SPARC salaries

One of the signs of third termitis is the automatic defence of the status quo. The Government and associated left blogs have rushed to defend SPARC, and claim thereis no need to change anything.

I was intrigued by National’s sports policy as it appeared to be meticiously well researched and referenced. What that suggests to me is that sporting insiders have been helping write the policy because of the level of knowledge.

Since the policy was released, I’ve chatted to a few people in the sports administration arena, and to a person they are critical of SPARC and its growing bureaucracy. Now a smart third term Government would be hestitant about rushing in to defend it, when so many people are unhappy.

Bernard Hickey has done an interesting analysis. National revealed 55% of SPRAC staff earn over $100K a year. He wondered how that compares with other government agencies. Now Bernard could have chosen a lightweight agency such as Youth Affairs to compare to, but he chose the Reserve Bank – can’t get much more critical than that. What does he find:

The Reserve Bank of New Zealand’s annual report shows that it has 221 staff and that 71 or 32% of those are paid more than NZ$100,000. Over 55% of Sparc staff are paid over the NZ$100,000 threshold. There are 25 staff at the RBNZ who are paid more than NZ$150,000 or 11% of staff.

That compares with Sparc’s 16% of staff who are paid more than NZ$150,000. The total remuneration cost for the RBNZ in 2006/07 was NZ$21.8 million or an average of NZ$96,642 per staff member. That’s 24% less than the average for Sparc of NZ$129,411.

So we are paying our Reserve Bank staff 24% less than our sports funding agency staff. Now let us compare their importance starting with the RBNZ:

The RBNZ has the power to destroy or save the economy with its monetary policy and the power to regulate and/or save our banks. Every single bank note we have in our wallets is printed by and managed by this institution. Our payments system depends on it. …

Governor Bollard must front up to the public, politicians and his own board once every 6 weeks or so to explain what he’s going to do with the economy. He is regularly criticised by many commentators (including me) and will be held responsible for the economic life of the nation. The pressure is intense and the stakes are high.

If one of the big four banks were to fail on his watch (which I think is utterly unlikely), he and the bank would be responsible for a national disaster. It would cripple the economy for years. …

The Reserve Bank is an institution integral to the economic life of New Zealand and the Governor is one of the four or five most powerful people in the country. If he stuffs up we all pay.

Yep pretty critical indeed. And SPARC:

Sparc encourages us to take up sport and its CEO is a former international hockey player who once was the head of sales for New Zealand Post, a monopoly. Its success is measured by (I hope) how many of us regularly play sport and are therefore healthier, although Sparc’s Statement of Intent seems not to give any specifics on these or how it has performed recently. If the CEO of Sparc stuffs up it would be a one day story that maybe generates an independent inquiry that ends in a 50 page report that no one remembers.

A fair summary. So the conclusion:

Sparc is not more important than the Reserve Bank, its people should not be paid 24% more than people at the Reserve Bank and we should not be paying more than half of its staff NZ$100,000 to give away around NZ$71 million of public money.

Bernard also has a lot of good stuff on the $18 million SPARC is planning to spend on their websites, on how Trade Me and Staff websites have cost far less than this, and how the traffic to the SPARC sites appears to be so small it is unmeasurable.

There seems to be a very strong case for change.

Is Hager suing?

The Hive notes that Radio New Zealand has removed from its website, the audio of Monday’s Focus on Politics.

It has been suggested that Nicky Hager is threatening Radio New Zealand with defamation over the item – presumably over Matthew Hooton’s comments rather than Laila Harre’s.

I am not sure if it is true, but imagine if it was Nicky Hager being threatened with defamation. We’d probably hear all about how big monied interests are trying to silence him.

A defamation case would be fascinating. I’d love to hear testimony on how the e-mails were not stolen, and the ability for this to be cross-examined.

The cost of the train set

The Press wonders how much the train set will cost:

When he announced the deal to great fanfare in April, the Minister of Finance, Michael Cullen, said the Government would pay $665 million in the deal. That has now become $690m and covers only the rolling stock and a passenger rail ferry, plus leases on two other ferries.

