KiwiSaver and tax cuts

Vernon Small in the Dom Post speculates that National is planning some changes to KiwiSaver help fund its tax cuts. That is an interesting possibility, and let us look at the possible changes.

Over time the major benefit to the KiwiSaver saver is the 4% employer contribution. That is a 100% subsidy for your 4% contribution. I believe it is that compulsory contribution plus the opt out nature of it for new employees which is driving the growth in the scheme. Now neither of these cost the taxpayer any money (they cost business) so I don’t expect changes there.

The three major costs for the taxpayer are:

  1. The $1,000 initial contribution
  2. The $20 a week employee subsidy
  3. The $20 a week employer subsidy

With regards to (1) I don’t see much sense in changing that as 750,000 have already claimed it, and it is a one off expense – quite minor as things go. Same goes for the potential contribution to a mortgage.

No (2) is a fair bit of money – up to $1,000 a year per employee. If one took that away, then you could have a fair few people upset as they only decided to go into KiwiSaver due to that subsidy. On the other hand it is arguable that the matching employer contribution still makes KiwiSaver incredibly attractive to anyone who can afford the 4%. If one got rid of it the argument would be you are losing $1,000 a year from your future savings in order to have more money now when times are tight. It is a debate you can win, but not without risk.

What would be most appealing for me, is a change to (3). You see if you got rid of the employer subsidy it wouldn’t affect a single employee. They would still get their 4% from the employer and their $1,000 from the Government.

But it would remove that subsidy from employers? Wouldn’t that be terribly unpopular with employers and unfair to business owners? Well maybe, but maybe not. Consider these reasons for getting rid of it:

  1. Compliance costs – the employer subsidy is a bureaucratic nightmare. Accountants and employers hate it, and getting rid of it would save them hassle, and also free up some IRD staff.
  2. It is only a part subsidy anyway, and will probably never increase. Once employers are putting in the full 4%, the employer subsidy of $20 a week will on average cover less than half of this and sure as hell will not be inflation adjusted.
  3. It actually makes life hard for employers to calculate total cost of an employee. For example I have a formula where I add on to an employee’s salary 8% holiday pay, 4% to cover sick leave, 2% to cover ACC and now also need to cover KiwiSaver. It would be easier for me to have KiwiSaver cost as a flat 4% rather than being 4% less $20 a week if they earn over $500 a week. The total cost of an employee is a vital piece of information for budgeting and costing jobs. The employer subsidy makes this a lot harder.
  4. Most employers will use the extra 1% a year subsidy for KiwiSaver (until it reaches 4%) as a factor in pay rates for new employees, and hence may not personally end up paying significantly more.

Now what do the different components cost. Well according to Treasury by 2011/12:

  1. The $1,000 kickstart – hard to find but not significant
  2. Employee tax credit – $661 million
  3. Employer tax credit – $674 million

So if one scrapped the employer tax credit, that would free up in the medium term $700 million a year. And as the takeup has been so much higher than forecast, it might even be that getting rid of the employer tax credit could give an extra $1 billion a year compared to keeping it.

Please note I have no idea what National’s KiwiSaver policy is. This is my speculation on what would seem an intelligent move to me. And personally as an employer I would rather never ever hear about the employer tax credit again!

The House today

The Winston question was a fizzer – his so called dirt on National was all old stuff.

The questions on borrowing for infrastructure has been wonderful. Someone in National Research deserves a keg of beer for digging up quotes from Helen Clark in 1994 and 1999 advocating increased borrowing.

The 1994 quote was priceless as debt as a % of GDP was 56% then, and Clark explicitly said there should be more money on infrastructure and not to worry about the debt.

Key also revealed that the first thing Clark did when she became PM was lift the Govt’s target for debt as a % of GDP from 25% to 30%. Hilarious.

National will get beaten up later on for Bill’s tape recorded comments, but those quotes were priceless, and the look on her face as Key read them out – superb.

Anyone who has a copy of the actual full quotes should feel free to e-mail them to me!

Peters referred to Privileges Committee

The Speeaker has ruled that there is a question of privilege over the $100,000 gift from Owen Glenn to pay off Winston’s legal bills, so the Privileges Committee will hold hearings on this.

It would be imprudent to speculate on what the conclusion will be, as that will or should depend on the evidence. But it does mean this issue will be in the public domain for some time to come.

Apart from the televised hearings of the Privileges Committee, the report back to the House will be subject to a debate – normally two hours or so.

A half denial

Whale Oil has a scan of a letter to a newspaper from one of the Standard authors. It is a classic case of denying something one has not been accused of and refusing to comment on what actually was alleged. He says that The Standard is not funded or directed by the Labour Party. But that is not what I claimed a few weeks ago. What I claimed was that two of the bloggers there are Beehive staffers, a third is a Labour Party Head Office manager and one or two others are employees of Labour’s largest union affilitate.

