NBR column now online

The full interview

Paris Hilton’s response to John McCain

See more Paris Hilton videos at Funny or Die

I sometimes suspect Paris Hilton is smarter than her public persona. She has certainly out together a very funny video response to John McCain who criticised Barack Obama as being a big celebrity like Paris and Britney Spears.

I did quite like the McCain camps’ response:

“Sounds like Paris is taking the ‘All of the Above’ energy approach that John McCain has advocated — both alternatives and drilling,” spokesman Tucker Bounds told the gossip site. “Perhaps the reality is that Paris has a more substantive energy plan than Barack Obama.”

The proposed Fijian charter

No Right turns covers some salient points of the proposed charter.

I beleive the coup was quite unjustified (and illegal), and the military Government has engaged in some nasty thuggish activities. I also doubt the Commodore will even really give up power (I suspect he plans to become President).

But I will say that his proposed charter would be a lot better for Fiji in the long term, than the current racially divisive constitution. Now that does not mean coups are a legitimate way to deliver better Government. They are not – and at this stage the charter is only words. But the charter does represent some light at the end of the tunnel.

Some key aspects:

  • replaces racially divided seats with a one person, one vote system
  • Introduce anti-discrimination laws
  • remove the requirement for all major parties to be offered a place in Government, so that there is a functioning Opposition
  • reduce the voting age to 18 from 21
  • Abolish compulsory voting
  • an independent Commission against Corruption (we need one of those in NZ also)

There are some aspects not so good, such as compulsory military service, and expanding the role of the military. They claim these are to stop the coup culture. I think it may be too late for that.

The current electoral system is not just racist but a gerrymander. One seat has 3,340 registered voters and another has 19,044. A voter in the first seat has six times the effect of a voter in the second seat. If the Commodore does get a truly democratic electoral system in place, he will be doing a good thing.

No full Herceptin treatment

Despite being ordered by a court to review their decision, the Government has decided not to fund Herceptin for the full 12 months – as is the norm in most countries. It will be made avilable for a nine week course only.

If I recall correctly the cost of full funding of Herceptin was slightly less than the cost of moving the snails on the West Coast.

Will Owen be called?

The Dom Post reports that the Privileges Committee is initially calling Winston Peters and Brian Henry to testify.

I am somewhat surprised by this. Winston, by his own words, says he knew nothing about the donation/gift, so I don’t know what value there will be from questions to him.

Surely the most important things is to first establish the facts around the donation – who was the cheque from, who was it made out to, what was it intended for, what account was it paid into etc. Once you have the facts then it would be more useful, in my opinion, to seek explanations.

Rodney Hide is worried that Owen Glenn may not be asked to testify. I can’t imagine how the Committee could expect to have any credibility if they do not invite Mr Glenn to testify, so I’m not that worried. I am sure they will issue appropriate invitations in due course.

The Farrier/Farrar interview with the Veronicas

Unemployment Up

The number of people unemployed rose by 7.000 in the latest Household Labour Force Survey. This saw the unemployment rate go up to 3.9% (a two year high). It is forecast to make 6% by the Reserve Bank.

The number of people in the labour force and employed also increased. I am not surprised as I thought the fall in the last quarter of 28,000 was too extreme, and that rebounded this quarter.So the economy may not be as weak as some have thought.

Will Helen go early?

I said on TV3 this morning, that there is a reasonable chance (not a probability, but a significant possibility) that Helen Clark may call an early election.

Why?

Just one reason, really.

The thought of Owen Glenn testifying to the Privileges Committee. This is the stuff of nightmares for Helen and her Foreign Minister.

If she goes early, she kils off the inquiry for Winston, and secures his loyalty post-election if he gets back (and she needs him to do so to have a chance).

And even better, the inquiry can not be re-established in a new Parliament.

So Helen will be reading the results of the UMR poll on how she has handled Winston very carefully. And if she is worried about what Owen Glenn may say, she will do anything to stop that happening.

What if Owen is asked by a Maori Party MP whether he was behind the $250,000 offered donation to the Maori Party, if they would agree to back Labour? If you are Helen, do you want to run the risk of that?