The Government has also taken on $140m of debt. In addition, it has announced that hundreds of millions of dollars more is to be poured into the company and into the associated rail network company, Ontrack, which the Government bought four years ago. At the moment, Cullen’s trainset looks like costing at least $1.3 billion in the near future, and goodness knows how much after that. The Government has already said the company will need large subsidies to survive. It is no wonder that Treasury was kept out of negotiations.

Cullen has boasted that the Government paid a premium to buy the company back, as though there were some virtue in spending more money.

Oh when you spend other people’s money there is great virtue in paying a premium. Funnily enough less so when spending your own.

Truly Toll looked like they won Sale of the Century.

Bad, nasty and ugly

That is John Armstrong’s take on Parliament yesterday:

An ugly afternoon in Parliament – and, at times, a downright nasty one; an afternoon when the atmosphere was choked with personal attacks, personal insults, charges of blackmail, allegations of dirt-throwing and threats to really dish the dirt. …

Quite why things should have got so rough is hard to explain. But the tone was set from the moment the Prime Minister produced some material which she and Labour thought would finally nail John Key. …

But if Clark’s gaffe was a low point – and it was revealing in showing the lengths to which Labour is going to find some dirt on Key – there was more to come.

Has Clark apologised yet by the way?

A further argument which began with Mark’s leader, Winston Peters, accusing National of “venal, corrupt politics” culminated in Act leader Rodney Hide referring to Peters as a “tired old drunk”.

It took a few minutes, but Peters eventually demanded Hide apologise. “If he does not, then I am going to tell the House the truth about him, which I have hitherto kept to myself. He can laugh and giggle. This is his last warning.”

But Hide argued he could not apologise. If he did, it would look like he was being blackmailed and Peters had “something on me that was true”.

There was more argument and more intervention from the Speaker. But no apology. Peters saved whatever he had to say about Hide for another day.

In fact Rodney did not call Winston a “tired old drunk”. The full Hansard is below:

Rt Hon Winston Peters: If the Insurance Council of New Zealand is a subscriber to a political party’s coffers and gains from it a commitment to privatise ACC after the next election, what do we call that, if not venal, corrupt politics?

Hon Bill English: I raise a point of order, Madam Speaker. That member is an experienced member and knows that it is out of order to imply that someone in the House is influenced by factors outside the House.

Hon Trevor Mallard: The member certainly raised that as a possibility; he did not state it as a fact. I think there is room for the Minister to answer the question properly.

Rt Hon Winston Peters: Just because the truth hurts is no reason for someone to object in this House. Let me say this: the Insurance Council of New Zealand is a subscriber to the National Party’s coffers. Those members know it, and I—

Madam SPEAKER: That is not speaking to the point of order.

Rodney Hide: That is not correct. The Minister has no responsibility for what Mr Peters raised. And Mr Mallard is wrong, because if he were right, we would be able to raise as a possibility that Mr Peters is a tired old drunk, and we are not allowed to say that.

Rodney was making the point that Winston can not accuse MPs of corruption by hiding behind the defence he merely said it was a possibility, and used an example to illustrate that.

But the interjections, barracking, needling and insults continued. At one point, Labour’s Trevor Mallard described a question from National’s Anne Tolley as “just stupid”. The stopper had clearly been put on the milk of human kindness.

But most sobering of all was the realisation that all this was a portent of what is yet to come – an ugly, nasty and vicious election campaign.

Sadly John will probably be correct. But I would suggest readers reflect on where the ugliness, the nastines and viciousness is almost exclusively coming from.

The 2008 truckies protest

Tomorrow will be a nad news day for the Government with 1,000 or more truckies planning to protest against the increase in road user charges announced by Annette King on Monday.

It will be the first ever national protest by the trucking industry.

The issue is not so much the 7.5% increase per se, but the fact it was imposed with no warning period.

What I find interesting is the increasing trend for groups to be more assertive against the Government, as they calculate the probability of a change is likely, so the fear of retribution is reduced. We see school principals going to Close Up as another example. Something which would never have happened I suspect in earlier years. The same thing happened in 1999.