What is interesting is that on five occasions the Prime Minister’s chief press secretary has been asked by media to deny that Beehive staff blog at The Standard, and on every occasion they have chosen not to comment rather than deny it. I guess there is a reason they passed up the opportunity to say “Farrar fucked up and has it all wrong, none of our staff are involved”.

Amusingly the letter to the editor claims The Standard is the most read political website in New Zealand. That is also as amusing as the claim that they ensure comments from readers are civil, as the author of the letter repeatedly makes references in the comments there to my weight and girth. And he is one of the moderators!!

I have no particular desire to get consumed in a flame war with The Standard. My issues are not with the authors (I have had perfectly civil conversations with Clinton, think “Eddie” is a lovely person and many of my friends who know “All your base” speak highly of him) but over the decision not to be transparent over the involvement of ministerial staff in the blog.

This will probably come off as patronising, but I offer it as sincere advice. Their biggest weakness at the moment is their shrillness, and aggressiveness. And this is often a function of mainly being anonymous. One of the good things about blogging under either your name, or with your associations known, is it moderates what you say. But each to their own – my unsolicited advice to them is probably as welcome as pork chops at a synagogue 🙂

Danyl (who is definitely on the left) at the Dim-Post did a scathing post on The Standard last week. I will resist quoting large segments of it here. Rather than flame him for his comments (and they were well very very robust), it might be worth considering what motivated him to make them, and the fact he is far from the only person on the left who thinks that way.

On a more positive note, I am enjoying the new gblog for Green Party members. Not that I agree with much said there, but I do think it is good value. Oh, and talking of the Greens, if you really want to be scared, read on Frog Blog about the first time Metira Turei had sex. I hope this won’t be a precedent for other MPs to detail their first time 🙂

A new low

I meant to get to this earlier, but it is appropriate to deal with it now, with the House about to resume. The Herald on Sunday covers what happened:

A former New Zealand First staff member branded a “paedophile” in Parliament last week is demanding an apology from the MP responsible, after more mud-slinging over the secretive Spencer Trust.

Rex Widerstrom, who last week alleged the trust was a slush fund for Winston Peters’ legal battles, has written to NZ First MP Ron Mark challenging him to repeat the underage sex claim outside Parliament – or at least have “the guts” to apologise.

Widerstrom has also claimed it was “a bit rich” of Mark to make such an allegation when the MP had a conviction for unlawful sex with a 15-year-old. In 2001, it emerged that Mark had been convicted 30 years ago of unlawful sex with a minor. He was fined $150.

During heated debate at question time in the House last week over donations to NZ First, Mark accused Widerstrom of being a “paedophile”. Mark yesterday declined to comment.

I’ve always had a lot of time for Ron Mark. Even though I think it is misplaced, I respect his loyalty to his leader. So it saddens me to make this post but nothing justifies using parliamentary privilege to label a critic a “paedophile”.

The fact that Ron actually has a conviction for under-age sex, should mean he should be especially prudent about his language. Now Ron was 17 when he was convicted of sleeping with a 15 year old and personally I don’t think that is anything particularly unusual or immoral, even though technically illegal. But Ron would not appreciate having his opponents label him nasty things on the basis of that conviction.

It would be the honourable thing to do for Ron to withdraw his remark and apologise when the House resumes, by way of point of order.

Party Pills as a defence

The Herald reports:

A student who attacked a friend and police officers while high on party drugs has walked free from court after a Palmerston North District Court jury accepted his defence of automatism.

The court heard James Tito, 20, and a friend had taken a BZP party pill. When nothing happened they took another. Tito eventually assaulted his friend because he thought he was the demon coming to take him to hell.

Automatism is a defence used to represent loss of control and a lack of intent when committing a criminal offence. It has been used to acquit people who commit crimes while sleep walking or suffering a hypoglycaemic episode or epileptic fit.

I am not aware of any evidence that two BZP party pills can cause anything like automatism. Was there possibly a copious amount of alcohol involved also, or some more serious drugs?

Labour polling on what to do re Winston

I got an e-mail last night from someone who was polled by UMR – Labour’s polling company.

On top of the normal questions asking if people think John Key is slippery, there were at least two questions on how the Prime Minister has handled the Winston Peters funding scandal. They asked if people thought she had been decisive and also if people approve of her handling of Peters on a five point scale from strongly approve to strongly disapprove.

This is pretty significant. You don’t ask questions for no reasons. The results of that polling will obviously influence what Clark does once the confidence vote is passed this week.

Winston may not be amused to find out Helen is polling, effectively to find out whether she should sack him or not.

The results will be interesting. You see NZ First can survive by pissing off 90% of the public and confusing half of the remaining 10%. Major parties can not. When National had NZ First’s Tukugate (which was a completely trivial issue compared to this) scandal, it was National that eventually also got pushed down in the polls as you get suffer guilt by association.