What if Owen won’t back up Winston’s claims to have known nothing at all about his donation? How do you look if as PM you didn’t even take the simple step of verifying this yourself?

So if Helen does call a snap or early election, it will not be due to any of the public reasons she will trot out. They will be as ludicrous as her justification for the 2002 snap election – she claimed an extra 12 minutes a day of points or order (about the status of the Alliance) had paralyzed Parliament and made governign impossible.

The reason will be the possible testimony of Owen G Glenn – Labour’s largest donor.

What happened to my relaxed day?

Today was meant to be a relaxing day in Auckland, with only one meeting. But in the 24 hours since I said I was coming up here, today has become:

  1. Check out hotel at 6.30 am to go to TV3 (groan)
  2. Do Sunrise at 7.10 am
  3. Breakfast with Nick B at Chancery
  4. Meeting with a client at 10 am
  5. Conference call at midday
  6. Coffee with MF2 at 2 pm
  7. Chair a public policy committee meeting at 3 pm
  8. Drink with a friend at 5 pm
  9. Taxi to Airport at 6.30 pm
  10. Flight at 8 pm

Somewhere during the day, I also need to write the NBR column for tomorrow!

Who dun it?

There is a great deal of interest in the person who made the secret tape recordings. They claim to be not a member of a political party, but they are obviously an extremely dedicated anti-National activist to have done the following:

  1. Trespassed at a private function
  2. Lied about being a party member to MPs (he claimed he had joined Young Nationals)
  3. Lied about his beliefs (claimed to support nuclear ships etc)
  4. Asked leading questions to MPs with the deliberate intention of getting them to say something he could use against them
  5. Used the fact he was pretending to be a party member to try and entrap MPs, knowing they will give more sympathetic responses to a viewpoint from someone who is a volunteer for a party, than if they were a random member of the public
  6. Had wired himself up with a hidden tape recorder
  7. Knew enough about the media to then know who best to give them to

They incidentially am almost certainly a reader of this blog, because in the transcript with Bill talking about WFF, he refers to Lockwood’s spreadsheets. Now I recently blogged about how five years ago or so I worked with Lockwood on some tax and benefit modelling, and that is the only mention in recent times of those – so they are obviously an avid reader who remembers such minor details.

As I said, I am not entirely surprised that someone would do this one day – in fact had been predicting this. Somewhat sad though. I have had many candid conversations with Labour MPs, Greens MP, other activists over the years and could cause all sorts of nastiness if I was the sort to tape them. I do hope this does not start a trend.

Garth George pulls no punches:

Politics in New Zealand, despicable as it has been for decades, has reached a new low with the secret taping of private conversations at last weekend’s National Party conference.

And what I want to know is what sort of scumbag would do such a thing, then spill his or her guts to the media.

The Herald editorial also weighs in:

Whoever has released recorded conversations with unwitting National MPs at the cocktail function at their party’s annual conference last weekend probably believes the ruse serves a public interest. The country now knows, if it did not before, that National has compromised some of its policy desires for the sake of its electoral prospects.

Oh yes this is a well kept secret – known only to three million people. Never before has a political party compromised on policy desires. I mean we didn’t see a Labour Cabinet pass a resolution to steal over a million dollars a year from the taxpayer in state funding of their party operations, and then weeks later rescind it as it looked to damage their electoral prospects.

As revelations go, these are rather less remarkable than the method by which they were obtained. Discreet recording is done but not commonly published by ethical news organisations for two reasons.

First, it is not fair to release a reporter’s tape or transcript unless the subject denies something plainly said or the recording could serve a public interest somewhat more compelling than partisan politics. Second, the publication would damage the gathering of further information. Once bitten, a public figure is twice shy.

Nothing revealed from National’s conference sneak so far offers insights to its intentions that could not have been obtained by a journalist trusted to use a private conversation responsibly.

When you consider the nature of the setup – an imposter pretending to be a right wing party member trying to get National MPs to agree with him, it is remarkable nothing more damaging was said. MPs get bombarded at conferences with policy ideas from members, and often say stuff like “Yeah that is not a bad idea, and we can look at that one day, but not immediately”. You don’t tend to tell someone you think is a hard working volunteer for your party that their ideas are whacko and they should eff off.

