonstrably and palpably, that that information was not correct.

Now the Herald reports Rodney’s response:

He said he was not affected by the attack, though Mr Peters was suggesting “I’m guilty of financial impropriety, bizarre sexual practice and various other misdemeanours” and insinuating he was gay.

“Quite how me being gay gets him off the hook I don’t know”. Asked if he was gay, Mr Hide replied: “Not yet.”

Now Rodney doesn’t actually do a categorical denial, so one has to ask if Winston actually correct and is Rodney gay? Let us look at the evidence in favour:

  1. Took part in a dancing competition.
  2. Loses a lot of weight
  3. Takes up swimming (and many swimmers shave their legs)
  4. Has a crush on Roger Douglas
  5. Splits up with his wife
  6. Goes around with attractive young blond female, allowing people to mistakenly conclude they are sleeping together (the standard decoy)
  7. Was played by Michael Hurst in the movie about David Henderson’ battle with the IRD. And Hurst had previously played Iolaus in the Hercules TV series – Hercules’ gay lover.
  8. Flirted with supporting Labour a few months ago
  9. Talks about his rebirth as a gentler, kinder Rodney
  10. That yellow jacket!

So that evidence is pretty overwhelming I have to say. The yellow jacket was of course the final proof.

Cullen and Iti

I’ve stolen this image from NZPA. It thought people would like to look at it, while they have recalled for them these quotes:

Hon Bill English: Can the Prime Minister promise the House that tonight at the opening of the Auckland business school she will sit with Owen Glenn and allow herself to be photographed with him?

Hon Dr MICHAEL CULLEN: Yes, but I can assure him she will not be hongi-ing Tame Iti at the same time.

Instead Michael gets to do the hongi.

Trevor Mallard: How can he, when he knows someone is facing very, very serious charges under the Arms Act-and that is a matter of public record-put himself in a position where he is seen to endorse the mana of that individual by greeting him in the way he did? I cannot believe that any responsible politician in New Zealand would endorse Tame Iti in the way that John Key did at Waitangi. It was absolutely wrong, and I think it shows-and I have to be very careful with my words here-that he lacks what is necessary to be a strong leader who is prepared to stand up for his principles and stand up for what is right for New Zealand. That is what he showed us when he put himself in the position where he endorsed Tame Iti in that way.

So Trevor is saying Michael Cullen is not a responsible politician? And that Cullen endorses Iti? ANd that Cullen is not a strong leader and Cullen does not stand up for his principles and Cullen does not stand up for what is right for NZ. Wow Trevor is very harsh on Cullen.

Mallard again: First of all, I ask John Key the same question I asked him last week. It is a question that I will ask him every time I have the opportunity. Why did he not have the courage to turn his back on Tame Iti when Tame Iti approached him? We expect someone of principle, someone who aspires to be the Prime Minister, to say “I will not cuddle up to someone who is charged with serious firearm offences.” We expect someone like him to have the courage to front up in these matters, or, in this case, to not front up-to turn his back, to walk away, and to say it is not appropriate to meet with someone like that, to hongi, to give endorsement, and to give approval. Every single week that we have the opportunity to do so we will ask that question, until John Key gets off his backside, gets into this House, and answers that question

So will Trevor also ask this every week of Michael? Why didn’t Michael Cullen have the courage to turn his back and walk away instead of cuddling him?

Hon DARREN HUGHES : I seek leave to table a photograph of John Key hongi-ing with Tame Iti, who is currently on bail and facing serious firearm charges.

And Darren jumps in also. I hope Darren will also seek leave to table the photo of Michael Cullen and John Key.

Satire from Pound

Simon Pound does an excellent satirical guest post at Public Address:

John Key has announced the adoption of yet another flagship Labour policy – having a female leader. In a one-page policy briefing released today he stated that under a National government he would undergo gender realignment to have what it takes to lead the Country.

Heh. Excellent.

ACT leader Rodney Hide could not be reached for comment having lost his cellphone while attempting to jump a shark on a jetski.

Ouch. That is so biting for those who remember Happy Days.

Green Party co-leader Russell Norman welcomed the move:

“In our party we have for a long time believed that a person’s sex was an important consideration when selecting an able leader. Our constitution requires it. We are glad that National are starting to adopt our sound policies also.”

This is true. Because Sue Bradford does not have a penis, she was ineligible to replace Rod Donald as a co-leader.

Field’s trial in April 2009

Latest from Dom Post

I’ve been in meetings up until now, so only catching up with the latest from the Dom Post.

First we have the undisclosed $20,000 deposit in 1999. If the deposit was all from the same donor it has to be declared. Now possibly it was made up from a number of different donors. The Dom Post doesn’t specify – I assume they may have more than they have published to date.