Jones threatens NZ First with Police

Bob Jones has said he will complain to the Police if he does not get an answer from NZ First:

Sir Robert Jones has written again to New Zealand First, this time threatening to go the police if he gets another “evasive reply” about where his $25,000 donation went. …

“My sole concern is the money was used for party purposes, but getting a straight answer from New Zealand First is a recipe for disappointment,” Sir Robert said. “If the money has not reached the party, it constitutes theft. If I receive another evasive reply then clearly it is a matter for the police.”

Here is the dilemna for NZ First. If they say “Yes the money was spent on behalf of NZ First” then they have arguably filed a false donations return. If they say “No, we won’t tell you” then Bob will go to the Police.

Anderton wants EFA changed

Having been referred to the Police for breaking the Electoral Finance Act, Jim Anderton now wants it changed.

Basically Jim thought the law would just apply to “bad people” and not himself. Here’s the real irony:

The decision means all four parties that supported the controversial electoral law changes last year have now fallen foul of the tight new rules on election advertising – mostly for not carrying authorising statements.

There was close to a dozen decisions released on Friday by the Electoral Commission. If I have time later today, I’ll take readers through them one by one. As usual I agree with most of them, but differ with a couple.

Coming to a screen near you!

An analysis of declared donations and expenses

The NZ First funding scandal got me interested in the overall picture of declared donations and expenses for our major political parties. More specifically I was interested in the linkages between declared donations and declared election expenses.

I had no expectation that there would be 100% correlation. Because a party generates much income that isn’t declared – only donations over $10,000 tend to be. And likewise only campaign expenses are declared, not the total costs of running the party.

But do most of the parties have some consistent ratio of declared donations to declared campaign expenses? Did any party have a very low ratio which might suggest a deliberate strategy to (legally) conceal large donations by breaking them into bits or having them never put through the party’s accounts?

Now it is important to stress that it is not bad per se to have income from non declared sources. National for example brings in up to $1 million a year just from membership subscriptions and donations. That is a good thing.

Now to the data, which is taken from the Electoral Commission website. Records only started in 1996. I have excluded 1996 as we don’t have donation returns for the full 1994 – 1996 period (law was only changed in 1995). So I have covered the periods 1997 – 99, 2000- 02, 2003 – 05 and 2006 – 2008. We don’t yet have expense returns for 2008 but I have included 2008 as we now have continous disclosure for amounts of over $20,000. This means everyone’s ratio is higher than would normally be the case, but as I am looking at the differences between them, it isn’t a huge factor. I wanted it to be as up to date as possible.

1997 – 2008 Donations Expenses Ratio
Maori $ 122,000 $ 100,897 121%
National $ 5,181,863 $ 5,320,413 97%
Labour $ 4,856,037 $ 5,311,906 91%
Alliance $ 710,710 $ 884,251 80%
Greens $ 765,331 $ 1,420,432 54%
United $ 117,200 $ 251,191 47%
Progressive $ 207,384 $ 489,941 42%
ACT $ 1,127,452 $ 3,250,061 35%
NZ First $ 45,000 $ 826,587 5%

The Maori Party have only had expense returns for one election, so they are artifically high. If you exclude post 2005 their ratio is 52%.

National and Labour are very close to each other. If you exclude post 2005 elections National are at 80% and Labour 67%.

The Alliance is the only non current party in there. I included them as they are probably the closest to NZ First as a larger third party. Over the last three elections they have both spent similar amounts – $884K for the Alliance and $827K for NZ First. And during that time the Alliance has declared $711K of donations (including donations to Democrats when they were part of Alliance).

Then in order we have the Greens, United, Progressive and ACT at 54%, 47%, 42% and 35% respectively. A reasonable degree of difference, but all within that one third to one half range.

Finally we have NZ First. Since 1997 they have declared $827K of expenses but declared only $45,000 of large donations – a ratio of 5% – just 1/7th of the next lowest party ACT at 35%.

So what conclusions can one draw from this? Well remember the data is not complete. But there would seem to be two main conclusions one can draw – but competing conclusions. They are:

  1. That NZ First is the only party that has never ever attracted large donors. That they are entirely funded by small donors and have had only one quarter as many large donations as the miniscule Progressive Party and one sixteeneth as many large donations as the Alliance.

    OR

  2. That since 1997 NZ First has had a deliberate strategy of concealing large donations by means such as having had them broken up into smaller parcels, or channelling them through associated trusts who do not pass them onto the party but spend them at the discretion of the unknown trustees.

I will leave it to readers to decide which conclusion they think is most likely.

The full English quote

08wire has a transcript of the audio recording of Bill English. It is copied below:

ENGLISH: The basic point is… We spend a lot of time on this. The basic dynamics of it are… you look at it from the punters point of view – they’re saying they don’t like the government, and Clark, they took all this frickin’ tax off me and they spend billions of it, and it went on What’s Up badges and websites and bullshit

NATIONAL DUDE: Yeah

ENGLISH: They got a bit fat.