If National’s conference mole was working for the Labour Party, as National supposes, it is a new dimension to desperate politics in this country, and readily copied. All parties will know how easily opponents could plant an observer in their conferences capable of circulating at the tea break and engaging leading figures in candid discussion of sensitive issues.

I am sure Helen Clark did not tell anyone to go out and do this. That is ludicrous of course. But whoever did it, was motivated by a desire to help Labour retain power, and it will be very interestign if the identity emerges to see what links are there.

The Labour Party appears convinced Mr Key has more drastic economic policies in mind than he will admit before the election. Would that it were so. The more safely Mr Key is playing the game at present, the more genuine his caution seems. And Mr English is even less daring. He led National back to centrist conservatism after the defeat of the Shipley Government and he would keep it there for the time being.

Anyone who thinks a Key/English leadership is going to suddenly in office sell everything in sight, is basically barking. As the Herald notes, some of us do wish they would be a bit bolder in some areas!

Lots of fun

The interview with the Veronicas was lots of fun. God knows how it will look on air, but we enjoyed doing it. A couple of minutes will be on Nightline tonight and the full 20 minutes or so will be on You Tube at some stage.

I have to say that Jessica and Lisa were absolutely lovely. They had no ego or pretences as some celebrities have, and were just very fun to talk to. At the beginning of the interview, David Farrier said we should all label ourselves to avoid confusion so he did a “David F 1” label and I did “David F 2”. But then Jessica and Lisa labelled themselves “Veronica 1” and “Veronica 2” so we still had no idea who was who, and they refused to tell us.

Nightline is known to be a bit quirky, but I may have set some record with my question when they said how much they wanted to be in NZ, as they loved Lord of the Rings. For some reasons I asked them if they had “pet hobbit nicknames” for each other. David Farrier was like “Where the hell did that come from?” but they just laughed and said no nicknames but Lisa liked Frodo while Jessica liked Aragorn.

I was going to end the interview by asking them the “Rove” question – “Who would you turn gay for?”. But luckily I checked just before we filmed, and it seems both girls are bisexual and have had girlfriends (but currently are dating boys) so that question may not have quite worked!!

As I said, it was a lot of fun, and they were genuinely really nice. Not at all what I expected.

By coincidence I am also on Sunrise tomorrow. Not sure exactly when, but the taxi comes for me at 6.30 am so I guess just after 7 am on air. Talking about the taped conversations and ramifications for National and others.

Saunders Unsworth Party

Saunders Unsworth had their annual party last night at the Backbencher, and it was a great affair. It is probably the only party in town where you see the CEOs of the main ministries, their Ministers and the Opposition Spokespersons all in attendance – plus scores of media, industry groups, clients and the like.

The party always has really interesting people, copious amounts of quality wine, and top class nibbles to soak up the alcohol. There are so many people to talk to, you probably don’t spend more than 10 minutes with any one person.

Many jokes last night about secret recordings of course. At least I hope they were jokes.

Got to meet half of Dr Cullen’s staff, who were a very pleasant bunch (well to my face anyway 🙂 and had some interesting conversations around tax and Working for Families policy design, as well as Cullen’s wit in the House yesterday.  Also amused chats with my occassional Green Party drinking buddy over the outrage in the blog comments that we sometimes socialise and drink together.

One highlight for me was chatting to a Labour MP about a private company, with the MP praising them for their commitment to a heavy capital works programme, and I couldn’t resist quipping that this sounds like praising borrowing for infrastructure – it was taken in good humour 🙂

Eventually a few of us headed down to the Green Parrot around midnight. When I say a few, I mean around 30 – 40 people! It was probably one of the more unusual and larger groups they have had –  a collection of current and former National, Labour and Maori MPs/Cands and staff and a few journalists and others. I was really tempted to grab a photo of the 30 of us all around one large (series of) table, but a few people are camera shy!

So congrats to Saunders Unsworth on another very good function.