Then we have the wonderful audio file of Phil Kitchin phoning Winston for comment. The whole clip is 12 seconds long of which six seconds is the phone ringing, three seconds of Kitchin saying who he is and then three seconds of Winston saying

“Phil, I told you I’m not talking to a lying wanker like you. See you.”

and hanging up.

They also have a story on the explanation Peters had walking into the House:

“Let me just say, any moron who knew anything about political parties and election expenses would have known exactly what that was about.”

Vernon Small is unimpressed with the bluster:

There are signs in his behaviour in the past week that he is beginning to believe his own legend, that all he has to do is bluster, attack the messenger and flash his smile to rise above any and all allegations, even those of hypocrisy. He cannot and he has not. …

Of course, the trust fund, and Mr Peters’ refusal to engage with any questions about it, is not an issue of ministerial responsibility but is one of his own credibility with his supporters – but still an area of legitimate interest to the media.

Not accusations, but legitimate questions that deserve answers from an elected representative so the jury in the court of public opinion can come to a verdict.

Labour’s delay of the confidence and supply vote from today until next week is not a coincidence. There are growing concerns in Labour about how their final weeks leading up to an election campaign could be tainted by association with Peters’ tactics.

If the SFO do decide to investigate (and in 2002 they investigated National over similar allegations), then Clark will be under real pressure to suspend Peters. He would react very badly to being suspended and this is why the timing of the confidence vote is increasingly important.

My 100th National Party conference

Tomorrow is the start of National’s 72nd annual conference. I’ll be in attendance blogging from it from Friday to Sunday.

By coincidence it is also my 100th National Party conference. I suspect I have attended more National Party conferences than almost anyone else, apart from Sir George Chapman!

The reason for this is that most people attend at most two conferences a year – their local regional one, and maybe the national conference. However during my years in Parliament I often accompanied the Leader to all five regional conference plus the national conference. It was actually quite exhausting working five weekends in a row for the regional conferences – basically you work for 40 days in a row without a day off. The only four people who tended to attend all five were the Leader, President, General Manager and myself and God were we glad when they were over. During those eight years we had four leaders, four presidents and four general managers so I was the one constant!

Since 1986 I have attended 9 Northern Region conferences, 9 Central NI Conferences, 19 Lower NI conferences, 9 Canterbury/Westland conferences, 13 Southern conferences and 17 Young Nationals conferences. Plus including this one about to start, 24 National conferences, which makes the total exactly 100.

I reckon that deserves a cake or something!

The myth that the Electoral Finance Act would stop what NZ First does

Many on the left (and some journalists who should know better) have been pushing a theme (started by Helen) that all this nasty non-transparent stuff done by NZ First is due to the old Electoral Act, and could not happen under the Electoral Finance Act.

Now it is true the EFA does tighten up things in some areas, but it makes little difference to the three funding controversies that NZ First has had exposed. Let’s take them one by one.

The Owen Glenn $100,000 donation

As we now know, Owen Glenn donated $100,000 towards Winston’s legal bills – which made it effectively a donation to Winston personally as he would have had to pay $100,000 more if Glenn had not donated.

Now the Electoral Finance Act only deals with donations to parties, not to MPs personally.

So foreign billionaires could continue to make large donations to MPs, while seeking favours from them, and it would all be legal under the EFA, and there would be no requirement for it to be made public.

So the EFA in no way affects repeats of the Owen Glenn donation.

And here is the sad reality. The EFA probably makes such donations more likely and more common. If donations to parties have to be disclosed but donations to trusts which pay off bills for MPs do not have to be disclosed, then more and more donors may choose to donate to MPs personally instead of their parties.

And no the Register of Pecuniary Interests will not have much effect here either, if they do it through a trust.

The Vela $150,000 donations

Now what it appears the Vela did was make a series of $10,000 donations from different people and companies. Now surely this could not happen under the EFA?

Well yes it could. Every company and every adult is treated as a seperate donor under 21(2)

donor means a person who makes a donation

And even if the companies are all owned by the same individual, each is a separate donor as they are separate persons in a legal sense..

Now the EFA does have some provisions which tighten things up. For example if I have $30,000 I can’t give $10,000 to my secretary and $10,000 to my cleaner for them to donate to a party. If I supply the money to them for a donation, they need to disclose whom they are donating on behalf of under s 26(1).

But in the case of the Velas, each company and each adult has their own money so they can easily arrange to donate $50,000 or $100,000 in a year with none of it ever getting disclosed.

The Bob Jones $25,000 donation

As we know Bob paid $25,000 to the Spencer Trust, thinking it was going to NZ First. Now as the Spencer Trust was never disclosed as a donor itself, it is highly unlikely under the EFA Sir Bob would end up being listed as a donor.