NATIONAL DUDE: Yeah.

ENGLISH: And all our work tells us they’re pretty keen to keeping the bit they’ve got. And we call them Labour-plus voters – and they’re sitting there thinking “that nice man Mr Key is pretty smart – he’ll get me a bit more.” They’re not saying “that nice man Mr Key will take something off me” – they’re saying “he’ll give me a bit more”.

And the reality is if we had been the government with the surpluses they had, we would have had something, like working for families, but not the same. We would have given them quite a bit of cash back. And what happens is – you go in there to try and change it, frankly Don and co got a bit carried away, cos they didn’t understand it. If you give people money then, it is very hard, there’s a set of inevitable problems. It’s like physics, right. If you push something up its gonna drop. If you give people cash, you have high marginal tax rates. OK, that’s it. You can’t get round that. Don thought he could but he couldn’t. So did John, actually – but you can’t. So the only – the raw choice is: fix the problems; or take money off them. And there’s no way you can fix the problems without taking money off them. So we’re sitting here saying the punters are keen to keep it. They’re facing a recession. The last thing we want is to spend the whole election campaign with families of four on TV saying “Mr Key’s taking money off us”. You can’t do that.

NATIONAL DUDE: Yeah.

ENGLISH: So later on we’re gonna have to have a bit of a sort out. Yeah, we’re gonna do something, but we can’t do it now.

NATIONAL DUDE: What about selling Kiwibank?

ENGLISH: And actually, we just have one guy with a spreadsheet. And it’s bloody complicated.

NATIONAL DUDE: I’m sure you’ve Lockwood Smith’s spreadsheet…

ENGLISH: Oh yeah yeah, it is.

NATIONAL DUDE: What about getting rid of Kiwibank, I mean…

ENGLISH: Well, eventually, but not now. Well, its working. A lot of our supporters get a bit antsy about it, but its working. It’s like a lot of things…

The Working for Families aspect is very interesting. People forget National actually introduced child tax credits and the like. Labour gave it a slogan, and extended it.  So it is quite unremarkable that Bill says National would have done something like WFF, but not the same. I expect it would have been like the 96 and 98 packages where National both cut taxes and put money into family support/child tax credits. It has been the lack of balance from Labour which has been the problem.

The comment on high marginal tax and abatement rates are the same comments I made last week – it is a very challenging trade off.

The full Kiwibank quote is revealing also, because it has Bill saying Kiwibank is working, that there is no need to change anything despite supporters being antsy. That is pretty obviously saying nothing will happen against the policy – just a desire for the future.

This will of course be messy, as any taped conversation is where an MPs personal opinions differ from a party’s position. A tape recording of what Michael Cullen really thinks of tax cuts would be fun. But does that mean a party will break its election promises? Nope – both Labour and National did that in the 80s and 1990, and have been scarred by the experience since. No one wants to be a one term Government.

I fully expect National in Government will look at Working for Families (in fact I strongly urged them to do so) and also ownership of certain assets. And if they come up with a good case for change, will include them in their manifesto for the 2011 election.

The Press on Rodney

The Press is impressed with Rodney:

It is now obvious that New Zealand First has no intention of publicly accounting for its secret funding and that, of the other parties, only ACT is willing to press the issue. …

Winston Peters had the perfect opportunity to retrieve something from the ashes when he made a statement to Parliament on Wednesday. Under standing orders he was entitled to be heard in silence and not questioned, but he squandered that opportunity by failing to clarify the issues or answer the serious questions. Instead, Peters made a rambling and confusing attack on the media, his political opponents, and shadowy evil forces he alleged were out to get him. …

Labour does not want to drive New Zealand First to the wall at this time when that would scupper the Government and perhaps prevent the re-establishment of the coalition after the election; National is keen to maintain good relations with NZF in the expectation that the Center-Right (which includes NZF) will emerge from the poll best placed to form a government. They are both praying that the electorate will eventually solve the Winston problem and remove the troublesome politician from their concerns.

The improbable figure of Rodney Hide arises from this wasteland of principle to carry the fight against NZF and its failure to account. His request to the Serious Fraud Office for an investigation takes the issue out of the hands of the politicians and places it in the hands of an independent organisation with considerable powers. The SFO can require that evidence be produced, and it is outside the authority of the Attorney-General.

If the SFO does investigate the NZF donations, the result will be the thorough scrutiny that the issues need if the political process is to escape the charge that it shelters unethical and perhaps illegal practices.

Hide, of course, has more than just a principled interest in this business, as the unedifying abuse between him and Peters in the House last week showed. But Hide has plainly enunciated the principles involved, the justified annoyance at their possible disregard, and has made the only significant effort to have them vindicated.