If Bill had been Winston

In my mind, I have been imagining what the response to the secret taped conversation would have been if Bill English had been Winston. I guess something like:

  1. Deny the tape exists
  2. Deny it is you on the tape
  3. Claim that tape is a forgery
  4. Angrily call on Duncan Garner to apologise and be sacked from his job for broadcasting it
  5. Hold a press conference, and call everyone morons and scumbags
  6. Suggest Duncan personally fabricated the tape
  7. When proof comes out your voice is on it, claim that your lawyer never told you what the question was
  8. Demand Duncan be sacked again
  9. Upon questioning, deny you have a policy on Working for Families
  10. Then later on claim you do have a policy, and it is the same policy as written in 1993 and only lying wankers would claim otherwise
  11. Then as focus turns to comments on Kiwibank, deny all knowledge of Kiwibank. Say you have never even been inside a branch, and if you have never been inside Kiwibank how could you possibly have a policy on whether to sell it. Stress anyone who is not a moron could work that out.
  12. Go into the House and attack press gallery as rodents
  13. The following day claim you have proof that 15 years ago an MP from another party did the same thing. Produce no proof of this.
  14. Demand Duncan be sacked again

The Veronicas

I am in Auckland this afternoon, to help interview The Veronicas for TV3’s Nightline.

Now the obvious question is why?

Well Jessica and Lisa are identical twin sisters, so are often mistaken for each other.

TV3’s Entertainment reporter is David Farrier. Now David and I look nothing at all alike [think taller, skinny, younger, handsomer and with hair :-)] but to our great amusement we are often mistaken for each other. He often gets told how much people like reading his blog, and I occasionally get told, when people hear my name, how much they enjoy me on TV3.

So David thought it would be amusing to have me help interview the twin rock stars, as we could empathise with them about being mistaken for each other. We are meeting them this afternoon, so guess it should air tonight on the 10.25 Nightline.

Have been swotting up on questions to ask them. Feel free to suggest possible questions below, and if they are appropriate (ie clean, interesting or funny) I may use them. And no I will not be asking about certain recent photos.

General Debate 6 August 2008

Another secret donation?

The Dom Post cites a “well-placed NZ First source” that NZ First has banked at least one cheque bearing the Simunovich name.

And the problem for Winston, if this is true, is:

Mr Peters was asked in 2004 if his party had received donations from Simunovich Fisheries when it was revealed that his adviser, former National MP Ross Meurant, was also working for Simunovich. “I’m saying no,” Mr Peters said.

The Hive recalls previous issues with Smunovich.

We also have the latest response from Helen Clark’s Minister of Foreign Affairs:

WP: Got your tape rolling, Phil?

WP: I told you I’m not talking to a lying gripper

WP: You know what that is? That is a lying wanker who won’t let go. See you.

Helen Clark promised new standards for her Government when she was elected. This is obviously what she meant. This is not Muldoonism. This is far beyond anything Muldoon did.

Labour claims polling not for them

Keeping Stock blogs, quoting the Dom Post:

“Prime Minister Helen Clark denied yesterday that Labour was polling voters on her response to the furore – a move which could signal she had not ruled out a firmer line against Mr Peters.

It is understood that polling company UMR was asking several questions, including whether Miss Clark had been decisive enough, but she said the poll was nothing to do with Labour.

“It would be news to me, because neither I, nor my staff, nor the Labour Party have authorised any such polling.””

Okay, well we know UMR has Labour as a client. So what are the possibilities:

  1. UMR are polling for another political party on whether Helen is tough enough on Winston and do people think John Key is slippery. Of course you are not allowed to work for two competing clients, so that theory is impossible.
  2. UMR on their own initiative decided to pay for a poll on how slippery is John Key and is Helen tough enough on WInston? And when they get the results of this poll, they will throw them in the bin, and not show them to anyone.
  3. Helen is not being upfront on this issue – which is rather hypocritical considering how much she went out of her way to claim she had no secrets about the who does polling for her,

There is I guess, another possibility. That the Spencer Trust commissioned the poll from UMR!!!

40 year plan beats 20 year plan

I joked to Radio Live, when I went on to discuss National’s infrastructure plan with Chris Trotter that Chris should like National’s 20 year infrastructure plan, as even the old Soviet Union only had five year plans 🙂

Anyway Labour have trumped that with a 40 year plan for greener safer transport!