The Spencer Trust may have made a series of anonymous $10,000 donations to NZ First under the old Electoral Act, and this would have been legal. They could still do this under the EFA but would have to make a series of $1,000 anonymous donations instead.

Under the EFA the Spencer Trust could donate $36,000 anonymously through the Electoral Commission to NZ First and not have this disclosed.

If the Spencer Tust pays expenses of behalf of Winston personally, then that is like the Owen Glenn donation and not something disclosed under the EA or EFA.

And even if the Spencer Trust pays for expenses of behalf of NZ First, then it is just as likely that would be illegal or legal under both the EA or EFA. Their definitions are pretty similiar. First the old EA, s214F:

party donation, in relation to a party registered under Part 4,-

(a) means a donation (whether of money or of the equivalent of money or of goods or services or of a combination of those things)-

(i) which is received by or on behalf of the party by any person or body of persons involved in the administration of the affairs of the party; and

(ii) which, either on its own or when aggregated with all other such donations made in the same year by the same person exceeds $10,000 in sum or value (inclusive of goods and services tax); and

(b) includes, where goods or services are provided to the party under a contract at 90% or less of their reasonable market value, the amount of the difference between the contractual price of the goods or services and the reasonable market value of those goods or services; but

(c) does not include the labour of any person which is provided to the party free of charge by that person;

So the old EA made clear donations include goods or services, and any discounting beyond 10%. And the EFA, s 21(2):

party donation means a donation (whether of money or of the equivalent of money or of goods or services or of a combination of those things) that is made to a party, or to any person or body of persons on behalf of the party who are involved in the administration of the affairs of the party, and-

(a) includes,-

(i) where goods or services are provided to a party, or to any person on the party’s behalf, under a contract or arrangement at a value less than their reasonable market value, the latter being a value which exceeds $1,000, the amount of the difference between the former value and the reasonable market value of those goods or services; and

(ii) where goods or services are provided by a party under a contract or arrangement at a value that is more than their reasonable market value, the amount of the difference between that value and the reasonable market value of those goods or services; and

(iii) where credit is provided to a party on terms and conditions substantially more favourable than the commercial terms and conditions prevailing at the time for the same or similar credit, the value to the party of those more favourable terms and conditions;

Some change and tightening up, but overall its is likely that the legality of how the Spencer Trust “assists” NZ First without disclosing it is a donor, is unchanged under the new law.

So don’t believe what Helen says about these are all problems of the old Electoral Act, and can’t happen under the Electoral Finance Act. Absolutely everything NZ First has been doing, could continue under the Electoral Finance Act. And in fact there is now a greater incentive for people to donate personally to MPs, rather than to their parties. And that would be a very bad thing indeed.

Winston’s fuller explanation

Winston has just spoken in the general debate. If the allegations were not so serious, it would be comical. He did not address a single issue of substance, but of course just attacked everyone. He basically said:

  • Informed Speaker in May 2005 of allegations now appearing in Dominion Post (I think this is re the scampi issue back then)
  • Said TVNZ has two investigators trying to dig up dirt on him.
  • Talked of how Bill Ralston at TVNZ hired Phil Kitchin, as is this is somehow sinister
  • Alleged that Phil Kitchin has misled Bob Jones in order to get a story
  • Said that he sacked Rex W in 1996 and Rex not credible as he chats to teenage girls online
  • Said that he was told at his mother’s funeral that there is a “pot of money” on offer for anyone who can dig up dirt on him
  • Referred to the media as brainless meerkats
  • Said that when he refuses to answer a stupid question, that is not a denial!

Remember how he said last week he would address the conflicts between what Bob Jones (and Professor Wright) said and what he has said. He hasn’t even attempted to do this.If this was meant to be a fuller explanation, I would hate to see a less full explanation.

In related news, Rodney Hide has laid a complaint with the Serious Fraud Office. It will be interesting to see if they decide to investigate. Considering they invesigated a similiar allegation against National in 2002, I can’t see how they can credibly not invesigate. That is not to say they will necessairly find illegal behaviour. Unless one actually knows what the Spencer Trust spends its money on, you can’t conclude on issues of legality.

Backbenches Tonight

The four MPs tonight are:

  1. Paula Bennett (National)
  2. Russell Fairbrother (Labour)
  3. Dail Jones (NZ First)
  4. Gordon Copeland (Kiwi Party)

The topics are

  1. Winston Peters and those financial contributions
  2. National promising to continue with Working for Families plus a tax cut
  3. The flying visit of Condeleezza Rice … we’re an “ally” now … what does that mean?

People wanting to attend in person should head down to the Backbencher pub between 8 and 8.30pm. It is broadcast on TVNZ7 just after 9 pm live.

I won’t be making it myself as a group of us are going to see the Batman movie tonight. I think this will become the highest grossing movie of all time – it has made US$452 million in less than a fortnight already!