An accidential prize

Very amusing at Back Benches last night. The spot quiz prize question was “What is the name of the main Opposition Party in Zimbabwe?”.

Someone at my table said they thought it was MDC but wasn’t sure what MDC stands for. I replied that it is Movement for Democratic Change and then suddenly I hear Wallace Chapman yelling out something along the lines of Bloody Hell David Farrar wins again. I honestly didn’t realise my voice would have carried as I have actually been consciously trying not to become the resident prize grabber.

However the prize was a very cool book of Bromhead cartoons from the 1970s (and so many are still relevant today), so not complaining too much.

Ended up being a fairly long night. Normally I head home by 10 pm afterwards but a few of us ended up staying at the Backbencher until it closed at midnight. Then in the interests of fostering closer National-Greens relations some of us ended up going down to Mighty Mighty in Cuba Mall until they closed around 2.30 a.m. A really fun night – the only sensible way to debate free trade policies is at 1 am after some Black Russians!

Another failed smear

I have been predicting for some months that Labour’s re-election campaign will be a campaign of personal denigration and smears against John Key, and today we saw Stage One.  Colin Espiner blogs on how Clark tried to smear john Key but got her facts wrong:

There are generally three golden rules for MPs planning a personal smear attack on an opponent in Parliament.

The first is to make sure your facts are correct. The second is to ascertain that you are not guilty of the same things you are accusing your opponent of. The third is to do it under the cloak of parliamentary privilege, so if you fail on the first two, at least you can’t be sued.

Prime Minister Helen Clark managed to get two out of three right in Parliament today, but unfortunately she fell down on the most important one: accuracy.

This is the one which probably least bothers Labour.

She further claimed that Key’s family trust owned 30,000 shares in TranzRail at a time that Key made comments as Opposition associate transport spokesman in 2003, in which Key made disparaging remarks about the Government’s offer for the company and suggested Toll was more likely to win the bid.

That is of course what ended up happening. Toll won the bid and I imagine – although I don’t know this – that Toll’s share price went up too.

The only problem is that Key’s family trust had already sold its shares before Key made his comments. He has told Parliament this afternoon (and so I imagine he must be very certain of this) that neither he nor his trust held any shares in TranzRail at the time he made his remarks in June 2003.

Of course one could have checked the facts rather than just make it up. I mean to have the Prime Minister accuse the Leader of the Opposition of such a serious thing, and to get it wrong, should result in apologies.

But Labour don’t care if their smears are correct. John Key is a “rich prick” and they want the public to associate him with greed. They think if they repeat lies often enough, some mud will stick.

Their problem is that it looks so desperate. They are 20% to 25% behind in the polls and as Rodney Hide said in the House, they can’t even tell us how much the purchase of Toll cost, yet can find time to go through share registers trying to smear John Key.

Back Benches

Back Benches is on tonight at the Backbencher

The four MPs are:

  • Metiria Turei from the Greens
  • Heather Roy from ACT
  • David Bennett from National
  • Hone Harawira from the Maori Party

Topics for discussion are

  • kiwi kids and sport
  • Zimbabwe … the Prime Minister and the Greens think we should cancel our cricket tour next year
  • leaks from within National are they electronic or a mole?

As usual, turn up between 8 pm and 8.30 pm for a 9 pm start, or watch it on TVNZ7.

Our largest currency speculator

Ben Thomas at NBR reports on how the Reserve Bank has gambled a massive $4.2 billion on currency speculation in the last year.

This has all been through way of sales of NZ dollars. The Reserve Bank is hoping it can then buy the dollars back in the future when the exchange rate is lower.

I have to say I prefer to do my own currency speculation, rather than have the Government do it for me.

Clark on media

Helen Clark’s office has spent months and months refusing OIA requests for a copy of what she said to a journalism conference last November, about the media. They claimed there were no notes, no formal speech and no transcript.

They did finally admit there was a tape recording of the speech, and after eight months of effort by a member of the public, the PMs Office has been forced by the Ombudsman to release the audio tape.