I now await ACT’s 100 year plan for overtaking the United States GDP.

Oh and NZ First’s 1000 year plan for world domination 🙂

Secret Recordings

I suspected, reading the Bill English transcript, that this was not some conversation picked up accidentially between a delgate and Bill. It seemed to me the person he was talking to was most likely to have been the one doing the recording – ie someone fraudulently posing as a National Party delegate asked him questions, while secretly taping him.

This was confirmed with the release of recordings with Lockwood Smith. So my suspicions were correct. I am not terribly shocked – in fact I had predicted such tactics in presentations I have done to the Chamber of Commerce etc. We have seen similar in the US.

This will to some degree set off a race to the bottom as secret tape recordings become a standard tactic in politics.

Anyway let us go to what Lockwood said, according to NZ Herald:

There’s some bloody dead fish you have to swallow … to get into Government to do the kinds of things you want to do … and you have to balance up what really matters.

Heh the term is dead rats. This part is just the obvious. You drop unpopular policies in the areas that do not matter so much so you get to do work in the areas that matter most. This is for example why Labour finally gacve in on tax cuts – to get a fourth term.

If you try to do everything differently you’ll scare the horses and under MMP it’s very hard to win.

Again nothing unusual there.

Once we have gained the confidence of the people, we’ve got more chance of doing more things.

This is in fact the exact opposite of having a secret agenda. I have said much the same on this blog – you gain confidence by keeping your promises, not breaking them, and establishing good faith with the electorate. If National, for examples, serves a first term without selling any state assets, then it means if they campaign in 2011 to consider selling (for example) 25% of Solid Energy, people will trust National that they would only sell those assets it says it will, and not sell everything. You do not gain confidence to break it – you gain it, to keep faith with it. Otherwise you get thrown out.

We may be able to do some things we believe we need to do, perhaps go through a discussion document process … you wouldn’t be able to do them straight off … I’m hoping that we’ll do some useful things that way that may not be policy right now.

And again here he is talking good faith again – talking about having a public discussion process on proposed policies.

Labour are desperate to work up the fear of broken promises and secret agendas, because once National is in office – and does keep its promises, they will never have that weapon again. Anyone who thinks John Key is going to break his election commitments does not know the man well. My prediction is he will have a big wall chart of all the election commitments and have monthly progress reports on how things are going towards implementing them. There will in fact be a zealousness about making sure that in 2011, no-one can seriously claim National broke its word.

Preparing for Privileges

For the Privileges Committee to do its job, and reach a fair conclusion on whether the $100,000 Owen Glenn donation should have been declared on the MPs Register of Pecuniary Interests, they are going to need to be able to answer the following question:

  1. Who or what was the $100,000 paid to?
  2. Why was it donated?
  3. Who knew about it?

That is not an exhaustive list. But even off that, what sort of evidence would you want, so one could make a fair conclusion.  Rodney Hide has suggested that Owen Glenn should give evidence – maybe by video conference. It is almost unthinkable that one can resolve this issue without hearing from the donor. I would expect evidence to include the following:

  1. Testimony from Owen Glenn on why he donated, who he thought he was donating to, and who did he discuss the donation or the possibility of a donation with?
  2. Testimony from Steve Fisher as to why he said it was vital Glenn did not contradict Peters?
  3. A full forensic investigation of the money –
    1. Who was the cheque/draft made out to?
    2. Into what account was it paid?
    3. Was it the Spencer Trust?
    4. Was the money passed onto someone else?
    5. What bills were paid with it?
  4. Was the $40,000 damages to Clarkson (which is beyond dispute a personal debt) paid for by way of donation – whether Glenn or someone else?
  5. Does Peters personally make up any shortfall in the costs for his legal actions?
  6. Would Peters have paid over time at least $500 more to Henry, if the donation had not been made?
  7. How many donations of greater than $500 have been made towards the legal fees?
  8. Expert advice from the Law Society regarding barristers fees?
  9. If money was donated to a formal trust (such as the Spencer) is Peters a beneficiary of it, which requires a declaration on the Register?