If he succeeds, and Peters is forced to face the consequences of his actions, no sympathy need be expended. Peters in this scandal has confirmed his reputation as the most cynical of New Zealand politicians, a harmful influence on the nation’s public life and an unfit participant in government.

It will be delicious if the outcome of Peters’ refusal to answer the most basic questions on this issue is a boost for Rodney Hide and ACT, and oblivion for Peters!

Is God dead?

There is a public debate today organised by the Victoria University of Wellington Debating Society. It will take place (Monday 4 August) at 6pm in Rutherford House at Victoria University (Lecture Theatre Two).
The motion is “That God is Dead”
Affirming is:
Kent Stevens – Humanist Society of NZ
Udayan Mukherjee – Philosophy and economics student at Vic
Tom Mathews – Philosophy and politics student at Vic
Negating is:
Gordon Copeland MP (Independent)
Tim McKenzie (Chaplain, VUW Anglican Chaplaincy)
Joe Connell (champion Vic student debater)
Chair: Professor Paul Morris, Religious Studies Department at VUW
There’ll be tea and coffee after the debate for those who want to keep arguing! Gold coin donation appreciated at the door.

Kiwibank

Secret recordings seem to be the in thing at conferences this year. We had Mike Williams at Labour’s conference, and now Bill English at National’s. English was asked (not during a session, but over coffee it seems) about whether National would sell Kiwibank and he replied “Well eventually, not now”.

Now in one sense, his response is quite unremarkable and consistent with National policy which is not to sell any state asset in their first term of office. And it can be no surprise that as Bill voted against the establishment of Kiwibank, that he doesn’t see any long term reason for keeping Kiwibank – why should the state own a competitive trading enterprise? Why not own New World also?

Now the reality is that if National does get elected, it won’t sell Kiwibank in its first term, and if it wants to sell it in its second term it will have to get re-elected on a policy allowing it to do so. National is not going to break its policy on asset sales, if elected later this year, as they have no desire to be a one term Government.

But the politics are of course a different issue. Bill will be kicking himself for his response, as it means the focus shifts from the infrastructure announcements to Kiwibank. And there will no doubt be many patsy questions to Dr Cullen in the House tomorrow on the issue.

EFA strikes again

As not everyone in the room was a party member, it was noticeable that most of the powerpoint presentations had authorisation statements on them, and even the walk in video for John Key finished with an authorisation statement showing some poor bloke’s home address.

Amusingly the placards of the half dozen protesters lacked authorisation statements 🙂

National’s Infrastructure Plan

The major focus of Key’s speech was on investing in better infrastructure in New Zealand. Major aspects of the policy/plan are:

  • Appoint a Minister of Infrastructure to oversee a co-ordinate approach to infrastructure development.
  • A 20 year infrastructure plan covering investment in roads, public transport, electricity, telecommunications and water.
  • Will take into account the changing world such as the need for more renewable energy and the growing price of oil.
  • $1.5 billion investment into an ultra-fast broadband network.
  • Designate a new category of state highway – a Road of National Significance. These roads, such as SH1, will be a priority for funding as the core backbone of our roading network.
  • Introduce priority consenting for major national infrastructure projects, where a streamlined process will guarantee in law a decision within nine months, so that the consenting doesn’t take longer than the actual construction.
  • Will invest an extra $500 million a year on infrastructure (as well as the Broadband investment) on top of Labour’s proposed levels.
  • A total of $5 billion additional capital investment over six years, resulting in an increase of gross debt as a percentage of GDP of 2%.
  • Willing to do this as NZ does not have a debt problem, but a growth problem and the higher economic growth will pay back the investment over time.
  • Will introduce infrastructure bonds as an option for financing national infrastructure projects, and make greater use of public-private partnerships.

Key’s National Conference Speech

Key has, as expected, entered the Town Hall to a rapturous welcome. They had a nice wee video intro and a great song (no not Clocks) for the walk in.

In his speech he is laying out ten parts of National’s Blueprint for Change. They are:

  1. Cut taxes on 1 April 2009 and 1 April 2010
  2. Bring discipline to government spending to reduce pressure on interest rates
  3. Have a lid on staff numbers in the core public service
  4. Attack gangs and the “P” trade with tougher laws and more powers for the Police
  5. Introduce an RMA Amendment Bill within 100 days
  6. Involve the private sector and communities more in providing government services
  7. Set national standards for literacy and numeracy for primary school pupils
  8. Retain all superannuation entitlements and eligibility, and through lifting average after tax incomes, increase the amount paid to senior citizens
  9. Repeal the Electoral Finance Act, and reach out to all parties to reach a consensus on legislation to replace it that will retain measures to provide greater transparency in political donations
  10. A binding referendum on MMP by no later than 2011

There was also a major announcement on infrastructure, which I’ll deal with in a separate post.