It is especially ironic that it took so much effort to get a copy of what she said, after all the denials. Because one of the things Clark complained about to the conference was the perception that politicians are dishonest!

Colin Espiner covers some of the transcript:

On the tape, Clark is severely critical of journalists for their alleged lack of knowledge of world events, historical context, and “letting the facts get in the way of the story.”

She singles out TV3 political editor Duncan Garner, claiming he had told a seminar that “politicians always lie”.

“I’m sorry, politicians don’t always lie. I’m quite appalled by that statement. I think it’s important that scrutiny is not confused with cynicism,” Clark said.

Garner contests Clark’s remark, and says what he actually said was that the first instinct of politicians when cornered was to lie. …

Most journalists were too young to remember seminal events in the country’s history, she says.

“Today’s political editors of the two main TV channels were barely in their infancy, if born, when Norman Kirk brought the troops back from Vietnam, the Springbok tour, sent the frigate to Mururoa – events that to many of our age group were seminal events,” Clark said.

Oh dear. How dare the media employ anyone not born in the 1950s or earlier.

Whale Oil has further quotes from the tape.

Soul for Sale

Politicians in Paris

Sadly for me, not all my time overseas was a holiday. In Paris I also attended an IDU meeting. The International Democrat Union is a grouping of centre-right parties from around the world – around 95 parties are now members.It was founded by Ronald Reagan, Margaret Thatcher, Helmet Kohl and Jacques Chirac.

I’ve been involved in the IDU and IYDU for a number of years. This meeting is the big one though – the party leader’s meeting which is held every three years. The last one was in Washington DC in 2005.

The French National Assembly where we met for the Party Leaders Plenary. There were representatives from 46 countries, including eight Prime Ministers and a further 24 Party Leaders. The Prime Ministers included France, Croatia, Denmark, Georgia and Iceland. Some of the Leaders included David Cameron (UK), Bosnia, Chile, Ecuador, Lithuania, Sri Lanka, Nicaragua, Norway, Peru and Portugal.

The Conference lasted for two days with Regional meetings on Wednesday morning, an IDU Executive meeting on Wednesday afternoon and the main plenary session on Thursday.

The lady speaking is an Opposition Leader from Venezuela. A growing number of attendees are from semi or fully autocratic countries such as Venezuela, Cuba and Belarus where their parties are banned back home. It is quite inspiring talking to them and realizing how much they risk to get what we take for granted.

John Howard (IDU Chairman) greeting the French Prime Minister – François Fillon. The French PM gave one of the best speeches I have heard – hard to believe it was from a French politician. He quoted economic heroes of the right and the merits of free trade and liberalism which is not socialism or conservatism. I am going to try and get a copy – it really was that good.

On the Wednesday Night we were taken out to the Elysee Palace to meet President Sarkozy. The bus even got a police escort who cleared traffic for us, and you can see us travelling on the wrong side of the road here. A lot of pedesterians were wondering who was on the bus to warrant such treatment and must have been very disappointed to see me on the front seat. Mind you there were also half a dozen Prime Ministers with us!

The attendees are entering the Palace. Quite unusually there were no security checks (despite us all having been told to bring our passports. We were just escorted from the bus straight into the Palace without even a metal detector.

I did get to meet President Sarkozy (who is even shorter than Winston!) and The Stig remarked to me that it was the first time meeting someone who actually has his finger on the bomb!

The photo above is a poor quality one (taken via cellphone) of Sarkozy and UK Conservative Leader David Cameron. Cameron was in attendance for the full two days, and is a very engaging personality. He is quite charismastic and a good public speaker, but also very engaging on a one on one level. You feel you are talking to a person, not just a politician.

Sarkozy was, well, very French. 🙂

After a couple of hours of champagne and nibbles at the Palace, we were taken to the Senate for a reception dinner. Also a fine venue, to say the least. And the food was absolutely first class.

This was taken out the window of the Senate. What is really amazing is the photo was taken a bit after 10 pm. Paris has amazingly long days, staying light until after 11 pm. It was one of the many things I loved about the city.