As I said this is just an initial list.

Kiwiblog Problem Fixed

Many/most readers today have probably been getting binary jibberish for a few hours. There was a problem with a page in the cache which caused this.

Many thanks to those who took the time to let me know, but especially to Adrien who actually diagnosed the problem and sent me the solution to fix it, so I just had to pass it on to my ISP.

It reminds me that one of the great things about blogging, is the range of skills out there you get connected to.

Clark and Cullen on Debt

I have managed to obtain from a helpful staffer the full collection of quotes from Helen Clark and Michael Cullen on debt. Now remember they have been saying that going from gross debt being 20% of GDP to 22% of GDP is absolute lunacy and madness. So how does this measure up with their past statements. First Dr Cullen:

“The previous government had established a 30 percent of GDP target when the Fiscal Responsibility Act was passed in 1994, and had reduced it to 25 percent in 1999. When we came into office that year we made the judgement that the Crown finances and the state of the economy could not sustain that lower target, so we restored it to 30 percent of GDP.” – Michael Cullen 18 May, 2004, Speech to Chen Palmer & Partners Business and Government Seminar

So National had a target of 25%, and Labour increased it to 30%. yet now they are saying 22% is lunacy and madness.

And now Miss Clark:

All these quotes are from 1994, when debt was in excess of 50% of GDP!!”

“I am pleased that economic growth has produced enough tax revenue to declare a surplus and repay debt. But I am appalled at the rate at which debt repayment is occurring at the expense of families, and schools and other essential social and public services.” – Helen Clark (July 1994) Speech Auckland Labour Regional Conference

“The Government is putting an undue emphasis on debt repayment at the expense of our failing services and infrastructure in New Zealand,” – Helen Clark (June 1994) Opening address to the Massey University Winter Lecture Series.

“We agree that we should be aiming to ensure that the ratio of debt to GDP in New Zealand is not out of line with other smaller industrialised countries. But Labour does not accept that having the smallest debt to GDP ratio in the OECD is an important goal. Nor do we believe that reducing our debt quickly should take precedence over improving the living standard,” – Helen Clark (July 1994) Speech to Northern South Island Labour Regional Conference.

“At Budget time our net public debt was equivalent to 42 per cent of GDP – down from 48 per cent a year earlier… Given those figures, it is hard to believe that the international credit rating agencies with which the Government is so besotted can have any real concern at our current level of debt,” – Helen Clark (June 1994) Waikato Labour Regional Conference.

“The Government is obsessed with debt reduction over all other needs for spending,” – Helen Clark (July 1994) Speech to Wellington Labour Regional Conference.

So when gross debt was over 50% of GDP, Clark time and time again attacked reducing that level of debt, and specifically advocated investing money into infrastructure instead.

I trust we will hear no more hysteria from Helen or Michael on a gross debt setting of 22% of GDP!

Toppled

A year or so ago, I found out to my great surprise I actually held a record at my local gym.  I had the high score on the rowing machine for the “Fish” game, having exceeded 2,000 points on it.

As one can imagine, I am a rather unlikely record holder in the gym, but this is not a game of purely speed or stamina but of co-ordination and timing also, so my mis-spent youth playing space invaders is useful for some things! Basically you row on the rowing machine to move your player up and down the screen – go fast and you move up, slow down and you drop down. And the aim is to eat up the approaching fish while avoiding the sharks. You have a set period of time to get as many points as possible – 30 for small fish and 60 for large fish.

It’s a great way to exercise without realising you are exercising as you get so intent on the game and doing speed bursts here and there.

But sadly I was told today that my record got broken over the weekend 🙁

I am determined to regain it by the end of the year!

Heh Cullen can be so funny

Gerry Brownlee was winding up Michael Cullen for his hongi with Tame Iti after he and Mallard had attacked Key for a hongi on Waitangi Day with Iti.

Gerry made the point that Cullen had done three hongis with Iti, as opposed to just one for Key. Cullen’s reply was priceless though:

I’m sure the member will find out sooner or later in his life that after the first time, it is much easier.

Heh.