General Debate 3 August 2008

HoS on Peters

The Herald on Sunday editorial calls for the winds of change:

New Zealand First leader and Foreign Affairs Minister Winston Peters has exceeded even his own characteristically pugnacious standards in the past week as he has continued to deflect questions about the cash donations made either to him or to his party. Promising much but delivering nothing in terms of clearing the air, he has engaged in behaviour which has been at times hard to distinguish from the paranoid and irrational.

Except that Peters is just acting – the whole thing is just a charade to him.

It is difficult not to see Peters’ actions as those of a man committing slow political suicide. His party’s poll ratings (which is to say his; there has never been a significant distinction) are averaging barely 3.5 per cent, a long way from the threshold that would ensure its return to Parliament (he seems beyond unlikely to recapture the Tauranga seat).

National’s Tauranga candidate Simon Bridges is a very happy man. Peters may or may not fool 5% of the electorate into believing his protests he is victim of a media conspiracy, but he will not fool 40% of Tauranga voters.

But what is much more likely is that his behaviour is both shrewdly calculated and tactically astute. Fighting for his political life, Peters is interested in appealing only to the small number of voters – most of them lapsed NZ First loyalists who are making eyes at National – who can push his party over the threshold. If he alienates and exasperates the rest of the country, generous wealthy donors, his political opponents and even his coalition partners in the process, that is neither here nor there.

Spot on. He is not worried about the 90% who will never vote for him. He is just trying to lock in half or more of the 10% who might vote for him.

Until now, the Prime Minister has adopted a legalistic wait-and-see approach, saying she must let matters run their course. It is notable that her endorsements of Peters, never warm, are becoming steadily cooler. But it is intolerable that she should allow one of her ministers the freedom to manipulate the democratic process.

Clark will be laughed at if she tries to campaign on transparency or accountability.

Up to now, she has had to consider the implications for the coalition’s stability of alienating Peters, but this week, as the last of the Budget legislation is passed, represents the last procedural opportunity for NZ First to bring the Government down and force an early election. Come Friday, the PM could, and should, sack the minister and expose him to the chill electoral winds that are blowing his way. It would be a good thing for the country if those winds, once and for all, blew him from the political stage.

She made pretty clear on Agenda this morning, she would not be doing that.

National’s Infrastructure Forum

The Infrastructure Forum has just started. I’m only half taking it in, as was a pretty late night out with the Young Nationals celebrating the All Blacks massive victory.

Got absolutely soaked to the bone getting home – it was thundering down, and taxis were scarce with a 30 minute delay if you phoned for one.

Anyway back to infrastructure. First up was Maurice Williamson on transport and he summed it up himself with a one liner – National will build more roads – lots of them! He gave some staggering figures on the massive increase in costs that some roading projects have incurred due to consent delays. He stressed this wasn’t about even getiing enough roads for future volume, but just getting us enough for our current needs.

Then Gerry Brownlee on energy. Gerry said that if we found Maui field today, it would be worth around $50 billion. Said that concern over carbon emissions doesn’t change the fact that replacements for current fuel sources are not extensively available, so demand will stay high. NZ second only to Canada in our mineral endowment.

Third up was Nick Smith on RMA reform.  Round up of how multiple business organisations, government advisory groups and surveys all rate this as the highest priority. Will be enacted within months not years of the election.

Questions were fairly as expected. A patsy on why broadband is a better infrastructure investment than trains. Some discussion on coal and carbon emissions and whether one can sequester the co2 from coal. Also focus on consenting for roads – the desirability of having one consent application for an entire motorway, rather than breaking it down into lots of small packages – each of which has its own process.

English Conference Speech

Bill English delivered a well received speech on the economy to the conference. The key focus will be his comments on debt, so I’ll deal with them at the end and cover the other stuff first. First his summary of the economic picture:

On the negative side:

  • The economy will continue to struggle.
  • Inflation is high.
  • Interest rates are high.
  • The business outlook is grimmer than it has been since 1988.
  • There is considerable uncertainty about some parts of the investment market, given the collapse of many finance companies.
  • Oil prices are much higher than they were a year ago and, despite some short term relief, are likely to remain high.

On the positive side:

  • Commodity prices are at an all-time high.
  • Provincial areas are doing reasonably well, and the further south, the better.
  • The dollar is dropping, pushing up export incomes.
  • The economy is tilting more towards the export sector.

A good round-up.

First, we are going to have tax cuts. New Zealanders have been taxed too high for too long.

Even the Labour party has grudgingly conceded the argument. But it has come awfully late to the party. Australia is in its sixth year of significant personal income tax cuts and has signalled further cuts to come. It’s time we got started.

Tax cuts will put some cash in people’s pockets and that’s good. But the longer-term reason for cutting taxes is to improve the incentives to work, save, and invest – and that’s what National is committed to doing.

This is worth remembering. Tax cuts are great in that people get to keep more of their own money. But having tax cuts leading to higher economic growth is the bigger goal – for that is the way we get better services, and have more money.