Chief Political Strategist for Honesty

Helen Clark has declared she is Labour’s Chief Political Strategist. This is interesting as she also yesterday refused to rule out push polling, claiming if they do it it would only be honest push polling.

This would be like the “honest” push polling several electorates reported last election, was done by Labour – claiming National would raise the age of superannuation eligibility. Not a push poll as done in Labour’s name (I presume) but not honest.

Also like the “honest” pamphlet they put out to state house tenants about how National will sell their state houses and out up rents.

And like their “honest” letter to the Chief Electoral Officer where they lied about including the pledge card as election advertising.

It is good to see Helen taking responsibility for all this honesty!

Hell freezes over

Fairfax restructures

Fairfax is making up to 40 staff redundant as it restructures. Insiders tell me there are 190 – 200 subs nation-wide so that is a large number of redundancies.

I am told by said insiders that the announcement was brought forward by two days when someone accidentally posted details of it on the Fairfax Intranet. And it seems the way it was communicated has been sub-optimal.

But despite that, it does seem to be a quite different kettle of fish to what APN have done, which is outsource almost all sub-editing to Pagemakers – a very controversial move.

From what I can tell Fairfax is saying that subs will remain with each paper for local and sports news, but that centralised hubs in Christchurch and Wellington would sub-edit financial and world news plus features across all Fairfax papers.

Putting aside the obvious commercial imperative, and the impact it has on current staff (restructuring is never pleasant) I am not sure it isn’t a bad idea. Financial and world news doesn’t tend to be local and building up centres of excellence in those specialised areas makes some sense to me, while keeping local subs for local news.

The case for science funding

Simon Upton makes a strong case for more funding for science:

I support spending taxpayer dollars on science more than most other areas of government expenditure. Extending the frontiers of human knowledge is a legitimate goal of public policy.

To start, two science stories. This (northern) summer, the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) will be commissioned. In the form of a ring with a circumference of 27km and buried 100 metres below the Franco-Swiss border on the outskirts of Geneva, it is the most powerful tool of its type ever constructed.

The scientific questions it will be targeting are mind-boggling: what happened in the first second following the inception of our universe some 13.7 billion years ago? Why do particles have mass? Does the Higgs boson really exist? What is the dark matter that makes up most of the universe made of?

Every statistic about the LHC is overwhelming. Particles will be accelerated to 99.99% of the speed of light; detectors will sift through vertiginous amount of data created by 600 million collisions per second. The instrument has taken nine years to build. While the Europeans have funded 90 per cent of the 3.7 billion euros the project has so far consumed, it will engage scientists from more than 100 countries.

To which I can only say “bravo” to the Europeans for such a staggering commitment which has no goal other than the quest of understanding why our universe is the way it is.

Like Simon, I think there is a legitimate case for public spending on science. Knowledge is what seperates us from the cavemen.

And now you ask, why do particles have mass??

School fighting for three years to get drains fixed

I’ve just watched last night’s Close Up, after Bernard Hickey blogged about it.

If you did not view it, go watch it now. It is disgusting. They have spent three years fighting the Ministry of Education to get their drains unblocked etc. Finally they wrote to the Minister Chris Carter but he hasn’t even replied to them, so in desperation they went public:

They’ve had 25 meetings with the Ministry of Education over their property plan. You wonder why numbers at the Ministry of Education has increased so much – this is why. Let me quote Bernard:

The school’s poor principal, Diane McCallum, and the board had been jumping through bureaucratic hoops for three years trying to get a decision on fixing the decrepid school buildings. Tiaho School’s drains overflow when it rains, flooding the toilets and the playing fields with sewage. The students have to walk on duckboards to cross the playground. McCallum is worried that the students are afraid to go to the toilet because of the smell and therefore may struggle to learn.

The rain gets into the wires and sets off the fire alarm. The principal has to climb on a ladder and jam blu-tack into the alarm to stop it ringing when it rains so classes aren’t disrupted. The school wanted some money for some new buildings or to renovate the buildings. There had been 25 meetings with the ministry and 3 different building plans had been submitted. Consultants had visited at a cost of NZ$24,000. Letters had been exchanged. Formulas considered. Yet nothing happened.