Secondly, New Zealanders are not getting value for money – their hard-earned money – from government services. Too much is caught up in a burgeoning Wellington bureaucracy designed to make the government feel big and ministers to feel powerful.

And commercial property prices in Wellington keep going up.

Thirdly, we will cut red tape.

This is easy to say and hard to do. People wonder how we can be in favour of small workplaces, soundly build houses, and yet achieve it with fewer rules.

We will do it in two principled ways.

We will use bureaucracy against the bureaucrats. Let officials and ministers jump the hurdles, fill out the forms and incur the cost of compliance before they can have a new regulation. We will also attack specific costs, like complexity in the tax system, the time and costs of the RMA, and the extensive new rules and bureaucracy under the new Building Act.

Fight fire with fire – I like it.

Fourthly, we will introduce national standards in education.

Almost 10,000 young New Zealanders leave school every year without the basic competence to learn more skills….

We will introduce national standards in literacy and numeracy. This will be a spur to taking the best teaching practise from schools that are succeeding and spread this across the whole system. If every child is assessed and taught appropriately, we can help the thousands who now miss out.

This will take time but again we will not lift economic growth without improving our education outcomes.

Finally, we will lift the quality and quantity of New Zealand’s infrastructure investment, to remove the blockages that are currently holding our economy back.

New Zealand under Labour is virtually the only country in the developed world that refuses to use private sector financing and risk management techniques to help spend taxpayers’ money effectively and make it go further.

Over the next 10 years, central and local government will spend between $60 billion and $70 billion on infrastructure. We can do it badly or we can do it well. Let’s do it well.

That’s a lot of money!

So now let us look at the reports of deficits and borrowing – from NZPA:

But deputy leader and finance spokesman Bill English told delegates National was prepared to borrow more to fund infrastructure.

He said New Zealand had one of the lowest levels of debt of any developed country and “additional borrowing” for infrastructure would boost economic growth.

Any increase in debt for infrastructure would be transparent and voters could trust National to be a “conservative” manager of the economy.

“So that will be extremely clear cut and rather hermetically sealed.”

Mr Key argued that increased borrowing overall — ostensibly to fund infrastructure — could be separated from National’s tax cuts.

“What effectively will be happening is you will be able to see exactly what our tax cut programme costs, exactly what Labour’s cost, exactly what we are delivering, what differences or priorities we’ve chosen over Labour’s.

Now one is going to hear a lot of rhetoric around this, so I am going to try and explain the situation by looking at a normal company’s accounts.

A company has three major financial statements – the income and expenditure, the balance sheet and the cash flow.

The income and expenditure is the measure of profitability and to a degree of sustainability. The difference between the two is your profit/surplus or deficit/loss. Asset purchases, borrowing, investment in infrastructure doesn’t directly show up here. However depreciation on assets does show up as an expense, as does interest on any borrowing. So if you borrow too much, you will face pressure on your surplus, as interest costs go up. In the bad old days before Ruth, interest on borrowing was something like over 20% of all expenditure.

In the 11 months to May 2008, the surplus is $5.3b and the underlying surplus (excluding one offs) is $7.3 billion. These are forecast to reduce massively in the next few years due to a weaker economy which means less tax, plus tax cuts plus increased spending.

Interest expenses are currently $2.8b out of total expenditure of $66.8b – so less than 5% of expenditure. However the Crown also gets revenue from investments it has – and they totalled $3.0 billion. So in fact the Crown made $200 million more from investments than it paid on debt.

You do want to make sure interest expenses do not get too high – but as Bill English said we do not have a debt or interest problem at the moment – we have a productivity problem.

So you do want the income and expenditure to be in surplus, or at worst for any deficits to be temporary – with there being a surplus over the medium term.Companies really want to be profitable every year without fail. A country isn’t quite the same – instead of paying dividends through profits, you pay dividends through tax reductions.

Next we have the balance sheet. These are your assets and liabilities. Many major transactions happen here, and don’t even directly affect the income and expenditure. If you buy a frigate for $1 billion then you simply have an increase in assets of $1 billion and an increase in debt of $1 billion or a decrease of the cash asset.

Now many asset purchases are funded through borrowing. Why would you do this? Well a couple of reasons. The first is if one gets the value from an asset over 30 years, then it is fairer to spread the cost over 30 years.

The second, and more important arguably, is that the value you will get from the asset, is greater than the cost of the interest of borrowing to purchase it, so that the company/country as a whole becomes more profitable.

Let’s take an example of say a polling company. You may want to buy 40 computers with CATI software on them at a cost of $400,000. But you don’t have $400,000 in the bank. So you might borrow $400,000 which will mean an interest cost of $32,000 a year. And if they are expected to last for 10 years depreciation of $40,000 a year so it will add $72,000 to your annual expenditure.

But having that software may mean you can call people 30% faster. So if your annual wages bill was $500,000 it shrinks to $350,000. Hence the $72,000 a year expenditure leads to $150,000 of savings and you profit increases by $78,000.

So what this means is borrowing for infrastructure and assets can be both fair and a good way of increasing profitability,

But it does increase risk. If you lose some customers and revenue drops, then you have fixed costs with interest and depreciation instead of variable costs such as wages, and your chance of going bust is higher.

Hence it is not universally good or bad to borrow for asset purchases. It depends on how much existing debt you have, and what you are going to buy with any borrowing.

Finally we have the cashflow. This is where you track the cash in and out from both your operating account and your capital account (plus some others). Now there are linkages. If you have a small cash surplus in your operating account and a larger cash deficit in your capital account, then you have an overall cash deficit. And as I said before the more cash you borrow the more it adds to expenditure.

But there is a difference between cashflow for operating and capital. It is quite normal for there to be a cashflow deficit in the capital account – an expanding business often is purchasing assets faster. The challenge is whether the borrowing on those assets overwhelms your operating account.

If we look at the Government, Dr Cullen himself is saying he will run a cash deficit – he will (just) have a cash surplus in the operating account but have a cash deficit in the capital account. Bill English is saying he will have a larger cash deficit – but again it seems in the capital account primarily. They have not ruled out a cash deficit in the operating account, but if so it is expected to be minor and temporary.

Until we see the actual figures from National in October, it is silly to get too worked up about it – after all Cullen is already running something like a $10 billion cash deficit over three years. The issue is not the size of the cash deficit per se – but what impact it will have on net debt (gross debt is far less important than net debt) and what impact it will have on interest. And most of all what is the long-term forecast in terms of the operating surplus.

Herald’s related tags

Duncan’s questions

Duncan Garner blogs the questions he wants answered:

  1. Who set up the Spencer Trust?
  2. Who donates to it?
  3. What is the money spent on?
  4. Does New Zealand First receive money from the Trust?
  5. How much?
  6. Why isn’t it declared? (Donations to parties over 10k must be declared)
  7. What else does the Trust spend its money on?

And none of them answered.

But Winston will not answer these questions. He can’t. Answering them will only confirm what he and his party are up to. His MPs are in the dark – they know nothing. They trudge to Parliament each day – grasping some pre-written patsy question to ask their leader.

Like, why did Condi Rice come to New Zealand and would it have happened under any other Foreign Minister? How embarrassing for them. What sycophants.

They owe their jobs to Peters. None would make it under their own steam. Barbara Stewart. Ever heard of her? Now Peters is making his MPs look like the hopeless docile poodles that they are. And these people call us meercats!

I understand several gallery offices now have pictures of meerkats up on their walls. One journalist told me of an e-mail they got complaining on behalf of the meerkats with the comparisons to the media!

A member of the press gallery, taken from Wikipedia.

Peters now has no credibility. He does not believe in being accountable. His only defence is attack. He has promised on three occasions this week to ‘clear things up’. He hasn’t. What are you so embarrassed about Winston?

Journalists are asking legitimate questions. Peters hopes his loyal 5% still agree with him. And unlike Helen Clark, Winston doesn’t need to appeal to the masses. He needs 5% percent. This will be hurting him in Tauranga. I don’t think he can win the seat. Can he get 5% – perhaps not, though it’s too early to write him off.

I think Peters is now toast in Tauranga. Their chance of survival is making 5%. It is possible that there are enough stupid people to get a boost in the polls from his antics. But will he retain that support (if he even gains it) through until the election?

And Duncan concludes on trusts:

Trusts by their very nature are set up to hide things – established to protect people, their money and assets. National has the Ruahine and Waitemata Trust. The Labour Party also declares a legal trust fund for those who want to give to the party on the quiet.

But all these trusts are declared. They have been for years. Peters has kept his quiet. Even from his own people. Only a select few knew about it.

The point here is 25K was solicited from Sir Bob Jones by Winston Peters and his party hacks. Jones has a right to know if it ever went to the party. And so does the NZ public.

The Spencer Trust looks like a secret slush fund. And the Right Honourable Winston Peters doesn’t deserve the title.

I do not think the media will stop asking questions on this, even though there is no chance Winston will ever usefully answer them.

The “B” word

Oh dear. Bob Clarkson goes out as he came in – saying things he shouldn’t.

They had just before lunch the farewells for the five retiring MPs. And each of those there (Connell wasn’t attending) said some brief words of thanks. Bob concluded his thanks by saying “Oh and Judy won’t like me saying this, but I also want to thank the 150 Brethren who helped my campaign”.

God it was hilarious. After a moment of stunned silence, everyone burst into laughter (especially on the media table) as it was classic Bob. Well, not quite everyone was laughing – the top stage did resemble a collection of statues 🙂