Then the boiler broke last week. The Ministry of Education told the principal to buy a bunch of heaters because it wasn’t worth fixing the boiler. The school then spent NZ$4,000 on oil column heaters to warm up the school so the students wouldn’t be too cold. Then the caretaker turned them all on and the electrical system shorted out.

An apt summary of the background. And then the Ministry:

The Education Ministry’s National Property Manager Paul Burke first went through his bureaucratic routine of trying to explain why the school hadn’t quite jumped through all the hoops yet, despite three years of trying. He was trying to explain the shape of the hoops, the number of hoops, how round they were, what they were made of and the exact nature of the leaps required to jump said hoops. He wore a lovely suit with a beautiful tie. He seemed like a man who knew the rules very well.

I wanted to throw things at the television. Mike Hosking avoided throwing things. But he did quickly tear apart the Kafka-esque web the good bureaucrat was weaving. Why was it taking so long? Why couldn’t the drains be fixed? How many consultants does it take to change the lightbulbs at Tiaho school….and why?

I’m just amazed that we make schools jump through such hoops and have to get Wellington to approve a new boiler. Sounds like a case for bulk funding for me. Sure large exceptional items will always be an issue, but forcing a school to spend three years and 25 meetings justifying why they need the drains and sewers unblocked is madness.

Don’t some people have better things to do with their time?

The Press Council has rejected a complaint about the NZ Herald regarding the term “puzzle mania”:

The Press Council has not upheld a complaint by Philip Wright regarding the use of the word mania in a billboard publicising the feature insert Puzzle Mania in the Herald of May 19.

The billboard read Inside today Puzzle Mania.

Mr Wright advised he was a barrister who did a lot of work in the mental health area in New Zealand and the United Kingdom.

He had seen first-hand the horrific and gut-wrenching effects caused by mania, hypermania and depression.

He took grave exception to the Herald’s use of both the word and a psychiatric condition to sell newspapers.

He thought the Herald should apologise to all mental health sufferers and consumers and be forced to make a significant donation to a trust of which he was an adviser.

Really some people are far far too sensitive.

PM will not rule out push polling

Audrey Young blogs on the Crosby Textor issue, and there is one startling revelation:

She [Helen Clark] would not rule out push-polling either from Labour – something that Key categorically ruled out from National in the coming election campaign – but only “honest” push-polling.

So Helen Clark has refused to rule out push polling. Is this not massively more newsworthy than National using the same consultants as they have in the previous five elections?

Now I await all the left bloggers to condemn the Prime Minister for not ruling out push polling. How long shall we hold our breath for?

Smart kids

The kids at Wellington High School are showing some good sense in responding to their first brush with Nanny State and the tuck shop. Effects have been:

  • The school’s cafe operator has thrown in the towel, saying she could not turn a profit under the Education Ministry’s new healthy eating regime
  • a group fundraising for a Japanese trip has seized on the opportunity by setting up a daily sausage sizzle and baking stall
  • The Dominion Post watched yesterday as a stream of pupils headed to the nearby Wallace St shop for mince pies, chippies and fizzy drinks.

One also has to praise the principal’s attitude:

Principal Prue Kelly was relaxed about the week-long sausage sizzle, saying she hoped pupils would support the fundraising effort. Asked if the new culinary option met the ministry’s healthy eating guidelines, she said: “Who knows? It’s how we’re coping with the problem today.

“I think they’re using brown bread instead of white.

“They look like pretty good sausages to me. In fact I might get one.”

Good on her.

The Government is as usual missing the point. The problem isn’t kids having a sausage occasionally, but if they are having that for lunch everyday. But rather than concentrate on having a varied diet, instead they are purging tuck shops of any food they do not approve of. It will get worse if the Public Health Bill is passed into law.

A wind powered Wellington

The Dom Post reports on a proposed third wind farm for Wellington, which would mean the 140 wind turbines would be enough to power every home in the city.

The proposed location is on the south west coast of Wellington – near Oteranga Bay by the look of it.

I am a big fan of wind power and think that wind turbines look wonderful dotted on the hills. Sure they shouldn’t be within a few metres of people’s homes, but they should not be blocked just because someone doesn’t want them in their line of sight.

Even the Auditor-General gave up

Some people think waste in the public sector is just the odd conference at a resort hotel. But the big ticket items are the massive cost blowouts on projects, with Corrections and Defence being the worst offenders.

Bernard Hickey blogs on this:

Late last week the Auditor General Kevin Brady reported back to the public that he had abandoned an investigation into why the cost of the Ministry of Defence’s NZ$2.2 billion programme for buying new ships and helicopters and upgrading planes had blown out by NZ$392.6 million.

He abandoned the investigation because the Ministry’s financial reporting systems were so poor that he couldn’t tell exactly why the costs had blown out.

This should indeed be a major story.

Crosby/Textor

God knows how the SST thinks it is front page news that the National Party uses focus groups and advisors that Nicky Hager doesn’t like.

They breathlessly report:

An April 2005 Crosby/Textor report described how the focus group questions probed for latent negative “hesitations or concerns” about her. “Regardless of your overall view of Helen Clark,” the moderator asked, “what would you acknowledge are her weaknesses at the moment, even if they are slight or begrudging weaknesses?” The report’s “strategic opportunities” section concluded that the research revealed “an emerging perception that Helen Clark is too busy with `minorities’ and `other people’ to worry about the concerns and the pressures on `working families’.”

This is of course normal fare for parties, but only front page news if done by National. I blogged back in February how Labour were testing attack lines in their polling. And I concluded:

So that poll, presumably on behalf of Labour, was entirely legitimate as a form of message testing.  They were trying to find out which attack lines on Key will have the most effect on reducing National’s support, and conversely which lines about Labour will be most effective at increasing support for them.

Yet the SST thinks that it is front page news that National does the same thing.

But wait you say, isn’t the issue that the firm is Crosby/Textor who were associated with Don Brash.

Well no, that is crap. I am going off memory but Mark Textor has been giving advice to National since the 1993 election. So 2008 would be the 6th election where he has been involved. So what is the news value in National having the same advisor as the last five elections?

Matthew Hooton aptly summarises the situation on National Radio yesterday describing Nicky Hager as the Patricia Bartlett of NZ politics – wanting to be the moral guardian of NZ, yet he himself is a political activist himself.

Even Russell Brown has a reasonable balance:

A sense of perspective is worthwhile here. Political strategy is a cynical business by its nature. Labour’s people were not appealing to higher ideals when they ran the “slippery” campaign against Key this year. Even the Greens once (in 2002) hired themselves an electoral shitkicker from Australia.

Adam Smith also weighs in:

Predictably the Hager árticle’ in the SST had all the usual left voices acting as if John Key had been found indulging in an act of bestiality, rather than doing what politicians do, that is acting rationally and legally in taking advice from a variety of sources on how to win.

That is what party leaders are supposed to do – win elections.

Textor and Crosby are centre right campaign and research advisors. In some countries they actually run the campaign (such as in the UK), while in NZ (as far as I know – I am not privy to exact details) their role is far less. National has its own Campaign Manager and campaign staff.

The only documented wrong doing was an alleged push poll in 1995 – 13 years ago. Now I think push polls have no role in politics or market research (but make sure you do not confuse push polls with testing attack lines) but their real sin seems to be that they are often sucessful, rather than one mistake in 15 years.

The Hive also highlights an apology to Crosby and Textor from Crikey in 2007.

David Cohen notes that Crosby Textor offered some blunt advice last year to Australian Liberal Party:

Still, last year’s Australian federal election campaign does offer a useful test of the article’s overall judgment.

This was the same federal election, of course, in which at least one political pr outfit famously advised the ruling Coalition that it had left voters disillusioned over broken promises and dishonesty, even while Labor leader Kevin Rudd was acquiring a deserved reputation as compassionate, human, genuine and likeable. .

Excellent advice, that; honest, open and straightforward, too. Unfortunately for Hager, it also came from Crosby/Textor

Colin Espiner also looks at the fuss:

So far National’s leader John Key has not denied he is using Crosby Textor, and indeed his staff are confirming it, off the record. National is playing down Hager’s story, and indeed there is a “so what?” component to it. More than 70% of respondents to a Stuff poll this morning agree with them.

Let’s be honest – all political parties use polling companies and image consultants if they can afford to. Labour uses UMR. The companies road-test ideas, probe communities for hot-button issues, test the weak spots of opponents, and help political parties form an attack plan for election campaigns.

Colin then looks at Crosby Textor specifically:

However I think his decision to continue using Crosby Textor was a mistake, for a number of reasons. If he was trying to rid the party of the remnants of the Brash years, why use the same image makers? Why use a company that has a controversial reputation in Australia and Britain? A company that has been involved in scandals such as push-polling over a candidate’s mythical support for abortion to the ninth month of pregnancy? Who wants to be involved with a company tied up with stories about baby killers and the children overboard fiasco in Australia?

On top of all this, for all its fearsome reputation, Crosby Textor’s results are mixed at best. It has advised National in its last four campaigns. National has lost three in a row. It advised John Howard last year. Howard lost. It advised Michael Howard in Britain. Howard lost. Its sole recent success was Boris Johnson in the London mayorlty, and Red Ken was history after introducing the congestion charge.

I think Colin is off the mark here somewhat. First of all it is simplistic to judge campaign advisors simply by the result. Minor little things such as leaders, policies, political and economic environment all affect the result – not just the campaign. In the US people like Bob Shrum are well respected as campaign managers despite not having advised a winning presidential campaign.

But even if one does want to look at results, then Colin should not just quote the 2007 election loss for Australia but also the four previous wins. Likewise in NZ, Mark Textor had a role (going off memory) in the 1993 and 1996 election campaigns, so their record is a positive one, and the fact they are in demand is because they are very good at what they do.

The real irony is that I have heard from a friend of a friend who has taken part in a recent focus group for what was obviously the Labour Party. The entire thing consisted of testing attack lines against John Key. They were left in no doubt that Labour will be using their research to try and undermine John Key on all fronts. Watch this space.

An interesting contrast

As far as I can tell the Government is spending tens of millions of dollars through eight different campaigns to encourage kids to play more sport.

National is saying we’ll take that money and spend it directly on funding and facilities for kid’s sports.

I know which one appeals more to me.

A useful comparison:

One big cost for example is the Sparc website. This year Sparc will spend $5.5 million on its website.  And between 2006 and 2010, Sparc will spend $11.5 million on its website.  That’s enough to give almost $6,000 worth of sporting equipment to every primary school in New Zealand.  Or to buy a decent cricket set for every family in Waitakere City.

That is a hell of a lot of money for a website!

Paris

After the UK leg of our trip, we had six days in Paris – partly to attend an International Democratic Union conference, and partly for holiday.

This is the view from the hotel we were at the first night. Pretty damn good. Mind you the rooms cost more than the GDP of a few third world countries.

Converting prices in Europe back to NZ dollars is damn depressing and eventually I just gave up, and abandoned any idea of fiscal restraint. I don’t mean buying unnecessary things, but not fretting that a small bottle of coke is NZ$8. In the end can’t do anything about the fact that high inflation in the 1970s and 1980s devalued our dollar so much that our purchasing power today is reduced.

Ginga Ninja, German Girl and The Stig out enjoying the nightlife. We ate and drank outside every night – beautifully warm, sunny and light. There are thousands of places to choose from also. The six days there went all too quickly and will be returning.

I didn’t realise the Cathedral of Notre Dame de Paris was actually on an island in the Seine.

Students performing outside the Notre Dame Cathedral.

The Arc de Triomphe at Place General De Gaulle.

The Eiffel Tower. Superb.

Around 11 pm the Eiffel Tower lights up magnificently. It serves as a beacon for thousands of Parisian youths to party in the park next to it.